28 views

Original Title: Design of Decoupling Controllers for an MIMO Systems

Uploaded by Ricardo Villalonga

- Standard PID Control - Manual
- 05-MathematicalReference.pdf
- A New Coordinated Control Strategy for Boiler-Turbine System of Coal-Fired Power Plant
- PID Calculation
- Pid Controller Design and Tuning
- Control Theory 11
- Analysis and Control of a Nonlinear Boiler-turbine Unit
- A Real-Time Approach to Process Controls - Preview
- Feedback and Temperature Control
- Mohd Fadzli Mohd Noris
- I_PD
- PID Self Tuner e
- cstr1.pdf
- Coreano PID Thesis
- An Introduction to Feedback Control Systems
- Cascade Control
- Lab 6 Engineering Measurement and Lab sample
- PID Presentaion
- Eee 550 – Advanced Control Systems November 2008
- IMCkomp

You are on page 1of 4

________________________________________________________________________________________________

Janani Rajaraman

Department of Electronics and Instrumentation Engineering, SCSVMV University, Tamil Nadu, India

Abstract. The main objective in this paper is to do a

comparison of various decoupling techniques used to (decentralized, centralized, decouplers control

design a PID Controllers for a binary distillation column. strategies) are manual controller strategies but they fails

These decoupling controls were simulated for set point to achieve the desired stable response because of high

tracking using MATLAB/ SIMULINK. Various methods interaction affects among control loops, improper

like Least Square Optimization, Real coded Genetic pairings, random disturbance and nonlinearity of

Algorithm, Desired Dynamic Equation are compared with dynamic systems.

Ziegler Nichols Method. Performance indices values like

Integral Absolute Error, Integral Square Error are All these effects make the system response unstable.

obtained and compared. These drawbacks can be overcome by using the hybrid

expert system based tuning methods and optimization

I. INTRODUCTION tuning methods in the literature. Various auto tuning

In Industries it is necessary to control the several output control strategies are proposed to design multi variable

by selecting various manipulated variable such a process systems such as sequential auto tuning, multivariable

is called Multi Input Multi Output (MIMO System). PID controllers. To implement optimization tuning

This multivariable system is successfully operated by control strategies to multivariablesystems required

designing PID Controllers.[1] There are various knowledge of biological rules. But auto tuning

controller methods to design MIMO Systems in controllers are very easily implemented, it contain

literature such as synthesis controller, Sliding mode several pre tuning functions. In this auto tuning function

control, Model Predictive control.[2] Due to the is very important it has automatic ability to

presence of coupling between two variables however, communicate between PID algorithm and external

many well developed closed loop control methods for devices. These auto tuning controllers are also referred

SISO system with time delay can extended to MIMO as self-tuning controllers. This paper mainly organized

system with time delay. The problem of stability gets as follows, case study of distillation column, Wood and

more complex as the result of internal coupling in Berry distillation column in Section II, Decoupling

MIMO process with time delay. This time delay impacts Strategies in Section III, Performance Indices in Section

the stability causes maximum overshoot, oscillations etc. IV, Controller Methods in Section V and MATLAB

Despite all the advanced control strategies, PI/PID simulation results and comparative study of these

Controllers are being used in most of the industries. In optimization techniques is mentioned in Section VI.

this by varying the gains of PID parameters desired

II. BINARY DISTILLATION COLUMN

output response can be achieved. Still active research

isgoing on in this area because in many cases design of Distillation is one of the most common liquid-liquid

PID controllers are poorly tuned, so as a result some separation processes, and can be carried out in a

controllers are too aggressive and some controllers are continuous or batch system. Distillation works by the

giving too sluggish output response. Now advances in application and removal of heat to exploit differences in

control theory, PID control algorithms are using in relative volatility. The heat causes components with

sophisticated control algorithms such as model lower boiling points and higher volatility to be

predictive control, are built as a supervisory control vaporized, leaving less volatile components as liquids.

algorithm, which gives set points to PID controller.PID Mixtures with high relative volatilities are easier to

controller is expressed mathematically in two forms are separate. Distillation can be used to separate binary or

given below multi-component mixtures. Many variables, such as

column pressure, temperature, size, and diameter are

P s = + + ( ) determined by the properties of the feed and the desired

products. Some specialized columns perform other

1 functions, such as reactive distillation columns, which

P s = 1+ + ( )

combine reaction and separation of products into a

single unit. Distillation column mainly consists of

Where P(s) = Controller Transfer function. reboiler, condensers and vertical columns, itself called as

