_

• Sb dlltE_ o T7 IT -6-\?; ctr6
INDICTMENT
DIV. `7"s
A TRUE BILL

IN THE NAME OF AND BY THE AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL
CIRCUIT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA

In and for Palm Beach County, at the Second Term thereof, in the year Two Thousand and
Sixteen, to-wit:

COUNT 1:
FIRST DEGREE MURDER

The Grand Jurors of the State of Florida, inquiring in and for the body of said County of Palm
Beach, upon their oaths do present and charge that:

KRISTEN MEYER and ALEJANDRO ALEMAN on or about April 1, 2016, in the County of
Palm Beach and State of Florida, did unlawfully from a premeditated design to effect the death
of a human being, kill and murder T. A., a human being by, depriving T.A of food and/or water
and/or proper nutrition and/or medication, contrary to Florida Statute 782.04(1)(a)1 and
782 .04(1)(a)2 . (CAPITAL FELONY)

COUNT 2:
AGGRAVATED CHILD ABUSE

The Grand Jurors of the State of Florida, inquiring in and for the body of said County of Palm
Beach, upon their oaths do present and charge that:

KRISTEN MEYER and ALEJANDRO ALEMAN on or between January 1, 2016 and April 1,
2016, in the County of Palm Beach and State of Florida, did knowingly or willfully, intentionally
inflict physical injury that resulted in great bodily harm, permanent disability or permanent
disfigurement to T.A. a child,{or) willfully tortured, maliciously punished, or willfully and
unlawfully caged T. A., a child, contrary to Florida Statute 827.03(1)(a)lifd (2)(a). (1 DEG
FEL)

02/13/17 Page 1 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
• •
COUNT 3:
CRUELTY TO ANIMALS

The Grand Jurors of the State of Florida, inquiring in and for the body of said County of Palm
Beach, upon their oaths do present and charge that:

KRISTEN MEYER and ALEJANDRO ALEMAN on or between March 1, 2016 and April 1,
2016, in the County of Palm Beach and State of Florida, did unlawfully and unnecessarily
torment or deprive of necessary sustenance or shelter, any animal in a cruel or inhumane manner,
contrary to Florida Statute 828.12(1). (1 DEG MISD)

Against the form of the statute, and against the peace and dignity of the State of Florida.

I hereby certify that I have advised the Grand Jury returning this indictment as authorized and
required by law.

DAVID ARONBERG
STATE AT ORNEY
c

By:
Desi BY ated Assistant Stat ttorney of the
Fill enth Judicial Circu of the State
of Florida, prosecuting for the said State

GRA P JURY FOREPERSON

DATE
?/07404-
KRISTEN MEYER, W/F, 10/03/1973
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN, W/M, 03/03/1978
Booking No.:

FCIC REFERENCE NUMBERS:
1) FIRST DEGREE MURDER SAGES:0999 FDLE REC NO:2535
2) AGGRAVATED CHILD ABUSE SAGES:3802 FDLE REC NO:7324

02/13/17 Page 2 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION WITHIN COURT FILING
Pursuant to Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2.420(d)(2), the filer of this court
record (Indictment) indicates that confidential information is included within the document
being filed; to wit: Social Security Number, § 119.0714.

02/13/17 Page 3 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
• cy6rn5t- ARREST ! NV-1
,110E TO APPEAR
3<;), 3
OBTS Number 1. Arrest 3. Request for Warrant Juvenile I
.J.,.. I I
Juvenile Referral Report 2. N.T.A. 4. Request for Capias a.
Agency ORI Number Agency Name Agency Report Number
tu
FLO!
Charge Type:
5 , 0 1 0 l 0, 0 1 0 PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFFS DEPARTMENT
0
0
Weapon Seized
61-[ I IV
. I-1°15 A 1 --1 3 &1(1
Multiple
i I)
10"- Check as many
Z as apply.
1. Felony
2. Traffic Felony
3. Misdemeanor
0
4. Traffic Misdemeanor
5.
6.
Ooth
rdenranceuxdrc
Enter Type
Clearance
Indicator In i
a
Location of Arrest (Incligling Name it Batess) AA
,..i __a_..:3
Location of Offense (Business Name, Address)

1019 1 ?CfbhOiti . e ivesf &
e oy.rrest c TiTe of. Irresti r
i
5
Booking Date 1M:oking ime Jail Date Jail Time Location of Vehicle
Dg
11 I Illib i I s-i 1 1
NameP1(Lest, First,
Fir; Middle) 4 f Alias (Name, DOB, Soc. Sec. #, Etc.)
1 ez,
:i Cdti 6fri.)
t
Race 1 Sex Date of Birth ,..._ Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color f. Compl ion Build
W - White
B - Black
I -American Indian 1 u M
O- OrientaVAsian 1
D 2) I 45 3
t 1 ,---7 16 --C, 2 _ .?e,'D 6/Aii_it/ 4c Id .v /1/1W4
Scars, 7r-21:12toosi Unique Physical Features (Location, Type, Description) Marital Status i Religiog , Indication of:
_ Alcohol Influence t7' 8
i- fliAA ett (a-Mir,. /fie") Drug Influence 0 0
Z Local Addcess (Stree,t, Apt, Number) .--7-
< , -, i "City) , A (State) (Zip) Phone Residence Type:
3. Florida
Z
tit / 014 5c ifitoiti -isk° West Fax 6re,Cit (c, 327,0 ( 5.401)60,4 5, 2. County 4. Out of State I
[i
`j Permanent Address ptreq Apt. Numbp...., (City), i (State) (Zip) Phone, Address.Spurce 7

- fact 5ci /Awn/ -(Sie 1,6 e/ 9f-g 1ifeca Fc- '32,10 (561)00,2-W Vt"ri'i
Business Address (Name, Street) (City) (State) (Zip) Phone Occu ation ,,,..-...
) .,
__-- ( OC../ /repolri 1., efr----
INS Number Place of Birth (CttyyVte) , D: s hip
ctti c490 ,..t t t A./0 el
Co-Defendant Name (Last, First, Middle) Race Sex Date of Birth 0 1. Arretted 0 3. Felony
.L: 0 2. At Large 04. Misdemeanor
05. Juvenile
D Co-Defendant Name (Last, First, Middle) Race Sex Date of Birth 0 1. Arrested 0 3. Felony
0 2. At Large 04. Misdemeanor
05. Juvenile
0 Parent Name (Last) ira) (Middle) Residence Phone
ID Legal Custodian
0 Other: ( )
Address (Street, Apt. Number) ) (State) (Zip) Business Phone
( )
U Notified by: (Name) ate Time Juvenile Disposition
J 1. Handle/Processed within 2. TOT HRS/CYF
Dept. and Released. 3. Incarcerated
2
Released to: (Name) Relationship Date Time
/
The above address was provided by 0 defendant and / or 0 defends 's parents. The child and / or parent was told School Attended Grade
to keep the Juvenile Court Clerk's Office (Phone 355-2526) informed of ny change of address.
CI Yes, by: (Name) 0 No: (Reason)
Property Crime? Description of Property Value of Property
0 Yes 0 No

Drug Activity S. Sell R. Smuggle K. Dispense/ M. Manufacture/ Z. Other Drug Type B. Barbiturate H. Hallucinogen P. Paraphernalia/ U. Unknown
) N. N/A B. Buy D. Deliver Distribute Produce/ N. N/A C. Cocaine M. Marijuana Equipment Z. Other
) P. Possess T. Traffic E. Use Cultivate A. Amphetamine E. Heroin 0. Opium/Deriv. S. Synthetic
Charge Descri174.on

RP1Dec&
Drug Activity Drug Istie
It Udtir-
Amitint / Unit Offense #
Counts Storesfic .
ic ence
OY 121N - Statute. Violation Number

1115 19-1.10 1%-t 1 1
Warrant / Capias Number
i

1(1 1 ..,4 )
(..."Ydtie 1 Bondfl
Violation of ORD #

I10-0
4R1 tin ()DCr7 irS crAkX co( i ubite
Charge Description , t .) t Domestic
.. (
Counts
nolence
Statute Violation Number Violation of ORD 4

k - uc chi 14 hipsz y ON 913-1-7 1.1 Dt.31 1 1(1 I I I )
Drug y Drug ype Amount / Unit IOffense # Warrant / Capias Number Bond
1 4(,'-a 03 t ( Lt. 6 Derif 6- C__MCK cv
Charge Description . Couits Domestic lute Violation Number ,, Violation of ORD #
n
r-ft)?-(./ jr) Alvith9(5 oy ON .t :
I K 1.1 1 410 0- (s ') I (61
10I I )
Drug Activity DruglType Amount / Unit Ofitse # Warrant / Capias Number Bonititve
...._
o c 8.1.3%. t 11C1 00eilik crAKY
Charge Description Counts Domestic Statute Violation Number Violation of ORD #
Violence

Drug Activity Drug Type
OY ON I 1 1.1 I I I 1(1 1 I I )
Amount / Unit Offense # Warrant / Capias Number Bond

Location (Court, Room Number, Address)

- -- -N-
Court Date and Time ....e-_ ‘... - .....
Month Day Year Time
P.M. A.M.
I AGREE TO APPEAR AT THE TIME AND PLACE DESIGNATED TO ANSWER THE OFFENSE CHARGED OR TO PAY THE FINE SUBSCRIBED. I UNDERSTAND THAT SHOULD I WILLFULLY
FAIL TO APPEAR BEFORE THE COURT AS REQUIRED BY THIS NOTICE TO APPEAR, THAT I MAY BE HELD IN CONTEMPT OF COURT AND A WARRANT FOR MY ARREST SHALL BE ISSUED.

Signature of Defendant (or Juvenile and Parent / Custodian) Date Signed

HOLD for other Agency apuriCiArre ing Officer Name Verification (Printed by Arrestee)
Name:
it.. 1 (4, 0
0
r
Dangerous 0 Resisted Arrest N e of A estTfic r rint) (PRINT)
0 Suicidal 0 Other PAGE
LAiv rfrt CIA/
Intake Deputy I.D. # Pouch # s ing Officer I. D . # ...., Agency t
Qs, / 3 fr c ?,,'.c.„.S .I Witness here it subject signed with an "X" _ OF ___
"0. ,2,„ ....
02/13/17
DISTRIBUTION: WHITE - COURT COPY GREEN - STATE ATTORNEY Page 4YELLOW - AGENCY PINK Public
- JAIL Records Request No.: 17-058
GOLD - DEFENDANT(N.T.A 's ONLY)
0 #148 REV. 04/10
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 1
OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: INACTIVE
DIVISION: ROAD PATROL

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 04/01/16 SATURDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 6972 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

DECEASED DOB:
SEX: F RACE: W HT: 0 WT: 0 HR: UNKNOWN EYE: UNKNOWN
RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS: 17148 N 30TH LA LOX FL 33470
HOME PHONE: 561 000-0000
BUSINESS PHONE: 561 000-0000
COMPLAINANT KRISTEN A MEYER ALEMAN DOB: 10/03/1973
SEX: F RACE: W HT: 500 WT: 200 HR: BLOND EYE: BROWN
RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS: 17148 N 30TH LA LOX FL 33470
HOME PHONE: 772 475-4478
BUSINESS PHONE: 561 000-0000
ARRESTEE ALEJANDRO ALEMAN DOB: 03/03/1978
SEX: M RACE: W HT: 509 WT: 250 HR: BALD EYE: BROWN
RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS: 17148 N 30TH LA LOX FL 33470
HOME PHONE: 561 662-1684
BUSINESS PHONE: 561 000-0000
LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CHAD M EASTERDAY DOB: 11/28/1978
SEX: M RACE: W HT: 511 WT: 0 HR: UNKNOWN EYE: UNKNOWN
BUSINESS PHONE: 561 776-2000
ARRESTEE KRISTEN A MEYER ALEMAN DOB: 10/03/1973
SEX: F RACE: W HT: 500 WT: 200 HR: BLOND EYE: BROWN
RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS: 17148 N 30TH LA LOX FL 33470
HOME PHONE: 772 475-4478
BUSINESS PHONE: 561 000-0000

OFFENSE INDICATOR: OFFENSE 1 VICTIM NUMBER: 1
VICTIM TYPE: JUVENILE
RESIDENCE TYPE: COUNTY RESIDENCE STATUS: FULL YEAR
EXTENT OF INJURY: FATAL
INJURY TYPE(1): OTHER
INJURY TYPE(2): NOT APPLICABLE
VICTIM RELATION: CHILD
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE RELATED: YES

VICTIM NUMBER: 1 OFFENDER NUMBER: 1
HOMICIDE CIRCUMSTANCES: OTHER

02/13/17 Page 5 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
5
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 2
OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

JUSTIFIABLE CIRCUMSTANCES: NOT APPLICABLE
JUSTIFIABLE CODE: NOT APPLICABLE
AGENCY: PBSO OFFICER NAME: EASTERDAY
SUPERVISOR ON SCENE: SGT SAVAGE 4356
WHERE BODY FOUND: 17148 30TH LANE. N. LOX
OFFICER VIEWED BODY AT: PALMS WEST HOSPITAL
UNIDENTIFIED REMAINS: N
BODY I.D. BY: PARENTS
FIRE RESCUE: 21, 22
REMOVAL SERVICES: MEDICAL
PRONOUNCE BY: PALMS WEST AT: PALMS WEST
CAUSE OF DEATH: UNKNOWN
BODY RELEASED TO: MEDICAL EXAMINER DATE: 040116
NEXT OF KIN NOTIFIED:
NEAREST RELATION: KRISTEN MEYER-ALEMAN

VICTIM NUMBER: 1 OFFENDER NUMBER: 2
HOMICIDE CIRCUMSTANCES: OTHER
JUSTIFIABLE CIRCUMSTANCES: NOT APPLICABLE
JUSTIFIABLE CODE: NOT APPLICABLE
AGENCY: PBSO OFFICER NAME: EASTERDAY
SUPERVISOR ON SCENE: SGT SAVAGE 4356
WHERE BODY FOUND: 17148 30TH LANE N LOX
OFFICER VIEWED BODY AT: PALMS WEST HOSPITAL
BODY I.D. BY: PARENTS
FIRE RESCUE: 21, 22
REMOVAL SERVICES: MEDICAL
PRONOUNCE BY: PALMS WEST AT: PALMS WEST
CAUSE OF DEATH: UNKNOWN
BODY RELEASED TO: MEDICAL EXAMINER DATE: 040116
NEXT OF KIN NOTIFIED:
NEAREST RELATION: KRISTEN MEYER-ALEMAN

VEH/VESS STATUS CODE: MISC / OTHER VEH/VESS TYPE: TRUCK / VAN
VALUE OF VEH/VESS: $ 40000
LICENSE TYPE: TRUCK
VEH STATE LICENSE: FL TAG YR: 2016 VEH YR: 2016
VEH LICENSE NO. E8004D VEH LICENSE DECAL: 19177797
VEH MAKE: FORD VEH STYLE:
VEH COLOR: BLK
VIN NUMBER: 1FDUF4GT8GEA24241
INSURANCE CO: GRANITE STATE INS. POLICY: 84607461 PH:

REPORT NUMBER: 1
FLORIDA VICTIM ? N
WEATHER: CLEAR

ON FRIDAY 04/01/16 AT APPROXIMATELY 18:57 HOURS I RESPONDED TO 17148 30TH LN
N LOXAHATCHEE IN RESPONSE TO A 1 YEAR OLD NOT BREATHING.
UPON MY ARRIVAL PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE #21 AND #22 WERE ALREADY ON
SCENE. THEY HAD THE CHILD, IN THE BACK OF THE FIRE RESCUE TRUCK.
I SPOKE TO THE COMPLAINTANT W/F KRISTEN MEYER-ALEMAN. I OBTAINED HER NAME AND
INFORMATION AND THE CHILDS INFORMATION. KRISTENS HUSBAND W/M ALEJANDRO ALEMAN
THEN SHOWED UP. HE DROVE KRISTEN TO PALMS WEST. I GAVE A TAPED WITNESS
STATEMENT TO THIS INVOLVEMENT TO DETECTIVE L. KING #5487. SEE HIS REPORT FOR

02/13/17 Page 6 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 3
OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

THE DETAILS.
I THEN STOOD BY TO WAIT FOR DETECTIVES TO SHOW UP. I CONTACTED THE DCF
HOTLINE AND FILED A REPORT. I SPOKE TO KRISTEN #058. I THEN COMPLETED A CAC
FORM AND A LOG ENTRY. I CONTACTED ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL FOR THE DOGS WHICH
WERE INSIDE THE RESIDENCE. I WAS THEN RELOCATED TO STANDBY WITH THE FAMILY 1
HOUSE TO THE EAST OF MY ORIGINAL LOCATION. I STOOD BY HERE FOR THE REMAINDER
OF MY TIME. I ALSO COMPLETED A CRIME SCENE LOG WHICH WILL BE TURNED IN TO
EVIDENCE.
THIS ENDS MY INVOLVEMENT WITH THIS CASE.
DS EASTERDAY 6972 040216 0608
TRANS VIA COPY/PASTE 040416 RL/7727

02/13/17 Page 7 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
7
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 4
SUPPLEMENT 1 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 04/04/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON FRIDAY, APRIL, 01, 2016, I RESPONDED TO PALMS WEST HOSPITAL IN
REFERENCE TO A DECEASED ONE-YEAR-OLD TODDLER, . MOTHER
KRISTEN MEYER, CALLED 911 STATING TAYLOR WAS UNRESPONSIVE AND NOT BREATHING.
EMERGENCY SERVICES ARRIVED ON SCENE AND TRANSPORTED TAYLOR TO THE HOSPITAL
WHERE SHE WAS LATER PRONOUNCED DECEASED. THE EMERGENCY ROOM DOCTOR STATED THE
CAUSE OF DEATH IS DUE TO EXTREME MALNUTRITION. DCF WAS NOTIFIED AND RESPONDED
ON SCENE. THE MEDICAL EXAMINER WAS NOTIFIED. THE STATE ATTORNEY'S OFFICE WAS
ALSO NOTIFIED AND RESPONDED ON SCENE.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:04-04-16@10:17AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 8 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 5
SUPPLEMENT 2 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 04/01/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 23163 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON 4/1/16 AT APPROXIMATELY 2100 HOURS I WAS DISPATCHED TO 17148 30TH LN N IN
UNINCORPORATED LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 TO ASSIST DEPUTY EASTERDAY WITH A MAN
DOWN/ SICK PERSON CALL.
WHEN I ARRIVED I MET WITH DEPUTY EASTERDAY IN FRONT OF THE RESIDENCE. I STOOD
IN FRONT OF THE HOUSE AWAITING FURTHER INSTRUCTION UNTIL APPROXIMATELY 2300
HOURS WHEN I WAS RE-ASSIGNED TO THE REAR OF THE PROPERTY. I TOOK A POSITION ON
THE REAR WEST SIDE OF THE RESIDENCE. AFTER THE CHILDREN WERE REMOVED FROM THE
HOUSE I WAS ASSIGNED TO ESCORT THE CHILDREN AND DCF TO A DCF FACILITY. AT
APPROXIMATELY 0500 HOURS I RETURNED TO THE RESIDENCE TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
SECURITY FOR INVESTIGATORS STILL ON SCENE. I REMAINED IN MY VEHICLE IN FRONT
OF THE RESIDENCE UNTIL APPROXIMATELY 0620 HOURS. THIS CONCLUDES MY INVOLVEMENT
WITH THIS CASE.
DS SINNOTT 23163 040316 0600
TRANS VIA COPY/PASTE 040416 RL/7727

02/13/17 Page 9 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 6
SUPPLEMENT 3 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: ROAD PATROL

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 04/01/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 18352 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON FRIDAY, APRIL 1ST, 2016, AT APPROXIMATELY 2002 HOURS, I, D/S STOCKWELL
#18352 WAS DISPATCHED TO 13001 SOUTHERN BOULEVARD, LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
(PALMS WEST HOSPITAL) IN REFERENCE TO A DECEASED PERSON CALL. WHILE EN-ROUTE,
I WAS INSTRUCTED BY SERGEANT THOMAS #6492 TO MAKE CONTACT WITH LIEUTENANT
FUSCA #24992, IN THE EMERGENCY ROOM (ER), ONCE I ARRIVED. UPON MY ARRIVAL, AT
APPROXIMATELY 2017 HOURS, I MADE CONTACT WITH LIEUTENANT FUSCA WHO HAD BRIEFED
ME ON THE SITUATION. LIEUTENANT FUSCA THEN INFORMED ME THAT I WAS TO REMAIN
OUTSIDE OF ER ROOM #1. WHILE OUTSIDE OF THIS ROOM, I WAS TO MAINTAIN VISUAL
AND PHYSICAL SECURITY OVER THE ROOM. HE FURTHER INSTRUCTED ME THAT NO ONE WAS
ALLOWED TO ENTER THE ROOM OTHER THAN OFFICIAL INVESTIGATORS OF THIS CASE. I
REMAINED AT THIS POST UNTIL THE BODY WAS REMOVED BY THE MEDICAL EXAMINER'S
OFFICE, AT APPROXIMATELY 0015 HOURS, ON APRIL 2ND. AT THAT TIME, I MADE
CONTACT WITH LIEUTENANT KALMUS #2092, WHO WAS NOW THE ON SCENE SUPERVISOR.
LIEUTENANT KALMUS INFORMED ME THAT I WAS NO LONGER NEEDED AND COULD RETURN TO
SERVICE. IT IS NOTED THAT I DID NOT HAVE ANY INVOLVEMENT WITH THE
INVESTIGATION OF THIS CASE, NOR DID I SPEAK WITH ANY POTENTIAL SUSPECTS OR
WITNESSES.
AT THIS TIME, THIS CONCLUDES MY INVOLVEMENT WITH THIS CASE.
THIS REPORT IS FOR SUPPLEMENTAL PURPOSES ONLY.
D/S STOCKWELL #18352
EMAILED 4/4/16 AT 0109 HOURS
TRANS 4/5/16/KR

02/13/17 Page 10 Public Records Request No.: 17-058 l-0
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 7
SUPPLEMENT 4 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: ROAD PATROL
PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 04/01/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 4356 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000
ON 04-01-16 AT 18:48 HOURS I WAS DISPATCHED TO 17148 IN REFERENCE TO A ONE
YEAR OLD NOT BREATHING. UPON MY ARRIVAL I NOTICED THAT FIRE RESCUE HAD ALREADY
ARRIVED AND HAD STARTED TREATMENT ON THE CHILD. D/S EASTERDAY WHO ALSO
RESPONDED TO THE CALL WAS WITH THE MOTHER OF THE CHILD STANDING IN THE DRIVE
WAY. I WAS ADVISED BY FIRE RESCUE THAT THE BABY WAS IN BAD CONDITION AND WAS
BEING TRANSPORTED TO PALMS WEST HOSPITAL FOR FUTHER TREATMENT.
I THEN RESPONDED TO PALMS WEST HOSPITAL TO FOLLOW UP ON THIS INCIDENT. UPON
ARRIVAL I NOTICED NUMEROUS HOSPITAL PERSONNEL IN A TREATMENT ROOM ATTEMPTING
TO REVIVE THE BABY. I WAS THEN ADVISED BY THE ER DOCTOR THAT THE BABY HAD BEEN
PRONOUNCED DEAD. I THEN ENTERED THE TREATMENT ROOM WHERE THE BABY WAS LOCATED
AND SEEN THAT THE BABY'S BODY WAS SEVERELY MALNOURISHED. I THEN NOTIFIED MY
SUPERVISOR AND REQUESTED THE COMMUNICATION SUPERVISOR CONTACT OUR SPECIAL
INVESTIGATION UNIT TO INVESTIGATE THIS INCIDENT. I THEN SECURED THE TREATMENT
ROOM WHERE THE CHILDS BODY WAS LOCATED WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF ROAD PATROL
DEPUTIES UNITL DETECTIVES AND CRIME SCENE COULD ARRIVE. I ALSO ASSISTED WITH
THE FAMILY MEMBERS AT THE HOSPITAL.
PRIOR TO LEAVING THE RESIDENCE I ASKED D/S EASTERDAY TO REMAIN AT THE
RESIDENCE IN CASE THE RESIDENCE BECAME A CRIME SCENE. WHEN DETECTIVES ARRIVE
AT THE HOSPITAL THEY ADVISED THAT THE RESIDENCE WOULD BE A CRIME SCENE AND
THAT THEY WOULD BE SECURING A SEARCH WARRANT AS PART OF THERE INVESTIGATION.
AFTER CLEARING THE HOSPITAL I RETURNED TO THE RESIDENCE ON 30TH LANE AND
REJOINED D/S EASTERDAY AND D/S SINNOTT AND REMAINDED AT THE RESIDENCE UNITL
A WARRANT COULD BE SECURED AND DCF ARRIVED TO TAKE CUSTUDY OF THE THE
REMAINING KIDS INSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE. I REMAINED ON SCENE UNITL
APPROXIMATELY 04:45 HOURS
SGT SAVAGE 4356 040216
TRANS VIA COPY/PASTE 040516 RL/7727

02/13/17 Page 11 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
1/
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 8
SUPPLEMENT 5 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE
PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 04/18/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000
ON FRIDAY, APRIL 01, 2016, I, DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN# 8192 ALONG WITH
ASSISTING DETECTIVE LARA #8679, ARRIVED AT PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, LOCATED AT
13001 SOUTHERN BLVD, IN LOXAHATCHEE FLORIDA OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, REFERENCE
DECEASED ONE-YEAR-OLD TODDLER, UPON INTO THE EMERGENCY ROOM I
WITNESSED A WHITE MALE YELLING AT THE HOSPITAL STAFF AND TAKING PICTURES OF
THEM FROM THE NURSING STATION. THE MAN WAS LATER IDENTIFIED AS THE VICTIM'S
FATHER ALEJANDRO "ALEX" ALEMAN. MR. ALEMAN WAS VERY IRATE AND UPSET BECAUSE HE
WAS NOT ALLOWED TO ENTER THE ROOM WHERE THE DECEASED VICTIM WAS BEING HELD. WE
THEN MADE CONTACT WITH RESPONDING DEPUTIES AND SHIFT SUPERVISOR SERGEANT
SAVAGE #4356, WHO BRIEFED US ON THE INCIDENT.
WE THEN MADE CONTACT WITH THE PARENTS OF THE DECEASED CHILD, MR. ALEJANDRO
"ALEX" ALEMAN AND MRS. KRISTEN MEYER, WHO WERE IN THE FAMILY BEREAVEMENT AREA
OF THE EMERGENCY ROOM. DETECTIVE LARA AND I SPOKE WITH SOME FAMILY MEMBERS WHO
WERE PRESENT BUT WERE NOT INVOLVED WITH THE INCIDENT. DETECTIVE LARA AND I
INTRODUCED OURSELVES TO MR. ALEJANDRO ALEMAN WHO WAS ON HIS CELLULAR PHONE
SPEAKING TO A WOMAN NAMED DANA EARLE WHO HE TOLD ME WAS HIS ATTORNEY.
MR. ALEMAN THEN PUT HIS CELLULAR PHONE ON LOUD SPEAKER IN ORDER FOR
DETECTIVE LARA AND I TO HEAR WHAT SHE WAS ADVISING HIM TO DO WHICH WAS NOT
SPEAK TO ANY LAW ENFORCEMENT REPRESENTATIVE REFERENCE THIS INCIDENT SINCE WE
WERE DECLARING THERE WAS A CRIME SCENE. MR. ALEMAN TOLD US HE WAS NOT GOING
TO COOPERATE WITH THE INVESTIGATION AT THIS TIME PER HIS ATTORNEY'S ADVICE.
MR. ALEMAN PROVIDED ME WITH HIS ATTORNEY'S NAME AND TELEPHONE NUMBER FROM A
PRE-PRINTED BUSINESS CARD.
DETECTIVE LARA AND I THEN PROCEEDED TO WHERE THE DECEASED CHILD WAS BEING
HELD IN THE EMERGENCY ROOM. UPON ENTERING THE ROOM I MADE THE FOLLOWING
OBSERVATION OF BODY: THE CHILD'S BODY APPEARED VERY FRAIL AND
SMALL IN SIZE. BODY DID NOT LOOK LIKE THAT OF AN AVERAGE ONE-YEAR-OLD
CHILD. THE CHILD'S WEIGHT AT DEATH WAS APPROXIMATELY SEVEN POUNDS. THE CHILD'S
SKIN APPEARED VERY LOOSE AND WRINKLED IN TEXTURE. THE SKIN ON THE CHILD'S
VAGINAL AND BUTTOCKS AREA APPEARED VERY RED IN COLOR. THE SKIN APPEARED RAW
WITH SORES WITH OBVIOUS BREAKAGE OF THE SKIN. THE CHILD HAD WHAT APPEARED TO
BE A DARK COLORED CIRCULAR BRUISE AROUND HER LEFT EYE. WHILE INSPECTING THE
MOUTH OF THE CHILD I OBSERVED SHE DID NOT HAVE ANY DEVELOPED TEETH FOR HER
AGE
I LATER ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN IF SHE WOULD BE WILLING TO SPEAK TO ME IN
ORDER TO HELP US UNDERSTAND THE EVENTS THAT LED TO THE DEATH OF HER DAUGHTER
MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN AGREED TO SPEAK TO ME BRIEFLY. SHE THEN
IDENTIFIED HERSELF TO ME AS MRS. KRISTEN MEYER-ALEMAN. REFERENCE THE INCIDENT,

02/13/17 Page 12 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 9
SUPPLEMENT 5 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME SHE HAS TEN CHILDREN IN TOTAL WITH HER HUSBAND
ALEJANDRO "ALEX" ALEMAN. SHE STATED WAS THEIR TENTH AND YOUNGEST CHILD.
MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME TOLD ME SHE IS A STAY AT HOME MOM AND THIS EVENING
SHE WAS AT HOME WITH HER CHILDREN FEEDING AT APPROXIMATELY 6:24 P.M.
MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME SHE REMEMBERS THE TIME BECAUSE THAT IS WHEN HER
HUSBAND "ALEX" CALLED HER LIKE HE USUALLY DOES ASKING WHAT WAS FOR DINNER.
MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME SHE WAS FEEDING AND MUST HAVE BEEN
FULL BECAUSE SHE NO LONGER WANTED HER BOTTLE. SHE TOLD ME HAD ALREADY
EATEN 8 TO 9 OUNCES OF HER FORMULA THREE TO FOUR HOURS PRIOR. MRS. MEYER-
ALEMAN TOLD ME THE DOCTOR HAD ADVISED HER TO FEED EXTRA FORMULA BECAUSE
SHE WAS A LITTLE UNDERWEIGHT. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME THIS IS WHAT THE
PEDIATRICIAN LOCATED IN PORT ST. LUCIE, FLORIDA TOLD HER BACK IN DECEMBER WHEN
SHE LAST TOOK FOR A CHECK-UP. I ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN THE NAME OF
PEDIATRICIAN SHE TOLD ME SHE COULD NOT REMEMBER THE DOCTOR'S NAME BUT
SHE IS AN INDIAN WOMAN WITH A PRIVATE PRACTICE.
MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME AFTER SHE GOT OFF THE PHONE WITH HER HUSBAND
APPEARED A LITTLE "LETHARGIC" AS IF SHE WAS SLEEPY. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME
SHE CONTINUED HOLDING IN HER ARMS AND THAT IS WHEN SHE NOTICED SOMETHING
WAS WRONG WITH THE MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME SHE CALLED HER HUSBAND
BACK AND HE TOLD HER TO CALL 911. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN SAID SHE THEN CALLED 911
WHO HELPED WALKED HER THOUGH CPR UNTIL RESCUE ARRIVED AND TRANSPORTED TO
PALMS WEST HOSPITAL. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN STATED HER HUSBAND THEN ARRIVED AT THE
HOUSE AND THEY LEFT THEIR OLDEST SON TO WATCH THE CHILDREN WHILE THEY WENT TO
THE HOSPITAL.
I ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN IF HAD BEEN SICK OR NOT FEELING WELL IN
THE PAST FEW DAYS AND SHE SAID, "NO." MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME WAS A
PERFECTLY, HEALTHY BABY WHO WAS FINE UNTIL THIS EVENING. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN
TOLD ME SHE CANNOT UNDERSTAND WHAT HAPPENED BECAUSE EVERYTHING OCCURRED SO
FAST. SHE SAID ONE MINUTE WAS FINE AND SUDDENLY SHE JUST STOPPED
BREATHING WHILE IN HER ARMS AND NOW SHE IS DEAD. I ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN IF
HAD ANY MEDICAL CONDITIONS AND SHE SAID, "NO." MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME
WAS BORN AT MARTIN MEDICAL IN STEWART, FLORIDA WEIGHING NINE-POUNDS WITH
NO BIRTH DEFECTS OR MEDICAL COMPLICATIONS. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN SAID ALL OF HER
TEN CHILDREN WERE BORN HEALTHY WITH ABSOLUTELY NO MEDICAL ISSUES OR
COMPLICATIONS. I ASKED MRS.
I ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TO TELL ME WHAT ROUTINE DIET CONSISTED
OF AND SHE TOLD ME WAS NOT YET EATING SOLID FOODS. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN
TOLD ME WAS STILL ON THE FORMULA CALLED SIMILAC BUT SHE HAS BEEN GIVING
THE FORMULA WITH REGULAR MILK SUGGESTED BY THE DOCTOR TO GET HER WEIGHT
UP. SHE TOLD ME WOULD DRINK AN 8 TO 9 OUNCE BOTTLE EVERY 3 TO 4 HOUR
DAILY. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME EVEN THOUGH THE DOCTOR RECOMMENDED SHE FEED
MORE FORMULA TO GET HER WEIGHT UP SHE DID NOT WANT TO OVER FEED
BECAUSE AT TIMES WOULD BE TOO FULL AND SHE WOULD NOT WANT TO DRINK
ANYMORE. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME HER TWO-YEAR OLD SON WAS
ALSO A LITTLE UNDERWEIGHT JUST LIKE WHEN HE WAS AGE BUT HE
FINALLY FILLED IN AND IS NOW PERFECTLY HEALTHY IN SIZE.
I ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN ABOUT THE RASH AND REDNESS HAD ON HER
VAGINAL AND BUTTOCKS AREA. MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN TOLD ME SHE NOTICED WHAT SHE
REFERRED TO AS, "MINOR RASH" ON VAGINA AND BOTTOM ONLY YESTERDAY. I
ASKED HER WHAT SHE WAS USING TO TREAT THE "MINOR RASH" AND SHE SAID SOME
DIAPER RASH CREAM. I ASKED MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN IF SHE KNEW HOW GOT THE
RASH AND SHE TOLD ME IT WAS PROBABLY FROM THE "JUICE." I ASKED MRS. MEYER-
ALEMAN WHAT KIND OF JUICE SHE WAS GIVING THAT WOULD CAUSE THAT KIND OF A
RASH AND SHE SAID, "APPLE JUICE." MRS. MEYER-ALEMAN WAS COOPERATIVE AND
PROVIDED ME WITH THE NAMES, AGES AND DATES OF BIRTH FOR ALL OF THE CHILDREN

02/13/17 Page 13 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
13
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 10
SUPPLEMENT 5 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

WHO WERE CURRENTLY AT THE RESIDENCE. ALTHOUGH MR. ALEMAN WAS NOT PRESENT AT
THE TIME OF THE INCIDENT HE REFUSED TO COMMENT OR COOPERATE WITH THIS
INVESTIGATION PER HIS ATTORNEY'S LEGAL ADVICE.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING OBTAINING A SEARCH WARRANT FOR THE ALEMAN
RESIDENCE.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:04-18-16@7:21AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 14 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
/9
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 11
SUPPLEMENT 6 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE
PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 06/08/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON SATURDAY, 04/02/2016, ASSISTING DETECTIVE LARA #8679 WAS ABLE TO OBTAIN
A SEARCH WARRANT FOR THE ALEMAN RESIDENT LOCATED AT 17148 30TH LANE NORTH IN
LOXAHATCHEE, FLORIDA OF PALM BEACH COUNTY. THE WARRANT WAS APPROVED AND SIGNED
BY THE ON DUTY JUDGE MARTIN H. COHEN AT APPROXIMATELY 0233 (2:33 A.M.). DCF
INVESTIGATOR ALONG WITH ASSISTING DEPUTIES WAS PRESENT ON
SCENE. THE ALEMAN FAMILY WAS PRESENT ON SCENE AS WELL ALONG WITH SOME FAMILY
MEMBERS STANDING BY A FEW HOUSES AWAY FROM THE FAMILY RESIDENCE. DCF
INVESTIGATOR SPOKE TO THE ALEMAN'S AND FAMILY BRIEFLY AND
EXPLAINED TO THE PARENTS THAT THE OTHER NINE(9) CHILDREN WERE GOING TO BE
REMOVED AND PLACED INTO DCF CUSTODY DUE TO THE NATURE OF THIS CASE AND THE
DEPLORABLE LIVING CONDITIONS OF THE HOME. MR. AND MRS. ALEMAN WERE VERY UPSET
ABOUT THIS DECISION. MS. PROVIDED THEM WITH HER CONTACT INFORMATION AND
THE NECESSARY STEPS THEY NEEDED TO FOLLOW WITH THIS PROCESS.
MR. ALEMAN WAS THEN ASKED TO CALL HIS OLDEST SON FROM HIS CELL PHONE TO
HAVE HIM OPEN THE DOOR. MR. ALEMAN WAS VERY PERSISTENT ABOUT GOING TO THE
FRONT DOOR HIMSELF BECAUSE HE STATED THAT HIS AMERICAN BULLDOG CAN BECOME VERY
AGGRESSIVE AND THE CHILDREN WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO CONTROL THE DOG AND ONLY HE
COULD. WE ASSURED MR. ALEMAN HIS ASSISTANCE WOULD NOT BE NECESSARY AND WE HAD
A PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE K-9 DEPUTY WHO IS TRAINED TO HANDLE THE
SITUATION. AS RESPONDING DEPUTIES PROCEEDED TO THE FRONT DOOR THE TWO OLDER
CHILDREN CAME OUT WITH THE BOXER DOG. THE DOG WAS VERY COOPERATIVE AND WAS
TAKEN FROM THE CHILDREN AND HANDED OVER TO MR. ALEMAN. THE K-9 DEPUTY THEN
ENTERED THE RESIDENCE TO LOCATE THE OTHER DOG AS THE CHILDREN WALKED OVER TO
WHERE DCF INVESTIGATORS WERE STANDING BY IN THE DRIVEWAY. THE CHILDREN STATED
THE OTHER DOG WAS INSIDE ONE OF THE BEDROOMS IN HIS CAGE. ONCE THE AMERICAN
BULLDOG WAS LOCATED BY K-9 DEPUTY AND HE DID NOT APPEAR TO BE A THREAT AND HE
WAS CAGED THE K-9 DEPUTY EXITED THE SCENE.
CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATOR JULIANN BRANT #4169 ARRIVED ON SCENE TO PROCESS
THE RESIDENCE. ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL WAS ALSO NOTIFIED AND RESPONDED.
UPON ENTERING THE HOME I WAS OVERWHELMED BY A STRONG, PUNGENT ODOR OF
URINE AND FECES COMING FROM INSIDE THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE. ONCE INSIDE WE
ASSISTED DCF IN REMOVING THE CHILDREN. THE HOUSE REEKED SO BAD ONE CAN SMELL
THE URINE AND FECES FROM THE FAR END OF THE DRIVEWAY LEADING TO THE HOUSE.
ONCE INSIDE THE HOUSE THERE WERE FLIES, GNATS AND WHAT APPEARED TO MAY HAVE
BEEN FLEAS SWARMING THE HOUSE. THERE WERE PILES OF CLOTHING LOCATED ON THE
FLOOR ENTRANCE OF THE FOYER. THE LIVING ROOM WALLS HAD WHAT APPEARED TO BE
FECES SMEARED ON THEM. SEVERAL OF THE CHILDREN WERE ASLEEP ON THE SECTIONAL
COUCH LOCATED IN THE LIVING ROOM AREA. THE OTHER CHILDREN WERE SCATTERED ON

02/13/17 Page 15 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 12
SUPPLEMENT 6 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
THE COUCH OF THE MASTER BEDROOM LYING UNDER PILES OF CLOTHING WHERE ALL THAT
COULD BE SEEN WERE THE BOTTOM OF THEIR LITTLE FEET.
I ALONG WITH RESPONDING DETECTIVES AND DEPUTIES ON SCENE ASSISTED DCF WITH
THE REMOVAL OF THE CHILDREN. THE OLDEST OF THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WAS VERY
COOPERATIVE AND HELPED WAKING UP AND CARRYING OUT HIS YOUNGER SIBLINGS TO THE
DCF VEHICLES THAT WERE PARKED IN THE DRIVEWAY. ONCE ALL OF THE CHILDREN WERE
INSIDE OF THE VAN THE OLDEST TWO BOYS BECAME RESISTANT AND DEMANDED TO SEE
THEIR PARENTS. DCF AND PBSO DEPUTIES ATTEMPTED TO TALK TO THE CHILDREN TO CALM
THEM DOWN BUT THE OLDEST TWO BOYS REFUSED TO GET INSIDE OF THE VAN BY PLACING
THEIR FEET IN THE DOORWAY OF THE VEHICLE. THE BOYS THEN TRIED RUNNING OUT OF
THE VAN BUT WERE RESTRAINED AND THEN ESCORTED BY RESPONDING DEPUTIES INTO THE
BACK OF A PBSO VEHICLE WHERE THEY WERE TRANSPORTED INTO DCF CARE. THE OTHER
YOUNGER CHILDREN REMAINED IN THE VAN AND WERE TRANSPORTED AS WELL BY ASSISTING
DCF INVESTIGATOR WITHOUT FURTHER INCIDENT.
THERE WAS AN AMERICAN BULLDOG FOUND IN A RUSTED CAGE INSIDE OF WHAT
APPEARED TO BE ONE OF THE CHILDREN'S BEDROOMS. THE DOG APPEARED VERY
MALNOURISHED, DIRTY AND UNCARED FOR. THE CAGE APPEARED AS IF IT HAS NOT BEEN
CLEANED OUT IN WEEKS. THE CAGE WAS FILLED WITH DOG FECES AND URINE WHICH HAD
HARDENED AND COMPOSTED INTO A SOLID MASS. THE DOG DID NOT APPEAR TO BE
AGGRESSIVE AT ALL AS STATED BY MR. ALEMAN. THE DOG APPEARED TO BE AFRAID AND
WAS LATER REMOVED BY ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL REMOVED THE AMERICAN BULLDOG FROM
THE RESIDENCE.
WHILE EXECUTING THE SEARCH WARRANT IT WAS DISCOVERED THAT THERE WAS NO
FOOD IN THE HOME. THERE WAS ONLY ONE FEEDING BOTTLE FOUND IN THE HOME FOR
AND A HALF CONTAINER OF GENERIC BRAND SIMILAC BABY FORMULA POWDER. IT
APPEARS THAT SLEPT INSIDE OF THE MASTER BEDROOM OF THE HOME. THERE WAS
NO CRIB BUT INSTEAD A DIRTY PLAYPEN THAT APPEARED TO CONVERT INTO A BASINET ON
TOP WAS FOUND NEXT TO THE BED OF THE MASTER BEDROOM. IT APPEARS TO BE WHERE
BABY SLEPT. THERE WAS VERY FEW BABY CLOTHING FOUND IN THE ROOM FOR
THERE WERE SEVERAL TUBES OF DIAPER RASH CREAM ALONG WITH AN OPEN BAG OF
DIAPERS.
INSIDE OF THE KITCHEN THE GARBAGE CANS WERE FILLED WITH DOG FECES WHICH
FLIES AND FLEAS WERE HOVERING OVER. IN THE KITCHEN PANTRY THERE WERE ONLY TWO
LARGE BOXES OF MASH POTATOES FOUND. THERE WERE TWO REFRIGERATORS IN THE HOME.
ONE WAS A NEWER MODEL STYLED REFRIGERATOR THAT SAT INSIDE OF THE KITCHEN AREA
WHICH WAS COMPLETELY EMPTY. THE OTHER REFRIGERATOR WAS AN OLDER MODEL STYLED
REFRIGERATOR WHICH SAT ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE KITCHEN. THE OUTSIDE THE
REFRIGERATOR WAS FILTHY. INSIDE THE REFRIGERATOR THERE WAS A HALF-GALLON OF
MILK SOME UNKNOWN CHUNKY LIQUID THAT APPEARED TO BE EXPIRED AND ROTTEN. THERE
WERE VERY LIMITED EDIBLE ITEMS FOR THE CHILDREN TO EAT. IN THE FREEZER THERE
WAS AN OPEN BAG OF FRENCH FRIED THAT WERE SPILLED OVER ONTO THE FREEZER TRAYS.
INSIDE ONE OF THE KITCHEN CABINETS WAS A FEW CANS OF SOUP AND SOME LARGE SIZED
BOTTLES OF CONDIMENTS SUCH AS KETCHUP AND MUSTARD AND A HALF LOAF OF MOLDY
BREAD
INSIDE, THE CARPETS IN THE BEDROOMS WERE BLACK IN COLOR, STAINED, WET,
STICKY AND HAD A REEKING ODOR. THERE WERE TWO TOILETS, ONE IN THE MASTER
BEDROOM WHICH WAS OCCUPIED BY THE PARENTS AND THE OTHER IN THE MAIN HALLWAY
WHICH APPEARED TO BE THE OLDER CHILDREN'S BATHROOM. THE TOILETS WERE FILLED
WITH UNFLUSHED FECES AND URINE AND IT APPEARED AS THOUGH THE TOILET WAS NOT
WORKING. INSIDE OF THE LAUNDRY ROOM WAS A PILE OF CLOTHES SO HIGH IT WAS
DIFFICULT TO OPEN THE DOOR. THE DOOR HAD TO BE PUSHED WITH GREAT FORCE IN
ORDER TO SEE INSIDE. THE CLOTHES WERE ALL SOILED AND REEKING OF URINE. THE
PILE OF CLOTHING WAS STACKED SO HIGH IT BLOCKED THE ACCESS DOOR WHICH LED INTO
THE GARAGE. THERE WAS A LOAD OF LAUNDRY THAT APPEARED TO HAVE BEEN SITTING
INSIDE THE WASHING MACHINE FOR WEEKS BECAUSE THE CLOTHES STARTED TO SMELL LIKE

02/13/17 Page 16 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 13
SUPPLEMENT 6 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

A WET BUILDUP OF MILDEW.
PHOTOGRAPHS AND VIDEO FOOTAGE WAS DOCUMENTED BY CSI BRANDT AND PLACED INTO
PBSO EVIDENCE.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING THE MEDICAL EXAMINERS AUTOPSY EXAMINATION
AND FINDINGS.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:06-08-16@7:16AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 17 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
/7
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 14
SUPPLEMENT 7 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 06/08/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON SATURDAY, 04/02/2016, THE AUTOPSY EXAMINATION OF WAS
CONDUCTED AT THE PALM BEACH COUNTY MEDICAL EXAMINER'S OFFICE BY DR. JUSTE. PER
DR. JUSTE THE CAUSE OF DEATH HAS NOT YET BEEN DETERMINED AND IS CURRENTLY
PENDING LABORATORY EXAMINATION RESULTS.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:06-08-16@7:21AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 18 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
1?
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 15
SUPPLEMENT 8 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 06/23/16 THURSDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON WEDNESDAY, 6/22/2016, I WENT TO THE PALM BEACH COUNTY MEDICAL
EXAMINER'S OFFICE WHERE I MADE CONTACT WITH MS. PAMELA CAVENDER REFERENCE THE
STATUS OF THIS CASE AND AN UPDATE ON THE LABORATORY RESULTS FOR THE CAUSE OF
DEATH OF MS . CAVENDER WAS ABLE TO LOCATE THE FILE IN THE
DATABASE WHICH STATED THE FINAL DETERMINATION AND RESULTS WERE STILL PENDING
REVIEW.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:06-23-16@7:10AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 19 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 16
SUPPLEMENT 9 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 08/08/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON APRIL 6, 2016 I ARRIVED AT THE CHILD PROTECTION TEAM (CPT) LOCATED AT
5305 GREENWOOD AVENUE IN WEST PALM BEACH. CONDUCTED AN
INTERVIEW WITH THE FOLLOWING IS A BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE
STATEMENTS MADE DURING THE INTERVIEW. DETAILED STATEMENTS WILL NOT BE
REITERATED AS THEY ARE CONTAINED WITHIN THE RECORDED INTERVIEW.
IS A TWELVE YEAR OLD WHITE MALE WHO LIVES WITH HIS FATHER,
MOTHER AND SIBLINGS. HE IS HOME SCHOOLED. HE QUALIFIED HIS UNDERSTANDING OF
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TELLING A TRUTH AND TELLING A LIE BY PROVIDING
EXAMPLES. AGREED TO SPEAK ONLY THE TRUTH DURING THE INTERVIEW. HAS
A SPEECH IMPEDIMENT AND IS DIFFICULT TO UNDERSTAND AT TIMES DURING THE
INTERVIEW.
IN REFERENCE TO THE INCIDENT, STATED HE WAS TAKEN AWAY FROM HOME AND
PUT INTO ANOTHER HOME WHERE HE CAN'T SEE OR TALK TO HIS FAMILY. HE FURTHER
ADVISED HE WAS SCARED HE WOULD NEVER SEE HIS MOTHER OR FATHER AGAIN.
STATED HE AND HIS SIBLINGS WERE TAKEN AWAY BECAUSE HIS BABY SISTER
STOPPED BREATHING. SAID HE WAS PLAYING WITH HIS BROTHERS AND SISTERS IN
THE FRONT YARD WHEN HE HEARD HIS MOTHER SCREAM. THEY ALL RAN INSIDE WHERE
SAID HE SAW HIS MOMMY CRYING AND CALLING 911. SAW HIS MOTHER GIVING
CPR ON THE BED AND LATER ON THE SOFA. AN AMBULANCE ARRIVED AND
TRANSPORTED TO THE HOSPITAL. HIS PARENTS LEFT WITH IN THE
AMBULANCE AND HE WAS TOLD TO STAY IN THE HOUSE TO WATCH HIS BROTHERS AND
SISTERS
CC ASKED IF HE THOUGHT WAS SKINNY OR HEALTHY.
SAID WAS HEALTHY AND EXPLAINED THAT HE AND HIS SIBLINGS WERE ALL SIMILAR
TO IN SIZE THEN GREW BIGGER. HE SAID HIS MOTHER ALWAYS FED . HE
DOESN'T KNOW WHAT WAS FED BECAUSE HIS MOTHER ALWAYS FED HER IN THE
BEDROOM BUT HE KNOWS SHE MADE HER BOTTLES. SAID THERE IS ALWAYS FOOD IN
THE HOUSE BUT THEY HADN'T GONE GROCERY SHOPPING BECAUSE OF WHAT HAPPENED WITH
HIS SISTER. HE SAID HIS PARENTS ARE GOOD PARENTS. THERE IS NO FURTHER
INFORMATION. FOR COMPLETE AND ACCURATE DETAILS, AUTHORIZED PERSONS SHOULD
REVIEW THE DVD COPY OF THE INTERVIEW IN ITS ENTIRETY.
CC THEN INTERVIEWED . SHE QUALIFIED HIM BY HIS UNDERSTANDING
OF THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TELLING A TRUTH AND TELLING A LIE. TYLER
DEMONSTRATED HIS UNDERSTANDING OF BOTH. TYLER IS A FOURTEEN YEAR OLD WHITE
MALE WHO ADVISED THAT HE DOES NOT GO TO SCHOOL AND HE IS HOME SCHOOLED BY HIS
MOTHER. SHE TEACHES FROM A TABLET AND ADMINISTERS TESTS TO HIM. TYLER STATED
THAT HE NOW LIVES AT A SHELTER CALLED PLACE OF HOPE BUT BEFORE THEN HE WAS
LIVING IN LOXAHATCHEE WITH HIS MOM, DAD, AND HIS SIBLINGS. HE THEN INFORMED

02/13/17 Page 20 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 17
SUPPLEMENT 9 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
THAT SOMETHING HAPPENED TO
BEGAN TO EXPLAIN WHAT HAPPENED HOWEVER HE DID NOT EXPLAIN THE STORY
IN A LOGICAL CHAIN OF EVENTS AND KEPT SKIPPING AROUND. MULTIPLE TIMES
HAD TO STOP AND ASK QUESTIONS TO CLARIFY HIS STATEMENT. HE TOLD HER ALL HE
REMEMBERS IS THAT " STOPPED BREATHING." HE WAS PLAYING OUTSIDE WITH HIS
BROTHERS; TREVIN, TANNER, AND A FRIEND (HE DID NOT PROVIDE A
NAME). TRECE, TEGAN, AND TRACEN WERE INSIDE WITH HIS MOTHER WHO WAS PREPARING
A BOTTLE FOR WHILE TYLER WAS OUTSIDE ONE OF HIS BROTHERS RAN OUTSIDE
WITH HIS DAD ON THE PHONE. HE GOT ON THE PHONE WITH HIS DAD WHO ASKED TYLER
TO GO INSIDE AND SEE WHAT'S GOING ON. WHEN HE WENT INSIDE HE SAW THAT HIS
SISTER WASN'T BREATHING IN THE CRIB. HIS MOM CALLED 911 AND HIS DAD RETURNED
HOME. HIS MOTHER WAS GIVING CPR TO AND BROUGHT TO THE SOFA AND
WAITED FOR THE PARAMEDICS TO COME TO THE HOUSE.
ASKED TYLER WHY THERE WASN'T VERY MUCH FOOD IN THE HOUSE. TYLER
SAID THAT HIS DAD WAS SUPPOSED TO GO SHOPPING THAT DAY BUT COULDN'T BECAUSE OF
WHAT HAPPENED TO ASKED TYLER WHY WAS SKINNY. TYLER
STATED THAT TAGAN AND TRACEN LOOKED LIKE WHEN THEY WERE BABIES AND THEY
BOTH GOT BIGGER. TYLER WAS ASKED ABOUT THE BRUISE ON FACE. TYLER
MADE SEVERAL INCONSISTENT STATEMENTS THAT HE DIDN'T KNOW OR THAT
DROPPED A TOY ON HER FACE CAUSING THE BRUISE.
TYLER EXPLAINED THAT HIS MOTHER TOLD HIM THE DCF (DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILIES) WERE GOING TO COME AND SHE WAS WORRIED ABOUT THEM. HIS DAD TOLD
HIM AND THAT PASSED AWAY BUT HIS OTHER BROTHERS WERE NOT TOLD YET.
TYLER DID NOT KNOW WHY DIED EXCEPT THAT SHE STOPPED BREATHING. THERE
IS NO FURTHER INFORMATION.
NEXT, CC CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW WITH TANNER ALEMAN. THE FOLLOWING
IS A BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE STATEMENTS MADE DURING THE INTERVIEW. DETAILED
STATEMENTS WILL NOT BE REITERATED AS THEY ARE CONTAINED WITHIN THE RECORDED
INTERVIEW. TANNER IS AN EIGHT YEAR OLD WHITE MALE. TANNER SPOKE WITH A
SPEECH IMPEDIMENT AND APPEARED TO HAVE A DEVELOPMENTAL DELAY. TANNER DID NOT
ANSWER MOST OF THE QUESTIONS ASKED BY TANNER COULD NOT BE QUALIFIED
DURING THE INTERVIEW. HE DID NOT PROVIDE ANY RELEVANT INFORMATION.
FOLLOWING THE INTERVIEW WITH TANNER, CC CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW
WITH THE FOLLOWING IS A BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE STATEMENTS MADE
DURING THE INTERVIEW. DETAILED STATEMENTS WILL NOT BE REITERATED AS THEY ARE
CONTAINED WITHIN THE RECORDED INTERVIEW. TREVIN IS A SEVEN YEAR OLD WHITE
MALE WHO SPOKE WITH A SPEECH IMPEDIMENT. MOST OF HIS STATEMENTS WERE NOT ABLE
TO BE UNDERSTOOD. TREVIN DID NOT PROVIDE ANY RELEVANT DETAILS OF THIS
INCIDENT. THERE IS NO FURTHER INFORMATION. FOR COMPLETE AND ACCURATE
DETAILS, AUTHORIZED PERSONS SHOULD REVIEW THE DVD COPIES OF THE INTERVIEWS IN
THEIR ENTIRETY.
FINALLY, CC CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW WITH THE
FOLLOWING IS A BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE STATEMENTS MADE DURING THE INTERVIEW.
DETAILED STATEMENTS WILL NOT BE REITERATED AS THEY ARE CONTAINED WITHIN THE
RECORDED INTERVIEW. IS A TEN YEAR OLD WHITE MALE WHO SPEAKS WITH A
SPEECH IMPEDIMENT. AT TIMES DURING THE INTERVIEW IT WAS DIFFICULT TO
UNDERSTAND HIS STATEMENTS. WAS QUALIFIED BY HIS UNDERSTANDING OF THE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TELLING A TRUTH AND TELLING A LIE. DID NOT OFFER ANY
RELEVANT INFORMATION DURING THE INTERVIEW. INFORMED HE AND HIS
SIBLINGS WERE OVERHEARD DISCUSSING WHAT TO SAY DURING THE INTERVIEW WHILE THEY
WERE WAITING AT CPT. DENIED THAT ANYBODY TOLD HIM WHAT TO SAY. THERE
IS NO FURTHER INFORMATION REGARDING THE INTERVIEWS. FOR COMPLETE AND ACCURATE
DETAILS, AUTHORIZED PERSONS SHOULD REVIEW THE DVD COPIES OF THE INTERVIEWS IN
THEIR ENTIRETY.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192

