You are on page 1of 45

Effluent Analyzer (Comparison

)

Anodyne Real
Anodyne Real Tech Real
Anodyne Trios Anodyne Tethys Anodyne Tethys Tech Real Spectrum
Description Opus UV300 UV500 Spectrum PL2020 GL2020

Attenuation,
Spectral
Analysis(UV-Vis UV-Vis Dual UV-Vis Dual UV-Vis Dual Beam
MEASURING Double Beam Beam Beam Spectroscopy(Sens UV/Vis Spectral
PRINCIPLE Spectroscopy) Spectroscopy Spectroscopy e Pro Technology) Measurement

200-380 nm (200
-750 nm with
Platinum Visible
WAVELENGTH 190-720 nm 180-800 nm 180-800 nm Plus option) 200-750 nm
Deuterium Lamp
(Deuterium
+Tungsten with
Xenon Flash Platinum Visible Xenon Flash
LIGHT SOURCE Xenon Flash Lamp Xenon Flash Lamp Lamp Plus option) Lamp

5 sec (except PO4, 5 sec (except
NO2, Fe, Cr(VI) : PO4, NO2, Fe,
3min; Cl2, Al : Cr(VI) : 3min;
SAMPLING 2min; SiO2 : 6 Cl2, Al : 2min;
TIME 1 Minute min) SiO2 : 6 min) 1 minute 1 minute

300 - 800 mL /
FLOW RATE 0.1-10 m/s 0-5 L/Min 0-5 L/Min 300 - 800 mL / min min
Measuring
Wavelengths(Cha Single/Double/Mul 550 up to 40
nnels) 256 Channels ti Wavelength Wavelengths 512 wavelengths Wavelengths

5000 Lines of
measurements
5000 Lines of for each
measurements for parameter (upto
each parameter 16 Parameters) Can store Data
(upto 16 Channels) with date and Can store Data for for more than 1
Memory 2 GB with date and time time more than 1 year year

Page 1

Effluent Analyzer (Comparison)

Zero
Calibration : An
auto zero is
performed at
Zero Calibration : every cleaning
An auto zero is cycle. Span:
performed at every Factory Global
cleaning cycle. calibrated. It is calibration and
Span: Factory capable of custom
calibrated. It is weekly Global calibration calibration
capable of weekly calibration for and custom options.
calibration for COD, BOD and calibration Exclusive
COD, BOD and TSS parameters options. Exclusive technologies(Spl
TSS parameters with keeping all technologies(Split it Sense pro
with keeping all calibration data Sense pro technology)
calibration data points in technology) allow allow
points in memory memory for continuous continuous
for matrix change matrix change automatic automatic
Auto/Manual adaption adaption calibration during calibration
CALIBRATION Calibration interpretation. interpretation. operation during operation

Automatic, Automatic,
Automatic, Chemical Chemical
Chemical Cleaning Cleaning ; Cleaning;
; Chemical Chemical Chemical
compressed air Consumption: 220 Consumption: Consumption:200 Automatic,
cleaning; Auto Air ml Sulfuric Acid 220 ml Sulfuric ml Lactic Acid per Chemical
CLEANING Blast Cleaning Per Day Acid Per Day day Cleaning

Continuous Continuous
detection of leaks, detection of
lamp leaks, lamp
output,humidity, output,humidity,
SELF temperature and temperature and
DIAGNOSTICS Available Available Available electrical fault electrical fault

Page 2

Effluent Analyzer (Comparison)

Colour TFT
LCD, Size :
10.4”, Backlit LCD
Colour TFT LCD, Resolution: 640 Backlit LCD with with LED alarm
Size : 5.7”, x 480 pixels LED alarm indicator
7 inch capacitive Resolution: 320 x LED backlight indicator (optional (optional 10"
touch screen (800 x 240 pixels LED with screen 10" colour LCD colour LCD
480 pixels); 5 x backlight Resistive saver Resistive 800x600 with 800x600 with
DISPLAY status LED touch screen touch screen Touch Panel) Touch Panel)

Windows7, Windows7,
with Internet with Internet
Explorer version 9, Explorer
Nexus 7 tablet version 9, Nexus
under Android 7 tablet under
with Android with
Opera version Opera version
12.10, Apple I- 12.10, Apple I-
OPERATOR User Friendly with phone 4S with phone 4S with
INTERFACE Touch/ Push Button Safari Safari Windows 7 Windows 7
Onscreen
alarms and dry Onscreen alarms Onscreen alarms
contacts to and dry contacts and dry contacts
signal alarm to signal alarm to signal alarm
ALARMS Available Available condition condition condition
Humidity
sensor with
Humidity sensor large plug-in Humidity sensor Humidity sensor
with large plug-in regeneratable with large plug-in with large plug-
HUMIDITY regeneratable desiccant regeneratable in regeneratable
CONTROL Not Applicable desiccant system system desiccant system desiccant system

Page 3

Effluent Analyzer (Comparison)

RS 232 with
MODBUS Most common
RS 232 with protocol;HTTP/ communication
MODBUS Web interface, Most common protocols
protocol;HTTP/We RS 485 for communication available ie.
b interface, RS 485 external probes, protocols available MODBUS,
for external USB, WIFI, ie. MODBUS, Datalogging via
probes, USB, Ethernet;Comp Datalogging via RS232, RS485,
RS-232 or RS-485 WIFI, atible with RS232, RS485, 4- 4-20mA
(Modbus RTU, Ethernet;Compatib windows 7, 20mA (Ethernet (Ethernet and
ASCII, TriOS, le with windows 7, Nexus Tablet, and USB drive USB drive with
(SCPI));ethernet Nexus Tablet, Apple Iphone 4 with Touch Panel Touch Panel
OUTPUTS (TCP/IP) Apple Iphone 4 S S option) option)

