You are on page 1of 4

Case 2:16-cr-01012-SRB Document 158 Filed 06/16/17 Page 1 of 4

1 ANNALOU TIROL
Acting Chief
2 Public Integrity Section, Criminal Division
U.S. Department of Justice
3
JOHN D. KELLER
4 Illinois State Bar No. 6293104
Deputy Chief
5 VICTOR R. SALGADO
DC Bar No. 975013
6 SIMON J. CATALDO
Massachusetts Bar No. 690879
7 Trial Attorneys
Public Integrity Section, Criminal Division
8 U.S. Department of Justice
1400 New York Ave, NW, 12th floor
9 Washington, D.C. 20005
Tel: (202) 514-1412
10 John.Keller2@usdoj.gov
Victor.Salgado@usdoj.gov
11 Simon.Cataldo@usdoj.gov

12
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
13
FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
14
United States of America,
15 No. CR-16-01012-PHX-SRB
Plaintiff,
16
v. STIPULATIONS
17
18 Joseph M. Arpaio,
19 Defendant.
20
The government, by the undersigned attorneys for the Department of Justice,
21
22 Criminal Division, Public Integrity Section, and the defendant, by his undersigned
23 attorneys, stipulate as follows:
24
I. The documents and recordings listed below are authentic duplicates under
25
26 Federal Rules of Evidence 901, 902, and 1003. As such, the parties stipulate that these

27 documents and video and audio recordings are admissible without additional seals,
28
certifications, or testimony regarding authentication. The parties reserve the right to
Case 2:16-cr-01012-SRB Document 158 Filed 06/16/17 Page 2 of 4

1 challenge admissibility of the evidence on any other grounds, including relevance.

2
a. Gov. Ex. 1: December 23, 2011, Preliminary Injunction, ECF No. 4941
3
b. Gov. Ex. 2: Expedited Motion to Vacate Hearing, ECF No. 948
4
5 c. Gov. Ex’s. 3–3r: Transcripts and recordings of Arpaio’s prior testimony and
DOJ interviews, as identified by the date and Bates numbers provided in the
6
Government’s Exhibit List.
7
d. Gov. Ex. 4: Declaration of John MacIntyre, ECF No. 838-1
8
9 e. Gov. Ex’s. 5–5d; 7–7i; 15–15l; 16–16d; 17–17b; 21–21d; 22; 35–35c; 39:
Transcripts and recordings of potential witnesses’ prior testimony and
10 monitor interviews, as identified by individual, date, and Bates numbers
11 provided in the Government’s Exhibit List.

12 f. Gov. Ex’s. 6, 8–14, 23–33: Emails identified by the date, sender, and Bates
number provided in the Government’s Exhibit List.
13
14 g. Gov. Ex. 34: Timothy Casey’s redacted billing records identified by the years
and Bates numbers provided in the Government’s Exhibit List.
15
16 h. Gov. Ex’s. 36a–36m, 43: MCSO press releases identified by the dates and
Bates numbers provided in the Government’s Exhibit List.
17
18 i. Gov. Ex. 38: Joe Show documentary footage
19 j. Gov. Ex’s. 40–41a: MCSO incident reports identified by the date and Bates
20 number provided in the Government’s Exhibit list.

21 k. Gov. Ex. 42: MCSO LEAR Protocol identified by the Bates number provided
22 in the Government’s Exhibit List.

23 l. Def. Ex’s. 100–150, as identified by the descriptions, exhibit numbers, and
24 Bates numbers provided in the Defendant’s Second Supplemental Exhibit
List, dated June 13, 2017.
25
26
27 1
All ECF entries refer to docket entries in Melendres v. Arpaio, No. 2:07-cv-02513,
28 (D. Ariz. 2007).
-2-
Case 2:16-cr-01012-SRB Document 158 Filed 06/16/17 Page 3 of 4

1
2 II. The parties further stipulate that the media interviews identified as Exhibit

3 Numbers 37a–37t in the Government’s Exhibit List are authentic duplicates under Federal
4
Rules of Evidence 901, 902, and 1003, and are admissible without additional seals,
5
certifications, or testimony regarding authentication. The parties reserve the right to
6
7 challenge the admissibility of the evidence on any other grounds, including relevance.
8 III. The parties further stipulate that the HSU Master Logs and DR summaries
9
identified as Exhibit Numbers 18, 19, and 20 in the Government’s Exhibit List are authentic
10
11 duplicates pursuant to Federal Rules of Evidence 901, 902, and 1003, are admissible

12 without additional seals, certificates, or testimony regarding authentication. The parties
13
reserve the right to object to the evidence on any other grounds.
14
15 Respectfully Submitted,

16 ANNALOU TIROL
Attorneys for the Defendant: Acting Chief, Public Integrity Section
17
18 /s/Dennis I. Wilenchik By: /s/ John D. Keller
Dennis I. Wilenchik, Esq. John D. Keller
19
John D. Wilenchik, Esq. Deputy Chief
20 Wilenchik & Barntess, P.C. Victor R. Salgado
The Wilenchik & Bartness Building Simon J. Cataldo
21 2810 N. Third St. Trial Attorneys
22 Phoenix, AZ 85004
admin@wb-law.com United States Department of Justice
23 Public Integrity Section
24 /s/ Mark D. Goldman 1400 New York Ave. NW
Mark D. Goldman, Esq. Washington, DC 20005
25 Jeff S. Surdakowski, Esq. (202) 514-1412
26 Goldman & Zwillinger PLLC John.Keller2@usdoj.gov
17851 N. 85th St., Suite 175 Victor.Salgado@usdoj.gov
27 Scottsdale, AZ 85255 Simon.Cataldo@usdoj.gov
28 docket@gzlawoffice.com
-3-
Case 2:16-cr-01012-SRB Document 158 Filed 06/16/17 Page 4 of 4

1
2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
3 I HEREBY CERTIFY that on today’s date, I electronically filed the foregoing via the
4 CM/ECF system which will provide notice to counsel of record for the defendant.

5
/s/ John D. Keller
6 John D. Keller
7 Deputy Chief

8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-4-