Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Powder Technology
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Gypsum is a crystalline form of hydrated calcium sulfate (CaSO42H20) generally used in cements and plasters in
Received 18 June 2015 the construction industry, though also in paints, fertilizers, medicines, papers, and textiles. For use in these ma-
Received in revised form 28 August 2015 terials, gypsum must be ground nely (b 100 m), if not ultra-nely (b10 m), for which ball mills are most ef-
Accepted 21 December 2015
fective. Despite gypsum's widespread use and the regular need to grind it, studies concerning the grinding of
Available online 21 December 2015
gypsum ore remain scarce. In response, in this study, we have systematically investigated how certain grinding
Keywords:
parameters (i.e., mill speed, ball lling ratio, ball size distribution, powder lling ratio, grinding aid ratio, and
Gypsum ore grinding time) of conventional dry ball mills affect the grindability of gypsum ore. We determined the properties
Ultra-ne grinding of the micronized gypsum products obtained in optimal grinding conditions, and the results showed that the dry
Dry ball mill ball mill grinding process can effectively produce ultra-ne gypsum products.
Product features 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2015.12.027
0032-5910/ 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
B. kszolu, M. Uurum / Powder Technology 291 (2016) 186192 187
Fig. 1. Particle size distribution of the crushed sample. Fig. 2. Particle size distribution of products obtained in different mill speeds.
As such, the objective of this study was to examine how grinding pa- The critical speed (Nc), ball lling ratio (Jb), and powder lling ratio
rameters such as mill speed, ball lling ratio, ball size distribution, pow- (fc) were calculated using Eqs. (1), (2), and (3), respectively:
der lling ratio, grinding aid ratio, and grinding time impact the h i
grinding of gypsum ore. For this purpose, batch dry grinding tests Nc 42:3=Dd
0:5
rpm D mill diameter and d 1
were performed in a laboratory-scale ball mill to determine the particle
ball diameter; in meters
size, width of PSD (particle size distribution), total surface area, and
color parameters of the nal micronized gypsum products.
Jb mass of balls=ball density=mill volume 1=0:6 2
Gypsum ore (K Global, from UluklaNide, Turkey) containing There are several ways that have been used to describe the particle
29.67% CaO, 46% SO3, and 20.93% LOI was used in this study. The sample size distribution (PSD) width [8]. An additional property is the steep-
was crushed to a nominal maximum size of 2 mm using a jaw crusher ness of the particle size distribution curve, dened by the steepness
in a closed circuit with a 2 mm screen. The particle size distribution of factor (SF) [9]. This value is the quotient of the d50 and the d20 values
the crushed sample was determined by dry screening, the results of corresponding to the particle size such that 20% by weight of the parti-
which appear in Fig. 1. As shown, the sample contained particle sizes cles present are ner. A curve with SF greater than 2 is described as
of approximately d80 = 1.10 mm. broad and curves with a factor of less than 2 as narrow or steep.
The grinding machine was a laboratory-scale ball mill made of stain- [10]. The SF value is calculated from d50/d20. The ratio (d90d10)/d50
less steel with the dimensions 200 200 mm. The grinding media were can also be used [11,12] in addition to the ratio d80/d20 [13]. The d80/
stainless steel balls with a density of 8.000 kg/m3 and with three differ- d20 ratio is the simplest to calculate and is related to d80, the value
ent diameters (i.e., 2, 3, and 4 cm). Powder density was found to be most commonly used in mineral processing to describe the product
2.3 g/cm3. The grinding experiment was performed as a batch process; size. As the product size distribution becomes narrower, both ratios
after each test, all media and ground samples were removed from the (d90d10)/d50 and d80/d20 decrease [8]. In addition, the particle size
mill and the media separated from the products by dry sieving. ratio of d90/d10 becomes more useful for representing the PSD width,
To investigate the effect of the experimental grinding parameters, and therefore this ratio was used in this study.