________________________________________________________________________________________________

ISSN (Online): 2347-2820, Volume -4, Issue-6, 2016

18

International Journal of Electrical, Electronics and Computer Systems (IJEECS)

________________________________________________________________________________________________

the shells. Within the shell trays are available. It is used Table 1: Time Integral Performance

to increase the component separations. Reboilers are

used for enhancing transfer of mass and heat energy. It ( )

is used to provide an amount of heat for the vaporization ()

from the bottom of the column. Condensers are used to 0

condense distilled vapor. This condensed vapors ( )

collected in reflux drum and required amount is 2 ()

extracted from it.Due to load fluctuations and noise it is 0

very difficult to maintain the stability of system and (

purity of outputs. Wood and Berry Distillation column ) ()

is a 2x2 binary column which separates the methanol 0

and water. It consists of a reboiler and 8 numbers of (

trays.[4] The system process function is stated below. ) 2 ()

12.8 18.9 3 0

= 16.77

+1 21 + 1

6.6 19.4 3 V. METHODS OF CONTROLLER DESIGN

10.9 + 1 14.4 + 1

Most of the industries adopting auto tuning PID control

Overhead mole fraction methanol (y1) and bottom mole strategies because of its simple nature and easy to use.

fraction methanol (y2) are considered as the controlled In the auto tuning method PID parameters are evaluated

variables, Overhead reflux flow rate (u1), bottoms steam based on the Least Square Optimization, Real coded

flow rate (u2) are taken as manipulated variables. Genetic Algorithm,[6] and Desired Dynamic

Equation[5] are compared with Ziegler Nichols Method.

III. DECOUPLING STRATEGIES These algorithms are implemented by using MATLAB

The simulation diagram of Decoupling Controller for a simulation tool directly. To design Wood-Berry

MIMO Processes is shown in the Fig. 1 below which distillation column, the PID values used in the above

uses the technique for tuning of PID Controllers mentioned control strategies are tabulated in table 2.

parameters. In the centralized control of PID both Table 2: Tuning Parameters for Various Method

diagonal elements and off diagonal elements are

designed. [7] Method Controller Kc i d

PIDC11 0.400 0.0850 0.3

Least Square

Optimization PIDC21 0.1092 0.0238 0.3

Tuning PIDC12 0.1217 0.0866 0.3

PIDC22 0.1134 0.0680 0.3

PIDC11 0.7175 0.2368 0.7134

RGA Tuning PIDC21 0.3262 0.1204 0.1957

PIDC12 0.3698 0.0120 0.0897

PIDC22 0.0143 0.0188 0.2415

PIDC1 0.1971 0.0512 0.0992

DDE Tuning

PIDC2 0.2258 0.0387 0.1589

VI. SIMULATION RESULTS

Fig.1. Block Diagram of Decoupling PID Controller for

Consider a unit magnitude step change in first reference

a MIMO Process

at t=0 and second reference at t=150 seconds with a total

IV. PERFORMANCE INDICES time period of 300 seconds. The summarized values of

performance indices of various control strategies are

Set point tracking, regulatory response and noise tabulated in Table.3. In order to determine the better

rejection in output response are the most important one among the above tuning methods are applied for the

performance characteristics for any control of decoupling PID control of the binary distillation column,

multivariable systems. The time integral performance is for the set point tracking case the performance criteria

the major consideration for designing PID controller. Integral Absolute Error (IAE) and Integral Square Error

These time integral performances are integral of squared (ISE) of the controllers were calculated with the aid of

error (ISE), integral of time weighted square error Simulink and the results are obtained are shown in Table

(ITSE), integral of absolute value of error (IAE) and 3

integral of the time weighted absolute error (ITAE).