470 mm x 48 mm
(with 10 mm path)
having Depth Range 525 x 345 x 260 16”h x 20”w x
DIMENSIONS 300 m 420 x 360 x 200 mm mm 16”h x 20”w x 8”d 8”d

Stainless Steel
with Epoxy
IP68, Stainless steel IP65/NEMA4X , Coating, IP65,
(1.4571/1.4404) or Steel with epoxy wall mounting IP66, NEMA 4, IP66, NEMA 4,
ENCLOSURE titanium (3.7035) coating Brackets wall mountable wall mountable

Double ring
Double ring fittings for semi-
fittings for semi- rigid plastic
rigid plastic tubing tubing :External
:External diameter diameter (OD)
(OD) 9.6 mm 9.6 mm
(3/8”);Internal (3/8”);Internal
FLUID diameter (ID) 6.4 diameter (ID) 1/4” tube push-in 1/4” tube push-
CONNECTIONS Not Applicable mm (1/4”) 6.4 mm (1/4”) fittings in/out in fittings in/out

Power
Consumption
(Analyzer +
Controller) 8 W + 30 W (Max) 40 W 80 W 120 W 120 W

90-264 VAC 24 VDC 120W 24 VDC 120W
50/60 Hz 40 VA- power adapter power adapter
12 V DC 3 A included (power included (power
12-24 VDC (± 10 90 - 264 VAC maxi; 90-264 adapter accepts adapter accepts
%), with power 50/60 Hz 40 VA – VAC 50/60 Hz 90-250 VAC 50/60 90-250 VAC
ELECTRICAL consumption ≤ 8 W 12 V DC 3A maxi 80 VA Hz) 50/60 Hz)

Page 4

-20 to 60°C (-4 to -20 to 60°C (-4 TEMP +80 °C to +80 °C 20 to +80 °C 140°F) to 140°F) 0-60 °C. 0-30 °C for 0 to 55°C (32 to 0 to 55°C (32 to TEMP 0 to 45 °C 0 °C to 80 °C H2S and NH4 113°F) 113°F) 2 Years Limited 3 year limited 3 year limited 2 year limited 3 year limited WARRANTY Warranty warranty warranty warranty warranty  Automatic  Automatic Zero Zero calibration calibration   Validation of Validation of the the analyser is analyser is possible  The possible due to patented flow Cabinet type cell allows very design  The high level of patented flow cell suspended solid allows very high without level of suspended clogging.  The solid without turbidity is clogging. 0-80 OPERATING °C. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) STORAGE Storage Temp:-20 to Storage Temp:-20 Storage Temp:.5 % FS ± 2 % FS 2 .  The automatically turbidity is compensated by automatically a dual compensated by a wavelength  • Dual Feed • dual wavelength Optional multi • Dual Feed • Real Real Clean  Optional multi streaming Clean System • System • Pump Extended Warranty streaming facility facility is Pump Systems • Systems • Touch Added Advantage Options is available available Touch Panel Panel ACCURACY ±2% ±2% ±2% ± 0.5 years 4000 hrs(6 (dependant on LAMP LIFE up to 10 Years up to 10 Years up to 10 Years months) application) Page 5 .

colour. HS. SAC. PARAMETERS TOC. COD. Conductivity. TSS. Hydrocarbons(PA Hydrocarbons(P Colour. DOC. BTX. pH. Temperature.NO2. ANALYSIS UV254. BOD. Cr. Cl2. TSS. Temperature. NO2. NO3. PARAMETER Colour & Grease Oil & Grease NO3 NO3 compensation for compensation for compensation compensation for compensation COMPENSATIO interferences and interferences and for interferences interferences and for interferences N turbidity turbidity and turbidity turbidity and turbidity PRESSURE RESISTANCE 30 Bar(Max) 10 Bar(Max) 10 Bar(Max) 10 Bar(Max) 10 Bar(Max) 4 bar (4000 hPa or 60 psi) without sampling pump or 1 bar (1000 hPa or Operating 15 psi) with the 0-80 PSI.NO2.5 0-80 PSI. DO. NO3. H2S. PO4. colour. Colour.5 Pressure 0-3 Bar sampling pump 0-4 Bar Bar(Max) Bar(Max) Supports Light Source Supports Only Supports Only Deuterim- Support Xenon Xenon Supports Xenon Tungstun Supports Xenon Reference KHP/formazane KHP/formazane KHP/formazane KHP/formazane Standard Distilled Water equivalent equivalent equivalent equivalent System Type Inline Online Online Online Online Probe Style Cabinet style for Cabinet style Cabinet style for Cabinet style for Optics Housing constrained optics larger optics for larger optics larger optics larger optics upto 40 wavelengths can Wavelength be configured in Resolution 2. Turbidity. BOD. BOD.NH2CL. NO2. COD.2 nm 254 nm 1nm 1nm entire spectrum Page 6 . DOC. TOC. NH4. TOC. TSS. NO2. ORP. DO. H). NO3.BTX. PO4. A. DOC. Aromatic Aromatic BOD. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) COD. pH. 5. Turbidity. Conductivity. /MULTI. ORP. Oil AH). Cr. Chlorophyll Chlorophyll A. NH4. H2S. COD. Cl2. BTX. 5. COD. BOD.

