You are on page 1of 7

Ehrenfest

Paul Ehrenfest

Born: 18 Jan 1880 in Vienna, Austria


Died: 25 Sept 1933 in Leiden, Netherlands

Click the picture above


to see two larger pictures

Show birthplace location

Previous (Chronologically) Next Biographies Index

Previous (Alphabetically) Next Main index

Paul Ehrenfest's father, Sigmund Ehrenfest, came from a poor Jewish family. He was working in a
weaving mill in the Jewish village of Loschwitz in Moravia when he married Johanna Jellinek. After the
marriage they moved to Vienna where they set up a grocery business which fared rather well. They had
five children who survived birth, and Paul was the youngest, having four older brothers Arthur, Emil,
Hugo, and Otto. Johanna Ehrenfest worked long hours in their shop and Paul was looked after at home
by a nursemaid.

As a child Paul's health was poor. He was sickly, had dizzy spells, and suffered frequent nosebleeds. He
suffered from anti-Semitic comments from other children in the neighbourhood but his brothers
supported him strongly and played an important role in his childhood. His oldest brother was twenty-two
years old by the time Paul was five and it was through his brothers that Paul became interested in
education. They gave him puzzles which he enjoyed solving.

By the time he was six years old Paul could read, write and count. Mostly he had taught himself these
things, helped a little by his mother, and encouraged by his brothers. At this age, in 1886, he began to
attend primary school, moving to a different primary school in 1888. He was introduced to science and

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (1 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]


Ehrenfest

mathematics by his brothers, rather than from his school, and their attitude was one which would have
quite an influence on him [2]:-

This early impression of science as something to be learned with joy, something to be


discussed and argued about, was absorbed into Ehrenfest's innermost being.

He completed his primary schooling in 1890 and his school reports show that it had been a very
successful time academically with top marks in all his subjects, but already his life was becoming
unhappy. His mother who had been ill for some time died of breast cancer in 1890. Paul's father was also
in poor health, suffering from stomach ulcers. Soon after Johanna 's death Paul's father married again, his
second wife being Josephine Jellinek, his first wife's younger sister. Josephine was about the same age as
Paul's oldest brother.

In 1890 Paul began his secondary education at the Akademisches Gymnasium. Perhaps not surprisingly
given his problems at home his performance at school deteriorated greatly, both his marks and his
behaviour. The only subject he continued to excel in was mathematics. Clearly he was an unhappy child
[2]:-

He was often miserable, deeply depressed and at odds with himself and the world.

Life did not get better, for when he was sixteen years old his father died from the stomach trouble which
had got progressively worse for many years. Arthur, his oldest brother, became his guardian and
managed to persuade Paul not to leave school as he wished to do. Things got somewhat better [2]:-

Paul was apparently able to work himself out of his depression, which had sometimes been
deep enough to make him contemplate suicide. His intellectual interests grew stronger,
perhaps as a form of self-protection.

In the summer of 1899 Ehrenfest successfully took his school examinations, but his experiences of
school had been decidedly negative as he showed later in life when he insisted that his own children were
educated at home. Ehrenfest became a student at the Technische Hochschule in Vienna in October 1999.
There he formed a close friendship with three other students of mathematics, Heinrich Tietze, Hans Hahn
and Herglotz. They called themselves the 'inseparable four'. Ehrenfest attended Boltzmann's lectures on
the mechanical theory of heat during 1899-1900. Suddenly, thanks mainly to Boltzmann, the negative
thoughts about education which he had at school were replaced with a great love for mathematics and
physics.

As was the custom at the time, students in Austria and Germany did not usually stay at a single university
for their whole undergraduate course. In 1901 Ehrenfest moved to Gttingen where he studied under
Klein and Hilbert. There he took Max Abraham's course on the electromagnetic theory of light and also
attended courses by Stark, Walther Nernst, Schwarzschild and Zermelo. While attending courses by

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (2 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]


Ehrenfest

Klein and Hilbert, Ehrenfest saw a young Russian student of mathematics Tatyana Alexeyevna
Afnassjewa. He wondered why she did not come to meetings of the mathematics club but then
discovered that the reason was that women were not allowed to attend. Ehrenfest challenged this rule
and, after quite a battle, was able to get the rule changed. It was the beginning of their friendship which
led eventually to their marriage.

