Riset dan Publikasi Ilmiah

Ocky Karna Radjasa

Direktorat Riset dan Pengabdian Masyarakat

Direktorat Jenderal Penguatan Riset dan Pengembangan
Kemenristek Dikti
14 Desember 2016

Publikasi dalam sistem ranking PT Dunia
Academic Ranking of
World Universities (ARWU)

QS World University Rankings
(QS-WUR)

Times Higher Education of
World University Ranking (THE)

Per CapitaNobel/ Fields
Medal Alumni,
Performance
10%
10%

SCI/SSCI/ A&
HCI Articles,
20%

Nobel/ Fields
Medal Winner,
20%

Citations Per
Faculty, 20%
Research volume,
income and
reputation, 30%

Teaching & learning
environment, 30%
Int'l Student, 5%

Int'l Faculty, 5%

Research Income
from Industry, 2.5%

Nature/ Science
Articles, 20%

HiCi
Researcher,
20%

Academic Peer
Review, 40%

Int'l Staff and
Student, 5%

Citations, Per Paper,
32.5%
Student Faculty
Ratio, 20%
Employer Review,
10%

Shanghai Jiao Tong Criteria
Criteria

Quality of Education

Indicator

Weight

Alumni of an institution winning Nobel Prizes and Fields Medals

10%

Staff of an institution winning Nobel Prizes and Fields Medals

20%

Highly cited researchers in 21 broad subject categories

20%

Articles published in Nature and Science*

20%

Articles in Science Citation Index-expanded, Social Science Citation
Index

20%

Academic performance with respect to the size of an institution

10%

Quality of Faculty

Research Output

Size of Institution

Targetted outputs of Research in University

Research Productivity:
-No. papers published in
international peer-reviewed
journal
-No . competitive research
grants
- No. IPR

Research Impact:
- No. citation
- No. research based-teaching
materials
- No. research based-teaching
books
- Outreach

Attractiveness and Competitiveness

Survival of University

Research excellence:
-No. highly cited papers
- H-index
- No. publication in highly impact
journals
- No. CoE

Two major academic literature collections (Indexers): Web of
Science and Scopus
• Thomson Reuters Web of Science (WoS) and SciVerse Scopus are the most widespread databases on
different scientific fields which are frequently used for searching the literature (Guz & Rushchitsky,
2009)
• The competition between WOS and Scopus databases is intense “kompetisi yang intens, kuat, tajam ..
”. This competition has led to improvements in the services offered by them.
• WoS: http://www.webofknowledge.com - Journal Citation Reports  Impact Factor
• SCOPUS: SCOPUS.com - SCImago (www.scimagojr.com)  SNIP and SJR

http://adat.crl.edu

H-index

Impact Factor
Impact Factor (IF), Thomson: perbandingan antara jumlah artikel yang
mensitasi terhadap jumlah artikel yang dipublikasi oleh sebuah jurnal

THE-QS World University Rankings
International Student 5%
International Staff 5%

Score calculated based on the proportion of total
students that are international.

Score calculated based on the proportion of Full
Time Equivalent (FTE) faculty that are international.

Academic Peer Review 40%

Citation/Staff 20%

Score based on research performance factored against
the size of the research body .

Five years of publication data with citations from
Scopus.

Number of citations is divided by the number of FTE
staff to give an indication of the density of research.

Staff/Student 20%

Score based simply on the student faculty ratio, the higher the
number of faculty per student the higher the score.
Full- and part-time numbers for staff and students obtained; FTEs
used throughout as far as possible.

THE-QS
Rankings

Academics indicate which field they specialise in and
then list up to 30 universities they regard as leaders in
this field.
Composite score drawn from peer review survey (which
is divided into five subject areas). Results compiled based
on three years’ worth of responses totaling 6,354 in
2008.
Safeguards against individuals voting for their own
university strengthened.
Rise of Asian universities is least apparent in this ranking.