________________________________________________________________________________________________

ISSN (Online): 2347-2820, Volume -4, Issue-6, 2016

19

International Journal of Electrical, Electronics and Computer Systems (IJEECS)

________________________________________________________________________________________________

Time Series Plot:Y2

ISE IAE

Method

Y1 Y2 Y1 Y2 1.5

Optimization 1

(LSO)

Y2

RGA 2.722 6.921 8.16 13.8 0.5

0

system for various decoupling methods like Least

Square Optimization (LSO), RGA (Real Coded Genetic

-0.5

Algorithm) and Desired Dynamic Equation (DDE) 0 50 100 150

Time (seconds)

200 250 300

Method

The Least Square Optimization, RGA and DDE Time Series Plot:

2

algorithms are applied to design Wood and Berry binary

distillation column. Minimum values of performance 1.8

Y1

1

Time Series Plot:Y2

2 0.8

0.6

1.5 0.4

0.2

1 0

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

Y2

Time (seconds)

2

0

1.5

-0.5

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

1

Time (seconds)

Y2

2

0.5

1.8

1.6

0

1.4

1.2

-0.5

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

Y1

1 Time (seconds)

0.8

0.6

Fig.4: Closed Loop Response of Y1 and Y2 by DDE

Method

0.4

0.2 REFERENCES

0

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

Time (seconds)

[1]. K.J. Astrom and T. Hagglund, PID Controllers:

Fig.2: Closed Loop Response of Y1 and Y2 by Least Theory, design and tuning, 2nd. ed. Instrument

Square Optimization Method Society of America 1995.

2

Time Series Plot:Y1

[2] H.E. Musch and M. Steiner, Robust PID control

1.8 for an industrial distillation column, IEEE

1.6 Control Systems, Vol 15, pp46-55, Aug 1995.

1.4

[3] W.L. Luyben, Process Modelling Simulation and

1.2

Control for Chemical Engineer. 2nd ed. McGraw-

Y1

1

Hill, New York, 1990

0.8

0.4 composition control of a binary distillation

0.2 column, Chem.Eng. Sci, Vol 28, pp. 1707-1717,

0 Sep 1973.

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

Time (seconds)

________________________________________________________________________________________________

ISSN (Online): 2347-2820, Volume -4, Issue-6, 2016

20

International Journal of Electrical, Electronics and Computer Systems (IJEECS)

________________________________________________________________________________________________

[5] Zeng-Rong Hu, Dong-Hai Li, Jing Wang, optimization tuning method, IEEE international

FengXue, Analytical Design of PID Decoupling conference on computational intelligence and

control for TITO Process with Time Delay, computing research, 2014.

Journal of Computers, Vol.6, No.6, pp. 1064-

[7] K.J. Astrom, Karl Henrik Johansson, Qing-Guo

1070, 2011

Wang, Design of Decoupled PID Controllers for

[6] CH Suresh Kumar, Design PID Controller for MIMO Systems

TITO Process Based on Least square

________________________________________________________________________________________________

ISSN (Online): 2347-2820, Volume -4, Issue-6, 2016

21

- Standard PID Control - ManualUploaded byJustin Puscasu
- 05-MathematicalReference.pdfUploaded bymirofelo
- A New Coordinated Control Strategy for Boiler-Turbine System of Coal-Fired Power PlantUploaded byBhuvanithaaKesavan
- PID CalculationUploaded byCandiano Popescu
- Pid Controller Design and TuningUploaded byGesang Rakhmad Utomo
- Control Theory 11Uploaded byfaestning
- Analysis and Control of a Nonlinear Boiler-turbine UnitUploaded byAbdullah Nur Aziz
- A Real-Time Approach to Process Controls - PreviewUploaded byZain Hami
- Feedback and Temperature ControlUploaded bynishith316
- Mohd Fadzli Mohd NorisUploaded byLao Zhu
- I_PDUploaded byAnonymous WkbmWCa8M
- PID Self Tuner eUploaded byTaha Mohammed
- cstr1.pdfUploaded byGary Kiel Palacios Espinoza
- Coreano PID ThesisUploaded byAlan
- An Introduction to Feedback Control SystemsUploaded bypandey99
- Cascade ControlUploaded byمحمد سلام
- Lab 6 Engineering Measurement and Lab sampleUploaded bytk_atiqah
- PID PresentaionUploaded byGilagidkid
- Eee 550 – Advanced Control Systems November 2008Uploaded byKumaraguru Rau
- IMCkompUploaded bySertug Başar
- Controller TuningUploaded byAnonymous 0zrCNQ
- [IJCT-V2I3P19] Authors : Galal Ali HassaanUploaded byIjctJournals
- An Advanced LFC Design ConsideringUploaded byAhmed58seribegawan
- chap1Uploaded byMaria Agustin Taolin
- Student Version Merged- Process Control Short Lecture 2013Uploaded byDiogo
- Exercises 160912Uploaded bymartin
- Instrumentation and Control EXP - 3Uploaded byRashail Ashas
- 06820549Uploaded bydebasishmee5808
- Turbo Kat RacersUploaded byMadhusudhanan Ravi
- 06690237Uploaded byAnjireddy Thatiparthy

