The Oracle of Oberhausen

Paul The Psychic Octopus
by Phantomimic All rights reserved © RAGG

The Soccer World Cup is over, a new champion, Spain, has emerged, and the Spaniards have finally gotten over the hangovers from celebrating the event. This World Cup with its brilliant games and many controversies both thrilled and outraged us, giving rise to many vigorous debates and more World Cup lore. The goal that was not called for England in their loss against Germany. A goal eerily similar to Geoff Hurst's infamous "ghost goal" in the 1966 final, also against Germany, that England won. The handball that allowed Uruguay to defeat Ghana and creep into the semifinals after a 40 year dry spell. The shocking non-performances of former world champions Italy and France. The stunning defeats of the Brazilian favorites by the "Clockwork Orange" Dutch team, of Flamboyant Diego Maradona's Argentina by Germany, and of the German team itself by the Red Spanish Furies. And finally the nail-biting final that condemned the Dutch team to yet another second place finish. But years from now when the soccer has all but been forgotten the event that will be remembered will be how Paul, an unassuming octopus dwelling in a tank at the Sea Life Center in Oberhausen, Germany, correctly predicted the outcome of 8 consecutive World Cup games. It all started during the 2008 matches for the European Soccer Cup. In what was a publicity stunt for the aquarium, Paul's keepers began introducing into his tank 2 plastic boxes each containing a tasty mussel. The boxes with lids that the octopus could open had the flag of the German team on one of them and the flag of the opposing team on the other. The idea was that the box that Paul opened first would be the winner of the game. Thus, during the European Cup Paul predicted that the German team would win all of its 6 games but got 2 of the results wrong when the German team was defeated by

Croatia in the Group phase and by Spain in the final. As it turns out Paul was just honing his divination skills. Two years later, during the group phase of the World Cup the cephalopod correctly predicted that Germany would defeat Australia and Ghana and lose against Serbia, but still he remained a local phenomenon. It was during the round of 16 games when Paul predicted that Germany would defeat England that he began to receive international attention, and then everyone went wild when the octopus correctly predicted that Germany would defeat Argentina in the quarter finals. Paul's divinations began to be transmitted live throughout Germany and to other countries, and pundits for and against the mollusk expounded their views in electronic and printed media. Paul became a superstar, a media sensation with his own Twitter and Facebook fan pages. The German soccer fans sensed that the mysterious forces that Paul channeled were on their side. Would Germany win the World Cup? Alas it was not to be, Paul was an honest soothsayer and he called them like he saw them. For next game he chose Spain as the winner. Gloom and doom washed over the German fans. The German players were shocked to learn the news; the cephalopod's "vibes" were no longer on their side. How could THEIR octopus do this to them? On the eve of the game they all prayed and many took solace that Paul had been wrong before, but to no avail, Spain defeated Germany in the semifinal. Angry fans flooded the German media with their favorite octopus recipes. Articles were printed labeling Paul a "traitor". The aquarium received threats and Paul's security detail had to be doubled. Spaniards on the other hand were delighted that the oracle was on their side. The Spanish president announced that he was considering sending

a team of bodyguards to protect Paul, and Spain's environment minister promised to grant Paul the condition of an endangered species so Germans would not eat him. Paul redeemed himself a bit by correctly predicting that Germany would defeat Uruguay in the game for third and fourth place. His handlers then for the first time asked the tentacled oracle to predict the outcome of a game where Germany did not play; the final between Spain and The Netherlands. In his final World Cup prediction the mollusk chose Spain. This was significant as half a world away in Singapore another psychic animal wonder (albeit with a spottier track record), a parrot named "Mani", picked the Netherlands to win. So that fateful final game that we all saw was not just The Netherlands vs. Spain, it was also a clash between the two psychic titans, the parrot vs. the octopus, and you all know the outcome. Despite many hefty monetary offers to the aquarium to have Paul expand his soothsaying abilities to things like the economy as well as requests that Paul be present at different events to honor him, his handlers have said that the mollusk will now retire from the divination business and will live the rest of his life making children happy at the Oberhausen Sea Life Center. Because his species of octopus live at most 4 years it is unlikely that Paul will be with us for the next World Cup. However, besides all the fun and games some people have been left wondering whether Paul was for real. Was there something to his soothsayer abilities? Did Paul have hidden powers? Was he a psychic?

This question is not as silly as it looks. By the time Paul started getting noticed there were individuals who were betting on World Cup games based on his predictions. People "out there" believe the darnedest things and I am sure that Paul's feat convinced many of his fans that there was something going on with this octopus beyond mere chance. So let's put Paul's performance into perspective. First of all the chances of getting the outcome of 8 consecutive games right is 1/256, the same chance of tossing a coin 8 times and correctly predicting the outcome of each coin toss. Although this is not a very probable event it is within the realm of the possible. Paul was not operating against million to one odds here. One way to look at these odds is that if 256 people tossed 8 coins at least one would succeed in predicting the outcome of all eight of them. If you consider that there were a billion plus people throughout the world watching the World Cup and trying to do this, you can calculate that 4 million people or so probably guessed the outcome of 8 games in a row correctly. However, none of them had the tentacles to become a media sensation. The other issue to consider is possible sources of biases in the divination procedure itself. Although octopuses like Paul do not have color vision they do perceive light and dark contrasts, and notice shapes including horizontal lines or bars. So, one possibility is that the flag design on one of the boxes attracted the mollusk's attention more than another. If Paul were attracted to the German

flag design this could have biased his choice in favor of Germany, which he predicted to win 5 out of 7 times. The box location is another possible source of bias. In 6 out of 7 of Paul's divination trials the location of the box he chose was the one on the right (the information about the position of the box is lacking for one of the games). This is important because in 4 out of 6 of his predictions the box with the German flag was also the one on the right. Did Paul predict accurately or did he have a bias for the box on the right and the flag of whoever won happened to be there? Other possible sources of bias include whether any scent or food smears were stronger in one box vs. the other, or even whether the performance of some superstitious players could have been influenced, positively or negatively, when they learned about Paul's choice. The elimination of sources of bias is a common procedure in the scientific test of the abilities of psychics and so far in the history of scientific psychic testing, when all the biases are accounted for, not a single psychic has been able to perform above chance. Thus, if Paul's handlers had been interested in asking the question of whether Paul was for real, they could have concealed the flags, made sure the flags were randomly assigned to a given box, made sure there were no scent or food smears cues in either box, or even revealed Paul's choice after the game to make sure no superstitious players were influenced. But the handlers were not interested in doing this because their intention was not to ask whether Paul really had psychic abilities. They just wanted to attract attention, raise money for the aquarium, and have a good time. And in

this they succeeded beyond their wildest dreams. Others were not so fortunate. For example the Chemnitz zoo also in Germany tried its luck at the divination business with Leon the porcupine, Petty the pygmy hippo, and Anton the tamarin but each of these animals struck out in the group phase of the World Cup picking the wrong team to win. So let's all have a good laugh with the exploits of "The Oracle of Oberhausen" and not take things too seriously and, oh yes, enjoy a nice seafood dish every now and then.

The picture from "Voice of America" is in the public domain. Information for this article was obtained from several printed and electronic sources, including Wikipedia's article on Paul.