including mill speed (% of critical speed), ball lling ratio (Jb), ball size An organization called Commission Internationale del'Eclairage
distribution, powder lling ratio (fc), grinding aid ratio (% of powder (CIE) determined the standard values that are used worldwide to mea-
mass), and grinding time (min), on the micronized gypsum product sure color. The values used by CIE are called L*, a*, and b*, and the color
size, a series of experiments were conducted. Poly-acrylic acid
(CH2CHCOOH)n was used as a grinding aid, and to analyze the ground
products, a dry screen was constructed using 0.5000.3000.212
0.180 and 0.106 m sieves. Full size distributions were measured, after
which product sizes ner than 80% were passed through a sieve (d80)
diameter derived from the results of a sizer. The nal micronized prod-
ucts were measured using a dry laser sizer (Sympatec, NJ, USA).
Table 1
Experimental conditions of mill speed.
Condition Variable
Table 2
Experimental conditions of ball lling ratio.
Condition Variable
h i0;5
2 3.2. Inuence of ball lling ratio (Jb)
E L0 L2 a0 a2 b0 b 4
rial is held against the shell throughout the cycle. As the critical speed is Condition Variable
larger at smaller radii, the centrifuging layer becomes thicker and Operational speed (% of Nc) 80
thicker as the speed increases until the entire charge is centrifuging Ball lling ratio (Jb) 0.30
and the net power draw is zero [17]. It is well known that the rotational Ball size distribution (234 cm) Group I:05050
speed of any ball mill is important to efcient mill operation. The oper- Group II:50050
Group III:50500
ating variables for the optimization of mill speed appear in Table 1; the
Group IV:304030
mill speed varied between 50 and 90% of the critical speed in this work. Group V:206020
The experimental results are shown in terms of cumulative undersize Group VI:108010
(Fig. 2) and d80 values (Fig. 3), which were best at 80% and 90% of critical Powder lling ratio (fc) 0.10
speed, as shown by the results in which ground products have a particle Grinding aid ratio (% of powder mass) 0
Grinding time (min) 5
size of d80 = 340 m. As a lower mill speed consumes less energy, 80% of
the critical speed (i.e., 85 rpm) was preferred for studying the next
parameter.
Fig. 4. Particle size distribution of products obtained in different ball lling ratios. Fig. 6. Particle size distribution of products obtained in different ball size distributions.
B. kszolu, M. Uurum / Powder Technology 291 (2016) 186192 189
Fig. 8. Particle size distribution of products obtained in different powder lling ratios.
the charge that lead to maximum power draw and optimal throughput
[7]. The energy input to a mill increases with the ball charge, and
reaches a maximum at a charge volume of approximately 50% [18]. In be reduced in size. If, after some time, the grinding medium is worn,
this study, the ball lling ratio (Jb) of the mill was increased from 0.15 then it is simply replaced [20]. In this experimental study, the inuence
to 0.40, and experiments were conducted at different operating param- of the gypsum lling ratio was observed using the conditions shown in
eters, shown in Table 2. The results are provided in Figs. 4 and 5 based Table 4. The results are reported in Figs. 8 and 9 in terms of cumulative
on the cumulative undersize and d80 values, respectively; better results undersize and d80 values, respectively, the latter showing that the parti-
were obtained at ball lling ratios of 0.30 and 0.40. Based on d80, the cle size decreases linearly with a decreasing gypsum lling ratio. The
products have a particle size of 320 m. As increased grinding media ll- best results were obtained at a lling ratio of fc = 0.05. As shown by
ing ratios in ball mills use more energy, a ratio of Jb = 0.30 was applied the results, micronized products had a particle size of d80 = 200 m.
as the optimal value in this study.