This modular in nature. Highly Secured . No Direct Entire Correlation. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) On site as the On site as the On site as the entire design is On site as the entire design is entire design is modular in entire design is modular in modular in nature. Highly Secured . Full upto 40 Correlation. Data secured over two secured over two secured over secured over two secured over two Software Security continents continents two continents continents continents SSL encryption SSL encryption SSL encryption SSL encryption SSL encryption from from equipment to from equipment from equipment to from equipment Data Storage equipment to server server to server server to server M2M (Machine to Machine) M2M (Machine to Communication M2M GPRS M2M GPRS GPRS Machine )GPRS M2M GPRS Software Class Enterprise Enterprise Enterprise Enterprise Enterprise Time Stamp Accuracy NTP NTP NTP NTP NTP Two way Communication Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Audit Logs Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Data Flagging Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Map Integration Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Change Request Management Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Direct Direct Measurement. Spectrum Spectrum wavelength Technology wavelengths Single Wavelength Scanning Scanning scanning Page 7 . nature. Measurement. nature. Highly Secured . Direct Measurement. Data Managed. factory. 256 Measurement. to factory. Measurement. Highly Secured . Data Managed. Professionally Professionally Professionally Professionally Professionally Managed. Direct No correlation. Data Managed. Software Cloud Cloud Cloud Cloud Cloud Logicladder/Glens/ Logicladder/Glens/ Logicladder/Gle Logicladder/Glens Logicladder/Gle Software Support Anodyne Anodyne ns/Anodyne /Anodyne ns/Anodyne Server Cloud Cloud Cloud Cloud Cloud Highly Secured . factory. Data Managed. No No Correlation. This This reduces reduces This reduces reduces downtime due to downtime due downtime due to downtime due to shipping back to to shipping back shipping back to shipping back to Repair Factory factory.

design.Carbovis(X Series( Real xis nano). with Robust design . and calibration. cleaning and cleaning and Chemical cleaning Auto cleaning Low maintenance. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Costly Competitively Competitively equipment with priced priced equipment Robust design. Spectro::Lyzer( Carbo::lyser(Aa Techno. Costly equipment equipment with with Robust Low with Robust Robust design. No and calibration. Auto maintenance. Spectro::lyzer(A comparison Nano) ylem) Tech) UV500(Tethys) axis Nano). Carbo::lyser(Aaxis Aaxis nano). Low maintenance. commercial Spectro::lyzer(Aaxis Nano). Auto Auto Chemical maintenance. PL Spectro::lyser( Aa xis Nano). No calibration. Instruments for Horiba. calibration.(OPSA 150) s(Xylem). Best Instrument Rating Based on comparison 4 8 1 2 7 Page 8 . design. No Human Human Human No Human No Human Intervention and Intervention and Intervention Intervention and Intervention and Cost long life long life and long life long life long life I::Scan(Aaxis Carbovis/Nicavi Equivalent Nano). Low Low Costly Equipement maintenance.

7 nm. UV 720 nm.optics. spectrometry 190 .200 nm .1 minute Provision must Provision must Can store data for for more than 1 intervals for 10 be there for 1 be there for 1 more than 1 year year with days data.390 nm two beam light path 2 UV/Vis based measurement.7 nm. < 3 m/s (~1 < 3 m/s (~1 Maximum 20 ft/s) ft/s) 3 m/s(Max) 3 m/s(Max) L/min 2 Wavelengths(U Single V: 253.720 nm) (200 .UV Compensated UV-VIS range UV-VIS range spectrometry 190 .Dual Beam 720 nm. Absorbance(2 Uv/Vis optical.1 nm) Provision must be there for 1 year data Can store data storage.UV: 253. wavelength cell Spectral spectrophotom complete length Measurement eter spectrum absorption modulation) Light Emitting Diode(LED) UV-Vis Technology . Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Xylem Xylem CarboVis® CarboVis® Aaxis nano Aaxis Nano Horiba OPSA 705 IQ 701 IQ Spectro::Lyser UV-Vis I::Scan 150 spectrometry 190 .UV Absorbance/Vis spectrometry 190 .1 nm Light source: Low pressure mercury lamp / Xenon Flash Xenon Flash Detector: Silicon Lamp Lamp xenon flash lamp LED photo cell T 90 within 1 minute (flow 1 Minute 1 Minute 1 Minute 1 Minute rate of 5 L/min) Minimum 2 L/min. 256 Channels 256 Channels 256 Channels Wavelength VIS: 546. (200 .720 nm) 390 nm 800 nm VIS: 546. 1 hour year data year data with Con::cube (4 Con::cube (4 intervals for 1 storage storage GB) GB) year s data Page 9 .

span solution Auto/Manual Auto/Manual Auto/Manual Auto/Manual (single touch Calibration Calibration Calibration Calibration calibration) ultrasonic ultrasonic cleaning.comp cleaning.compr ressed air essed air compressed air Automatic cleaning cleaning compressed air cleaning . Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Solution calibration (calibration solution inserted in ampule) via zero solution. Auto cleaning via available available cleaning brush wipers Available Available Available Available Available Page 10 .

49 x 3. display. (4. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) LCD display: 320 x 240 monochrome crystal display with backlight (touch panel type) Display details: UV absorbance. backlit in). be changed to resolution 320 resolution 320 absorption x 240 pixels. UV- VIS absorbance Graphic Graphic (Absorbance can display.39 (4. VIS absorbance. constant (SAC: visible area visible area m-1). x 240 pixels. 2x LED turbidity level User Friendly User Friendly User Friendly with User Friendly User Friendly with Touch/ with Touch/ Touch/ Push with Touch/ with Touch/ Push Button Push Button Button Push Button Push Button Available Available Available Available Available Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Page 11 . Converted 114 x 86 mm 114 x 86 mm COD level.49 x 3.39 Converted in). backlit Graphic Display LCD.

