You are on page 1of 62

:

, 2008

1. ................................................................................................................... 3
2. ............................................. 9
2.1 ........................................................................................ 10
2.2. ........................................................................................... 20
2.3 ............................................ 27
3. .................... 31
3.1 ......................................................................... 42
4. ............................................................................. 46
5. .................................................................... 54
6. ................................................................................................................... 59
7. ........................................................................................................... 61

1.
, , ,
.
,
.
(, ,
) . ,
,
. , ,
- -
( ) ,
. ,
, -
. ,
,

,
.

,
,
,
.
..


. ,
,
, .
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel 1770,
, (Stuttgart) 1831

. ,
, ,
, -

1 -

.
1788

(Tubingen)

(Holderlin) (
Schelling) .
, , (Bern) (Frankfurt)
(Jenas) (
Berlin) (Nuremberg)2.
1770,
, (1789)
( ),


( Spinoza), (Fichte), (Hobbes), (Schelling),
, ,
(Kant).
.
,
, :
(1807) , (1821)
(1832-40).


,

1
2

I.N.Findlay, Hegel a re-examination, .28


Inwood, Hegel, London/New York, Rootledge 1983,xiii-xv

3. , ,

.

,
.

,



4. ,

, .
,
,
,
5
6.
,
7 .
(
)

,
.


, , -,
3

Ritter, , ,1966 . ., ,
1998.27-33
4
., Hegel, , 1977 .25-27
5
Ritter, , ,1966 . ., , 1998.
34-39
6
, Inwood, Hegel, London/New York,Rootledge 1983, .100
7
., Hegel ,, 1977,.35

.
, ,
, ,
. ,
, , - , -
, -
. ,

,
,
, ,

.
:
,
.


, ,

, .
, ,
,

, .


, , ,
. ,

,
, ,

6


.

. ,

,
, .
, , ,
,
.
,
, .
,
,
,

8. , ,
. ,
,
, ,
.
, , ,
. , ,
, , -
,

- .


.
( ,
8

Elements of the philosophy of right,Allen Wood,Nisbet,Cambridge,Cambridge University


Press,1991:
260

, , ),
,
(Volksgeist)
. ,


.
,
,

,
- - ,
,

().


, ,
, , ,
, ,
.
- -




.

2.



, ,
.

, ,
(,
, ). , ,
,
. , , ,
, ,

, ,
,
.9
,
-
. ,
,
,
.

., ,,1977, .104-105

2.1


,
. ,
.
/ / 10


.
-
,
-
,
.
,
, .


(
). ,

, . , ,

,
, , ,
-

.11

- -

, . ,
10

Inwood, Hegel, London/New York,Rootledge 1983, .469


MacIntyre Al., Hegel: a collection of critical essays, University of Notre Dome, Notre Dome
London, 1976, .291-7
11


,
, .12 , ,


, .13
,

. ,
, . ,
, ,


, ,
.14 , 15
.
,
-
(Willkr) -
, ,
, .16


,
, .
-
-

12

Beiser, The Cambridge Companion to Hegel and Philosophy to Right,2002,.218-9


MacIntyre Al., Hegel: a collection of critical essays, University of Notre Dome, Notre Dome London,
1976, 289
14
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, . xi-xii
15
Ritter, , ,1966 . ., , 1998, . 34
16
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, . xii
13

11


- - .

,
, . ,
,

, .17 ,
18
,
,
,
.
, , ,
, ,
. ,
,

(Dasein). ,
: 1) , , - 2)
,
3)

.19 , .
, , ,

. ,
,

17

.. 4
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 56
19
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 5-7
18

12

, ,

, ,
,
.20


, ,
,
, .
,


,
.21

-
,
.22
, ,
,


.
23
20

MacIntyre Al., Hegel: a collection of critical essays, University of Notre Dome, Notre Dome
London, 1976, . 306-308
21
Neuhouser Fr., Foundation of Hegels social theory; Actualizing freedom, Cambridge Massachusetts,
Harvard university Press, 2000 . 78
22
Rilley P., Will and Political legitimacy: a critical exposition of social contract theory in Hobbes,
Locke, Rousseau, Kant 7 Hegel, Harvard university Press, , Cambridge, 1992, . 178
23
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 56-57 . , , ,
, , , 2006 .125-6 :
.
, . ,
, , ,
, [ ] . ,
, ,

13

-
,
,
(
)
.
, ,
:

.