Ehrenfest returned to Vienna after spending eighteen months in Gttingen. He obtained his doctorate
from Vienna in 1904, under Boltzmann's supervision, on a topic in classical mechanics The motion of
rigid bodies in fluids and the mechanics of Hertz. It was considered a good piece of work but Ehrenfest
himself never rated it very highly and chose not to publish it after receiving his doctorate on 23 June
1904. After this Tatyana came from Gttingen to join Ehrenfest in Vienna and they married after
overcoming the severe problem of having different faiths. Each had to renounce their religion before the
marriage was allowed - it took place on 21 December 1904.

In 1905 Ehrenfest published a paper on Planck's theory of black-body radiation. It [2]:-

... shows Ehrenfest's real interests and particular talents and the beginning of his personal
style.

He remained at Vienna but without a post. He returned to Gttingen in September 1906, hoping there
might be a position available but there was not. He was shocked to learn, however, that Boltzmann had
committed suicide on 6 September. Ehrenfest took on the task of writing his obituary. Klein, Hilbert,
Minkowski and Carathodory were all working in Gttingen at this time and it was an important period
for Ehrenfest's research. Klein asked him to write, jointly with his wife if he wished, an article on
statistical mechanics. The two Ehrenfests began working on the article which would not appear in print
until 1911.

In 1907 Ehrenfest went to St Petersburg. It was not that he had a post there but his wife was Russian and
the move was probably aimed at finding somewhere where they could feel at home. Certainly Ehrenfest
had mixed feelings about his own country given the anti-Semitic attitudes he had encountered. Once in St
Petersburg he made contact with Tamarkin, Friedmann, Steklov and other mathematicians and physicists.

The Ehrenfests spent five years in St Petersburg. It was a time when Ehrenfest was deeply engrossed in
research problems. Together with his wife he worked on the review article on statistical mechanics which
took longer to complete than expected. He corresponded with Klein who told him that what was required
was a survey, not a complete solution of all the problems of the subject by Ehrenfest himself. In the hope
that this might lead to an academic post Ehrenfest, despite holding a doctorate, took the degree of Master
of Physics at St Petersburg. He was successful in obtaining the degree but not the academic post for
which he hoped. He tried to find a position by writing to many institutions, including some in North
America, but nothing came of any of his enquiries.

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (3 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]


Ehrenfest

An important paper was published by Ehrenfest in 1911 in Annalen der Physik on the essential features
of quantum theory. In January 1912 Ehrenfest set out on a tour of universities in the German speaking
world in the hope of a position. He visited Berlin where he saw Planck, Leipzig where he saw his old
friend Herglotz, Munich where he met Sommerfeld, then Zurich, Vienna, and Prague where he met
Einstein for the first time. On his travels he learnt that Poincar had written a paper on quantum theory
which gave similar results to those in his Annalen der Physik paper. Poincar had not known of
Ehrenfest's contribution and therefore had not referred to his work.

Ehrenfest returned to St Petersburg saddened that Poincar's paper had been published before he could
point out his own contribution to him - he was paying the price for being isolated from mainstream
research in St Petersburg. However, his fortunes were about to change. Lorentz was looking for someone
to succeed to his chair at Leiden. Sommerfeld recommended Ehrenfest, writing (see [2]):-

He lectures like a master. I have hardly ever heard a man speak with such fascination and
brilliance. Significant phrases, witty points and dialectic are all at his disposal in an
extraordinary manner ... He knows how to make the most difficult things concrete and
intuitively clear. Mathematical arguments are translated by him into easily
comprehensible pictures.

On 29 September 1912 Ehrenfest received a telegram saying that he had been name professor at Leiden.
He remained at Leiden for the rest of his career. We examine now some of the contributions which he
made while working there.

In 1917 and 1920 Ehrenfest published papers investigating the problem of the extent to which the three-
dimensional nature of physical space is determined by the structure of basic physical equations or is
reflected in these basic equations. Ehrenfest's arguments were based both on Newton's celestial
mechanics and also on Einstein's relativity theory.