02/13/17 Page 21 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 18
SUPPLEMENT 9 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:08-08-16@6:48AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 22 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 19
SUPPLEMENT 10 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 08/08/16 MONDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON WEDNESDAY, JULY 13TH, 2016, I RECEIVED THE FINAL AUTOPSY REPORT FOR THE
CAUSE OF DEATH OF PER MEDICAL EXAMINER DR. JUSTE'S REPORT THE
MANNER OF DEATH FOR 13 MONTH OLD WAS RULED A HOMICIDE AND THE
CAUSE OF DEATH WAS "INANITION DUE TO NEGLECT." THE AUTOPSY FINDINGS STATED THE
FOLLOWING: AT THE TIME OF BIRTH WEIGHED (8LBS, 15 OUNCES) AND AT
THE TIME OF DEATH WEIGHED (7.32 LBS.). THE MEDICAL EXAMINER ALSO
DETERMINED THAT THE CHILD SUFFERED FROM: INFLUENZA B, E. COLI, BETA-HEMOLYTIC
STREPTOCOCCUS GROUP B AND HAEMOPHILUS INFLUENZA. THERE WAS ALSO POSITIVE
CULTURES FOR STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS, HAEMOPHILUS INFLUENZA AND STREPTOCOCCUS
VIRIDANS.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:08-08-16@6:51AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 23 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
g3
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 20
SUPPLEMENT 11 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 08/25/16 THURSDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON THURSDAY, 07/21/2016, ASSISTING DETECTIVE VAUGHAN #18335 AND I ARRIVED
AT THE SPEARMAN RESIDENCE LOCATED AT 17211 30TH LANE NORTH IN LOXAHATCHEE
FLORIDA, OF PALM BEACH COUNTY. I SPOKE WITH MR. AND MRS. SPEARMAN WHO RESIDE
ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE FORMER HOME OF THE ALEMAN FAMILY. MRS. SPEARMAN WAS
ABLE TO PROVIDE ME WITH A SWORN RECORDED STATEMENT. REFERENCE THE ALEMAN
FAMILY MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME SHE DID NOT HAVE ANY DIRECT CONTACT WITH
ALEJANDRO OR KRISTEN ALEMAN WHILE THEY RESIDED IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD EXCEPT FOR
AN ALTERCATION SHE HAD WITH MR. ALEMAN REFERENCE THE CHILDREN. MRS. SPEARMAN
STATED THE CHILDREN HAD BEEN THROWING OBJECTS OUT IN THE ROAD BEHIND AN
EIGHTEEN-WHEELER TRUCK.
MRS. SPEARMAN STATED SHE WAS CONCERNED FOR THE SAFETY OF THE CHILDREN.
MRS. SPEARMAN SAID SHE WENT TO KNOCK ON THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE DOOR WHERE MR.
ALEMAN CAME TO THE DOOR. MRS. SPEARMAN SAID MR. ALEMAN APPEARED TO BE VERY
UPSET AND ASKED HER WHY SHE WAS KNOCKING ON HIS DOOR. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME
SHE EXPLAINED WHAT SHE HAD JUST WITNESSED THE CHILDREN DOING IN THE MIDDLE OF
THE ROAD. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME MR. ALEMAN BECAME VERY BELLIGERENT. SHE
STATED SHE WALKED BACK TO HER RESIDENCE AND CONTACTED THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE
WHERE A DEPUTY ARRIVED ON SCENE FOR A NEIGHBOR DISPUTE. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME
HER HUSBAND AND ONE OF HER NEIGHBOR'S WALKED OVER TO THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE AND
HAD A TALK WITH MR. ALEMAN ABOUT THE ALTERCATION. MRS. SPEARMAN SAID SHE DID
NOT HAVE ANY OTHER ENCOUNTERS WITH MR. ALEMAN SINCE THAT DAY.
MRS. SPEARMAN STATED SHE NEVER MADE ANY TYPE OF CONTACT WITH MRS. ALEMAN.
I ASKED MRS. SPEARMAN HOW MANY CHILDREN SHE SAW LIVING IN THE ALEMAN HOUSE.
MRS. SPEARMAN SAID SHE ESTIMATED THERE WERE 8 TO MAYBE 10 CHILDREN LIVING IN
THE HOME. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD SHE IS A RETIRED DEPUTY FOR THE PALM BEACH COUNTY
SHERIFF'S OFFICE AND HE HUSBAND IS ALSO RETIRED FROM RIVIERA BEACH POLICE
DEPARTMENT. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME THEY ARE EITHER HOME ALL DAY OR SOMETIMES
THEY ARE IN AND OUT OF THE HOME I ASKED MRS. SPEARMAN IF SHE HAS EVER SEEN THE
ALEMAN CHILDREN OUT AND ABOUT THE NEIGHBORHOOD. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME SHE
WOULD SEE THE ALEMAN CHILDREN ALWAYS OUT PLAYING IN THE MIDDLE OF THE DIRT
ROAD WITH NO SHOES ON, AND THEIR APPEARANCE WAS "DISHEVELED." MRS. SPEARMAN
SAID THE CHILDREN APPEARED NORMAL TO HER IN SIZE BUT THEY WERE ALWAYS WEARING
THE SAME TYPE OF CLOTHING EVERYDAY SHE SAW THEM. THE OLDER BOYS WOULD ALWAYS
HAVE ON A BLACK TOP WITH BLACK BOTTOMS. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME THE CHILDREN
APPEARED TO BE BETWEEN THE AGE OF 2 THRU 14 YEARS OF AGE. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD
ME THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WERE NEVER OUT RIGHT DISRESPECTFUL TO HER AND SHE HAS
NEVER HAD TO INTERVENE WITH THE CHILDREN BUT HER HUSBAND WOULD SPEAK TO THEM
ONCE IN A WHILE. SHE STATED SHE NEVER SAW THE CHILDREN BEING SUPERVISED BY AN

02/13/17 Page 24 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 21
SUPPLEMENT 11 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

ADULT WHEN THEY WERE OUTSIDE. MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME SHE HAS SEEN MRS. ALEMAN
IN PASSING BUT NEVER UP CLOSE AND PERSONAL AND NEVER OUTSIDE WITH THE CHILDREN
WHILE THEY WERE RUNNING AROUND IN THE SWELL, THE BUSHES OR IN THE ROADWAY.
MRS. SPEARMAN TOLD ME SOME OF THE CHILDREN WOULD GO AND PLAY WITH HER
NEIGHBOR'S SON THAT LIVES TO THE WEST OF HER RESIDENCE, THE WARD FAMILY.
I ASKED MRS. SPEARMAN IF SHE EVER HEARD OR SAW AN INFANT CHILD BEING
CARRIED IN OR OUT OF THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE AND SHE SAID, "NO." I ASKED MRS.
SPEARMAN I ASKED HER IF SHE EVER SAW THE CHILDREN OUT IN THE ROADWAY DURING
SCHOOL TIME OR SCHOOL HOURS AND SHE SAID, "YES." MRS. SPEARMAN SAID SHE COULD
HEAR THE CHILDREN FORM INSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE AND THEY WOULD SOMETIMES COME
OUTSIDE AT APPROXIMATELY 2P.M. MRS. SPEARMAN SAID THE CHILDREN WOULD SOMETIMES
BE OUTSIDE AFTER DARK WITH NO SUPERVISION. SHE STATED A DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILIES (DCF) INVESTIGATOR CAME TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD A COUPLE OF MONTHS
PRIOR TO HER ALTERCATION WITH MR. ALEMAN IN OCTOBER OR NOVEMBER OF 2015, A
MONTH PRIOR TO HER ALTERCATION WITH MR. ALEMAN WHICH OCCURRED ON DECEMBER 24,
2015. MRS. SPEARMAN WAS ABLE TO PROVIDE ME WITH THE (DCF) INVESTIGATORS
CONTACT INFORMATION.
I ASKED MRS. SPEARMAN IF SHE EVER SAW ANY OTHER PEOPLE AT THE ALEMAN
RESIDENCE BESIDES THE CHILDREN AND PARENTS. MRS. SPEARMAN SAID SHE WOULD
SOMETIMES SEE A YOUNG ADULT MALE AND FEMALE AT THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE BUT SHE
DOES NOT KNOW WHAT THEIR RELATIONSHIP WAS WITH THE FAMILY.
MRS. ALEMAN HAD NOT FURTHER INFORMATION. I THEN CONCLUDED THE INTERVIEW.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:08-25-16@8:18AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 25 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
0ZS
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 22
SUPPLEMENT 12 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: OPEN
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 08/25/16 THURSDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 0 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON MONDAY, 07/25/2016, ASSISTING DETECTIVE TERWILLIGER #6654 AND I ARRIVED
AT THE RESIDENCE OF MRS. BARBRA CLORAN WHO RESIDES DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET
FROM THE FORMER ALEMAN HOME LOCATED AT 17151 30TH LANE NORTH, IN LOXAHATCHEE
FLORIDA, OF PALM BEACH COUNTY. MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME SHE IS A RETIRED SCHOOL
TEACHER AND HAS LIVED IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD ALMOST TWENTY-ONE YEARS. MRS. CLORAN
TOLD ME IS VERY CLOSE WITH MRS. SPEARMAN WHO HAS LIVED NEXT DOOR TO HER FOR
APPROXIMATELY TWENTY-YEARS. IN REFERENCE TO THE ALEMAN FAMILY MRS. CLORAN TOLD
ME SHE DID NOT HAVE MUCH CONTACT AT ALL WITH THE ALEMAN FAMILY BUT SHE DID
OBSERVE THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WHO WERE ALWAYS OUTSIDE BY THEMSELVES RAIN OR
SHINE. MRS. CLORAN STATED AT TIMES SHE WITNESSED THE CHILDREN WOULD BE BEATING
ON THE FRONT DOOR OF THE HOUSE WANTING TO GO INSIDE.
MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME THE CHILDREN WERE HARDLY EVER SUPERVISED NOR WAS THERE
AN ADULT OUTSIDE WITH THE CHILDREN. MRS. CLORAN SAID, "ONCE IN A GREAT WHILE
THE FATHER WAS BUT USUALLY THERE WAS NEVER AN ADULT WITH THEM." MRS. CLORAN
SAID THE CHILDREN WOULD BE OUT IN THE DIRT ROAD PLAYING WITH NO SHOES ON. SHE
STATED ONCE IN A WHILE A FEW OF THEM WOULD BE WEARING SHOES BUT NOT OFTEN.
MRS. CLORAN SAID SHE NEVER GOT THAT CLOSE TO THE CHILDREN TO DETERMINE IF THY
APPEARED CLEAN OR NOT. MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME ONE TIME SHE CAUGHT THE CHILDREN
DIGGING IN HER TRASH ONCE AND SHE EVEN SUSPECTS THEY HAD BEEN GOING THROUGH
HER MAIL. MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME SHE THOUGHT THERE WERE ONLY SEVEN CHILDREN
LIVING IN THE HOME UNTIL SHE SPOKE TO THE OWNER OF THE HOUSE, VICTOR, WHO TOLD
HER THERE WERE APPROXIMATELY TEN CHILDREN LIVING IN THE HOME AND THE WIFE WAS
CURRENTLY PREGNANT AGAIN.
I ASKED MRS. CLORAN IF SHE EVER SAW AN INFANT AMONGST THE CHILDREN AND SHE
SAID, "NO." SHE TOLD ME THE CHILDREN WERE ALWAYS OUTSIDE ALONE AND SHE NEVER
EVEN HEARD A BABY CRYING. SHE STATED SHE ONCE WENT OUTSIDE TO WALK HER DOG AT
MIDNIGHT AND SOME OF THE CHILDREN WERE STILL OUTSIDE UNSUPERVISED. MRS. CLORAN
TOLD ME SHE RECALLS A WOMAN FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES (DCF)
CALLED AND SPOKE TO HER OVER THE TELEPHONE ASKING QUESTIONS ABOUT THE ALEMAN
FAMILY MONTHS AGO BUT SHE WAS NOT SURE EXACTLY WHEN. MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME THE
(DCF) INVESTIGATOR DID CALL HER BEFORE THE DEATH OF THE BABY OCCURRED IN APRIL
2016
MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME SHE NEVER SAW THE CHILDREN LEAVE OR GET INTO A CAR TO
GO ANYWHERE. MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME IN THE DAY TIME WHEN CHILDREN SHOULD BE IN
SCHOOL SHE WOULD SEE THE CHILDREN OUTSIDE. MRS. CLORAN SAID FROM WHAT SHE
WITNESSED THE CHILDREN WERE DEFINITELY UNSUPERVISED AND NEGLECTED. MRS. CLORAN
SAID SHE IS USUALLY OUTSIDE A LOT DURING THE DAY AND SHE NEVER SAW THE
CHILDREN GETTING PROPER ATTENTION.

02/13/17 Page 26 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
plY
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 23
SUPPLEMENT 12 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

MRS. CLORAN TOLD ME SPEAKS TO THE OWNER OF THE HOME OFTEN AND SHE STILL
COLLECTS HIS MAIL FOR HIM FROM THE MAILBOX. MRS. CLORAN WAS ABLE TO PROVIDE ME
WITH THE HOME OWNER'S CONTACT INFORMATION. I THEN CONCLUDED THE INTERVIEW WITH
MRS. CLORAN.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:08-25-16@8:20AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 27 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
R7
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 24
SUPPLEMENT 13 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/02/16 THURSDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 6477 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON 09/29/2016 DETECTIVE VIONIDE SAINT JEAN FROM THE PBSO SPECIAL
INVESTIGATION DIVISION REQUESTED THE ASSISTANCE OF THE PBSO TACTICAL UNIT
AND THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS FLORIDA REGIONAL TASK FORCE. THE
AFOREMENTIONED REQUEST WAS TO LOCATE AND ARREST KRISTEN MEYER, 10-03-1973
AND ALEJANDRO ALEMAN, 03-03-1978 THAT ARE A MARRIED COUPLE. THEY WERE WANTED
FOR FELONY WARRANT #16 009718 CFAXX IN REFERENCE TO FIRST DEGREE MURDER,
AGGRAVATED CHILD ABUSE AND CRUELTY TO ANIMALS. THE WARRANT WAS ISSUED BY
JUDGE COLBATH ON TODAY'S DATE WITH A BOND AMOUNT OF NONE. PER DETECTIVE
SAINT JEAN, MEYER AND ALEMAN COULD BE POSSIBLY LOCATED AT 1019 SALMON ISLE,
WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33413.
ON TODAY'S DATE AT APPROXIMATELY 1330HRS AGENTS BEGAN SURVEILLANCE ON
THE ABOVE AFOREMENTIONED ADDRESS. AT APPROXIMATELY 1410HRS AGENTS VISUALLY
OBSERVED MEYER AND ALEMAN EXIT THE RESIDENCE AND ENTER A 2016 FORD TOW TRUCK
BLACK IN COLOR BEARING FLORIDA TAG #E8004D. AT THIS TIME AGENTS MADE CONTACT
WITH THEM AND THEY BOTH WERE ARRESTED WITHOUT INCIDENT. THEY WERE THEN
TRANSPORTED TO THE DETECTIVE BUREAU AND RELEASED TO DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN FOR
QUESTIONING. THIS CASE HAS BEEN CLEARED BY ARREST.
AGENT ALVIN HERMAN #6477
TRANS 10-03-16 CDL

02/13/17 Page 28 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 25
SUPPLEMENT 14 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/25/16 TUESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 6231 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON APRIL 1, 2016, AT ABOUT 8:00 PM, I RESPONDED TO THE PALMS WEST HOSPITAL
EMERGENCY ROOM REGARDING A DEAD CHILD. UPON ARRIVAL I MET WITH DET. SAINT-
JEAN, #8192, WHO I ASSIGNED AS THE LEAD DETECTIVE IN THE ENSUING
INVESTIGATION. DET. SAINT-JEAN INFORMED ME THAT THE CHILD WAS, IN FACT,
DECLARED DEAD BY THE EMERGENCY ROOM PHYSICIAN, WHO ALSO TOLD HER WORDS TO THE
EFFECT THAT THE CHILD'S CONDITION WAS THE WORST CASE OF STARVATION HE HAD SEEN
IN HIS PRACTICE OF MEDICINE. SHE ALSO TOLD ME THAT THE FAMILY HAD NINE
SURVIVING CHILDREN WHO WERE STILL AT THE RESIDENCE WITH ROAD PATROL DEPUTIES.
THE DECEDENT'S MOTHER AND FATHER WERE LOCATED IN THE PARKING LOT OF THE
HOSPITAL. DET. SAINT-JEAN TOLD ME THEY HAD AN ATTORNEY AND ELECTED NOT TO
ALLOW A WARRANTLESS SEARCH OF THEIR HOME. WHILE DET. SAINT-JEAN WAS ABLE TO
GET A STATEMENT FROM KRISTEN MEYER-ALEMAN, THE DECEDENT'S MOTHER, ALEJANDRO
ALEMAN, THE CHILD'S FATHER, ELECTED NOT TO MAKE ANY STATEMENT WITHOUT THE
PRESENCE OF COUNSEL.
DET. SAINT-JEAN INTRODUCED ME TO THE ALEMANS IN THE HOSPITAL PARKING LOT.
I EXPRESSED MY CONDOLENCES. THEY REINFORCED TO US THAT THEY WOULD NOT ALLOW A
WARRANTLESS SEARCH OF THEIR HOME UNDER THE ADVICE OF THEIR COUNSEL. I
INFORMED THEM THAT WE RESPECTED THAT AND THAT A SEARCH WARRANT REQUEST WOULD
BE PROMPTLY PREPARED AND PRESENTED TO A JUDGE. I FURTHER TOLD THEM THAT THEIR
ACCESS TO THE HOME WOULD NOT BE PERMISSIBLE UNTIL THE CONCLUSION OF THE SEARCH
WARRANT.
MR. ALEMAN STATED IN A FIRM TONE THAT HE WANTED "A LIMITED SEARCH
WARRANT". I INFORMED HIM THE ISSUANCE AND SCOPE OF THE SEARCH WARRANT WOULD
BE AT THE DISCRETION OF THE REVIEWING JUDGE. I ALSO EXPRESSED THAT IF THE
SEARCH WARRANT WERE APPROVED, I WOULD NEED THEIR ASSISTANCE IN GETTING THE
CHILDREN TO COME OUTSIDE WITHOUT TRAUMATIZING THEM. MY BRIEF CONVERSATION
WITH THE ALEMANS (APPROXIMATELY 5 MINUTES) WAS LIMITED TO MY CONDOLENCES AND
EXPLAINING THE MECHANICS OF THE NEXT PROCEDURAL STEP IN THE INVESTIGATION. AT
MY DIRECTION, DET. U. LARA, #8679, ASSISTED DET. SAINT-JEAN IN THE PREPARATION
OF THE SEARCH WARRANT AFFIDAVIT AND REQUEST FOR A WARRANT.
I NEXT RESPONDED TO THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE, 17148 30TH LANE NORTH,
LOXAHATCHEE. ENROUTE I SUMMONED THE ASSISTANCE OF OTHER PLAIN CLOTHES
DETECTIVES TO ASSIST IN THE LIKELY REMOVAL OF THE CHILDREN FROM THE HOME TO
FACILITATE THE EXECUTION OF THE SEARCH WARRANT. DETECTIVES J. SUAREZ, #7953,
AND L. KING, #5487, LATER ARRIVED ON SCENE AND SUBSEQUENTLY ASSISTED IN
ESCORTING THE CHILDREN FROM THE HOME.
AT SCENE I COORDINATED WITH THE PATROL SUPERVISOR, SGT. D. SAVAGE, #4356,
FOR THE CONTINUED SECURITY OF THE CRIME SCENE AND LATER THE ESCORT OF THE DCF

02/13/17 Page 29 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 26
SUPPLEMENT 14 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

VAN CONTAINING THE SURVIVING ALEMAN CHILDREN FROM THE AREA. UPON LEARNING OF
THE APPROVAL OF THE SEARCH WARRANT, I COORDINATED WITH DCF PI
WHO ARRIVED ON SCENE PRIOR TO THE APPROVAL OF THE WARRANT. I INFORMED HER
THAT DETECTIVES WOULD ASSIST IN ESCORTING THE CHILDREN FROM THE HOUSE WHILE
THE UNIFORMED DEPUTIES MAINTAINED THE CRIME SCENE PERIMETER.
I REQUESTED ALEJANDRO ALEMAN (OUTSIDE THE CRIME SCENE PERIMETER) CALL HIS
CHILDREN AND DIRECT THEM TO THE FRONT DOOR AND OUTSIDE. HE DID SO WHILE I
RETURNED TO THE FRONT DOOR TO SUPERVISE THE EFFORTS OF PLAIN CLOTHES
DETECTIVES DURING THE INITIAL CONTACT WITH THE CHILDREN AND THEIR SUBSEQUENT
REMOVAL FROM THE HOUSE. STATE ATTORNEY INVESTIGATORS ALSO ASSISTED MOVING THE
CHILDREN OUTSIDE (CHIEF INVESTIGATOR W. FRASIER AND INVESTIGATOR T. WILLS).
THE CHILDREN WERE PLACED INSIDE A VAN BROUGHT TO THE SCENE BY DCF WITH THE
EXCEPTION OF THE OLDER TWO MALES WHO BECAME EMOTIONALLY UPSET. SGT. SAVAGE
DIRECTED DEPUTIES TRANSPORT THE ELDER TWO CHILDREN SEPARATELY TO PREVENT
UPSETTING THE YOUNGER ONES INSIDE THE VAN. WE REQUESTED THE ASSISTANCE OF
DCF INVESTIGATORS INSIDE THE HOME. THEY INFORMED US THAT BASED ON THEIR
OBSERVATIONS OF THE HOME AND CHILDREN THEY WERE GOING TO SHELTER THE CHILDREN
PENDING FAMILY COURT ACTION. I WAS PRESENT WHEN THEY INFORMED THE ALEMAN'S OF
THEIR DECISION OUTSIDE THE CRIME SCENE.
FOR DETAILS OF THE RESIDENCE/CRIME SCENE, SEE THE CRIME SCENE PHOTOS,
PROPERTY RECEIPTS, AND THE CRIME SCENE REPORT. IT SHOULD BE ADDITIONALLY
NOTED THAT WHILE APPROACHING THE HOUSE'S OPEN DOOR AND ONCE INSIDE, I COULD
SMELL THE PUNGENT ODOR OF URINE AND FECES. INSIDE, THERE WAS ALSO THE SMELL
OF FECAL MATTER EMANATING FROM BOTH BATHROOMS AND A BEDROOM WHICH CONTAINED A
CAGED DOG, AND THE AMMONIA-LIKE SMELL FROM A LARGE PILE OF CLOTHES IN THE
LAUNDRY ROOM. THE KITCHEN SMELLED OF GARBAGE.
UPON THE REMOVAL OF THE CHILDREN FROM THE HOME AND SCENE, I RELEASED
DETECTIVES KING AND SUAREZ FROM THE SCENE TO END THEIR TOUR OF DUTY.
DETECTIVES SAINT-JEAN AND LARA REMAINED ON SCENE UNTIL THE CONCLUSION OF THE
SEARCH OF THE HOME INCIDENT TO THE WARRANT.
THIS CASE REMAINS CLEARED BY ARREST.
SGT. KEITH 6231 102416
COPY:PASTE:10-25-16@8:10AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 30 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
so
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 27
SUPPLEMENT 15 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 5487 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON 04/02/16 AT 0019 HOURS I CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW WITH DEPUTY EASTERDAY,
ID 6972, AT THE LOCATION OF 17148 30TH LANE NORTH, IN REFERENCE TO CASE NUMBER
16-058738.
IN THE ONSET OF THE INTERVIEW, I ASKED THE DEPUTY TO EXPLAIN THE CALL HE
RESPONDED TO AND EXPLAIN THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CALL. HE INDICATED TO ME HE
RESPONDED TO A ONE YEAR OLD CHILD WHO WAS NOT BREATHING AND WAS COLD TO THE
TOUCH. HE ARRIVED ON SCENE, AND FIRE RESCUE WAS ALREADY PRESENT WITH THE
VICTIM IN THE TRUCK. THE MOTHER WAS SITTING ON THE BACK END OF THE TRUCK
SPEAKING TO FIRE RESCUE. DEPUTY EASTERDAY ADVISED ME THAT HE APPROACHED THE
MOTHER AND RETRIEVED HER BASIC INFORMATION AND THE BASIC INFORMATION OF THE
CHILD DIRECTLY, BUT THE REMAINDER OF INFORMATION GATHERED WAS THROUGH FIRE
RESCUES QUESTIONING OF THE MOTHER.
SHE ADVISED FIRE RESCUE THAT THE CHILD HAD NO MEDICAL HISTORY AND THAT SHE
HAD TAKEN THE CHILD TO THE DOCTOR RECENTLY AND THE DOCTOR INDICATED THAT THE
CHILD WAS UNDERWEIGHT AND NEEDED TO EAT MORE. SHE STATED THAT SHE HAD TEN
CHILDREN TOTAL AND NONE OF THEM HAD ANY MEDICAL HISTORIES. FIRE RESCUE ASKED
THE SUSPECT IF THE CHILD WAS PREMATURE AND SHE INDICATED THAT THE CHILD WAS
NOT PREMATURE AND WAS BORN AT 9LBS.
I ASKED DEPUTY EASTERDAY IF THE MOTHER MENTIONED THAT THE DOCTOR INDICATED
THERE WAS A PROBLEM WITH THE CHILD'S WEIGHT TO WHICH SHE STATED THAT SHE
NEEDED TO GIVE THE CHILD MORE FOOD AND STATED THAT THE CHILD WAS FULL SO SHE
STOPPED FEEDING HIM. THE SUSPECT STATED THAT SHE NOTICED THE CHILD WAS COLD TO
THE TOUCH AND SUSTAINED BRUISING UNDERNEATH THE EYES, AND AT THAT POINT SHE
CALLED HER HUSBAND WHO ADVISED HER TO NOTIFY LAW ENFORCEMENT.
I ASKED DEPUTY EASTERDAY WHAT HAPPENED AFTER THAT AND HE ADVISED ME THAT
FIRE RESCUE TOLD THE SUSPECT TO GET INTO THE TRUCK TO HEAD TO THE HOSPITAL,
BUT SHE HESITATED AND STATED THAT SHE NEEDED TO INFORM HER OTHER CHILDREN
WHERE SHE WAS GOING AND SAID SHE WOULD RIDE OVER TO THE HOSPITAL WITH HER
HUSBAND WHEN HE ARRIVED SHORTLY AFTER.
SHE ASKED DEPUTY EASTERDAY TO WAIT TO SEE WHEN HER HUSBAND PULLED UP INTO
THE STREET, TO WHICH HE ADVISED HER TO GO WITH HER HUSBAND AND HE WOULD NOTIFY
THE CHILDREN. SHE DECLINED AND RETURNED INTO THE RESIDENCE TO TELL THE
CHILDREN THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF HER ABSENCE.
DEPUTY EASTERDAY ADVISED ME THAT SHORTLY AFTER THE MOTHER WENT INTO THE
RESIDENCE, HE ARRIVED HOME. HE THEN ADVISED THE FATHER TO DRIVE CAREFULLY TO
THE HOSPITAL, BECAUSE HE SMELLED THE OVER EXHAUST OF THE VEHICLE. THE MOTHER
EXITED THE RESIDENCE, GOT INTO THE TRUCK AND THEY DROVE OFF TO THE HOSPITAL
TOGETHER.

02/13/17 Page 31 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
3/
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 28
SUPPLEMENT 15 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

I THEN ASKED DEPUTY EASTERDAY IF HE SAW THE OTHER CHILDREN AND HE ADVISED
THAT HE DID NOT MAKE CONTACT WITH THEM, BECAUSE THE PARENTS TOLD THEM NOT TO
OPEN THE DOOR IF THEY WERE NOT HOME. HE INDICATED THIS INFORMATION CAME FROM
SERGEANT SAVAGE WHO SPOKE WITH THE PARENTS AND DID NOT GIVE LAW ENFORCEMENT
PERMISSION TO ENTER THE RESIDENCE PRIOR TO LEAVING FOR THE HOSPITAL, AND
ADVISED THE CHILDREN TO STAY IN THE RESIDENCE.
I CONCLUDED THE INTERVIEW AT 0027 HOURS.
DETECTIVE L. KING #5487
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@6:57AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 32 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 29
SUPPLEMENT 16 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 9452 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON THURSDAY, 7/28/16, I DETECTIVE CHRISTOFFEL #9452 ASSISTED DETECTIVE
SAINT-JEAN #8192, WITH PRESENTING A PHOTO LINE UP TO SEVERAL WITNESSES IN
LOXAHATCHEE. I RESPONDED TO 17128 30TH LN IN LOXAHATCHEE AND MADE CONTACT WITH
LUKE AND DEANNA BUSH. DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN PROVIDED ME WITH THE PHOTO LINEUP
FOR EACH WITNESS. I WAS UNAWARE OF WHO THE SUSPECTS WERE OR WHICH POSITION IN
THE LINEUP THEY WERE PLACED. I FIRST PRESENTED THE LINEUP TO DEANNA BUSH AND
THE PRESENTATION WAS DIGITALLY RECORDED. I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP INSTRUCTIONS
TO DEANNA WHO INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY WERE READ STATING SHE UNDERSTOOD
THEM. DEANNA VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE FEMALE SUSPECT AND SELECTED THE
SUSPECT IN POSITION #5. DEANNA INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE PHOTOGRAPH SHE
SELECTED. DEANNA THEN VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE MALE SUSPECT AND
SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN POSITION #3. SHE INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE
PHOTOGRAPH SHE SELECTED.
I THEN PRESENTED A PHOTO LINEUP TO LUKE BUSH AND THIS ADMINISTRATION WAS
DIGITALLY RECORDED. I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP INSTRUCTIONS TO LUKE WHO
INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY WERE READ, STATING HE UNDERSTOOD THEM. LUKE
VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE FEMALE SUSPECT AND SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN
POSITION #5. LUKE INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE PHOTOGRAPH SHE SELECTED.
LUKE THEN VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE MALE SUSPECT AND SELECTED THE SUSPECT
IN POSITION #3. HE INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE PHOTOGRAPH SHE SELECTED.
I THEN RESPONDED TO 17211 30TH LN IN LOXAHATCHEE AND MADE CONTACT WITH
YOLANDA AND SILUS SPEARMAN. I FIRST PRESENTED THE LINEUP TO YOLANDA SPEARMAN
AND THE PRESENTATION WAS DIGITALLY RECORDED. I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP
INSTRUCTIONS TO YOLANDA WHO INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY WERE READ STATING SHE
UNDERSTOOD THEM. YOLANDA VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE MALE SUSPECT AND
SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN POSITION #3. YOLANDA INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE
PHOTOGRAPH SHE SELECTED. DEANNA THEN VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE FEMALE
SUSPECT BUT STATED SHE DOES NOT KNOW WHAT SHE LOOKS LIKE AND WOULD NOT BE ABLE
TO PICK HER PHOTO OUT.
I THEN PRESENTED THE LINEUP TO SILUS SPEARMAN AND THE PRESENTATION WAS
DIGITALLY RECORDED. I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP INSTRUCTIONS TO SILUS WHO
INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY WERE READ STATING HE UNDERSTOOD THEM. SILUS
VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE MALE SUSPECT AND SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN
POSITION #3. SILUS INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE PHOTOGRAPH HE SELECTED.
SILUS THEN VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE FEMALE SUSPECT BUT STATED HE HAS
ONLY SEEN HER FROM FAR AWAY AND WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO PICK HER PHOTO OUT. THE
PHOTO LINEUPS AND INSTRUCTIONS WERE RETURNED TO DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN.
ON 7/29/16 I ASSISTED DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN WITH WRITING A SEARCH WARRANT

02/13/17 Page 33 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 30
SUPPLEMENT 16 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
FOR MEDICAL RECORDS FROM PALMS WEST HOSPITAL LOCATED AT 13001
SOUTHERN BLVD, LOXAHATCHEE, OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL 33470. I COMPLETED THE
SEARCH WARRANT ON THE EWARRANTS SYSTEM AND FORWARDED IT TO ASSISTANT STATE
ATTORNEY JILL RICHSTONE FOR REVIEW. ONCE APPROVED, THE WARRANT WAS NOTARIZED
BY SGT. KEITH BEFORE BEING SENT TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE STEPHENS. A COPY WAS
PROVIDED TO DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN FOR EXECUTION.
ON 8/5/16 I RESPONDED TO 17253 30TH LN N IN LOXAHATCHEE TO ASSIST DETECTIVE
SAINT JEAN WITH PRESENTING A PHOTO LINEUP TO SHAWN WARD. DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN
PROVIDED ME WITH THE PHOTO LINEUP. I MADE CONTACT WITH SHAWN WARD AND
PRESENTED THE PHOTO LINE UP TO HIM. THE PRESENTATION WAS DIGITALLY RECORDED.
I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP INSTRUCTIONS TO SHAWN WHO INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY
WERE READ STATING HE UNDERSTOOD THEM. SHAWN VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE
FEMALE SUSPECT BUT WAS UNABLE TO SELECT A PHOTO. SHAWN THEN VIEWED THE
PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE MALE SUSPECT AND SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN POSITION #3. HE
INITIALED AND DATED NEXT TO THE PHOTOGRAPH HE SELECTED. THE PHOTO LINEUP AND
INSTRUCTIONS AND CD OF THE DIGITAL RECORDING WERE PLACED INTO PBSO EVIDENCE.
ON 9/13/16 I ASSISTED DET. SAINT JEAN WITH PRESENTING A PHOTO LINE UP TO
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES (DCF) CHILD PROTECTIVE INVESTIGATORS (CPI)
JEASSIECA AND I FIRST PRESENTED A PHOTO LINEUP TO CPI
AND THIS ADMINISTRATION WAS DIGITALLY RECORDED. I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP
INSTRUCTIONS TO CPI WHO INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY WERE READ, STATING
SHE UNDERSTOOD THEM. CPI VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE FEMALE SUSPECT
AND SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN POSITION #5. CPI INITIALED AND DATED NEXT
TO THE PHOTOGRAPH SHE SELECTED. SHE THEN VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE MALE
SUSPECT AND SELECTED THE SUSPECT IN POSITION #4. SHE INITIALED AND DATED NEXT
TO THE PHOTOGRAPH SHE SELECTED.
I THEN PRESENTED THE PHOTO LINEUP TO CPI AND THIS ADMINISTRATION WAS
DIGITALLY RECORDED. I READ THE PHOTO LINEUP INSTRUCTIONS TO CPI WHO
INITIALED EACH LINE AS THEY WERE READ, STATING SHE UNDERSTOOD THEM. CPI
VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE MALE SUSPECT BUT WAS NOT ABLE TO MAKE A
SELECTION. SHE VIEWED THE PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE FEMALE SUSPECT AND WAS NOT ABLE
TO PICK OUT THE SUSPECT. SHE STATED IT WAS A LONG TIME AGO AND DOES NOT
REMEMBER. BOTH PHOTO LINEUPS AND THE CD COPY OF THE RECORDING WERE PLACED
INTO PBSO EVIDENCE. THIS CONCLUDES MY INVOLVEMENT IN THIS CASE ON 9/13/16.
DET. BRITTANY CHRISTOFFEL #9452
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@6:59AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 34 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
39
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 31
SUPPLEMENT 17 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 7953 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON 4/2/16 I RESPONDED TO 17148 NORTH 30TH LANE IN UNINCORPORATED
LOXAHATCHEE PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA IN ORDER TO ASSIST WITH THE EXECUTION
OF A SEARCH WARRANT AND THE REMOVAL OF CHILDREN FROM A FAMILY. UPON ARRIVAL I
MET WITH DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN WHO BRIEFED ME WITH THE FACTS SURROUNDING THE
CASE
I WAS ADVISED WE WERE WAITING FOR THE APPROVAL FOR SEARCH WARRANT. I WAS
ADVISED THE SEARCH WARRANT WAS FOR REMOVAL OF THE CHILDREN AND SEARCH FOR
INCRIMINATING EVIDENCE. AS SOON AS I WAS ADVISED THE SEARCH WARRANT HAD BEEN
APPROVED I TEAMED UP WITH OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PBSO SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS
DIVISION AND ROAD PATROL. THE SEARCH WARRANT WAS EXECUTED AND ENTRY WAS MADE
INTO THE HOME.
ONCE I ENTERED THE HOME THE SMELL OF FECES AND URINE WAS OVERWHELMING. I
OBSERVED SEVERAL YOUNG CHILDREN SLEEPING ON THE COUCH AND THE TELEVISION WAS
ON. THE TILE APPEARED TO HAVE BEEN CLEANED OR WIPED UP. THE FLOORBOARDS
LOOKED AS IF WHATEVER WAS WIPED HAD BEEN WIPED UPWARD ONTO THE FLOORBOARD. AT
FIRST IT APPEARED LIKE DIRT BUT AT FURTHER INSPECTION UNDER THE TELEVISION IT
WAS APPARENT IT WAS FECES. I LOOKED INTO THE FIRST BEDROOM ON THE NORTHEAST
SIDE OF THE HOUSE AND SAW A DOG IN A CAGE STANDING ON DRIED UP FECES. THE DOG
LOOKED VERY FEARFUL AND WAS SHAKING. THE DOG ALSO APPEARED TO HAVE SORES AND
WAS VERY DIRTY. THE CARPET AROUND THE CAGE LOOKED MATTED WITHOUT ANY FLUFF.
I ASSISTED IN WAKING UP THE YOUNG CHILDREN WHO WERE SLEEPING ON THE COUCH. I
OBSERVED THE CHILDREN HAD WHAT APPEARED TO BE EITHER BUG BITES ALL OVER THEIR
LIMBS OR SOME SORT OF RASH. THEY WERE ALL VERY DIFFICULT TO WAKE. THEY WERE
ALL IN A VERY DEEP SLEEP AS IF THEY WERE COMPLETELY EXHAUSTED. THERE WERE
ANOTHER TWO CHILDREN IN THE SOUTHWESTERN SIDE OF THE HOUSE. THE CARPET WAS
ALSO VERY MATTED AND WITHOUT FLUFF. DURING THIS TIME I HAD TO EXIT AND RE-
ENTER THE HOME AS THE SMELL WAS SO OVERWHELMING. THE CHILDREN WERE VERY
LETHARGIC. ALL THE CHILDREN WERE PLACED IN A VAN WHICH WAS PROVIDED BY DCF.
ONCE OUTSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE THE SMELL OF URINE AND FECES COULD BE DETECTED
MORE THAN HALFWAY TO THE STREET WHICH WAS NEARLY FIFTY TO ONE HUNDRED FEET.
ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL (ACC) ALSO RESPONDED TO REMOVE THE DOG FROM THE
RESIDENCE. THE ACC OFFICER WHO RESPONDED SHOWED ME THE THICKNESS OF THE DRIED
UP FECES AND IT APPEARED TO BE AT LEAST A HALF OF AN INCH. I RE-ENTERED THE
HOME AS ONE OF THE ROOMS HAD NOT BEEN SEARCHED AND THE DOOR WAS DIFFICULT TO
OPEN. ONCE I PUSHED THE DOOR IT LEAD INTO THE LAUNDRY ROOM WHICH LED TO WHAT
APPEARED TO BE THE GARAGE. THERE WAS DIRTY CLOTHES PILED UP ABOUT FIVE FEET
AND THE CLOTHES APPEARED TO HAVE FECES ALL OVER THEM. WHILE WALKING AROUND
THE HOME I OBSERVED THE COUNTERS TO BE CLEAR OF ANY OBJECTS, ONE REFRIGERATOR

02/13/17 Page 35 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
,T5
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 32
SUPPLEMENT 17 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DID NOT HAVE ANY FOOD IN IT AND THE OTHER HAD ONLY A COUPLE OF GALLONS OF MILK
AND WATER. AT THIS POINT THE HOME WAS SECURED CRIME SCENE WAS PROCESSING AND
THERE WAS NO LONGER A NEED FOR MY ASSISTANCE. I WALKED OVER TO THE CROWD OF
WHAT I WAS TOLD WAS FAMILY TO ESCORT THE DCF INVESTIGATOR. WHEN SHE EXPLAINED
TO THE FAMILY THE CHILDREN WERE BEING REMOVED AN ELDERLY MAN ASKED, "WHY CAN'T
THEY COME WITH ME?" HE IDENTIFIED HIMSELF AS THE GRANDFATHER AND HE EXPLAINED
HE HAD JUST BEEN VISITING THE FAMILY OVER THE EASTER HOLIDAY. I THEN ESCORTED
THE DCF INVESTIGATOR BACK TO THE VAN AND SHE CLEARED THE SCENE.
THIS WAS THE EXTENT OF MY INVOLVEMENT IN THIS CASE.
DETECTIVE JAMES SUAREZ #7953
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@7:23AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 36 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
36-
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 33
SUPPLEMENT 18 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 7953 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON 10/25/16 I MET WITH DETECTIVE B. QUALTERS WITH THE PALM BEACH SCHOOL
DISTRICT POLICE DEPARTMENT IN REFERENCE TO OBTAINING SCHOOL RECORDS IN
REFERENCE TO DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN'S INVESTIGATION. I TURNED OVER CUSTODY OF
THE SCHOOL RECORDS TO DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN.
THIS WAS THE EXTENT OF MY INVOLVEMENT.
DETECTIVE JAMES SUAREZ #7953
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@7:31AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 37 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
37
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 34
SUPPLEMENT 19 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 7953 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON 4/2/16 I RESPONDED TO 17148 NORTH 30TH LANE IN UNINCORPORATED
LOXAHATCHEE PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA IN ORDER TO ASSIST WITH THE EXECUTION
OF A SEARCH WARRANT AND THE REMOVAL OF CHILDREN FROM A FAMILY. UPON ARRIVAL I
MET WITH DETECTIVE SAINT JEAN WHO BRIEFED ME WITH THE FACTS SURROUNDING THE
CASE
I WAS ADVISED WE WERE WAITING FOR THE APPROVAL FOR SEARCH WARRANT. I WAS
ADVISED THE SEARCH WARRANT WAS FOR REMOVAL OF THE CHILDREN AND SEARCH FOR
INCRIMINATING EVIDENCE. AS SOON AS I WAS ADVISED THE SEARCH WARRANT HAD BEEN
APPROVED I TEAMED UP WITH OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PBSO SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS
DIVISION AND ROAD PATROL. THE SEARCH WARRANT WAS EXECUTED AND ENTRY WAS MADE
INTO THE HOME.
ONCE I ENTERED THE HOME THE SMELL OF FECES AND URINE WAS OVERWHELMING. I
OBSERVED SEVERAL YOUNG CHILDREN SLEEPING ON THE COUCH AND THE TELEVISION WAS
ON. THE TILE APPEARED TO HAVE BEEN CLEANED OR WIPED UP. THE FLOORBOARDS
LOOKED AS IF WHATEVER WAS WIPED HAD BEEN WIPED UPWARD ONTO THE FLOORBOARD. AT
FIRST IT APPEARED LIKE DIRT BUT AT FURTHER INSPECTION UNDER THE TELEVISION IT
WAS APPARENT IT WAS FECES. I LOOKED INTO THE FIRST BEDROOM ON THE NORTHEAST
SIDE OF THE HOUSE AND SAW A DOG IN A CAGE STANDING ON DRIED UP FECES. THE DOG
LOOKED VERY FEARFUL AND WAS SHAKING. THE DOG ALSO APPEARED TO HAVE SORES AND
WAS VERY DIRTY. THE CARPET AROUND THE CAGE LOOKED MATTED WITHOUT ANY FLUFF.
I ASSISTED IN WAKING UP THE YOUNG CHILDREN WHO WERE SLEEPING ON THE COUCH. I
OBSERVED THE CHILDREN HAD WHAT APPEARED TO BE EITHER BUG BITES ALL OVER THEIR
LIMBS OR SOME SORT OF RASH. THEY WERE ALL VERY DIFFICULT TO WAKE. THEY WERE
ALL IN A VERY DEEP SLEEP AS IF THEY WERE COMPLETELY EXHAUSTED. THERE WERE
ANOTHER TWO CHILDREN IN THE SOUTHWESTERN SIDE OF THE HOUSE. THE CARPET WAS
ALSO VERY MATTED AND WITHOUT FLUFF. DURING THIS TIME I HAD TO EXIT AND RE-
ENTER THE HOME AS THE SMELL WAS SO OVERWHELMING. THE CHILDREN WERE VERY
LETHARGIC. ALL THE CHILDREN WERE PLACED IN A VAN WHICH WAS PROVIDED BY DCF.
ONCE OUTSIDE OF THE RESIDENCE THE SMELL OF URINE AND FECES COULD BE DETECTED
MORE THAN HALFWAY TO THE STREET WHICH WAS NEARLY FIFTY TO ONE HUNDRED FEET.
ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL (ACC) ALSO RESPONDED TO REMOVE THE DOG FROM THE
RESIDENCE. THE ACC OFFICER WHO RESPONDED SHOWED ME THE THICKNESS OF THE DRIED
UP FECES AND IT APPEARED TO BE AT LEAST A HALF OF AN INCH. I RE-ENTERED THE
HOME AS ONE OF THE ROOMS HAD NOT BEEN SEARCHED AND THE DOOR WAS DIFFICULT TO
OPEN. ONCE I PUSHED THE DOOR IT LEAD INTO THE LAUNDRY ROOM WHICH LED TO WHAT
APPEARED TO BE THE GARAGE. THERE WAS DIRTY CLOTHES PILED UP ABOUT FIVE FEET
AND THE CLOTHES APPEARED TO HAVE FECES ALL OVER THEM. WHILE WALKING AROUND
THE HOME I OBSERVED THE COUNTERS TO BE CLEAR OF ANY OBJECTS, ONE REFRIGERATOR

02/13/17 Page 38 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 35
SUPPLEMENT 19 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DID NOT HAVE ANY FOOD IN IT AND THE OTHER HAD ONLY A COUPLE OF GALLONS OF MILK
AND WATER. AT THIS POINT THE HOME WAS SECURED CRIME SCENE WAS PROCESSING AND
THERE WAS NO LONGER A NEED FOR MY ASSISTANCE. I WALKED OVER TO THE CROWD OF
WHAT I WAS TOLD WAS FAMILY TO ESCORT THE DCF INVESTIGATOR. WHEN SHE EXPLAINED
TO THE FAMILY THE CHILDREN WERE BEING REMOVED AN ELDERLY MAN ASKED, "WHY CAN'T
THEY COME WITH ME?" HE IDENTIFIED HIMSELF AS THE GRANDFATHER AND HE EXPLAINED
HE HAD JUST BEEN VISITING THE FAMILY OVER THE EASTER HOLIDAY. I THEN ESCORTED
THE DCF INVESTIGATOR BACK TO THE VAN AND SHE CLEARED THE SCENE.
THIS WAS THE EXTENT OF MY INVOLVEMENT IN THIS CASE.
DETECTIVE JAMES SUAREZ #7953
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@7:59AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 39 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

3-
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 36
SUPPLEMENT 20 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON WEDNESDAY, 07/27/2016, I ALONG WITH ASSISTING DETECTIVE TERWILLIGER
#6654 ARRIVED AT 17128 30TH LANE NORTH IN LOXAHATCHEE, FLORIDA, OF PALM BEACH
COUNTY. WE MADE CONTACT WITH MR. LUKE BUSH AND HIS WIFE MRS. DEANNA BUSH
FORMER NEIGHBORS TO THE ALEMAN FAMILY. THE FAMILY STATED THEY HAVE BEEN LIVING
IN THEIR HOME FOR APPROXIMATELY TWO YEARS WITH THEIR SIX-YEAR-OLD SON CARTER
BUSH. I ASKED MR. AND MRS. BUSH IF THEY WERE FAMILIAR WITH THE ALEMAN FAMILY
WHEN THEY LIVED NEXT DOOR TO THEM AND THEY BOTH SAID, "YES." I ASKED THE MR.
AND MRS. BUSH HOW THEY BECAME ACQUAINTED WITH THE ALEMAN'S AND THEY TOLD ME
WHEN MR. AND MRS. ALEMAN FIRST MOVED INTO THE HOUSE NEXT DOOR TO THEM ABOUT A
YEAR AGO SOMETIME IN JULY OF 2015. MR. BUSH TOLD ME HE AND HIS WIFE HAD
INTRODUCED THEMSELVES TO MR. AND MRS. ALEMAN WHEN THEY FIRST MOVED INTO THE
NEIGHBORHOOD. HE TOLD ME HE KNEW MR. ALEMAN BY THE NICKNAME "ALEX."
MR. BUSH STATED HE SPOKE TO MR. ALEMAN OFTEN. MR. BUSH STATED HE HELPED
MR. ALEMAN WORK ON FIXING HIS VEHICLE A COUPLE OF TIMES. MR. BUSH STATED MR.
ALEMAN WOULD AT TIMES SEE HIM IN THE DRIVEWAY AND HE WOULD STOP AND SPEAK TO
HIM AT THE END OF HIS DRIVEWAY OFTEN. I ASKED MR. BUSH HOW OFTEN HE WOULD SEE
MR. ALEMAN. MR. BUSH STATED THEY WOULD PASS EACH OTHER BETWEEN 5AM AND 6AM ON
HIS WAY TO WORK. MR. BUSH TOLD ME "ALEX" TOLD HIM HE WORKED AS A CAR
REPOSSESSION MAN SO "ALEX" MOSTLY WORKED AT NIGHT AND HE WORKED EARLY IN THE
MORNING HOURS SO MR. BUSH SAID THEY WOULD HONK AND WAVE TO ACKNOWLEDGE EACH
OTHER IN PASSING IN THE MORNINGS. MR. BUSH STATED A DAY OR TWO MIGHT PASS AND
THEY MIGHT NOT SEE EACH OTHER BUT FOR THE MOST PART MR. ALEMAN DEFINITELY
RESIDED IN THE HOME BECAUSE HE WAS ALWAYS THERE AND THEY OFTEN SAW EACH OTHER.
MR. AND MRS. BUSH STATED THE ONLY VISITORS THEY EVER SAW COME OVER TO THE
ALEMAN'S RESIDENCE IS A YOUNG MAN, APPROXIMATELY IN HIS LATE TEENS OR EARLY
20'S WHO "ALEX" INTRODUCED TO THEM AS EITHER HIS COUSIN OR NEPHEW. MR. ALEMAN
STATED THE NEPHEW WOULD COME TO THE ALEMAN HOUSE WEEKLY AND "ALEX" WAS ALWAYS
OUTSIDE HELPING THE COUSIN FIX HIS F-150 PICKUP TRUCK. MR. BUSH SAID THERE ARE
TIMES WHERE MR. ALEMAN WOULD SEND ONE OF THE OLDER BOYS OVER TO BORROW SOME OF
HIS TOOLS TO WORK ON HIS CARS. I ASKED THE BUSH FAMILY IF THEY KNEW MRS.
ALEMAN'S FIRST NAME. MRS. BUSH TOLD ME MRS. ALEMAN INTRODUCED HERSELF TO THEM
AS KRISTEN. MRS. BUSH STATED A MONTH OR TWO AFTER THE ALEMAN'S HAD MOVED IN
THEY INVITED THEM OVER TO THEIR HOUSE TO HAVE SOME DRINKS. MRS. BUSH TOLD ME
DURING THEIR CONVERSATION THEY LEARNED THE ALEMAN'S HAD TEN (10) HAD CHILDREN
IN COMMON.
I ASKED THE BUSH FAMILY IF THEY HAD A LOT OF CONTACT WITH THE ALEMAN
CHILDREN AND THEY SAID, "YES." MRS. BUSH SAID ALL OF THE CHILDREN DID NOT COME
TO THEIR HOUSE BUT TWO OF THEM CAME OVER OFTEN TO PLAY WITH HER SON. I ASKED

02/13/17 Page 40 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Vo
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 37
SUPPLEMENT 20 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
HER IF THE CHILDREN EVER ATE AT THEIR HOME AND SHE SAID THEY WOULD SOMETIMES
HAVE SNACKS AND THE ALEMAN BOYS WOULD USUALLY SEND THEIR SON CONNOR INSIDE TO
ASK FOR SOMETHING TO EAT OR DRINK FOR THEM. MR. BUSH TOLD ME WHEN HE CAUGHT ON
TO THIS HE WOULD MOST TIMES TELL HIS SON CARTER, "NO, BECAUSE I CAN'T AFFORD
TO FEED THE NEIGHBORHOOD." I ASKED MR. AND MRS. BUSH TO DESCRIBE THE
APPEARANCE OF THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WHEN THEY DID SEE THEM OR HAVE THEM OVER AT
THEIR HOME THEY BOTH STATED THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WERE USUALLY "DIRTY." THEY
STATED THE CHILDREN WOULD ALMOST NEVER HAVE ANY SHOES ON. MR. BUSH STATED THE
CHILDREN WOULD SOMETIMES COME TO THEIR HOME FROM THE WEEDS IN BETWEEN THE
PROPERTY LINE. MR. BUSH STATED HE WOULD WARN THEM ABOUT COMING THROUGH THAT
PATH WITHOUT ANY SHOES ON BECAUSE OF THE SNAKES IN THE AREA. MR. AND MRS.
BUSH STATED DURING THE SCHOOL YEAR THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WOULD BE IN THE HOUSE
UNTIL APPROXIMATELY 2:30 P.M. UNTIL THE OTHER CHILDREN WHO ATTENDED SCHOOL
WOULD BE COMING HOME FROM SCHOOL THAT I WHEN THEY WOULD COME OUT. MRS. BUSH
STATED THREE MONTHS INTO THE SCHOOL YEAR THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WOULD BE OUTSIDE
IN THE STREET RUNNING AROUND THE NEIGHBORHOOD UNSUPERVISED ALL OF THE TIME.
I ASKED MR. AND MRS. BUSH IF THEY EVER SAW A BABY OR INFANT WITH THE
ALEMAN'S. MRS. BUSH STATED WHEN THE ALEMAN'S CAME OVER FOR DRINKS AT THEIR
HOME THEY DID MENTION THEY DID HAVE A BABY BUT THEY NEVER SAW AN INFANT OR
HEARD ONE CRYING. MR. BUSH STATED HE NEVER SAW THE BABY EITHER OR MUCH OF MRS.
ALEMAN. MR. BUSH STATED HE NEVER SAW MRS. ALEMAN COME OUTSIDE OF THE
RESIDENCE. HE STATED EVERY NOW AND THEN HE WOULD HEAR HER YELL AT ONE OF THE
KIDS FROM INSIDE OF THE HOUSE. I ASKED THEM IF MRS. ALEMAN WAS A STAY AT HOME
MOTHER AND THEY BOTH STATED THAT MR. ALEMAN DID TELL THEM THAT HIS WIFE STAYS
AT HOME WITH THE CHILDREN AND SHE HELPS THEM RUN THEIR ROOFING AND PRESSURE
CLEANING BUSINESSES FROM THE HOUSE.
REFERENCE THE NIGHT OF THE INCIDENT MR. BUSH STATED HE CALLED MR. ALEMAN
TO ASK IF EVERYTHING WAS ALRIGHT WHEN HE CAME HOME AND SAW THE POLICE
PRESENCE. MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN SPOKE TO HIM IN A WHISPERING VOICE AND
SAID, "I'M AT THE HOSPITAL MY BABY GIRL DIED LET ME KNOW IF ANYBODY TRIES TO
GET INTO MY HOUSE." MR. BUSH STATED HE ASKED MR. ALEMAN IF THERE WAS ANYTHING
HE COULD DO TO HELP HIM OUT AND MR. ALEMAN RESPONDED, "NO JUST MAKE SURE NONE
OF THE KIDS COME OUT AND NOBODY GOES INSIDE. CALL ME IF THEY DO." MR. BUSH
STATED HE TOLD MR. ALEMAN OK AND ENDED THE CONVERSATION. MR. BUSH SAID ON THE
NIGHT OF THE INCIDENT WHEN MR. ALEMAN RETURNED TO THE HOUSE FROM THE HOSPITAL
WITH THE POLICE MR. ALEMAN WAS YELLING THAT HE WAS GOING SUE THE PALM BEACH
COUNTY SHERIFF'S. MR. BUSH STATED THE ALEMAN'S DID NOT RETURN BACK TO THE
HOME FOR THREE OR FOUR NIGHTS AFTER THE INCIDENT. MR. BUSH STATED WHEN HE
SPOKE TO MR. ALEMAN HE TOLD HIM THEIR BABY GIRL DIED AND THE OTHER CHILDREN
WERE TAKEN AND THEY WERE MOVING.
IN REFERENCE TO THE CONDITION OF HOW THE BABY DIED MR. BUSH STATED MR.
ALEMAN TOLD HIM HE HOPES IT WAS A PARASITE THAT KILLED THE BABY. MR. BUSH SAID
MR. ALEMAN TOLD HIM THE BABY WEIGHED ONLY TWELVE (12) POUNDS. MR. BUSH STATED
DURING THE CONVERSATION WITH MR. ALEMAN HE SAID, "THIS IS WHY PEOPLE THROW
THEIR BABIES IN DUMPSTERS BECAUSE THEY HARASS YOU LIKE THIS WHEN ACCIDENTS
HAPPEN."
MR. BUSH STATED EVEN THOUGH HE WAS NOT ALWAYS OUTSIDE HE WOULD BE OUT
FRONT IN HIS YARD OFTEN WORKING ON HIS CARS. MR. BUSH STATED HE WAS ALWAYS
CURIOUS ABOUT WHY HE NEVER SAW ANYONE COMING AND GOING WITH GROCERIES LIKE A
NORMAL FAMILY. MR. BUSH STATED HE KNOWS MR. ALEMAN USE TO EAT AT A LOCAL CUBAN
SANDWICH SHOP AT THE GAS STATION NEARBY IN LOXAHATCHEE. MR. AND MRS. BUSH
STATED ON THE NIGHT THEY HAD THE ALEMAN'S OVER AT THEIR HOME FOR DRINKS MRS.
ALEMAN STATED SHE DOES NOT COOK. MRS. BUSH STATED MRS. ALEMAN TOLD HER SHE WAS
TRYING TO LOSE WEIGHT AND SHE ONLY ATE POPCORN. MRS. BUSH STATED SHE ASKED
MRS. ALEMAN WHAT DID THE KIDS EAT AND SHE NEVER GAVE AN ANSWER.