.24

(objektiv) (subjektiv),
(spekulativ - praktisch)

.



,
, .

(Selbstbestimmung)
. , ,
, []
. ,
, ,
, ,
,
.
24
MacIntyre Al., Hegel: a collection of critical essays, University of Notre Dome, Notre Dome
London, 1976, .312

14

,
,
, .25 , ,


.
,
, ,
.26 :
-

, , ,
- .
, ,
.
,


,
, . ,


.
,

,
.27

,
. , ,
25

Neuhouser Fr., Foundation of Hegels social theory; Actualizing freedom, Cambridge Massachusetts,
Harvard university Press, 2000 . 18-20
26
Hegel G-W, Critical Assessments, ed. by R.Stern, Rootledge, London & New York, v.IV, 1993,.
257-271
27
Neuhouser Fr., Foundation of Hegels social theory; Actualizing freedom, Cambridge Massachusetts,
Harvard university Press, 2000 . 25

15


, .
,
, (Sittlichkeit),
. , ,


. ,

,
, , .

,

, .28
,

29
.
,
,
,
.

-
,
. ,
,
-

- ,
28

Hegel G-W, Critical Assessments, ed. by R.Stern, Rootledge, London & New York, v.IV, 1993,.
260-264
29
.. . 264-5

16

. ,
.
, , -
,

.30 , -

. ,
,
, ,
.
,

.31
, , ,
,
. , ,

,

( -),
,
,
. , (Pelczynski)

,

, .32


.
30

.. . 265-271
Stace W.T., The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publication, INC, 1955, 311
32
Hegel G-W, Critical Assessments, ed. by R.Stern, Rootledge, London & New York, v.IV,
1993,.271
31

17

-
, .33 ,
, ,
,

. -
-
.
,
,
,

. ,

. , ,

,
, .

, .

,
.
, ,
,
.
,

.34 ,
,

33

Stace W.T., The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publication, INC, 1955, 575
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 98-99
34

18

.35
,


-
. ,


, ,
. , ,
,
,

,
. ,

.36
,

37
, ,
. ,

38,
. ,


-
.
35

Stace W.T., The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publication, INC, 1955, 575
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, .97
37
Hegel G-W, Critical Assessments, ed. by R.Stern, Rootledge, London & New York, v.IV, 1993,
349
38
Stace W.T., The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publication, INC, 1955, 575
36

19



,39
.

2.2.
,
.

.

,
40

.

,
,
. , ,

, - ,
, ,
. , ,
.41 ,42 ,

39

Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 99
40
., , . . . , 3 ., . .,
1963, . 29
41
., , ,
, . . ., . , . , 1989

20



-
,
. ,


,
, , , ,
.
,
, ,

.
-

(volont gnrale) .
, , ,

. ,
. ,
,

. , ,
, ,
(sittlehkeit), ,
.43

,
-

., , . . . , 3 ., . .,
1963, . 57
43
Pelczynski , Hegels political philosophy problems & perspectives, a collection of new essays,
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1971, . 6
42

21

- . ,
,
- ,
, .
,
-
.
,
44

. , ,


( ).
, ,
,
,
, .
:
,
, , .45

, ,


,

. 150
: ,
,
,
44

, Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of


right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991, 258
45
Pelczynski, The state & civil society: studies in Hegels political philosophy, , Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1984 . 55

22

,
. ,

,
- . , ,

()
-
,
.
, , ,
,
.
,
,
, , ,
.