Window: .5 Titanium Titanium mm:sapphire 3.35 in) mm (2.. with 10 -18 VDC. 5 mm: fused IP 68. (D) x 404 (H) Sapphire glass Sapphire glass silica (UV-grade) POM-C (units: mm) Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Not Applicable Rc-1/2 socket 20 W + 60 W 8 W + 30 W 8 W + 30 W (Max) 1 W + 30 W 60 W + 20 W Power Consumption: Power 8 W.. Interface to S::Can S::Can RS-232. 0.optical path . Bluetooth. Bluetooth. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Communicatio Communicatio ns via modem.7035. PEEK PEEK optical path length 200 (W) x 180 . MODBUS.Housing: IP68 . PEEK.35 in) 547 mm / 591 mm 38. terminals: RS MODBUS. ns via modem.. 0. Two wire Consumption: AC 100 V to AC shielded IQ 8 W.5 x 295 mm bps IP68 connected: IP 68. radio radio transmission. optional...9 35 .9 Sensor with diameter 59. optical path length Communication SACIQ diametercable 59. MODBUS net.5 mm:44 x speed: 19200 connected: SACIQ cable mm (2. Two wire 120 V: 45 VA cable provides shielded IQ 11-15 VDC. USB optical path length 100 mm:44 x 612 RS-232C Length 802 Length 802 mm / 656 mm Compatible Sensor with mm (31. maximum AC power and cable provides power with power 200 V to AC 230 communicatio power and consumption 20 consumption V: 60 VA n communication W(max) 200 mA @ 12V maximum Page 12 . MODBUS. transmission. 3. Interface to PROFIBUS. mm (31.5 in). terminals: RS 485 ..Window: 100 . PROFIBUS.5 in).Ether RS-232 RS-232 MODBUS 485 .7035.Housing: length 15 .

. Options . - ±2% ±2% ±2% ±2% ±2% up to 10 Years up to 10 Years up to 10 Years up to 10 Years 2-5 years Page 13 . Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) 32 to 113ºF (0 to 45ºC) for 32 to 113ºF (0 sensor and°C-4 -10 to 50 to -1045ºC) to 50for °C Storage temp:-10 Storage temp:- to 131º F (-20 (14 to 122 °F) sensor and °F) (14 to 122 -4 to 50 °C 10 to 50 °C 0 to 50°C to 55ºC) for to 131º F (-20 controller / to 55ºC) for display controller / module display module 0 to 45 °C 0 to 45 °C 2 to 40°C 2 Years 2 Years Limited Limited 3 Years Limited 3 Years Limited 1 Years Limited Warranty Warranty Warranty Warranty Warranty Extended Warranty .

UV254 AOC.7 nm. SAC. DOC.UV254 .1 nm Page 14 .2 nm 2. . SAC DOC.5 maximum psi). TSS. SAC. DOC. TOC.Colour. BOD. TSS. NO2. 1 bar (14. TSS. NO2. UV254. SAC NO3.5 and turbidity turbidity and turbidity and turbidity psi). DOC. UV254.2 nm 254 nm VIS: 546.2 nm 2. BOD. UV254. TOC. COD. TSS. TSS.O3 Colour NO3 compensation compensation for for compensation for compensation compensation interferences interferences interferences and for interferences for interferences 1and barturbidity (14. TOC. maximum immersion immersion depth = 10 depth = 10 meters meters 10 bar(Max) 10 bar(Max) 10 bar(Max) 1 Bar 1 Bar 0-3 Bar 0-6 Bar 0-3 Bar Supports Only Supports Only Supports Only Supports Xenon Xenon Xenon Supports LED Mercury Distilled Water Distilled Water Distilled Water Distilled Water Distilled Water Inline Inline Inline Inline Inline Probe Style Probe Style Probe Style Probe Style constrained constrained Probe Style constrained constrained optics optics constrained optics optics optics UV: 253. 2.BTX. BOD. HS. COD. COD. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) COD. SAC. BOD. COD. TOC.

than cloud. than cloud. 256 BOD. than cloud. Wavelengths Wavelengths wavelengths Wavelength Two Wavelength Page 15 . Measurement. Not Known Not Known Not Known Not Known Not Known GPRS GPRS GPRS GPRS GPRS SCADA SCADA SCADA SCADA SCADA Not Known Not Known Not Known Not Known Not Known Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Direct Measurement. Direct Measurement for Direct 256 256 Measurement. Direct Direct Correlated Measurement. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Factory Factory Factory Factory Factory Physical Physical Physical Physical Physical HydroQ HydroQ Physical Server Physical Server Physical Server Physical Server Physical Server Less secured Less secured Less secured than Less secured Less secured than cloud. cloud. Single Measurement.

OPSA Carbo::lyser(A 150(Horiba). GL Series(Real Series(Real UV300(Tethys). No No Human No Human No Human Human Human Intervention Intervention Intervention and Intervention and Intervention and and long life and long life long life long life long life OPSA 150(Horiba). e). Trios Carbovis(Xylem Trios(Anodyn Trios(Anodyne Opus(Anodyne). Low design . Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Competitively Competitively Competitively priced priced Very Low priced priced Equipement Equipement Equipement with Equipement with with Robust with Robust Costly Equipement Robust design . Robust design . Tech). design . No maintenance. 150( Horiba) xis Nano) 5 6 3 10 9 Page 16 . maintenance. Carbo::lyser(A GL axis Nano). axis Nano). Tech). Low maintenance. Low with Robust design Low Low maintenance. OPSA Carbo::lyzer(Aa hys) s) UV500( Tethys). maintenance.UV300(Tethy Series(Real Tech). ). .UV300(Tet ).PL UV300(Tethys).