02/13/17 Page 41 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
ez/
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 38
SUPPLEMENT 20 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

MRS. BUSH SAID SHE WOULD NOTICE THAT WHEN MR. ALEMAN WAS HOME THE KIDS
WOULD SOMETIMES BE RUNNING AROUND OUTSIDE EATING A BAG OF CHIPS OR A PIECE OF
FROZEN PIZZA. MRS. BUSH SAID THE CHILDREN WOULD OFTEN BE AT THEIR HOUSE FROM
SEVEN IN THE MORNING UNTIL EVENING TIME AND NO ADULT FORM THE ALEMAN HOUSE
WOULD COME AND ASK FOR THE KIDS OR CHECK TO SEE IF THEY HAD ANYTHING TO EAT
ALL DAY. MR. BUSH SAID THEY WOULD HAVE TO TELL THE ALEMAN CHILDREN IT WAS TIME
FOR THEM TO GO HOME WHEN IT GOT LATE. MR. BUSH STATED THE ALEMAN CHILDREN
WOULD BE OUTSIDE AT LATE HOURS OF THE NIGHT. MR. BUSH STATED WHEN THE CHILDREN
KNEW THEIR FATHER WOULD BE HOME THEY WOULD MIGRATE BACK TO THEIR HOUSE. MRS.
BUSH SAID SHE ONLY SAW MRS. ALEMAN OUTSIDE ONCE OR TWICE SMOKING A CIGARETTE
WITH MR. ALEMAN SINCE THEIR INITIAL MEETING. MR. ALEMAN TOLD ME HE ONCE GOT A
WASHER AND DRYER FORM A FRIEND AND WHEN MR. ALEMAN SAW HIM COMING IN WITH IT
MR. ALEMAN TOLD HIM HE NEEDED A WASHER SO THEREFORE MR. BUSH SOLD IT TO HIM
FOR APPROXIMATELY TWO-HUNDRED DOLLARS. MR. BUSH SAID IT WAS A WHITE FRONT LOAD
WASHER AND DRYER WHICH MR. ALEMAN NEVER FINISHED PAYING HIM THE FULL AMOUNT.
MRS. BUSH SAID SHE FOUND IT ODD WHEN SHE ASKED THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WHAT
SCHOOL THEY WERE ATTENDING AND ALL THEY WOULD DO IS SHAKE THEIR HEAD YES TO
WHATEVER SCHOOL SHE NAMED. MRS. BUSH SAID SHE COULD NOT UNDERSTAND OR MAKE OUT
WHAT THEY KIDS WERE TRYING TO SAY. MRS. BUSH STATED AS THE SCHOOL YEAR
PROGRESSED SHE WOULD SEE THE CHILDREN OUTSIDE MORE AND MORE AND THAT IS WHEN
SHE REALIZED THE ALEMAN CHILDREN COULD NOT POSSIBLY BE GOING TO SCHOOL. MRS.
BUSH STATED SHE WOULD SEE THE CHILDREN GOING THROUGH THE GARBAGE OF THE
NEIGHBOR DIRECTLY ACROSS THE STREET. MR. BUSH SAID AROUND CHRISTMAS TIME LAST
YEAR A CHRISTMAS PACKAGE FOR HER SON WAS TAKEN FROM THEIR FRONT DOOR. MR. BUSH
SAID THAT SAME DAY AS SHE WAS COMING HOME SHE NOTICED LITTLE FEET RUNNING BACK
TOWARDS THE DIRECTION OF THE ALEMAN HOUSE. MRS. BUSH SAID AT THAT POINT SHE
DID NOT WANT HER SON PLAYING WITH ALEMAN KIDS ANYMORE. MRS. BUSH SAID THE
ALEMAN CHILDREN WERE SO PERSISTENT IN COMING OVER THAT HER AND HER HUSBAND
EVENTUALLY ALLOWED THEM BACK. MRS. BUSH STATED THE KIDS WOULD BE OUTSIDE
UNSUPERVISED ALL THE TIME. MRS. BUSH TOLD ME SHE RECALLED SEEING ONE OF THE
YOUNGER BOYS APPROXIMATELY THREE YEARS OLD STANDING BY THE CANAL AT THE END OF
THEIR STREET BY HIMSELF UNSUPERVISED.
WHEN ASKED IF THEIR SON CARTER HAS EVER BEEN OVER TO THE ALEMAN'S HOUSE TO
PLAY THEY BOTH STATED, "NO." MR. BUSH SAID HE DID NOT ALLOW CARTER TO GO
INSIDE OF THE ALEMAN'S HOUSE BUT HE HAS BEEN IN THEIR FRONT YARD TO PLAY WITH
THE ALEMAN CHILDREN. I ASKED THE BUSH'S IF THEY HAVE EVER SEEN THE ALEMAN
CHILDREN IN THE POND UNSUPERVISED AND THEY SAID, 'YES." MR. BUSH SAID HE HAS
SEEN THE ALEMAN CHILDREN FREQUENTLY IN THEIR BATTLE BOAT IN THE POND
UNSUPERVISED. I ASKED MR. AND MRS. BUSH IF THEY HAVE ANY KNOWLEDGE OF THE
ALEMAN'S BEING SEPARATED FROM EACH OTHER WHILE LIVING NEXT DOOR TO THEM AND
THEY SAID, "NO." MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN ALWAYS REFERRED TO KRISTEN AS HIS
WIFE. MRS. BUSH SAID ONLY AFTER THIS INCIDENT OCCURRED DID MR. ALEMAN MAKE A
COMMENT ABOUT HOW THIS INCIDENT WAS GOING TO BREAK UP THEIR MARRIAGE. MR. BUSH
STATED THEY WERE DEFINITELY MARRIED AND MR. ALEMAN DEFINITELY RESIDED AT THE
HOUSE WITH HIS FAMILY.
MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN WAS COMPLAINING TO HIM HOW WORK WAS SLOW. HE
STATED HE DID NOT SEE THE TOW TRUCK FOR ABOUT A MONTH AND MR. ALEMAN WAS HOME
A LOT DURING THAT PERIOD OF TIME. MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN ALSO HAS A
TRAILER HE USED FOR HIS PRESSURE CLEANING BUSINESS. MR. BUSH SAID HE NOTICED
MR. ALEMAN WAS USING THE TRAILER A LOT BECAUSE IT WAS NOT PARKED IN THE YARD
LIKE IT USUALLY WAS BECAUSE HE WAS USING IT. MR. BUSH STATED HE WAS TALKING TO
MR. ALEMAN ONE DAY AND HE WAS TELLING HIM HOW THINGS WERE SLOW AND HE WAS
BROKE. MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN TOLD HIM HE HAD JUST BOUGHT A BRONCO TRUCK
AND MADE THE COMMENT, "SHE'S GOING TO KILL ME BECAUSE I SPENT WHAT WE HAD IN
THE SAVINGS ACCOUNT." MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN HAD ALSO TOLD HIM HE JUST

02/13/17 Page 42 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 39
SUPPLEMENT 20 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

FINANCED A HUGE SHOW TRUCK. MR. BUSH TOLD ME WHEN HE ORIGINALLY MET WITH MR.
ALEMAN HE TOLD HIM THAT HE OWNED THE TOW TRUCK COMPANY. MR. BUSH SAID ONE DAY
WHILE HE WAS TALKING TO ONE OF ALEXANDRO'S ALLEGED EMPLOYEES HE DISCOVERED
ALEJANDRO WAS LYING ABOUT OWNING THE TOW TRUCK COMPANY. MR. BUSH STATED HE
DOES TO UNDERSTAND WHY MR. ALEMAN HAD LIED TO HIM ABOUT OWNING THE TOW TRUCK
COMPANY BECAUSE HE DOES NOT CARE.
MR. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN'S NEPHEW WOULD OFTEN COME OVER WITH HIS
GIRLFRIEND BUT HE DOES NOT KNOW HER NAME. MR. BUSH STATED ONE DAY HE CAME HOME
FROM WORK AND WAS "THROWN BACK" AS TO WHAT HE SAW WAS GOING ON AT THE ALEMAN
HOUSE. MR. BUSH STATED HE FOUND MR. ALEMAN, HIS NEPHEW INSIDE OF MR. ALEMAN'S
NEW SHOW TRUCK HE HAD JUST FINANCED WITH AN EXTENSION LADDER PROPPED UP
AGAINST THE TELEPHONE POLL AT THE CORNER OF THEIR PROPERTY. MR. BUSH SAID HE
WALKED OVER TO WHERE THEY WERE AND ASKED THEM WHAT THEY WERE DOING AND THEY
QUICKLY DROPPED DOWN THE LADDER AND STATED, "OH NOTHING JUST CHECKING OUT SOME
STUFF IN THE CABLE LINES." MR. BUSH THEN STATED, "OH YEAH TRYING TO GET SOME
FREE CABLE ARE YA?" MR. BUSH STATED THE NEPHEW, HIS GIRLFRIEND AND A FEW OF
THE NEPHEW'S FRIENDS WHO WERE THERE ALL STARTED LAUGHING. MR. BUSH STATED MR.
ALEMAN FINALLY ADMITTED TO HIM THAT THEY WERE TRYING TO HOOK UP THE CABLE
LINE
MR. BUSH STATED THE CHILDREN WERE ALWAYS UNSUPERVISED AND ALL OVER THE
PLACE. HE ALSO STATED THAT MR. ALEMAN DEFINITELY LIVED THERE BECAUSE EVERY
SUNDAY MORNING HE WOULD TAKE HIS SON CARTER FOR BREAKFAST AND HE WOULD SEE HIM
OUTSIDE OF THE HOUSE SITTING ON THE FRONT IN HIS SHORTS TALKING ON THE PHONE
AND SMOKING A CIGARETTE. MRS. BUSH STATED MR. ALEMAN WOULD COME HOME FROM WORK
IN THE MORNING AND HE WOULD BE IN THE HOUSE ALL DAY UNTIL HE WOULD LEAVE
AGAIN. MRS. BUSH STATED THE ONE THING THAT SHE OBSERVED THAT REALLY BOTHERED
HER WAS HOW THE ALEMAN CHILDREN APPEARED TO BE LOCKED OUT OF THE HOUSE
SOMETIMES DURING THE DAY. MRS. BUSH STATED IT WOULD BE SO HOT AND THE CHILDREN
WOULD HAVE NO WATER OR FOOD ALL DAY JUST ROAMING OUTSIDE FROM THE YOUNGEST
WALKING CHILD TO THE OLDER BOYS.
MR. BUSH STATED HE ONCE WENT FOR A BIKE RIDE WITH SON AND HE SAW TWO OF
THE YOUNGER BOYS RIDING THEIR TEN SPEED BIKES IN THE MIDDLE OF THE DIRT ROAD
ON CHEATHAM HILL WITH NO SHOES ON. MR. BUSH SAID THE BOY'S FEET COULD HARDLY
REACH THE GROUND AND THEY WERE WEARING NO HELMETS. I ASKED THE BUSH'S' ABOUT
THE CHILDREN'S SPEECH AND MRS. BUSH DESCRIBED THE CHILDREN'S SPEECH AS A
"GRUNTING" SOUND. MRS. BUSH SAID HE FOUND THIS TO BE VERY ODD BECAUSE THE BOYS
WERE BETWEEN SEVEN AND EIGHT AND THEY COULD NOT SPEAK PROPERLY. SHE SAID IT
WAS HARD TO UNDERSTAND A CLEAR WORD FROM THEM. MRS. BUSH SAID SHE WOULD HAVE
TO ASK HER SON CARTER SOMETIMES TO SEE IF HE COULD MAKE OUT WHAT THE BOYS WERE
TRYING TO SAY. CARTER WHO WAS PRESENT STATED HE COULD ONLY UNDERSTAND TALON
ALEMAN AT TIMES. MRS. BUSH STATED CARTER WOULD SOMETIMES HAVE TO ASK THE OLDER
OF THE ALEMAN BOYS WHO COULD SPEAK TO TRANSLATE WHAT THE YOUNGER ONES WERE
TRYING TO SAY. MRS. BUSH SAID EVEN THE OLDER BOYS COULD NOT WRITE HIS NAME.
MRS. BUSH TOLD ME SHE NOTICED THAT ONLY THE TWO OLDER BOYS DID NOT HAVE THE
SPEECH PROBLEM. MRS. BUSH STATED FOR THE MOST PART THEY COULD NOT UNDERSTAND A
CLEAR WORD THE ALEMAN CHILDREN WERE SAYING WHEN THEY WOULD COME OVER TO THEIR
HOUSE. THE ALEMAN'S HAD NO FURTHER INFORMATION AT THIS TIME. END OF THE
INTERVIEW.
CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@8:09AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 43 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

ez?
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 40
SUPPLEMENT 21 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000
ON FRIDAY, JULY 29TH 2016, I MADE CONTACT WITH THE HOME OWNER AND FORMER
LANDLORD OF THE ALEMAN FAMILY MR. VICTOR HIJUELOS. MR. HIJUELOS CURRENTLY
RESIDES IN NASSAU COUNTY, NEW YORK. MR. HIJUELOS TOLD ME HE RENTED OUT HIS
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 17148 30TH LN., N., LOXAHATCHEE, FLORIDA TO ALJENADRO
ALEMAN WHOM HE REFERS TO AS "ALEX." MR. HIJUELOS TOLD ME HE MET THE ALEMAN
FAMILY THROUGH HIS FORMER TENANT. MR. HIJUELOS STATED HIS FORMER TENANT WAS
SUCH A PLEASANT TENANT THAT WHEN SHE REFERRED MR. VICTOR ALEMAN (THE SUSPECT'S
FATHER) HE THOUGHT IT WOULD BE A SMOOTH TRANSACTION. MR. HIJUELOS STATED HE
WAS LATER INFORMED THAT VICTOR ALEMAN WAS RENTING THIS HOME FOR HIS SON "ALEX"
ALEMAN AND HIS WIFE. MR. HIJUELOS STATED HE WAS AWARE THEY HAD CHILDREN BUT HE
DID NOT REALIZE THE FAMILY WAS SUCH A LARGE FAMILY.
I ASKED MR. HIJUELOS IF HE WOULD BE WILLING TO PROVIDE AN OFFICIAL STATEMENT
WHICH WOULD HAVE TO BE TAKEN BY A DETECTIVE IN NASSAU COUNTY, NEW YORK WHERE
HE CURRENTLY LIVES SO THEY CAN AUTHENTICATE HIS IDENTITY AND HIS STATEMENT.
MR. HIJUELOS WAS VERY COOPERATIVE AND WILLING TO ASSIST AND PROVIDE ANY
INFORMATION NECESSARY.
I LATER MADE CONTACT WITH DETECTIVE ARLINE BUTTS OF THE NASSAU COUNTY,
NEW YORK POLICE DEPARTMENT. MS. BUTTS WAS ABLE TO ASSIST ME WITH THIS
INVESTIGATION BY HAVING DETECTIVE BELLAMY OBTAIN AN OFFICIAL WRITTEN STATEMENT
FROM MR. HIJUELOS ON MONDAY, AUGUST 1, 2016, ALONG WITH CERTAIN LEGAL
DOCUMENTATIONS FROM PALM BEACH COUNTY SHOWING THAT ALEJANDRO "ALEX" ALEMAN WAS
IN FACT RENTING/ RESIDING IN MR. HIJULEOS'S PROPERTY AT THE ABOVE MENTIONED
ADDRESS IN LOXAHATCHEE FROM JULY 2015 TILL MAY 2016. IN THE STATEMENT MR.
HIJUELOS STATED MR. ALEMAN SIGNED A LEASE AGREEMENT IN THE AMOUNT OF ONE-
THOUSAND SEVEN-HUNDRED DOLLARS ($1700.00). MR. HIJUELOS STATED THE SUSPECT
WOULD MAKE CASH RENTAL PAYMENTS DIRECTLY INTO HIS BANK ACCOUNT. MR. HIJUELOS
STATED HE OFFICIALLY MET ALEJANDRO "ALEX" ALEMAN IN PERSON ON OCTOBER 4, 2015,
WHEN HE CAME TO FLORIDA TO SERVE HIM WITH A NOTICE OF EVICTION.
IN MR. HIJUELOS'S STATEMENT HE STATED HE WAS ABLE TO REGAIN POSSESSION OF
THE PROPERTY WITH THE PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE IN MAY 2016 WHEN HE
OFFICIALLY EVICTED THE ALEMAN'S. MR. HIJUELOS DESCRIBED THE CONDITIONS OF HIS
PROPERTY AS IN DISREPAIR. MR. HIJUELOS STATED THERE WAS DAMAGE TO THE WALLS,
TILES AND CARPET. HE STATED THERE WERE FECES FOUND ALL OVER THE RESIDENCE. HE
STATED THE APPROXIMATED AMOUNT OF PROPERTY DAMAGES TO BE TEN-THOUSAND DOLLARS.
MR. HIJUELOS TOLD ME WHILE HE WAS CLEANING OUT THE HOUSE HE FOUND BURNT
SPOONS AND SYRINGE NEEDLES WHICH APPEARED TO HAVE BEEN POSSIBLY USED FOR
ILLEGAL RECREATIONAL DRUG USE. MR. HIJUELOS TOLD ME HE SPENT AN EXTENSIVE
AMOUNT OF MONEY TO HAVE THE HOUSE CLEANED OUT AND REPAIRED. MR. HIJUELOS

02/13/17 Page 44 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
("/
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 41
SUPPLEMENT 21 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
STATED WHEN HE RENTED THE HOUSE OUT TO THE ALEMAN FAMILY IT WAS NOT IN THE
CONDITION THEY LEFT IT IN WHEN THEY MOVED OUT.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@8:14AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 45 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
6/5
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 42
SUPPLEMENT 22 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON TUESDAY, 09/13/2016, I CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW WITH CHILD PROTECTIVE
INVESTIGATOR FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES, AT
THE PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
REFERENCE HER INVOLVEMENT IN THIS CASE MS. STATED SHE RECALLS
RESPONDING TO A CASE INVOLVING THE ALEMAN FAMILY BACK IN LATE OCTOBER EARLY
NOVEMBER OF 2015. MS. STATED ANOTHER CHILD PROTECTIVE INVESTIGATOR
NAMED MADE FIRST INITIAL CONTACT WITH MR. ALEMAN THE FATHER OF
THE CHILDREN. MS. SATED SHE BELIEVED MR. THEN LEFT THE ALEMAN
HOUSE WITHOUT INCIDENT AND UPDATED HER ON THE INCIDENT.
MS. STATED SHE THEN WENT BACK OUT TO THE ALEMAN HOUSE WITH A PALM
BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE DEPUTY WHOSE NAME SHE STATED SHE DOES NOT
RECALL. MS. STATED WHEN SHE ARRIVED AT THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE THE DAD
(ALEJANDRO ALEMAN) SPOKE TO HER FROM THE FRONT GATE AND REFUSED TO ALLOW HERE
ACCESS TO HIS HOME OR THE CHILDREN. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN WAS UPSET AND
HE TOLD HER HE WAS TIRED OF PEOPLE CALLING DCF ON HIM AND HE WANTED HER TO
OBTAIN A WARRANT IN ORDER TO GIVE HER ACCESS INTO HIS HOME. MS. STATED
MR. ALEMAN TOLD HER HE WANTED HER SUPERVISOR TO COME OUT TO SPEAK TO HIM. MS.
STATED A FEW DAYS LATER SHE CAME BACK OUT TO THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE WITH
HER SUPERVISOR AND MR. ALEMAN STILL REFUSED TO ALLOW THEM TO
CONDUCT THEIR INVESTIGATION.
MS. STATED SHE THEN REQUESTED A MOTION TO COMPEL THROUGH THE DCF
LEGAL DEPARTMENT IN ORDER TO GET ACCESS TO THE ALEMAN HOME. MS. STATED
ONCE THE MOTION TO COMPEL WAS GRANTED HER SUPERVISOR AND ANOTHER INVESTIGATOR
WERE THE ONES WHO WENT OUT TO THE ALEMAN HOUSE TO SERVE THE COURT ORDER. MS.
STATED SHE WAS STILL ASSIGNED THE CASE AT THE TIME BUT FOR PERSONAL
REASONS SHE WAS NOT ABLE TO PERSONALLY SERVER THE COURT ORDER WITH HER
SUPERVISOR. STATED SHE HAD NO FURTHER INVOLVEMENT WITH THE ALEMAN
FAMILY.
NEXT, I CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW WITH DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES
(DCF) INVESTIGATOR REFERENCE HER INVOLVEMENT IN THIS CASE. MS .
STATED SHE HAS BEEN EMPLOYED WITH DCF FOR APPROXIMATELY A YEAR AND A
HALF. MS. STATED SHE BECAME INVOLVED WITH THIS CASE WHEN SHE ASSISTED
HER SUPERVISOR IN SERVING THE MOTION TO COMPEL THAT WAS GRANTED BY
THE COURTS. MS. STATED SHE BELIEVES THIS WAS IN LATE 2015 POSSIBLY IN
THE MONTH OF DECEMBER. ONCE THEY ARRIVED AT THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE A PALM BEACH
COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPUTY ARRIVED TO ASSIST THEM. MS. STATED THEY HANDED
THE SHERIFF DEPUTY WITH A COPY OF THE MOTION TO COMPEL. MS. STATED PRIOR
TO THE DEPUTY ARRIVING ON SCENE THE FATHER MR. ALEMAN CAME OUT OF THE HOUSE

02/13/17 Page 46 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 43
SUPPLEMENT 22 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

AND WALKED OUT TO SPEAK TO THEM. MS. STATED WHEN THEY HANDED MR. ALEMAN
THE MOTION TO COMPEL HE STATED HE WOULD HAVE ALLOWED THEM TO ENTER THE HOME
AND HE APOLOGIZED TO THEM FOR THE MISCOMMUNICATION.
STATED DURING THE WALK THROUGH OF THE HOME MR. ALEMAN FOLLOWED
DIRECTLY BEHIND THEM THE ENTIRE TIME THEY WERE INSIDE OF THE HOME. MS.
STATED THEY ENTERED A BEDROOM WHICH APPEARED TO BE THE OLDER BOYS' ROOM WHERE
THE BOYS WERE SITTING ON THE BEDS WHICH WERE MADE UP. MS. STATED THE
CHILDREN'S ROOM WAS "EXTREMELY CLEAN." MS. STATED SHE DID NOT SEE
ANYTHING ON THE GROUND. THE CHILDREN APPEARED CLEAN, WITH NO MARKS OR BRUISES
ON THE CHILDREN. MS. STATED THE LIVING ROOM AREA WAS ALSO CLEAN AND
THERE WAS NO SMELL INSIDE OF THE HOME. MS. STATED SHE DOES NOT RECALL
EXACTLY HOW MANY ROOMS WERE INSIDE OF THE HOME. MS. STATED SHE RECALLS
ON ONE SIDE OF THE HOUSE THERE WAS TWO ROOMS WHERE THE BOYS SLEPT AND ON THE
OTHER SIDE OF THE HOME WAS WHERE THE BEDROOM THE SHE SAW THE OTHER MOM
(KRISTEN MEYER).
MS. STATED WHEN THEY WENT INTO THE BEDROOM WHERE THE MOTHER OF THE
CHILDREN WAS THEY SAW HER CHANGING THE BABY'S DIAPER ( MS.
STATED SHE SAW THE BABY LYING ON HER BACK AS THE MOTHER CHANGED HER DIAPER.
MS. STATED SHE RECALLS GLANCING AT THE BABY'S VAGINAL AREA BECAUSE HER
LEGS WERE OPEN AS THE MOTHER WAS CHANGING HER DIAPER. MS. STATED SHE DID
NOT SEE ANY REDNESS OR ANYTHING OUT OF THE ORDINARY THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN
ALARMING TO HER. MS. STATED THEY CONTINUED ON TO THE KITCHEN WHERE THEY
CHECKED THE KITCHEN CABINETS AND MR. ALEMAN OPENED THE REFRIGERATOR FOR THEM
TO INSPECT INSIDE. SHE STATED THERE WAS ONLY ONE REFRIGERATOR INSIDE OF THE
HOME AT THE TIME WHICH WAS LOCATED IN THE KITCHEN AREA. MS. STATED THERE
WAS FOOD IN THE KITCHEN CABINETS AND REFRIGERATOR. MS. STATED THERE WAS
A DOOR IN THE HOME THAT HER SUPERVISOR ASKED MR. ALEMAN TO OPEN FOR THEM TO
INSPECT AND HE REFUSED TO OPEN THE DOOR SO THEY CONTINUED ON. MS. STATED
THEY THEN ASKED MR. ALEMAN TO HAVE THE CHILDREN STEP OUT INTO THE LIVING ROOM
AND ASKED THEM TO POINT THEM ALL OUT ONE BY ONE. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN
POINTED TO THE OLDER BOY AND HE SAID HIS NAME BUT SHE COULD NOT RECALL HIS
NAME. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN THEN POINTED TO THE NEXT CHILD AND SO ON.
MS. STATED DURING THIS TIME THE MOTHER WAS STILL IN THE BEDROOM CHANGING
THE BABY'S DIAPER.
MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN THEN HAD HER AND HER SUPERVISOR STEP OUTSIDE
OF THE HOME TO THE FRONT DOOR AREA. MS. STATED THEY TOLD MR. ALEMAN THEY
NEEDED TO SPEAK TO THE CHILDREN INDIVIDUALLY AND MR. ALEMAN STARTED TO GIVE
THEM A HARD TIME ASKING WHY THEY NEEDED TO SPEAK TO THE CHILDREN INDIVIDUALLY
WITHOUT HIM BEING PRESENT. MS. STATED THEY EXPLAINED THE PURPOSE AND
REASONS WHY THEY HAVE TO FOLLOW THERE DCF PROCEDURES AND WHY THEY HAVE TO ALSO
TAKE PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE CHILDREN. MR. ALEMAN TOLD THEM HE DID NOT WANT HIS
CHILDREN PHOTOGRAPHED SO THEY DID NOT TAKE ANY PHOTOS OF THE ALEMAN CHILDREN
THAT DAY. MS. STATED THEY ASKED TO SPEAK TO THE CHILDREN STARTING WITH
THE OLDEST CHILD FIRST. MS. STATED THEY THEN HAD THE OLDEST CHILD GO
BACK INTO THE HOME AND SENT THE NEXT CHILD OUT. MS. STATED WHEN THAT
CHILD CAME OUT THEY COULD NOT MAKE OUT A WORD OF WHAT HE WAS TRYING TO SAY SO
THEY ASKED THE OLDEST CHILD TO REMAIN OUTSIDE TO HELP THEM UNDERSTAND HIM.
MS. STATED IT WAS HARD TO UNDERSTAND EVERY OTHER CHILD THEY
ATTEMPTED TO INTERVIEW AFTER THE OLDEST CHILD. MS. SATED SHE DOES NOT
RECALL WHAT THE SECOND OLDEST CHILD WAS TRYING TO SAY NOR DOES SHE RECALL IF
THE OLDEST CHILD STAYED OUTSIDE WITH THEM TO HELP INTERVIEW THE REST OF THE
CHILDREN. MS. STATED THE CHILDREN WERE NOT VERBAL AND THEY ALL MADE
GRUNTING NOISES AND WEIRD SOUNDS WHEN THEY WOULD RESPOND TO THEIR QUESTIONS.
MS. STATED EVEN THE MOVEMENTS OR GESTURES THE CHILDREN WOULD MAKE IN AN
ATTEMPT TO ANSWER THEIR QUESTIONS DID NOT MAKE SENSE. MS. STATED IT WAS

02/13/17 Page 47 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
97
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 44
SUPPLEMENT 22 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
AS IF THE CHILDREN KNEW THEY WERE BEING ASKED A QUESTION AND THEY WERE
CONFIDENT IN THE STRANGE NON-VERBAL WAYS AND GESTURES THEY WERE MAKING TO
RESPOND. MS. STATED THE CHILDREN RANGED FROM THE AGES OF AN INFANT WHICH
WAS A FEW MONTHS (7 TO 8 MONTHS) OLD ALL THE WAY UP TO THE OLDEST BOY WHO
MIGHT HAVE BEEN IN HIS PRE-TEENS.
MS. STATED SHE THEN ASKED THE MOTHER (KRISTEN MEYER) TO STEP OUTSIDE
SO THEY CAN INTERVIEW HER. WHEN THE MOTHER CAME OUT OF THE HOME SHE WAS
HOLDING THE BABY ( UP AGAINST HER HIP AND MR. ALEMAN FOLLOWED
MRS. ALEMAN OUTSIDE. MS. STATED THEY ASKED MR. ALEMAN IF THEY COULD
SPEAK TO MRS. ALEMAN ALONE. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN WENT INSIDE OF THE
HOUSE BUT HE CONTINUOUSLY CAME IN AND OUT OF THE HOME DURING THE INTERVIEW.
MS. STATED MRS. ALEMAN DID NOT APPEAR TO BE IN FEAR, SHE WAS CONFIDENT
IN HER ANSWERS AND SHE ANSWERED ALL OF THEIR QUESTIONS WILLINGLY WHILE HOLDING
THE BABY ( AT ONE POINT DURING THE INTERVIEW WITH MRS. ALEMAN
MR. ALEMAN CAME ALL THE OUT WAY OUTSIDE NEAR A TRUCK IN THE DRIVEWAY AND HE
PROCEEDED TO CARRY A CONVERSATION WITH THE DEPUTY ON SCENE THAT WAS STANDING
IN THE DRIVEWAY.
MS. STATED AT ONE POINT DURING THE INTERVIEW THE MRS. ALEMAN PLACED
THE BABY DOWN ON THE GROUND. SHE STATED THE BABY WAS STANDING ON HER OWN TWO
FEET WHILE CLINGING UP AGAINST THE MRS. ALEMAN FOR SUPPORT. MS. STATED
MR. ALEMAN THEN CAME OVER TO WHERE THEY WERE STILL TALKING TO MRS. ALEMAN AND
HE STOOD ON THE SIDE OF HER. MS. STATED SHE ASKED THE ALEMAN'S WHERE
THEY LIVED BEFORE LOXAHATCHEE AND THEY SAID MARTIN COUNTY. MS. STATED
SHE ASKED THEM WHY THEY WERE TRYING TO MOVE FROM LOXAHATCHEE AND MR. ALEMAN
SAID BECAUSE DCF WAS BACK INVOLVED IN THEIR LIVES. MS. TOLD ME MR.
ALEMAN WAS VERY UPSET ABOUT THIS AND HE STATED THAT THESE WERE ALL FALSE
ALLEGATIONS.
WHEN ASKED HOW THE BABY ( APPEARED PHYSICALLY WHEN THEY WERE
AT THE ALEMAN HOUSE THAT DAY MS. STATED THE BABY WAS A SKINNY SEVEN
MONTH OLD BABY BUT NOT SKINNY TO THE POINT WHERE THE BABY APPEARED AS IF SHE
WAS NOT BEING FED. MS. STATED SHE RECALLS THE BABY WAS WEARING SOME PINK
AND WHITE POLK-A-DOT SHORTS, SHE HAD BROWN/BLONDE HAIR, WHICH WAS NOT THAT
LONG BUT SHE HAD ENOUGH HAIR TO PUT UP IN A LITTLE PONYTAIL, SHE WAS
PHYSICALLY ACTIVE MOVING HER ARMS AROUND TO GRAB AND TOUCH HER MOTHER'S FACE.
MS. STATED THE BABY APPEARED TO BE A NORMAL SIZED THIN BUILT BABY. I
ASKED MS. IF MR. ALEMAN RESIDED IN THE HOME AND SHE TOLD ME MR. ALEMAN
DEFINITELY RESIDED IN THE HOME. I ASKED MS. IF MR. ALEMAN TOLD HER WHAT
HIS OCCUPATION WAS AND SHE STATED HE TOLD THEM HE WAS A TOW TRUCK DRIVER AND
MRS. ALEMAN WAS A STAY AT HOME MOTHER.
MS. STATED THAT ACCORDING TO THE OLDEST CHILD, MR. ALEMAN AND MRS.
ALEMAN STATED SHE HOME SCHOOLED THE CHILDREN. I ASKED MS. IF THEY HAD
ANY CONCERNS ABOUT THE OTHER CHILDREN NOT BEING ABLE TO VERBALLY COMMUNICATE
AND IF THEY ADDRESSED THESE ISSUES WITH THE PARENTS. MS. STATED THEY
WERE CONCERNED ABOUT THE CHILDREN NOT BEING ABLE TO COMMUNICATE VERBALLY AND
THEY DID ADDRESS THIS ISSUE WITH THE MOTHER SHE STATED THE CHILDREN WOULD GROW
OUT OF IT. MS. STATED THE MOTHER DID NOT SEE ANYTHING WRONG WITH HER
CHILDREN'S SPEECH. MRS. ALEMAN TOLD MS. THE ONLY CONCERN SHE HAD WAS FOR
HER SON WHO COULD NOT PRONOUNCE CERTAIN WORDS. MS . STATED THE
MOTHER STATED THE CHILDREN'S LANGUAGE WOULD GET STRONGER AS THEY GET OLDER AND
THEY WOULD GROW OUT OF IT. MS. STATED THE MOTHER TOLD HER BECAUSE SHE IS
FROM CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, SHE SPEAKS EXTREMELY FAST AND THAT IS WHERE HE
CHILDREN GET IT FROM. MS. STATED MRS. ALEMAN MOTHER TOLD HER ALL OF HER
CHILDREN WERE HEALTHY AND SHE HAD NO CONCERNS. MS. STATED SHE OFFERED
THE MOTHER ALL TYPES OF SERVICES AND SHE DECLINED. MS. STATED THE MOTHER
STATED MAYBE SHE WOULD CONSIDER SPEECH THERAPY FOR

02/13/17 Page 48 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 45
SUPPLEMENT 22 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

I ASKED MS. IF SHE SAW ANY DOGS IN THE HOME AND SHE SAID, "NO." MS.
TOLD ME SHE WAS AWARE THEY DID HAVE TWO DOGS BUT THEY DID NOT SEE THE
ANIMALS. I ASKED MS. IS THE MOTHER TOLD HER WHICH SCHOOL THE CHILDREN
WERE REGISTERED WITH AND SHE SAID, "NO." SHE TOLD ME WHEN SHE WALKED INTO THE
ALEMAN HOME THAT DAY THE HOUSE WAS "SPOTLESS." MS. STATED THE HOUSE
LOOKED LIKE A "MODEL HOUSE." SHE STATED IT WAS OBVIOUS THAT THEY HAD CLEANED
THE HOME. MS. STATED THERE WAS NO CLUTTER, NO APPLIANCES EVERYWHERE
EVERYTHING WAS IN ORDER.
I ASKED MS. HOW LONG DID IT TAKE FOR THE MOTION TO COMPEL TO BE
APPROVED AND SHE STATED IT TOOK APPROXIMATELY THREE WEEKS. MS. STATED
THERE WAS A COURT HEARING THE MORNING AND THE ALEMAN'S WERE SUPPOSED TO HAVE
BEEN IN COURT BUT THEY DID NOT SHOW UP. MS. STATED SHE WAS PRESENT WHEN
HER CO-WORKER MS. SPOKE TO MR. ALEMAN WEEKS PRIOR OVER THE PHONE
TELLING HIM THAT WHEN THE MOTION TO COMPEL WAS GRANTED THEY WERE GOING TO COME
BACK TO THE HOME TO CONDUCT AN INVESTIGATION. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN MAY
NOT HAVE KNOWN EXACTLY WHAT DATE AND TIME THEY WERE COMING WITH THE MOTION TO
COMPEL BUT HE DEFINITELY WAS PREPARED FOR THEIR VISIT. MS. STATED THE
ALEMAN HOUSE WAS CLEAN WITH NO FOUL ODOR, FECES OR FILTH. MS. STATED MR.
ALEMAN RUSHED THEM THROUGH THE WALK THROUGH OF THE HOUSE. SHE STATED MR.
ALEMAN TOOK TOTAL CONTROL OF THE SITUATION. MS. STATED SHE NOTICED A
CERTAIN BOND OR SECRET CODE GOING ON BETWEEN THE FATHER AND THE OLDEST BOY.
SHE STATED HE WOULD LOOK AT THE FATHER WHEN ANSWERING THEIR QUESTIONS. THERE
WAS CONSTANT EYE CONTACT BETWEEN HIM AND THE FATHER WHILE THEY WERE TALKING TO
THE OLDEST CHILD. MS. STATED THE SECOND OLDEST CHILD ONLY COMMUNICATED
BY MAKING THESE STRANGE NON-VERBAL SOUNDS WHICH THEY FOUND TO BE VERY UNUSUAL.
MS. TOLD ME THEY SPENT APPROXIMATELY AN HOUR AND A HALF AT THE ALEMAN
RESIDENCE AND MR. ALEMAN WAS TRYING TO RUSH THEM ALONG WITH THEIR
INVESTIGATION. MS. STATED THEY HOME APPEARED "SPOTLESS" AND ASIDE FROM
THE CHILDREN'S SPEECH ISSUES THEY WERE CLEAN, THERE WAS FOOD IN THE HOME AND
THEY WERE FREE OF MARKS AND BRUISES. MS. HAD NO FURTHER INFORMATION. I
THEN CONCLUDED THE INTERVIEW.
NEXT, I CONDUCTED AN INTERVIEW WITH DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES
CHILD INVESTIGATOR SUPERVISOR MS. TOLD ME SHE HAS BEEN
EMPLOYED WITH DCF APPROXIMATELY FOUR TO FIVE YEARS. SHE STATED HER SUPERVISORY
POSITION ENTAILS REVIEWING CASES, CLOSING CASES AND PROVIDING GUIDANCE ON WHAT
STEP INVESTIGATORS NEED TO FOLLOW. REFERENCE THIS CASE MS. STATED SHE
MADE CONTACT WITH THE ALEMAN FAMILY ON TWO DIFFERENT OCCASIONS IN LATE 2015
REFERENCE ALLEGATIONS OF ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS CLAIMING THAT THE HOUSE WAS
DIRTY. MS. STATED THE FIRST TIME SHE MADE CONTACT WITH THE ALEMAN FAMILY
IS WHEN INVESTIGATOR TOLD HER SHE WAS HAVING DIFFICULTIES WITH MR.
ALEMAN WHO WAS BEING UNCOOPERATIVE AND NOT ALLOWING HER ACCESS TO SEE THE
CHILDREN.
MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN PERSONALLY REQUESTED A SUPERVISOR SO SHE WENT
OUT TO THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE WITH MS. MS. TOLD ME THEY SPOKE TO A
NEIGHBOR ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE ALEMAN HOME FIRST BEFORE MAKING CONTACT AT
THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE THAT DAY. MS. STATED THE NEIGHBOR SHE SPOKE TO
INVITED THEM INTO HER HOME AND SHE OPENLY SPOKE TO THEM ABOUT THE ALEMAN
FAMILY. THE NEIGHBOR TOLD MS. SHE WAS RETIRED FROM PBSO (PALM BEACH
COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE). THE NEIGHBOR DESCRIBED THE ALEMAN FAMILY AS A LITTLE
ODD. SHE STATED ONE OF THE CHILDREN IN PARTICULAR DISPLAYED SOME ODD BEHAVIOR
WHERE HE WOULD BE HIDING IN BUSHES. THE NEIGHBOR STATED SHE FOUND THIS STRANGE
BECAUSE THE CHILD WAS NOT PLAYING WITH ANYONE. THE NEIGHBOR TOLD HER SHE WOULD
SEE A WOMAN COME AND GO ONCE IN A WHILE IN A BLACK VEHICLE AND SHE ASSUMED
THAT SHE MIGHT HAVE BEEN THE MOTHER OF THE CHILDREN BUT SHE NEVER MADE CONTACT
WITH THE WOMAN.

02/13/17 Page 49 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 46
SUPPLEMENT 22 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
MS. STATED AFTER CONCLUDING THE INTERVIEW WITH THE NEIGHBOR SHE AND
MS. THEN WALKED OVER TO THE ALEMAN RESIDENCE WHERE THEY KNOCKED ON THE
DOOR. MS. STATED THEY WAITED APPROXIMATELY TEN MINUTES BEFORE MR. ALEMAN
FINALLY CAME TO THE DOOR. MS. STATED WHILE THEY WERE WAITING OUTSIDE
THEY COULD HEAR THE CHILDREN INSIDE OF THE HOME. MS. STATED WHEN MR.
ALEMAN CAME OUT HE SAID HE HAD BEEN SLEEPING. SHE STATED MR. ALEMAN CAME
OUTSIDE TO SPEAK TO THEM AND HE CLOSED THE DOOR BEHIND HIM. MS. STATED
SHE ASKED FOR PERMISSION TO SEE THE CHILDREN AND MR. ALEMAN TOLD THEM HIS WIFE
WAS NOT CURRENTLY HOME AND HE WAS NOT GOING TO ALLOW THEM TO SEE THE CHILDREN
AT THIS TIME. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN WOULD NOT EXPLAIN HIS REASONING FOR
THIS. MS. STATED AT THIS POINT SHE PROCEEDED TO GET BASIC INFORMATION
FROM MR. ALEMAN SUCH AS HIS OCCUPATION AND WHERE THEY LIVED PRIOR TO
LOXAHATCHEE.
MS. STATED SHE THEN INFORMED MR. ALEMAN THAT IF HE CONTINUED TO DENY
THEM ACCESS TO THE HOME AND THE CHILDREN THEY WOULD HAVE TO FILE A MOTION TO
COMPEL WITH THE COURTS. MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN SAID SOMETHING TO THE
EFFECTS OF "DO WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO." MS. STATED MS. THEN FILED
THE MOTION TO COMPEL AND WHEN IT WAS APPROVED SHE EXECUTED THE COURT ORDER FOR
MS. WHO HAD A DEATH IN THE FAMILY AT THE TIME. MS. STATED SHE
WENT WITH MS. TO EXECUTE THE COURT ORDER. MS. STATED THEY
CONTACTED PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERRIFF'S OFFICE FOR ASSISTANCE ONCE THEY ARRIVED
IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. MS. STATED SHE TRIED TO PARK DISCRETELY BEHIND THE
ALEMAN RESIDENCE WHERE THEY COULD MAKE A QUICK EXIT IF NECESSARY BUT MR.
ALEMAN SAW THEIR VEHICLE AND HE CAME OUT OF THE HOUSE TO SPEAK TO THEM.
MS. STATED SHORTLY AFTER THE DEPUTY ARRIVED ON SCENE THEY PROVIDED
HIM WITH A COPY OF THE COURT ORDER. MS. STATED WHEN SHE SERVED MR.
ALEMAN WITH THE COURT ORDER MR. ALEMAN DEMEANOR WAS AS IF HE THOUGHT THE
SITUATION WAS FUNNY AND HE SAID, "YOU GUYS DIDN'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH ALL THIS
I WOULD OF LET YOU SEE THE KIDS." MS. STATED MR. ALEMAN THEN ALLOWED
THEM INTO THE HOME. MS. STATED WHEN SHE WALKED INTO THE HOME SHE WALKED
INTO THE LIVING ROOM/KITCHEN AREA. SHE STATED TO THE LEFT OF THE RESIDENCE
THERE WERE TWO BEDROOMS WHERE SHE OBSERVED ONE OF THE OLDER BOYS SITTING ON A
BED WITH AN OPEN BOOK AS IF HE WAS READING A SCHOOL WORKBOOK. MS. STATED
ALL OF THE BEDS WERE PERFECTLY MADE IN THE CHILDREN'S BEDROOMS. MS.
STATED WHEN THEY ENTERED THE KITCHEN THERE WAS AN OVERABUNDANCE OF FOOD IN THE
KITCHEN CABINETS AND REFRIGERATOR. MS. STATED THE HOUSE APPEARED TO BE
CLEAN. WHEN I ASKED HER IF SHE SAW ANY PETS IN THE HOME MS. STATED SHE
RECALLS THEIR MIGHT HAVE BEEN TWO DOG KENNELS THAT WERE COVERED IN THE FRONT
ROOM OF THE RESIDENCE BUT SHE DID NOT SEE OR HEAR THE DOGS.
MS. STATED WHEN SHE SPOKE TO MR. ALEMAN ABOUT HIS OCCUPATION HE TOLD
HER HE WAS A "REPO AGENT." I ASKED MS. IF SHE RECALLS THE OCCUPATION OF
MRS. ALEMAN AND SHE SAID SHE DID NOT RECALL. I ASKED MS. IF THE CHILDREN
WERE ENROLLED IN SCHOOL AT THE TIME AND SHE SAID, "NO." MS. STATED
KRISTEN ALEMAN TOLD HER ALL OF THE CHILDREN WERE BEING HOME SCHOOLED EXCEPT
FOR THE OLDEST CHILD WHO WAS NOT ENROLLED IN SCHOOL AT THE TIME BECAUSE SHE
WAS HAVING ISSUES GETTING HIS BIRTH CERTIFICATE BECAUSE HE WAS BORN OUT OF
STATE. SHE STATED THIS ISSUE WAS KEEPING HER FROM ENROLLING HIM IN HOMESCHOOL.
I ASKED MS. LEITY IF SHE RECALLS SEEING THE BABY ( THAT DAY
AND SHE SAID, "YES." I ASKED HER WHERE SHE INITIALLY SAW THE MOTHER WHEN SHE
WAS DOING THE WALK THROUGH. MS. STATED SHE COULD NOT RECALL WHERE
EXACTLY SHE SAW THE MOTHER CHANGING THE BABY'S DIAPER WHEN THEY FIRST CAME
INTO THE HOME. I ASKED MS. IF SHE WAS ABLE TO SEE THE BABY'S GENITAL
AREA WHILE THE MOTHER CHANGING HER DIAPER AND SHE SAID, "NO." I ASKED MS.
TO DESCRIBE THE PHYSICAL APPEARANCE OF IN HER PROFESSIONAL
OPINION. MS. STATED THE BABY APPEARED TO BE A LITTLE UNDER A YEAR OLD.

02/13/17 Page 50 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE PAGE 47
SUPPLEMENT 22 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738
SHE DESCRIBED AS A HEALTHY NORMAL LOOKING BABY. MS. STATED
APPEARED NORMAL, CLEAN, WEARING A "CUTE OUTFIT." MS. STATED ALL OF THE
CHILDREN APPEARED CLEAN AND NOTHING INDICATED THE BABY WAS MALNOURISHED OR NOT
BEING FED AT THE TIME.
MS. TOLD ME SHE STATED SHE ADDRESSED HER CONCERNS ABOUT THE CHILDREN
NOT BEING VERBAL FOR THEIR AGE AND SHE MENTIONED THAT ONE OF THE BOYS POSSIBLY
NAMED WAS RECEIVING SPEECH THERAPY SOMEWHERE. MS. STATED DURING
THEIR WALK THROUGH WITH MR. ALEMAN IT WAS APPARENT IN HIS DEMEANOR THAT HE
WANTED THEIR VISIT TO BE QUICK. MS. LIETI STATED WHEN THEIR WALK THROUGH OF
THE HOUSE WAS COMPLETED MR. ALEMAN HELPED THEM OUT OF THE HOUSE. MS.
STATED IT IS NORMAL/STANDARD FOR THEM TO TAKE PICTURE IN CASES INVOLVING AN
ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLAINT UNLESS THEY WERE TOLD NOT TO TAKE ANY PICTURES. I
ASKED MS. IF MR. ALEMAN ASKED THEM NOT TAKE PICTURES OF THE HOME OR THE
CHILDREN AND SHE SATED SHE COULD NOT RECALL. MS. HAD NO FURTHER
INFORMATION THIS TIME. I THEN CONCLUDED THE INTERVIEW WITH MS.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@8:17AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 51 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
S/
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 48
SUPPLEMENT 23 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON THURSDAY, AUGUST 11, 2016, I MADE CONTACT WITH INVESTIGATOR EDWARD
ARENS FROM THE MARTIN COUNTY STATE ATTORNEY'S OFFICE DISTRICT NINETEEN.
INVESTIGATOR ARENS PROVIDED HIS ASSISTANCE TO OBTAIN AND SERVE SEARCH WARRANTS
FOR THE MEDICAL RECORDS OF THE SURVIVING ALEMAN CHILDREN INCLUDING THE MEDICAL
RECORDS OF THE DECEASED VICTIM, IN BOTH MARTIN AND ST. LUCIE
COUNTY. I WAS ABLE TO OBTAIN THE BIRTH RECORDS OF THE DECEASED VICTIM FROM
MARTIN MEDICAL WHERE SHE WAS BORN. WE THEN ARRIVED AT TENDER CARE PEDIATRICS
IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY WHERE THE CHILDREN'S PEDIATRICIAN DR. ANITHA JAGADISH IS
LOCATED. THE STAFF WAS ABLE TO PROVIDE ME WITH THE MEDICAL RECORDS OF THE
CHILDREN THAT WERE ACTUAL PATIENTS AT THIS OFFICE. THERE WAS NO MEDICAL
RECORDS FOUND INDICATING, THE DECEASED VICTIM, WAS EVER A PATIENT
UNDER THE CARE OF DR. JAGADISH AS STATED BY HER MOTHER KRISTEN MEYER.
AFTER AN EXTENSIVE SEARCH FOR MEDICAL RECORDS FOR WAS
CONDUCTED BY MULTIPLE GOVERNING AGENCIES SUCH AS PALM BEACH COUNTY MEDICAL
EXAMINER'S OFFICE; CHILD PROTECTION TEAM (CPT) OF PALM COUNTY AND DEPARTMENT
OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES (DCF) THERE APPEARS TO HAVE BEEN NO ACTIVITY ON
MEDICAID BENEFITS ACCOUNT WHICH WAS ACTIVATED AT THE TIME OF HER
BIRTH AT MARTIN MEDICAL WHERE SHE WAS BORN UNTIL SHE EXPIRED AT PALMS WEST
HOSPITAL. THESE FINDINGS INDICATE THAT NEVER SAW A DOCTOR FROM
THE DAY SHE WAS BORN MARCH 7, 2015 TILL THE TIME OF HER DEATH, APRIL 1ST, 2016
I THEN PLACED THESE RECORDS INTO PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
EVIDENCE.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@9:26AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 52 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
18335 10/26/16 ELTO
PALM BEACH COUNTY S H E R I F F' S OFFICE PAGE 49
SUPPLEMENT 24 OFFENSE REPORT CASE NO. 16058738

DISPOSITION: CLEARED BY ARREST
DIVISION: DETECTIVE

PREMEDIT MURDER CODE: 090A DATE: 10/26/16 WEDNESDAY
ZONE: X11 GRID: DEPUTY ID.: 8192 ASSIST: TIME D 1848 A 1857 C 0702
OCCURRED BETWEEN DATE: 04/01/16 , 1848 HOURS AND DATE: 04/02/16 , 0600 HOURS
EXCEPTION TYPE:
INCIDENT LOCATION: 17148 N 30TH LA APT. NO.:
CITY: LOX STATE: FL ZIP: 33470
NO. OFFENSES: 03 NO. OFFENDERS: 02 NO. VEH. STOLEN: 0 NO. PREM. ENTERED: 0
LOCATION: RESIDENCE - SINGLE FAMILY
NO. VICTIMS: 01 NO. ARRESTED: 2 FORCED ENTRY: 0
WEAPON TYPE: OTHER
OFFENSE NO. 1 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 782 04 1A1 CIS CODE 090A
OFFENSE NO. 2 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 827 03 1A CIS CODE 130A
OFFENSE NO. 3 FLORIDA STATE STATUTE: 828 12 CIS CODE 9000

ON AUGUST 1ST, 2016, A SEARCH WARRANT WAS OBTAINED FOR THE MEDICAL RECORDS
OF THE VICTIM, FROM PALMS WEST HOSPITAL LOCATED AT 13001 SOUTHERN
BLVD, IN LOXAHATCHEE, FLORIDA. I WAS ABLE TO OBTAIN THE MEDICAL RECORDS FOR
WHICH I LATER PLACED INTO EVIDENCE AT THE PALM BEACH COUNTY
SHERIFF'S OFFICE.
THIS CASE REMAINS OPEN PENDING FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
DETECTIVE SAINT-JEAN #8192
SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
COPY:PASTE:10-26-16@9:28AM/KK #4315

02/13/17 Page 53 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
$HERIPP'$ OPF10E
RIO L. BRADSHAW, SHERIFF

Crime Laboratory Technical Services Division, 3228 Gun Club Rd., WPB, FL 33406 Tel (561) 688-4262 Fax (561) 688-4280

Crime Scene Report

Detective Vlonide Saint-Jean PESO Case #: 16-068738
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Agency Case #: 16-068738
3228 Gun Club Road
West Palm Beach, FL 33406

Deceased:
secondary Agencies:
Date of Birth:
Medical Examiners Office
16-000525 Suspect Aleman, Alejandro
Date of Birth: 03/03/1978

Suspect Meyer, Kristen A
Date of Birth: 10/03/1973

REQUEST FOR INVESTIGATION:

On 04/01/2016 It was requested that the Crime Scene Unit perform the following: Crime Scene investigation - Lead

NARRATIVE:
On 04/01/16, at approximately 2114 hours, CSI Brandt, ID 4169, was contacted by PBSO Communications and told to call
Special Investigations Division (SID) Sgt. Keith, ID 6231. CSI Brandt did so and was told to respond to Palms West
Hospital, 13001 Southern Blvd., Loxahatchee, in reference to the death investigation of a one year old child Involving
possible neglect. CS1 Brandt was enroute at approximately 2128 hours and arrived at approximately 2148 hours.

CSI Brandt met with lead SID Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192, and assisting SID Det. Lara, ID 8679, In the emergency room.
Det. Saint Jean Identified the child as W/F, Taylor Aleman, DOB/030715. The child's mother was identified as W/F, Kristen
A. Meyer, D013/100373. The child's father was identified as W/M, Alejandro Aleman, DOB/030378, CSI Brandt was told
both were present at the hospital but were uncooperative with law enforcement in providing additional information about
the child and the immediate events prior to her death, as well as granting access to their residence located at 17148 30
Lane North, Loxahatchee. CSI Brandt was told by Det Saint Jean Mr. Aleman contacted an attorney, as well as his nine
other children at the residence, telling the children not open the door to anyone or let anyone in the residence until they
(Mr. Aleman and Ms. Meyer) returned.

Det. Saint Jean told CS1 Brandt deputies responded to the Aleman residence in response to a 911 call reporting a child was
not breathing. The child ( was transported to the hospital by Palm Beach County Fire Rescue and was
pronounced by Dr. Jaime Estrada at 1926 hours. Det. Saint Jean told CSI Brandt Dr. Estrada stated the child died from
extreme malnutrition. Det. Saint Jean told CS1 Brandt preliminary information had been gathered by the hospital's medical
staff during triage of the victim (TaylorAleman) and consisted of the victim having been born in Stuart, Florida at a weight
of 9 lbs., with no defects or deformities at birth and no medical issues since. Ms. Meyer reported during the 911 call that
she was feeding the victim from a bottle when she suddenly stopped breathing. The medical staff weighed the victim while
In the emergency room. Her current weight was 7 lbs. Ms. Meyer admitted not having taken the victim to a doctor In
several months.

CSI Brandt was directed to an exam room within the emergency room marked as "Exam 1." The victim was lying on her
back on a gurney in the room, covered from the neck down by a white blanket with blue stripes. Medical intervention
discards were scattered atop the gurney. A Carter's pink blanket with orange dots (Item 4) was on the foot of the gurney.

10/26/2016
An ASCLD /LAB Accredited Laboratory Since 2006
Page 1 of 7

02/13/17 Page 54 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Crime Scene Report, 16-058738 - Continued 10/26/2016 Page 2 of 7

CSI Brandt wore nitrile gloves while at the hospital, and changed gloves during the handling/collection of different items of
evidence so as not to cross contaminate same.

CSI Brandt retrieved her department issued Nikon D7000 digital SLR camera with on camera flash, loaded with a Maxflash
2GB SD card (item 1), Nikon 18-105mm lens, and began photographing the victim at approximately 2203 hours.

CSI Brandt removed the blanket covering the victim. Her face was pale and her body was emaciated. Her eyes were
partially open. The whites of her eyes were discolored black/dark grey. Bruising was present under her left eye. Two
tubes protruded from her mouth (airway, gastric). Extra body hair was present on the child's face (forehead, cheeks),
shoulders, upper arms and legs. A large EKG patch was on her left chest. The outline of her ribcage was visible below
the skin of her chest and abdomen. A hospital identification band was around her right ankle. White gauze was taped to
the top side of her right foot. A small area of blood-like stains (BLS) was on the bottom of the heel of her right foot. A
pulse monitor was taped to the child's left big toe. An IV was in her left shin. The child's skin was loose, dry, wrinkled and
covered by a brown film. Under the child's body was a size 3 mos Carter's pink animal print onesle sleeper with long
sleeves and feet (Item 3). A urine soiled diaper (Item 2) was lying across the child's groin area. CS) Brandt moved the
onesle sleeper and soiled diaper aside to take additional photographs of the child. The skin of the child's labia majora was
raw and red. CSI Brandt repositioned the child so her posterior side could be viewed and photographed. The hair on the
back of her head appeared to be thinning. Extra body hair was present across the child's upper back and back of her
shoulders. A large EKG patch was on the midsection of her back. The skin of her buttocks was raw and red. The child's
coccyx was pronounced. A red rash-like area was on the child's lower back, above the coccyx.