,
(
),
. ,

, ,
. ,

( )

,
( - ).
(Carrit ),

23


.46
, ,
-



. ,

: . ,

.
,
,


,
. ,
,
,


. , ,
.
, - ,
, ,
,
, .
, ,
,
,
46

MacIntyre Al., Hegel: a collection of critical essays, University of Notre Dome, Notre Dome
London, 1976, .322

24

,
,
. ,
.
,



.47 ,

,
. ,
,

,
. ,


, -
. , ,
,
. ,

(!).
,
-
( ) . ,
, , -

, .48

, , .
47
48

..
Stace W.T., The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publication, INC, 1955, 608

25

,
. , ,
,
,
(
).49 ,
,

.
.50
,

.
,
, ,
,
.
- ,

.51 , ,


. , ,
52 , :
,
,

,

49

., 377
., 608
51
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 94-102
,

52
Hegels Philosophy of Mind, trans by W. Wallace & Av. Miller, Oxford University Press, London,
1971 539
50

26

2.3


, .
,
, .
,

,


.
-
.
, ,

. ,


.
, 53 . ,

, (

) . ,
53

Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 121

27


,
.

(Verfassung), ,
,
, . , ,

,
.
, ,

54.

, 55.
,
.
, ,
, ,
.
.
, : 1.

56
2.
,


57. ,

54

.. . 116-122
Inwood,Hegel, Routledge & Kegan Paul,1983 . 456
56
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991, . 98
57
. . 116 . .
55

28


.
, ,
.
, ,
,
,
58.

, ,

59.
,

. , ,
(Sittlichkeit) ( ,)
,

.60 , ,
,


.61
,
.62 ,
,

,

58

.Findlay I.N,Hegel a re-examination, New York Humanities Press, INC,1970 . 322


.Stace W.T,The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publications,INC,1955 440
60
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 261
61
Hegel, Political Writings, L. Dickey- H.B. Nisbet, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1999,
. ix
62
Pelczynski, The state & civil society: studies in Hegels political philosophy, , Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1984 . 75
59

29

(Interesse) [ , ]
.
- -

,
,63
. , ,
, ,
,
64.
, , ,

, :
,
.
,
( )

,
-, .
, ,
- 65
,

.

63

Stace W.T,The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publications,INC,1955 575


Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991 . 99
65
.. . 70
64

30

3.

, ,
,,

. ,

,
, ,66


,
, .
,

,
( )
67. ,
,
, ,

, . , ,
.


, .


, ,
.
66
67

Strauss & Cropsey, History of political thought, 2nd edition, Rand McNally, Chicago, 1972, . 687
Findlay I.N,Hegel a re-examination, New York Humanities Press, INC,1970 . 323

31

,
. ,

, ,

( ) .
: .
- -,

. , ,
,
.


. ,

, -
, .
[Krone],
.
(Stnde)
.68
,

.69
, -

,
:
,
, , , ,
68

, , , ,
., ., , 1985, . 95-96
69
Hegels Philosophy of Mind, trans by W. Wallace & Av. Miller, Oxford University Press, London,
1971 542.

32


,
- ,

, ;
,

, (, , ).
, ,

i.70
,
, .

[
],
.71
,


, ,
,
.72

[ ]

, ,
,

70

Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 280
71
Pelczynski , Hegels political philosophy problems & perspectives, a collection of new essays,
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1971, . 25
72
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 281

33

,73

.74 ,
. ,

,
.75 , ,

, ,
280 ,
.76

,
,
, ,
. , :


,
,
. , ,

,

.77
, , ,
,
,
73

Avinery S, Hegels theory of the modern state, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1974, .
187
74
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 281
75
.. 279 - 280
76
.. 280 ...
...
77
., , . ., ., ,
1991, . 377

34


.
.78
,
. ,
,
,
( )
.
, 79 (Kenneth Westfal),

. ,



(!).
,
, , , .
(),
,
, , ,
, .80 ,
,
. ,

,

, .81
,

78

Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 275
79
Beiser, The Cambridge Companion to Hegel and Philosophy to Right, 2002, 262
80
Strauss & Cropsey, History of political thought, 2nd edition, Rand McNally, Chicago, 1972, . 701
81
Avinery S, Hegels theory of the modern state, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1974, .
186

35

, ,
. ,
,
,
. , ,


,
/
,
. , , .
,

: .

