142 N o 14 2

20 11 11 C A FL E N o v. 20 1 1

, ,

., , , . , 4, 5
( 1. , 100
0 8
9 ;2 . ,
3 . , 07
1 0 2;
4 . , 3 3
5
5 . , 5 0 14 )
2

: " "
12 !27 70 ; 5
1 !1 2 5 " ,
8 8
, "
: ; ;
:H 3 19 .3 :A :10
0 1795 (20 11 )0
6 1
9 ( 05

, 1 .1 t
. / e / tieal thinking disposition 0
" / 0 ( D e
l ph
i Pr
j e
o c t
) ,
" , ! / 0, !
, ( F
a c
ion e , et a ) :6 ) "
l . , 20(
X
" ( er
i tiea
l rhinking skills ) ( eri tieal
" " hi
t n k
ing ) ,
2 0 8 , (anear
io & F 0 1 :3 ) "
a eion e , 20
, (C a
l if
orn ia C r
i tiea
l T
h inking D isposi-
tion Invent , C C T
D I) F
a eione
"200 8 12 1995 , ,
27 70 "2(X) 9 , " / 0
, 51 18825 "
" , "
" 2 0 8 20 0 " 25
0
" , ,
,
1

: : , , " : ! ! ! "
: , , " : "
: , , " : "
: , , " : "
: , , " : "
:20 11 829
15
. 5 62009 l / 0 , crit cal thi nk ing , k
l l:
i
/ 0 "
 , :

150 (Faeione , et al. , 2001:4 ) " , "

/ 0 / 0 " , ;
, 6 6 ! 182
9 ,
" , , "
, 1
5 0 75 " , C C T D
I
CV
5 7 , !
7 "
, 7 : ! ! !
. ! ! ! ! " , !
9 12 "7 !
Al pha 0 .71 0 . 80 , 0 .9 1
; , (eo ns tru ct )
10 19 , 7 " "
0 .60 0 .78 , 0 .90 " , 20
0 8 , C C T D
I
, " " 20
0 9
/ 0 I , 2
, C C D T
"
, C C T D
I ,
, 2 2008
" 2 .1
1.2 2 . 1.1
c c T DI 26
7 7 1
2 ,
! " (2002 ) 9 , 9 3 /9
8 50
" 173 :422 3 /2 11 0 ;1340
" , 7 A
l - ( 1 ) " 86
5 , 19 07
pha 0 .39 0 .65 , Al pha , .4 % " ,
0 .64 " 8 " 1 98
1 8 , 2 86
5 ,3
, " , 38
2 823 ( 1 ) " ,
, , 7 , 1
C ronbaeh " 0 .46 0 . 83 , C C T D I
1 ! !
Cr c h a 0 .86 " 87
o nba
l 2 3
, , 3
9 85 i
O6
4

,!
,r/
!-
- 3 13 i5
k
(
3
l)1
(
60
9 73
3
l2
)
(
8
7
9
5 81
5
3
7
4
0 !-, 0

93
81
8 4-, 9
8
2
0
5 267
91542
/ 0 "
21 1 l6
4 72
0
9
1
7
5

(2004 ) C C T DI
, "
, , c C rD
I : 5 .1
C V ) "
( C C T DI
2. 1.2
,
7
5
75 80 " 3
" 5
0 , "
8
,5 , 5
0 , "
1
" ,
70 , 7 , 10 , 1
6
,
" ! , , . / 0 -
/ sy
stem a
tl v 0
ci
t
, / 0 ,
Al a 0 .90 "
/ . , " f / 0 "
, C C T - , , i ,
D l " ! / 0_
 , :

