Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Robert F. Simons
Received October 3, 1980; revised version received March 11, 1981; accepted March 24, 1981.
Abstract. The vast majority of research programs investigating subjects at high risk
for psychopathology have relied on genetic criteria for subject selection. Recent
reports, however, have begun to suggest alternative definitions and sets of criteria
for the selection of high-risk subjects. One such alternative is a psychometric
definition of risk-the selection of subjects on the basis of psychological test data.
The present experiment used this strategy to study orienting and habituation to
simple auditory stimuli in groups of young adult subjects reporting either physical
anhedonia or perceptual aberrations. The study provided support for the hypo-
thesized continuity between anhedonic subjects and the autonomically hypores-
ponsive group of patients frequently described in the literature on schizophrenia.
Results are discussed in light of recent appeals to identify biologically homogene-
ous subgroups of schizophrenic patients.
This article is based on portions of adissertation project submitted to the University of Wisconsin-Madison
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Ph.D. degree in clinical psychology. Robert F. Simons,
Ph.D., is now Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 1971 I.
have studied individuals with schizotypic code types (Koh and Peterson, 1974;
Steronko and Woods, 1978) on the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory
(MMPI).
Recently, Chapman and his colleagues at the University of Wisconsin have reported
the successful development of psychometric instruments that assess the presence of
personality characteristics thought to be closely associated with schizophrenia. The
two scales they have most thoroughly researched are the Physical Anhedonia Scale
(Chapman et al., 1976) and the Perceptual Aberration Scale (Chapman et al., 1978).
These scales have been very successful in differentiating groups of schizophrenic and
normal subjects, and have also been useful in the identification of individuals in the
normal population who deviate from control subjects in a number of ways analogous
to schizophrenics. For example, both anhedonic and perceptual aberration subjects
report psychotic symptoms when administered the Schedule for Affective Disorders
and Schizophrenia-Lifetime Version (SADS-L) structured psychiatric interview (J.
Chapman, personal communication) and produce evidence of schizophrenic-like
thought disorder when administered the Rorschach test (Edell and Chapman, 1979).
One of the more ubiquitous findings of psychophysiological investigations with
schizophrenic subjects is their consistent deviance on electrodermal measures of
orienting and habituation to simple stimuli. The nature of these differences has been
hotly debated, however. Some investigators have found schizophrenics to be overres-
ponsive and very slow to habituate-that is, hyperaroused (Zahn et al., 1967), while
other investigators report hypoarousal and rapid habituation (Bernstein, 1970).
Gruzelier and Venables (1972; see also Venables, 1977) have helped clarify these
discrepancies by reporting a bimodality of responsivity in schizophrenic patients; a
substantial part of the population is hyperresponsive, while a second group is hypores-
ponsive, often failing to respond to even the first presentation of the orienting stimulus
(nonresponders). Evidence for this bimodality has been independently obtained by
Rubens and Lapidus (1978). Patterson and Venables (1978) have made a case for a
third group of schizophrenics who produce only one or two small, parametrically
unusual responses before complete habituation.
The present experiment investigated electrodermal and cardiac orienting behavior
in subjects defined as schizotypic on the basis of their responses to the Chapman
scales. Three groups of subjects were studied: Subjects reporting physical anhedonia,
subjects reporting body-image distortions, and a group of normal controls. It was
hypothesized that since the anhedonic and perceptual aberration subjects were pre-
sumed to be continuous with schizophrenic subjects (i.e., at high risk), they would
differ from normal controls as schizophrenics do. Specifically, it was hypothesized
that the bimodality proposed by Venables might be demonstrated by these two groups
of schizotypic subjects. If this hypothesis were correct, anhedonic subjects, with a
proposed deficiency in autonomic arousal or arousability, would be hyporesponsive
to nonsignal orienting stimuli, while the perceptual aberration subjects, with a pro-
posed defect in arousal control, would show the opposite, or hyperresponsive pattern
of electrodermal activity. Changes in heart rate were also recorded in response to the
orienting stimuli to determine more clearly the nature of the hypothesized group
differences.
349
Methods
Apparatus. The orienting stimulus was a 1,000 Hz pure tone with a l-second duration
generated by a Hewlett-Packard Model 200 AB oscillator. An electronic switch assured a rise
and fall time of 2 msec. The tone was amplified to 75 dB (SPL) by a Sherwood Model S-9500b
stereo amplifier and presented binaurally to subjects through VanCo Model HF-3 stereo
headphones. A LINC-8 laboratory computer was used for experimental control.