- Connectivity Options between Honeywell® and DeltaV™ SystemsUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Cuckoo Search - WikipediaUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Particle Swarm Optimization - WikipediaUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Matlab y SimulinkUploaded byDae Hyun Kim
- Crane Engineering Valve Terminology GlossaryUploaded byharoon_siyech_engg
- Gas TurbineUploaded bytamson19071978
- Digital Control Systems (2015)Uploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Process Dynamics and Control. 2nd Edition - Dale E. Seborg (2003)Uploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- ActuatorsUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- CircuitsUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Linear–Quadratic Regulator (LQR) - WikipediaUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- H-Infinity Methods in Control Theory - Wikipedia.pdfUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Manómetro Ashcroft 45-1279-09LUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Manómetro Ashcroft 45-1279-02BUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- System Identification - WikipediaUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- H-Infinity Methods in Control Theory - WikipediaUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- IntroCircuitDiagramsUploaded byMuhammad Saqib
- Manómetro Ashcroft 45-1279-04L-X56Uploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- RotationUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- TransferUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- BodeUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- PowerandEnergyUploaded byMuhammad Saqib
- FeedbackUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- CalculusUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- analog.pptUploaded byRicardo Villalonga
- Lecture Slides 1-1Module1OverviewUploaded byNestor Plasencia Prado
- Lecture Slides LinearCircuitsIntroductionUploaded byCesar Santiago Bolaño Salazar

- 10.1.1.1001.9483.pdfUploaded bysaeed
- Modeling of ExtractorUploaded byDilip Katekar
- Prezentare Tehnici de Evaluare RiscUploaded byMihai Caraiman
- Dr Amir Mosavi Receives the UNESCO Young Scientist AwardUploaded byAmir Mosavi
- Chemical Engineering Thermodynamics Final ExaminationUploaded bykevidread
- mixed non integer programmingUploaded bysunilbhardwajblb2392
- excerptDUploaded byEugenio Manghesi
- Anomaly Network Intrusion Detection System BasedUploaded bysunil_sanver
- Water FalUploaded byHuma Zainab
- lectures for cam and automationUploaded bysai vamsi
- Chapter 2 - Introduction to Object-Oriented Systems Analysis and Design With Unified Modeling Language(2)Uploaded byChen Zhi Hong
- ece5655_chap10Uploaded byhariharankalyan
- Identification of Nonlinear Predictor and Simulator Models of a Cement Rotary Kiln by Locally Linear Neuro Fuzzy TechniqueUploaded byRa Him
- ch01 (3)Uploaded bymaheshonline99
- CURRENT TRENDS IN INDUSTRIAL AUTOMATIONUploaded byAnkur Ajmani
- AgileUploaded byRajat Bal
- SMM SyllabusUploaded byNAGARJUNA
- systems-analysis-and-design.pdfUploaded byFaraz Pasha
- Data Question Papers Third It TqmUploaded bymkkaran90
- Control System PresentationUploaded byJosh King
- Lecture3 FlatUploaded byShubham
- ch-1_Why we model.pptUploaded bybhargavi
- lec_3.4Uploaded bySandeep Reddy Kankanala
- Covey's 7 HabitsUploaded byscribdddddddddddd
- The Human Importance of the Intelligence Explosion (Eliezer Yudkowsky, SSS)Uploaded byA Roy
- [EE3101] Laboratory 2 ReportUploaded by94747
- 0008- fish culture automation with auto pumping, temperature control and food feeding.docUploaded byPrasad Rao
- Introduction to RBMUploaded byEmmanuel Mecanosaurio
- SRV02 Exp4 Flexible JointUploaded byK-rolina Meneses
- bytronic_sistemUploaded bySedat Iriç