Industry is free to choose the instrument but in case of variation in data and incorrect measurement. Mercury. UV-Vis light Source is Xenon.COD and TSS. CPCB guideline states that Instrument must have inbuilt feature of water matrix adaption change with UV Vis Dual beam multi wavelength entire spectrum scanning. CPCB Asked for entire spectrum Full wavelength. library of matrices as Factory Calibration with onboard finger-print spectra and addition of unlimited multi-calibration local water matrix points without any deletion of previous matrix calibration. In case of failure. Sampling time must be within 1 minute for in situ (inline) probe system instrument. Xenon has very good lamp life.200 nm = 550 wavelengths/Spectra/Fingerprints/Photodiodes). Dueterium-Tungesten. Industry will have to calibrate the instrument and have to pass the performance audit test. etc. CPCB requires data submission at every 15 minutes interval. Industry will have to discard the installed instrument and re-install relevant instruments with UV-Vis Dual Beam Entire Spectrum Scanning to serve the desired purpose(COD. it is the responsibility of industry to submit correct data without delay. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) CPCB Guideleines Both Online as well as Inline UV-Vis Dual Beam Entire Spectrum Scanning with Full Wavelength recommended for measuring BOD. Probe Style is limited to 256 photodiodes. CPCB required local data storage on the equipment for a period of minimum one year. BOD & TSS measurement with single instrument without correlation). Page 17 .Industry must go for full wavelength( 750 nm.

8 hrs. BOD and TSS parameters with keeping all calibration data points in memory for matrix change adaption interpretation. CPCB requires complete diagnostic of instruments.(CPCB Guideline see page no. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Instrument must be capable of weekly calibration for COD. previous matrices are kept in library to achieve better &precise results. During new point addition. 12 hrs…) reduces headache of periodic cleaning. 17. Chemical cleaning system automatically cleans itself at a specified frequency (4 hrs. Page 18 . Fouling can rapidly increase error in reading or can cause equipment to not function.1 Quantification) Most common challenge that most UV Vis spectrometry equipment is fouling of Optics. point # 4. Mostly air and ultrasound cleaning is the only option for probes while chemical cleaning system can be used in case of bypass analyzers. Air and ultrasound cleaning will still require manual cleaning every month. Chemical cleaning is the best system and gives the best cleaning.

It is a feature of software. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) CPCB requires alarms generations and sms alert to be sent for corrective actions. Page 19 .

Page 20 . So industry must choose best with available options. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Communication interface should be up to date with latest available configuration. Industry can choose any instrument but ultimately the responsibility for data transmission and submission lies with industry.

Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Page 21 .

example in case of probes.11. Instruement should be well capable of system validation with known buffers and traceable standards LIKE APHA and such as KHP for COD & TOC and formazan equivalent standard for TSS with pH buffers for pH parameter. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Required parameters could be configured in to the system based on selected system measuring range/parameters. 14. So the safest bet is to use an analyzers that provides high resolution. Page 22 . more difficult it is to get more accurate values. CPCB Recommends both Online and Inline Instruments.(see page no. Absence of TSS and Color change gives erratic analysis of COD & BOD parameters. Which are good for freshwater or trending purpose but will not meet your requirement when you need to meet compliance.Petroleum and other Industries without any addition of hardware with only software/Configuration updation. point # 3. suitability of technologies for different matrices point # 4) Light source also affects the analyzer accuracy. Xenon is good for most applications where accuracy is not a big concern or the effluent matrix is mostly stable. Most UV vis equipment manufacturer’s will only provide a resolution of 5-10 nm in the spectrum band of 200-750 nm. More constrained the optics are . Only Few Analyzers like Tethys allow analysis of Oil & Grease which is also required by Dairy. For most ETP the effluent is complex as compared to STP’s. Specially designed Single Wavelength system also has limitations. table 2. But this depends more on the chemical composition that make us the effluent. Instrument must provides compensation to Color and TSS with compensated spectra in visible region during UV-Vis scanning.

Required by CPCB. Required by CPCB CPCB guideline for technology selection Clearly states that for direct measurement UV-Vis Dual Beam Entire Spectrum Scanning( 550 Wavelengths) instrument is ideal for measuring BOD. Where multiple entities have to consume data (SPCB. Data points which are send after delay should be flagged by server. Required by CPCB to trace calibration changes. Data coming from many analyzers would require a storage system that can scale. Page 23 . Audit logs to trace calibration changes. CPCB requires 5 years data to be retained at the servers. Change request and workflow management. M2M GPRS provides more reliable and secure communication than the normal GPRS connectivity. CBCB and Industry) you require an enterprise sytem. Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Probe styles are not modular in design so cannot be repaired at site. COD and TSS in wastewater with varying water matrix.

Effluent Analyzer (Comparison) Page 24 .

CO. UV Fluorescence(SO2).Nox. SOx. along with sample cooler Chemiluminescence (Nox). UV Fluorescence(SOx). NOx.CO) No. GFR(CO2). Technologies for CO. etc.CO) . Technologies CO. different Gases O3 etc. O2. CO).Electrochemical(SOx.).) NDIR(SO2. NDIR(Multi Parameters like SO2. Chemiluminescence (NOx). Aaxis Nano ABB EL 3000 Specifications Anodyne Uniphos Analyzer Series Type Of Instrument Extractive Extractive Single Pass (Single Instrument) as well as Multi-Pass(Separate Instrument for Single Pass(Single instrument Analyzer separate gases) for Multi gases) NDIR(NOx. etc. Electrochemical(SOx. NOx. NDIR(CO). NOx.of Instruments Comes in rack with complete set Single Heated Not required if patented Peltier Probe Required Heated Sampling line Sampling Line system will be used. NOx. NDIR(CO).) NDIR(SOx.