" ,
,
, , , " " ,
2 .1.3 , , ! ,
4 , 70 " "
" , 6 .7% "
, , 8
! , 6 /
3
, 12 81 , * 0,
" 200 8 fl 12 " "
, 20 " , ,
2 . 1.4 "
" " " 30 ,
, , , ,
, " , " " 6
7 .2 %
2 0 % , 93 " " 4
5 /
, 40 " " * 0,
S PS S Seal e R eliab ility 7 ,
" 75 " , ,
, 7 , "
, 7 Al pha 74 .8% "
5 , 63 "
2 , ,
, 0 .0 5 " ,
1 0 .0
"
" ,
2.2 ,
2 7
"
" 0 .84 ,
, 7 , / 0 , 3 2009
, " /
3 .1
0 Al pha 0 .29 , "
3 . 1.1
"
1895
3 ,
2 2677 537
5 9 ! ! "
1 , 1

1882
5 ,
26 77 13 137 1 5 37

A IPa
12
8 ,
0 .5 3 0 .5 0 0 .54 9
0

2
1 U .7 2 " "
0 .2 9 0 .3 0 0 .2 9 0 7
57
0
4
3
82
3 , 5
1 , 98
5 9 , Zn 8
4 " 34 .06 % "
, 3

18 82
5

( / 0) 1 !2 !3 ,

"

75 0 .9
)
( 3

, 98 5 7
6

, 2 11 D
4

" !47

24 / , * 0 254
 , :

1369 , 603
6 , 18.5% ;

4434 , 5 9 % ; 2677
, 36 .2 % , 390 "

1604 , 3741 , 30 % ;
} ! } } }
24 60 , 45 .5 % ; 25 38 ,
6 .9 % , 40 9 "
4
}1} }] >l }}
3353 , 246 8 , 57 .6 % ;
1
3 11
9 , 5
2 .82 % , 2348 ,
39 .76 % , 4 5 " ( aeadem iC dim ension ) ,
, 655 , 13 8 , ( Soei dim ension ) " ,
23 , 4 71 ! 23 " "
38 , 48 " , ;
3 .1.2 ,
" " 8
, " , ,
8 , 7 C C TDI , ,
(ju
s t
c e
i or
ien te
d ) , "
! ! " 3 .2
" 4
, , !A a , "
l ph
, , A
l pha 0 .8
7 ; A
l ph
a
" 0 .8
4 0 .8
0 ; A
l ph
a 0 .7
4
C C T DI 75 0 .7
9 ; A
l ph
a 0.7
0
, ; 0.64 " 8 A
l ph
a 0 .5
0 0 .73
" , " , "
6 " , 4

5
4 ( ) , 6 8
lpha Z ^ lp
a 3 pha 4 A lpha

" 5 54
22 0 .74 5 0 55 ,22 ,30 !
14 ,2
, , , 0 84 6 0.62 05,13,29,31,37 455
. 5 0.70 10 , 18 ,26 ,34 ,49
9
" 12 0 .799
7 0 73 0 1,0
9 , 17 ,25 ,33 ,4 1,48
8
3 .1.3
, , 7 0.50 05 , 12 , 26 ,24 32 ,53 ,

" 0 8
0

15 0 70
0
6 0 55 23 ,39 ,47 ,s 52 ,54
4
8 58 0 ,2
4 0 ,28 ,36 ,3
8 ,42 ,4
4 ,5
0
1 8 " , ,
2 12 0 .64
6 0 50 0 3 #11 #19 ,27 #35 ,4 3
" "
2008 , 5 4 "
"
200 9 2008 "
, "
, ; ,
2 8 " 8
0 0 , "
0 ,4 , 02 , 06 ,07 , "
5
, 2009 ,
8 ,
"
( l) "
"
8 , ( int el e( 1
u -
t
"
alness) ! (em otionality ) ! ( ra tionality ) "
( m orai t
l y ) ;
#22 #
 , :

5
4
2(X 200 8

882 5 26 77 18 29 537 , !
86
50
3
7
2 7
0
6
3
5 4
7
2
6 87
74
D
S
2

,

"

, ,

1!q
O
j 1

R o
,,-
2 0.
57 72 ,



57 75 4 " ,
2(
) 9 ,
X
0 .50 /
! !
"
-
: (08 BY Y026 )
A IP h a
A IP a
/21 1 0 ( ) "