Employer Review 10%

Score based on responses to employer survey. 2,339 responses in
2008.
Recruiter names are sourced through QS databases, media partners
and partner schools & universities.
Responses are weighted by region to reach a final score.

What is Scopus?
 Largest Citations and Abstract database – 16,700+
sources from 6,000 publishers

 Comprehensive Scientific, Technical, Medical and
Social Sciences coverage. Arts & Humanities
 Quality Web Sources – Institutional Repositories
 Patent searching from 5 major patent offices
 Citations Analysis of your researchers, institution,
journal, research area

Focused
web
information

16,700+ titles
STM &
Social
sciences

SCOPUS
Academic
library
sources

10

Repositories

Mengukur Kualitas Riset
 Classic measure of research quality
 Citations per staff member (not per paper)

 Number of publication per staff
 Source: Scopus (http://www.scopus.com

12/6/09

Quartile Score Ranking
Quartile Score Ranking membagi jurnal termasuk yang terindeks Scopus
menjadi 4 Quartile score (Q1-Q4) berdasarkan distribusi Impact Factor per
jurnal. (www.scimagojr.com), yaitu
Q1: 25% terbaik IF

Q2: terbaik IF 25-50%
Q3: terbaik IF 50-75%

Q4: terbaik IF 25% di bawah

12

Scopus-indexed publications
• Research article
• Review
• Short Communication
• Proceeding
• Book/book chapter

JURNAL Terindeks Scopus

Country

2011

2016

Malaysia

46

79

Thailand

26

26

Philippines

13

22

Indonesia

8

25

DOAJ 200
SCOPUS 25

Pola Pertumbuhan PUBLIKASI
INTERNASIONAL Terindeks Scopus
(sd Oktober 2016)

Sumber: Analisis berbagai sumber tahun 2016

10 best ASEAN QS WORLD UNIVERSITY RANKING (2016)
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

University

Ranking

Country

National University of Singapore
(NUS)
Nanyang Technological
University of Singapore
University of Malaya (UM)
Chulalongkorn University
Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM)
Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM)
Singapore Management
University
Mahidol University
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia
Universitas Indonesia

1

Singapore

Overall
Score
100

3

Singapore

98.4

27
45
49
51
60

Malaysia
Thailand
Malaysia
Malaysia
Singapore

84.9
69.8
67.8
66.7
62.6

61
63
67

Thailand
Malaysia
Indonesia

62.5
61.9
61.0

Number of publications indexed by Scopus in TOP 10
(per 23/11/2016)

No

Institution

Documents

1

ITB

6639

2

UI

5208

3

UGM

4068

4

IPB

2613

5

LIPI

1957

6

ITS

1958

7

UB

1393

8

UNDIP

1319

9

UNPAD

1177

10

CIFOR

1108

Capaian dan Target Kinerja Ditjen Penguatan Riset dan Pengembangan
2015
No

Indikator Kinerja

2016

Target

Reali
sasi

Target

Realisa
si*)

Target
2017

1

Jumlah Publikasi Internasional

5.008

6.470

6.229

7.463

7.769

2

Jumlah HKI yang Didaftarkan

1.580

1.521

1.735

2.100

1.910

3

Jumlah prototipe R&D  TRL s.d 6

530

1.641

632

442

783

4

Jumlah prototipe industri  TRL 7

5

5

15

48

20

Keterangan:
*) Sumber: http://simonev.ristekdikti.go.id tanggal 6 September 2016
*) Realisasi masih dalam proses pencapaian

17

JURNAL ILMIAH ELEKTRONIK DI
INDONESIA
JURNAL ILMIAH TERINDEKS SCOPUS
JURNAL ILMIAH ELEKTRONIKINDONESIA
Country

2011

2015

2016
16280

16000

Malaysia

46

79

84

Thailand

26

26

28

14000
12000
10000

Philiphine

13

22

23

Indonesia

8

20

25

9240

8000
6000
4000

4000
2000
300

1500

700

900

2010

2011

0

2009

2009

2010

2011

2012
2012

2013
2013

2015

2015
2016

2016

DAFTAR JURNAL INDONESIA TERINDEKS SCOPUS PER JUNI 2015
No
1

Nama Jurnal Ilmiah
International Journal of Electrical Engineering and Informatics