3.5. Inuence of grinding aid ratio
3.3. Inuence of ball size distribution
Generally, in many industries handling ne powders, various chem-
The efciency of grinding depends on the surface area of the grind-
ical additives and treating agents are used in several processes after the
ing medium. Grinding in a ball mill is effected by contacts between
grinding process for purposes such as the prevention of agglomeration
the ball and ore particles. The angle of nip is important, and ball sizes
between particles, the stabilization of the powder surface and the en-
must be carefully chosen in relation to the largest and hardest particles
hanced formation of ceramic powder. Therefore, if these chemical addi-
in the feed [19]. As not all industrial grinding processes in ball mills are
tives can be used as grinding aids, process simplication of the process
performed with the same ball diameter, using a mixture of different ball
diameters and ratios is common. The effect of parameters is particularly
important in ultra-ne grinding processes in ball mills. The experimen-
tal conditions and range of variables used as parameters in the ball mill
tests are summarized in Table 3. The results are given as a function of
the cumulative undersize and d80 values in Figs. 6 and 7, respectively.
These gures reveal a slight decrease in particle size as the ball size dis-
tribution changes. However, the results indicate that the particle size of
gypsum is not sensitive to variation in ball size distribution in this range.
Groups 4, 5, and 6 showed the same results: the d80 values for the
ground products were approximately 320 m. Therefore, Group 5, in
which 20% of diameters were 2 cm, 60% were 3 cm and 20% were
4 cm, was preferred for studying the next parameter.
Table 4 Table 5
Experimental conditions of powder lling ratio. Experimental conditions of grinding aid ratio.
Table 6
Experimental conditions of grinding time.
Condition Variable
Fig. 11. d80 values of products obtained in different grinding aid ratio. Fig. 12. d80 and d50 values of obtained gypsum products.
B. kszolu, M. Uurum / Powder Technology 291 (2016) 186192 191
Fig. 13. d50/d20, (d90-d10)/d50, d80/d20 and d90/d10 values of obtained products.
Fig. 15. a* values of feed and micronized gypsum products.
color difference between the feed and micronized gypsum products, ratio, and grinding time at unusually high levels. In the conditions ap-
which is considered to be a natural result of the grinding process. plied, the impact of other variables such as ball size distribution on
product size was minor. In addition, four different measures of PSD
4. Conclusions width were calculated for each ultra-ne gypsum product obtained.
This work shows that a narrower product particle size distribution can-
In this study, batch grinding tests of gypsum ore were performed not be achieved with the lack of separation. Surface area increased from
using a ball mill to investigate the effects of grinding parameters such 7.365 to 10.855 cm2/g with increased grinding times between 5 and
as mill speed, ball lling ratio, ball size distribution, powder lling 30 min. Because it is well known that the specic surface area is in-
ratio, grinding aid ratio, and grinding time. The properties of the mi- creased as the particle size becomes small, the L* color parameter
cronized gypsum products obtained were determined, among which value of gypsum ore increased from 95.75 to 97.38, while the b* value
the best set of results was obtained with 80% of critical speed decreased from 2.51 to 1.83 due to the grinding process. As expected,
(85 rpm) for operation speed, 0.30 as the ball lling ratio (Jb), 20% L* values of ultra-ne samples increased and b* values decreased, prob-
(2 cm), 60% (3 cm) and 20% (4 cm) as the ball size distribution, 0.05 ably due to a clean particle surface on which agitation can cause the oc-
as the powder lling ratio (fc), 0.5% of powder as the grinding aid currence of a new mineral surface. The results show that the dry
ratio, and a grinding time of 30 min, which produced particle sizes of grinding technique in conventional ball mills for gypsum ore can effec-
d50 = 4.25. The results show that the grinding operation was highly tively obtain ne and ultra-ne products.
sensitive to the mill speed, ball and powder lling ratio, grinding aid
Acknowledgments
Table 7
The total surface area values of micronized gypsum products. The authors would like to thank K Global Company from Ulukla
Nide, Turkey to their colleagues.
Grinding time (min) Total surface area (cm2/g)
5 7.365
10 8.395 References
15 9.218
20 9.905 [1] A. Founie, Gypsum, U.S. Geological Survey Minerals Yearbook (2003), 2003 (http://
30 10.855 minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/gypsum/gypsumyb03.pdf).
[2] V. Deniz, Inuence of interstitial lling on breakage kinetics of gypsum in ball mill,
Adv. Powder Technol., 22 (2011) 512517.
