You are on page 1of 4

Developing a “tax-smart” Investor Education

retirement income strategy


Combining fundamental and advanced strategies to develop an effective plan

After a lifetime of saving and investing, the goal in • Include stocks in your portfolio to help manage
retirement is to preserve wealth and invest it in ways longevity risk. When you consider that you’re likely
that generate lasting retirement income. This may sound to need an income stream for 25 years or longer, it
simple enough, but the challenge has never been more becomes clear that your goal should be to include stocks
complicated than it is today when you consider factors in your portfolio to help generate long-term returns that
such as: will keep pace with the rising cost of living. Please keep in
mind that stocks are subject to market risk.
• Changes to employer retirement plans resulting in a lack
of guaranteed income sources • Ensure that your portfolio is properly diversified
to reduce the effect of market swings when taking
• Conflicting elements of risk — the risk of outliving your
withdrawals during a bear market. A properly
portfolio (longevity risk) versus the risk of excessive
diversified portfolio should include bonds, cash, and
volatility due to too much exposure to stocks
alternative investments, as well as stocks. If your
The responsibility for saving for retirement has gener- portfolio is structured to cushion the extremes of
ally shifted from corporate pension plans to individuals. volatility that typically occur during a bear market,
Accordingly, the task of making contributions, selecting you’ll be less likely to experience “reverse dollar cost
investments, and preparing for income distributions averaging.” Reverse dollar cost averaging occurs
rests with you and your advisor. when you are forced to liquidate a greater amount of
What’s more, today’s retirees can anticipate living shares to produce the same amount of income — and
considerably longer than did past generations. As a it can shorten your nest egg’s lifespan. Remember that
result, you need to plan for sufficient income to support diversification does not assure a profit or protect against
your retirement lifestyle for many years, while grappling loss and it is possible to lose money.
with the risk of your portfolio lasting throughout • Select a withdrawal rate that can be sustained over
retirement. a long period of time. Industry research suggests that
an annual withdrawal rate of 6% or greater may not be
The fundamentals of an effective sustainable over an extended period of retirement. For
retirement income plan that reason, most retirees should target a withdrawal
While the challenges to creating sustainable retirement rate of no more than 4% to 5%.
income are daunting, there are basic considerations that, • Consider adding a guaranteed income component,
if properly implemented, will strengthen any retirement such as an annuity, to your portfolio. Adding
income plan: guaranteed income, or income that you cannot outlive,
such as an annuity product that provides guaranteed
income for life, can improve the odds that your portfolio
will survive throughout retirement, and may allow you to
allocate a greater proportion of your nest egg to stocks.
Moving beyond the fundamentals: TAX TREATMENT OF VARIOUS TYPES OF RETIREMENT ASSETS
tax diversification
Type of asset/account Taxability
Now that we’ve highlighted the fundamentals of
Traditional retirement Taxable at ordinary income
effective retirement income planning, we’ll turn next to accounts (e.g., pensions, IRAs, rates when distributed
ways that an income plan can be optimized from a tax 401(k)s)

standpoint. Specifically, we’ll look at: Roth IRAs and 401(k)s Contributions made with
after-tax dollars; not taxed
1. Building tax diversification into your overall portfolio when distributed

2. Taking “tax-smart” withdrawals during retirement Taxable investment accounts Capital gains and dividends:
taxed at a maximum 15% rate
A key challenge to building proper tax diversification into Other income:
taxed at ordinary income rates
investors’ portfolios is the fact that many individuals hold Return of principal:
a disproportionate percentage of their overall savings not taxable

in tax-deferred retirement accounts. These accounts, Social Security May be partially taxable
which include Traditional IRAs, 401(k) plans, and at ordinary income rates

pensions, are fully taxable at ordinary income rates when


money is distributed.
Effect of taxes on the success of
an income plan
A recent study showed that among
A historical analysis of different tax scenarios showed
families with assets in defined the survivability over various time periods of a diver-
contribution plans or IRAs, these sified portfolio of stocks, bonds, and cash when the
resources accounted for a median of portfolio is taxed at different rates. Not surprisingly, the
portfolio with the highest tax bracket had the shortest
62.5% of their total financial assets. 1
survivability.