Penerbit
Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB)

2
3
4
5
6
7

Journal of ICT Research and Applications
Journal of Mathematical and Fundamental Sciences
Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences
Indonesian Journal of Chemistry
Gadjah Mada International Journal of Business
International Journal of Power Electronics and Drive Systems

Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB)
Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB)
Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB)
Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM)
Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM)
Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science (IAES)

8

International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering

Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science (IAES)

9
10
11
12
13
14
15

Bulletin of Chemical Reaction Engineering & Catalysis
International Journal of Technology
Biodiversitas
Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics
Agrivita
Al-Jami’ah
TELKOMNIKA Telecommunication Computing Electronics and Control

Universitas Diponegoro (UNDIP)
Universitas Indonesia (UI)
Universitas Negeri Sebelas Maret (UNS)
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia (UPI)
Universitas Brawijaya (UB)
UIN Sunan Kalijaga
Universitas Ahmad Dahlan (UAD)

16
17
18
19

Biotropia
Critical Care and Shock
Acta Medica Indonesiana
Kukila (Bulletin of Indonesian ornithology)

SEAMEO BIOTROP
Indonesian Society of Critical Care Medicine
Indonesian Society of Internal Medicine
Pusat Informasi Lingkungan Indonesia (PILI-NGO Movement)

Studia Islamica

UIN Jakarta

20

No
Nama Jurnal Ilmiah
21 Medical Journal of Indonesia

ISSN
2252-8083

Penerbit
Universitas Indonesia

22 International Journal on Advanced Science, Engineering 2088-5334
and Information Technology

Indonesian Society for Knowledge and Human
Development

23 Telkomnika: Indonesian Journal of Electrical
Engineering
24 Media Peternakan

2302-4046

Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science (IAES)

P-ISSN 0126-0472
E-ISSN 2087-4634
ISSN 1978-6301
E-ISSN 2355-6994

Institut Pertanian Bogor

25 Journal of Indonesian Islam

Sunan Ampel Surabaya

Fasilitasi Publikasi Ilmiah
Insentif Artikel Terbit di
Jurnal Internasional (100)
50 Insentif Buku

Pelatihan Penulisan Artikel
Internasional (400)

100 Bimbingan
Penulisan Buku

Publikasi
Nasional
300 Pelatihan
Penulisan Artikel

Publikasi
Internasional
Penyelenggaraan
Konferensi Internasional
di Indonesia 19

1 Peta Publikasi
Perguruan Tinggi
Mengikuti Konferensi Internasional
di LN 225

Fasilitasi Jurnal Ilmiah
(700) Pelatihan
Penggunaan OJS

Bantuan
Internasionalisasi
Jurnal Ilmiah (25)
Workshop
Internasionalisasi
Jurnal Ilmiah (43)

269 Akreditasi
Jurnal Ilmiah

Jurnal
Nasional
(1) Perbaikan Sistem
Akreditasi

Jurnal
Internasional
Langganan basis
data e-Jurnal (4
pkt)
Sosialisasi, Monitoring,
Evaluasi e-Journal
(900)