Physiological Recordings. Skin conductance and heart rate were continuously monitored on
a Beckman Type R Dynograph and simultaneously stored on FM magnetic tape. Measurement
of skin conductance was accomplished with Beckman Ag-AgCl standard electrodes placed on
the second phalanges of the first and second fingers of the subjects nonpreferred hand (palmar
surface). The skin was rinsed with distilled water before electrode application. A Beckman Type
9844 constant voltage skin conductance coupler was used for recording purposes with Johnson
and Johnson K-Y Jelly as the electrolyte.
Beckman miniature Ag-AgCl electrodes were used for recording the electrocardiogram
(EKG) with Beckman electrode paste used as the conducting agent. The two electrodes were
placed on the lower antero-lateral rib cage on each side of the heart and the EKG was recorded
with a Beckman 9806A A-C coupler.
Procedure. Subjects were seated in a comfortable reclining chair in the upright position.
Following the attachment of all electrodes and inspection of the recordings, subjects were read a
standard set of instructions. The instructions simply informed the subjects that following a short
rest period they would be presented a series of pure tones. They were instructed to relax and
listen to the tones as they were presented. They were also asked to keep movements to a
minimum once the experimenter returned to an adjacent room housing the recording
apparatus.
The experiment began with a S-minute rest period during which base level information was
gathered. At the completion of this base period, the LINC-8 delivered a series of 15 pure tone
stimuli with intertrial intervals (ITIs) semirandomly determined. The mean IT1 was 45 seconds
and varied from 30 to 60 seconds.
Data Reduction. Analog skin conductance data, stored on magnetic tape, were played into a
PDP-12 laboratory computer and digitized at the rate of 20 conversions per second. This
digitization resulted in 15 single trial response curves which served as input to a second program
which scored the amplitude of each skin conductance orienting response (SCOR). A SCOR was
defined as a change in skin conductance of at least 0.05 pmhos with an onset latency from 0.5 to
4.5 seconds following stimulus delivery.
The EKG, stored on FM tape, was converted into heart period using the LINC-8 computer to
detect the occurrence of each R wave and measure the R-R intervals in msec. Subsequently,
350
these interval data were converted into heart rate by computer and expressed in beats per minute
(BPM) for each half-second interval following stimulus onset. Each beat was weighted accord-
ing to the proportion of the half-second interval it occupied (Graham, 1980). These data were
reduced further by averaging every three successive trials into a total of five trial blocks to assess
changes in the heart rate response with repeated stimulus presentations. Components of these
averaged evoked heart rate responses were identified and scored according to the criteria
described by Gatchel and Lang (1973). Statistical analyses on all measures were performed on a
UNIVAC 1110 computer using an unweighted means solution for an unequal n mixed design
analysis of variance. Hypotheses regarding the differences among the three groups were tested
by constructing two orthogonal planned comparisons. These a priori comparisons were used
consistently to test group differences on both electrodermal and heart rate measurements. Other
analyses will be reported only when specifically relevant. The two orthogonal comparisons took
the following form:
Comparison 1 HO:
Perceptual Aberration = Controls
Comparison 2 HO:
Anhedonic = Perceptual Aberration and Controls.
Results
Skin conductance. The results of the Group X Sex X Trial analysis of variance on
SCOR magnitudes yielded a highly significant TRIAL effect (F= 26.20, df = 14,840,~
< 0.001). As Fig. 1 indicates, the significant TRIAL effect reflects the customary large
magnitude response to the first presentation of the stimulus and the rapid diminution
of responding with subsequent exposures. Since the SCOR is normally a rapidly
habituating response, early trials are most likely to reflect between-group differences
in the orienting response. The two orthogonal comparisons were conducted to test the
important variable of group responsivity to the first presentation of the orienting
stimulus. A significant Comparison 2 confirmed the impression from Fig. 1 that
anhedonic subjects were significantly less responsive to the initial stimulus than their
nonanhedonic counterparts (F= 4.62, df = 1,59, p < 0.05). Perceptual aberration and
control subjects did not differ in response to the initial or any subsequent stimulus
presentation (Comparison 1, F < 1). By trial 2, differences between groups no longer
reached statistical significance, although anhedonic subjects continued to remain the
least responsive.
The nature of the difference between anhedonic, control, and perceptual aberration
subjects is clarified further by inspection of Table 1, which presents the relative
frequency of normal and hyporesponsive orienting patterns which occurred in these
groups. Subjects assigned to the hyporesponsive category were either nonresponders
or fast habituators. Fast habituation was defined as a response to the first stimulus
presentation with no response observed on subsequent trials.1 A chi-square analysis
conducted on these data revealed that much of the response magnitude difference
I. The inclusion of a fast habituation category was suggested by the report of Patterson and Venables (1978).
The definition of fast habituation used here, however, does not correspond precisely to that offered by
Patterson and Venables whose criteria contained parameters of the skin conductance response not mea-
sured in the present study.