At the same time, Roth IRA accounts, which are funded


with after-tax dollars and are therefore not taxable when historical success rate

money is withdrawn, comprised just 5% of all IRA assets.2 20 years 30 years 40 years

No taxes 96% 75% 56%


This concentration of assets in traditional retirement
15% tax rate 84% 54% 35%
accounts has occurred as personal income tax rates
25% tax rate 75% 39% 16%
declined to historically low levels. Consequently, retirees
35% tax rate 58% 21% 3%
who have the majority of their assets in traditional
accounts could be in for an unpleasant surprise. This hypothetical illustration is based on rolling historical time period
analysis and does not represent the performance of any Putnam fund
or product, which will fluctuate. This illustration uses the historical
During the past 80+ years, tax rates rolling periods from 1926 to 2010 and a portfolio composed of 60%
stocks (as represented by an S&P 500 composite), 30% bonds (as
have been at current levels or lower represented by a 20-year long-term government bond (50%) and a
20-year corporate bond (50%)), and 10% cash (as represented by U.S.
only 14% of the time. If tax rates revert 30-day T-bills) to determine how long a portfolio would have lasted
back to pre-1980s levels, the tax savings given a 5% initial withdrawal rate adjusted each year for inflation.
A one-year rolling average is used to calculate performance of the
investors enjoyed during their working 20-year bonds. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
The S&P 500 Index is an unmanaged index of common stock perfor-
years could be more than offset by mance. You cannot invest directly in an index.

higher taxes in retirement.


Benefits of tax diversification TAX LEGISLATION OPENS THE DOOR
Tax diversification offers several distinct benefits: TO ROTH IRAs AND ROTH 401(k)s

Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act (EGTRRA):


• Flexibility to draw income from different sources
Introduced Roth 401(k) plans for employee salary deferrals.
depending on your tax situation and changes in overall
Tax Increase Prevention and Reconciliation Act (TIPRA):
life circumstances Eliminated the modified adjusted gross income requirement
for converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. Effective 2010,
• May help your portfolio last longer Roth IRA conversions are available to all taxpayers regardless
of income.
• Allows you to hedge your portfolio against the direction
Small Business Jobs Act of 2010:
of tax rates, which could be higher in the future Allows Roth conversions inside 401(k) plans.