(50) Bantuan Tata
Kelola Jurmnal
Internasional

23

PROSES

Penilaian Kinerja Penelitian PT
http://simlitabmas.dikti.go.id/kinerja

KOMPONEN PENILAIAN
Peneliti
http://forlap.dikti.go.id

SUMBER DAYA
PENELITIAN

Dana dari DRPM dan
Non-DRPM

30%

Fasilitas Penunjang

Kelembagaan

MANAGEMEN
PENELITIAN

Standar prosedur

15%

Forum Ilmiah
Publikasi di jurnal

LUARAN
PENELITIAN

Pemakalah
HKI dan Luaran lainnya

MANDIRI

Verifikasi
Data

50%

UTAMA
Validasi
Data

MADYA

Buku Ajar

REVENUE
GENERATING

Kontrak kegiatan
Unit Bisnis

BINAAN

5%

Skor
Kinerja
KLASTER PERGURUAN TINGGI

PELAPORAN

melalui http://simlitabmas.dikti.go.id/kinerja

HASIL PEMETAAN

No Periode
Pemetaan

TIGA PERIODE PEMETAAAN KINERJA PENELITIAN
PERGURUAN TINGGI

Mandiri

Utama

Madya

Binaan

Total
Kontributor

1

Tahun 2007-2009

10

22

71

291

394

2
3

Tahun 2010-2012
Tahun 2013-2015

14
25

36
73

79
160

772
1.219

901
1.447

HASIL

Konversi Nilai Total Kinerja Penelitian dengan Jumlah Perolehan Bintang

Kelompok Perguruan Tinggi Mandiri

(Bidang prioritas & isu strategis)

Kemana harus mencari?

PARAMETER PEMETAAN RISET PT
1

4
2

5
BUKU AJAR/TEKS

3

7

6

Data 2015, Sumber: www.simlitabmas.dikti.go.id per 31 Januari 2016 dan www.sciencedirect.com

8

KEUNGGULAN RISET NASIONAL
BERDASAR TOTAL 8 PARAMETER
2680

Kesehatan, Penyakit Tropis, Gizi dan Obat-obatan
Teknologi Informasi dan Komunikasi

1854

MIPA

1469

Ilmu Teknik

1312

Integrasi Nasional dan Harmoni Sosial (Sosio Humaniora)

1174

Pembangunan Manusia dan Daya Saing Bangsa

972

Ilmu Ekonomi

880

Material Maju

825

Perubahan Iklim dan Keanekaragaman Hayati

643

Ketahanan dan Keamanan Pangan

532

Ilmu Pendidikan

532

Ilmu Tanaman

432

Energi Baru dan Terbarukan

426

Seni dan Budaya/Industri Kreatif

389

Ilmu Hewani

374

Infrastruktur

247

Ilmu Bahasa

200

Pengelolaan dan Mitigasi Bencana
Transportasi

155
115

Otonami Daerah dan Desentralisasi

90

Maritim

89

Pengentasan Kemiskinan

60

Pertahanan dan Keamanan

19

Mart,2015

32

Mart,2015

33

Mart,2015

34

Mart,2015

35

36

Mart,2015

37

Mart,2015

38

Publication ethics—is there a problem?
The view from the press

Definitions
• Fabrication is making up data or results and recording or reporting them.
• Falsification is manipulating research materials, equipment, or processes, or
changing or omitting data or results such that the research is not accurately
represented in the research record.
• Plagiarism is the appropriation of another person’s ideas, processes, results, or
words without giving appropriate credit

40

Why does misconduct happen?

 Publish or Perish Pressure
 Desire to “get ahead”
 Personal problems
 Grant or gone
 Cultural Differences

Retracted Publications: The Hidden World of Biomedical Literature

Merle Rosenzweig*, Anna Ercoli Schnitzer, Katy Mahraj, and Irina Zeylikovich
University of Michigan Taubman Health Sciences Library

Why types of misconduct are reported?

A. Gawrylewski (2009) The Scientist 23:67.

Who commits scientific misconduct?

A. Gawrylewski (2009) The Scientist 23:67.

Retractions on the rise
But is misconduct also on the rise?

Ricahrd Van Noorden, Nature (2011) summarizing

Wager & Williams. Journal Medical Ethics
Why and how do journals retract articles? An analysis of Medline retractions
1988–2008
Carl Zimmer, NYTimes (2012)summarizing
Steen. Journal of Medical Ethics
Retractions in the scientific literature: is the incidence of research
fraud increasing

Results: Average of Months to Retraction

Terima Kasih atas perhatiannya

KEMENTERIAN RISET TEKNOLOGI DAN
PENDIDIKAN TINGGI
48