CSI Brandt collected Items 2 through 4.

Department of Children and Families (DCF) representative and Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office
Investigator William Frasier, arrived at the hospital to begin their investigations.

Det. Saint Jean advised a search warrant was going to be prepared by Det Lara for the Aleman residence at 17148 30
Lane North, Loxahatchee.

CSI Brandt was informed by SID detectives that on-call Palm Beach County Medical Examiner's Office (PBCMEO)
Forensic Investigator Lydia Littlefield had been contacted and declined to respond to the hospital . Investigator Littlefield
dispatched Elite Removal Service to the hospital to transport the child to the PBCMEO. Investigator Littlefield provided her
agency's case number as 2016-0525.

CSI Brandt placed manila envelopes over the child's hands and secured them In place with evidence tape. CSI Brandt
initialed/dated/photographed same.

A representative from Elite Removal Service arrived at the hospital at approximately 0007 hours on 04102/16. The child
was placed in a body bag, which was sealed with a locking tag #1236275. CSI Brandt photographed the taa. The child
was transported to the PBCMEO by Elite Removal Service.

Sgt. Keith told CSI Brandt he would contact her once the search warrant had been secured for the Aleman residence.

CS) Brandt secured the evidence in her department vehicle and cleared the hospital at approximately 0022 hours. CSI
Brandt responded to PBSO headquarters and secured the evidence in the Crime Scene processing room.

At approximately 0141 hours, CSI Brandt was contacted by Sgt. Keith and told the search warrant had been secured and
to respond to 17148 30 Lane North, Loxahatchee. CSI Brandt was enroute at approximately 0202 hours and arrived at
approximately 0231 hours.

Several marked PBSO road patrol vehicles and uniformed deputies were on scene. A deputy and his vehicle were
blocking access to 30 Lane North at Cheetham Hill Blvd. Detectives from SID were also on scene: Saint Jean, Lara, King,
ID 5487, Suarez, ID 7953, and Sgt. Keith, as well as representatives from DCF.

CSI Brandt met with Det. Saint Jean who provided a copy of the search warrant, which was seeking: nutritional items such
as infant formula, toddler formula, milk, bottles, baby food, diapers and similar well-being items, photographs of residence
interior to document living conditions. Det. Saint Jean advised representatives from DCF were on scene to remove the

02/13/17 Page 55 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Crime Scene Report, 16-058738 - Continued 10/26/2016 Page 3 of7

nine remaining children from the residence.

Sgt. Keith advised Palm Beach County Animal Care and Control (PBCAC&C) had been contacted to respond to the
residence to remove a dog.

CSI Brandt retrieved her department Issued Vixia HF400 video camera, loaded with a SanDisk 8GB SD card (Item 8) and
began video recording the scene at approximately 0337 hours.

PBCAC&C Officer Chase Cook, ID 2133, arrived on scene to remove the dog from the residence. He provided his
agency's case number as A16-004620. At approximately 0401 hours, CS1 Brandt took preliminary photographs of the
residence ahead of Officer Cook removing the dog in order to document conditions prior to him entering the residence ,
using the same camera equipment and SD card used at the hospital, with the additional of a Nikon SB-900 flash
attachment

17148 30 Lane North was a single story north facing residence on the south side of the road. its exterior was yellow in
color with white trim around the windows. An attached garage was at the northwest end of the residence with a closed,
white, north facing door, One exterior light (on) attached to the north face of the garage, at its east end. "17148" was
displayed on the exterior north face of the residence, on the fascia trim surrounding the roof, above the garage door. A
driveway abutted the garage door, A freestanding basketball hoop, barbeque and trash cans were at the south end of the
driveway. A walkway extended east from the southeast side of the driveway and turned south , ending at the residence's
open north facing front door, located east of the garage. Several vehicles were parked in the grass west of the driveway.
The back (south) yard was surrounded by a wood privacy fence.

The front door opened to a foyer. An odor of mildew and feces was immediately noticeable at front door, An arched
opening in the west foyer wall led to a small room containing a sofa against the north wall. A car seat for an infant was
atop the east seatback of the sofa. A sheet covered the seat cushions and seatbacks of the sofa. Black plastic trash
bags, linens and clothing were piled on the fioor on the east side of the sofa. A chair was against the west wall. Two open
white plastic trash bags, containing discarded trash, were on the floor on the south side of the chair. An armoire was in the
southeast corner of the room. An arched opening was in the approximate midsection of the south wall, parallel with the
north end of the kitchen, provided access to an east/west oriented hall that separated the small room from the kitchen.

A closed door in the north hall wall at its east end opened to a laundry room . The door was unlocked, but had to be forced
open by Det. Suarez. The door was blocked from opening completely by a large pile of dirty clothes on the floor in the
laundry room. A washer and dryer were against the west wall. Dirty clothes were piled on the floor between the washer
and dryer and atop the dryer. A closed door in the north wall led to the garage. This door was inaccessible due to the pile
of dirty clothes blocking it. The pile of dirty clothes also blocked access to the dryer door. Clothing was inside the washing
machine. The laundry room smelled of mold/mildew.

The master bedroom was at the west end of the hall. A walk in closet was in the north wall at its east end. The closet
contained a high chair, two drawer file cabinet and a pile of clothing on the floor, An armoire was against the north wall,
west of the walk in closet. A two drawer night stand was against the west wall at its north end. Atop the night stand was
an open cardboard box labeled Berkley Jensen baby wipes which contained a sealed pack of diapers, an open pack of
baby wipes, an open pack of diapers, two loose diapers, a drinking glass, three tubes labeled Dr. Sheffield's 2 oz. Diaper
Rash ointment (Item 7 - one tube), one tube labeled Cerave 3 oz. baby diaper rash cream (Item 6), and a white plastic
Walmart shopping bag containing several loose diapers and a white plastic hanger with unknown brown residue . A
dresser was against the east wall, south of the night stand. A large screen television (off) was atop the dresser. Atop the
dresser, behind the north side of the television, was a gallon size container labeled Publix drinking water that was
approximately'/ full of clear liquid - expires 10/12/2016, a gallon size container labeled Nice purified water that was
approximately IA full of clear liquid (no cap) - expires 02/02/2018, and an open canister labeled Parent's Choice Sensitivity
birth - 12 months milk-based powder infant formula with iron 33.2 oz. (Item 9) - use by 05/30/2018, approximately half full
of pale yellow powder. What appeared to be a sectional type sofa was against the east wall at Its south end and south wall
its east end. The sofa was covered by a pile of clothes. Two shelving units were against the south wall at its west end. A
pile of clothes topped a chair against the west wall at its south end. The head of a bed (made) was against the
approximate midsection of the west wall. A wicker table, topped with books, a cardboard box and a pair of sneakers, was
against the west wall, north of the head of the bed. A Baby Trend Nursery Center (Pack N Play type bed) was against the
west wall at its north end. A blanket was draped over the south frame of the bed. Toys, stuffed animals, an unused diaper
and a tube labeled Angel of Mine diaper rash ointment were along the south side of the mattress . Additional toys, blankets
and three sleeper type onesies were along the north end of the mattress. A white duck print blanket was present in the

02/13/17 Page 56 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Crime Scene Report, 16-058738 - Continued 10/26/2016 Page 4 of 7

midsection of the mattress. Under the duck print blanket was a smaller white/pastel diamond print stained blanket. The
fabric covering the mattress was dark brown and was stained under the white/pastel diamond print stained blanket. This
area of the mattress was also concave.

An opening in the north wall, west of the armoire led to the master bathroom. The vanity was against the west wall at its
south end. The bathtub/shower was along the north wall. The bathtub surround contained several toys. The bathtub and
lower portion of the shower walls contained brown stains. A partially shredded shower curtain hung from a rod along the
south side of the bathtub/shower. A linen closet was in the north wall, east of the bathtub/shower. A plastic storage
container was on the top shelf in the linen closet and contained several prescription bottles, most with labels, but some
with no labels and handwritten contents. The labeled prescription bottles appeared to be old (2014 and 2015) and were In
the names of Alejandro Aleman, Kristen Meyer, Josephina Aleman and Victor Afeman. The toilet was
against the east wall, south of the linen closet. The toilet bowl was filthy, containing dark brown stains and brown water.

A washer and dryer were along the east side of the foyer, immediately east of the residence's front door. A dining room
area with a dining table and chairs was east of the washer and dryer. The table top was piled with dishes.

The living room was south of the foyer and east of the kitchen. The living room and kitchen spaces were open to each
other. A large screen television (on) was against the east wall: Three empty (pet food) bowls and an empty bag of dry dog
food were on the floor along the east living room wall at its north end (north of the large screen television that was on). A
second large screen television (off) was against the east living room wall, south of the television that was on. The second
television was turned screen side to the wall. Cardboard boxes and large plastic buckets were at the south end of the east
living room wall, south of the second television.

A white Amana refrigerator (working) was against the south living room wall at its west end. The floor of the exterior water
and ice dispenser was coated with an unknown dark brown gelatinous substance. In the freezer section was a container
labeled Goya Sofrito, a bag of ice, a frozen pizza, two cellophane wrappers containing one frozen waffle each, a bag
labeled sliced beef and vegetables, and two bags of frozen fries. The refrigerator door contained slices of cellophane
wrapped cheese, jars of applesauce and condiments (hot sauce, ketchup, salad dressing). The shelves in the refrigerator
contained slices of cellophane wrapped cheese, a container of sour cream, a container of butter, a container of dip, a jar of
salsa, a jar of jelly, packets of guacamole, a carton of eggs, three gallon size containers of milk - two Price First brand, one
half full, expiring 04/04/16, one less than one quarter full, expiring 04/03/16, one Great Value brand, half full, expiring
04/05/16, a bottle of syrup, and an unlabeled jar that appeared to contain mayonnaise, Standing brown liquid and food
remnants were at the bottom interior section of the refrigerator. Brown stains were present on the interior walls of the
refrigerator and freezer.

A dark colored sheet covered two glass sliding doors in the south living room wall , east of the Amana refrigerator. A north
facing brown sofa was north of the glass sliding doors. A cartoon themed blanket was on the east-most seat cushion of
the sofa. A Mickey Mouse themed blanket was on the floor north of the northwest end of the sofa . An 12 shaped black
sectional sofa was north of the brown sofa arid east of the kitchen bar. Four blankets were scattered on the sectional sofa.
A coffee table separated the sofas.

An island was centered in the kitchen space. A trash can containing a white trash bag and smaller plastic shopping type
bags filled with discarded trash and what appeared to be dried animal feces was on the north side of the island. A silver
colored Electrolux refrigerator was against the east kitchen wall at its north end. It was empty and unplugged. A •
counter/bar with two sinks was along the east side of the kitchen, south of the refrigerator, under which was a dishwasher
filled with dirty dishes and a liter bottle of 7 Up. Additional dirty dishes were in the cabinet below the sinks. Two bowls, a
knife and a drink cup were in the north sink. Several dishes were in the south sink. A First Essentials 9 oz./270 ml baby
bottle with a pink cap (Item 5) was on the counter next to the north sink. The bottle contained white milky coagulated
residue. Floor and wall mounted cabinets, with counters, lined the north and west walls of the kitchen. A stove was in the
approximate midsection of the cabinets along the west wail. A pantry with two bi-fold doors (closed) was in the west
kitchen wall at its south end. It contained empty glass canisters, silver colored bowls and two sealed boxes of instant
mashed potatoes. A full loaf of bread was in a bread keeper on the kitchen counter south of the stove . Two microwaves,
a toaster and a crackpot were on the kitchen counter north of the stove. A cell phone was on the kitchen counter near the
crockpot The cell phone was plugged into a charger in a wall outlet in the north kitchen wall. Most of the kitchen
cabinets/drawers contained pots/pans/silverware. Dry food items were located in the north wall mounted kitchen cabinets
and consisted of a Jar of peanut butter, spices, canned soup, a box of macaroni and cheese, a pack of crackers, 1
box/lbag of pasta, condiments (bottles of mustard, barbeque sauce, salad dressing, a jar of jalapeno peppers, ketchup,
packets of dry seasoning mix). A wood table was against the south kitchen wall.

02/13/17 Page 57 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
(67
Crime Scene Report, 16-058738 - Continued 10/26/2016 Page 5 of 7

A north/south oriented hall was east of the dining room area and living room and contained two bedrooms, a full size hail
bathroom and a linen closet. The first bedroom was at the north end of the hall. Immediately inside the entry door was a
dog crate containing a large short haired white/brown dog with sores on its paws, legs and flank. Its back bone and tall
bone were pronounced. The bottom of the crate was covered by a layer of what appeared to be compacted animal feces.
Two empty black plastic (pet food) bowls were on the floor of the crate and were covered with an unknown dark brown
residue. The head of a bed was against the north wall at its west end. The mattress was covered by a blue sheet, end a
decorative pillow was on the foot of the bed. A window In the north wall was covered by a blue sheet. A dresser, covered
by a blanket, was against the east wall at its north end. A large screen television (off) was against the east wall, south of
the dresser. A reach in type closet was in the south wall and contained what appeared to be bed frames . A white tarp-like
piece of fabric was on the floor between the bed and the television and dresser. Toy guns and sneakers, and what
appeared to be dried animal feces, were on the floor in front of the television.

A full size half bathroom was on the east side of the hall, south of the north-most bedroom. The vanity was against the
south wall at its west end. The toilet was against the south wall, east of the vanity. The bathtub/shower was along the
east wall. The toilet bowl contained what appeared to be feces and dark brown water.

A linen closet was on the west side of the hall at its south end.

A bedroom was at the south end of the hall. The heads of two beds (made) were along the east wall, one at the north end
and one at the south end. A chair was against the east wall and separated the heads of the beds . A dresser was at the
foot of the north-most bed. A dresser was against the south wall at its west end. A television (off) was atop the south wall
dresser. A closet was in the west wall at its south end. A bookcase was against the west wall at its north end.

PBCAC&C Officer Cook removed the dog from the crate in the north-most bedroom. Once Office Cook secured the dog
in his vehicle, he returned to the north-most bedroom and used a screwdriver to dig up a section of the floor (suspected
compacted animal feces) in the crate to take as a sample. Officer Cook estimated the thickness of the sample at 3". CSI
Brandt photographed same, A rusted Rayovac C cell battery was discovered in the suspected compacted animal feces on
the floor of the dog crate as Officer Cook was collecting his sample.

CS] Brandt completed photographing the residence, then used her department issued Vixia HF R400 video camera,
loaded with a SanDisk 8GB SD card (Item 8) to video record the scene.

CSI Brandt secured Items 1 through 9 in her department vehicle and cleared the scene at approximately 0708 hours. CSI
Brandt responded to PBSO headquarters and secured the evidence in the Crime Scene processing room.

At approximately 1306 hours, CSI Brandt photographed Item 4 using the same camera used at the hospital and at the
scene, loaded with a second Maxflash 2GB SD card (Item 10), wrapped Item 4 In brown paper, sealed it in an evidence
bag and recorded it on a property receipt.

At approximately 1316 hours, CSl Brandt sealed Items 6 and 7 in the same evidence bag and recorded them on the same
property receipt.

At approximately 1326 hours, CSI Brandt wrapped Item 3 in brown paper, sealed it in an evidence bag and recorded it on
a property receipt.

At approximately 1334 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 1 in an evidence bag and recorded it on a property receipt.

At approximately 1342 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 8 in an evidence bag and recorded it on a property receipt.

At approximately 1352 hours, CS! Brandt secured Items 1 and 8 in the Photo Lab via a drop slot.

At approximately 1400 hours, CSI Brandt packaged Items 5 and 9 and placed them In the refrigerator in the Crime Scene
processing room.

At approximately 1410 hours, CSI Brandt secured Items 3, 4, 6, and 7 in an Evidence Room locker.

On 04/03/16, CSI Brandt learned from Det. Saint Jean the child's first name was not Taylor as originally given.

02/13/17 Page 58 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Crime Scene Report, 16-058738 - Continued 10/26/2016 Page 6 of 7

On 04/10/16, at approximately 0749 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 2 In an evidence bag, recorded It on a property receipt
and placed It in the refrigerator in the Crime Scene processing room.

At approximately 0804 hours, CS! Brandt removed Item 5 from the refrigerator in the Crime Scene processing room and
from its sealed evidence bag. CSI Brandt photographed Item 5, resealed it in its evidence bag and returned it to the
refrigerator.

At approximately 0814 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 10 in an evidence bag, recorded it on a property receipt and secured
it in the Photo Lab via a drop slot.

On 04/17/16, at approximately 1710 hours, CSI Brandt signed for/took possession of autopsy evidence (Items 11 through
15) collected from the PBCMEO by CSI Chehab, ID 7456, on 04/17/16 at 1400 hours and secured in the Crime Scene
processing room.

At approximately 1845 hours, CSI Brandt secured Item 15 in the Crime Scene drying room.

On 04/18/18, at approximately 1010 hours, CSI Brandt turned over Items 2, 5 and 9 to Evidence Technician Weinberg, ID
3927, In the Crime Lab.

On 04/22/16, at approximately 0135 hours, CSI Brandt removed Item 15 from the Crime Scene drying room and secured it
in the Crime Scene processing room.

On 04/23/16, at approximately 0420 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 11 In an evidence bag and recorded it on a property
receipt as follows:

Item 11 - (5) sealed manila envelopes labeled "Aleman, hair standard front, back, left side, right side, vertex"

At approximately 0440 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 14 In an evidence bag and recorded it on a property receipt as
follows:

Item 14 - (1) sealed manila envelope labeled "Aleman, Police DNA Standard"

At approximately 0448 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 12 in an evidence bag and recorded it on a property receipt as
follows:

Item 12- (1) sealed brown paper bag (PBCMEO evidence bag) labeled "Aleman, 2 hand bags"

At approximately 0456 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 15 in an evidence bag and recorded it on a property receipt as
follows:

Item 15 white sheet

At approximately 0518 hours, CSI Brandt secured Items 11 and 14 In the Crime Lab via a drop slot.

At approximately 0530 hours, CSI Brandt secured Items 12 and 15 in an Evidence Room locker.

On 04/24/16, at approximately 2000 hours, CSI Brandt sealed Item 13 in an evidence bag and recorded it on a property
receipt as follows:

Item 13 - (1) inked footprint card In name of W/F, DOB 5

On 04/29/16, at approximately 1945 hours, CSI Brandt secured item 13 in the Evidence Room via a drop slot.

This concludes CSI Brandt's involvement In this case.

02/13/17 Page 59 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

39
Crime Scene Report, T6-058738 - Continued 10/26/2016 Page 7 of 7

Juliann Brandt- Crime Scene Investigator 11

02/13/17 Page 60 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
10/25/2016

Case # Submission # Description Size Location

16-058738 001 Video SSB PHOTO LAB VAULT

16-058738 001-01 Video (cont) PHOTO LAB VAULT

16-058738 002 Digital Images SSB DIGITAL IMAGES SERVER

16-058738 003 Size 3 mos Carter's pink animal print onesie sleeper, long SSB H1647
sleeves, footed.

16-058738 004 Carter's pink blanket with orange dots. SMB H1647

16-058738 005 3 oz. tube Cerave baby diaper rash cream (master bedroom) SSB H1647
/ 2 oz. tube Dr. Sheffield's diaper rash ointment (master
bedroom).

16-058738 006 Digital Images SSB DIGITAL IMAGES SERVER

16-058738 007 Soiled Baby Diaper SSB FREEZER #4

16-058738 008 First Essentials 9oz/270m1Baby Bottle containing White SSB FREEZER #4
Residue (kitchen counter)

16-058738 009 Open 33.2oz canister Parent's Choice Sensitivity birth - 12 SMB FREEZER #4
months milk based powder infant formula with iron (master
bedroom)

16-058738 010 Sealed manila envelope labeled "Aleman, Police SSB 16A
DNA Standard"

16-058738 011 5 sealed manila envelopes labeled "Aleman, hair SSB 16A
standard front, back, left side, right side, vertex"

16-058738 012 Sealed brown paper bag (PBCMEO evidence bag) labeled SMB H1647
'Aleman, 2 handbags

16-058738 013 White sheet SLB H1647

16-058738 014 Inked footprint card in name of W/F, DOB SSB H1647

16-058738 015 Photo line up and instructions (Deanna Bush)/ Photo line SMB H1647
up and instructions (Luke Bush)/ CD with photo line up
presentations

16-058738 016 (2) Photo line up and instructions (Yolanda Spearman)/ SMB H1647
Photo line up and instructions (Silus Spearman)/ CD with
photo line up presentation.

16-058738 017 Medical records St. Lucie County/ Medical records Martin SLB H1647
County

16-058738 018 Medical records (Palms West Hospital). SLB H1647

16-058738 019 Photo line up and instructions (Shawn Ward)/ CD w/ photo SMB H1647
lien up presentations

02/13/17 Page 61 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
10/25/2016

Case # Submission # Description Size Location

16-058738 020 Miscellaneous papers, search warrants from Palms West SMB H1647
Hospital.

16-058738 021 Miscellaneous papers, search warrants from St. Lucie SMB H1647
County and Martin County.

16-058738 022 Miscellaneous papers of eviction final judgements (Victor SMB H1647
Hijuelos).

16-058738 023 Subpoena for FPL (misc. papers) SMB H1647

16-058738 024 Inventory and return receipt (seized items from SW) SSB H1647

16-058738 025 5 CPT dvds of Aleman children interviews. SMB H1647

16-058738 026 Photo line up and instructions ( Photo SMB B2012
line up and instructions ( CD with photo line up
presentations.

02/13/17 Page 62 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
16-058738
PROPERTY RECEIPT
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC Number
04/01/16 2235 15-11 Child Neglect/Homicide \-114L-1
O Drugs O Firearms 0 Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered

ID Toxicology O Crime Scene 0 Lost Property [0 Trial

O Serology/DNA O Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192 PESO SID, 688-4143
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom
O Yes Pi No
Photographed by & I.D. # J. Brandt, ID 4169
Address where property recovered: Palms West Hospital, 13001 Southern Blvd., Loxahatchee
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: J. Brandt, ID 4169 04/01/16 PBSO Crime Scene 688-4270
Owner:
Victim: Deceased
Suspect(s) Kristen A. Meyer 10/03/73 W/F 17148 30 Lane North, LOX
Suspect: Alejandro Aleman 03/03/78 W/M 17148 30 Lane North, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
. Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
3 1 Size 3 mos Carter's pink animal print onesie sleeper, long sleeves, footed

Palm Beach Sheriff's Office
Cue # 16-050738 Sub # 003

III111 11111 111 II1111I II

Size 3 mos Carter s pink animal print onesie sleeF

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by
taken- from my possession and that-I have received a copy of this me lathe Official "performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or Support
receipt. En Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Juliann Brandt CS
Print Name: Print Name: I.D.# 4169 Div

0-4...-f—
Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time
4 1 '(_1,) Aist.4"--C- 4-H69 5,..,,,,,Lci. 6-
v, ./.044.__Ie.0,2,-,,,, 14 c/fit, a Ito al6 /fie)
C' -LA, Ito Cr-
Iv -(U2S Litt 'ii

DISTRICT 15-11 PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 63 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PROPERTY RECEIPT 16- 058738
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC Number
04/01/16 2240 15-11 Child Neglect/Homicide
0 Drugs CI Firearms 0 Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered

0 Toxicology 1:1 Crime Scene 0 Lost Property m Trial

0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192 PESO SID, 688-4143
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom
0 Yes [21 No
Photographed by & I.D. # J. Brandt, ID 4169
Address where property recovered: Palms West Hospital, 13001 Southern Blvd., Loxahatchee
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: J. Brandt, ID 4169 04/01/16 PESO Crime Scene 688-4270
Owner:
Victim: Deceased
Suspect(s) Kristen A. Meyer 10/03/73 W/F 17148 30 Lane North, LOX
Suspect: Alejandro Aleman 03/03/78 W/M 17148 30 Lane North, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
4 1 Carter's pink blanket with orange dots

---- Palm Beach Sheriff's Office
Case # 6-058738 Sub # 004

1 1 1111 III 111 1 1 1 1111 11 1 11

Carter s pink blanket with orange dots.
I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by
taken from my possession and that I have received a copy of this me in the official peformance Of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer orSupport
receipt. c:3 Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

Print Name: Print Name:
Juliann Brandt I.D.# 4169 Div. CS

(4—a-;:,-, --;
e•--046-t.A.- CL
Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time

t•-a-,,, d,r- 41 679 S— 4, cAA,..21 (5 v ,* d—e-v. es— re_oo-rpiLocice..4..0(top-llo iefio
L_Izrzalsz0_Lwi Nk":`(\ Li_q_1(00--)(7:

DISTRICT 15-11 PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 64 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PROPERTY RECEIPT 16-058738
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC Number
04/02/16 0627 15-11 Child Neglect/Homicide Ic~ y1
0 Drugs ID Firearms 01 Photo Lab ID Stolen Recovered

0 Toxicology 0 Crime Scene El Lost Property Trial

0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints ID Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192 PBSO SID, 688-4143
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom

0 Yes RI No
Photographed by & I.D. # - J. Brandt, ID 4169
Address where property recovered: 17148 30 Lane North, Loxahatchee
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: J. Brandt, ID 4169 04/02/16 PBSO Crime Scene 688-4270
Owner:
Victim: Deceased
Suspect(s) Kristen A. Meyer 10/03/73 W/F 17148 30 Lane North, LOX
Suspect: Alejandro Aleman 03/03/78 W/M 17148 30 Lane North, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
6 1 3 oz. tube Cerave baby diaper rash cream (master bedroom)
7 1 2 oz. tube Dr. Sheffield's diaper rash ointment (master bedroom)

Pa m Beach Sheri f 's Office
Case # 6-058738 Sub # 005

1 1111 11 111 I III 1111 111 1 1111111 II

3 oz tube Cerave baby diaper rash cream (master t

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by
taken from my possession and that I have received-a -copy of this me in the official performance of duty as-a Law Enforcement Officer or Support
receipt. 0 Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

Print Name: Print Name:
Juliann Brandt I.D.# 4169 Div.
CS

'.4.- LAILaa-unn ti QL—
.
Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time
.....—
4 . (1,..41,t,t4iti::(el 0 5 ,s1.4,........e_al L- -. v .` citi,c_o_ Zoeit„ ix12 c-I (.4-1 o 4o xie 1 47 z 1 0
-Piz_Lf2-14-tiliPI %(6)>1 ±:1LiLtevj0:s..

DISTRICT PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 65 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Cs
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PROPERTY RECEIPT PirC/Y1Eo 2014)--o$A 16-058738
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC Number
04/02 / 16 1215 1-12 Child Neglect/Homicide NI 641
0 Drugs 0 Firearms 0 Photo Lab ID Stolen - Recovered
ID Toxicology 0 Crime Scene 0 Lost Property 66 Trial

0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192 PBSO SID, 688-4143
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom
0 Yes Eli No
Photographed by & I.D. #
Address where property recovered: PBCMEO, 3126 Gun Club Road, WPB
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: Dr. Juste 04/02/16 PBCMEO 688-4584
Owner:
Victim: Deceased
Suspect(s) Kristen A. Meyer 10/03/73 W/F 17148 30 Lane North, LOX
Suspect: Alejandro Aleman 03/03/78 W/M 17148 30 Lane North, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
12 1 Sealed brown paper bag (PBCMEO evidence bag) labeled "Aleman, 2 hand
bags"

IIIIIIIIIGINIIIN ,, label.

I I
I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property Impounded by
taken from my posses§ion and that I have received a copy of this me in the"officiallWificirrifanCt iff-dtity84-0 LOW Enforcement Officeror Support
receipt. Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

Print Name: Print Name:
Juliann Brandt I D # 4 16 9 Div.
CS

Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time

• 69 -- 0
tak4A-d. C/044_0_12.-- raoa-PK (cJCa 0 4'2"1G a 5-30
1401/U40 izUe241Sm
1
41 0q2.51le, 0-730

DISTRICT 1-33 PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 66 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

6g-
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PROPERTY RECEIPT aid -- 0525 tbeir (.0 16-058738
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC umber
04/02/16 1215 1-12 Child Neglect/Homicide .v.k 1(04-7
0 Drugs 0 Firearms El Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered

0 Toxicology 0 Crime Scene 0 Lost Property WI Trial

0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints El Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192 PBSO SID, 688-4143
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom

0 Yes Wi No
Photographed by & I.D. #
Address where property recovered: PBCMEO, 3126 Gun Club Road, WPB
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: Dr. Juste 04/02/16 PBCMEO 688-4584

Owner:
Victim: Deceased

Suspect(s) Kristen A. Meyer 10/03/73 W/F 17148 30 Lane North, LOX
Suspect: Alejandro Aleman 03/03/78 W/M 17148 30 Lane North, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
15 1 White sheet

Palm Beach Sher f 's 0 f ce
Case * 6-058738 Sub SI 013

YIII11Il IA Il l'
White sheet

I
I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by
taken frcirn rriy-pos -essio-n and that I have received a copy of this me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or Support
receipt. C] Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Juliann Brandt CS
Print Name: Print
nt Name: I.D.# 416 9 Div.

CIA GL.-,..011-k v,..,..1 11-
L.__
A-A.4,1- Ck:-
Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time
1 —
.' 1
::I
:: .6 41 6 q ,5_4...C..4-4......Q.4 C:: to r` d....12-TACJI-1-Gerh/ LE00....(Ca,1/4, 0 51Z. 3/ 6, d' -S- 3(

‘.6kith .1() sc:L_ N15 1(0 cria

DISTRICT 1-33 PAGE 1 OF 1
PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 67 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
C7
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PROPERTY RECEIPT Pociae, Reit, o5aS 16-058738
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC umber
04/02 / 16 1215 1-12 Child Neglect/Homicide /2
1
0 Drugs 0 Firearms 0 Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered
0 Toxicology 0 Crime Scene 0 Lost Property 21 Trial
0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
Det. Saint Jean, ID 8192 PBSO SID, 688-4143
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom
0 Yes 2i No
Photographed by & I.D. #
Address where property recovered: PBCMEO, 3126 Gun Club Road, WPB
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: Dr. Juste 04/02/16 PBCMEO 688-4584
Owner:
Victim: Deceased
Suspect(s) Kristen A. Meyer 10/03/73 W/F 17148 30 Lane North, LOX
Suspect: Alejandro Aleman 03/03/78 W/M 17148 30 Lane North, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
13 1 Inked footprint card in name of W/F, DOB/03072015

Palm Beach Sheri f 's Office
Sub * 014

iiiiiiiiiiiiii111 1111111
Inked footprint card in name o Rieman, W/F

I hereby_ acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property Impounded by
taken from my possession and that I have received a copY of this me in the cifFicial performance of duty as a LAW Enforcement-Officer or Support
receipt. 1::3 Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

Print Name: Print Name:
Juliann Brandt I.D.# 4169 Div. CS

(A.—QAe3--
- t•t-t. P --
Signature: Signature: Signature:

. Received By Reason Date & Time

1 r..4t-4 - CH(9e't 5--Q-e-tAxii. a c- v--, cisa....catitoorr,lcod LA-. oil-R 916 (9 4

DISTRICT 1-33 PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 68 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

61?
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PROPERTY RECEIPT 16- 058738
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC umber
7/28/16 1939 15-11 DEATH INVESTIGATION
0 Drugs 0 Firearms 0 Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered
0 Toxicology 0 Crime Scene 0 Lost Property WI Trial
0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
DET. SAINT JEAN 8192 SID/CAC
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom
0 Yes 66 No N/A
Photographed by & I.D. # N/A
Address where property recovered: 17128 30TH LN N, LOXAHATCHEE , FL 33470
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: DET. CHRISTOFEL 7/28/16 N/A N/A PESO
Owner: STATE OF FLORIDA
Victim: 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
Suspect(s) KRISTEN MEYER 10/3/73 W/F 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN 3/3/78 W/M 17148 30TH LN N, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
1 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS (DEANNA BUSH)
I
2 1 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS (LUKE BUSH)
3 1 $1 CD WITH PHOTO LINE UP PRESENTATIONS

Palm Beach Sheriff's Office
Sub # 015
Case * 6-058738

1
11 11 1 1I 11 IN I 1
(Deanna Bush)! Phot
Photo line up and instructions
I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property Impounded by
taken from my possession and that I have received -a copy of this me in the -official performance of duty-es a-Law Enforcement"Officer orSuppOrt
receipt. Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
DET B. CHRISTOFFEL SID
Print Name: Print Name: I D.# 838 7 Div.

Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time

,., .,,ot\e, u\lW -''
L. G-,4-1 (0 C/7
.101 .8 1, 8-\ -0/1)
/4 (-0.- CRZZR0 oil

DISTRICT SID/CAC PAGE 1 OF 1
PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 69 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
16- 058738
PROPERTY RECEIPT
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC Number
7/28/16 2005 15-11 DEATH INVESTIGATION (04-1
O Drugs O Firearms 0 Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered

O Toxicology O Crime Scene 0 Lost Property RI Trial

O Serology/DNA O Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
DET. SAINT JEAN 8192 SID/CAC
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom
O Yes RI No N/A
Photographed by & I.D. # N/A
Address where property recovered: 17211 30TH LN N, LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: DET. CHRISTOFEL 7/28/16 N/A N/A PESO
Owner: STATE OF FLORIDA
Victim: 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
Suspect(s) KRISTEN MEYER 10/3/73 W/F 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN 3/3/78 W/M 17148 30TH LN N, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
1 2 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS (YOLANDA 'SPEARMAN)
2 1 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS (SILUS SPEARMAN)
3 1 $1 CD WITH PHOTO LINE UP PRESENTATIONS

Palm Beach Sheriff's 0 !ice
Case * 16-058738 Sub # 016

111111 11111 I II 1111 I I I III II 11

(2) Photo line up and 'nstructions (Yolanda Spearrt

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded by
- taken from my possession and that I have received a copy-of this - - me in the official performance of duty -as -a Law Enforcement Officer or Support
receipt. Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Print Name: Print Name: DET. B CHRISTOFFEL I.D.# 8387 Div. SID

Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time
'(WA i LIU
ille a _,z,A
I (_ IB711, 61 36
(iilit, /Re kkok 68--7.1(o. IV`,

DISTRICT SID/CAC PAGE 1 OF 1

PESO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 70 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
16-058738
PROPERTY RECEIPT
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC umber
8/5/16 1655 15-11 DEATH INVESTIGATION

O Drugs El Firearms O Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered (14?
O Toxicology ❑ Crime Scene O Lost Property V Trial 9- I,.
O Serology/DNA O Latent Prints O Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
DET. SAINT JEAN 8192 SID/CAC
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom

O Yes IZI No N/A
Photographed by & I.D. # N/A
Address where property recovered: 17253 30TH LN N, LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: DET. CHRISTOFEL 7/28/16 N/A N/A PESO

Owner: STATE OF FLORIDA
Victim: 17148 30TH LN N, LOX

Suspect(s) KRISTEN MEYER 10/3/73 W/F 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN 3/3/78 W/M 17148 30TH LN N, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value Description of Property
1 2 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS (SHAWN WARD)
2 1 $1 CD WITH PHOTO LINE UP PRESENTATIONS

Palm Beach Sheriff's Office
Case It 16-058738 Sub SI 019

11111 1111111 11111110
Pho o line up and instructions Shawn Ward)/ CD
I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property I hereby acknowledge trim. u C CLIVI/C UZI. I cy......,........ .... ,....., -.., -..,- - -. - - _ _ ,
taken from my possession and that I have received a copy of this me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or Eupport
- receipt.— - - — persormer as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

Print Name: Print Name:
'ET. B. CHRI OFFEL LD.# 9452 Div. SID

Signature: Signature:

Received By Reason Date & Time

—T'W--=''qr'44..—
- q A kLo C71.

DISTRICT SID/CAC PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 71 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PALM, UEAUM CAJUN I Y britKirr-b- urrIL.,=
PROPERTY RECEIPT I
LOC Number
it 1T-'r
Type Case
Date 0 Time , Zone
I I 1\1(elki-7
/ 1--'
0 Drugs F terirms CI Photo Lab LI Stolen - Recovered „1
1:11Hold for
0Toxicology „ ❑ Crime_ Scone LostProPerty 0 Trial
Forfeiture
0 Serology/DNA 01;atent Print ❑ Property of Deceased CI Destroy
Send ReportTo: -7,t4 Division: r
k 1 me,
Release After Procesting per .r.S.S. 90.91. 7 Yes N UT Wh o
Whom

Photographed by & I.D. # ip
Address Where Property Redovered: c/
c pct., t _);((
2
)•
Name D.O.B. Race/Sex .Askireis Phone

Discovered by An.
.P1
) le
Owner S k
Victim' if9ko f?,4,1dikir
Suspect(s) ihAc \ 4-1(10. f ,9

A k.)1114 11(,00'1 'i'V'l to

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property
I .
in ‘ Y.- .------- kl -f::
'd ( (74A I. ri'r': e•nj C .511 c tit)! Cie (.....()(
'7 .1.111._

,.-' \\11.i .1 ...,''''' -',(- 1 'I-1( ei'l t_ fer,,ov. 3 C Ili A-1 v..k.n v) (7ouvt-

_

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
pronsrtv taken from .mv nossession and that I have by mein the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
n Palm Beach Sheriff's Office Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Case i1 16-058738 Sub # 017
c , I A
\/:: i CI. I'
P Print Name: -• W. 4 , (1-) DIv. ...4-IN CA.
,
Medical records St. Lucie County Medical records / --,.(7 )
siu........... Signature: 11 -') /-; '-
'',..','_...f.'1 - .V1'11--
Received By Reason ,----- Date &Time

-,)',-e.,/
i '
) i+.-- , 1.- -A qi: h i„ / 57
'(-it"' .
...‘ A•• '-• , ..- "-Ii.,,,,,t- KV-1,3:- 11-k il 1 kV h Al j'i-,„Y (..' 1;74(t.r. C.,(ZL_ 1! ( tG j< S.(..
zr

-al .--
ANA/
L.1 (cell'? i-copV ,691c.57(WV
----- vr .8 it 1 /637
.Slai 31 i 1 •-11 .:, A 'E.\),A,z..,.1 v 1 -.' 1 04
kzi'a. : 4114‘ Kin R(.ik , 0&-z7,1(0 6-26
DISTRICT PAGE
OF
02/13/17 Page 72 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PEiS0 40149 REV. 01/08 ANALYSIS COPY
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PALM, BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE!
Date
, PROPERTY RECEIPT
Time Zone Type Case 4t
lb-05ff q3?'
LOC Number
211 POP 1630 /1 viii I
ri Hold for
0 Drugs 1:1 Firearms ❑ Photo Lab ID Stolen -
UToxicology LI Trial
6.1
U Crime Scene 0 Lost Property
Forfeiture
U Serology/DNA LI Latent Prints U Property of Deceased U Destroy
Send ReportTo: Division:

Release After Processing per F.S.S. 90. M CIA? Yes UT° Whom

Photographed by & I.D. #
Llf tNACT1VE
Address Where Property Recovered:
15 f 9tAta LAL.40(7 I iCt• IAA 1,0. L-. .» —t'-W
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex ' Address Phone
Discovered ve .--
. fitri(il /Ctle— (.4. LH 143
Owner SniCh F ---' 0 1,---Cb*
victim el 1.,„/ (B49114-10.k5g, _ AA___
Suspect(s) kA.4,,At Are 61 Ai d(t.((co 1 otk ey W p 0
It AA4-
ii
Altivtn clvo Al ern lin RIO f9 3I(4171< 1J( hi 4
I
Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property

L tfi,. ..------- Iti.esicrAL 6e eovaS r b
e 1.<,tcLcabi,),a-
I
d 0(4 _-- (y), r _teti cv L ei.ees042c tratat-1 //4 .1‹i.o Couvtt-j

Palm Beach Sheriff's Of ice
......_
Case * 16-058738 Sub * 017 if
11 11 1111 1 1 II 11 11111 1 11 11
\Medical records St. Lucie County/ Medical reoords

I hereby acknowledge tha the above list represents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
property taken from my possession and that I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
received a copy of this receipt. Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

Print Name: Print Name: 14. ,1 I.D.41. JAL Div._416

1.6e
Signature: Signature: el i f/9-.
Received By Reason ll. Date & Time

9C Sz.‘ qhfici, / .545—
6 tois6d-- 61-14_ 1)14-00,,plys ot(K&__ si((((c, 15,5g

INACTIVE
DISTRICT 02/13/17
(DAL ( Page 73
PAGE OF
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
I

PAM 40149 REV. 01/08
PX/Inpnir.P (-YIPV
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # P 0 CASE #
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Date
, - PROPERTY RECEIPT
Time l cs .5 Zone Type Case LOC Number
i Dc 1 7SS

tqS,3
1J Stolen -01-ec- o-
ID Drugs
CiToxicology
CI Firearms
LI Crime Scene
I:I Photo Lab
CI Lost Property •i •)
ID Hold for
Forfeiture
[:1 Serology/DNA LI Latent Prints Ca Property of Deceased Destroy
Send ReportTo: Division:
Fag ,sn/e4c/
Release After Processing per F.S.S. 90.91? ID Yes To Whom

Photographed by & I.D. #
Address Where Property Recovered:
CTIVE
112M f7 .?3(-/cL
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by Crt)(c4a eft. 4/ (43
Owner C-111-1-- gI
-
--- -rt,0 :1
- -l' (er
Victim ,70/''' Lpsn_c K Lol-A 1,1,c-1, Wip
,i ,
prteo,,,,hi giwk,
suspect(s) \,,6(v ..( h ,,,, k\
06-
NI-zj oinclir0 6evyi 14)7_, kt ( (Pk', 3/1cr(V W Vli (I AM

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Oty. Value Description of Property

1 c.
,s\ C- ------ r)/ledi 0 ili_ 6 uvd_s (Pwlwis (.J-kA Adpkt

I horesk r es nie ........1....1 ...... ....- —. a.._ _ I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
rents all
Palm Beach Sheri is Of ice I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
Case # 6-068738 Sub # 018 Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

1111 1 111 1 1 11 11 11 111 1111 .
Print Name: --(111 , Or I.D.#ML Div. 4c,fab
Medical records Rieman (Palms West Hospital)
/
Signature: Signature: rrC)-e-Q I 0 93-
Received By Reason Date &Time

k CYYThaf- E5--)7-11 6L6 I )
1 11Lotitn IL0Q0
) 5iP6 0€ Of tAri g(q, --T ,S, C. 4,6 kre(4(.,, S(( I (r,c ( l, I (tie;

MOTIVE
Public Records RequestfNo.: 17-058
02/13/17 Page 74
PAGE OF
PRSOit0149 REV. 01/08
FV11)PNICP CC)PY
OTHER AGENCY & CASE CASE *
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
PROPERTY RECEIPT
LOC Number
3
Date zone Type Case
1(& (1C2 Time 1C55 it-0 •Htinqn 4rice
❑ Drugs 0 Firearms °Photo Lab °Stolen - figiv1;;; )
°Toxicology Ci Crime Scene GI Lost Property
Ca Hold for
Forfeiture
I° Serology/DNA CI Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased
Send ReportTo: Division:
f 1q s1
-6/64c/
After Processing per F.S.S. 90.91?
Release After °Yes ❑ To Whom

Photographed by & I.D. #
1 Pc
Address Where Property Recovered:
A 9M 17. 33(./
Name ' Date D.O.B. Race/Sex . Address Phone

Discovered by CrD(C4C- 1'4' LI/ Li
Owner 0 .—:- ;#1-

Victim 10-(11 Leib:. Ni CL4.4" k Fk. Op_
Suspects) \,(,(vc h Av,,,,,,,t.,, 0 gp A 10149 3 c 1i
ia 'OIL_
rI
pitlitocko iliewl d ap((6 3/1c4V 14 vli QV it

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property

iV)6C.. ,/--.----- rrnedi eI 12) 0-69vci_s --r ( a Owl (P wt tdeg -App r1

rents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
Palm Beach Sheriff's off
Off ic
ice I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
Case # 16-058738 Sub # 018 Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

I

Medical records (Palms West Hospital)
--------C(I
Print Name: j-i I.D.# Div._sa

Signature: Signature: ,ri....-, '' / g 92-
Received By Reason Date & Time

C1—Trsr-NaJD
::: --f- \ 1 (._6. .811L,Aitc. Rnao
r)
)c . g19 ; --c0 ,S,0.0. -1,r rf,th't
k (,, I (,,c «, ((,,,,),
Yom., i. s .3 k€,-- I Co k 6(-1-f
'
SiNivi4,--- e\rvi c4 61)- . ITT R ,l bra NIL 104
DISTRICT 02/13/17 Page 75 Public Records
PAGE Request No.: 17-058
OF
OTHER AGENCY & L.:Abt if roo:
PALM, BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE!
PROPERTY RECEIPT (0
Date /
to, /oc
Tim Zon7
i..2.
Type Case LOC Number
HI
C
0 Drugs GI Firearms GI Photo Lab ecoveed C:11 Hold for
01Toxicology Crime Scene - -0 Lost Property - .-
Forfeiture
GI Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased
Send ReportTo: . -Division:

Release After Processing per F.S.S. Yes No CI To Whom

Photographed by & I D #

Address Where Property Recovered:
)Ac
il lg

In 0.1J7 Ads F. .23ce-40C,
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone

Discovered by
g(i (4 Ode e'r" 41/43
Owner LC) •

Victim C( [Za111 LNI taonirmidA-4"
I)
Suspect(s)14rIevx lypi ;therti I ice( (Oen
AO(
Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property

.1, 4. . ti, 141 _ - . A___.•
UM " IMMIIP 1 i' CAI(

ig
(1411111111
11 11111111._
1\111
WM
ME
I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
property taken from my possession and that I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
rer Palm Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Beach Sheriff's Office
Case # 6-058738
Sub # 021

Pr 11111 UR 111111111111 Print Name: .-be.A SI9:1417 I.D.# giqd—Div. Cf(VA.1

Miscellaneous papers search war awls f, cw St Luc .
Sly Signature: (:),,Q1 (1/1 t.--"P _1.----
Received By Reason i Date &Time

F).4 (tit\ 1 VS S 1m 61 lb OsS

_ • • .
DISTRICT <an/ me_
02/13/17 cri Page 76
PAGE
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
OF

PBS0.0149 REV. 01/08
finp Alr.F r.C1PY A
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Date
PROPERTY RECEIPT
' Timi ,cc Zone Type Case i 1
I lbOgg
LOC Number

01 Drugs
,.... ...
EI
DI Firearms
FI 2 .itrai ci riS2-
ID Photo Lab CI Stolen - Recovered
ktVt
1:11 Hold for
L7I Toxicology IZI Crime Scene ID Lost Property
.. Forfeiture
CI Serology/DNA L I Latent Prints "1:21 Property of Deceased estroy
I . .
Division:
Send ReportTo:
garh-L--
Release After Processing per F.S.S. •0.91?
-81"
Q Yes .. LTo Whom
Photographed by & # •
)(
Address Where Property- Recovered:

Name Date- D.O.B.- Race/Sex - Address.. Phone

Discovered by
SZ11(0 to '1-1L-L3
Owner

Victim
(A- Ui I'M 2 G04,Ateliest7E.Srlo
Suspect(s)
)91 ilieerof 0111. (9 V 1 gig
11
-Pik5mAeso -MeivYwh;? Saitop ICI
Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property

1
ma. Nk Ise_ ,,ears ,IP44-trch bilivv-AA,15 T---yo ?alms Uc-e-
-1-\-acp\-1004_

vs-7
--...miliiiir
of

— — -- — —

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
property taken from my possession and that I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
recel- • - - - --- — "'- ------- Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Palm Beach Sheri f's Off ce
Case # 6-058738 Sub # 020

Print 11 1 Print Name: IV y,....(67 I.D. # g 64Div. .....11)164

Miscel aneous papers search warrants from Palms L.
Sign: Signature: )67.f
Received By Reason ate & Time

aSO, 1 1 a sm bL \t,o \LP Oscc

DISTRICT 02/13/17 fl Page 77 Public Records OF
PAGE Request No.: 17-058

11111tICI FIFV ni/DR
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE'
PROPERTY RECEIPT
Zone Type Case
/
LOC Number
-fisr-93f
Date
q1,416
U Drugs
Timal to

U Firearms
//11Km
U Photo Lab U Stolen - Recovered
'VC
[a Hold for
CI Toxicology ❑Crime Scene CI Lost-Property - LI Trial- - - - -
Forfeiture
U Serology/DNA CI Latent Prints Frciporty of Deceased U Destroy
Send ReportTo: Division: SU /

Release After Proceising per F.S.S. 90.9 CI No ZIT° Whom

Photographed by & I.D. #
(Pf-
Address Where Property. Recovered:
?c24-1 v-t boegre,, 224 • —
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone

Discovered by ‘cpol---
Etrr ti43
glo)11110
Owner

Victim 1
suspect(s) kelproclifo qb-k(c6 IA 3
CqC rn-f47^r—Pik fra cf(9-116_ 10(S( 43 - 114-11-ii 301A, 1-44144614A-011- -33446 LK(

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Oty. Value Description of Property
r, p i /
li ,------- \\I • 'v)41..:4,t, aie-mx4-4
Il. a pi- tAMAA di) E CU (64-6 14
'
(0,S_

Vcc.,3"

AK

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
property taken from my possession and that I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
rec Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Palm Beach Sheriff's Off ce
Case # 6-058738 Sub # 022

Pri 1111 Print Name: )0'.;
4 i
II 1 III 4.41, I.D.# f gal Div._&46
1111
misc.ti.,er. 1 P r. S o evictio, 1 ,81 judgements
Sig. Signature:
Received By Reason Date & Time

t
23-.SCI\ rnU srn Qi 9 IlD \ ltio OSP)

DISTRICT 02/13/17 ONe Page 78 Public Records OF
PAGE Request No.: 17-058

DelCri 11111g0 RFU nirrut r— , oirs,k4e,r- r,NZ
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # I PBSO CASE #
PALM , BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
PROPERTY RECEIPT
LOC Number
6 --- D5342‘
Date Time, Zone
47)
Type Case
I ILIA `-( CL-C2 VW('
CI Drugs
01Toxicology
CI Firearms
LI Crime Scene
CI Photo Lab
CI Lost Property
CI Stolen - Recovered
CI Trial
Li Hold for
Forfeiture
1:1 Serology/DNA ID Latent. Prints ._ 121 Property of Deceased 1:1 Destroy
Send ReportTo: b ( Division:
e. g(c9
Release After Processing per F.S.S. 90.91? Yes CI No CiTo Whom

Photographed by & I.D. #

Address Where Property Recovered:
actin (PIA) -( in9e11.) -. 1-/-06,
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone

Discovered by scillvyk
., . 043
Owner cS—rk
Vic
Suspect(s) do prrem 13+) 6-0k,
QJIn 19114-1.-307.111419-1014Mb‘ AV
for- imp/ - OF

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property

\
tAiSt ,S ffrypict ..i60 -ep L OPIRPCIM

ri97

I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
property taken from my nriceraccinn eh vs A • 6...4 ' r,ve by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
receiv Palm Beach Sheriff's Office Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
Case * 6-058738 Sub # 023

Print N 111 I I111 II II I 1111 III 1 III I II I 0 Print Name: (.1 JA1 I.D. # (C Div. i1Ci
Subpoena for FPL (misc. papers)
Signatu._. Signature: I '. (161
IL 0
A' .. 1.••1•11k. .f
Received By Reason ate & Time

quo 1\0 .-
t(6/ 5, , 'l_
...sSb.i Silk (-)L Illb ()\t S; L
i4 , z.v T.Yil k2) fo c/ ?go i 55C

DISTRICT 02/13/17 Page 79 Public Records OF
PAGE Request No.: 17-058

Dliers11111A0 DPW 111
r- n‘x
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSOgAsg #
PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Date
PROPERTY RECEIPT
Zo n 7 12 Type Case LOC Number
615t1 )36
r-

cifaii(4, 1 140ki ° L 1-A kokr1
U Drugs
0 Toxicology
0 Firearms
❑ Crime Scene
U Photo Lab
0 Lost Property
0 Stolen - Recovered
(*Fria'
CI Hold for
Forfeiture
0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints - - 0 Property of Deceased 0 •Destroy
Send ReportTo: Division:

Release After Processing per F. . 9Q.91 ID Ye§ IP 0 1:3 To Whom
Photographed by & I.D. #

Address Where Property Recovered:
&kin &ICA Id rig 671):. 3 RAO (P
Name Date --•• D.O.B: • Race/Sex Address Phone

Discovered by 3rn
Owner

Victirr lf
a t_
wiry,
Suspect(s) n mem ple) tiA11141641-€A11179-
1(3-2,

I1
fYiew-Atentrol CAM
Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)

Item # Qty. Description of Property

r, VtraAvvi a(Axi.

Palm Beach Sheriff's Office
I hereb Case 8 6-058738 Sub 8 024 I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property Impounded
p ro ile r Hi 111 111 I 11 11111 1111 IIIIII by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
rece ve, Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.
III

seized items from f
I Inventory and return receipt
Print Name. Print Name: be4 iy1-7 1,-- .# yr 901- Div.Y.Zied9
Signature: Signature:
Received By Reason ? ate & Time

1 .t
,._ -)Mb (L -DC)5
.---
S S ti c( \qo osso
. w-ii.LP-2)A ..e, ict)(y.e4-ci ottoric. 1 t5c,

DISTRICT 02/13/17 Page 80 PAGE Request No.: 17-058
Public Records OF

PBSO#0149 REV.01/08
=N/IIIMVPF nropv
OTHER AGENCY & CASE # , PBS() CASE #
PALM BEACH COUNTY SFIERIFF'S OFFIC'
..._)- PROPERTY RECEIPT I /arr. OS0'38
Date (/11 3 )1 ( Time )11 to Zone fri A Type Case d 4_0cNtler
0 mail (ti e 4 ( ii
Ca Dr gs CI Firearms 0 Photo Lab ID Stolen - Recovered
[:1 Hold for
UToxicology CI Crime Scene 0 Lost Property terrial
Forfeiture
0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased Destroy
Send Report To:
rL
Release After Processing per F.S.S. 90.9
Division:

❑ Yes
Via CliToWhom

Photographed by & I.D. #

Address Where Property Recovered: cp A
4go4-6 coLVA-P tA VA. torVal 4.6.
Name Date D 0 B Race/Sex Address Phone
GC
Discovered by Sit)tf*
11311(0
Owner 6
vic Lhi Lo.N.43.4aluifqn —
Suspect(s) ipv•Aev
, 10131'13 Li (niuk 20h belt to)1.04,46,T24 3340 99)-6(95
Lf4r;
1-\t.c)oneo vA.r) 113( t Why) (gig' 3M-thittivAkthil‘g°'''
Type of Analysis Requested (ankh Cilibel.ab Inforinatioff Rift)

Item # Qty. Value Description of Property

--- di Nbs v-P `,tm I AA to ' i

Palm Beach Sheriff's Office )sents all I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property impounded
Case * 6-058738 Sub * 025 3t I have by me in the official performance of duty as a Law Enforcement Officer or
Support Personnel as defined in F.S.S. 943.10.

11101111 111 II 111 31111111H NA e,
5 CPT dvds of Aleman children interviews . Print Name: ut---t Sm'n-L-- I.D.#A19_,XDiv.We

Signature: Signature: k _....t
Received By Reason Date & Time

•i41, ',14 9 gL,t() 141q cnni3L 09 1(6 IA 0-130

DISTRICT 02/13/17 ne Page 81 Public Records
PAGE Request No.: 17-058
OF

ROCA nn1AO DRI 111MR •—• •-••-sr-ssx
PALM 13EACii COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE OTHER AGENCY & CASE # PBSO CASE #
16 - 058738
PROPERTY RECEIPT
Date Time Zone Type Case LOC Number
9/13/16 1550 15-11 DEATH INVESTIGATION g a)ia
0 Drugs 0 Firearms 0 Photo Lab 0 Stolen - Recovered

0 Toxicology 0 Crime Scene 0 Lost Property 6Q Trial

0 Serology/DNA 0 Latent Prints 0 Property of Deceased 0 Destroy
Send report to: Division
DET. SAINT JEAN 8192 SID/CAC
Release after processing per F.S.S. 90.017 To Whom

0 Yes EZI No N/A
Photographed by & I.D. # N/A
Address where property recovered: 3228 GUN CLUB RD, WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406
Name Date D.O.B. Race/Sex Address Phone
Discovered by: DET. CHRISTOFFEL 7/28/16 N/A N/A PBSO
Owner: STATE OF FLORIDA
Victim: 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
Suspect(s) KRISTEN MEYER 10/3/73 W/F 17148 30TH LN N, LOX
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN 3/3/78 W/M 17148 30TH LN N, LOX

Type of Analysis Requested (attach Crime Lab Information Form)
Item # Qty- Value . Description of Property
1 1 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS
2 1 $1 PHOTO LINE UP AND INSTRUCTIONS (
3 - 1 $1 CD WITH PHOTO LINE UP PRESENTATIONS

. .. . _. _
I hr ' ' I hereby acknowledge that the above list represents all property Impounded by
- tal Palm Beach -Sheriff . s Office - mein-the official performance-of duty as a Law Enforcement-Officer-or Support
re( Case # 6-058738 Sub # 026 Personnel as definedin F.S.S. 943.10.
DET B . #11 iTO 0 I.D. 9452 Div. SID
Prl
it I II II it 111111111 11
Print Name:
e 01..
i

Sic. Photo 1 ne up and instructions (Jeass ieca I_Signature: ' 'I
P"

Received By Reason Date & Time

j3 k.
. 51-n.6(___ q hit(,. c,..