0 .58 0 59 0 .5 8 0 .5 7
0 74 0 .74 0 .74
0 .6 2 0 .6 2 0 .6 2 0 .6 1

[l] G ia
c
n i
r
a o , C .A . & F a e io n e , P . A . A lo
o k a I.
c o
s s fo ur y ea l

0 .50 0 .79 0 .79 at th e di spo sition tow ard eri tieal th ink i m g un deradua
te

0 .50 0 .4 8 0 .5
0 0 51 s =J
studen
t ] . J
o
o
f
n,2(
) l(50 ).
X
0.6
8 0.7
2 0.70 12 8 F ae io
e
n , P .A . , F
a c
i e, N .C . & i c ", C . A . Th e
G
0 , 5 O , 55 0 . 62 0 .5 7

di s siti on tow ald eri ti eal th ink in g : Its eharac ter , m ea

s ur
e -
0 .55 0 .55 0 .5 6 0 .5 4
0.6
4 0.6
5 0.65
0 "5 0 0 .4 , 0 51 0 .5 1 m ent , and re lati onship to eri tie th ink ing skill =J 8.
b
I ID
g ie , 2(2
0 ).
[3 ] Pac ion e , P .A . , F ac ione , N .C . & G ian cari o , C . A . CU
i-
) 9 " 8 ,
6 2(
X
o ~
f C
in O -n : -eOr
k i D , P y M dn
-
/ 0 (0.6 2 )
ual [M 8. Cal ifo m ia: Th e Cal ifo mi a A ead em ie Pre ss,200 1
(0 .5
5 ) (0 .57 ) , 7
, . 5 6
F
s
e
L
.
J
I
J,.I

j-
4q
U
0 . 1 0 .2 " 4
=J2. ,2(
) 1(3).
X
, Al p ha , 0 . 1 0 .2 " , , ,.
, =J
] . ,2(
X (39
) .
" , , , .
1J 2. ,2(X (1).
S tu d y o f th e R e liab ility of C r
i tie a l T h in k in g D isP o sitio n In v e n to r
y
fo r C h in e se C o lle g e S tu d e n ts

, Qiu, , - n
, in
z
g ra n 8, / v Ya n, ing.
, z0 Ca i C Ha i
me i,
( 1. N ational R ese arc h C entre fo r Fore i, U n, age E dueation ; B eij ing F ore i S tu dies U nivers ity ;
B eijing l 5XX)89 , C hina ; 2 . Fo re i n, e D epart m ent, X inzhou T eaehers . U nivers ity , X inzhou 034 (X, C hina ;
3 . D epar
t m e n t of Fo re i, U n a ge T e a eh in g an d R e se a
r e h , H e b e i U n iv eity , B a od in g 0 7 1(
) 2 , C h in a :
X

4 . F
O r
e i, n a g e D ep alt m en t , Gu an 1 F in a
n e e & E e o n om ies U n ive r
s ity , N a
n n in g 5 3 0
( 3 , C h in a ;

5 . Forei, ne D epari m ent, Shan dong F

i na
n ee & P
o lities U niver
s it
y , Jina
n 250
) 14 , C hina )
(
A b str a et : T
h e p er r
e Por
t s on t
w o l e
sea
l e stu d ie s o f th e re liab ility of C ri tieal Th in k in g D ispo sitio n In v e nto fo r
C h in e se C o lleg e S tu d e n ts . T
h e f
irs t stu d y in vo lve d 2 7 7 0 stu d en ts fro m 12 u n ive rs itie s an d th e se e on d stu dy , 18 8 2 5

stu d e n ts f
o m 5 1 u n ive ities . T
r h e r
e su lts sh o w t
h at th e re v ised in stru m en t 15 re liab le an d ea n b e u sed ex te n siv e ly to

m ea
s ur
e C h in e se un ivers ity stu d en ts, e ri tieal th in k in g d isp osition .
K e
y w ord
s : C ri tieal Th in k in g S k ill s ; C ri tieal T
h in k in g D isp ositio n ; C r
itiea
l T
h in k in g D isp o sitio n In v e n to