Achieving tax diversification


Investors are accustomed to hearing their advisors Implementing a tax-efficient
speak of the importance of properly diversifying invest- withdrawal strategy
ments with respect to asset classes and investment When it comes time to withdraw funds for retirement
styles. But retirees must also be concerned about having income, the conventional wisdom is that retirees should
their assets diversified on the basis of taxability. take money from accounts in the following order:
Simply put, tax diversification involves allocating retire- 1. Taxable
ment assets across accounts and investment vehicles
2. Tax deferred
that are taxed differently — taxable, tax deferred, and
tax free. A sound tax diversification plan may include the 3. Tax free
following elements: The motivation behind this conventional wisdom is
• Allocate assets by tax status. In general, consider to preserve tax-deferred assets for as long as possible.
placing a larger percentage of your stock holdings outside However, depending on an individual’s tax situation,
of retirement accounts and a larger percentage of your the conventional wisdom may not be the best course
fixed-income holdings inside retirement accounts. of action.
With respect to stock investments, allocating a greater For example, if you have substantial unrealized capital
proportion of your buy-and-hold or dividend-paying gains on taxable assets, it may be better to withdraw
investments to taxable (i.e., non-retirement) accounts funds from tax-deferred or tax-free (e.g., Roth IRA)
may increase your ability to benefit from the 15% tax rate accounts first. By doing so, you may be able to preserve
on qualified dividends and long-term capital gains. all or a significant amount of your taxable assets, which
• Look at holding a larger percentage of taxable (i.e., could then be passed to your heirs with a “stepped-up”
non-retirement plan) fixed-income assets in municipal cost basis (i.e., the market value of the assets on your
3
bond funds. Municipal bonds are free from federal, and date of death rather than their original cost).
in some cases, state income taxes, and are particularly Similarly, it may make sense to time the withdrawal of
advantageous for investors in the highest tax brackets. funds from tax-deferred accounts for years when you’re
Tax-free bonds are especially attractive now because likely to be in a lower marginal tax bracket compared
their yields are significantly above the long-term average with your pre-retirement tax bracket. These years could
versus comparable U.S. Treasury securities — a historical occur early in retirement before required minimum
rarity. What’s more, although Treasuries are exempt distributions (RMDs) from retirement accounts begin
from state and local taxes, they are subject to federal (normally age 70½), or later in retirement when medical
income taxes while municipal bonds are not. expenses may be higher. Drawing from tax-deferred
• Utilize a Roth IRA/401(k) strategy. Consider funding accounts when your tax rate is low will allow you to enjoy
a Roth 401(k) account, rolling over a retirement plan the full benefit of the lower rate.
distribution to a Roth IRA, or converting a traditional IRA
to a Roth IRA. Remember that distributions from a Roth
IRA or 401(k) are not taxable if requirements are met.
The table below summarizes various retirement situa- Maximizing the use of tax brackets
tions and the corresponding withdrawal strategies that A related strategy is to draw income from different tax
may be optimal from a tax standpoint. sources as you gradually transition from lower to higher
tax brackets. That is, draw enough income from tax-
TAX-EFFICIENT WITHDRAWALS deferred sources such as Traditional IRAs or 401(k)s to
If the retirement situation Then consider the reach the limit of the 15% income tax bracket ($34,500
involves: following:
for single filers). This approach maximizes use of the rela-
Lower marginal tax rate Draw from tax-deferred tively low 15% tax bracket for ordinary income. This also
assets to maximize use of
lower relative tax bracket,
reduces the balance of tax-deferred accounts, which
which may help to reduce lowers required minimum distributions in the future.
RMDs at age 70½
As more income is needed, consider drawing from other
Higher marginal tax rate Use tax-free or taxable assets
to avoid higher income tax sources (taxable or tax-free) to avoid increasing ordinary
rate and/or take advantage income, which is subject to higher tax rates.
of lower capital gains rates
TAX SINGLE JOINT
Significant capital If a legacy goal exists, STRATEGY
BRACKET* FILERS FILERS
appreciation in a preserve taxable assets to
taxable account take advantage of “stepped- 10% $8,500 $34,500 Tax-deferred
up” cost basis at death
15% $34,500 $69,000 Tax-deferred
Working in retirement Avoid tax-deferred assets,
25% $83,600 $139,350 Taxable
which will increase overall
income (higher income 28% $174,400 $212,300 Taxable
could trigger taxes on
Social Security benefits) 33% $379,150 $379,150 Tax-free

35% — — Tax-free

*2011 federal tax rate.

Sound planning is the key


The goal of achieving lasting retirement income is more
challenging today than in the past. However, through a
combination of fundamental and advanced strategies,
your advisor can help you meet this challenge head on
by developing a plan that links inflation protection with
sustainable, tax-efficient withdrawals.

1 “Individual Account Retirement Plans: An Analysis of the 2004 Survey of Consumer Finances,” Employee Benefit Research Institute, May 2006.

2 ICI, “U.S. Retirement Market,” February 2010.

3 Treasury bills are guaranteed as to the timely payment of principal and interest and are exempt from state and local income taxes whereas municipal
bonds are free from federal and in some cases state and local taxes. Funds that invest in bonds are subject to certain risks including interest-rate risk,
credit risk, and inflation risk. As interest rates rise, the prices of bonds fall.

For some investors, investment income may be subject to the federal alternative minimum tax.

This material is for informational purposes only. It should not be considered tax advice. You should consult your financial representative to determine
what may be best for your individual needs.

Investors should carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses of a fund before investing.
For a prospectus, or a summary prospectus if available, containing this and other information for any Putnam fund or
product, call Putnam at 1-800-225-1581 and ask for a prospectus. Please read the prospectus carefully before investing.
 Putnam Retail Management
Putnam Investments | One Post Office Square | Boston, Massachusetts 02109 | putnam.com II866 266770 3/11

You might also like