(vii) Communication Port: RS-485 / RS- 232 & USB (viii) Data Logging: Supports internal data logging. (iii) Display: Large OLED display. SO2: Supports internal data logging. NOx: Not Available (i) Measurement Method: Fluorescence (ii) Measuring Range: 0-2000 ppm (iii) Display: Large OLED display (iv) Resolution: 1 ppm (v) Auto / Remote calibration with calibration gas cylinder. (vi) Inbuilt zero air generator for instrument zeroing. 1. (ii) Measuring Range: 0- 2000 ppm. 3. CO: Available . Not Available (i) Measurement Method: NDIR technique. (iv) Resolution: 1 ppm (v) Auto / Remote calibration with calibration gas cylinder. (vii) Comes with moisture and hydrocarbon removal system (viii)Communication Port: RS-485 / RS- 232 & USB (ix) Data Logging: 2. (x) Communication Port: RS-485 / RS-232 & USB (xi) Data Logging: Supports internal data logging. (i) Measurement Method: Chemiluminescence (ii) Measuring Range: 0-2000 ppm (iii) Display: Large OLED display (iv) Resolution: 1 ppm (v) Auto / Remote calibration with calibration gas cylinder (vi) Internal ozone generation.

Moderate Cost(Multi-pass Cost of NDIR). Robust. Available Cleaning System Compressed Air Compressed Air Air Pressure Required: up to 4 kg/cm2 up to 4 kg/cm2 Auto. Patented Design. Made-in India Certified. (x) Probe Length: 4. TUV/USEPA sampling Line. (ix) Gas velocity: Minimum 4 m/s. please refer USEPA/Mcert Maintenance Low Maintenance evaluation certificate) Rugged. TUV/USEPA Technology Certified.3 μm or larger. Robust. SPM: As required. Low maintenance. No Heated Rugged. manual and Remote calibration with zero and span Calibration calibration Auto and manual calibration Remote Available (Can be Calibration In-built Remote calibration. (vii) Relay Alarm Setting: Automatic. configured) Warranty 1 year 1 Year High Maintenance( maintenance interval recommended 4 weeks. (v) Relay delay time: 0-180 second (vi) Particle Size: 0.1 mg per m3. (i) Measuring Objects: Solid particles in gas flow. (iv) Signal dumping time(mA): 0-300 second. with lowest operational cost per annum. (viii) Offset Trim: Automatic Drift Compensation. UV Fluroscence). Low Cost( Single Pass Multi Gas Low Cost( Single Pass Multi Instrument NDIR) Low Cost(Electrochemical) Gas NDIR) . High-End Technology. (ii) Measurement Principle: Inductive Electrification. Imported High Cost(Chemiluminescence. (iii) Measuring Range: From 0. High sampling line required with petlier Maintenance with Heated system.

CO. CO) . O3 NDIR(SO2.) NDIR(SO2. FTIR Single Single Single Required Heated Sampling Required Heated Sampling No Heated Sampling line along with sample line along with sample Required because it is cooler cooler mounted on stack NDIR(SOx.NOx. CO) NDIR NDIR. NOx. NOx. CO) etc. Forbes Marshall Codel Xylem Emission Analyzer Horiba Stack Gas Analyzer GCEM4000 Extractive Extractive In-Situ Single Pass(Single Single Pass(Single Single Pass(Single instrument for various instrument for various gases) instrument for various gases) gases) NDIR(SOX. NOx.

Available for ambient Air Not Available Monitroing Not Available Available for ambient Air Not Available Monitroing Not Available Available Available Available .

Imported Low Cost( Single Pass Multi High Cost( Single Pass Multi High Cost (Single Pass Gas NDIR) Gas NDIR) Multi-gas Analyzer) . TUV/USEPA Certified. Robust. TUV/USEPA sampling Line. High insitu intrument which Maintenance with Heated Maintenance with Heated directly mounted on sampling Line.Available Available Available Compressed Air Compressed Air Compressed Air up to 4 kg/cm2 up to 4 kg/cm2 up to 4 kg/cm2 Auto and manual Auto and manual Auto and manual calibration calibration calibration Available (Can be Available (Can be Available (Can be configured) configured) configured) 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year High maintenance High Maintenance High maintenance Rugged. High cost. Imported Certified. Robust. Imported Certified. High Maintenance Rugged. TUV/USEPA stack. Robust. High Rugged.

Single Pass Instrument has meaurement limitations and possibilities of interference and cross sensititivity. CPCB follows USEPA norms for umblical gas meaurement for preventing condensation of gases for that heated sample line is required with sample gas cooler before analyzer. Maintenance is very difficult in In-Situ system and it requires plant shut down. Where as only few supplier in the world has patented technologies for preventing such heated sample line which follows the USEPA guidelines. GFR(CO2). Individual Gas Analyzer has advantage that if one analyzer went under maintenance rest parameters will be submitted simultaneously on real time basis. . CPCB has also recommended technologies for CEMS in their Draft Guidelines: Chemiluminscence for NOx. Fluroscence for SO2. NDIR for CO.FTIR etc. One of Such instrument is Uniphos Peltier Drier & Cooling system which drastically reduces the operational cost and also saves the natural resources in generating that electricity.CPCB Guidelines Extractive system has advantage over In-situ system.

Highly Recommended by CPCB for NOx measurement Highly Recommended by CPCB for SO2 measurement Highly Recommended by CPCB for CO measurement .