351
l.OO- It!.I
;,I
fl - ANHEDONIC
f\
.80- ;\ a.. .__ .p PERCEPTUAL
\\ ABERRATION
;,1
:\ o----o CONTROLS
;\
:I
.60-
1:: ~._~~~
I 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 IO II I2 I;
TRIAL
Control 19 3
Perceptual aberration 20 6
Analysis of the electrodermal data collected during the initial base period again
suggests a general hypoarousal among anhedonic subjects. Although the finding was
not statistically significant, anhedonics showed the lowest skin conductance level (7.48
pmho/cmZ vs. 11.38 and 9.84 for groups B and C, respectively) and the fewest number
of spontaneous fluctuations exceeding criterion (2.9 vs. 4.9 and 3.2 for groups B and C,
respectively).
352
Heart Rate.2 Fig. 2 depicts the change in heart rate which followed the tone
presentation averaged across all groups and trial blocks.3 The basic morphology of
this response was similar for each group and did not show evidence of significant
change over trial blocks. Such triphasic responses have been shown to be composites
of a number of separable and independent components (Headrick and Graham, 1969).
Those components reflecting cardiac deceleration are particularly relevant in the
present context since Graham and Clifton (1966) have convincingly argued that heart
rate slowing is the cardiac reflection of orienting behavior. Gatchel and Lang (1973)
have shown that a measure of total deceleration (analogous to the shaded area in Fig.
2) may best index a subjects orienting or attention toward an external stimulus, and
this composite measure was chosen as the primary dependent heart rate variable in the
present study. Statistical analysis was conducted to parallel that performed on the
electrodermal data and revealed very similar results. While no differences were
apparent between perceptual aberration and normal control subjects (Comparison I),
Comparison 2 showed once again that anhedonic subjects do demonstrate the hypo-
thesized deficiency in orienting (F= 5.04, df = 1,59, p < 0.05).This pattern was similar
in each of the two individual measures of deceleration which comprised the composite
dependent variable (Table 2). While sex of subject was not a significant factor in the
statistical analysis, the effect of group membership on both the heart rate and skin
conductance measures was most clearly displayed by anhedonic females.
Fig. 2. Average heart rate response of all subjects to the 15 pure tone stimuli
1234567
Seconds
Heart rate change (in beats per minute! was measured from the half-second prestimulus. Shaded areas were
summed to index cardiac orienting.
2. Resting heart rates were virtually identical among the three groups, varying from 65.4 to 67.6 beats per
minute.
3. Respiration was not recorded during the present experiment. However, the basic heart rate response to
simple stimuli of the type reported here is quite reliable across laboratories and is unlikely to be due to
stimulus elicited respiratory changes (see Hart, 1975).
353
Discussion
References
Anthony, E.J. A clinical and experimental study of high-risk children and their schizophrenic
parents. In: Kaplan, A.R., ed. Genetic Factors in Schizophrenia. Charles CThomas, Spring-
field, IL (1972).
Bernstein, A.S. Phasic electrodermal orienting response in chronic schizophrenics: II. Response
to auditory signals of varying intensity. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 75, 146 (1970).
Bernstein, A.S., Schneider, S.J., Juni, S., Pope, A.T., and Starkey, P.W. The effect of stimulus
significance on the electrodermal response in chronic schizophrenia. Journal of Abnormal
Psychology, 89,93 (1980).
Buchsbaum, M.S., Coursey, R.D., and Murphy, D.L. The biochemical high-risk paradigm:
Behavioral and familial correlates of low platelet monoamine oxidase activity. Science, 194,
339 (1976).
Buchsbaum, M.S., and Haier, R.J. Biological homogeneity, symptom heterogeneity, and
the diagnosis of schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 4, 473 (1978).
Chapman, L.J., Chapman, J.P., and Raulin, M.L. Scales for physical and social anhedonia.
Journal of Abnormal Psvcholog_v, 85, 374 (1976).
355
Chapman, L.J., Chapman, J.P., and Raulin, M.L. Body-image aberration in schizophrenia.
Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 87, 399 (1978).
Edell, W.S., and Chapman, L.J. Anhedonia, perceptual aberration, and the Rorschach.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 47, 377 (1979).