. ,

,
-

. ,

,


.82
,
,
-
,
. ,

82

Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 287-295

36



. ,


83, ,
.
,
, . ,
, ,
.
,

, ,
.
, ,


.
,
,
,
,

, ,
.

. ,

, .
,
. , ,

83

.. 297

37

,



.
,
-
, ,

, ,


.84
, ,


. (Stande)
: , -
.85 , -
,
(, ). ,

,


. ,

84
85

.. 298-310
Strauss & Cropsey, History of political thought, 2nd edition, Rand McNally, Chicago, 1972, . 698

38

,
.86
, ,
: 87

86

Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 202-206
87
Beiser, The Cambridge Companion to Hegel and Philosophy to Right, 2002, 269

39















(, , )

( )

( )

--------------------------

40

,

, ,
. ,
,

,


,
. ,

,
,

(, , )
.

.

41

3.1

, ,
,
. ,
,

,
- .88


,
, - , ,
,

,

.89
,
.
, ,

( ) ,
( ).

. ,
, , -,
,

88

Pelczynski, The state & civil society: studies in Hegels political philosophy, , Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1984 . 62
89
Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1991 . 76

42


(
),

.
,
[


-]
, ,
.
, ,
. ,

-

.90

5.. , . ,

,
. ,

,
,
(
),
. , ,

.91
90

Strauss & Cropsey, History of political thought, 2nd edition, Rand McNally, Chicago, 1972, . 702
Hegel G-W, Critical Assessments, ed. by R.Stern, Rootledge, London & New York, v.IV, 1993,
271

91

43

92,

, ,

. ,

, ,
.
21 ,
19 . ,
. , , - ,
-
, , ,
, .


,
. ,

,
.93

, 94
.
, ,


.95 ,

92

., : , . ,
, 1980
93
Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 311
94
...
95
... . xxix

44



,
. , ,

, ,

. ,

,


.96
, ,

, , .

, 1) ,
, 2)
.

96

.. 166

45

4.
, ,
,

.
,

, . ,
,
-
,
,
. ,
,
,
,
,
, . ,

, -
.97 ,

.
,

-

,
,
, ,

97

.. 41-46

46

.98 , ,


. , ,

, , . , ,

,

. ,



.
,


.
,
(Klaus Hartmann),


, ,

,

,
.99 ,

98

Marx K., , ,
, 1978, . 152
99
Pelczynski, The state & civil society: studies in Hegels political philosophy, , Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1984

47

-
.
,
,

. ,
, ,

. , ,


.

,

, .
, ,
,

.

, . ,

,

, .
, , 295100
()101

100






Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet,
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991, 295
101
Beiser, The Cambridge Companion to Hegel and Philosophy to Right, 2002, . 262

48

( )
,
:

-
.
, ,
: ,

,
.

,
. ,


, -
.
(Karl
Popper),

,
,


. , ,
,
.102

, ,

- . ,
102

., , , , ., .,,
, 1982, . 54

49

(K. H. Ihlting)


103

.
, ,

, ,
. ,

, , . , ,

-
.
,
,
.104

. ,

,

.
, ,
,

. , ,
-
.
103

Pelczynski, The state & civil society: studies in Hegels political philosophy, , Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, 1984 . 109
104
Plamenatz John, Man and Society, Addison Wesley Longman, London & New York,. III, 1991 .
144

50

, ,


.
, ,

. ,


,
.
,

,
, ,

,
.105 ,
(John Plamenatz)


.
, ,

, .106


.107
,

105

Lefevre, , . ., , , 1998, . 88-92


Plamenatz John, Man and Society, Addison Wesley Longman, London & New York,. III, 1991 .
144-145
107
., , . ., ., ,
1991, . 374-376
106

51


. , ,
347 ,
,
.
( ).


,
. ,
,

(Nietzsche) 20 ,
.

.....108
.
, . ,



,

.

,
.
, ,
,


,

108

., , . ., . , , 2000, . 36-37

52

,
. ,
,


, ,

.

53

5.

18 19
, . , ,
, ,
.
,
.
, , , ,

- . ,
,

,


,
( )109

( ) .110
, ,
.

.
, , ,
.