Triboelectric has advantage over opacity Analyzer. CPCB requires Remote calibration as a mandatory feature for CEMS. Auto Probe Cleaning is required for efficient functioning of instrument. .CPCB recommends Triboelectric/Opacity.

8 10 438 (Note: Compressed Air Required for cleaning of SPM & Gas Analyzer Probes/ If industry Provide required compressed air upto 4 Bar) it is not required) 4. Emission : (i) SPM (Triboelectric S303) 50 W 1.88 10 7708.8 (B) Cloud Server Data Transmission & Submission annual Cost: 60000 .12 43.92 (ii) pH Electrode (+GF+) (iii) Ultrasonic Flow Meter (+GF+/Siemens) 8W 0.) Units/Annum Electricity Units/Day (Considering Total consumption/ (Considering 24 365 Days in a Unit Cost/Annum( (A) Electricity Consumption: Hour Hrs in a day) year) Price(Rs.96 4204.) Rs.8 2.2 (ii) Peltier Probe System (Uniphos) 80 W 1. Pvt. Effluent : (i) UV-Vis Analyzer with HMI Controller (Tethys UV500) 80 W 1. Air Compressor Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.92 (iii) Chemiluminscence NOx Analyzer (Uniphos) 250 W 6 (iv) UV fluroscence SO2 Analyzer (Uniphos) 60 W 1.8 10 438 (Note: Data Logger required for Data Transmission over cloud without any intermediate PC) Total cost of Electricity consumed: 50632. Co. Operational Cost of Complete High-End System (Anodyne Water Engg.) 1.44 (v) Non Dispersive Infra Red CO Analyzer (Uniphos) 40 W 0.192 770.12 43.Ltd. Data Logger (EnvirologiciQ/Glens/Anodyne data): Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.8 10 42048 (Note: No Heated Sample Line required Due to Patented Peltier system) 3.

35/Ltr 2810. 30000/Annum for Each: Emission & Effluent) (C) Cleaning Chemical Consumption: Annual Cost of Sulfuric Acid Consumption 220 ml/Day x 365 Days = 80.3 Ltrs/Annum @ Rs.5 Total Cost: 113443.3 (In Words: One Lac Thirteen Thousand Four Hundred Forty Three Rupees Only) .(Approx Rs.

Effluent : (i) UV-Vis Analyzer with HMI Controller (Tethys UV500) 80 W 1.6 2452.8 10 438 (Note: Compressed Air Required for cleaning of SPM & Gas Analyzer Probes/ If industry Provide required compressed air upto 4 Bar) it is not required) 4.) Units/Day Units/Annum Electricity (Considering (Considering (A) Electricity consumption/ 24 Hrs in a 365 Days in a Unit Total Consumption: Hour day) year) Price(Rs.12 43.12 43.8 2.Ltd. Air Compressor Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.8 .92 (iii)NDIR Multi-Gas Analyzer for SOx.8 10 438 (Note: Data Logger required for Data Transmission over cloud without any intermediate PC) Total cost of Electricity consumed: 33112.192 770.8 10 24528 (Note: No Heated Sample Line required Due to Patented Peltier system) 3.92 (ii) pH Electrode (+GF+) (iii) Ultrasonic Flow Meter (+GF+/Siemens) 8W 0. Data Logger (EnvirologiciQ/Glens/Anodyne data): Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0. and CO(Uniphos) 150 W 3.) Cost/Annum(Rs.2 (ii) Peltier Probe System (Uniphos) 80 W 1. Operational Cost of Complete Cost Effective High-End System (Anodyne Water Engg. Pvt. NOx.) 1.88 10 7708. Co. Emission : (i) SPM (Triboelectric/Opacity) 50 W 1.

35/Ltr 2810.5 95923. 30000/Annum for Each: Emission & Effluent) (C) Cleaning Chemical Consumption: Annual Cost of Sulfuric Acid Consumption 220 ml/Day x 365 Days = 80.3 Ltrs/Annum @ Rs.3 (In Words: Ninety Five Thousand Nine Hundred and Twenty Three Rupees Only) .(B) Cloud Server Data Transmission & Submission annual Cost: 60000 (Approx Rs.

192 (iv) HMI Controller (IQ Sensor 2020) 30 W 0. Operational Cost of Complete System (Xylem) Units/Day Units/Annum Electricity (Considering (Considering Total (A) Electricity consumption/ 24 Hrs in a 365 Days in a Unit Cost/Annum Consumption: Hour day) year) Price(Rs.6 . Air Compressor Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.12 43.2 (ii) NDIR Multi-Gas Analyzer for SOx.72 402. Effluent : (i) UV-Vis Analyzer (Carbovis) 8W 0.6 2.) (Rs.2 10 2299062 (Note: Heated Sample Line consumes typically 100 VA per meter) 3.12 43.) 1. - (iii) Ultrasonic Flow Meter (ABB/Siemens) 8W 0.96 10 4029.44 229906.192 (ii) pH Electrode .8 10 438 (Note: Data Logger required for Data Transmission without any intermediate PC) Total cost of Electricity consumed: 2303967.44 (v) Sample Gas Cooler 200 W 4. Data Logger: Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.8 (vi) NO2/NO Converter 560 W 13.8 10 438 (Note: Compressed Air Required for cleaning of SPM & Gas Analyzer Probes/ If industry Provide required compressed air upto 4 Bar) it is not required) 4. Emission : (i) SPM 50 W 1. Nox and CO 250 W 6 (iii) Heated Sample Line (Considering for 25 meters) 2500 W 600 (iv) Sample Gas Feed Unit 185 W 4.