DISTRICT SID/CAC PAGE 1 OF 1

PBSO #0149 REV 7/98

02/13/17 Page 82 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
ga
.Cit e PHOTO ARRAY / WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Case #:
Witness Name: 1161 WV) ni

Administrator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
5Gtx• 1. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.

Sa-) 2. The person of interest mayor may not be in this photo array and the photos are not

in any particular order.

560 3. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.
SGV 4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.
52.d 5. Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on

the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject

to change.

6. It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to

identify the perpetrator.

`5-4-1 7. The investigation will continue whether or not an identification is made.
SC4-1 8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial
and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.

"S-c.` 9. Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup

or the results.
5 C.A.)
10. Please open the folder and review the photo array.

1, SA aciA) r hereby acknowledge that the above
(Please Print)

instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array

procedure will be administered.

Witness signature Admi ator signature

Date/T me
02/13/17 Page 83 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up
7/28/2016

1 2

5 6
16-058738
02/13/17 Page 84 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Im

2 3

4 5 6
16-058738
02/13/17 Page 85 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
onire PHOTO ARRAY / WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Case #:
Witness Name:
Date/Time:

Administrator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
45E3 1. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.
2. The person of interest mayor may not be in this photo array and the photos are not

in any particular order.

..151 3. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.

4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.

5. Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on

the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject

to change.

try 6. It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to

identify the perpetrator.

7. The investigation will continue whether or not an identification is made.

8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial

and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.

ZC
- On. 9. Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup

or the results.

10. Please open the folder and review the photo array.

ht--:YAIL) hereby acknowledge that the above
(Please Print)

instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array

procedure will be administered.

Witness signature Admin strator signature

7-2 8-1 7 (/ 3 1"/&_ [co 1 :Ci3e0nil
Date/Time Date/T me

02/13/17
PRRO tinnoR RFV 06/13
Page 86 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
86
Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016

1 3

6
16-058738
02/13/17 Page 87 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016 1C)

1 2

5

16-058738
02/13/17 Page 88 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
sAcii PHOTO ARRAY / WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Case #: / OEV3?
Witness Name: L-1/(Pe
Date/Time: / 2-C3/ / I CI 3q

Administrator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
1. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.
The person of interest mayor may not be in this photo array and the photos are not
in any particular order.
. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.
4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.
. Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on
the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject
to change.
It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to
identify the perpetrator.
. The investigation will continue whether or not an identification is made.
8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial
and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.
9. Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup
or the results.
Please open the folder and review the photo array.

ZAk,, Atd\ hereby acknowledge that the above
(Please Print)

instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array
procedure will be administered.

ness signature Ad rator signature

3 i fry
D te/T' e

02/13/17 Page 89 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016`-)-

1

4

16-058738
02/13/17 Page 90 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016 C3'

4

16-058738
02/13/17 Page 91 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
sAcricoz,. PHOTO ARRAY / WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Case #: 1 (0 —6 588e
Witness Name:)); r\ `O od

Date/Time: g i3 ko 1550 '
-u'llAFF'S 0
Administrator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
c:9171. 1. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.

ain. 2. The person of interest may or may not be in this photo array and the photos are

not in any particular order.
4.P1, 3. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.

71- 4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.
obi 5 Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on

the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject to

change.
o 6 It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to

identify the perpetrator.

7. The investigation will continue whether or not an identification is made.
(9)/11 8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial

and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.

cJilik 9. After viewing all the photographs, if you cannot make a positive identification, you

may, if you wish, inform me of any photograph that you believe most resembles the

person you saw.
eta 10. Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup

or the results.
Otht 11. Please open the folder and review the photo array.

1,CEse r:Ot_ hereby acknowledge that the above
(Plea e Print
instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array

procedure will be administered.

J Gtt.67,
ness signature Admi i sig ature

q \e2) \ ;CN -
Date
02/13/17me Page 92 Date/Ti 1
t Public Records Request No.: 17-058
9m2
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up
7/28/2016

1 2 3

6

02/13/17 Page 93 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016

1 3

6
16-058738
02/13/17 Page 94 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
sital PHOTO ARRAY / WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Case #: 05813%
Witnesi Name:

Date/Time:
Tap
'q
Let+1
3 1 J (4 155
'<r411P10 S 0
Administrator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
17/ 1. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.

17/ 2. The person of interest may or may not be in this photo array and the photos are
not in any particular order.

3. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.

lir 4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.

5. Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on

the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject to

change.

91 6. It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to
identify the perpetrator.
continue whether or not an identification is made.
7. The investigationwill'

8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial

and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.

9. After viewing all the photographs, if you cannot make a positive identification, you

may, if you wish, inform me of any photograph that you believe most resembles the

person you saw.
1/ 10. Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup

or the results.

I/ 11. Please open the folder and review the photo array.

I, LeHI(Please Print)
hereby acknoWledge that the above

instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array

procedure wyll be administered.

itness signature Admi stator sig re

11311(p 51PAil RI 3) 5,61 pro
Date/Time DateiTim
02/13/17 Page 95 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
9S
Public Records Request No.: 17-058 Page 96 02/13/17
SEL80-9I
9
-17
910Z/8Z/L
do-
euTI 9vageo0 ;MINS Auno0 gm% 1RM
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016

1 2 3

4 6

16-058738
02/13/17 Page 97 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
cu PHOTO ARRAY /'WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Witness Name:
Date/Time:

strator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
1. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.

2. The person of interest mayor may not be in this photo array and the photos are not

in any particular order.

3. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.

4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.

5. Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on

the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject

to change.

6. It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to

identify the perpetrator.

7. The investigation will continue whether or not an identification is made.

8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial

and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.

9. Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup

or the results.

10. Please open the folder and review the photo array.

iaKtdco ear (Ka hereby acknowledge that the above
(Please P nt)

instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array

e administered.

Adminis • nature

' °21rsif
Date/Time Date/Ti e

02/13/17 Page 98 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
pacri ttnnnA RFV 06/13
Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016

I cc

1

4

02/13/17
16-058738 Page 99 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
r ,1 agetu 30 0 s 'Jag Aiuno one

Ni
01
F•A

00

00

02/13/17 Page 100 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
tos Awn PHOTO ARRAY / WITNESS INSTRUCTIONS

Adm' istrator: READ ALOUD AND INITIAL BEFORE SHOWING PHOTO ARRAY
. You will be asked to view a group of photos of individuals.

2. The person of interest mayor may not be in this photo array and the photos are not

in any particular order.

. You should not feel that you have to make an identification.

4. Take as much time as you need to look at each photograph.

5. Individuals presented in these photographs may not appear exactly as they did on

the date of the incident because features such as head and facial hair are subject

to change.

/17
6. It is just as important to exclude innocent persons from suspicion as it is to

identify the perpetrator.

1/(A. The investigation will continue whether or not an identification is made.

8. After viewing all the photographs, if you can make an identification, please initial

and date the photograph of the person you have identified and close the folder.

/fr9• Since this is an ongoing investigation, you should not discuss this photo lineup
or the results.

r0. Please open the folder and review the photo array.
tr45 /2444A/ ,J /2' hereby acknowledge that the above
(Please Print)

instructions have been read aloud to me and that I understand how this Photo Array

procedure will be administered.

fitness s natur Ad stra r signature

2__Viih
Date/Ti ate !
Dme

02/13/17 Page 101 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
/0
I-4
41i
cn
a
co
1-4

00

02/13/17 Page 102 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
()

Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Image Line-up 7/28/2016

3

6

16-058738
02/13/17 Page 103 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
IN THE CIRCUIT/COUNTY COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA

AFFIDAVIT AND APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT

THE STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH

COMES NOW, Detective Usbaldo Lara Jr., herein after referred to as "Affiant," who being first
duly sworn, deposes and says that he/she has probable cause to believe that a certain premises
located in PALM BEACH County, Florida, described as: 17148 30th Lane N , Loxahatchee, FL,
33470.

To arrive at the said location,

From US-98/Southern Blvd and Kirk Rd: Follow US-98 Southern Blvd west for 12.7 miles and
turn right (northbound) onto Seminole Pratt Whitney Rd. Follow Seminole Pratt Whitney Rd for
1.6 miles and turn left (westbound) onto Okeechobee Blvd. Follow Okeechobee Blvd for 0.3
miles and turn right (northbound) onto Cheetham Hill Blvd. Follow Cheetham Hill Blvd for 1.2
miles and turn left.(westbound) onto 30th Lane N. Continue on 30th Lane N for 0.2 miles and
destination will be on left (south side of 30th Lane N).

The target residence is a single family residence, predominantly yellow with white trim around
the windows. The numerical address of the target residence consists of gold numbers, 17148, and
is clearly visible from the north side of the property above the white garage door facing 30th
Lane North.

Herein after referred to as the "Premises"

Being the premises of, or occupied by, or under the control of:

Kristen Meyer, W/F, 10/03/1973, SS#

Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Agency Name: Palm Beach County Sheriffs Warrant No.: PBSO_2016_000377
Office
Agency Case No.: 16-058738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 104 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
/0q
Alejandro Aleman, W/M, 03/03/1978,

Now has certain property contained therein, to wit:

• Nutritional items such infant formula, toddler formula, milk,
bottles, baby food, diapers, and similar well-being items.
• Photographs of residence interior to document current living
conditions.

Herein after referred to as "Property,"

That constitutes evidence relevant to proving that a felony has been committed, to wit:

1 Count of 782.07(3)--Aggravated Manslaughter of a Child-- (FELONY)

The facts establishing Affiant's basis for probable cause that the Property sought constitutes
evidence of a weapon, instrumentality, or means by which a felony has been committed or
constitutes evidence relevant to proving that a felony has been committed, and that such Property
is located in or on the above described Premises are as follows:

Your Affiant, Detective Usbaldo Lara Jr, is a duly appointed Deputy Sheriff for Pahn Beach
County, and has all the powers of a law enforcement officer in and for Palm Beach County,
Florida. Your Affiant, Detective Usbaldo Lara Jr, has been employed with the Palm Beach
County Sheriffs Office continuously since March 2007. Your Affiant is registered with and
certified by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Criminal Justice Standards and
Training Commission. Your Affiant served more than five years as a road patrol officer, in the
District 7 West Boca Raton community of the Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office. During Your
Affiant's tenure in road patrol, he investigated crimes related but not limited to narcotics,
Page 2 of 7 Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Agency Name: Palm Beach County Sheriffs Warrant No.: PBS0_2016_000377
Office
Agency Case No.: 16-058738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 105 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
assaults, domestic related incidents, thefts, frauds, child abuse, and other general assignment
cases. Currently, Your Affiant is assigned to the Special Investigation Division of the Palm
Beach County Sheriff's Office as a detective. As a Detective assigned to this unit, Your Affiant
is responsible for investigating crimes against children, sex crimes, crimes against the elderly,
missing persons, child abuse, and child deaths. Your Affiant has also completed numerous hours
of training related to law enforcement including but not limited to, traffic speed enforcement,
interview and interrogations, and crimes against children.

On March 31, 2016, at approximately 18:48 hours, the Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office
responded to 17148 30th Ln North in Loxahatchee, Florida, in reference to a one year old who
was unresponsive. The one year old was later identified as Taylor Aleman. It was reported the
mother of Taylor, Kristen Meyer, was the complainant who contacted emergency services. It
should be mentioned the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office communications department noted
in the call that Kristen was attempting CPR on the child. That being said, it was also noted
Kristen was not performing CPR properly as she was hesitant to listen to the CPR instructions
given to her by the call taker. At approximately 18:56 hours, Palm Beach County Fire Rescue
arrived at the residence. Shortly thereafter, Taylor was transported to Palms West Hospital
located at 13001 Southern Blvd in Loxahatchee, Florida, for further medical intervention. Dr.
Jaime Estrada and Palms West Hospital medical staff provided medical treatment however the
child, Taylor Aleman, was declared deceased at 19:26 hours. Your Affiant spoke with Dr.
Estrada who stated the child was extremely malnourished, had severe excoriation on her genitals
and buttocks, and also noted a contusion around her left eye. Dr. Estrada also mentioned the
child's current weight was measured at approximately 7 lbs. Dr. Estrada also mentioned the
medical staff spoke with Kristen who reportedly stated her child, Taylor, has not been seen by a
pediatrician in several months. Dr. Estrada said it his professional opinion, it appeared as if the
child's death was caused due to neglect and extreme malnourishment. Detective Saint-Jean
#8192 spoke with Kristen who stated she was feeding Taylor at approximately 18:24 hours.
Kristen said while feeding Taylor the child passed out and stopped breathing. Kristen said she
contacted emergency services afterwards. Detective Saint-Jean asked Kristen about
abnormal weight however she was unable to provide an adequate response. Detective Saint-Jean
asked Kristen about the child's daily eating habits which she replied the child eats approximately
8-9 ounces of Similac infant formula or milk, every 3-4 hours. Detective Saint-Jean also asked
Kristen about the excoriation on her genitals and buttocks (rash) which Kristen replied she
noticed the "minor rash" yesterday and believes it was caused by giving her child "juice" to
drink. Kristen was also asked when was the last time the child was taken to the pediatrician and
Kristen stated it was sometime during December 2015. Detective Saint-Jean asked Kristen if the
child had any known medical conditions which she stated no. Based on your affiant's
investigation at this point in time, as well as your affiant's training and experience, there is a
significant likelihood that nutritional items such infant formula, toddler formula, milk, bottles,
baby food, and similar well-being items or lack thereof corroborating the child's
malnourishment, are presently located at the mentioned residence. Furthermore, recovery of said
items would assist greatly with the investigation and ultimately successful prosecution of Kristen
Meyer and Alejandro Aleman.

Page 3 of 7 Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Agency Name: Palm Beach County Sheriffs Warrant No.: PBS0_2016_000377
Office
Agency Case No.: 16-058738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 106 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
to g
WHEREFORE, Affiant makes this affidavit and prays that a search warrant be issued
commanding the Sheriff of PALM BEACH County, Florida, and all of his deputies, any police
officer in PALM BEACH County, Florida, within whose jurisdiction the aforesaid Property to be
searched is found, the Commissioner of the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, and any of
his duly constituted Agents, with proper and necessary assistance, to search the premises and all
of its spaces where the Property might be kept for the Property specified and any person thereon
reasonably believed to be connected with the illegal activity; making the search in the daytime or
the nighttime, as the exigencies may demand or require, or on Sunday, and to bring the property
and any person arrested before a court having jurisdiction of the offense.

lisbaldolaral
DetectiV'e Usbaldo Lara Jr. (1.D. #1 8679)
2 April 2016 02:24:00

The foregoing Affidavit and Application for Search Warrant was sworn to (or affirmed) and
subscribed before me this 2 day of April, 2016.

Sergeaii Eric P Keith
Ex-Officio/Notary (Lg.# 6231)
2 April 2016 02:25;00
Law Enforcement Officer Authorized to Administer Oaths under F.S. 117.10.

Page 4 of 7 Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Agency Name: Palm Beach County Sheriffs Warrant No.: PBS0_2016_000377
Office
Agency Case No.: 16-058738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 107 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
To?
IN THE COUNTY/CIRCUIT COURT
OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA

SEARCH WARRANT

THE STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH

IN THE NAME OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, TO ALL AND SINGULAR:

The Sheriff of PALM BEACH County, Florida, and the Sheriffs deputies, any police officer in
PALM BEACH County, Florida, within whose jurisdiction the Property to be searched is found,
and the Commissioner of the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, and any of his duly
constituted Agents.

WHEREAS, a complaint on oath and in writing, supported by affidavit of a credible witness has
this day been presented to me, and upon examination of the affidavit and application for this
search warrant, I am satisfied that probable cause exists that the Premises located in PALM
BEACH County, Florida described as: 17148 30th Lane N , Loxahatchee, FL, 33470.

From US-98/Southern Blvd and Kirk Rd: Follow US-98 Southern Blvd west for 12.7 miles and
turn right (northbound) onto Seminole Pratt Whitney Rd. Follow Seminole Pratt Whitney Rd for
1.6 miles and turn left (westbound) onto Okeechobee Blvd. Follow Okeechobee Blvd for 0.3
miles and turn right (northbound) onto Cheetham Hill Blvd. Follow Cheetham Hill Blvd for 1.2
miles and turn left.(westbound) onto 30th Lane N. Continue on 30th Lane N for 0.2 miles and
destination will be on left (south side of 30th Lane N).

The target residence is a single family residence, predominantly yellow with white trim around
the windows. The numerical address of the target residence consists of gold numbers, 17148, and
is clearly visible from the north side of the property above the white garage door facing 30th
Lane North.

Herein after referred to as the "Premises",

Being the Premises of, or occupied by, or under the control of:

Kristen Meyer, W/F, 10/03/1973, DL: SS#

Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Warrant No.: PBSO 2016 000377

58738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 108 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
0
Alejandro Aleman, W/M, 03/03/1978, DL: SS#

Now has certain Property contained therein, particularly described as:

• Nutritional items such infant formula, toddler formula, milk,
bottles, baby food, diapers, and similar well-being items.
• Photographs of residence interior to document current living
conditions.

Herein after referred to as "Property,"

which constitutes evidence relevant to proving that a felony has been committed, to wit:

1 Count of 782.07(3)--Aggravated Manslaughter of a Child-- (FELONY)

NOW THEREFORE, the Sheriff of PALM BEACH County, Florida, and all of his deputies, any
police officer in PALM BEACH County, Florida within whose jurisdiction the aforesaid
Property to be searched is found, the Commissioner of the Florida Department of Law
Enforcement, and any of his duly constituted Agents, are hereby commanded with lawful and
proper assistance as may be necessary in the name of the State of Florida, to enter and search the
Premises hereinbefore specified and all of its spaces where the Property might be kept and any
person thereon reasonably believed to be connected with the illegal activity; making the search in
the daytime or the nighttime, as the exigencies may demand or require, or on Sunday, and if the

Page 6 of 7 Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Agency Name: Palm Beach County Sheriffs Warrant No.: PBSO 2016 000377
Office
Agency Case No.: 16-058738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 109 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
log
Property is found there, to seize it, arrest all persons unlawfully possessing it, and to bring the
same before a court of competent jurisdiction.

You are further commanded, in the event that you seize any of the said Property hereinbefore
described, to make up, at the time and place of seizure, a full, true and itemized list and inventory
of all things seized and taken, in duplicate, signed by you, and to then and there give and deliver
the said duplicate copy thereof to the person from whom possession shall be taken, if taken from
the possession of anyone, together with a duplicate copy of this warrant, and if not taken from
the possession of anyone, then to any person in charge of said Premises and in the absence of any
such person, to leave the same on or in the Premises.

The original of the warrant, together with the original inventory, shall be returned and filed with
the Clerk of the Court as stated above within ten (10) days of the issuance of this warrant.
Further, any Property seized or taken shall be impounded for use as evidence at any trial of any
criminal or penal cause growing out of any subject having or possession of said Property.

WITNESS MY HAND AND SEAL this 2 of April in the year 2016.

Niariin
sil • ct
••••, •-••*

••••

Z4V • ''S•••

Martinli Colin
15TH Judicial Circuit
In and for PALM BEACI4 'County, Florida
2 April 2016 02:33:32

Page 7 of 7 Saturday, April 02, 2016
02:33:32

Agency Name: Palm Beach County Sheriffs Warrant No.: PBSO 2016 000377
Office
Agency Case No.: 16-058738 Reviewing Prosecutor:Lauren Godden

02/13/17 Page 110 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
110
INVENTORY AND RETURN
STATE OF FLORIDA S.

COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
ncl
Received this search warrant, Palm Beach County, Florida, this day of
Served the Same by reading and delivering a copy to tper8A(0 1 e—vit())-1()
\4,(C-\a/tr)

and making
making search as directed; upon which search I found:

bostA/te. oom clue_
kAav-eyi.k-t atAoie-e_, 40051 --Samt14 OU n S
e_ev-..t\kje- ev- VIS ciefAcryllCf‘,)
skrye_ci,k,A,'( r2)Ac

k (4_ the officer by whom this warrant was
executed, do swear that the above inventory contains a true and detailed account of all the property taken by me under the
authority of this warrant.
Sworn to and subscribed before me
‘na -
this a day of 1‘-- r, OI \,c) OFFI GNATURE - I.D. #

11101.11 111r
-

.—dg h
N u bticIC Anf Court 0 er (F.S.S. 11 Page of
NOTE: e original Search Warrant, original affidavit, and the inventory and return must be filed with the Clerk of the Court
as stated in the Search Warrant within ten (10) days of the date of issuance of the warrant.

WHITE - Clerk of The Court CANARY - State Attorney PINK - File GOLD - Originating Officer
PBSO #014502/13/17
REV 04/94 Page 111 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
11
Palm Beach County Activity #: Al 6-004620.1

Animal Care and Control
Case Report
Complainant Defendant
DISPATCH PBSO KRISTEN ALEMAN
3228 GUN CLUB RD 17148 30TH LN
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406 LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
561.688.3400 / 561.242.5800 772.475.4478

Animal
i ID: A1821369 Breed: AMER BULLDOG Sex: M

Name: ACHILLES Color: WHITE / BRINDLE Age: 2 YEARS

Activity Type: POLICE AGENCY EMERG. ASSISTANCE (1914)

Location: Loxahatchee

Arrival Date/Time: 4/2/2016 3:35:00 AM Complete Date/Time: 4/2/2016 4:45:00 AM

Report Narrative:

On 4/2/2016, 3:35 a.m., I responded to 17148 30th Lane North Loxahatchee, Fl 33470 in reference to a
police assistance investigation. The Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office dispatch center requested I respond to
the address noted above in reference to several residents being removed from the home. It was reported that
two dogs were inside the home and may need to be removed due to lack of care.
Upon arrival I met with Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Crime Scene investigator Brandt ID # 4169 (Case
number 16-058738) along with several other police detectives and deputy sheriffs. I was advised that a search
warrant had been executed and nine children had been removed from the occupancy including one who was
deceased. The residents Alejandro and Kristen Aleman were currently under investigation but were not being
arrested at that time. Escorted by Brandt I entered the residence in order to observe the dog in question. Upon
entering I detected a strong odor of urine. I located the dog inside a bedroom adjacent to the living room. Inside
was a white and brindle intact male American Bulldog wearing a black nylon collar. The dog was confined to a
wire dog kennel with the dimensions of 24 inches wide by 24 inches tall by 36 inches long. The dog appeared to
be malnourished and thin scoring a 3 on the TACC scale with one being ideal body weight and five being
emaciated. The bottom of the cage appeared to be almost completely covered with what appeared to be a
buildup of compacted dog feces. There was a double bowl inside as well but it had no contents. I took twenty
photographs of the dog in the kennel as well as the front of the home and the living room. I noticed an empty bag
of dry dog food leaned up against the living room wall adjacent to two dog bowls, one empty and one half full of
water. One of the deputies on scene advised that there was a second dog on the property but it had been
removed by one of the owners. Brandt advised that she searched the home and was unable to locate and dog
food and hardly any human food as well. At that time I contacted Animal Control Special Investigations
Supervisor Lt. Misti Scaggs and explained to her the situation. The decision was made to seize the dog due to it
living conditions and negative health. I removed the dog from the crate with the use of a catch pole as it was
growling at me and appeared fearful. Once removed, I noticed the dog had sores on its paw and leg. I took
seventeen photographs of the kennel after removing the dog. Upon further inspection, I pried large sections of
the compacted feces from the floor of the cage up to about two inches thick. I kept one such chunk for evidence.
Inside the cage I also found a ketchup package and a C battery. I completed a yellow official notice with case
and contact information on it land left it on top of the dog cage. Upon leaving the scene I briefly met with resident
Alejandro Aleman who was standing down the street. He stated the dog named Achilles had been rescued and
was in him and his wife's custody for about two weeks. I explained to him I left all my information on a card on
the dogs kennel and the dog will be kept at Animal Control for further investigation. I also advised an investigator

Activity #: A16-004620.1 Page 1 of 2 Officer ID: COOK - 2133

02/13/17 Page 112 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
with Animal Control will be in contact with him in the near future. Upon arrival Back to Animal Control I took two
more photographs of the two sores I noticed on the dog earlier. It should be noted that the dog urinated in the
cage I had him confined to and the dog drank his own urine. Upon feeding the dog it rapidly consumed the food.
This activity was closed with one report, one seize, 39 photographs and one respond to scene. No recheck set
at this time.

Officer C. Cook 2133.

Activity #: A16-004620.1 Page 2 of 2 Officer ID: COOK - 2133

02/13/17 Page 113 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
I li
A16 -outli,x
/44 •-•

`ailinv----Fi9F insairimmorim
Ailiwnezz,
AuxIr t II s'-=7,
-.1-1v
HIM cm imisiareozz=s=!: -
..oraja
ti111111L;€911:131•111
'.?.-11•11ElijW_:;_1:__ 7.171-4
=MR

,4 4Si 1. _1

02/13/17 Page 114 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
N.:15d1
• „? • • i14).
••• •••••-•- , •
1,
4.3.-.01•11:40.14.!ea.-- avers (i",- lige:

"frafr414,47,*

02/13/17 Page 115 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
1_5
91 /1

02/13/17 Page 116 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
02/13/17 Page 117 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
I17
?'''
K--,
,
• ...........,..

02/13/17 Page 118 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
CERTIFICATION OF CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS OF REGULARLY CONDUCTED BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
Pursuant to Fla. Stat. §90.803(6)(a) & (c), § 90.902(11), § 92.60(2), and/or§ 92.605(5)

The undersigned declarant hereby declares, certifies, verifies or states the following:

I, HALINE HAUBER, am a duly authorized officer and/or custodian of records for Florida Power & Light
Company, with authority to execute this affidavit and to certify to the authenticity and accuracy of
the records of regularly conducted business activities which are the subject of this certification.

The records produced herewith, and described below, are original documents or are true copies of
records of a regularly conducted business activity that:

Were made at or near the time of the occurrence of the matters set forth by, or from the information
transmitted by, a person having knowledge of those matters;
Were kept in the course of the regularly conducted business activity; and
Were made as a regular practice in the course of the regularly conducted business activity.
The total number of pages produced is 25 pages. The records provided are described as follows:

Subpoena response re: 17148 30th Ln. N. Loxahatchee Fl.

I declare under penalty of perjury of the State or country in which this certification is made that the
foregoing is true and correct.

September 2, 2016
HALINE HAUBER Date

Before me, the undersigned authority, personally appeared HALINE HAUBER, who, being by me first
duly sworn deposes and says that this certification is true and correct. The foregoing instrument was
acknowledged under oath before me this fd day of September, 2016, by the individual whose name
and signature appear above, and who [X ] is personally known to me, or [ ] produced the following
identification

September 2, 2016
Notary Pub Date

State of Florida
County of Palm Beach

*0:0'44\ INES GUZMAN
Notary Public - State of Florida
-E
Commission # FF 973869
My Comm. Expires Mar 22..2020

02/13/17 Page 119 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
71_
GMPH PREMISE/CUST HISTORY INQ PREMISE/CUST HISTORY 08/31/16 15:00:58
01916-92276 42 14 526 ELE ACT 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
VICTOR HIJUELOS PH (516)652-9239 S
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX. A1LN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 P
CUSTOMER NAME C.A.R. HOW ACCT DEP
IN DATE OUT DATE SSNJTAX ID BALANCE BILL ACCT LEFT STAT TYPE
05/06/16 VICTOR HIJUELOS 01916-92276 ON ACT DW

07/28/15 05/06/16 ALEJANDRO ALEMAN 86722-28080 ON FBL WP

06/01/11 07/26/15 TATIANA RAMIREZ REGO 40025-20411 ON UAR PP

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
BOTTOM OF LIST
NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 120 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
37(
GMBA BILL ACCOUNT MAINTENANCE 08/31/16 15:01:42
01916-92276 42 14 526 ELE ACT 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
VICTOR HIJUELOS PH (516)652-9239 S
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX A1LN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 P
BILL ACCT OPEN DT 05/06/16 TRFR/PREV BILL ACCT OPEN DTE 05/06/16
TYPE EFFECTIVE DT 08/31/16 ADDR ACTION (A,C,D)
MAIL ADDRESS ALWAYS SEND ENVELOPE

CITY STATE ZIP F BILL MESSAGE N
SEASONAL BEG END E-MAIL BILL ENROLLED 05/05/16
E-MAIL ACTION (A,C,D) INTERNET ACCESS? Y
E-MAIL ADDR VHIJUELOS@HOTMAIL.COM
FRIENDLY REMINDER N SUSPEND ESTIMATE (TEMP) N
62. PLUS PLAN 0 SUSPEND ESTIMATE (PERM) N
WAIVE LATE PYMT CD _ DT EFF PROMOTIONAL LIT CODE 0
REQUEST BY CONTACT PHONE
BILL ACCT PHONE 516 652-9239 OTHER PHONE N/A
ISSUE RMKS
VOID PEND B/ACCT DM IN ERROR N CM IN ERROR N CC Y (Y/N)
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
USE SUPER WINDOWS TO UPDT MAIL ADDR
20-ADDRESS INQ 22-PREM MAINT 23-OUST MAINT NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 121
37
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
BIHI BILLING HISTORY 08/31/16 15:01:45
01916-92276 42 14 526 ELE ACT 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
VICTOR HIJUELOS PH (516)652-9239 S
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 P
CC N (Y/N) RQST BY PAGE 1 OF 1
S SVC DT RM DYS T S BILL KWH KWD ELE AMT BB AMT TOT BILL AMT
_ 08/22/16 8 32 A B 1259 0 135.22 0.00 135.22
07/21/16 7 31 A B 1639 0 181.01 0.00 181.01
06/20116 6 32 A B 1284 0 138.26 0.00 212.76
05/19/16 5 13 A B 542 0 54.62 0.00 69.50

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
COMPLETE LIST
13-MRDG HIST 16-BUS BRKDWN 17-HI BILL 18-READ/VERIFY NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 122 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
36X
PYMT PAYMENT/CREDIT MAINT '08/31/16 15:01:47
01916-92276 42 14 526 ELE ACT 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
VICTOR HIJUELOS PH (516)652-9239 S
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 P
PAGE 1 OF 1
PMT
PAYMENT/CREDIT BATCH SEQ POST PMT TDR EXCR EX CREDIT
SEL DATE SRCE LOC AMOUNT NO NO CODE TYPE TYP TYPE AMOUNT
08/01/16 PYMT 928 181.01 00 POL
06/22/16 PYMT 928 212.76 00 POL

RQST BY CUSTOMER CONTACT N (Y/N)
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
COMPLETE LIST
17-CR/PMT REAP 18-CR/PMT IRAN NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 123 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

3Ce7
POLU PAY ONLINE PAY ONLINE 09/02/16 09:26:12
01916-92276 42 14 526 ELE ACT 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
VICTOR HIJUELOS PH (516)652-9239 S
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 P

ENROLLMENT DATE 06/21/16 POL PAYMENT ELIGIBLE Y

BANK ROUTE-TRANSIT NUMBER 266086554 BANK ACCOUNT NUMBER 3106949729

REQUESTED BY CUSTOMER CONTACT Y (YIN)

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40

NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 124 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
POLU PAY ONLINE PAY ONLINE 09/02/16 09:26:12
01916-92276 42 14 526 ELE ACT 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
VICTOR HIJUELOS PH (516)652-9239 S
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 P

ENROLLMENT DATE 06/21 /1 6 POL PAYMENT ELIGIBLE Y

BANK ROUTE-TRANSIT NUMBER 266086554 BANK ACCOUNT NUMBER 3106949729

REQUESTED BY CUSTOMER CONTACT Y (Y/N)

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40

NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 125 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
,270
REPORT: CUCP008-201 -062316 DA/LX ACR TRANSMISSION DETAIL REPORT A9 or DATE 06-23-16 PACE 906

PILE /D: A DESTINATION: BANK or AMERICA BATCH NUMBER: 0000002

REC TR RECV DPI ID CR DPI ACCOUNT # INDIVIDDAI I 4 DD ADD TRACE NUMBER
TIRE CD TRNST/RTM DG EANX ACCOUNT 4 . AMOUNT FPI ACCOUNT 4 CUSTOMER DXST REC ETI-T/R/ABA/SE4

C 27 26608655 4 3106949729 212.76 0191692276 MEET 815649400 42 0 266086550044366

02/13/17 Page 126 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
GMBA BILL ACCOUNT MAINTENANCE 08/31/16 15:01:51
86722-28080 42 14 526 ELE FBL 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN PH (561)662-1684 S SPEC CASH
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX A1LN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
BILL ACCT OPEN DT 07/28/15 TRFR/PREV BILL ACCT OPEN DTE 07/28/15
TYPE _ EFFECTIVE DT 08/31/16 ADDR ACTION (A,C,D)
NAIL ADDRESS ALWAYS SEND ENVELOPE _

CITY STATE ZIP F N BILL MESSAGE N
SEASONAL BEG END E-MAIL BILL DISCONTINUED 05/09/16
E-MAIL ACTION _ (A,C,D) INTERNET ACCESS? Y
E-MAIL ADDR ALLABOUTTHEROOF@AOL.COM
FRIENDLY REMINDER N SUSPEND ESTIMATE (TEMP) N
62 PLUS PLAN 0 SUSPEND ESTIMATE (PERM) N
WAIVE LATE PYMT CD DT EFF PROMOTIONAL LIT CODE 0
REQUEST BY CONTACT PHONE
BILL ACCT PHONE 561 662-1684 OTHER PHONE 561 662-1684
ISSUE RMKS
VOID PEND B/ACCT DM IN ERROR N CM IN ERROR N CC Y (Y/N)
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
USE SUPER WINDOWS TO UPDT MAIL ADDR
20-ADDRESS INQ 22-PREM MAINT 23-CUST MAINT NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 127 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
GMAD GENERAL DATA MAINTENANCE ADDRESS INQUIRY 08/31/16 15:01:53
86722-28080 42 14 526 ELE FBL 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN PH (561)662-1684 S SPEC CASH
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
TYPE F FINAL ADDRESS LAST UPDATE 05/06/16
ADDRESS C/O ALEX ALEMAN
1019 SALMON ISLE
CITY GREENACRES STATE FL ZIP 33413 FOREIGN N

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40

21-BILL MAINT NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 128 377
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
BIHI BILLING HISTORY 08/31/16 15:01:56
86722-28080 42 14 526 ELE FBL 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN PH (561)662-1684 S SPEC CASH
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX AlLN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
CC N (Y/N) ROST BY PAGE 1 OF 1
S SVC DT RM DYS T S BILL KWH KWD ELE AMT BB AMT TOT BILL AMT
05/06/16 5 16 F B 1050 0 105.54 0.00 447.47-
04/20/16 4 30 A B 1658 0 183.10 0.00 436.02
03/21/16 3 32 A B 2124 0 243.31 0.00 430.92
02/18/16 2 28 A B 1452 0 160.62 0.00 487.61
01 /21/16 1 34 A B 2247 0 257.47 0.00 573.75
12/18/15 12 30 A B 2216 0 261.76 0.00 910.46
11/18/15 11 29 A B 2636 0 314.48 0.00 791.04
10/20/15 10 29 A B 3048 0 366.18 0.00 1,293.82
09/21/15 9 32 A B 3768 0 456.52 0.00 798.85
_ 08/20/15 8 23 A B 2322 0 273.97 0.00 761.23

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
COMPLETE LIST
13-MRDG HIST 16-BUS BRKDWN 17-HI BILL 18-READ/VERIFY NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 129
37(7
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PYMT PAYMENT/CREDIT MAINT 08/31/16 15:01:58
86722-28080 42 14 526 ELE FBL 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN PH (561)662-1684 S SPEC CASH
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX A1LN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
PAGE 1 OF 2
PMT
PAYMENT/CREDIT BATCH SEQ POST PMT TDR EXCR EX CREDIT
SEL DATE SRCE LOC AMOUNT NO NO CODE TYPE TYP TYPE AMOUNT
05/06/16 EXCR 3.77 00
05/06/16 EXCR 755.00 00
05/06/16 DPIN 3.77 00 DPIN 3.77
05/06/16 DEP 755.00 00 DEP 755.00
04/28/16 PYMT 960 247.92
6282 050 00 CARD 05
03/22/16 PYMT 613 4657 012 00 OPAL 00
183.00
02/24/16 PYMT 960 305.00
6242 864 00 CARD 05
01/26/16 PYMT 960 269.42
6262 645 00 CARD 05
01/15/16 PYMT 960 500.00
6152 503 00 CARD 05
12/30/15 PYMT 960 141.04
6302 166 00 CARD 05
RQST BY CUSTOMER CONTACT N (Y/N)
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
TOP OF LIST
08-PAGE DOWN 17-CR/PMT REAP 18-CR/PMT TRAN NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 130
37s-
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PYMT PAYMENT/CREDIT MAINT 08/31/16 15:01:58
86722-28080 42 14 526 ELE FBL 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN PH (561)662-1684 S SPEC CASH
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX A1LN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
PAGE 2 OF 2
PMT
PAYMENT/CREDIT BATCH SEQ POST PMT TDR EXCR EX CREDIT
SEL DATE SRCE LOC AMOUNT NO NO CODE TYPE TYP TYPE AMOUNT
12/02/15 PYMT 960 650.00 6022 326 00 CARD 05
11/02/15 PYMT 613 290.00 4291 002 00 OPAL 00
10/29/15 PYMT 960 569.10 6292 663 00 CARD 05
10/13/1 5 PEXC 28.98 00
10/12/15 PYMT 927 290.00 00 VRU
09/24/15 PYMT 927 289.00 00 VRU
09/17/15 PEXT 90.38 00
08/25/15 PYMT 960 270.00 6252 743 00 CARD 05
08/21/15 CANC 112.00 00

RQST BY CUSTOMER CONTACT N (Y/N)
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
COMPLETE LIST
02-TOP LIST 07-PAGE UP 17-CR/PMT REAP 18-CR/PMT TRAN NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 131 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
27a'
REPORT: CUCP120-201 04/28/16 11:15,31 ELECTRONIC DATA INTERMIT= BALANCED CASH PAYMENTS PROCESS DATE 04/28/16 PAGE 23

REGULAR 204 DATE - 04/28/16

BATCH 6282 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT POR

WESTERN UNI FPLCCCRED

1050 86722-28080 247.92 PROCESS 04/28/16 FLORMDAPOWERANDLIGE

02/13/17 Page 132 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT: CUCP120-201 02/24/16 11:15:35 ELECTRONIC DATA ntTNRCHANGE DATANCED CASH PAYMENTS PROCESS DATE 02/24/16 PAGE 41

REGULAR 204 MTV - 02/24/16

BATCH 6242 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT FOR

WESTERN UNT FPLCCCRED

1064 86722-28080 305.00 PROCESS 02/24/16 FLORIDAPOWEMANDLIGR

02/13/17 Page 133 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT: CUCP120-201 01/26/16 11:15;29 ELECTRONIC DATA INTERCHANGE BALANCED CASH PAYMENTS PROCESS DATE 01/2 6/16 PAGE 15

REGULAR 204 DATE - 01/26/16

BATCH 6262 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT FOR

.645 96722-28080 269.42 PROCESS 01/26/16 WESTERN URI PPLCCCRED FLOATDAPOWERANDLIGE

02/13/17 Page 134 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT: COCR120-201 01/15/16 11:15:37 ELECTRONIC man% =ERMA= RALANCIM CASE PAYMENTS PROCESS DATE 01/15/16 PAGE 33

REGULAR 204 DATE - 01/15/16

RATCR 6152 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT FOR

WESTERN DR/ FPLCCCRED

1503 66722-26080 500.00 PROCESS 01/15/16 FLORIDAPORSRANDLEGR

02/13/17 Page 135 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT: CBCP120 -201 12/30/15 11:15:31 ELECTRONIC DATA ENTERCHANGE BALANCED CASH PAYMENTS moans DATE 12/30/15 PAGE 26

REGULAR 204 DATE - 12/30/15

BATCH 6302 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT FOR

WESTERN TNT FPLCCCRED

1166 86722-28080 141.04 PROCESS 12 / 30/15 PLORIDAPowERANDL/GR

02/13/17 Page 136 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT: CUCP120-201 12/02/15 11:15:39 ELECTRONIC DATA INMSCHANCE DALANCED CASH PAYMENTS PROCESS DATE 12 /02/15 PACE 29

REGULAR 204 DATE - 12/02/15

BATCH 6022 DISTRICT 950
SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE =Imam PAYMENT POR

WESTERN UNE PPLCCCRED

1326 06722-28080 650.00 PROCESS 12/02/15 MORIDAPOWERANDLIGE

02/13/17 Page 137 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT: CUCP120-201 10/29/15 11:15:32 ELECTRONIC DATA INTERCHANGE BALANCED CASH PAYMENTS PROCESS DATE 10/29/15 PAGE 37

REGULAR 204 palmy — 10/29/15

BATCH 6292 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE DATE PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT FOR

WESTERN ONT mccomm

1663 86722-29000 569.10 PROCESS 10/29/15 PLORIDAPOWERANDLIGH

02/13/17 Page 138 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
REPORT; CUCP120-201 06/25/15 11:15:28 ELECTRONIC DATA 7:IMP:RERAN= BALANCED CASH PAYMENTS PROCESS DATr 08/25/15 PAGE 17

REGULAR 204 DATP - 08/25/15

BATCH 6252 DISTRICT 950

SEQUENCE ACCOUNT PMT AMOUNT PROCESS CODE 'ILerr PARTNER NAME TRACE NUMBER PAYMENT FOR

WESTERN UNI FPLCCCRED

743 86722-28080 270.00 PROCESS 09125/15 FIZRIDAPOW.RANDLI02

02/13/17 Page 139 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
RIHI RETURN ITEM HISTORY INFO RETURN ITEM HISTORY INFO 08/31/16 15:02:04
86722-28080 42 14 526 ELE FBL 05/06/16 1/044/ ACD5262
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN PH (561)662-1684 S SPEC CASH
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
PAGE 1 OF 1

DOC VRU PREMISE 782925319 BATCH 9999-0000 DATE 10/01 /1 5
NAME1 NAME2
ADDRESS
CHK NO RT# 043000096 BANK ACCT# 1138199096
AMOUNT 289.00 RTRN RSN INSUFFICIENT FUNDS

DOC VRU PREMISE 782925319 BATCH 9999-0000 DATE 10/19/15
NAME1 NAME2
ADDRESS
CHK NO RT# 043000096 .BANK ACCT# 1138199096
AMOUNT 290.00 RTRN RSN INSUFFICIENT FUNDS

TOTAL CHECKS 2 CASH ONLY DATE 10/19/15 TOTAL AMOUNT 579.00
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 4
COMPLETE LIST
NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 140 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Y6*
GMBA BILL ACCOUNT MAINTENANCE 08/31/16 15:02:15
40025-20411 42 14 526 ELE UAR 10/28/15 1/044/ ACD5262 UCS1
TATIANA RAMIREZ REGO PH (561)254-8172 S
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
BILL ACCT OPEN DT 06/01/11 TRFR/PREV BILL ACCT OPEN DTE 06/01/11
TYPE _ EFFECTIVE DT 08/31/16 ADDR ACTION (A,C,D)
MAIL ADDRESS ALWAYS SEND ENVELOPE _

CITY STATE ZIP F N BILL MESSAGE N
SEASONAL BEG END E-MAIL BILL DISCONTINUED 07/28/15
E-MAIL ACTION (A,C,D) INTERNET ACCESS? y
E-MAIL ADDR RRTATIANA@YAHOO.COM
FRIENDLY REMINDER N SUSPEND ESTIMATE (TEMP) N
62 PLUS PLAN 0 SUSPEND ESTIMATE (PERM) N
WAIVE LATE PYMT CD _ DT EFF PROMOTIONAL LIT CODE 0
REQUEST BY CONTACT PHONE
BILL ACCT PHONE 561 254-8172 OTHER PHONE 561 254-8172
ISSUE RMKS
VOID PEND B/ACCT DM IN ERROR N CM IN ERROR N CC Y (Y/N)
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
USE SUPER WINDOWS TO UPDT MAIL ADDR
20-ADDRESS INQ 22-PREM MAINT 23-CUST MAINT NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 141 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
276
GMAD GENERAL DATA MAINTENANCE ADDRESS INQUIRY 08/31/16 15:02:18
40025-20411 42 14 526 ELE UAR 10/28/15 1/044/ ACD5262 UCS1
TATIANA RAMIREZ REGO PH (561)254-8172 S
17148 30TH LN N SIT# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
TYPE F FINAL ADDRESS LAST UPDATE 07/27/15
ADDRESS 4801 CENTRAL GARDENS WAY APT 102

CITY PALM BCH GDNS STATE FL ZIP 33418 FOREIGN N

NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40

21-BILL MAINT NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 142 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
37
BIHI BILLING HISTORY 08/31/16 15:02:20
40025-20411 42 14 526 ELE UAR 10/28/15 1/044/ ACD5262 UCS1
TATIANA RAMIREZ REGO PH (561)254-8172 S
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F
CC N (Y/N) ROST BY PAGE 1 OF 4
S SVC DT RM DYS T S BILL KWH KWD ELE AMT BB AMT TOT BILL AMT
07/26/1 5 8 5 F B 333 0 34.06 0.00 285.38
07/21/15 7 32 A B 1867 0 219.05 157.92 157.92
06/19/1 5 6 30 AB 1578 0 182.63 152.00 152.00
05/20/15 5 30 A B 1533 0 176.91 148.12 148.12
04/20/15 4 31 A B 1579 0 187.82 143.04 143.04
03/20/15 3 29 A B 1187 0 137.12 136.01 136.01

02/13/17 Page 143 Public Records Request No.: 17-058 5ZY
PYMT PAYMENT/CREDIT MAINT 08/31/16 15:02:27
40025-20411 42 14 526 ELE UAR 10/28/15 1/044/ ACD5262 UCS1
TATIANA RAMIREZ REGO PH (561)254-8172 S
17148 30TH LN N S/T# XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL•33470 F
PAGE 1 OF 6
PMT
PAYMENT/CREDIT BATCH SEQ POST PMT TDR EXCR EX CREDIT
SEL DATE SRCE LOC AMOUNT NO NO CODE TYPE TYP TYPE AMOUNT
_ 06/30/15 PYMT 999 152.00 00 ABP
_ 06/01/15 PYMT 999 148.12 00 ABP
_ 05/01/15 PYMT 999 143.04 00 ABP
_ 03/31/15 PYMT 999 136.01 00 ABP
03/02/15 PYMT 999 137.99 00 ABP

02/13/17 Page 144 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
ABPI ABP INQUIRY AUTOMATIC BILL INQUIRY 08/31/16 15:02:34
40025-20411 42 14 526 ELE UAR 10/28/15 1/044/ ACD5262 UCS1
TATIANA RAMIREZ REGO PH (561)254-8172 S
17148 30TH LN N S/T4 XXX-XX-XXXX AILN POL CCIN
LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470 F

BANK ACCOUNT INQUIRY

BANK TRANSIT ROUTING NUMBER 267084131 BANK NAME WASH MUTUAL

BANK ACCOUNT 980178354 ABP STATUS REMOVED

STATUS DATE 07/14/15 BANK ACCOUNT TYPE C CHECKING

PAYMENT WITHDRAWAL = NUMBER OF DAYS AFTER BILLING(11 - 20 DAYS) 11
IF 62+ (11 - 31 DAYS)
APPLICATION REJECTION

APPLICATION REJECTION REASON
NEXT TYPE A FIND GWA 40
INVALID BILL ACCOUNT STATUS
17-ABP UPDATE NEWS
FACT

02/13/17 Page 145 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Comprehensive Case Information System Page 1 of 3

Sharon R. Bock, Esq., Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comptroller PALM BEACH COUNTY CCIS
A

Search TCATS Child Support Help Logout
weissb@pbso.org

Back Expand All

Images are unavailable.
Jury
Case Number Filed Date County Case Type Status ' '''''k\ Contested
Trial
PALM JUVENILE
11/17/2015 Open ) No No
BEACH DEPENDENCY

Filing Date Description Active Contested Judgement Date
JUVENILE
11/17/2015 NO NO -
DEPENDENCY

on 100
Party Name Party Type Attorney Bar ID
SCHER, JUDGEROSEMARIE JUDGE
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN DEPT OF CHILDREN AND
& FAMIL FAMILIES
ALEMAN, TYLER CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD
ALEMAN, CHILD

Dockets 0

Page : 1 r7 10 Ld
Document Action
Image Description Pages
# Date
ORDER; TO COMPEL IMMEDIATE ACCESS FOR ON-SITE PROTECTIVE
11/17/2015
INVESTIGATION SIGNED BY JUDGE MARTZ
EMERGENCY MOTION; MOTION FOR AN ORDER TO COMPEL IMMEDIATE
11/17/2015
ACCESS FOR ON-SITE PROTECTIVE INVESTIGATION F/B DCF
11/17/2015 CERTIFICATE OF CLERK; FB CLERK
REQUEST; F/B DCF Filed by DEPT OF CHILDREN & FAMILIES DEPARTMENT OF
11/17/2015
CHILDREN & FAMILIES
11/17/2015 ADDITIONAL COMMENTS
11/17/2015 HEARING EVENT SCHEDULED
11/17/2015 EVENT HELD
ORDER ORDER AUTHORIZING ACCESS TO THE CHILDREN'S MEDICAL AND
EDUCATIONAL RECORDS SIGNED BY JUDGE EVANS; ORDER AUTHORIZING
04/03/2016
ACCESS TO THE CHILDREN'S MEDICAL AND EDUCATIONAL RECORDS; SIGNED
BY JUDGE EVANS
ORDER ORDER FOR DEPARTMENT CUSTODY FOR CHILDREN PLACED IN OUT
OF HOME LICENSED CARE SIGNED BY JUDGE EVANS; ORDER FOR
04/03/2016
DEPARTMENT CUSTODY FOR CHILDREN PLACED IN OUT OF HOME LICENSED
CARE; SIGNED BY JUDGE EVANS
04/03/2016 COURT EVENT FORM; FB CLERK

02/13/17 Page 146 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://www.flccis.com/ocrs/app/caseinformation.xhtml?query=564ov3Zp3KJLgiRccEsQ... 10/26/2016 397
Comprehensive Case Information System Page 2 of 3

Judge Assignment History 0
Assigned Date Withdraw Date Judicial Officer Type
No records found.

Court Events 0
10 vl
Defendant
Event Date Judge Docket Type Location Prosecutor
Attorney
06/08/2016 SCHER, CC - CALENDAR
MB 3BMain
09:00:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE CALL
11/17/2015 SCHER, EM - EMERGENCY
MB 3AMain
13:30:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE HEARING
FANELLI,
09/29/2016 . JR - JUDICIAL
MAGISTRATEJUDE MB 31117M
09:30:00 REVIEW
N
06/27/2016 SCHER, MH - MOTION
MB 3BMain
13:30:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE HEARING
MMP - MOTION
05/25/2016 SCHER,
TO MODIFY MB 3BMain
09:00:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE
PLACEMENT
MMP - MOTION
06/27/2016 SCHER,
TO MODIFY MB 3BMain
13:30:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE
PLACEMENT
04/20/2016 SCHER, OH - OTHER
MB 3BMain
09:00:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE HEARING
FANELLI, PERM -
02/27/2017
MAGISTRATEJUDE PERMANENCY MB 31117M
14:00:00
N HEARING
05/25/2016 SCHER, RARN - RESET
MB 3BMain
09:00:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE ARRAIGNMENT
06/08/2016 SCHER, RARN - RESET
MB 3BMain
09:00:00 JUDGEROSEMARIE ARRAIGNMENT

Sentences 0
Seq Date Date
Sentence Status Judge At Sentence
# Imposed Effective
No records found.

Warrants / Capias / Summons 0

Issue Execution
CourJ Warrant SEQ Action Ordered Issuing Judge Status
I Date Date
No records found.

Financial Summary 0
No records found.

Reopen History 0

Reopen Date Reopen Close Date Reopen Reason ^
08/26/2016 08/29/2016 Other reason
08/26/2016 08/29/2016 Other reason
07/12/2016 07/22/2016 Other reason
06/23/2016 06/27/2016 Other reason
06/20/2016 06/27/2016 Other reason
06/03/2016 06/27/2016 Other reason
V
05/20/2016 04/20/2016 Other reason

02/13/17 Page 147 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://www.flccis.com/ocrs/app/caseinformation.xhtml?query=564ov3Zp3KJLgiRccEsQ... 10/26/2016 3v
Comprehensive Case Information System Page 3 of 3

Reopen Date Reopen Close Date Reopen Reason
05/18/2016 06/27/2016 Other reason
04/12/2016 04/20/2016 Other reason

02/13/17 Page 148 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://www.flccis.com/ocrs/app/caseinformationAhtml?query=564ov3Zp3KJLgiRccEsQ... 10/26/2016 3
Comprehensive Case Information System Page 1 of 2

COMPREHENSIVE CASE INFORMATION SYSTEM
Joseph E. Smith, Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comptroller

Search TCATS Child Support Help Logout
weissb@pbso.org

Back Expand All

Jury
Case Number Filed Date County Case Type Status— Contested
Trial
562013CF000938AXXXX)
04/10/2013 ST. LUCIE CRIMINAL FELONY REOPENED No No
[2013CF000938 Al

Charge Seq # Description Date Phase
CARRYING CONCEALED
1 09/10/2013 Court:Adiudication Withheld
WEAPON
DRIVE UNDER THE
2 09/10/2013 Court:Adjudicated Guilty
INFLUENCE - IMPAIRMENT

Party Name Party Type Attorney Bar ID
SWEET, GARY L JUDGE
SWEET, GARY L JUDGE AT DISPOSITION
GARCIA, SALVADOR POLICE OFFICER
STATE OF FLORIDA PLAINTIFF
GARLAND, THOMAS R OTHER
FOX, KELLY ATTORNEY
GARLAND, THOMAS
ATTORNEY
RICHARD II
ALEMAN, ALEJANDRO DEFENDANT

Dockets O
j Document Action
Imag Description Pages
# Date
b 55 03/18/2015 ORDER ON MOTION TO TERMINATE PROBATION 1
kJ 54 03/18/2015 DOCUMENT RECEIVED-EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE 1
53 03/02/2015 CASE REOPENED FOR OTHER
(11a 52 03/02/2015 MOTION TO MODIFY/TERMINATE PROBATION OR COMMUNITY CONTROL 2
b 51 06/04/2014 PAYMENT $362.50 RECEIPT #2014000057656 1
16 50 10/28/2013 PAYMENT $0.00 RECEIPT #2013000104630 1
tt,) 48 09/26/2013 ORDER OF PROBATION - Recorded (OR.3564.741 / 3881386) 4
Ira 47 09/25/2013 MAIL RETURNED UNDELIVERED 2

Judge Assignment History O
Assigned Date Withdraw Date Judicial Officer Type
04/10/2013 SWEET, GARY L

Court Events O
Defendant
Event Date Judge Docket Type Location Prosecutor
Attorney
06/06/2013
SWEET, GARY L DOCKET CALL Courtroom 3A - HC
09:00:00
07/10/2013
SWEET, GARY L DOCKET CALL Courtroom 3A - HC
09:00:00
SWEET, GARY L DOCKET CALL Courtroom 3A - HC

02/13/17 Page 149 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://wwvv.flccis.com/ocrs/app/caseinformation.xhtml?query=fMt5Rfl 9GomcaAVYIe8... 10/26/2016 39/
Comprehensive Case Information System Page 2 of 2

Defendant
Event Date Judge Docket Type Location Prosecutor
Attorney
08/21/2013
09:00:00
09/10/2013
SWEET, GARY L HEARING Courtroom 3A - HC
08:30:00

Sentences 0

Seq Date Date
Sentence Status Judge At Sentence
# Imposed Effective
1
Not
Probation 1 Year 09/10/2013 09/10/2013 SWEET, GARY L
Applicable
2
Probation 1 Year Consecutive 09/10/2013 09/10/2013 SWEET, GARY L

Financial Summary 0

Financial Summary
Assessment Total: $1,335.50 Paid to Date: $1,335.50 Balance Due: $0.00
Restitution Total: $0.00 Paid to Date: $0.00 Balance Due: $0.00

Financial Details
Assessment Paid Restitution Paid to Last Payment
Count Assessment Due Restitution Due
to Date Date Date
$25.00 $25.00 -
$525.00 $525.00 -
$150.00 $150.00 -
$223.00 $223.00 -
$50.00 $50.00 -
$362.50 $362.50 -

Reopen History 0

Reopen Date Reopen Close Date Reopen Reason
No records found.