Erlenmeyer-Kimling, L. A prospective study of children at risk for schizophrenia. In: Wirt,
D., Winokur, G., and Roff, M., eds. Life History Research in Psychopathology. Vol. 4.
University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis (1975).
Garmezy, N. Children at risk: The search for antecedents of schizophrenia: Part II. Ongoing
research programs, issues, and intervention. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 1 (9) 55 (1974).
Garmezy, N., and Streitman, S. Children at risk: The search for the antecedents of schizo-
phrenia: Part 1. Conceptual models and research methods. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 1,
(8) 14 (1974).
Gatchel, R.J., and Lang, P.J. Accuracy of psychophysical judgments and physiological
response amplitude. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 98, 175 (1973).
Gottesman, I.I., and Shields, J. Schizophrenia and Genetics: A Twin Study Vantage Point.
Academic Press, New York (1972).
Graham, F.K. Representing cardiac activity in relation to time. In: Martin, I., and Venables,
P.H., eds. Techniques in Psychophysiology. John Wiley & Sons, New York (1980).
Graham, F.K., and Clifton, R.K. Heart rate change as a component of the orienting response.
Psychological Bulletin, 65, 305 (1966).
Grinker, R.R., Sr., and Holzman, P.S. Schizophrenic pathology in young adults. Archives
of General Psychiatry, 28, 168 (1973).
Gruzelier, J.H., and Venables, P.H. Skin conductance orienting activity in a heterogeneous
sample of schizophrenics. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 155,277 (1972).
Hart, J.D. Cardiac response to simple stimuli as a function of phase of the respiratory cycle.
Psychophysiology, 12, 634 (1975).
Headrick, M.W., and Graham, F.K. Multiple component heart rate responses conditioned
under paced respiration. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 79, 486 (1969).
Heston, L.L. Psychiatric disorders in foster home reared children of schizophrenic mothers.
British Journal of Psychiatry, 112, 8 19 (1966).
Kety, S.S., Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H., Schulsinger, F., and Jacobsen, B. The biologic
and adoptive families of adopted individuals who became schizophrenic: Prevalence of
mental illness and other characteristics. In: Wynne, L.C., Cromwell, R.L., and Matthysse,
S., eds. The Nature of Schizophrenia: New Approaches to Research and Treatment. John
Wiley & Sons, New York (1978).
Koh, S.D., and Peterson, R.A. Perceptual memory for numerousness in nonpsychotic schizo-
phrenics. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 83, 215 (1974).
Mednick, S.A., and McNeil, T.F. Current methodology in research on the etiology of schizo-
phrenia: Serious difficulties which suggest the use of the high-risk-group method. Psycholo-
gical Bulletin, 70, 681 (1968).
Mednick, S.A., and Schulsinger, F. Some premorbid characteristics related to breakdown in
children with schizophrenic mothers. In: Rosenthal, D., and Kety, S.S., eds. The Transmis-
sion of Schizophrenia. Pergamon Press Ltd., Oxford (1968).
Meehl, P.E. Schizotaxia, schizotypy, and schizophrenia. American Ps.vchologist, 17, 827
(1962).
Meehl, P.E. Manual for use with checklist of schizotypic signs. Unpublished manuscript,
University of Minnesota (1964).
Patterson, T., and Venables, P.H. Bilateral skin conductance and skin potential in schizo-
phrenic and normal subjects: The identification of the fast habituator group of schizo-
phrenics. Psychophvsiology. 15, 556 (1978).
Rosenthal, D. Genetic Theory and Abnormal Behavior. McGraw-Hill, New York (1970).
Rubens, R.L., and Lapidus, L.B. Schizophrenic patterns of arousal and stimulus barrier
functioning. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 87, 199 (1978).
Salzman, L., and Klein, R.H. Habituation and conditioning of electrodermal responses in
high-risk children. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 4, 210 (1978).
356
Steronko, R.J., and Woods, D.J. Impairment in early stages of visual information processing
in nonpsychotic schizotypic individuals. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 87,48 1 (1978).
Venables, P.H. The electrodermal psychophysiology of schizophrenics and children at risk
for schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 3, 28 (1977).
Venables, P.H., Mednick, S.A., Schulsinger, F., Raman, A.C., Bell, B., Dalais, J.C., and
Fletcher, R.P. Screening for risk of mental illness. In: Serban, C., ed. Cognitive Defects
in the Development of Mental Illness. Brunner-Mazel, New York (1978).
Zahn, T.P., Rosenthal, D., and Lawlor, W.G. Electrodermal and heart rate orienting reactions
in chronic schizophrenia. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 6, 117 (1967).