- ,
109

Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 305
110
.. 308

54


, ,

. , ,
, ,

, ,

-
, .

, ,
,
,

, .111

,

.
, ,

,

- , ,



, ,
. , , -

,
111

Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Al. Wood Nisbet, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, 1991, 347

55


.

,

.
. ,

,

,
, . , ,



,
.
, ,

,
,


, . , , ,
,
- ,

.

,


,
56

.
,


.

,

,

-




(). , :
,



, (
),
, ,


,

,
.112
,
,

112

Paine, The rights of man, J.M.Dent & Sons, London, 1958, .94-97

57

58

6.

. ,
,
,
, ,
. ,
,

, ,
,
(1807)

(1820).


,
,
,
, .
, ,

,



. , , ,
,,
,

. ,
, ,
59




,

.
, , ,

,


.

60

7.
:
1. Hegel, Elements of the philosophy of right, Allen Wood H.B. Nisbet,
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991
2. Hegel, Lectures on the philosophy of world history, Introduction, trans by H.B.
Nisbet, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1975
3. Hegels Philosophy of Mind, trans by W.Wallace & A.V.Miller, Oxford
University Press, London, 1971
4. Hegel, Political Writings, trans by L.Dickey - H.B. Nisbet, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge,1999
5. Hegel, The Phenomenology of mind, trans by J.B.Baillie, 2nd edition,
Humanities Press, London, 1971

:
1. , , , 1966. .
., , 1998
2. , . ., , 1995
3. Beiser, The Cambridge Companion to
Hegel, Cambridge University
Press,1993
4. Cullen, Hegel today, Gower Publishing Company, USA, 1988
5. Inwood, Hegel, London New York, Routledge, 1983
6. Mure, The philosophy od Hegel, Thoemmes Press, 1993
7. Stauss & Cropsey, History of political thought, 2nd edition, Rand McNally,
Chicago, 1972
8. Wilkins, Hegels philosophy of history, Cornell University Press, Ithaca &
London, 1974
9. Wollin, Sh, Politics and Vision, Boston, MA, 2004

:
1. , ., , .
, , 1997
2.
3. , , : , .
, , 1980
4. ., , . . & .,
. , , 1991
5. , , , ., ,
, 1998
6. .,
, . , , 1978

61

7. ., ,
, . ., . , , 1985
8. ., , , 1977
9. ., , . ., . , ,
2000
10. ., ,. , . . , .
, , 1982
11. ., , . . . , 3 .,
. ., 1963
12. , , . , , 1994
13. ., , ,
, . . ., .
, . , 1989
14. Avinery Sh., Hegels theory of the modern state, Cambridge University
Press,1974
15. Findlay I.N., Hegel: a re examination, New York Humanities Press, c,
1970
16. Juszezak, J, Hegel et la libert, ed. Sedes Cdil reunis, Paris, 1980
17. Kojeve, Al, Introduction to the reading of Hegel, trans by J.C.Nichols, Cornell
University Press, Ithaca & London, 1986
18. Losurdo, D, Hegel and the freedom of moderns, Duke University Press,
Durham and London, 2004
19. MacIntyre, Al, Hegel: a collection of critical essays, University of Notre
Dome, London, 1976
20. Paine, The rights of man, J.M.Dent & Sons, London, 1958
21. Pelczynski, Hegels political philosophy problems & perspectives, a
collection of new essays, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1971
22. Pelczynski, The state and civil society : studies in Hegels political
philosophy, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1984
23. Plamenatz, Jh, Man and society, Addison Wesley Longman, London and New
York, v. II, 1991
24. Rilley, P., Will and Political Legitimacy: a critical exposition of social
contract theory in Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, Kant & Hegel, Harvard
University Press, Cambridge, 1992
25. Stace, W.T, The philosophy of Hegel, Dover Publication, INC, 1995
26. Stern, G W Hegel, Critical Assessments, Routledge, London & New
York,v. IV, 1993
27. Stirling, J.H, Lectures on the philosophy of Law, reprint of the edition London
1873. Scienta Verlag Aalen, Germany, 1977
28. Taylor, Ch, Hegel & modern society, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
1985

62