02/13/17 Page 150 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://www.flccis.com/ocrs/app/caseinformation.xhtml?query=fMt5Rfl9GomcaAVY1e8... 10/26/2016 g-
. PANL: A03. DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:31 pm
STDT: 26135087

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
ALEMAN TYLER ALEXANDER,

RESIDENCE # 9094 DIR STR ISAIAH TYPE LN PD
APT CITY PALM BEACH GARDENS ST FL ZIP44 33418

MAILING # DIR STR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP+4

S R !_DOB ; BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
M W 0630OLLOXAHATCHEE FL 1 561 6279550 N N 081606 061A

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
R02 180516 1371 09 01 N N N N N Y US FL 50
ENR:6TH ZONED
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 071806 ZZ 3 50 50 1371 N N N N N Z

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
RECORD IS DISPLAYED...NEXT? TERML: 1005

PANEL: A05. CONTACT INFORMATION SUMMARY YEAR: 17
Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:31 pm
STDT: 26135087 ALEMAN, TYLER ALEXANDER SCHL: 1371 GR: 09 ST: A

NAME HOME PHONE DAY PHONE EXT CELL PHONE PS P C R
PEDIATRIC ASSOCIATES 561 6277930 N N _
SHELDON OR AMY REDDITT G 561 6279550 561 2489450 Y Y Y _
ANY POH,CHS,DCF,CP EMP WIT 0 561 7757195 Y Y N N
NATALIE RIVERA 0 561 4004881 561 4004881 Y Y N
NO PARENT CONTACT 0 Y N
MARCHEN VOLMY 0 561 7757195 Y Y N —
KIM WATTY 0 561 7757195 Y N
STEPHANIE THALE 0 561 7757195 Y N

HEALTH CONDITIONS:
PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 9=ADD 12=ESCAPE
NO RECORD ON LINE SELECTED, RETRY. TERML: 1005

PANEL: A85. CONTACT INFORMATION SUMMARY YEAR: 17
Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:31 pm
STDT: 26135087 ALEMAN, TYLER ALEXANDER SCHL: 1371 GR: 09 ST: A
02/13/17 Page 151 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
NAME HOME PHONE DAY PHONE EXT CELL PHONE PS P C R
PEDIATRIC ASSOCIATES D 561 6277930 N N _
SHELDON OR AMY REDDITT G 561 6279550 561 2489450 Y Y Y _
ANY POH,CHS,DCF,CP EMP WIT 0 561 7757195 YYNN
NATALIE RIVERA 0 561 4004881 561 4004881 Y Y N
NO PARENT CONTACT 0 Y N
MARCHEN VOLMY 0 561 7757195 Y Y N
KIM WATTY 0 561 7757195 Y N _
STEPHANIE THALE 0 561 7757195 Y N

HEALTH CONDITIONS:
PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 9=ADD 12=ESCAPE PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 9=ADD 12=ESCAPE
NO RECORD ON LINE SELECTED. RETRY. TERML: T005

PANEL: Ale. CURRENT SCHEDULE YEAR: 17
Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:34 pm
STDT: 26135087 ALEMAN, TYLER ALEXANDER SCHL: 1371 GR: 09 ST: A
HMRM: TM:
ST: A T: SY: 17 S C
A COURSE SEC DATE SCHL T PROS DAYS BLD-RM TCHR T L
2001310 002 100516 3 0101 ERTH/SPA SCI MTWRF 03210 SHADE
1001310 019 100516 3 0202 ENG 1 MTWRF 02302 NAVAR
8718010 001 100516 3 0303 CMCL ART TECH 1 MTWRF 03219 THOMA
0101300 008 100516 3 0404 2-D ART 1 MTWRF 02104 WANKL
1502470 0131 100516 1 0505 REC MTWRF 05110 REPPE 4
1501300 007 010917 2 0505 PERS FIT MTWRF 05110 JACOB 4
8207310 009 100516 3 0606 DIGITAL INFO TECH MTWRF 03211 TESTA
1207300 008 100516 3 0707 LIB ARTS MATH 1 MTWRF 02205 GORDO

PORT:
PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 4=PROMPT 5=REFRESH 6=FORCE 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NXT 11=PRT 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL:- A10. CURRENT SCHEDULE YEAR: 17
Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:34 pm
STDT: 26135087 ALEMAN, TYLER ALEXANDER SCHL: 1371 GR: 09 ST: A
HMRM: TM:
ST: A T: SY: 17 S C
A COURSE SEC DATE SCHL T PROS DAYS BLD-RM TCHR I L
2001310 002 100516 3 0101 ERTH/SPA SCI MTWRF 03210 SHADE
1001310 019 100516 3 0202 ENG 1 MTWRF 02302 NAVAR
02/13/17 Page 152
8718010 001 100516 MTWRFPublic Records Request No.: 17-058
03219 THOMA
3 0303 CMCL ART TECH 1
39'7
Ut/25 IOU5lb 3 0404 2-0 ART 1 MTWRF 02104 WANKL
— UIVIJUU
1502470 0131 100516 1 0505 REC MTWRF 05110 REPPE 4
1501300 007 010917 2 0505 PERS FIT MTWRF 05110 JACOB 4
8207310 009 100516 3 0606 DIGITAL INFO TECH MTWRF 03211 TESTA
1207300 008 100516 3 0707 LIB ARTS MATH 1 MTWRF 02205 GORDO

PORT:
PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 4=PROMPT 5=REFRESH 6=FORCE 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NXT 11=PRT 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A07. ASSIGNMENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:36 pm
STDT: t-6135087 gaMAN.,'TYLER ALEXANDEfj Seti : 1374 GR: 09 ST: A

A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P E
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PFINt CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
R02 100516 17 01 50 1371 PA- GARbENSHIq?09
E01 081516 W02 100416 P 17 01 1971 W B DUNCAN MID 08
E01 040716 WO1 060316 R 16 01 1971 W B DUNCAN MID 08 40
E02 092313 W3A 122013 N 14 01 1691 CRESTWOOD MID 06 14 45
E01 082207 W3A 082207 N 08 01 2761 CHOLEE ELEM 01
E05 081606 WO1 060407 P 07 01 2761 CHOLEE ELEM KG 93 86

PFI=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A03. DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:37 pm
STDT: 12853 4 469 .z PLEASE, SEE A23 SCREEN

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
ALEMAN•

RESIDENCE # 9087 DIR STR ISAIAH TYPE LN PD
APT CITY PALM BEACH GARDENS ST FL ZIP+4 33418

MAILING DIR STR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP+4

02/13/17 Page 153 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
S R DOB BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
M W 041803 NAPERVILLE IL 1 561 6307406 N 092313 061A

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
E01 081516 1971 07 01 N N N N N Y US FL 50
ENR:OTH ZONED
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 081213 ZZ 3 50 50 1971 N N N N N F

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
RECORD IS DISPLAYED...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A07. ASSIGNMENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:38 pm
STDT: 28534469 qkLEMAN, SCHL: 1971 GR: 07 ST: A

A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PF SY CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
E01 081516 17 01 1971 W BiDUNCANMM:01
E02 042716 WO1 060316 R 16 01 1971 W B DUNCAN MID 07 26
E02 092313 W22 110813 N 14 01 0061 EVERGLADES ELE 03 19 14

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: Ae3. DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:38 pm
STDT: 48534493 PLEASE, SEE A23 SCREEN

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
tkLEMAN tvAtAtAN'

RESIDENCE # 1460 DIR E STR BEXLEY PARK TYPE DR PD
APT CITY DELRAY BEACH ST FL ZIP+4 33415

MAILING # DIR STR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP+4

S R DOB BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
M W 813006 PALM BEACH FL 1 561 7299251 N 092313 286

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
E01 081516 1891 03 01 N N N N N Y US FL 50
02/13/17 Page 154 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
ENR:OTH ZONED .279
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 081213 ZZ 3 50 50 1891 N N N N N F

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
RECORD IS DISPLAYED...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: 407. ASSIGNMENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:38 pm
STDT: e8534493 JALEMAN, gtHL: 18917 GR: 03 ST: A

A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PF SY CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
E01 081516 17 01 4891:-BANYAN -CREEf E 03
E04 040716 WO1 060316 R 16 01 1891 BANYAN CREEK E 03 38 2
E02 092313 W22 110813 N 14 01 0061 EVERGLADES ELE 01 12 21

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: 1005

PANEL: A03. DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:39 pm
STDT:128534402 PLEASE, SEE A23 SCREEN

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
VIEMAN

RESIDENCE # 1460 DIR E STR BEXLEY PARK TYPE DR PD
APT CITY DELRAY BEACH ST FL ZIP+4 33445

MAILING # DIR STR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP-1-4

S R DOB BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
M 0072807 RORT LUCIE FL 1 N 092313 286

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
E01 081516 1891 02 01 N N N N N Y US FL 50
ENR:OTH ZONED
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 081213 ZZ 3 50 50 1891 N N N N N F

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
02/13/17 Page 155 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
RECORD IS DISPLAYED, NEXT? TERML: T005
PANEL: A07. ASSIGNMENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:39 pm
STDT: e8534402- ALEMAN, SC L:' 1891 GR: 02 ST: A

A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PF SY CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
E01 081516 17 01 189143ANYAN CREEK E 02
E01 040516 WO1 060316 R 16 01 1891 BANYAN CREEK E 02 39 3
E05 092313 W22 110813 N 14 01 0061 EVERGLADES ELE KG 17 16

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A03, DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:39 pm
STDT: 29330867 PLEASE, SEE A23 SCREEN

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
4ALEMAN tT-44:EVIW

RESIDENCE # 1460 DIR E STR BEXLEY PARK TYPE DR PD
APT CITY DELRAY BEACH ST FL ZIP+4 33445

MAILING # DIR STR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP+4

S R DOB BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
M WA72708 WEST PALM FL 9 561 6307406 N 041116 286

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
E01 091516 1891 02 01 N N N N N Y US FL 50
ENR:OTH ZONED
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 040416 ZZ 3 50 SO 1891 N N N N N F

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
RECORD IS DISPLAYED„.NEYT? TERML: 1005

PANEL: A07, ASSIGN,IENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:39 pm
02/13/17
STDT: g9330867 IMAN, TREVIN Page 156 Public Records
SCHL: 1891 GR: Request No.: A
02 ST: 17-058
A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PF SY CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
E01 091516 17 01 50 1891 BANYAN CREEK- E 02
E01 081516 W02 091516 _ _ 17 01 2011 TIMBER TRACE E 02
E04 041116 WO1 060316 P 16 01 2011 TIMBER TRACE E 01 37

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...VExT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A03, DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:40 pm
STDT: 29329109 PLEASE, SEE D19 SCREEN

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
ALEMAN *TRACE

RESIDENCE # 172 DIR STR OREGON TYPE LN PD
APT CITY BOCA RATON ST FL ZIP+4 33487

MAILING # DIR STR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP+4

S R DOB BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
M W toms:UNKNOWN FL 9 561 7532226 N 040616 309

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
E01 081516 1891 01 A 01 NNNNNY US FL 50
ENR:OTH ZONED
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 040516 ZZ 3 50 50 1911 N N N N N Z

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
RECORD IS DISPLAYED...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A07. ASSIGNMENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:40 pm
STDT:09329109 ALEMAN, TRACE SCHL:01891 GR: 01 ST: A

A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PF SY CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
E01 081516 A 17 01 50 1891 BANYAN CREEVE4
02/13/17
E04 040616 Page 157
1941 CYPRESS TRLS EPublic
01Records
40 1Request No.:
Y 17-058
W01 060316 R _ 16 01
PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

PANEL: A83. DEMOGRAPHICS YEAR: 17
T228 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:40 pm
STDTS!'29395332

LAST APP FIRST MIDDLE AKA FORMER
PALEMAN 1RESSA

RESIDENCE # 1460 DIR E SIR BEXLEY PARK TYPE DR PD
APT CITY DELRAY BEACH ST FL ZIP+4 33445

MAILING DIR SIR TYPE PD
APT CITY ST ZIP+4

S R DOB BIRTH CITY ST VER PHONE PUB ML ORIG SAC SCH2
F W 052011 PORT ST LUCIE FL 9 954 7299251 N 081516 286

ENT DATE SCHL GR OD CL W/D DATE PR PF WR E I-A-B-P-W PC PS PD
E05 081516 1891 KG 01 NNNNNY US FL 50
ENR:OTH ZONED
LNG PGL COB A/F SURVEY STAT CAT ELL RES DS SCHL DS SCHL CH2 EHA D/B ST:C M EX
EN EN US N 051816 ZZ 3 50 50 1891 N N N N N Z

PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 7=BKWD 8=FWD 12=ESCAPE
RECORD IS DISPLAYED...NEXT? TERML: 1005

PANEL: A07. ASSIGNMENT HISTORY YEAR: 17
T234 Tuesday October 25, 2016 4:40 pm
STDT: 39395332 ACEMAN, TRESSA SCHL: X891 GR: KG ST: A

A ENTRY WITHDRAWAL P E
C CD DATE OD CD DATE R PF SY CL DS SCHL DESC GR PRS ABS UNX Y
E05 081516 17 01 f891 BANYAN CREEK E KG.

02/13/17 Page 158 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Vo3
PF1=HELP 3=EXIT 5=REFRESH 7=BKWD 8=FWD 9=NEXT PAGE 12=ESCAPE
NO ADDITIONAL PAGES...NEXT? TERML: T005

02/13/17 Page 159 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Incident: P BC 16036452
Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Patient: Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Patient Situation History
Patient Situation Medication NO KNOWN DRUG
Allergies ALLERGIES
LA.3! Name Aleman Other Non- NONE REPORTED
F imt Name
Arrest Data Medication
Arrest 04/01/2016 19:26:00 Allergies
Address 17148 30th Ln N
Date/Time
State Florida
Cause Respiratory/Asphyxia
city Loxahatchee Groves
Witnesses Not Witnessed
Zip Code 33470
Cardiac Arrest Yes, Prior to EMS Arrival
SSN 000-00-0000
AED Prior to No
Gender Female EMS?
Races White CPR Prior to No
Date of Birth 317/2015 EMS?
Age 1 First Arrest Asystole
Rhythm
Age Units Years
Resuscitation Initiated Chest Compressions
Hospital Account D00011463872 Attempted By
Number
EMS
Medical Record D513268
Number CPR Types by Compressions-Continuous
EMS Ventilation-Bag Valve Mask
Phone Numbers Hypothermia No
Used
Phone Number: 561-662-1684
ROSCs No

Pjyment End of Event Expired in ED
Rhythms at Asystole
ALS Assessment Yes Destination
Payment Method Insurance
Possible Injury No
Was ResQPod No
used?
Cardiac Arrest Yes, Prior to EMS Arrival
Was this a CO No
incident?
Was this patent an No
Alert?
Primary Impression Cardiac Arrest
Is the patient an Yes
adult (signs of
puberty) and not
pregnant?
Is there a No
suspected or
documented
infection?

osirnpOnt§ •
Type: Chief (Primary) Complaint: Cardiac Arrest
Duration: 30 Time Units: Minutes

Symptoms

Symptom: Cardiac Arrest

_ • ---••+-
Car,: Report Page 1
02/13/17 Page 160 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
-OS
of 4V
Incident: PBC16036452
Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Patient: Aleman,
Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33411
Case Status: CLOSED
Phone: (561) 616-7000
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Narrative
Engine and rescue arrived to find the mom holding her baby in a blanket saying that the baby was not breathing. She said she was feeding the baby a bottle and the baby was not
responding normally. Pt mother said this is her tenth child. Pt mother said the baby was a normal and healthy baby at birth and was nine pounds at birth. When asked if the patient
had cancer or any other illnesses the mother denied any. The patient appeared to be malnourished. Pt ribs were visible. Pt mom denies the pt being sick or having any diseases.
With the patient being one years old and being told that the baby was nine pounds at birth ten milligrams was the weight used for advanced cardiac life support doses and
equipment sizes. Captain took the baby and assessed that the baby was not breathing. Pt had no pulse. Pt was placed on the stretcher. Chest compressions were started at a 15:2
cc.rnpR;ssion to ventilation ratio about 10 cycles every 2 minutes. One rescuer was doing compressions and another rescuer was providing ventilatory assistance. A bag valve mask
to provide oxygen to the baby. The smallest opa was sized and found to be too large for the patient. CO2 detection device was placed on the bag valve mask and
c,ipnouraphy and capnometry were detected. The capnography showed a box like wave form. No resistance was felt with the ventilatory assistance being provided. Nasopharyngeal
,LiWilY13 were sized and found to be too large for the baby. An oropharyngeal airway was sized and found to be too large for the child. Airway was maintained by head positioning
aid bag valve mask attached to oxygen flowing at 15 liters per minute of 100% oxygen. Ventilatory assistance was continued and symmetrical rise and fall were seen, lung sounds
heard equally in all four fields, no resistance was felt, and a box like wave form was seen on the monitor with a capnography reading as well. Protocols were followed for medication
I administration followed by a normal saline flush. An advanced airway was considered and prepared. When the lower jaw was attempted to be displaced there was resistance that
was felt, and the lower jaw was not able to be displaced. Ventilatory assistance was continued by the bag valve mask with no complications. Pediatric quick combo pads were
placed on the front and rear torso. Pt was found to be in asystole for the entire transport. A blood sugar was checked by a heel stick and the glucometer read low". D10 was pushed
through the 10 with a syringe. Pt was continually monitored. Palms west hospital was notified. Upon arrival at er the nurses and doctors were given the information. Palm beach
county sheriff officers and the nurse were informed of that there is suspicion of possible abuse or neglect of the patient. Mm30731

Exam
Patient Position as Found Being Carried

Date/Time Assessments Comments

2016-04-01 18:57:00 Mental Status: Unresponsive
Skin: Cold
Neurological: Not Done
Eyes: Bilateral Dilated

Care Events

Date/Time Event Details
2016-04-01 18:57:00 Vitals Responsiveness (AVPU): Unresponsive Heart Rate: 0 Pulse Rhythm: Absent Heart Rate Method: Palpated
Respiratory Rate: 0 Respiratory Effort: Apnelc BP Method: Cuff-Manual Palpated Only BP Systolic: 0
2016-04-01 18:57:00 Patient Assessment Crew ID: Giamberini, Andrew T
2016-04-01 18:58:00 Oxygen Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 15.000 Dose Units: Liters Per Minute Route: BVM (non-intubated) Response:
Unchanged Complications: None Crew ID: Morzella, Steven
2016-04-01 18:58:00 Bagged Ventilations (via Mask) Crew ID: Morzella, Steven
2016-04-01 18:58:00 CPR (Manual) Prior to EMS?: No Response: Unchanged Crew ID: Giamberini, Andrew T
2016-04-01 19:01:00 10 (Intraosseous) IV Site: 10-Femoral-Left Distal Successful: Yes Response: Unchanged Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:01:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:03:00 Normal saline Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 100.000 Dose Units: Milliliters Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:04:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:08:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:10:00 dextrose 10 % Injectable Solution Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 50.000 Dose Units: Milliliters Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:12:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:15:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael

Patient Care Report Page 2 of 4
02/13/17 Page 161 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Incident: PBC16036452
Palm Beach County Fi re Rescue Patient: Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33 411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Crew/Times Disposition
Dispatch Disposition
Crew Members
Incident Number PBC16036452 Disposition Treated, Transported by EMS
Role: Paramedic Employee ID: 30731 Last Name:
Incident Type CARDIAC-ARREST McKeehan First Name: Michael Cert Level: EMT-
Transport Data
Address 17148 30TH LN N Paramedic Crew Cert ID: PMD523638
State Destination Hospital-Emergency
Florida
Type Department
City Loxahatchee Crew Members.
Destination Palms West Hospital
Zip Code 33470 Name
Role: Driver/Operator, Pilot Employee ID: 22140
Cross Street CHEETHAM HILL Last Name: Morzella First Name: Steven Cert Venfy patient Yes - Verified
BLVD<>DEAD END Level: EMT-Basic Crew Cert ID: EMT518644 (hospital)
Station I ESZ 22)434014000 destination is
Role: Captain Employee ID: 5783 Last Name: correct?
Response Giamberini First Name: Andrew Middle Name: T
Transport Priority 1
Crew Cert ID: PMD17120 Cert Level: EMT- Priority
Unit Cali Sign R22 Paramedic
Destination Protocol
Shin B Shift Reasons
Service Requested Times
911 Response (Scene) Patient refused No
Rei3ponse Mode to Lights and Sirens closest
Dispatched 04/01/2016 18:48:15
Scene appropriate
Level of Care En Route 04/01/2016 18:49:15 facility?
ALS-Paramedic
At Scene 04/01/2016 18:55:25 Conveyances Carried
Fire Incident At Patient TO Vehicle
04/01/2016 18:56:00
Firr> Incident EMS call, excluding vehicle Depart Scene Position During Supine
04/01/2016 19:04:33
accident with injury Transport
1Yt't! At Destination 04/01/2016 19:16:05
Primary Action Provide advanced life support Conveyance Carried
In Service 04/01/2016 19:28:17 FROM Vehide
Taken (ALS)
Pronerty Use Residential street, road or Pt Condition at Unchanged
residential driveway Destination

Mixed Property NN - Not mixed use Transport 4.80
Use Distance (mi)

Hazardous N - None
Materials
Re!edsed

Aid

Aid Date: 2016-04-01 19:29:32 Type of Aid: None
...
Aid Date: 2016-04-01 19:29:32 Type of Aid: None

Pr.iiieitt Care Report Page 3 of 4
02/13/17 Page 162 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
y-07
Incident: PBC16036452
Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Patient: Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Permission to Transport

PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE ("PBCFR")
I. Patient Signature

Privacy Practices Acknowledgment: by signing below, the signer acknowledges that PBCFR provided a copy of its Notice of Privacy Practices to the patient or other party with
Instructions to provide the Notice to the patient

*A copy of this form Is valid as an original*

PATIENT SIGNATURE

I authorize the submission of a claim to Medicare, Medicaid, or any other payer for any services provided to me by PBCFR now, in the past, or in the future, until such time as I
revoke this authorization in writing. I understand that I am financially responsible for the services and supplies provided to me by PBCFR, regardless of my insurance coverage, and
:n 2,onie cases, may be responsible for an amount In addition to that which was paid by my insurance. I agree to immediately remit to PBCFR any payments that I receive directly
from insurance or any source whatsoever for the services provided to me and I assign all rights to such payments to PBCFR. I authorize PBCFR to appeal payment denials or other
adverse decisions on my behalf without further authorization. I authorize and direct any holder of medical, insurance, billing or other relevant information about me to release such
information to PBCFR and its billing agents, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, and/or any other payers or insurers, and their respective agents or contractors, as
may be necessary to determine these or other benefits payable for any services provided to me by PBCFR, now, in the past, or in the future. I also authorize PBCFR to obtain
medical, insurance, billing and other relevant information about me from any party, database or other source that maintains such information.

Report Author
PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE ("PBCFR")
Report Author

'A copy of this form is valid as an original*

FIRE RESCUE CREWMEMBER STATEMENT

My signature below indicates that the information contained within this electronic patient care report (ePCR) is a true and accurate account of the events and circumstances of the
rt,.terenced incident.

Signatures

EMS Primary Care PrOVider (for Hospital Representative Unknown
this event)
Schultz, Christine
McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:49:08 2016-04-01 19:47:59
2016-04-01 19:46:57
Transfer of Patient Care
Report Author
Signed Patient
Signed
Aleman,
McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:47:37
Permission to Transport
kes-! Not Signed - Transferred Care/No
-0731 Access to Obtain Signature

Patient Care Report Page 4 of 4
02/13/17 Page 163 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Incident: PBC16036452
Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Patient: Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Patient Situation History
Patient Situation Medication NO KNOWN DRUG
Allergies ALLERGIES
Name Aleman Other Non- NONE REPORTED
F in-A Name
Arrest Data Medication
Arrest 04/01/2016 19:26:00 Allergies
tkodress 17148 30th Ln N
Date/Time
Florida
Cause Respiratory/Asphyxia
Loxahatchee Groves
Witnesses Not Witnessed
1..ode 33470
Cardiac Arrest Yes, Prior to EMS Arrival
SSNi 000-00-0000
AED Prior to No
Cir::Ider Female EMS?
White CPR Prior to No
Dales of Birth 3/7/2015 EMS?
Age 1 First Arrest Asystole
Rhythm
U nits Years
Resuscitation Initiated Chest Compressions
I h)spital Account D00011463872 Attempted By
Ni irnher
EMS
Record D513268
Number CPR Types by Compressions-Continuous
EMS Ventilation-Bag Valve Mask
Phone Numbers Hypothermia No
Used
1'hone Number. 561-662-1684
ROSCs No

Payment End of Event Expired in ED
Rhythms at Asystole
ALS Assessment Yes Destination
Pnyment Method Insurance
Possible Injury No
Was ResQPod No
used?
Cardiac Arrest Yes, Prior to EMS Arrival
Was this a CO No
incident?
Was this patient an No
Alert?
Primary Impression Cardiac Arrest
Is the patient an Yes
adult (signs of
puberty) and not
pregnant?
Is there a No
suspected or
documented
infection?

Complaints
, ••
Type: Chief (Primary) Complaint: Cardiac Arrest
Duration: 30 Time Units: Minutes

Symptoms

Symptom: Cardiac Arrest

!,• • Report Page 1 of 4
02/13/17 Page 164 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Incident: PBC16036452
Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Patient: Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Narrative
Engine and rescue arrived to find the mom holding her baby in a blanket saying that the baby was not breathing. She said she was feeding the baby a bottle and the baby was not
responding normally. Pt mother said this is her tenth child. Pt mother said the baby was a normal and healthy baby at birth and was nine pounds at birth. When asked if the patient
l,;:c1 cancer or any other illnesses the mother denied any. The patient appeared to be malnourished. Pt ribs were visible. Pt mom denies the pt being sick or having any diseases.
!:;t1 patient being one years old and being told that the baby was nine pounds at birth ten milligrams was the weight used for advanced cardiac life support doses and
;!Irionl sizes. Captain took the baby and assessed that the baby was not breathing. Pt had no pulse. Pt was placed on the stretcher. Chest compressions were started at a 15:2
to ventilation ratio about 10 cycles every 2 minutes. One rescuer was doing compressions and another rescuer was providing ventilatory assistance. A bag valve mask
,i:•ed to provide oxygen to the baby. The smallest opa was sized and found to be too large for the patient. CO2 detection device was placed on the bag valve mask and
,-.,p,e,oraohy and capnometry were detected. The capnography showed a box like wave form. No resistance was felt with the ventilatory assistance being provided. Nasopharyngeal
were sized and found to be too large for the baby. An oropharyngeal airway was sized and found to be too large for the child. Airway was maintained by head positioning
bag valve mask attached to oxygen flowing at 15 liters per minute of 100% oxygen. Ventilatory assistance was continued and symmetrical rise and fall were seen, lung sounds
equally in all four fields, no resistance was felt, and a box like wave form was seen on the monitor with a capnography reading as well. Protocols were followed for medication
administration followed by a normal saline flush. An advanced airway was considered and prepared. When the lower jaw was attempted to be displaced there was resistance that
felt, and the lower jaw was not able to be displaced. Ventilatory assistance was continued by the bag valve mask with no complications. Pediatric quick combo pads were
placed on the front and rear torso. Pt was found to be in asystole for the entire transport. A blood sugar was checked by a heel stick and the glucometer read low". 010 was pushed
through the IC with a syringe. Pt was continually monitored. Palms west hospital was notified. Upon arrival at er the nurses and doctors were given the information. Palm beach
county sheriff officers and the nurse were informed of that there is suspicion of possible abuse or neglect of the patient. Mm30731

Exam
Patient Position as Found Being Carried

DatelTime 'ASsessments Comments

2016-04-01 18:57:00 Mental Status: Unresponsive
Skin: Cold
Neurological: Not Done
Eyes: Bilateral Dilated

'Care Events
Dater-lime Event Details
2016-04-01 18:57:00 Vitals Responsiveness (AVPU): Unresponsive Heart Rate: 0 Pulse Rhythm: Absent Heart Rate Method: Palpated
Respiratory Rate: 0 Respiratory Effort: Apnetc BP Method: Cuff-Manual Palpated Only BP Systolic: 0
2016-04-01 18:57:00 Patient Assessment Crew ID: Giamberini, Andrew T
2016-04-01 18:58:00 Oxygen Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 15.000 Dose Units: Liters Per Minute Route: BVM (non-intubated) Response:
Unchanged Complication's: None Crew ID: Morzella, Steven
2016-04-01 18:58:00 Bagged Ventilations (via Mask) Crew ID: Morzella, Steven
2016-04-01 18:58:00 CPR (Manual) Prior to EMS?: No Response: Unchanged Crew ID: Giamberini, Andrew T
2016-04-01 19:01:00 10 (Intraosseous) IV Site: 10-Femoral-Left Distal Successful: Yes Response: Unchanged Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:01:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:03:00 Normal saline Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 100.000 Dose Units: Milliliters Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:04:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:08:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:10:00 dextrose 10 % Injectable Solution Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 50.000 Dose Units: Milliliters Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:12:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:15:00 Epinephrine 1:10,000 Prior to EMS: No Dosage: 0.100 Dose Units: Milligrams Route: Intraosseous (10) Response: Unchanged
Complications: None Crew ID: McKeehan, Michael

f'nh eft Core Report Page 2 of 4
02/13/17 Page 165 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

(-W
Incident: PBC16036452
--4).17A1;ff
Palm Beach County Fi re Rescue Patient: Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33 411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Crewrrimes DisPosition
Dispatch Disposition
Crew Members
Incident Number PBC16036452 Disposition Treated, Transported by EMS
Role: Paramedic Employee ID: 30731 Last Name:
Incident Type CARDIAC-ARREST McKeehan First Name: Michael Cert Level: EMT-
Transport Data
ACICh.,?1:6 17148 30TH LN N Paramedic Crew Cert ID: PMD523638
Destination Hospital-Emergency
Florida
Type Department
t.:ity Loxahatchee Crew Members
Destination Palms West Hospital
Zip Cede 33470 Name
Role: Driver/Operator, Pilot Employee ID: 22140
(.-rol..s Street CHEETHAM HILL Last Name: Morzella First Name: Steven Cert Venty patient Yes - Verified
BLVD<>DEAD END Level: EMT-Basic Crew Cert ID: EMT518644 (hospital)
Station I ESZ 221434014000 destination is
Role: Captain Employee ID: 5783 Last Name: correct?
Response Giamberini First Name: Andrew Middle Name: T
Transport Priority 1
Crew Cert ID: PMD17120 Cert Level: EMT- Priority
Cali Sign R22 Paramedic
Destination Protocol
B Shift Reasons
v cc Requested Times
911 Response (Scene) Patient refused No
!t•:;iierioe Mode to Lights and Sirens closest
Dispatched 04/01/2016 18:48:15 appropriate
iryttl of Care En Route 04/01/2016 18:49:15 facility?
ALS-Paramedic
At Scene 04/01/2016 18:55:25 Conveyances Carried
Fire Incident At Patient TO Vehicle
04/01/2016 18:56:00
F,re Incident EMS call, excluding vehicle Depart Scene Position During Supine
04/01/2016 19:04:33
i yt accident with injury Transport
At Destination 04/01/2016 19:16:05
Conveyance Carried
Pnn ,:iry Action Provide advanced life support In Service 04/01/2016 19:28:17 FROM Vehicle
(ALS)
Prorierhi Use Pt Condition at Unchanged
Residential street, road or
residential driveway Destination
Transport 4.80
Mixed Property NN - Not mixed use
Use. Distance (mi)

Ina7ardous N - None
Materials

Aid

Aid Dale: 2016-04-01 19:29:32 Type of Aid: None
A:d Date: 2016-04-01 19:29:32 Type of Aid: None

Pzi,,,,I1C.Are Report Page 3 of 4
02/13/17 Page 166 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
~tl l
Incident: PBC16036452
Palm Beach County Fire Rescue Patient Aleman,
405 Pike Road - West Palm Beach, FL 33411 Complaint: CARDIAC-ARREST
Phone: (561) 616-7000 Case Status: CLOSED
(Official document ONLY when signed by Records Custodian)

Permission to Transport

PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE ("PBCFR")
I. Patient Signature

j Privacy Practices Acknowledgment: by signing below, the signer acknowledges that PBCFR provided a copy of its Notice of Privacy Practices to the patient or other party with
instructions to provide the Notice to the patient.

'A copy of this form is valid as an original'

PA 1 !E NI SIGNATURE

I de/nerve the submission of a claim to Medicare, Medicaid, or any other payer for any services provided to me by PBCFR now, in the past, or in the future, until such time as I
rovukii this authorization in writing. I understand that I are financially responsible for the services and supplies provided to me by PBCFR, regardless of my insurance coverage, and
r..,onie cases, may be responsible for an amount In addition to that which was paid by my insurance. I agree to immediately remit to PBCFR any payments that I receive directly
ref,insurance or any source whatsoever for the services provided to me and I assign all rights to such payments to PBCFR. I authorize PBCFR to appeal payment denials or other
Adverse decisions on my behalf without further authorization. I authorize and direct any holder of medical, insurance, billing or other relevant information about me to release such
;1i-tom-Alan to PBCFR and its billing agents, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, and/or any other payers or insurers, and their respective agents or contractors, as
m..iy be necessary to determine these or other benefits payable for any services provided to me by PBCFR, now, in the past, or in the future. I also authorize PBCFR to obtain
insurance, billing and other relevant information about me from any party, database or other source that maintains such information.

Report Author
PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE ("PBCFR")
Report Author

'A copy of this form is valid as an original'

FIRE RESCUE CREWMEMBER STATEMENT

my siTiarure below indicates that the information contained within this electronic patient care report (ePCR) is a true and accurate account of the events and circumstances of the
:.-te.,,u,iiced incident.

EMS Primary Care Pitivider (for Hospital Representative Unknown
this event)
Schultz, Christine
McKeehan, Michael 2016-04-01 19:49:08 2016-04-01 19:47:59
)16-04-01 19:46:57 Transfer of Patient Care
I-!epcd Author Signed Patient
Aleman,
McKeehan, Michael
2016-04-01 19:47:37
Permission to Transport
,(4;7 Not Signed - Transferred Care/No
Access to Obtain Signature
-!70731

Potient Cere Report Page 4 of 4
02/13/17 Page 167 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PDCN 32B - REV. 6/83
POLICE DEPARTMENT, COUNTY OF NASSAU, N.Y.
SUPPORTING DEPOSITION
INSTRUCTIONS: Deponent must place signature immediately after his/her narrative statement which shall include a statement of non-permission when applicable.
Police Officer will complete boxed area of form and will witness the deponent's statement by placing signature immediately below the deponent's signature.

Case Report No. D.D. No. Defendant's Name if Known Relationship of Deponent to Property

Date & Time of Deposition Rank Name Printed Sena! No. Command
'MTNESS
Aug 1, 2016 ):4,30 Li al Det Stephen Bellamy 8069 4th Sqd
NOTICE
ANY FALSE STATEMENT MADE IN THIS DEPOSITION IS PUNISHABLE AS A CLASS A MISDEMEANOR
PURSUANT TO SECTION 210.45 OF THE PENAL LAW.

Iam Victor J. Hijuelos DOB 02/06/1972 I have read and understand the above notice.

On the 1st day of August 20 16 at about 1030 ❑ AM El PM

I, am the owner of 2 properties, one where I reside in, 2931 Morland Ave, Oceanside and the other that I was
renting out, 17148 30th Lane, North Loxahatchee, Fl 33470.1 have owned the Florida property for the past 12
years. It is a single family ranch, 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. I rented the Florida property to Alejandro Aleman.
Mr Aleman was referred to me by a former tenant. Mr Aleman rented the property from July 2015 to May 2016.
He signed a lease requiring him to pay $1700.00 monthly for rent. He lived in the residence with girlfriend Kristen
Mayer and their 10 children. Mr. Aleman would make cash rental payment directly to my bank account. I met Mr
Aleman in person around 10/04/16 when I served him with a Notice of Eviction. He was evicted from the
residence in early May due to lack of rental payment. In May 2016 I met with the Sheriffs Dept and took
possession of the residence. The residence was in disrepair. There was damage to the wall, tile and carpet. There
was feces found all over the residence. There was approximately $10,000 in damage to the property. If necessary I
could identify Mr Aleman. I am giving this statement to Det Bellamy who is writing it down for me, it is the truth.

02/13/17 Page 168 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
923
fro,M4WW, ft 1gT7' 36-2412 To:II8164159104rtfo cc Ft.' 416818416910 Paw 3 of 4 11110120134:60 PM

IN n COt..iNTY COURT FOR PALM REACH
CKK. , FLORIDA - CIVIL DIVISION

Vic • ijuelos and Amy flijuelos
Plaintiffs,

AleX eman aik/a Alejandro Alemau

Defendant, C.ase No. 502015CC0107'95XXX‘iMll
lud,ge: RY • Castor

juyiallal
l AMOZEQ1149,,ELLESZEI
r
COME NOW PLAINTIFFS, Victor Hijuelos and Amy Hijuelos t"Plaintiffs"), by and through the

under ed attorney. and Db,FENDANT Alex Alesnan wk/a Alejandro Ale a= ("lkfendant"), and hereby akxco as

folio

Defendant acknowledges that $1,700.00 was duc and owing to Plaintiffs fot rent far October 2015.

Defendant acknowledges that $1,700.00 was due and owing to Plaintilfs for rent for November 2015.

lwever, $1,000,00 of this amount is being spread out over the monthly payme its identified in paragraph

5.a.-d. below,

fiendant aclolowledges that $786.00 is due and owing to Plaintiffs for attorney lihA and expenses.

fendant agraes to pay to Plaintiffs $3,111,00 by deposit into Plaintiffs' Citibank account at the time

hat this Joint Stipulation for Settlement is signed.

aintiffs and Defendant agree as follows, All payments shall berm& by cleart,:d fit ids (c:tshier.,;' check or

oney order) &posited into Plaintiffs' Citibank account.

B. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,968,75 on or before December 1, 2015,

b. Ctfendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,968.75 on or before January 1, 2016.

c. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs 51.968.75 on or before Pebrtuiry 1. 2016.

d. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,968.75 nn or before March 2016.

a. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,700.00 on or before April 1, 2016, for April 2016 rent.

f. Plaintiffs acknowledge that Defendant is not responsible for the payment of May 2016 rent, as

Defendant paid a last month's rent deposit that will apply to May 2016 rent.

0T69IV9T99 L9 :9T STOZiOT/TT
TO 30Vd

02/13/17 Page 169 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
rVyti JArron ksx. (6,T)e242912 To: 1661641$0100terov.oc Far. +16016416810 P,g. A a, 4 11/10/2016 4:60 PM

6. Plaintiffs and Defemituit wire t hat Defendant shall vacate on or before midnight on June IF., 2016.

Flaintiffii and 1...kfendant al. tee that Defendant will pr rated ter t of $850.00 for ;two 2016 and that
it will be paid on nr befbre Juin 1, 2016,

7. The security deposit of S1,700..00 shell, be treated in aceordanee with Sec. 83.49. Florida Statutes.

8. D'Lierldarit makes the payment.: identified above, and does not intentionally damage destroy the bared

premises, and leaves the leased premises clean, and leaves appliances clean :Ind in working otJtv. he evil' be

deemed to have vacated as a tenant in good standing and his rent shall be deemed paid in full. In that event,

Plaintiffs shall not pursue :say claims for Backrent or damages that were demanded in Plaintiff's' complaint.

9. In the evtatt Defendant fails to make any of the payments identified above, or vacate by the agreed-upon

date, then upon a rectipt of an Affidavit of Non-Ccmplianco from Plaintiffs or Plaintiffs counsel, and

without hearing, the Court is hereby authorized and instruct ad to enter final judgment Plaintiffs

possession of the leased premises, directing the Clerk to foa•thwith issue a Writ of Possession which directs

he Sherill' to put Plaintiffs in possession after tut nty-foar (24) hours' notice has been posted eonspicitously

=eon. Plainiiin shag be entitled to a money judgment for my past due rent, waived rent and

rtstunding attcrtiQy foes and coats. Defendantwinves notice of hearing on application for such tisonoN'

u Liginern.

10 An executed facsimile copy of this Joint Stipulation for Settlement shall be deemed an original,

1 is reitruaents the entire avvenierit between the panic,,

12 le Court retain:, jurisdiction to enforee the terms of this Joint Stipulation for Settlement.

lley Grant, PA Alex /Liman silda Alejandro Alenaan
N NW 2nd Ave., Suite 222 17148 30th Lane North
oca itaton, 33432 Loxatiatehee, FL 33470-3601
el ophone t 877-8714300
ex 8774 8-2912

y: Alex Alernan a/k/a Alejandro Alernan
jetron .elley. Esq.
Florida liar No. 5441 Date: November ./ 2015

: November /O 2015

xilend 0169TV919g L9:9T 9TOZ/OVIT
ZO 3SVd
02/13/17 Page 170 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
IN THE COUNTY COURT FOR PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FLORIDA - CIVIL DIVISION

Victor Hijuelos and Amy Hijuelos
Plaintiffs, vs.

Alex Aleman a/lc/a Alejandro Aleman
Defendant. case No. 502015CC010795XXXXMB
Judge: - PANSE

FINAL JUDGMENT AS TO DAMAGES AND FOR POSSESSION

THIS CAUSE came before the Court upon Plaintiffs' Complaint, Court-ordered Stipulation of the parties, and

Plaintiffs' Affidavit of Non-Compliance:

It is ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Plaintiffs Victor Hijuelos and Amy Hijuelos do have and recover

from the Defendant Alex Aleman a/k/a Alejandro Aleman possession of the following premises located in Palm Beach

County, Florida, to wit: 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470-3601 and the Clerk is hereby directed to issue a

/ 2
Writ of Possession for the aforesaid premises."
T:b ce
41

DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers in Palm Beach County, Florida, on

BONED &DATED
2 Z 2016
County WOK CASVR
E
COUNTY. JUID-GE
Copies Furnished to:

Jerron Kelley, Esq., Florida Bar No: 544191, Kelley & Grant, PA, 399 NW rd Ave., suite 222, Boca Raton, FL
33432
Alex Aleman a/k/a Alejandro Aleman 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470-3601

02/13/17 Page 171 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Prom. Jorrfork Pe:cif/7+ b3e.2*12 To: IfetiSoM1010etokx co Po , +1151116oligie Pow 3 of 4 11/10/2316 4:60 PM

IN COUNTY COURT FOR PALM BEACH
CX)L. , FLORIDA - CIVIL DIVISION

Vic ijueloe and Amy Hijuelos
Plaintiffs,
vu.
Alex man aikia Alejandro Alklman

Defendant, Case No. 502015CC01079510:_70:MB
Judge: R.F - Castor

COME NOW PLIINTIFFS, Victor Hijuelos and Amy Hijuelos i''Plaintiffs"), by and through the

un ed attorney, and DEFENDANT Alex Aleman sik/a Alejandro Ale'nan ("Defendant"). and hereby agrcc as

folio

fondant acknowledges that $1,700.00 was due and owing to Plaintiffs fo rent for October 2015.

fondant acknowledges that $1,700.00 was due and owing to Plaintiffs for mitt for November 2015.

%over, $1,000.00 of this amount is being spread out over the monthly payments identified in paragraph

.a.-d. below,

fenchun acknowledges that $786.00 is due and owing to Plaintiffs for attorney ti. c and expenses.

ettdant agrees to pay to Plaintiffs $3,111.00 by deposit into Plaintiffs' Citibank ilocount at the time

hat this Joint Stipulation for Settlement is signed.

aintiffs and Defendant agree as follows, All payments shall be made by cleand fun& (c:ishier',', check or

oney order) deposited into Plaintiffs' Citibank Amami.

a. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,968.75 on or before December 1, 2015,

b. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,968.75 ctl or before January 1, 2016.

c. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1.968.75 on or before Febrtuuy 1. 2016.

d. Defendant is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,968.75 on or before March 1, 2016.

e. Defendan is to pay to Plaintiffs $1,700.00 on or before April 1, 2016, for April 2014 rent.

f Maine's acknowledge that Defendant is not responsible for the payment of May 2016 rent, as

Defendant paid a last month's rent deposit that will apply to May 2016 rent.

xiiEnd 0T6G1179T99 L9:9T 5102/0I/II fi
TO 39Vd
02/13/17 Page 172 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
fro t Artan Kt Grx (in RIS 2g4 2 Tty E51641$110Oretist cc cal t'4 1641E1!! Pig* 4 e 4 1 1 /10/2015 4:0 PM

6 Plaintiffs and Defendant apt,: :inn Defendant shall vacate only before midnight on June 16, 2016

Plaintiffs ar..el Defendant at see that Defendant will owe pr irated ire t of $850.00 for Awe 2016 and that

it will be pied on or before. Juni: 1, 2016.

The security deposit of SI,700,00 shall be treated in aceordamce with Sec. 83 49, Florida Statutes.

8. ;.t Lielendant makes the payrnerit.• identified above, and does not intentionally damage destroy the leased

premises, and leaves the leased premises clean, and leaves appliances clean in working oislt,r, he will

deemed to have vacated as :1 tenant in good standing and his rant shall he deemed pa td in full. In that event.

Plaintiffs shall not pursue .iny claims for Backrent cr damages that were demandod ire Plaintiffs. complaint.

9. 1r the evottt L)efendant tail..., to make any of the payments identified above, or vacate, h,' the agreed-upon

date.. then win a rea ipi of an Affidavit of Non-Compliance from Plaintiffs or Plairttiftb, counsel, and

witlout ileafing: the Court is hereby authorized and instructed to enter final judgmrsit Plaintiffs

possessim of the lei,sed premises, directing the Clerk to issue a Writ of Possession v.hich directs.

he Sheritl" to put Plaint. ifla in possession after tmenty-li (24; hours' notice has been posted ,:ons)+icuously

aeon Planitifts atall be entitled to a money judgirient for any }mot due rent, waived rtsit and

standing attom fees and costs. Oefendant V4i4iVeS notice of hcering stn application for such nione,.

Ain executed facsimile copy of this Joint Stipulation for Settlement shall be deemed an original.

11 This represents the entire aFeement between the pane,.

12 he Cowl rctain,, jurisdiction to enforce the terms of this Joint Stipulation for Settlement

hey Grant. PA Alex Nieman aile'a Alejandro Aleaian
399 NW 2nd Ave., Suite 222 17148 3C-th Lane North
uca Raton, 33432 Loxishatchee, FL 33470-3601
elephomet, 817-871-8300
rot: 877-

y Alex: Altman aik/a Alejandro Aienlan
Terron *ley, EN,
Florida liar No. 5441 Date: November _I 2015

)ate: November /0_ 2013

xi-land OTE51O9T95 LG :9T 5'10Z/0t/TT C.4
ze 02/13/17
39Vd
Page 173 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
IN THE COUNTY COURT FOR PALM BEACH
COUNTY, FLORIDA - CIVIL DIVISION

Victor Hijuelos and Amy Hijuelos
Plaintiffs, vs.

Alex Aleman a/k/a Alejandro Aleman
Defendant. case No. 502015CC010795XXXXMB
Judge: - PANSE

FINAL JUDGMENT AS TO DAMAGES AND FOR POSSESSION

THIS CAUSE came before the Court upon Plaintiffs' Complaint, Court-ordered Stipulation of the parties, and

Plaintiffs' Affidavit of Non-Compliance:

It is ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Plaintiffs Victor Hijuelos and Amy Hijuelos do have and recover

from the Defendant Alex Aleman a/k/a Alejandro Aleman possession of the following premises located in Palm Beach

County, Florida, to wit: 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470-3601 and the Clerk is hereby directed to issue a

Prik, ‘ Cesa...,g A / 2(
Writ of Possession for the aforesaid premises.

DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers in Palm Beach County, Florida, on
1V4.17 vtt

MOM WED
in 2l 2O6
County *0,4K CASTOR
COUNTY JUDGE
Copies Furnished to:

Jerron Kelley, Esq., Florida Bar No: 544191, Kelley & Grant, PA, 399 NW 2nd Ave., suite 222, Boca Raton, FL
33432
Alex Aleman a/k/a Alejandro Aleman 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470-3601

02/13/17 Page 174 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA, IN AND FOR
PALM BEACH COUNTY, CRIMINAL DIVISION

Palm Beach County Fire Rescue
STATE ATTORNEY SUBPOENA
405 Pike Road
PBSO CASE NO. 16-058738 West Palm Beach, FL 33411

DUCES TECUM PURSUANT TO FLORIDA STATUTE 92.153:

Run report and any and all records personnel on run for (D.O.B: 03/07/2016) on
April 1, 2016 at 1840 hrs.

Address: 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470

YOU MAY COMPLY WITH THIS SUBPOENA BY DELIVERING THE REQUESTED
RECORDS TO THE DETECTIVE SERVING THIS SUBPOENA, DETECTIVE
WILLIAM VAUGHAN, PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE, 3228 GUN
CLUB ROAD, WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406, VAUGHANWPBSO.ORG

GREETINGS:
YOUr, 6RA ii,HEREBY COMMANDED TO BE AND APPEAR BEFORE THE STATE
his assistant, in and for- Palm Beach County, Florida, at the State Attorney's
---7;9•N
'Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida, INSTANTER, on behalf of the
,/ e to appear will subject you tocontempt of Court.

WITNESS my hand and seal of this Court on
the 99 day of September, 2016.
SHARON R. BOCK, C19 and Comptroller

frt.( JI L RICHSTONE By:
ill TO 01
Assistant State Attorney Deputy Clerk
*****************************************************************************

Received this subpoena on the day of , 2016, and executed the same on
the day of , 2016, by delivering a True Copy thereof to the within named
witness in the County of Palm Beach, State of Florida.
RIC L. BRADSHAW, SHERIFF

By:
Deputy Sheriff

02/13/17 Page 175
vao
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY
FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY

DAVID ARONBERG
STATE ATTORNEY

September 28, 2016

To whom it may concern:

Pursuant to an official investigation being conducted by the Office of the State Attorney
of a suspected felony, it is requested that your company furnish INSTANTER:

Run report and any and all records personnel on run for (D.O.B: 03/07/2016) on
April 1, 2016 at 1840 hrs.

Address: 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470

YOU ARE NOT TO DISCLOSE THE EXISTENCE OF THIS REQUEST. Any such
disclosure could obstruct and impede the prosecution being conducted and thereby interfere with
the enforcement of the law.

Thank you for your cooperation.

INVESTIGATING OFFICER

L/L6C, Pk(.4) hata_z__
J L RICHSTONE
Assistant State Attorney
401 N. Dixie Highway
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

02/13/17 Page 176 Public Records Request No.: 17-058 yal
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA, IN AND FOR
PALM BEACH COUNTY, CRIMINAL DIVISION

STATE ATTORNEY SUBPOENA Palm Beach County Fire Rescue
405 Pike Road
PBSO CASE NO. 16-058738 West Palm Beach, FL 33411

DUCES TECUM PURSUANT TO FLORIDA STATUTE 92.153:

Run report and any and all records personnel on run for (D.O.B: 03/07/2016) on
April 1, 2016 at 1840 hrs.

Address: 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470

YOU MAY COMPLY WITH THIS SUBPOENA BY DELIVERING THE REQUESTED
RECORDS TO THE DETECTIVE SERVING THIS SUBPOENA, DETECTIVE
WILLIAM VAUGHAN, PALM BEACH COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE, 3228 GUN
CLUB ROAD, WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406, VAUGHANW(&,PBSO.ORG

GREETINGS:
YOU, 6.RGE, HEREBY COMMANDED TO BE AND APPEAR BEFORE THE STATE
•• -'- ;01.4:",i-4 kis assistant, in and for Palm Beach County, Florida, at the State Attorney's
'Dixie Highway, West Palm Beach, Florida, INSTANTER, on behalf of the
.-)5ur toe appear will subject you to contempt of Court.

I.
WITNESS my hand and seal of this Court on
the c9S day of September, 2016.
SHARON R. BOCK, Cl- r and Comptroller

trir JI L RICHSTONE
Al
By: I kr 'Ph
Assistant State Attorney Deputy Clerk
*************************************** *************************************

Received this subpoa a on the day of TWO--, 2016, and executed the same on
the ((o day of -1 :alt tl 'W 2016, by delivering a True Copy thereof to the within named
witness in the County of Palm Beach, State of Florida.
RIC L. BRADS , SHERI

1334-
Deputy Sheriff
Wtc-Le AO a

02/13/17 Page 177 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
OFFICE OF THE STATE ATTORNEY
FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY

DAVID ARONBERG
STATE ATTORNEY

September 28, 2016

To whom it may concern:

Pursuant to an official investigation being conducted by the Office of the State Attorney
of a suspected felony, it is requested that your company furnish INSTANTER:

Run report and any and all records personnel on run for (D.O.B: 03/07/2016) on
April 1, 2016 at 1840 hrs.

Address: 17148 30th Lane North, Loxahatchee, FL 33470

YOU ARE NOT TO DISCLOSE THE EXISTENCE OF THIS REQUEST. Any such
disclosure could obstruct and impede the prosecution being conducted and thereby interfere with
the enforcement of the law.

Thank you for your cooperation.

INVESTIGATING ICER

JILL RICHSTONE
Assistant State Attorney
401 N. Dixie Highway
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

02/13/17 Page 178 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
AFFIDAVIT AND APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINETEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR MARTIN COUNTY, FLORIDA

THE STATE OF FLORIDA,
COUNTY OF MARTIN

BEFORE ME, Judge in and for Martin County, personally
appeared this day, Detective Vionide Saint Jean of the Palm Beach County Sheriffs
Office. After having been duly sworn, Detective Vionide Saint Jean, deposes and states
that she has good reason to believe that certain evidence located in Martin County,
Florida, as described below, is relevant to the commission of a felony.

EVIDENCE TO BE SEIZED:

Records specifically and only pertaining to a white female with a date of
birth of including the medical records which include, but not limited to,
emergency room records, emergency medical service transport records, x-ray
images/reports, hospital records concerning any and all medical treatment, and blood
and/or urine toxicology testing/results from the time of birth at Martin Memorial Medical
Center on to April 01, 2016.

LOCATION:
The evidence to be seized is in the custody of or under the control of: Martin Memorial
Medical Center Medical Records Department located at 200 SE Hospital Ave, Stuart, FL
34994.

Directions to the place to be searched: From 3228 Gun Club Rd, travel east on Gun Club
Rd to Congress Ave. Turn left onto S Congress Ave and take the ramp for Southern Blvd
east. From Southern Blvd, travel north on 1-95, to SR-76, travel east toward Stuart. At
roundabout, take first exit onto SR-Al A/SE Ocean Blvd. Turn left onto SE Hospital
Ave. Martin Memorial Medical Center is located at 200 SE Hospital Ave.

And, there is present on the above described location evidence:

Records specifically and only pertaining to a white female with a date of
birth of including the medical records as described within the evidence to be
seized section of this affidavit.

VIOLATION OF LAW:

The above described evidence is material and relevant to proving the following violations
of law:
1) One count of FIRST DEGREE MURDER, FSS 782.04(1)(A)(1) AND (1)(A)(2)
2) One count of AGGRAVATED CHILD ABUSE, FSS 827.03(1)(B) AND (2)(A)

Page 1 of 3 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 179 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
PROBABLE CAUSE:

That the facts establishing the grounds for this application and the probable cause for
believing that such facts exist are as follows: On 4/1/16, thirteen-month-old
a human being, was transported to Palms West Hospital by Palm Beach County
Fire Rescue where she was pronounced deceased by their staff Dr. Estrada told your
affiant that died from extreme malnourishment.

On 4/2/16, the autopsy was conducted by Palm Beach County Medical Examiner Dr.
Gertrude M. Juste (reference M.E. Case #16-0525). The medical examiner results
determined the manner of death was a homicide and the cause of death
was inanition due to neglect. The medical examiner report stated at the time of birth
weighed 8 lbs, 15 ounces and at the time of death weighed
7.321bs. The medical examiner also determined that the child suffered from: influenza
B, E. Coli, beta-hemolytic Streptococcus Group B and haemophilus influenza. There was
also positive cultures for staphylococcus aureus, heamophilus influenza and
streptococcus viridans.

The requested medical records for from Martin Memorial Medical Center
will show if she was born with any medical conditions or birth defects and any treatment
she may have had for those conditions prior to her death. Any evidence seized or taken
shall be impounded for use as evidence at any trial of criminal or penal cause.

ANALYSIS / CONCLUSION:
Your Affiant, Vionide Saint-Jean, is a duly appointed Deputy Sheriff for Palm Beach
County, and has all the powers of a law enforcement officer in and for Palm Beach
County, Florida. Your Affiant has been employed with the Palm Beach County Sheriff s
Office continuously since April 2006. Your Affiant is registered with and dual certified
by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Criminal Justice Standards and Training
Commission in both law enforcement and corrections. Your Affiant was previously
assigned to the Eagle Academy for one year (2009-2010) and most recently Road Patrol.
This unit acts as the first responders to any calls for service including but not limited to
suspicious incidents, drug offenses, assaults, domestic incidents, crimes in progress as
well as delayed crimes, and other general assignment cases. Currently, Your Affiant is
assigned as a Detective to Special Investigation Division (SID), which investigates to
include but not limited to Crimes against Children, Sex Crimes, Crimes against the
Elderly, Child Abuse, Child Deaths and Homicides. Your Affiant has completed
numerous hours of training related to law enforcement including, Advanced Report
Writing Techniques, Crisis Intervention Team, Field Training Officer, Crimes against
Children, Domestic Violence and Instructor Techniques.

Your Affiant avers that the information contained in the above described records is
important and relevant evidence to help establish any medical conditions of
on the date of her birth, at Martin Memorial Medical Center until her
death on April 1, 2016.

Page 2 of 3 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 180 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
EXECUTION OF WARRANT:

The search warrant shall be served by your Affiant or any other officer pursuant to
Florida Statues 933.07, and said warrant may be served on Sunday (in the daytime or the
nighttime) if so necessary.

WHEREFORE, Affiant swears under oath that the above information is true, and requests
the issuance of a search/seizure warrant to search and seize the records and evidence as
previously described and affirmed.

AFFIANT

Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of , 2016.

JUDGE IN AND FOR
MARTIN COUNTY, FLORIDA

Page 3 of 3 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 181 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
(4?
SEARCH WARRANT

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINETEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA

THE STATE OF FLORIDA,
COUNTY OF ST. LUCIE

IN THE NAME OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, TO ALL AND SINGULAR:

The Commissioner of the Florida Department of Law Enforcement or any of his duly constituted Special
Agents, any State Attorney Investigator, the Sheriff of St Lucie County and his lawful deputies, all police
officers in St Lucie County, Florida,

WHEREAS, Detective Vionide Saint-Jean of the Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office deposes and states under
oath before the undersigned, the , JUDGE in and for 19TH Judicial Circuit, and also states
in writing in the Affidavit and Application for Search Warrant, hereto attached and made a part of this warrant,
the following:

Certain facts known to this Affiant constitute probable cause to believe that evidence of a crime exists
within the medical records specifically pertaining to (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a white male with
date of birth , (a white male with date of birth (a
white male with date of birth ), (a white male with date of birth
(a white female with date of birth ), (a white male with date of
birth (a white male with date of birth (a white
female, date of birth, until April 01, 2016).