Fig. 14. L* values of feed and micronized gypsum products. Fig. 16. b* values of feed and micronized gypsum products.
192 B. kszolu, M. Uurum / Powder Technology 291 (2016) 186192
[8] A. Jankovic, S. Sinclair, The shape of product size distributions in stirred mills, Miner.
Eng. 19 (2006) 15281536.
[9] D. Strauch, P. Belger, H. Hofer, and M. Merz, A.G. Pltiss-Staufer, U.S. Patent 4767464
(1988).
[10] R. Werner, Effect of extenders with narrow and broad particle size distribution on
the properties of coating, Technol. Form. 72 (90.3) (2000) 7176.
[11] H. Karbstein, F. Muller, R. Polke, Producing suspensions with steep particle size dis-
tributions in nes ranges, Aufbereitungstechnik 36 (10) (1995) 464473.
[12] H. Karbstein, F. Muller, R. Polke, Scale-up for grinding in stirred ball mills,
Aufbereitungstechnik 37 (10) (1996) 469479.
[13] J.A. Nesset, P. Radziszewski, C. Hardie, D.P. Leroux, Assessing the Performance and
Efciency of Fine Grinding Technologies, Proceedings of 38th Annual Canadian Min-
eral Processor Operators Conference, January 1719, Ottawa, Canada 2006,
pp. 283310.
[14] R. Sharafudeen, The manufacturing process parameters affecting color and bright-
ness of TiO2 pigmen, Sharafudeen Int. J. Ind. Chem. 3 (2012) 26.
[15] M. Maskan, Kinetics of color change of kiwifruits during hot air and microwave dry-
ing, J. Food Eng. 48 (2001).
[16] R.C.L. Homco, K.J. Ryan, S.E. Wicklund, C.L. Nicolalde, S. Lin, F.K. Mckeith, et al., Effects
of modied corn gluten meal on quality characteristics of a model emulsied meat
product, Meat Sci. 67 (2004).
Fig. 17. E values of feed and micronized gypsum products. [17] P.P. King, Technical Notes 8 Grinding, 2000 (http://www.mineraltech.com/
MODSIM/ModsimTraining/Module6/Grinding.pdf).
[18] B.A. Wills, T.N. Munn, Mineral Processing Technology, ISBN: 0750644508, Publisher:
[3] B. Epstein, Logarithmic-normal distribution in breakage of solids, Ind. Eng. Chem. 40 Elsevier Science & Technology Books, 2006.
(1948) 22892291. [19] N.N.S. Lameck, Effects of Grinding Media Shapes on Ball Mill Performance, Faculty of
[4] J.A. Herbst, D.W. Fuerstenau, The zero-order production of ne sizes in comminu- Engineering and The Built Environment, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannes-
tion and its implications in simulation, Trans. AIME 241 (1968) 538549. burg, 2005 (http://mobile.wiredspace.wits.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10539/1506/
[5] T.W. Chenje, D.J. Simbi, E. Navara, Relationship between microstructure, hardness, Dissertation,%20Final%20Submission.pdf?sequence = 1).
impact toughness and wear performance of selected grinding media for mineral [20] D.S. Fortsch, Ball Charge Loading Impact on Specic Power Consumption and Ca-
ore milling operations, Mater. Des. 25 (2004) 1118. pacity, IEEE-IAS Cement Industry Committee (2006) (http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/
[6] H. Ipek, Effect of grinding media shapes on breakage parameters, Part. Part. Syst. stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=1635707).
Charact. 24 (2007) 229235. [21] M. Hasegawa, M. Kimata, M. Shimane, T. Shoji, M. Tsuruta, The effect of liquid addi-
[7] K.K. Kiangi, H.M. Michael, Particle lling and size effects on the ball load behaviour tives on dry ultrane grinding of quartz, Powder Technol 114 (2001) 145151.
and power in a dry pilot mill: experimental study, Powder Technol. 187 (2008) [22] J. Zheng, C.C. Harris, P. Somasundaran, The effect of additives on stirred media mill-
7987. ing of limestone, Powder Technol. 91 (1997) 173179.