30000/Annum for each: Emission & Effluent ) Total Cost: 2363967.6 (In words: Twenty Three Lacs Sixty Three Thousand Nine hundred and Sixty Seven Rupees only) .(B) Physical Server Data Transmission & Submission annual Cost: 60000 (Approx Rs.

192 (iv) HMI Controller (Con::Cube) 60 W 1.) Units/Annum Electricity Units/Day (Considering Total (A) Electricity consumption/H (Considering 24 365 Days in a Unit Cost/Annum( Consumption: our Hrs in a day) year) Price(Rs. Data Logger (HydroQ): Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.8 2.44 229354.48 (ii) pH Electrode (pH::lyzer) .) 1.12 43. Effluent : (i) UV-Vis Analyzer (Spectro::lyser) 20 W 0.32 10 2293543.) Rs.44 (v) Sample Gas Cooler(ABB) 200 W 4.Ltd. - (iii) Ultrasonic Flow Meter (ABB) 8W 0. Emission : (i) SPM (Shreetec/Sintrol) 50 W 1.44 770. Air Compressor Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.2 (Note: Heated Sample Line consumes typically 100 VA per meter) 3.88 10 7708. Operational Cost of Complete High-End System (Aaxis Nano Pvt.8 10 438 (Note: Compressed Air Required for cleaning of SPM & Gas Analyzer Probes/ If industry Provide required compressed air upto 4 Bar) it is not required) 4.12 43.8 (vi) NO2/NO Converter (ABB) 560 W 13.488 (iii) Heated Sample Line (Considering for 25 meters) 2500 W 600 (iv) Sample Gas Feed Unit(ABB) 185 W 4.2 (ii) EL 3000 Series NDIR Multi-Gas Analyzer (ABB) 187 W 4.8 10 438 (Note: Data Logger required for Data Transmission without any intermediate PC) .

Total cost of Electricity consumed: 2302128 (B) Physical Server Data Transmission & Submission annual Cost: 60000 (Rs. 30000/Annum each) Total Cost: 2362128 (In words: Twenty Three Lacs Sixty Two Thousand One hundred and Twenty Eight Rupees only) .

Air Compressor Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.12 43.32 10 2293543.2 (Note: Heated Sample Line consumes typically 100 VA per meter) 3. - (iii) Ultrasonic Flow Meter (ABB) 8W 0.2 (ii) EL 3000 Series NDIR Multi-Gas Analyzer (ABB) 187 W 4.024 (ii) pH Electrode (pH::lyzer) .) (Rs. Data Logger (HydroQ): Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.192 (iv) HMI Controller (Con::lyte) 20 W 0.12 43.Ltd.04 10 2540.4 2.488 (iii) Heated Sample Line (Considering for 25 meters) 2500 W 600 (iv) Sample Gas Feed Unit(ABB) 185 W 4. Emission : (i) SPM (Shreetec/Sintrol) 50 W 1. Operational Cost of Complete Low-End System (Aaxis Nano Pvt. Effluent : (i) UV-Vis Analyzer (I::Scan) 1 W 0.) Units/Day Units/Annum( Electricity (Considering Considering Total (A) Electricity consumption/ 24 Hrs in a 365 Days in a Unit Cost/Annum Consumption: Hour day) year) Price(Rs.8 10 438 (Note: Data Logger required for Data Transmission without any intermediate PC) .44 229354.8 (vi) NO2/NO Converter (ABB) 560 W 13.44 (v) Sample Gas Cooler(ABB) 200 W 4.48 254.8 10 438 (Note: Compressed Air Required for cleaning of SPM & Gas Analyzer Probes/ If industry Provide required compressed air upto 4 Bar) it is not required) 4.) 1.

Total cost of Electricity consumed: 2296959. 30000/Annum each: Emission & Effleunt) Total Cost: 2356959.6 (In words: Twenty Three Lacs Fifty Six Thousand Nine Hundred Fifty Nine Rupees only) .6 (B) Physical Server Data Transmission & Submission annual Cost: 60000 (Approx Rs.

2 (iii) Heated Sample Line (Considering for 25 meters) 2500 W 600 (iv) Sample Gas Feed Unit 185 W 4.8 2.8 225438. Emission : (i) SPM (Triboelectric) 50 W 1.44 (ii) pH Electrode .12 43.68 10 5956.Ltd.) Units/Day Units/Annum( Electricity (Considering Considering Total (A) Electricity consumption/ 24 Hrs in a 365 Days in a Unit Cost/Annum( Consumption: Hour day) year) Price(Rs. - (iii) Ultrasonic Flow Meter 8W 0.8 .2 (ii) VA-3000/VS-3000 NDIR Multi component Gas Analyzer for SOx. Data Logger: Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0.) 1.8 10 438 (Note: Compressed Air Required for cleaning of SPM & Gas Analyzer Probes/ If industry Provide required compressed air upto 4 Bar) it is not required) 4.192 595.6 10 2254386 (Note: Heated Sample Line consumes typically 100 VA per meter) 3. Air Compressor Average Electricity Consumption 5W 0. NOx & CO (Horiba) 300 W 7. Effluent : (i) UV-Vis Analyzer with HMI Controller (OPSA 150) 60 W 1.44 (v) Sample Gas Cooler 200 W 4.12 43.) Rs. Operational Cost of Complete System (Horiba India Pvt.8 10 438 (Note: Data Logger required for Data Transmission without any intermediate PC) Total cost of Electricity consumed: 2261218.

30000/Annum each) Total Cost: 2321218.(B) Physical Server Data Transmission & Submission annual Cost: 60000 (Rs.8 (In words: Twenty Three Lacs Twenty Two Thousand Two hundred and Eighteen Rupees only) .