LOCATION:
The evidence to be seized is in the custody of or under the control of: Tender Care Pediatrics, 2115 S.E.
Lennard Road, Port St. Lucie, FL, 34952.

Directions to the place to be searched: From 3228 Gun Club Rd, travel east on Gun Club Rd to S Congress
Ave. Turn left onto S Congress Ave and take the ramp to Southern Blvd east. From Southern Blvd, travel
north onto 1-95. From 1-95, take the ramp for SR-76 East toward Stuart. Turn left onto US-1 N/SR-5
N/SW Federal Hwy. Turn right onto SE Lennard Rd. Tender Care Pediatrics is located at 2115 SE
Lennard Rd.

EVIDENCE TO BE SEIZED:
The evidence sought through this warrant and located in or on the above described premises, is described
as follows:

A copy of any and all records pertaining to, (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a white male with date of birth
), Aleman (a white male with date of birth (a white male
with date of birth (a white male with date of birth
(a white female with date of birth (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a white female
Page 1 of 2 Warrant Case # 16-058738

02/13/17 Page 182 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
7
with a date of birth until the date of her death (04/01/2016). This is to include all medical
records but not limited to, patient logs, prescription history from doctor visits, any and all medical
treatment received from doctor visits at Tender Care Pediatrics.

VIOLATION OF LAW:

The above described evidence is material and relevant to proving the following violations of law:
1) First Degree Murder per F.S.S. 782.04 (1)(a)(1) and 782.04 (1)(a)(2)
2) Aggravated Child Abuse per F.S.S. 827.03 (1)(a) and (b)
3) Child Neglect F.S.S. 827.03 (2)(d)

NOW THEREFORE, this Affiant or any other officer pursuant to Florida Statutes 933.07, are hereby
commanded, with proper and necessary assistance, in the name of the State of Florida, in the daytime or in the
nighttime, or on Sunday, within ten (10) days from the date of the signing of the warrant, to enter the said
premises as described above to seize the evidence as described above, and to bring the evidence and any person
or persons arrested in connection therewith before a Magistrate or any other Court having jurisdiction of the
above named offense. Such persons will be dealt with according to law.

Affiant, or any other officer pursuant to Florida Statute Fl 933.07, is also commanded to
deliver a copy of the warrant, as well as a written, itemized and true inventory of the evidence seized and
receipt for the same, to the person named in the warrant or his attorney. Such inventory shall be in duplicate
and signed by this Affiant or any other officer pursuant to Florida Statute 933.07 who serves the warrant and
seizes the evidence.

FURTHER, this court directs that the Affiant keep the original Affidavit and Application in support of this
Search Warrant, in the custody of the executing agency until further Order of the Court or until release by the
executing agency.

The original warrant and original written, itemized and sworn true inventory shall be returned and filed with
the Clerk of Court as stated above within ten (10) days of the issuance of this warrant.

FURTHER any property seized or taken shall be impounded for use as evidence at any trial.

WITNESS my hand and seal this day of , 2016.

JUDGE in and for the 19th Judicial Circuit

Page 2 of 2 Warrant Case # 16-058738

02/13/17 Page 183 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
AFFIDAVIT AND APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINETEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA

THE STATE OF FLORIDA,
COUNTY OF ST. LUCIE

BEFORE ME, , Judge in and for 19th Judicial Circuit, personally appeared
this day, Detective Vionide Saint-Jean of the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office. After
having been duly sworn, Detective Vionide Saint-Jean deposes and states that she has
good reason to believe that certain evidence located in St. Lucie County, Florida, as
described below, is relevant to the commission of a felony.

EVIDENCE TO BE SEIZED:

A copy of any and all records pertaining to, (a white male with date of
birth (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth ), Aleman (a white male with
date of birth (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a white
female with date of birth (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth
(a white female with a date of birth until the date of her death 04/01/2016),
including the medical records which include, but not limited to, patient logs, prescription
history from doctor visits, any and all medical treatment received from doctor visits at
Tender Care Pediatrics.

LOCATION:
The evidence to be seized is in the custody of or under the control of: Tender Care
Pediatrics, 2115 S.E. Lennard Road, Port St. Lucie, FL, 34952.

Directions to the place to be searched: From 3228 Gun Club Rd, travel east on Gun Club
Rd to S Congress Ave. Turn left onto S Congress Ave and take the ramp to Southern
Blvd east. From Southern Blvd, travel north onto 1-95. From 1-95, take the ramp for SR-
76 East toward Stuart. Turn left onto US-1 N/SR-5 N/SW Federal Hwy. Turn right onto
SE Lennard Rd. Tender Care Pediatrics is located at 2115 SE Lennard Rd.

And, there is present on the above described location evidence:
Any and all records pertaining to (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a
white male with date of birth ), Aleman (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a white female with date of
birth (a white male with date of birth
(a white male with date of birth (a white female with

Page 1 of 5 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 184 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
a date of birth until the date of her death 04/01/2016), including the medical
records as described within the evidence to be seized section of this affidavit.

VIOLATION OF LAW:

The above described evidence is material and relevant to proving the following violations
of law:

1) First Degree Murder per F.S.S. 782.04 (1)(a)(1) and 782.04 (1)(a)(2)
2) Aggravated Child Abuse per F.S.S. 827.03 (1)(a) and (b)
3) Child Neglect F.S.S. 827.03 (2)(d)

PROBABLE CAUSE:

That the facts establishing the grounds for this application and the probable cause for
believing that such facts exist are as follows:

On Friday, April, 01, 2016, I arrived at Palms West Hospital located at, 13001 Southern
Blvd, in Loxahatchee Florida, Palm Beach County, in reference to the death of a human
being, 13 month white female, date of birth Upon arrival I
spoke to the Emergency Room Pediatrician, Dr. Estrada, who declared the time of death,
approximately 7:26 p.m. and believed the cause of death was from extreme
malnourishment. I proceeded to where the deceased child was being held in emergency
room #1.

Upon entering the room I made the following observation of body: The
child's body appeared very frail and small in size, lying in the supine position.
body did not look like that of an average one-year-old child. The child's weight at death
was approximately seven pounds. The child's skin appeared very loose and wrinkled in
texture. The skin on the child's vaginal and buttocks area appeared very red in color. The
skin texture around her vaginal and buttocks area appeared raw with sores and with
obvious breakage of the skin. The child had what appeared to be a dark colored, circular
bruise around her left eye. While viewing the mouth of the child I observed she did not
have any developed teeth for her age. On the child's body there was a very fuzzy, fine
growth of hair covering her body and forehead.

During my observation of the child's posterior there was a significantly large amount of
dark hair growing on her upper back. On April 02, 2016, at approximately 9:30 a.m., I
observed the autopsy of conducted by Palm Beach County Medical
Examiner, Dr. Gertude M. Juste (reference M.E. Case #16-0525). On Wednesday,
07/13/2016, I received a copy of Dr. Juste's report. She determined the manner of
death a homicide caused by inanition due to neglect. The medical examiner
report stated at the time of birth weighed (81bs, 15 ounces) and at the time
of death weighed (7.32 lbs.). The medical examiner also determined that
the child suffered from: Influenza B, E. Coli, Beta-hemolytic Streptococcus Group B and

Page 2 of 5 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 185 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
haemophilus influenza. There was also positive cultures for staphylococcus aureus,
haemophilus influenza and streptococcus viridans.

On Saturday, April 2, 2016, due to the lack of cooperation from parents of the above
named children a search warrant had to be obtained to gain access into the home. While
executing the search warrant it was discovered that there was no food in the home. There
was only one feeding bottle found in the home for and a half container of generic
brand Similac baby formula powder. There was no crib but instead a dirty playpen that
appeared to convert into a basinet on top was found next to the bed of the master
bedroom. Inside of the kitchen the garbage cans were filled with dog feces which flies
and fleas were hovering over. In the kitchen pantry there were only two large boxes of
instant mash potatoes found. There were two refrigerators in the home. One was a newer
model styled refrigerator that sat inside of the kitchen area which was completely empty.
The other refrigerator was an older model styled refrigerator which sat on the opposite
side of the kitchen. The outside the refrigerator was filthy. Inside the refrigerator there
was a half-gallon of milk, another gallon of some unknown chunky liquid that appeared
to be expired and rotten. There were very limited edible items for the children to eat.
There were a couple cans of soup and some large sized bottles of condiments such as
ketchup and mustard and a half loaf of moldy bread.

The carpets in the bedrooms were black in color, stained, wet, sticky and had a reeking
odor. There were two toilets, one in the master bedroom which was occupied by the
parents and the other in the main hallway which appeared to be the older children's
bathroom. The toilets were filled with unflushed feces and urine and it appeared as
though the toilet was not working. Inside of the laundry room was a pile of clothes so
high it was difficult to open the door. The door had to be pushed with great force in order
to see inside. The clothes were all soiled and reeking of urine. The pile of clothing was
stacked so high it blocked the access door which led into the garage. There was a load of
laundry that appeared to have been sitting inside the washing machine for weeks because
the clothes started to smell like a wet buildup of mildew. Department of Children and
Families Investigator who was on scene spoke to the Aleman's and family
who were nearby on scene briefly and explained to the parents that the other nine(9)
children were going to be removed and placed into Department of Children and Families
custody due to the nature of this case and the deplorable living conditions of the home.
On April, 06, 2016, forensic interviews and forensic medical exams were conducted of
the Aleman children at the Child Protection Team located in Palm Beach County, Florida
after they were taken into Department of Children and Families custody. The interviews
were conducted by Case Coordinator and the forensic medical exams were
conducted by Dr. William Rosenstein. During the forensic interviews of the Aleman
children it was discovered that only the three oldest of the children were able to properly
express themselves verbally. During the interview with eight-year-old Tanner Aleman it
became apparent the he and the younger children have a severe speech impediment which
made it very hard to understand or make out what the children were trying to say during
the interview. The older children that were verbal stated they did not attend school but
they were home schooled by their mother. During the interviews of the rest of the
children it was apparent that none of the children were being educated at home due to

Page 3 of 5 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 186 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
their inability to properly communicate using any real form of dialect. Per the Child
Protection Team forensic medical exam there were positive findings for medical neglect,
dental neglect, educational neglect, emotional neglect and environmental endangerment
of all nine of the Aleman children who remain in the custody of Department of Children
and Families.

Your affiant spoke to Mrs. Meyer-Aleman who stated all ten of her children were born
healthy with absolutely no medical issues or complications. The mother stated
doctor was an Indian woman located in Port St. Lucie, Florida. Mrs. Meyer-Aleman told
me last saw the doctor in December, 2015. During this investigation I was able to
locate the doctor's office of Dr. Anitha Jagadish in Port St. Lucie, Florida, Tender Care
Pediatrics. It was discovered that several of the other Aleman siblings were patients at Dr.
Jagadish's office but not the deceased as stated by the mother. This affiant believes that
obtaining the medical records of the above named individuals will show if any or all of
the above mentioned individuals received medical care as stated by the mother and if so
to what degree. These medical records will be probative in determining if the parents of
were aware of the availability of medical care provided for any other
treated child, but willfully failed to provide medical care to in light of her
numerous medical conditions and her severely malnourished appearance. This affiant
also believes that obtaining these medical records of the all of the above mentioned
individuals will show if any or all of the above named individuals may have or had the
same or similar ailments of the decedent child, as well as any medical
condition that could account for the children who were unable to communicate verbally.
Any evidence seized or taken shall be impounded for use as evidence at any trial of any
criminal or penal cause.

ANALYSIS / CONCLUSION:
Your Affiant, Vionide Saint-Jean, is a duly appointed Deputy Sheriff for Palm Beach
County, and has all the powers of a law enforcement officer in and for Palm Beach
County, Florida. Your Affiant has been employed with the Palm Beach County Sheriffs
Office continuously since April 2006. Your Affiant is registered with and dual certified
by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Criminal Justice Standards and Training
Commission in both law enforcement and corrections. Your Affiant was previously
assigned to the Eagle Academy for one year (2009-2010) and most recently Road Patrol.
This unit acts as the first responders to any calls for service including but not limited to
suspicious incidents, drug offenses, assaults, domestic incidents, crimes in progress as
well as delayed crimes, and other general assignment cases. Currently, Your Affiant is
assigned as a Detective to Special Investigation Division (SID), which investigates to
include but not limited to Crimes against Children, Sex Crimes, Crimes against the
Elderly, Child Abuse, Child Deaths and Homicides. Your Affiant has completed
numerous hours of training related to law enforcement including, Advanced Report
Writing Techniques, Crisis Intervention Team, Field Training Officer, Crimes against
Children, Domestic Violence, Instructor Techniques and Interviews and Interrogation.
Your Affiant has attended national and state level conferences and seminars related but
not limited to the abuse of children.

Page 4 of 5 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 187 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
V3.2
EXECUTION OF WARRANT:

The search warrant shall be served by your Affiant or any other officer pursuant to
Florida Statues 933.07, and said warrant may be served on Sunday (day or night time) if
so necessary.

WHEREFORE, Affiant swears under oath that the above information is true, and requests
the issuance of a search/seizure warrant to search and seize the records and evidence as
previously described and affirmed.

AFFIANT

Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of , 2016.

JUDGE IN AND FOR 19th
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT

Page 5 of 5 Affidavit Case # 16-058738
02/13/17 Page 188 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
VZ3
SEARCH WARRANT

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINETEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR MARTIN, FLORIDA

THE STATE OF FLORIDA,
COUNTY OF MARTIN

IN THE NAME OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, TO ALL AND SINGULAR:

The Commissioner of the Florida Department of Law Enforcement or any of his duly constituted
Special Agents, any State Attorney Investigator, the Sheriff of Martin County and his lawful
deputies, all police officers in Martin County, Florida,

WHEREAS, Detective Vionide Saint Jean of the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office deposes and
states under oath before the undersigned, the , JUDGE in and for Martin County, and
also states in writing in the Affidavit and Application for Search Warrant, hereto attached and made
a part of this warrant, the following:

Certain facts known to this Affiant constitute probable cause to believe that evidence of a crime
may exist within the medical records specifically and only pertaining to a white
female with a date of birth of

LOCATION:
The evidence to be seized is in the custody of or under the control of: Martin MemorialMedical
Center Medical Records Department located at 200 SE Hospital Ave, Stuart, FL 34994.

Directions to place to be searched: From 3228 Gun Club Rd, travel east on Gun Club Rd to
Congress Ave. Turn left onto S Congress Ave and take the ramp for Southern Blvd east. From
Southern Blvd travel north on 1-95 to SR-76, travel east toward Stuart. At roundabout, take first
exit onto SR-Al A/SE Ocean Blvd. Turn left onto SE Hospital Ave. Martin Memorial Medical
Center is located at 200 SE Hospital Ave.

EVIDENCE TO BE SEIZED:
The evidence sought through this warrant and located in or on the above described premises, is
described as follows:

Records specifically and only pertaining to a white female with a date of birth of
including the medical records which include, but not limited to, emergency room records,
emergency medical service transport records, x-ray images/reports, hospital records concerning
any and all medical treatment, and blood and/or urine toxicology testing/results from the time of
birth at Martin Memorial Medical Center on to her death on 04/01/2016.
Page 1 of 2 Warrant Case # 16-058738

02/13/17 Page 189 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
VIOLATION OF LAW:

The above described evidence is material and relevant to proving the following violations of law:
1) One count of FIRST DEGREE MURDER, FSS 782.04(1)(A)(1) AND (1)(A)(2)
2) One count of AGGRAVATED CHILD ABUSE, FSS 827.03(1)(B) AND (2)(A)

NOW THEREFORE, this Affiant or any other officer pursuant to Florida Statutes 933.07,
are hereby commanded, with proper and necessary assistance, in the name of the State of Florida, in
the daytime or in the nighttime, or on Sunday, within ten (10) days from the date of the signing of the
warrant, to enter the said premises as described above to seize the evidence as described above, and
to bring the evidence and any person or persons arrested in connection therewith before a Magistrate
or any other Court having jurisdiction of the above named offense. Such persons will be dealt with
according to law.

Affiant, or any other officer pursuant to Florida Statute 0 933.07, is also commanded to
deliver a copy of the warrant, as well as a written, itemized and true inventory of the evidence
seized and receipt for the same, to the person named in the warrant or his attorney. Such inventory
shall be in duplicate and signed by this Affiant or any other officer pursuant to Florida Statute 933.07
who serves the warrant and seizes the evidence.

FURTHER, this court directs that the Affiant keep the original Affidavit and Application in support
of this Search Warrant, in the custody of the executing agency until further Order of the Court or
until release by the executing agency.

The original warrant and original written, itemized and sworn true inventory shall be returned and
filed with the Clerk of Court as stated above within ten (10) days of the issuance of this warrant.

FURTHER any property seized or taken shall be impounded for use as evidence at any trial.

WITNESS my hand and seal this day of , 2016.

JUDGE in and for Martin County

Page 2 of 2 Warrant Case # 16-058738

02/13/17 Page 190 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
q33--
I/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

Event Chronology -- E1600296257
El System Comments
Time Date Terminal Operator Action
EVENT CREATED: Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC , Cross Streets=CHEETHAM HILL BLVD /DEAD END
6:48:24 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll 54122 , Address=LION COUNTRY SAFARI TOWER NW FACE , Call Source=ANIALI , Phone Number=(772)
475-4478
Agency=PBSO, Group=D15, Beat=15-11, Status=A, Pnority=1, ETA=0, Hold Type=0, Primary
Unit:451312, Primary Member=6972, Current=F, Open Current=F, Type Code=73-MAN DOWN/SICK
PERSON
6:48:24 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 22. EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 18:48:24
(561) 511-1908 -80.31731 1 +26.7232
1 YOA NOT BREATHING**EMS LL/51***
6:48:32 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21886 Unit=15B12, Status=DP, Location-17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=6972
6:48:51 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21888 EVENT COMMENT=1556--48
6:48:55 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21888 Unit=1556, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=4356
6:49:03 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21888 EVENT COMMENT=1556--UNIT CODE
COMMO SPV AWARE
6:49:04 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll alf22 EVENT COMMENT=EMS GIVING CPR INSTRUCTIONS
6:49:06 PM 4/1/2016 $15812 On Unit=15812, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=6972
6:49:07 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21888 EVENT COMMENT=151312---CODE
6:49:35 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 2.1888 EVENT COMMENT=1039 UPDATE REF CPR
236U AWARE
6:50:22 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll EVENT COMMENT=MOTHER DOING CPR....TELLING EMS THAT BABY IS GE! iING COLD
6:50:35 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21888 EVENT COMMENT=1039 •
6:50:55 PM 4/1/2016 pbiarl 9443, Unit=1556, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=4356
6:50:55 PM 4/1/2016 $236U 24992 Unit=236U, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=24992
6:50:55 PM 4/1/2016 hqc13 22428 Unit=1556, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=4356
Unit=15S6, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
6:51:01 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 21888
Employee=4356
EVENT UPDATED: Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC , Cross Streets=CHEETHAM HILL BLVD /DEAD END
6:51:03 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll .512 Name=ALEMAN,KRISTIN Address=LION COUNTRY SAFARI TOWER NW FACE , Call Source=ANIALI
, Phone Number=(772) 475-4478
Agency=PBSO, Group=D15, Beat=15-11, Status=A, Priority=1, ETA=0, Hold Type=0, Primary
Unit=15612, Primary Member=6972, Current=F, Open Current=F, Type Code=73-MAN DOWN/SICK
PERSON
6:51:11 PM 4/1/2016 $15S6 515L Unit=1556, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=4356
EVENT COMMENT=MOTHER IS NOT DOING CPR PROPERLY/IS HESISTANT TO FOLLOW
6:52:02 PM 4/1/2016 hqc11 5E2 INSTRUCTIONS REF HURTING
BABY
6:52:55 PM 4/1/2016 arulobbyl 19009579 Unit=236U, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=24992
6:52:59 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll 5467, EVENT COMMENT=BABY NOT RESPONDING/STILL SAYING THAT BABY IS GE i I ING COLD
6:55:17 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll 5467 EVENT COMMENT=BABY NOT RESPONDING/NOT MOVING
Unit=236U, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
6:56:32 PM 4/1/2016 hqinq1 8122
Employee=24992
6:56:42 PM 4/1/2016 hqcll 5467 EVENT COMMENT=EMS IS 97
6:57:01 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 $82.2 EVENT COMMENT=1039
6:57:19 PM 4/1/2016 $15B12 5.912 Unit=15E312, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=6972
7:01:45 PM 4/1/2016 $15S6 1.15 Unit=1556, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=4356
7:02:19 PM 4/1/2016 hqc2 2122 Unit=15612, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=6972
7:02:19 PM 4/1/2016 hqc5 24900 Unit=15612, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=6972
7:03:18 PM 4/1/2016 $236U 24992 Unit=236U, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=24992

02/13/17 Page 191 Public Records
https://netviewer.pbso.org/netviewer/inquiry/evchron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=l&FromInquiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 9:39:36Request
AM] No.: 17-058
9,34
I/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

7:06:45 PM 4/1/2016 hqinql 1122 Unit=15S6, Status=,, , Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=4356

7:07:01 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 Unit=151312, Status-CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
U.22 Employee=6972

7:07:02 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 Unit=1556, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
UZI Employee=4356

7:10:05 PM 4/1/2016 Unit=15S6, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
hqr9 8873
Employee=4356
Unit=15S6, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=4356
7:10:05 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 8873 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 19:10:05
7:12:36 PM 4/1/2016 hqc8 21888 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/01/16 19:12:36
** »» by: DEBRA C. SCHWARZ on terminal: hqc8
7:12:41 PM 4/1/2016 hqc8 21888 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/01/16 19:12:41
** »» by: DEBRA C. SCHWARZ on terminal: hqc8
Unit=15S6, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
7:20:07 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9
Employee=4356
7:20:18 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 UZI EVENT COMMENT=15S6 -- 10108 PALMS WEST

7:25:07 PM 4/1/2016 hqr11 Unit=15S6, Status"—, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
23116
Employee=4356
7:26:48 PM 4/1/2016 $236U 24992 Unit=236U, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=-24992

7:26:58 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 I82.1 Unit=236U, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=24992

7:26:59 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 8873 Unit=236U, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=24992
7:26:59 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 8873 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 19:26:59
7:28:27 PM 4/1/2016 $15812 6912 EVENT COMMENT=** Case number 16058738 has been assigned
** »» by: CHAD M. EASTERDAY on terminal: $15612
CASE NUMBER ASSIGNED=16058738

7:29:35 PM 4/1/2016 Unit=1556, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC:
hqr9
@PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=4356

7:31:58 PM 4/1/2016 Unit=236U, Status"—, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
hqc4
Employee=24992
7:33:45 PM 4/1/2016 supvl 2.211 EVENT COMMENT=1039 VCD HOMICIDE
7:37:38 PM 4/1/2016 supv2 7725 EVENT COMMENT=499H ADV'G THIS WILL BE FOR SID NOT VCD

7:40:46 PM 4/1/2016 hqinql 8122 Unit=236U, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC:
@PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=24992
7:42:41 PM 4/1/2016 supv2 7725 EVENT COMMENT=1039 SGT KEITH SID
7:55:56 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 22411 Unit=265U, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=6884
7:55:58 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 22411 Unit=267U, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=2092

7:56:07 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 Unit=265U, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
77411
Employee=6884
Unit=265U, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=6884
7:56:07 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 22411 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 19:56:07

7:56:09 PM 4/1/2016 Unit=265U, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
$265U 6884
Employee=6884

7:56:12 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 Unit=267U, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
22iLl Employee=2092
Unit=267U, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=2092
7:56:13 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 22411 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 19:56:13
7:56:24 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 22411 Unit=61331, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=24088

7:56:32 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 22411 Unit=6B31, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=24088
Unit=6B31, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=24088

02/13/17 Page 192 Public Records
https://netviewer.pbso.orginetviewer/inquiry/evchron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=1&FromInquiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 9:39:36Request
AM] No.: 17-058
c(-37
I/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

7:56:33 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 22411 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 19:56:33
7:56:50 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 22411 EVENT COMMENT=267U -- 1051 TO PALMS WEST REF THIS
Unit=267U, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
7:58:02 PM 4/1/2016 $267U 2092
Employee=2092
7:58:26 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 22,111 EVENT COMMENT=267U -- SAME TRF
Unit=6B31, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
7:59:26 PM 4/1/2016 $6831 24088
Employee=24088
8:06:13 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 Unit=9821, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
8:06:17 PM 4/1/2016 $9821 20328 Unit=9B21, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
Unit=9B21, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
8:06:25 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9
Employee=20328
Unit=9621, Status=ER, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=20328
8:07:21 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 a$22 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI search completed at 04/01/16 20:07:21
8:08:04 PM 4/1/2016 hqrl 212_e6 Unit=1B24, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=18352
8:08:07 PM 4/1/2016 $1824 18352 Unit=1824, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=18352
8:08:41 PM 4/1/2016 hqrll 7218 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/01/16 20:08:41
** >>» by: CHRISTINA GREEN on terminal: hqrll
8:08:48 PM 4/1/2016 hqrll EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/01/16 20:08:48
** »» by: CHRISTINA GREEN on terminal: hqrll
Unit=9B21, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
8:16:55 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9
Employee=20328
Unit=265U, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
8:16:58 PM 4/1/2016 $265U 6884 Employee=6884
Unit=61331, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
8:17:20 PM 4/1/2016 $6831 24088
Employee=24088
8:17:22 PM 4/1/2016 hqrl 2.02m EVENT COMMENT=1B24 -- 97 AND SW TO WR2A
8:17:26 PM 4/1/2016 hqrl 20286 Unit=1624, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=18352

8:17:33 PM 4/1/2016 hqrl Unit=1824, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
20286
Employee=18352
Unit=1824, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=18352
8:17:33 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 20286 EVENT COMMENT=** LOT search completed at 04/01/16 20:17:33
8:19:38 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 2.1188 EVENT COMMENT=267U -- OUT AT PALMS WEST SW WR2

8:19:50 PM 4/1/2016 hqr4 Unit=267U, Status=CL, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
21888
Employee=2092
Unit=267U, Status=AR, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
Employee=2092
8:19:50 PM 4/1/2016 cad-01 21888 EVENT COMMENT=" LOI search completed at 04/01/16 20:19:50

8:21:55 PM 4/1/2016 Unit=9B21, Status=—, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
courtrl 5629
Employee=20328

4/1/2016 Unit=265U, Status=", Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
8:21:58 PM hqc5 24900
Employee=6884

8:22:20 PM 4/1/2016 courtrl Unit=6B31, Status=", Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
5629
Employee=24088

8:22:33 PM Unit=1624, Status=r,, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
4/1/2016 hqc6 25035
Employee=18352
Unit=265U, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC:
8:22:43 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 8873 @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=6884
Unit=6831, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC:
8:22:44 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 EE1 @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=24088
Unit=9B21, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC:
8:22:45 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 aaLl
@PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=20328
Unit=1B24, Status=CU, Comment=ON WR2A - Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN
8:22:52 PM 4/1/2016 hqrl 20286
BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=18352
Unit=267U, Status=—, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC: @PALMS WEST HOSPITAL,
8:24:50 PM 4/1/2016 courtrl 529

02/13/17 Page 193 Public Records
9:39:36Request
AM] No.: 17-058
https://netviewer.pbso.orginetviewer/inquiry/evehron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=1&FromInquiryCmd---0[4/3/2016
(13'S
1/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

Employee=2092
Unit=267U, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=13001 SOUTHERN BLVD PBC:
8:25:17 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 113
7
@PALMS WEST HOSPITAL, Employee=2092
8:29:25 PM 4/1/2016 $9B21 20328 Unit=9621, Status=AM, Employee=20328
8:35:29 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 aa.7-3 Unit=15821, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
8:37:29 PM 4/1/2016 hqc8 21888 Unit=15821, Status=", Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
8:38:32 PM 4/1/2016 $15821 23163 Unit=15021, Status=AK, Location-17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
8:39:30 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 RZ.3. Unit=15621, Status=UC, Comment=Preempt, Employee=23163
8:39:34 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 8873 Unit=15621, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
8:39:42 PM 4/1/2016 $15821 23163 Unit=15821, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
8:44:07 PM 4/1/2016 $598S 5487 Unit=5985, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=5487
8:46:07 PM 4/1/2016 supvl Zf Unit=598S, Status=,-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=5487
8:46:07 PM 4/1/2016 courtrl 5.(222 Unit=598S, Status=,-, Location =17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=5487
8:46:07 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 Unit=598S, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=5487
Unit=598S, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
8:50:34 PM 4/1/2016 hqinq1 L22
Employee=5487
8:53:03 PM 4/1/2016 $15821 23163 Unit=15621, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
8:58:03 PM 4/1/2016 hqr6 16611 Unit=15821, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
Unit=15821, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
8:58:39 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 laza Employee=23163
9:14:52 PM 4/1/2016 hqr13 8437 Unit=5205, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8679
9:14:53 PM 4/1/2016 hqr13 8437 Unit=5205, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8679
9:15:22 PM 4/1/2016 hqr13 8437 Unit=509S, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8192
9:15:23 PM 4/1/2016 hqr13 1412 Unit=509S, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8192
9:19:53 PM 4/1/2016 hqc2 21529 Unit=520S, Status=", Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8679
9:20:23 PM 4/1/2016 hqc2 21529 Unit=509S, Status=,,, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8192
Unit=509S, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
9:21:47 PM 4/1/2016 hqr9 EEL Employee=8192
Unit=520S, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
Employee=8679
9:21:53 PM 4/1/2016 $236U 24992 Unit=236U, Status=AM, Employee=24992
EVENT COMMENT=15612 LL REQ ACC FOR S/70 DOGS INSIDE THE RESD AFTER FORCED ENTRY..
10:45:33 PM 4/1/2016 hqc10
1039
ACC.. THEY WILL 45 BACK WITH 1052
EVENT COMMENT=--OFFICER COOK WITH ACC WANTING TO KNOW THE REASON THEY ARE
10:49:49 PM 4/1/2016 hqc9 2372 9 NEEDED, SAYS THE
REASON 15612 GAVE IS NOT ADEQUATE FOR THEM TO RESPOND...NEEDS MORE
S/14
EVENT COMMENT=OFFICER COOK'S 1088: 561-685-9563...HE WONT BE COMING OUT UNTIL HE
10:51:38 PM 4/1/2016 hqc9 23729 GETS MORE
S/14
12:11:45 AM 4/2/2016 $1360 32212 Unit=136U, Status=DP, Location=17148 30111 LN N PBC, Employee=3770
12:13:45 AM 4/2/2016 courtrl ZJ Unit=136U, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=3770
12:24:51 AM 4/2/2016 $1360 317n, Unit=136U, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=3770
12:29:36 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=8632, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8380
12:29:37 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=8B21, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8421
12:29:51 AM 4/2/2016 hqr3 21288 Unit=136U, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=3770
12:30:05 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=9B11, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=22948
12:30:10 AM 4/2/2016 $8632 /3_1aQ Unit=8832, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8380
12:30:13 AM 4/2/2016 $9811 22948 Unit=9611, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=22948
12:30:32 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=9621, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
12:30:38 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 EVENT COMMENT=2650 -- NEED TWO D8 AND TWO D9 UNITS

02/13/17 Page 194 Public Records
https://netviewer.pbso.orginetviewer/inquiry/evehron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=1&FromInquiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 Request
9:39:36 AM] No.: 17-058
I/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

12:30:45 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 71774 EVENT COMMENT=15S6 9811 TO 56 AT D15
12:31:11 AM 4/2/2016 $1624 1.8352 Unit=11324, Status=-AM, Employee=18352
12:31:37 AM 4/2/2016 arulobby2 19009204 Unit=8621, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8421
12:32:23 AM 4/2/ 2016 $8621 $121 Unit=8B21, Status=- ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8421
12:32:24 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 Unit=91311, Status=AR, Location=17148 30Th LN N PBC, Employee=22948
12:32:32 AM 4/2/2016 hqc6 23730 Unit=9621, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
Unit=136U, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=-17148 30TH LN N PBC,
12:33:25 AM 4/2/ 2016 hqinql 18189
Employee=3770
12:37:24 AM 4/2/2016 hqc13 22428 Unit=91311, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=22948
Unit=91311, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
12:37:31 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286
Employee=22948
Unit=91321, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
12:37:32 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 Employee=20328
12:40:00 AM 4/2/2016 $9B21 29328 Unit=9521, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
12:41:59 AM 4/2/2016 $509S $122 Unit=509S, Status=UE, Employee=8192
Unit=509S, Status=UU, Employee=8192
Unit=509S, Status=UC, Comment=New equipment list for Unit [509S] : SHOTGUN:1, Location=17148
12:42:00 AM 4/2/2016 $5095 $192 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8192
12:43:12 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 EVENT COMMENT=91311 -- 51 TO 30TH LN
12:43:21 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 Unit=9B11, Status=-ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=22948
Unit=9811, Status=CL, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=22948
12:43:22 AM 4/2/2016 cad-01 20286 EVENT COMMENT=" LOI search completed at 04/02/16 00:43:22
12:46:38 AM 4/2/2016 $8632 8380 Unit=8632, Status=AR, Location=17148 30Th LN N PBC, Employee=8380
12:46:47 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 Unit=9621, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
12:47:29 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 EVENT COMMENT=265 -- 30TH LN UNIT NEEDS TO BLOCK THE ROAD
12:47:33 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 20286 EVENT COMMENT=8632 IM BLOCKING RD
12:48:27 AM 4/2/2016 hqr12 21272 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 00:48:27
** »» by: TRACI E. LAPIERRE on terminal: hqr12
12:51:38 AM 4/2/2016 hqr3 2-.121$ Unit=81332, Status=", Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8380
12:51:47 AM 4/2/2016 hqr14 Unit=9621, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=20328
12:52:40 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=8621, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8421
Unit=-8632, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
12:52:44 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274
Employee=8380
Unit=91321, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
12:52:45 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274
Employee=20328
12:54:22 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 EVENT COMMENT=267U -- 1052 FOR K9
12:57:40 AM 4/2/2016 gladesrl 8320 Unit=8621, Status=,
-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8421
1:00:37 AM 4/2/2016 hqinql 18189 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:00:37
** »» by: JESSICA L. MARKS on terminal: hqinql
Unit=81321, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
1:01:09 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21229. Employee=8421
1:06:01 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=K912, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8833
1:06:10 AM 4/2/2016 $K912 Ka2 Unit=K912, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8833
1:06:48 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 EVENT COMMENT=K912 IS 51 REF S70
1:07:10 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 EVENT COMMENT=PER 267U 66 ACC REF K912 WILL HANDLE IT
1:09:08 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=9611, Status=CL, Location=200 CIVIC CENTER WAY RPB,300: @DIST15, Employee=22948
Unit=9611, Status=ER, Location=200 CIVIC CENTER WAY RPB,300: @DIST15, Employee=22948
1:09:11 AM 4/2/2016 cad-01 21274 EVENT COMMENT=** LOT search completed at 04/02/16 01:09:11
1:15:29 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=91311, Status=AR, Location=200 CIVIC CENTER WAY RPB,300: @DIST15, Employee=22948
1:20:29 AM 4/2/2016 hqr11 7218 Unit=9611, Status='', Location=200 CIVIC CENTER WAY RPB,300: @DIST15, Employee=22948
1:20:29 AM 4/2/2016 hqc5 24900 Unit=9611, Status=-, Location=200 CIVIC CENTER WAY RPB,300: @DIST15, Employee=22948

02/13/17 Page 195 Public Records
https://netviewer.pbso.org/netviewer/inquiry/evchron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=1&FromInquiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 9:39:36Request
AM] No.: 17-058
l/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

Unit=9B11, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=200 CIVIC CENTER WAY
1:21:01 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274
RPB,300: @DIST15, Employee=22948
1:27:37 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21.274 Unit=K912, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8833
1:32:37 AM 4/2/2016 gladesr3 222.E Unit=K912, Status=—, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=8833
Unit=K912, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
1:33:21 AM 4/2/ 2016 hqr9 21274
Employee=8833
1:47:28 AM 4/2/2016 cad-01 212 EVENT COMMENT=** PER search completed at 04/02/16 01:47:28
1:47:28 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 2142 SUPP INFO CREATED: PERSO: Name=ALEMAN,KRISTEN A, Race=W, Sex=F, DOB=19731003
1:47:32 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9102 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:47:32
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:47:33 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9192 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:47:33
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:47:38 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 202 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:47:38
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:47:38
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
** LOT information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:47:38
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:49:09 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 912 SUPP INFO CREATED: PERSO: Name=MYERALEMAN,KRISTIN, Race=VV, Sex=F, DOB=19731003
1:49:10 AM 4/2/2016 cad-01 9102 EVENT COMMENT=** PER search completed at 04/02/16 01:49:10
1:49:14 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9.1.02 EVENT COMMENT=** LOT information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:49:14
** >>» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:49:16 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9102 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:49:16
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:49:16
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:49:16
** >>>> by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:49:17 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:49:17
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:49:48 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 aQ2 SUPP INFO CREATED: PERSO: Name=MYER,KRISTIN, Race=W, Sex=-F, DOB=19731003
1:49:49 AM 4/2/2016 cad-01 9102 EVENT COMMENT=** PER search completed at 04/02/16 01:49:49
1:49:54 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9102 EVENT COMMENT=** LOT information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:49:54
** >>>> by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:52:21 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9102 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:52:21
** >>» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:53:25 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 91Q2 EVENT COMMENT=** LOT information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 01:53:25
** »» by: LORI A. KELLEY on terminal: hqc10
1:53:52 AM 4/2/2016 hqc10 9_142 EVENT COMMENT=KRISTEN - CLR/DL SUSP 052715 FTP - NO MATCH DOB PLMS
2:15:04 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 Unit=543S, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=7953
2:15:14 AM 4/2/2016 $5435 Unit=543S, Status=ER, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=7953
2:18:43 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21.274 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 02:18:43
** »» by: SARA M. MARTIN on terminal: hqr9
2:18:47 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 EVENT COMMENT=.** LOT information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 02:18:47
** >>>> by: SARA M. MARTIN on terminal: hqr9
2:20:48 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 21274 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 02:20:48
** »» by: SARA M. MARTIN on terminal: hqr9
2:22:05 AM 4/2/2016 hqr12 21272 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 02:22:05
** »» by: TRACI E. LAPIERRE on terminal: hqr12

02/13/17 Page 196 Public Records
https://netviewer.pbso.org/netviewer/inquiry/evehron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=1&FromInquiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 9:39:36Request
AM] No.: 17-058
clq
I/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

2:22:08 AM 4/2/2016 hqr12 2122.2 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 02:22:08
** »» by: TRACI E. LAPIERRE on terminal: hqr12
2:22:12 AM 4/2/ 2016 hqr12 21222 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 02:22:12
** >>» by: TRACI E. LAPIERRE on terminal: hqr12
EVENT COMMENT=15S6 ADV ACC WE NEED THEM TO COME OUT AND PICK UP A K9 FROM THE
3:10:31 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 $B22
PROPERTY
3:10:33 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 a73 EVENT COMMENT=1039 EOC

3:15:32 AM 4/2/2016 supv2 7725 EVENT COMMENT=ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL OFFICER CALLS IN TO REPORT HER WILL BE 51 40
MIN ETA
3:37:51 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 8873 Unit=5435, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=7953
3:38:21 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 8873 EVENT COMMENT=ACC 97
3:42:51 AM 4/2/2016 hqc9 23222 Unit=543S, Status=,., Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=7953

3:43:28 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 Unit=5435, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
egiL Employee=7953
3:43:52 AM 4/2/2016 $136U 3222 Unit=136U, Status=AM, Comment=BU, Employee=3770
3:44:23 AM 4/2/2016 supvl 2.21.1 Unit=598S, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=5487
3:49:23 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 B.522 Unit=598S, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=5487
3:54:16 AM 4/2/2016 $K912 a8_22 Unit=K912, Status=-AM, Employee=8833
4:04:04 AM 4/2/2016 $265U 014 Unit=265U, Status=AM, Comment=C, Employee=6884
4:04:38 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 aL7a Unit=81332, Status=AM, Employee=8380
4:06:54 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 E823 Unit=267U, Status=AM, Employee=2092

4:18:34 AM 4/2/2016 hqr11 21274 Unit=598S, Status=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
Employee=5487
4:26:21 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 8873 Unit=1556, Status=AM, Employee=4356
4:28:02 AM 4/2/2016 $15B21 23,mia Unit=15821, Status=AM, Employee=23163
4:40:30 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 $§322 Unit=9B11, Status=AM, Employee=22948
5:04:56 AM 4/2/2016 hqr11 21274 Unit=9B21, Status=AM, Employee=20328
5:05:14 AM 4/2/2016 hqr11 21279 Unit=151321, Status=DP, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
5:05:58 AM 4/2/2016 hqr11 21221 Unit=151321, Status=AR, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163
5:09:20 AM 4/2/2016 $5985 ,51$2 Unit=598S, Status=AM, Employee=5487
5:10:58 AM 4/2/2016 hqr4 18189 Unit=151321, Status=-, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC, Employee=23163

5:11:04 AM 4/2/2016 hgrll 21274 Unit=151321, Status-=CU, Comment=Alarm Timer Extended: 0, Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC,
Employee=23163
5:26:13 AM 4/2/2016 $8B21 8421 Unit=8821, Status=AM, Employee=8421
5:46:00 AM 4/2/2016 $543S 7953 Unit=543S, Status=AM, Employee=7953
6:14:06 AM 4/2/2016 $15B21 23163 Unit=15821, Status=AM, Employee=23163
6:30:23 AM 4/2/2016 $6831 24088 Unit=6831, Status=AM, Employee=24088
6:57:20 AM 4/2/2016 $15812 5222 Unit=15812, Status=AM, Employee=6972
6:59:52 AM 4/2/2016 supvl 112 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 06:59:52
** >>» by: HEIDI GROB on terminal: supvl
6:59:55 AM 4/2/2016 supvl 322 EVENT COMMENT=** LOI information for Event # E1600296257 was viewed at: 04/02/16 06:59:55
** >>» by: HEIDI GROB on terminal: supvl
EVENT UPDATED: Location=17148 30TH LN N PBC , Cross Streets=CHEETHAM HILL BLVD /DEAD END
7:00:00 AM 4/2/2016 supvl 392,9 , Name=ALEMAN,KRISTIN , Address=LION COUNTRY SAFARI TOWER NW FACE , Call Source=ANIALI
, Phone Number=(772) 475-4478
Agency=PBSO, Group=D15, Beat=15-11, Status=A, Priority=1, ETA=0, Hold Type=0, Primary
Unit=1.51312, Primary Member=6972, Current=F, Open Current=F, Type Code=73-MAN DOWN/SICK
PERSON
7:02:26 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 2132 Unit=509S, Status=AM, Employee=8192
Agency=PBSO, Group=D15, Beat=15-11, Status=A, Priority=1, ETA=0, Hold Type=0, Primary
7:02:28 AM 4/2/2016 hqr9 9439 Unit=15812, Primary Member=6972, Current=T, Open CurrentrF, Type Code=73-MAN DOWN/SICK
PERSON
EVENT CLOSED

02/13/17 Page 197 Public Records
https://nerviewer.pbso.org/netviewer/inguiry/evehron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=l&FromInguiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 9:39:36Request
AM] No.: 17-058
1/NetViewer -- Event Chronology

Unit=520S, Status=AM, Employee=8679

02/13/17 Page 198 Public Records
https://netviewer.pbso.org/netviewer/inquiry/evchron.asp?event=E1600296257&syscom=l&FromInquiryCmd=0[4/3/2016 Request
9:39:36 AM] No.: 17-058
(A/3
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT MEDICAL EXAMINER
DISTRICT 15 — STATE OF FLORIDA
PALM BEACH COUNTY
3126 GUN CLUB ROAD
WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33406-3005
(561) 688-4575
(561) 688-4592 FAX

NAME: CASE NUMBER: 16-0525

DATE OF DEATH: April 1, 2016 / 19:26 AGE: 13 MONTHS SEX: F RACE: W

DATE OF AUTOPSY: April 2, 2016 / 09:30

AUTOPSY FINDINGS:

1. Emaciated, 13 month old female
2. Born at 40 week gestation weighing 8lbs 15 ounces
3. Extreme developmental delay: below 3rd percentile for height (24-1/2") and weight (7.32 lbs)
4. Severe dehydration
Poor skin turgor
Sunken anterior fontanel (still open)
Vitreous urea nitrogen: 45.2 mg/dl, sodium: 142 mEq/L, chloride: 124 tnEq/L
5. Severe rash of perineum skin
6. Contusion of face
7. Newborn metabolic screening: within normal limits
8. Toxicology: non contributory
9. Cultures:
positive lung cultures for influenza B virus, E. Coli, Beta-hemolytic Streptococcus Group B
and haemophilus influenzae
positive blood cultures for staphylococcus aureus, heamophilus influenza and streptococcus
viridans

OPINION: a 13 month old female, died of inanition due to neglect

CAUSE OF DEATH: Inanition due to neglect

MANNER OF DEATH: Homicide

02/13/17 Page 199 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
'Ng
NAME: ALEMAN, CASE NUMBER: 160525

Associate Medical Examiner

Date Signed:

GMJ: df

2

02/13/17 Page 200 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
NAME: CASE NUMBER: 160525

OFFICIALS PRESENT AT AUTOPSY: Detectives Eric Keith and Vionide St Jean from the Palm Beach
Sheriff's Office and from the Florida Department of Children and Families.

PRESENTATION: The body presented in a sealed, white body bag with seal number "1236275". The bag
was opened at 9:30 a.m. in the presence of above officials.

EXTERNAL EXAMINATION:

The body is that of an underdeveloped, undernourished, white female that weighs 7.32 pounds, which is below
the 3rd percentile for her stated age of 13 months. The body temperature is cold due to refrigeration. Rigor
mortis is not present. Livor mortis is fixed on the posterior surface of the body. The thin skin has poor turgor
and shows numerous brown patches. The back is covered with abundant, fine hair. There is severe redness and
excoriation of the skin covering the entire perineum, extending to the inter gluteal region, the labia majora and
the folds of the bilateral inguinal regions. The anterior abdominal wall has a greenish discoloration due to early
decomposition.

The following measurements were obtained at the start of the external examination:

Crown-Heel Length: 24-1/4" (below 3rd percentile for age)
Crown-Rump Length: 19"
Head Circumference: 15"
Chest Circumference: 12-3/4"
Abdominal Circumference: 12"

There are no apparent developmental or traumatic abnormalities of the head and facial features. There is no
distortion of the shape of the head. The scalp hair is fine and brown. The anterior fontanel is still open and
sunken. The posterior fontanelle is closed. The irides are brown. The corneae are clear. There are no
conjunctival or scleral petechiae. The ears are normally formed. The nares are patent. There are no structural
abnormalities of the lips, gingival arches or palate. There are no palpable abnormalities of the neck. The chest,
abdomen and posterior torso are symmetrical and without structural abnormalities. The nipples are normally
formed. The abdomen has no palpable masses. The upper and lower extremities are normally formed with all
digits present. Palmar and plantar creases are unremarkable. The external genitalia are appropriate for those of
a 13-month-old female.

CLOTHING: The body presented nude. The hands are covered with bags retained at the wrists with evidence
tape.

MEDICAL INTERVENTION:

Tracheal and gastric tubes are in the mouth and are subsequently found well positioned within the trachea and
the esophagus respectively. One defibrillator pad is on the anterior chest, and another is on the posterior chest.
An intraosseous catheter is at the anterior left leg. A pulse oximeter is over the left great toe.

3

02/13/17 Page 201 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
446
NAME: ALEMAN, CASE NUMBER: 160525

INJURY:

There is a 3 centimeter x 1.5 centimeter purple contusion on the left lateral orbit.

INTERNAL EXAMINATION:

BODY CAVITIES:

The body cavities are opened using the usual Y-shaped incision and the chest plate removed. No adhesions or
abnormal collections of fluid are noted in the chest or abdominal cavities. All of the thoracic and abdominal
organs are present in their expected anatomical locations. There is no evidence of blunt force or penetrating
injury to the thoracoabdominal region.

CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM:

The pericardial sac has a smooth, intact outer surface, and when opened at autopsy, no signification amount of
fluid is released. There is no adhesion of the pericardium to the epicardial surface. The aorta, pulmonary trunk,
superior and inferior venae cavae, and the pulmonary veins connect to the heart in their usual configuration. All
of these vessels are patent and without areas of stenosis. The heart weighs 20 grams. The coronary arteries
follow the usual right dominant distribution and are patent. The cardiac valves are normally positioned. The
tricuspid and mitral valves each have three leaflets. The pulmonary and aortic valves each have three cusps.
The myocardium is uniformly red-brown. The maximum thickness of the left ventricular wall is 0.5
centimeters. The maximum thickness of the right ventricular wall thickness is 0.3 centimeters. There are no
perforating defects of the atrial or ventricular septae. The ductus arteriosus is closed. The foramen ovale is
membrane protected. The aorta and its major branches follow their usual distribution and are unremarkable.
The superior and inferior venae cavae are free of thrombi.

RESPIRATORY SYSTEM:

The nasal passages, pharynx, larynx, trachea, mainstem bronchi and their initial branches are free of foreign
material. The mucosal surfaces of the upper airways are pink and non-edematous. The pleural surfaces are
dark pink to red-purple, smooth, and free of adhesions. The right lung weighs 31 grams. The left lung weighs
33 grams. Serial sections through the lungs reveal red, congested parenchyma, with no focal solid or cystic
lesions. The cut surfaces yield marked amounts of foamy, serosanguineous fluid with compression. The
pulmonary arteries follow a normal distribution and are free of thrombi.

HEPATOBILIARY SYSTEM:

The liver weighs 176 grams. The hepatic capsule is smooth, thin and intact. Serial sections through the liver
reveal uniform, red-brown parenchyma with no focal solid or cystic lesions. The gallbladder has a minimal
amount of green-yellow bile. The extrahepatic biliary ducts follow their usual distribution and are patent.

4

02/13/17 Page 202 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
NAME: ALEMAN, CASE NUMBER: 160525

PANCREAS:

The size, shape and consistency of the pancreas are unremarkable. Serial sections through the pancreas reveal
the usual tan-white, lobulated parenchyma, and the pancreatic ducts are patent.

GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM:

There are no structural abnormalities of the tongue, esophagus or stomach. The esophageal and gastric mucosa
is unremarkable. The stomach has approximately 10 milliliters of creamy, milky substance. The small bowel
and its mesentery are free of adhesions. The small and large intestines are structurally unremarkable and
contain light brownish fecal material. The appendix is present in its usual retrocecal location.

GENITOURINARY SYSTEM:

The kidneys are 19 grams each. The renal capsules are thin and transparent and strip easily from the underlying
smooth, lobulated cortical surfaces. The cut surfaces of the bisected kidneys show normal renal architecture
with no cystic malformation. Corticomedullary demarcation is distinct. The calyces, pelves and ureters are
non-dilated and free of calculi. The urinary bladder is empty. The bladder mucosa has the usual light tan,
rippled texture. The uterus, fallopian tubes and ovaries are identified in their expected locations and are
structurally appropriate for the decedent's age.

HEMOLYMPHATIC SYSTEM:

The spleen is identified in its usual location and weighs 12 grams. The splenic capsule is thin, smooth and
intact. The splenic parenchyma is dark red-purple and moderately firm. The thymus gland is identified in its
usual anterior mediastinal location and weighs 4 grams. The parenchyma is tan-pink with a lobulated texture
and no evidence of focal intraparenchymal hemorrhage. Mesenteric lymph nodes are appropriately prominent,
and the bone marrow is red-purple and unremarkable.

MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM:

Muscle and bone development is appropriate for the decedent's age. There are no apparent pathologic or
traumatic abnormalities of the skeletal muscles, bones or joints.

ENDOCRINE:

The pituitary, thyroid and adrenal glands are structurally unremarkable.

NECK:

The great vessels, musculature and other soft tissues of the neck are unremarkable. The cartilaginous structures
of the larynx, the hyoid bone and cervical vertebrae are intact and non-displaced. The mucosal surfaces of the
larynx and pharynx are free of redness or swelling.
5

02/13/17 Page 203 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
NAME: CASE NUMBER: 160525

HEAD AND CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM:

The scalp is reflected, exposing an unremarkable infant calvarium, which is subsequently opened along the
sutures. The bones of the calvarium are unremarkable. The anterior fontanelle is neither bulging nor retracted.
The dura mater is intact. There is no evidence of epidural or subdural hemorrhage. The leptomeninges are thin
and clear. There is no subarachnoid hemorrhage. The brain weighs 72 grams. The contours, color and
consistency of the cortical surfaces are appropriate for the decedent's age. The cranial nerves and blood vessels
at the base of the brain are present in their usual configuration and are intact. Serial sectioning of the cerebral
hemispheres, cerebellum, brainstem and proximal spinal cord reveals no abnormalities of the internal cerebral
architecture and the usual configuration of the ventricular system. The cerebrospinal fluid is clear and
colorless.

SPECIMENS:

Samples of blood from the heart, lung tissue, liver and brain, vitreous fluid, urine and gastric contents were
collected at autopsy and submitted for cultures and toxicological examination.

6

02/13/17 Page 204 Public Records Request No.: 17-058 wig
hh
CASE # 6-S 1044

HEART 0-20a--c.- LUNGS RT Lj )

LT

LIVER / 7-6 5-1.. c-6v-Q-xx VOAc'?kIDNEY RT ly
LT • ) q
SPLEEN / cz2_, GASTRIC 1 0 -4—

BRAIN
'-')--ru URINE_ 2 S - + 9-464.., 4.,,,t, I:ILI

THYMUS °7 y ar0"•1

RT. CHEST

LT. CHEST

APPENDIX /NO

ABD. FLUID FP:

PERICARDIUM FLUID Micros:

NOTES:
RV m ;1 )
ttLA)
LV •

TV
PV
MV
AV

02/13/17 Page 205 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
NAME: CASE NUMBER: 16-0525

DATE: June 24, 2016 NUMBER OF SLIDES: 16

MICROSCOPIC EXAMINATION

HEART: Within normal limits.

LUNGS: There is expansion and collapse of alveoli. The bronchi contain mucus with inflammatory
cells. There is moderate to marked, chronic peribronchial inflammation.

LIVER: Within normal limits.

KIDNEYS: Within normal limits

PANCREAS: Within normal limits.

THYROID: Within normal limits.

ADRENALS: Within normal limits

SPLEEN: Within normal limits.

BRAIN: Within normal limits

de . Juste, M.D.
Associate Medical Examiner

643-1
Date Signed: 1- 11

GMJ: df

02/13/17 Page 206 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
VS7
District 15 • Palm Beach County
160525
Medical Examiners Office Aleman .
White Female 1 Y
3126 Gun Club Road • West Palm Beach, FL 33406
Dr. G J
TEL: (561) 688-4575 • www,:Ocggy.com/medig?,19xaminer
0 Aor/02/2016

cAsE#16-0525
"VD
DATE: APR 0 2 16 -7-11 ,1 " Ti r )
C1 NATURAL 0 ACCIDENT 0 SUICIDE ❑ FR3IVITUDE vr• II]

NAME: AGE:
LAST FIRST

l=1 WHITE ❑ BLACK El OTHER 0 CLOTHED ❑ NA D 0 HOSPITAL SPECIMEN

APPROX. HEIGHT:

APPROX. WEIGHT: b
4-r_ (cif
PRESERVATION
Good Hi ('‘,(
0 Early Decomposition
0 Advanced Decomposition
0 Embalmed ❑ Skeletonized
TEMPERATURE
0 Warm ❑ Cool
_2%Id 0 Frozen
RIG R
4bsent 0 Mild
0 Moderate 0 Marked
LIVOR
❑ Absent 0 Non-Fixed
0 Pink • Fixed
0 Ventral • rsal
NUTRITION
D Adequate D Obese Cle6“-; 4
achectic D Edema
0 Jaundice 0 Ascites
0 Cyanosis
EYES
--)6Brown 0 Blue
0 Gray 0 Hazel
0 Green
HAIR
Brown I I/Ct 0 Black
0 Blonde 0 None
0 Red
❑ Upper Teeth
0 Lower Teeth
0 Circumsized
Heart
R Lung
L Lung
Liver
Spleen
R Kidney
L Kidney
Brain
Uterus PROBABLE CAUSE OF DEATH:
Thymus
PATHOLOGIST:
Stomach PBC ME0 FORM 09
Urine 02/13/17 Page 207 Public Records Request
2013 DesignedNo.: 17-058
by Palm Beach County Graphics Division
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT MEDICAL EXAMINER
DISTRICT 15 — STATE OF FLORIDA
PALM BEACH COUNTY
3126 GUN CLUB ROAD
WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33406-3005
(561) 688-4575
(561) 688-4592 FAX

Name: W/F, D.O.B.
Case Number: 2016-0525
Prepared By: Forensic Investigator L. Littlefield, M.S., D-ABMDI

Date and Time Notified: April 1, 2016, 20:10 hours
Notified by: Sgt. E. Keith (I.D.# 6231)
Agency & Case#: Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office (P.B.S.O.) Case# 16-058738
Identification: Visual identification at hospital by parents
N.O.K.: Parents Alejandro "Alex" and Kristen Aleman
Home Address: 17148 30th Ln N, Loxahatchee, Florida 33470
Location of Death: Palms West Hospital Emergency Room, Loxahatchee, Florida 33470
Date & Time of Death: April 1, 2016, 19:26 hours
Past Medical History: Underweight
Medications: None
Narrative:
I was informed by Sgt. Keith of the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office Special Investigations Division (S.I.D.) a
child identified by her parents as had been pronounced dead at the Palms West Hospital Emergency
Room. P.B.S.O. S.I.D. Det. V. Saint-Jean (ID# 8192) was the lead detective. The Florida D.C.F. (Department of
Children and Families) and Rapid Response had been notified.
At 22:31 hours on April 1, 2016, I spoke by phone with P.B.S.O. Det. L. Usbaldo (ID# 8679), who was assisting Det.
Saint-Jean. Det. Usbaldo advised the decedent's mother, Kristen Aleman, contacted 911 around 18:30 hours on April
1, 2016 reporting the decedent became unresponsive at home. She attempted C.P.R. and the child was transported to
the emergency room, where she was pronounced deceased at 19:26 hours. The parents were uncooperative at the
hospital. The child was clothed in a onesie that appeared clean and a diaper stained with possible urine, which I
granted permission for crime scene personnel to collect at the hospital. The decedent appeared emaciated with sparse
dull hair on her head, hair on her extremities and back, "stretched out" skin, perinea' excoriations, dilated pupils, and
possible left periorbital ecchymosis. White fluid emanated from her mouth when she was turned over for
examination. The decedent weighted seven pounds at the hospital. The decedent resided in a residence with her
parents and nine siblings. She was nine pounds at birth. Mrs. Aleman reported the child had not been to a
pediatrician for several months. There were several occasions of D.C.F. involvement with the family in the past.
D.C.F. Child Protective Investigator (ID#TS10169) and Chief Investigator William Fraser of the Palm
Beach County State Attorney's Office were at the hospital.
I contacted the Palms West Hospital Emergency Room at 23:07 hours on April 1, 2016 and spoke with emergency
room physician Dr. Jamie Estrada. Dr. Estrada advised the decedent was transported to the hospital by Palm Beach
County Fire Rescue and cold and asystolic with dilated pupils on arrival to the emergency room at 19:16 hours. Her
temperature was 90.4°F and resuscitative efforts continued. She was unable to be revived and pronounced dead. No
antemortem specimens were obtained. The decedent had perianal excoriations, a sunken fontanelle, and appeared
malnourished and emaciated. Her only past medical history reported by her parents was low weight.
I dispatched Elite Removal Services personnel to Palms West Hospital at 23:30 hours on April 1, 2016 to transport
the decedent, with the Palm Beach County Medical Examiner's Office Homicide Protocol in place, and her chart to
our facility.
Page 1 of 2

02/13/17 Page 208 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
At 15:52 hours on April 14, 2016, I spoke by phone with Det. Saint-Jean, who advised the decedent's residence was a
single family home in a rural area and was dirty with flies, fleas, pet feces, and a foul odor and contained little food.
A search warrant had been obtained and executed on the residence. A dog kept in a cage containing feces and urine
had been removed from the home. Purified water and formula was present and the decedent had one bottle and a dirty
playard with a bassinet. Mrs. Aleman was a stay at home mother and Mr. Aleman was a repossession agent. They
received $1600 a month in food stamps. The parents were hesitant to provide information and had contacted a
lawyer. The decedent was delivered at Martin Medical Center in Stuart, Florida. Mrs. Aleman reported the decedent
was healthy and informed the child was underweight when she last saw pediatrician Dr. Anitha Jagadish of Tender
Care Pediatrics (772-335-1812) in Port Saint Lucie, Florida in December of 2015. The decedent's diet consisted of
formula and a few solid foods. She could not crawl or walk. There were nine other children; eight boys and one girl
ranging from age two to fourteen, residing in the home, all home schooled, and the younger children lacked verbal
skills and were undereducated. All had been removed from the home by D.C.F. Some were treated for scabies. The
younger children appeared slightly malnourished. Neither parent or the older siblings appeared underweight. Mrs.
Aleman reported the decedent appeared fine when she fed her formula on April 1, 2016. The decedent then played
and slept a little. When Mrs. Aleman began to feed the infant again approximately three hours later, the child began
spitting up and appeared lethargic. Mrs. Aleman had started rocking her when the decedent became unresponsive and
apneic and she called her husband before calling 911. None of the other children witnessed this. No criminal charges
had been filed, but were anticipated.
I spoke with Mr. Aleman by phone at 16:35 hours on April 14, 2016. He advised Mrs. Aleman was forty one years
old when the decedent was delivered full term and there were no complications during the pregnancy or delivery. The
decedent's mother possibly had "rare" blood and received a shot after the delivery. He did not know if genetic testing
was performed and did not confirm vaccinations. There was a family history of cardiovascular issues. The decedent
had no past medical history and had a check up on an unknown date after birth. She was able to roll over, squeeze
your finger, smile, and make noises, but could not crawl, walk, or say words. None of his other children talked until
one and a half to two years of age and did not walk early. According to Mr. Aleman, the decedent's sibling, Pagan,
had been small for his age group, but later gained weight. The other children had seen a pediatrician whose name
started with an M located in Royal Palm Beach and he did not know the last time the decedent was seen by a
pediatrician. The decedent did not like solid foods and was fed milk or formula purchased at BJ's Wholesale Club.
She frequently experienced diarrhea and urinated often. The decedent was not recently more tired than usual and
exhibited no shortness of breath. She had a cough the evening of April 31, 2016 and he recently had the flu. He
advised Mrs. Aleman had been feeding the decedent on April 1, 2016 when the decedent became tired, went limp, and
911 was contacted.
On April 20, 2016, at 10:08 hours, I spoke by phone with D.C.F. Investigator (D.C.F. Case# 16-
090250), who advised the decedent's parents would not speak with her. There was previous D.C.F. involvement with
the decedent's parents and siblings involving allegations of environmental hazards and inadequate supervision. Based
on information received, Mrs. Aleman reported her two year old child was also initially underweight, but later gained
weight and now at a normal weight. The decedent's diet consisted of formula and mashed bananas. She could not
walk and crawled some. There was no mention of the decedent suffering from a digestive disorder, Crohn's disease,
colitis, or diabetes. Mrs. Aleman reported she had been informed the decedent was a little small and to fed her more
when she last saw Dr. Jagadish in December of 2015. The decedent's father and grandparents suffered from
cardiovascular disease. During a later phone conversation with Inv. at 10:28 hours on April 26, 2016, she
advised the home had been dirty with a foul odor and feces and in deplorable condition. There was a small amount of
food and piles of laundry. The older children were dirty and the dog appeared neglected. The other children were
medically neglected, exhibited verbal deficits, and emotionally unattached. The decedent's parents were her only
caretakers and both denied psychological issues. Mr. Aleman had been arrested in 2013 for carrying a concealed
weapon and driving under the influence. Mrs. Aleman had no arrest history. On April 27, 2016, I was advised by
Inv. there were records for several of the other children, but none for the decedent, at Tender Care Pediatrics.
The decedent's birth records from Martin Medical Center and the P.B.S.O. scene photos were obtained. I submitted a
records request to Dr. Gomathy Mohan of Royal Palm Pediatrics (561-429-5898) and was advised the decedent's
siblings, but not the decedent, had been treated there.
No further information.

Page 2 of 2

02/13/17 Page 209 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
ysv
OFFICE OF THE MEDICAL EXAMINER
DISTRICT 15, State of Florida
Palm Beach County
West Palm Beach, FL 33406
(561) 688-4575

CASE INFORMATION SHEET
Printed: Jul 05, 2016

M.E. CASE: 160525 INVESTIGATOR: Lydia Littlefield, Forensic Investigator
PATHOLOGIST: Gertrude Juste,Pathologist
DECEDENT
NAME: AGE: 1 yts_
AKA: DOB:
S.S. #: D.L. #:. RACE: White
OTHER I.D.: P.W.H. / P.B.S.O. SEX: Female
OCCUPATION:
LOCAL ADDRESS: PH: ( ) -
17148 30th Ln N, Loxahatchee, FL 33470
PERM. ADDRESS: PH: ( ) -
17148 30th Ln N, Loxahatchee. FL 33470, United States

INVOLVED PARTIES
NAME: Alejandro "Alex" & Kristen Aleman RELATIONSHIP: Parents
LOCAL ADDRESS:
17148 30th Ln N. Loxahatchee. FL 33470
PERM. ADDRESS:
17148 30th Ln N. Loxahatchee, FL 33470. United States
Next of Kin PHONES: LOCAL: 5616621684 Father PERM.ADDR:
Contact CELL: BUSINESS:
El Identified by HOW IDENTIFIED: Visual ID Mother D.O.B.10/03/1973 F
Notified of Death

SCENE OF INJURY
OCATION OF INJURY
Unknown Unknown , FL non-std addr: Unknown

DATE TIME OF INJURY:(DateiTime Unknown)
SCENE ATTENDANCE BY M.E. DOCTOR: NO M.E. INVESTIGATOR: NO

Page 1 of 2

02/13/17 Page 210 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
1 /KC
OFFICE OF THE MEDICAL EXAMINER
DISTRICT 15, State of Florida
Palm Beach County
West Palm Beach, FL 33406
(561) 688-4575

CASE INFORMATION SHEET
Printed: Jul 05, 2016

M.E. CASE: 160525 INVESTIGATOR: Lydia Littlefield, Forensic Investigator
PATHOLOGIST: Gertrude Juste,Pathologist
SCENE OF DEATH
—LOCATION OF DEATH
Palms West Hospital 13001 Southern Blvd. Loxahatchee FL non-std addr: E.R.

DATE TIME PRONOUNCED DEAD OR FOUND:Apr 01. 2016 19:26
SCENE ATTENDANCE BY M.E. DOCTOR: NO M.E. INVESTIGATOR: NO

FOUND DEAD: NO DIED IN E/R: YES DIED AS INPATIENT: NO
PRONOUNCED DEAD: YES DIED IN 0/R: NO DEAD ON ARRIVAL: NO

AGENCIES
AGENCY 1 NAME: PALM BEACH SHERIFF'S OFFICE AGENCY 1 CASE #:16-058738
AGENCY 2 NAME: PALM BEACH COUNTY FIRE RESCUE AGENCY 2 CASE #: 16-036452
CRIME SCENE TECH(S) OTHER DETECTIVE(S)
Julie AnnBrandt. Crime Scene Tech ID:4169 Vionide Saint-Jean. Detective ID:8192
Child Protection Inv ID:0

)ATE TIME OF M.E. NOTIFICATION:Apr 1, 2016 0:00 DATE TIME OF TRANSPORT NOTIFIED:Apr 2, 2016 23:30

DISPOSITON OF BODY: All County Funeral Hm LW PHONE: (561) 533-8878

Page 2 of 2

02/13/17 Page 211 Public Records Request No.: 17-058

YC‘
Wood privacy fe ice
Wood privacy fence
tT

Front door 17148

(On)

Garage
Vehicles parked in grass west of driveway

Walkway

Barbeque 00
Garbage cans

16-058738
17148 30 Lane North Basketball hoop
Loxahatchee
Prepared by: CSI J. Brandt, ID 4169
09/27/16
Not To Scale

N Driveway

4 Mailbox

02/13/17 Page 212 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
resser
Curtains Table

Amana Refrig. Shelving units
,..
Fs Bedroom Kitchen
III-c Love seat

Toilet ;`

Vanity w/ sink
o
_c

Hall bathroom
Living room
co

16-058738
17148 30 Lane North
Closet Loxahatchee
Prepared by: CSI J. Brandt, ID 4169
09/27/16
Bedroom Not To Scale
Dog crate
Dining table

Tarp on floor

Garage
a cess OS010 Uelln

02/13/17 Page 213 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 1 of 7

Halms Motors Ft Lauderdale 866-310-8372
2000 N. State Road 7 Click To Email Dealer
Lauderdale Lakes, FL 33313

Used Cars Financing Specials About Us c Visit Our Website

Home > Used Cars > Used Ford > Used Ford Super Duty F-250> 2007 Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw Truck SEARCH

« Back to Search Results El Like G+1 NrfWeet

2007 Ford Super Duty F-250 Retail Price $44,995

4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw Truck Best Deal $36,688
2007 FORD F250 SUPER DUTY

Photos Videos

Location: Ft. Lauderdale, FL

866-310-8372
Call Us About This Vehicle

Request More Info
First Name

Last Name

Phone

Email Address

Comments

-Sender`

Request A Test Drive

Get A Quote

Make An Offer

Call Today

Get Pre-Approved

Photo 4 of 24 Full Size Media Viewer Get A Trade In Appraisal
View & Print Brochure

About This Ford Buyer Resources
PureCars

VIN #: 1FTSW21P17EA11424
2007 Ford Super Duty F-250 Similar Vehicles
4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw Truck Stock #: A11424C That May Interest You

Condition: Used Clear Title
City MPG: Hwy MPG:
Engine: 6.0L 8 CYLINDER TURBOCHARGED
N/A N/A
Transmission: Automatic Actual rating will vary with options, 2006 Ford CAB FORW 550 BLUE
driving conditions, habits and
vehicle condition. DI
Mileage: 7,376 GET THE JOB DONE? CLEAN LOW
MILES
Drivetrain: Four Wheel Drive $11,588

02/13/17 Page 214 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty J-250-4wd_crew_c... 9/27/2016 C-4--C?
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 2 of 7

Exterior Color: r Black WOMEN
Interior Color: ri Black/Red
analikr
View the Free
CARFAX
Interior Surface: Leather Report
2006 Ford Super Duty F-550
Warranty: As-Is
$11,788

Contact Information
Bast Dasills. No Ganars. Haims Motors Ft Lauderdale Internet Dept. Lauderdale
2004 Ford Super Duty F-350
2000 N. State Road 7 866-310-8372 DRW
Lauderdale Lakes, FL 33313 Crew Cab 156" XL
Request More Info
$10,977

CARFAX Vehicle History Report
The first step to protecting yourself against buying used cars with costly hidden problems.
SHOW ffr CARFAX searches its nationwide database and provides a detailed vehicle history report in seconds.
e r 2011 Ford F-150
View the Free 2WD SuperCrew 145" FX2
View the FREE CARFAX Report
CARFAX
Report $17,777

Vehicle Overview

2012 Ford F-150
Haims Motors is totally committed to full transparency and dedicated to customer $21,888
satisfaction. We are a high volume dealer and partner with over 50 banks Because
of our quality vehicles and huge volume our banks give us the very best rates and
the right loans to fit your needs.

Options & Features

Ext / Int Color Power Equipment Interior
Black with Black/Red Leather 12v Power Outlet Center Arm Rest
Interior Power Locks Center Console
Power Steering Clock
Cup Holders
Safety Features Tachometer
Four Wheel Drive Vanity Mirrors
Drivers Air Bag Exterior
Intermittent Wipers
Passenger Air Bag Locking Tailgate
Tow Hooks
Audio / Video
AM/FM
Bluetooth
CD Player
HD Radio
HD Radio
Premium Sound
Separate Tweeters
Subwoofer
Surround Sound
USB Port
USB Port
Voice Control
Voice Control

02/13/17 Page 215 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty_f-250-4wd_crew_c_. 9/27/2016 W0
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 3 of 7

Features & Specifications *
MECHANICAL

• 6.0L OHV V8 turbo-diesel "Power Stroke" engine • Trans Order Code : 448
• Stationary elevated engine idle control (SEIC) • Trans Type : 5
• Engine block heater *Standard in AK, CO, IA, ME, • Trans Description Cont : Automatic w/OD
MN, MT, ND, SD, WI & VVY. Optional in all other
• First Gear Ratio (:1) : 3.11
states.*
• Torqshift 5-speed automatic transmission w/OD • Second Gear Ratio (:1) : 2.22

• 2-speed transfer case w/manual locking front • Third Gear Ratio (:1) : 1.55
hubs • Fourth Gear Ratio (:1) : 1.00
• 3.73 axle ratio • Fifth Gear Ratio (:1) : 0.71
• 4-wheel drive • Reverse Ratio (:1) : 2.88
• Dual 78 amp/hr (750 CCA) battery • Transfer Case Model : New Venture 271
• 110-AMP HD ALTERNATOR • Transfer Case Gear Ratio (:1), High : 1.00
• Trailer tow pkg-inc: 7-wire harness w/relays, 7/4 • Transfer Case Gear Ratio (:1), Low : 2.72
pin combination connector, trailer brake wiring kit
w/o controller • Cold Cranking Amps @ 0° F (Primary) : 750

• 156" WB • Cold Cranking Amps @0° F (2nd) : 750

• 6-3/4' pickup box-inc: (4) tie-down hooks, • Maximum Alternator Capacity (amps) : HD 115
partitionable & stad<able storage • Maximum Alternator Watts : 1650
• 10000# GVVVR, 2800# max payload • Frame Type : Ladder-Type
• (2) Front tow hooks • Suspension Type - Front : Coil
• Mono-beam front axle w/coil spring suspension • Suspension Type - Rear : 2-Stage Leaf
• HD gas shock absorbers • Spring Capacity - Front (Ibs) : 4000
• Front stabilizer bar • Spring Capacity - Rear (Ibs) : 6100
• LT265/70R17E BSW all-season tires • Axle Type - Front : Dana Monobeam
• 17" premium forged polished aluminum wheels • Axle Type - Rear : Ford Full-Floating
w/bright center ornaments
• Axle Capacity - Front (Ibs) : 6000
• Full-size spare tire w/lock & carrier
• Axle Capacity - Rear (Ibs) : 6200
• 2-ton mechanical jack
• Axle Ratio (:1) - Front : 3.73
• Pwr steering
• Axle Ratio (:1) - Rear : 3.73
• Pwr 4-wheel disc brakes
• Shock Absorber Diameter - Front (mm) : 35
• 4-wheel anti-lock braking system (ABS)
• Shock Absorber Diameter - Rear (mm) : 35
• Chrome exhaust tip
• Steering Type : Pwr
• Vehicle Name : Ford Super Duty F-250
• Steering Ratio (:1), On Center: 17.0
• Body Style : Crew Cab 6-3/4'
• Turning Diameter- Curb to Curb (ft) : 51.8
• Body Code : 156" VVB
• Turning Diameter - Wall to Wall (ft) : 53.7
• Drivetrain : 4-Wheel Drive
• Brake Type : Pwr
• Gross Axle Wt Rating - Front (Ibs) : 5200
• Brake ABS System : 4-Wheel
• Gross Aide WI Rating - Rear (Ibs) : 6100
• Disc - Front (Yes or) : Yes
• Curb Weight - Front (Ibs) : 4356
• Disc - Rear (Yes or) : Yes
• Curb Weight - Rear (Ibs) : 2713
• Front Brake Rotor Diam x Thickness (in) : 13.66 x
• Gross Vehicle Weight Rating Cap (Ibs) : 10000 0.58
• Engine Order Code : 99P • Rear Brake Rotor Diam x Thickness (in) : 13.39 x
• Engine Type : Diesel V8 0.47

• Displacement : 6.0L/364
• Fuel System : Turbo-Charged OHV
• SAE Net Horsepower @ RPM : 325 @ 3300
• SAE Net Torque @ RPM : 570 @ 2000

EXTERIOR

INTERIOR

SAFETY

EPA Fuel Economy & Specification

• These are the standard features and specifications for this vehicle. Actual features may vary.
Please see the details for this vehicle above.

Vehicle Condition

02/13/17 Page 216 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty_f---250-4wd_crew_c_. 9/27/2016 V(4(
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 4 of 7

Warranty
As-Is - Not covered by a warranty. Contact seller for details.

CONTACT US TODAY TO SCHEDULE A TEST DRIVE.

AT HAIMS MOTORS WE ALWAYS TRY TO FIND THE BEST VEHICLES AT THE BEST PRICES,
SO WE CAN PASS ON THE SAVINGS TO OUR CUSTOMERS.
ON OCCASIONS, THE VEHICLE PURCHASED MAY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN AN ACCIDENT.
IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT ITS PERMANENTLY DAMAGED OR UNSAFE.
OUR QUALIFIED TECHNICIANS INSPECT EVERY VEHICLE BEFORE IT IS OFFERED FOR
SALE.
WE OFFER A COMPLIMENTARY CARFAX REPORT AND ENCOURAGE CUSTOMERS TO HAVE THE
VEHICLE INSPECTED BY AN INDEPENDENT MECHANIC.
EXTENDED WARRANTY PROGRAM IS AVAILABLE ON MOST VEHICLES.

CONTACT US TODAY TO SCHEDULE A TEST DRIVE OR VISIT US AT
WWVV.HAIMSMOTORS.COM

0.11.a• ••••Now•

NEE ttig "NW-
VIVACHAUMMOTOILCOM 961-211-3M

magammaziar—miimirkmeowsK"

02/13/17 Page 217 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty_f-250-4wd_crew_c... 9/27/2016 V6..;-
(
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 5 of 7

02/13/17 Page 218 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty J-250-4wd_crew c... 9/27/2016
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 6 of 7

02/13/17 Page 219 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty_f-250-4wd_crew_c_ . 9/27/2016 4/16.
2007 Used Ford Super Duty F-250 4WD Crew Cab 156" Outlaw at Haims Motors Ft Lau... Page 7 of 7

MID, BY FORD MOTOR CO.
DA ot,s stir zoome43Ar;
reoLiPwg .51'XiE *SC: VOtG IES SW 616:11 ik.W
2359* TO 15 : Iff215/651241. BPI
1:1775/55A2M wirs2011(11
twa 41 ,
450 kW :5:5 fil OLD; Of •151 VIA/ OS 3541
Al
Sinnac tOliFWV. Rtl Affilfilfil KIM Afff0
vat sAit WOWS 15 MO0015102 Of
IhOolfatral SOffintOlaii RN;
Oni_ 1 FISW11P17E.A11424
Tin' NA
ll,1111 ',151,101:11.i
1111/11PD1111.111:31j 11 rlu .0 0 :,
.
0,01 ---Fr Ili 131.35 1 ICI
ar k t 'TV ;41:if+1.14
15'i ti 1 S :(

866-310-8372 Call Us About This Vehicle
Request More Info Request A Test Drive Get A Quote Make An Offer

First Name Last Name Comments
Send
Phone Email Address

It is the customer's sole responsibility to verify the existence and condition of any equipment listed. Neither the dealership nor eBizAutos is responsible for misprints on prices or equipment. It is the customer's
sole responsibility to verify the accuracy of the prices with the dealer, including the pricing for all added accessories.

02/13/17 Page 220 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
http://haims-ft-lauderdale.ebizautos.com/detail-2007-ford-super_duty_f--250-4wd_crew_c... 9/27/2016 W2.:.0
DAVID I Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 2 of 17

Page No: 1
User ID:
Image Key:

GITY/0 AGYAI taw RPM
I MiretnI*11
STATE OF FLORIDA
ss0/39664

APPLICATION FOR VEHICLE/VESSEL 41443395
CERTIFICATE OF TITLE
TIRE NURIBER VENCLEMESTAEL IDENTIFICATION I YR LAKE MAHE cc BODY VEHICLE mice WTEENGTH GWV/LOO
AANUFACTLNER TTPE

120951529 IFTSW21P17EA11424 2007 FORD P] ELK FM69
Doe or ISSUE TRANS minx ta HIAA. ION WATER FL NURSER MTH
ND. DAY rem CODE MATERIAL DENTRUCTICN

11 18 13 OUT 1 PRIVATE
BIRTHOATE RESIDENT OM
SEX P. DAY YEAR Y N AUER FER#
AAANAMwses Name a Addmes
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN ' M 03 03 78 X ir-1
17148 30TH LANE N. 2/10 OWNER FUDU/ OR
LOXAFIATCHEE FL 33470 li moot RAL110111
FELDAI UNTTIT

00780830
A4550007$0830
A4550
I
WWII/TARN, CONTRIBUTIONS

AGENCY TITLE FEE SALES TM GRAND TOTAL
FEE

14.75 1 103.00 0.00 r —1077751
Ration Requested : OTUO USED TITLE Strands :
RETAINED AS ELECTRONIC TITLE

PREY. STATE DATE WED COCBIETER / VESSEL PANOJFACTURER ODOMETER
DECLARATION
CERTIFICATEIN
MS to/09/20 5 XX 39 MILES 10/09/2015 ACTUAL 0

LIEN INFORMATION CLUE OF LIEN RECEIVED DATE FEIO k OR FL / DI. AND SEXPOID OME OF BIRTH MeV AOCOUNT I
ELT 10/09/2015 11/113/2013 380572512-01 208951310
NAME OF FAST LET HOLDER
ALLY FINANCIAL
POOREST/ SALVAGE TICE
ELECTRONIC LIEN

SELLER INFORMATION
NAME OF SeJ.ER, FLORIDA DEALER, ON oTHEA PREVIOUS OWNER
MAIMS MOTORS INC
ADORERS
2000 N STATE RD 7
LAUDERDALE LAKES, FL 33313
own% ticoise I.
VI10063137 coNsumect MULES TAX EXEWTION II

INEXCATE TOTAL PURCHASE MOE. INCLUDING ANY
SALES TAX AND USE REPORT UNPAJD BALANCE DUE SELLER, BANK OR OTHERS
TRANSFER or TITTLE 0
PURCHASER BOLDS VALID
IS =NET TROIA maturirou CRIMETICATZ WWI SALES OR USE TM DUE AS FRovueo BY CHAPTER S 0,00
212,NCFDA STATUTES
now* sums OR 0 VEHICLE / VESSEL WILL BE
USE TAX TOP. TEE USED EXCLUSIVELY TOR RENTAL
wrap IS) CHAD 0 OTHER It. SELLING, PRICE VERIFIED

APPLICART CERTIFICATION
MA WNW COM/FT/AT THEWNTLENESSEL To w Timm WU. Nor SE 01/NATE0 UPONTHS !LAUD NOWINIMATENNITS OE WIS mu.
-- i NNW VAT TIN INISTIFICATSW WU 111 UNIT OROVATENED.
— towerrnArNes mormwmaavomA WO IIVONOIlloa trow mama trots UM INN ALNouNo 0 sow New NSIMODA
EMMET NINIVY NW NOTHAAAALT Otol MAMAS comANNo WHINAIWOUL,PRO AIMS APPTATATIONFORITRE IF DERN v11mos= NOIRE IS WNW WON TRW TWA. ISM
OSETINGITAIWIN USAINWINIMITONCLANT Tim veNcLevaNS. ONNIWEDAWNS MOWED ST 1.10110lOW/ OHM MOTE. TNT ITATINOININEE TOWNINO VW WM MIAMI NICUMPI.
11111:01 MOIL= OF HANWIN. I DEMME THAT NONE READ DIE FOFE60040 INSOUNNUNIO 111413-0417W111117ATIED IN IT AN11111111.

Donoluro or tosN/Dowir Ekoeure of Apptari/CoOsoir
1 HS/AV 1 RE KM CODE ?kyr

I UNDERSTAND THAT MY DRIVER LICENSE AND REGISTRATIONS WILL BE SO DED IMMEDIATELY W THE INSURER owes
THE INSURANCE INFORMATION SUBMITTED FOR THIS REGISTRATION.

02/13/17 Page 221 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScannedDocuments/ScannedDocumentImagePF?transact... 9/28/2016 w/
DAVID I Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 4 of 17

Page No: 2
User ID:
Image Key:

DMS Deal
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF
HIGHWAY SAFETY AND MOTOR VEHICLES Number: A11424
APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATE OF TITLE WITH/WITHOUT REGISTRATION MS Customer
SUBMIT THIS FORM TO YOUR LOCAL TAX COLLECTOR OFFICE
Number: NIA
yarew.fitommovio1112651
01,2sAILIKedseilyjn 1,1 0 OMOSNAL 0 TRANSVER VIEHIcLE rms: J MOTOR VEHICLE 0 MOBILE HOME 0 VESSEL 044E4GJIWAY VEHICLOf 0 ATV 0 ROY 0 MC
OWNER i 00.1CANT INFORMATFON
Customer No,bor Ctiack Are tee 0 you an rocitsestre Cotnier cialten Molitor RCN Ruffen'
the tettliftUtle of Re W Wpftniot
Are Ifade Hands ortiftent7 law Dv Ora 1BD
II
30393.12 lila ytiv no Mee Oyes Ono Ejp. jZin.
II OR 0 AND NOTE: Mee* Cernefthip, tiesse Indies* rot cieinrec tc shawl art POI Oen istrted I Wow OcK N ducked, the Ma Will he issued xdrand.'
It a . rtable U iNs EsladoRerrainkr Pomo 0II 'renew, By es EnIntif 0 %ft 1114,41 of Sivioatifie CefrOte; Coon of Resikrife RAL.l KACH . , ...._
• r er e IJrne An I AVOW* on Driver License /F1rO6 rdl MideteIMeltle, & Mot Nome} Cowers Email Mdse. Dote of Birth 000 FL Dd old Cloaca. or TEI=uffix 0
ALEJANDRO ALEMAN 3f3f1ST8 M
ce-o.co....esse eh None As h Atftfe fee ern Off4W1.4ornsa Ost LILT lakkiciffleden, A LCM No ) Co•Donte'srteseee's Erroll Addrt.ds i Data of SIM Part FL DO FERTI II

Domes Malang Maras.' Imendefory uttoos a I hilleary) zip
17148 30TH LANE N. LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470
Co-Oesectika4see's Msilra hi:Yen (hkrdoiory wGret a nrnsaer Or So M Meryl. Cry Ste Lp

Oirrie(alleetasiA PP,JWCSi Wool Addoesa es Florida fklartderbay ur4iiiiii a mealier of the MB:ay) cal, Mete
17148 30TH LANE N. LOXAHATCHEE FL 33470
110 Home Riveted Mdse Si 0a0kaba f C1000 0 kl 0 0000 maw wimp* 000 to aroma Ms. at, Stale bp

1.41 To CdAturce Nor. (V tlY,cfent From Above Crated MAT To Cutorkarner's email Aoeres. Die of Ft Ehioc License or FE IteSulls

Me 'ftt CO DI Iffertml f rern Above Mei rej ) DP

44 MOTOR VEHICLE , MOBILE HOME OR VESSEL DESCR1P
tdeLisAfissai ideelficatiart *NOW BtalsaBtarefooten- Year 504, COW Fiwids TM. NWtter

1FTSW21P17EA11424 FORD 2007 TK ELK Out of State
Prea:cus auto ie Issue Uwe* Pews Auld PelYtrain tlNtsee W0101 Level JUG CVAVLOC 1 VAN USE, IP own
FL hr.
MS IERLG71 TON 7200 CI PASSER:3ER 0 OTHER
TYPE (RILL MATERIAL U FUEL morr oFvEsse.
:1 Dow ihdfutrtif 0 Havutat 0 Pmeettl Dreamt 0 Word 0 anima 0 Odbosni Elsd 0 sid ow dein dwateta
0 Cable lAtatere 0 Part= 0 Cast 0 FAVOR ID $h.I Elks:sat 0 Air PlepaLlei 0 0CW vessel dreiNkf
0 had ary Salboal 0 Al twat 0 or& 0 wootmonsats 0 tboanotainard 0 °km IN.
Ft
0 talestA 0 Sanest 400. 0 Other 0 Other 0 Cara *Fry et WHOM Of fral CI
SrAr-47Y Avargi IIActi eamsateesabolti
USE OF VESSEL REMUS
0 Reiaticnel (Pthewee) 0 0:macre:MEW Crib ID 0701,040d0184re CZetb ID Othinment 0 CaortoseZ0 I Sleeve CUT•Cf.STATE
0 taglentIand. 0 Canoe rdal Fah 0 D'afirbred 11,93 Hli 1 a ConoulditShrimpRetip. 0 Coarnarcal ChM* 0 Giamatti Wee REGISTRATION NADER
0 Ewe, 0 lite (1.4ery) 0 Cue rforcal Mo:Terel 0 °motet& Mold+ NonAido, 0 oarmrtie oyoor 0 Canna/titSpar/LoirAr
Pookf.drty Federal,' Dethemnid Waal. Athe:h Capy of: Slate NOVO Lite
0 U.S. Coast Dowd Ream+ From Omani Itiart Rom or 0 Com et emceed Eloortatbtori Moen
BRAN ACEEtrill RE IOthaak Applicable Sexes)
OSHORT TERM LEASE 05003 TERM LEASE ORESOILT OPOUCE VEHICLEOPRWATE USE 0 TAXICAB ©FLOOD Om Ocusrou
0ASSEIMLED FROM PARTS OTIONDED rnis paw ©GLIDER KR 01.6kNUF. PUY BACA OREPLY:A 0 AUTONCNCTIS DE1ECTFOC OSTREET ROO
4 I LIENHOLOSA INFORMATION
CHECK(
IF ELT
r,,,- , 0 PEED!
De 0 Olt So ene Odle or 011ib 0 DMV Adecorti e D°4 6f Low.
Name

CLISTOWR 1-.....,- DMV: 208951310
1(102015 ALLY FINANCIAL
Lforthelliers anal Address Monooiderts Awress Ctly Mote Bp
PO BOX 8110 coCKEYSVILLE MD 21030
I- 1 Illlealaider thiamine the Magenta le sersIlkkieelar we** at male Maw 560 le De tow, semi bat mil ecuterailm.
L.....1 (Om [LI ern le made). Hew le nettsicust Ms oil to mated to the Lit ferthatu. [Stature of Lkalt4IMSHIPIIIIaletat

5 i TRANSFER TYPE
F OVAERSHPIOM DONSFERATII, flOW AM MEN WM THEY-01CM, NMI NNE, Ort VMS& ACCRIPED7
TALE 001T1 0 REPOSSEMIth __,C] =Krona 0 onestrinctrk, , . _ DATE ADMIRED 10 9 2015
6 1 ODOMETER DECLARATION

WARHING Wail mMJEDRIIILEtheathiLleatw. c1dfa Re trikorreIo omit . ,, . ., ,• ,,,,, - of F lb - .. •. a d RDNA In rims or lesttheaweat.
1
ME STATE DALT THIS 0 5 OR 0 6 CIDIT ODOMETER NOW READS ICI
THAT TO THE PEST OF LIYAWR ANOWLEDDE THE ODOMETER RF.,ADING:
0 L , EjEii AL to Nam RILES, DATE READ 1©I s 12015 MO 'ME PERM CERTIFY

0 t. REELECTS ACIONL MILEAGE.. II 2. IS IN EXCESS cc ITS ME:CHARM DINTS. ,. NOT TIE ACTUAL MILEAGE

1 seatsSALES TAX REPORT AND VEHICLE TRADE IN NM/MUM A PUT E)
TLORIDATAAT$TAX REDISTRAT.CS1 MAMA Oat GEMS LITALER tKvaE sid0DCLli AW78HT OFT .,„rifte .. i ••• 4, WI NAME

WM OF TRUER Maar TIMM el
10/9/2015 V110083137
Mt MAISEROP TiMGEM M
$1,400,82 111
I. DTIITOICAT .-4- r' 1- Hr Of lltAte DI
200$ FORD 94122594 1 4 $1P 6E812211
HSMV 82040 - REV. 12/12 RULE 150-21.001, FAC viwoHnirry.sin

02/13/17 Page 222 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScarmedDocuments/ScannedDocumentImagePF?transact.. . 9/28/2016 (1,,Y?
DAVID Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 8 of 17

Page No: 4
User ID:
Image Key:

STATE OF FLORIDA
AMENT OF HIGHWAY SAFETY AND MOTOR VEHICLES
DIVISION OF MOTORIST SERVICES
Neil Kirkman Building Tallshasnee FL 32399-0S00
MOTOR VEIIICLE TITLE REASSIGNMENT SUPPLEMENT
e,
t>
This reassignment is s to: Title No. tate of Issue MISS &)-1 Pc) 1
Menufscturi e Of Origin
Is Me title electronic? yes

VEHICLE DESCRIPTION
Valid.% Marmites:lion Number Year
IFTEW21P17EA11424 20fY7 FORD r—ase R 4WD CREW': Cf B 1..56
REASSIGNMENT INFORMA'T'ION
NAM orSencalsY I(Print) DL/IDJ,1 4 ACCr7P, FERMI DEALEPJAUCTION LICENSE (if li

-,41$4116-3441.1IMS-ilge mamas v
SoettAddrelo City State

AtilittinOrEir-7-Lat .1 6-Ittlaninou u sow Tex TO+ Ni,. DIApplicatded

a7J4. ,s Printed mewls) Date ofSale

ldelfteasiL-EPRN 14/09/15
.
City State

Clfl aciataer'sAddresslifappticabkr My Sttde Zip

Auction None Of applirobleI AaetioaLitenscNumber Statetd'Leceuse Dade of Ai un.

Street Address City State Zip

ra
ODOMETER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
WARNING: FEDERAL AND STATE LAW REQUIRE THAT YOU STATE THE ODOMETER MILEAGE IN CONNECTION WITH TRANSFER
OWNERSHIP. FAILURE TO COMPLETE OR PROVIDING A FALSE STATEMEYT MAY RESULT IN FINES ANDIOR IMPRISONMENT.

UWE STATE THAT THIS El 3 OR 8 DIGIT ODOMETER NOW itF_ADSaDD,00 0,0, (No
TENTHS) MILES.
DATE REATICAM__. AND IEREBY CERTIFY THAT TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE THE ODOMETER READING.
CAUTION: 13 I. REFLECTS ACTUAL MILEAGE
READ CAREFULLY Q 2. IS IN EXCESS OF ITS MECHANICAL LIMITS
BEFORE YOU 3. IS NOT THE ACTUAL MILEAGE. WARNING - ODOMETER DISCREPANCY
CHECK A BOX
UNDER PENAL TI F PEJUURY. I DECLARE THAT I VEHEAD THE FOREGOING
DOCUMENT AND THAT THE PACTS STAT IN rr, ARE TRUE
PriebedNaote of telbsisMiumit ScIleeDIP

I4 M biaTORS
Printed Num 9r Orscilzt BF applicable) C

Purchaser(s) Sipmdure a) Signature

PurciateEJANDROAALIEWRIM Middle or mcado, Cori Ca.PyinhasollA Primed Name PIM, Full Middle or Maiden. Lag

N ID
NOTICE: ANY ALTERATION OR ERASURE MAY VOID THIS ASSIGNMENT AND ALL ASSIGNMENTS THAT FOLLOW.
ORIGINAL: SUBMIT WITH APPLICATION FOR TITLE COPY: SELLEEDEA LER RETAIN IN FILE

fISMV 82994 (REV. 04/14) S

,„:": A :411." A A A AA A A ' AA 'A A 'ry
A A AI' 1". "4°7:17
,

02/13/17 Page 223 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScannedDocuments/ScannedDocumentImagePF?transact... 9/28/2016 077
DAVID1Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 12 of 17

Page No: 6
User ID:
Image Key:

7,
1 Form 78-10100-7-1-000
• ST. I' MISSISSIPPI REPLACEMENT

VEHICLE IDENTIFICATION NUMBER MAKE
YEAR MODEL BODY 1111E NUMBER
1FTSW21P17EA11424 FORD 2007 F2S CW E603503-02

DATE OF FIRST SALE PASS. Maio .119,,i7-NIENT tsar.*
ifhl RAW 0.11,1511e.18 IA* Ititiate
Ting DATE FOR vs5 NEW ONLY NO. CYL. NEr USED TYPLQF VSJICLE GVW NNNNNI NNW INN aNNN., MOAN.
08012007 029'200 1 08 TKULK.

ODOMETER - TENTHS NOT INCLUDED
000250

ACTUAL MILEAGE

OWPER

CD? INC
236 OLD SPANISH TRAIL
WAVELAND MS 39576

SET LIENETOLDER {OR OWNER F PEN) DATE:
CDP INC MONTH I DAY f YEAR
236 OLD SPANISH TRAIL
WAVELAND MS 3 9576

DATE:
2t UEn1HOLDER
MONTH I DAY I YEAR

UE-SISATIEFALIVAN 7141- uNDTN541.0 FC.L.C1NR OF NNV.NE CMWMPCO UEM0a OH T) 1031174 VE,NGLE OESCNIPSD MEINECH NEPEBN Aootow LOXES SATSFACTON THOM.

1ST LIEN By
WNW rE4CNNAutitt ANd

THIS DAY OF 20

2ND LIEN BY 1/•
,LE4.16_to, Tam
. ir. ..) .
THIS DAY OF —1-- ' CI
2O;h7
..---..--
,,,
IN WITTNERS WHEREOF I HAVE SEATO BET to HAND D- 's 1Atssafauppl
- Earaartmanl of Fifl.P.4 tNVIN01 MOW
v an alas:IS-Arian NUIN MONO, INN 'Dolga named Mein ▪ 673 NI
tgraftegz1t212tI% Uw vz
N0 re 18 NNIU1 tNfrr at ... 8
,,,,, ,,, .rit *NI
42,
-" 1 4
THE OM OF
18 MARL) as may subsequ;711/ ba Mad 'am 101 Oscalmanl
tf A04111,0. Taxa =TINAa of tats fs assaie pursuant to A -I co*
14077001010 Atentfaippi
it* Masissnan, Maw yaws TAN IAN SoalsTa 6341.1 NI
a log .....N.
U Coll
Conn af 1072. In.bINV, 10 t* PrOffetNNI
. ., in..., 'V 0 Cli
CONTROL NUMBER -..— I - C::#
DEPARTMENT OF IEVENUE ":::4 '9,40 1
0 i 7 3 20 i 2 ---- -..e.------- 7
p...
77- -7.:.
7 to

-44_44tot
4

02/13/17 Page 224 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScannedDocuments/ScannedDocumentImagePF?transact... 9/28/2016 1-/V
DAVID I Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 13 of 17

02/13/17 Page 225 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScannedDocuments/ScannedDocumentImagePF?transact... 9/28/2016
DAVID I Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 14 of 17

Page No: 7

User ID:

Image Key:

"'NOTICE: ANY ALTERATION OR ERASURE VOIDS THE ASSIGNMENT AND ALL ASSIGNMENTS THAT FOLLOW"'
Federal and Staft LIM Ourrikaa bun $.nu twin Via mienne is 41111160/011 WA 171011131 at owners D'• Fnitre In tampkin. ar provaltv a tat arnitinenl, 1114th In rotes attv5.1:( knrielment.

ASSIGNMENT OF TITL,E ,, ':BY REGISTERED OWNER
Thr cyrca Av., r 1,,55,11,414+55114 *MA,*siirL4 ror.,4,1145*55,, tp 11 xftmerip, r o; tot 4,, 5511 t,5145, 515 47".

Na 11%0 0 AdtbileS

cattily to the best of my lossiviadde that the octants*: rending is the actual mileage of t10 vshicle enlass one of sic Inflasing siatainente is checked
k CAUTION: READ U I.The Mikage sista') le Is excues of us easehentesd Smits,
-7 bp WREFULLY BEFORE
YOU CHECK A BLOCK D a Trif, vlomtater resting ts not the actual mileage.
ODOMEAR READINCi Tame) WARNING! ODOMETER DISCREPANCY A
g
SELLER:
Signaluro(a) 16— d Print Nnine(S)CDP 0,v-{ a 1, (5-
I am aware of The have odometer cietticatan made by selsr.'
BUYER:
Svnature(s) Prided '' 6)1'

FIRST GNMENT BY LICENSED DEALER I
5,1444,41 4 titsairte,lisa 11114 451 $ 1155 Wpm .•41 115 154v,,r5i peat 1'5,4 W 1401404 5.14 ,41,451, MI5 oe -,1 tnetilf MNc.Y4J1. 611'151i ateofF
.

Nat .1
a
esulify to the best of my knot/I/AN that the *demist r rending Is e o aohmimIonol of tliC Wider /mhos one of Ma Mhz:ono among= Is ohooltect
CAUTION: READ 0 I. The milaton elated is n access of Its mechanics.; limits.
d. CAREFULLY BEFORE
YOU CHECK A BLOCK 2. Tha odairiter morn la net Vie actual miens,
ODOMETER READ/NG (No TortOs) WARNING: ODOMETER DISCREPANCY
DEALER OR AG Delo
Sonata/Xs) Printed Firm 1 `6../""'"--• of Sale 41 -pit .-eS.
lam av /moo octangle( orntrtoo' an rr, by
EUYER:
Signature(s) Printed Name(s)
8 g

SECOND RE-ASSNMIII'&IT ST LICENSED DEALER

me Addams
Itcen,ty to the best of my inimulsits that 11w octurittor merino Is tos /Cool rorm‘C•of than trehtep ii/thiro:,thr of Plo lolleorne Mahttonutt 12 therotuut
CAUTION: READ El 1. ihz rritoitecieloso 'sinebeales of Mectilisileal rnlIs.
CAREFULLY BEFORE
--.
5:1 YOU CHECK A BLOCK 0 2. The cdorrater Teasing N nu me trugal mews.
ODOMETER FtE 4G No Ye WAfnNING: ocomerEn DISCREPANCY
DEALER OR AD
Signaturo(2) Noted Ran Ntmc / iCJ ••• 4e/ A-""--- not Sabo IC (14)
I ant I, of who r o tor =Mins' art mad: by Seel,"
BUYER:
Bignatrthe(s) Nk tags)

THIRD RE•ASSIGNMEIIT BY ucesIseo DEALER
Tr, tor 15 15:4 5155141,54 : 1.71115 C.:," 1..1'.-5 5, J14 ,Isz koD:nn r , . 1,1:4 III V•tr11. bt1"4 5144,r
.

Name Addreaa
- •
certify 2o me EI of thy kyssinteciga Stud the ottani& reading is ass Indust intlasso of L,,s sables unless coo of INS Sciltraing alaternents !a obacked:
CAIJTIOIJ: READ ❑ 1, The rotoeva MMod to in gyve q OA/ truchz.nroof hmik
CAREFULLY esPoRE 2.
YOU CHE= A BLOCK D Tn,t, totons.1i useing ti sot Sib etboll 11041(je-
OccM'ETER PEADiNG Roo Terit3.> . WitAirm, OCCUETERDfsoFtPANCY •

DEALER OR AGENT: Dale
Sagnature(e) Pr"mtect F mi Name of Sale
'I am aware of Ste atone Worn/ter cenfliceton mute by Leiter'
BUYER:
Sinaatvre(s) Prihled tk-rmcIff }

LIENHOLDER TO DE SI-It:ilia) OPa TIEVI TITLE

Lion in I woof of

whose address N

02/13/17
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScannedDocuments/ScarmedDocumentImagePF?transact... 9/28/2016
Page 226 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
yqy
DAVID I Driver and Vehicle Information Database Page 16 of 17

ALE:JANDRO -
ALEMAN
14S7 SW AACliEll A
PORT ST L9CfE,
EPS: 03-03478 S
ISSUtE1'

02/13/17 Page 227 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
https://david.flhsmv.gov/DAVID/ScannedDocuments/ScarmedDocumentImagePF?transact... 9/28/2016(i9f
Palm each County Activity #: A16-004620.1

Animal Care and Control
Case Report
Complainant Defendant
DISPATCH PBSO KRISTEN ALEMAN
3228 GUN CLUB RD 17148 30TH LN
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406 LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
561.688.3400 / 561.242.5800 772.475.4478

Animal
ID: A1821369 Breed: AMER BULLDOG Sex: M

Name: ACHILLES Color: WHITE / BRINDLE Age: 2 YEARS

Activity Type: POLICE AGENCY EMERG. ASSISTANCE (1914)

Location: Loxahatchee

Arrival Date/Time: 4/2/2016 3:35:00 AM Complete Date/Time: 4/2/2016 4:45:00 AM

Report Narrative:

On 4/2/2016, 3:35 a.m., I responded to 17148 30th Lane North Loxahatchee, Fl 33470 in reference to a
police assistance investigation. The Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office dispatch center requested I respond to
the address noted above in reference to several residents being removed from the home. It was reported that
two dogs were inside the home and may need to be removed due to lack of care.
Upon arrival I met with Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Crime Scene investigator Brandt ID # 4169 (Case
number 16-058738) along with several other police detectives and deputy sheriffs. I was advised that a search
warrant had been executed and nine children had been removed from the occupancy including one who was
deceased. The residents Alejandro and Kristen Aleman were currently under investigation but were not being
arrested at that time. Escorted by Brandt I entered the residence in order to observe the dog in question. Upon
entering I detected a strong odor of urine. I located the dog inside a bedroom adjacent to the living room. Inside
was a white and brindle intact male American Bulldog wearing a black nylon collar. The dog was confined to a
wire dog kennel with the dimensions of 24 inches wide by 24 inches tall by 36 inches long. The dog appeared to
be malnourished and thin scoring a 3 on the TACC scale with one being ideal body weight and five being
emaciated. The bottom of the cage appeared to be almost completely covered with what appeared to be a
buildup of compacted dog feces. There was a double bowl inside as well but it had no contents. I took twenty
photographs of the dog in the kennel as well as the front of the home and the living room. I noticed an empty bag
of dry dog food leaned up against the living room wall adjacent to two dog bowls, one empty and one half full of
water. One of the deputies on scene advised that there was a second dog on the property but it had been
removed by one of the owners. Brandt advised that she searched the home and was unable to locate and dog
food and hardly any human food as well. At that time I contacted Animal Control Special Investigations
Supervisor Lt. Misti Scaggs and explained to her the situation. The decision was made to seize the dog due to it
living conditions and negative health. I removed the dog from the crate with the use of a catch pole as it was
growling at me and appeared fearful. Once removed, I noticed the dog had sores on its paw and leg. I took
seventeen photographs of the kennel after removing the dog. Upon further inspection, I pried large sections of
the compacted feces from the floor of the cage up to about two inches thick. I kept one such chunk for evidence.
Inside the cage I also found a ketchup package and a C battery. I completed a yellow official notice with case
and contact information on it land left it on top of the dog cage. Upon leaving the scene I briefly met with resident
Alejandro Aleman who was standing down the street. He stated the dog named Achilles had been rescued and
was in him and his wife's custody for about two weeks. I explained to him I left all my information on a card on
the dogs kennel and the dog will be kept at Animal Control for further investigation. I also advised an investigator

Activity #: A16-004620.1 Page 1 of 2 Officer ID: COOK - 2133

02/13/17 Page 228 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
(m6
with Animal Control will be in contact with him in the near future. Upon arrival Back to Animal Control I took two
more photographs of the two sores I noticed on the dog earlier. It should be noted that the dog urinated in the
cage I had him confined to and the dog drank his own urine. Upon feeding the dog it rapidly consumed the food.
This activity was closed with one report, one seize, 39 photographs and one respond to scene. No recheck set
at this time.

Officer C. Cook 2133.

Activity #: A16-004620.1 Page 2 of 2 Officer ID: COOK - 2133

02/13/17 Page 229 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
W7
-001&020

INrampot

MIMI *Cr"
mac s, k 11111"11.641.
DAMI1111111111111111111ftiltA=agtte,
MOEN IIIINEWIlaur14- 1,
'31111-- irmato ftee-1 WNW
Nal " riaaawgrAw
1111111163:31=171==.-2,r—TivEASW
k Mitaishe
MN railiallffig witimapa.
.1.7s777 *VI 14

ii641011110*. "..

` 4

114•1•W•010••••
Mignif

IMILINF_
tittOrrEpTAisusisr
MUM g .
r—r—e .-AisrAdmmar
rnt 771t .-11r;

+ •

02/13/17 Page 230 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
02/13/17 Page 231 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
~1~9
4 it.
`q. •-4
Was -4'414044
111101, 1ter -
"Altkti
,a/1,340 qr."4411111w11141%
'3Z-•!111.11114111
413i,
1 111JA.L
IIIIii
11111Nrig.,%.
iimpmalaw •

lammome
fl mairee
l 424'
a
!!!mollummumm4:4
mooKININEAMOdimp
MINNIAMMImirion
in
NOWIrmsulimisimm
mumwsimItimmammt..:'

010 /UM
N. t^

fir

02/13/17 Page 232 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
02/13/17 Page 233 S- ,1
Public Records Request No.: 17-058
f-A,
c)
Lo

02/13/17 Page 234 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Activity #: A16-004620.2

Animal Care and Control
Case Report
Complainant Defendant
DISPATCH PBSO KRISTEN ALEMAN
3228 GUN CLUB RD 17148 30TH LN
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406 LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
561.688.3400 / 561.242.5800 772.475.4478

Animal
ID: A1821369 Breed: AMER BULLDOG Sex: M

Name: ACHILLES Color: WHITE / BRINDLE Age: 2 YEARS

Activity Type: DELIVER PAPERWORK (1953)

Location: PBCACC

Arrival Date/Time: Complete Date/Time: 4/2/2016 3:57:00 PM

Report Narrative:

On 4/2/16 at 1557hrs I was reviewing this case as it is a possible cruelty. I went to the clinic to observe the dog
as it was receiving an exam by staff veterinarian Dr. Virginia Sayre. When I arrived at the clinic the dog was
being taken for a bath. With the assistance of animal care technician Jason Cree we took Achilles outside for
photographs. I observed Achilles to appear terrified of almost every person that walked towards him. He
cowered down and would run to hide behind Jason. I took several photographs of him. I observed Achilles to be
underweight (TACC 3, 1 ideal and 5 emaciated) with his hip and ribs visible. He had pressure sores on his right
hip and on his legs in places. His nails were overgrown and had feces caked in them. His fur which was mostly
white was stained brownish yellow on his legs and underside and some of his face, from living in feces and
urine. He had small cuts on both of his ears. He smelled very strongly of urine and feces. His black collar was
removed and was placed in to evidence. The collar was extremely dirty and reeked of urine and feces. Jason
Cree then gave Achilles a much needed bath but the staining would still remain due to the length of time it had
been on his coat. Once inside of his kennel I brought him a thick blanket and that was the first sign of him
wagging his tail and he curled up on the comforter and was calm.
Recheck set to make contact with the owners by phone to see if they will surrender Achilles.

Activity #: A16-004620.2 Page 1 of 1 Officer ID: BATCHELOR - 2110

02/13/17 Page 235 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Ald-COL/6020 AA.

02/13/17 Page 236 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
02/13/17 Page 237 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Sc;25-
fi 1(0 -00 c/6,

FP:FI=Man
BM IMMO

02/13/17 Page 238 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Palm Beach County Activity #: A16-004620.4

Animal Care and Control
Case Report
Complainant Defendant
DISPATCH PBSO ALEJANDRO ALEMAN
3228 GUN CLUB RD 17148 30TH LN
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406 LOXAHATCHEE, FL 33470
561.688.3400 / 561.242.5800 772.475.4478 / 561.662.1684

Animal
ID: A1821369 Breed: AMER BULLDOG Sex: M

Name: ACHILLES Color: WHITE / BRINDLE Age: 2 YEARS

Activity Type: DELIVER PAPERWORK (1953)

Location: Loxahatchee

Arrival Date/Time: 4/6/2016 3:33:00 PM Complete Date/Time: 4/6/2016 4:28:00 PM

Report Narrative:

On 4/6/16 at 1533hrs I responded to 17148 30th Lane N., Loxahatchee to try and make contact with the
defendant regarding a dog seized from the property on 4/2/16.
Upon arrival I observed a black Ford Expedition in the driveway. I knocked on the front door and could hear a
large breed dog start barking inside of the home. No contact was made as no one came to the door. I posted a
yellow notice on the door to contact me regarding their dog.
As I was driving away down the road a large black pickup truck started to flash its lights at me. I pulled over
and met with Alejandro Aleman. He stated his wife had called him that I was at his door and she was afraid to
come to the door due to everything that has happened with them that week. He went on to state that he had
found the dog in question, Achilles one night while he was working. He explained that he was a repo man and
was working late at night in Lake Worth. He observed an older Spanish woman walking down the road with the
dog and noticed the dog did not look good and was underweight. He spoke to the woman about taking the dog
and trying to help it and she gave it to him. He thought she was homeless. There was no name of the woman
given. He stated he only had Achilles for a week or so. I asked why the dog was found in a crate that was
compacted with feces and he stated that when the police came that night they ordered his children to put the
dogs up and that the crate was in the garage but they brought it in the house and put the dog inside of it. He
stated he didn't realize there was some feces inside of it until he looked later and threw it away. Mr. Aleman was
very upset off and on speaking of the death of his one year old daughter that night and explaining that he and his
wife had alot going on right then. I advised that he could surrender Achilles to Animal Control or that I would be
going for custody if he chose not to and wanted to fight for him. Again he stated he had alot on his plate so it
would be in the best interest for him to surrender. I went over the owner surrender paperwork with him and he
signed it. I confirmed his identity by his Florida driver's license. I advised I would like to observe his dog that I
heard barking at his home. He stated he didn't want the neighbors to see me back at his property but that he
would go and bring the dog to me there on the side of the road. A few minutes later he retured with his dog
Zeus a brindle male Boxer. Zeus was sitting in the passenger seat and appeared healthy (TACC 1, 1 being
ideal and 5 emaciated). I took one photograph of the dog. Mr. Aleman asked what was going to happen now
and that he knew his story seemed far fetched about the woman in Lake Worth but that it was true. I advised
that if he had a neighbor or someone that could confirm that Achilles was a new dog to the property that may be
beneficial. I advised that the case would be turned over to the state attorney for their review but could not advise
anything beyond that.
No recheck set.

Activity #: A16-004620.4 Page 1 of 1 Officer ID: BATCHELOR - 2110

02/13/17 Page 239 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
5o7
A )6-xk-ipgO‘L-i

02/13/17 Page 240 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
So\'
A lb -00 (140, ao

02/13/17 Page 241 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
,C2/
02/13/17 Page 242 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
5/7
14,-001 b d.0

02/13/17 Page 243 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
Sll
02/13/17 Page 244 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
pia
X116 -00 (I& AO

02/13/17 Page 245 Public Records Request No.: 17-058
SU