Among Ehrenfest's contribution to quantum statistics was an understanding of the nature of photons, and
their properties which were implied by Planck's radiation law. He worked on quantum theory applying it
to rotating bodies. He recognised that Ampre's molecular currents are incompatible with classical
statistical mechanics. He proposed a model of diffusion in order to illuminate the statistical interpretation
of the second law of thermodynamics, that the entropy of a closed system can only increase. The modern
theory of nonequilibrium thermodynamics brings together the molecular, collisional ideas of Boltzmann
with the statistical ideas of Ehrenfest's to give a nonlinear, statistical theory.

In 1933 Ehrenfest presented a classification of phase transitions based on the discontinuity in derivatives
of the free energy function.

Uhlenbeck was a student of Ehrenfest who began research for his Master's degree in 1920. He spoke of
Ehrenfest's teaching style [9]:-

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (4 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]


Ehrenfest

First the assertion, then the proof ... His famous clarity [should] not to be confused with
rigour. ... He never gave of made problems; he did not believe in them; in his opinion the
only problems worth considering were those you proposed yourself. ... He worked with
essentially one student at a time, and that practically every afternoon during the week.

As to Ehrenfest's mathematical skills, Uhlenbeck wrote [9]:-

Although he knew mathematics it was not simple for him. He was not a computer. He could
not compute.

Pais writes about Ehrenfest's lectures in the early 1920s [10]:-

Ehrenfest's graduate lectures consisted of a two-year course: Maxwell theory, ending with
the theory of electrons and some relativity, one year; and statistical mechanics, ending
with atomic structure and quantum theory the other.

In 1925 when quantum mechanics began to dominate work in theoretical physics, Ehrenfest felt he had
problems [9]:-

I think he always hated it. All these youngsters who had, with great facility, made these
calculations ... and you didn't have to understand much. You just computed and you did
this and you did that and everything came out ... There was, therefore, a mathematical
apparatus built with Hilbert's basis, with operators, which had a sort of abstractness. It
was so against his creed that I'm sure he suffered from it. ... he understood it all alright.
He said he was just too old. It was against his creed to really take part in it.

Niels Bohr and Ehrenfest began to correspond in 1918. When they met in Leiden [7]:-

[Ehrenfest] and Bohr had much to talk about together -- from the current problems of
quantum theory to the Icelandic sagas, from the stages of a child's development to the
difference between genuine physicists and the other. Their exchanges ranged over heaven
and earth as Ehrenfest showed his new friend the treasures of the Dutch museums and the
brilliant colours of the bulb fields.

Ehrenfest presented Bohr's results to the third Solvay conference in 1921. Bohr did not attend through
overwork. Later in 1921 Bohr invited Ehrenfest to Copenhagen. He replied:-

Dear, dear Bohr, I would like so terribly much to be with you again.

Ehrenfest was unhappy at the disagreement between Bohr and Einstein over quantum theory. He brought

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (5 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]


Ehrenfest

them together at his home in Leiden in December 1925 in an attempt to have them reach an agreed
position. They did not and Ehrenfest was very unhappy that he was forced to take sides with one of his
two close friends. He said in 1927, while in tears, that forced to make a choice he would have to agree
with Bohr.

May 1931 Ehrenfest wrote to Bohr [3]:-

I have completely lost contact with theoretical physics. I cannot read anything any more
and feel myself incompetent to have even the most modest grasp about what makes sense in
the flood of articles and books. Perhaps I cannot at all be helped any more.

All through his life Ehrenfest had suffered from low self esteem, which was in marked contrast to the
high esteem in which he was held by his fellow scientists. He was also greatly saddened by his son
Wassik being a mongol and having severe problems both physically and mentally.

His last letter (which was never sent) is a sad document (see for example [3]):-

My dear friends: Bohr, Einstein, Franck, Herglotz, Joff, Kohnstamm, and Tolman!
I absolutely do not know any more how to carry further during the next few months the burden of my life
which has become unbearable. I cannot stand it any longer to let my professorship in Leiden go down the
drain. I must vacate my position here. Perhaps it may happen that I can use up the rest of my strength in
Russia. .. If, however, it will not become clear rather soon that I can do that, then it is as good as certain
that I shall kill myself. And if that will happen some time then I should like to know that I have written,
calmly and without rush, to you whose friendship has played such a great role in my life. ...
In recent years it has become ever more difficult for me to follow the developments in physics with
understanding. After trying, ever more enervated and torn, I have finally given up in desperation. This
made me completely weary of life .. I did feel condemned to live on mainly because of the economic cares
for the children. I tried other things but that helps only briefly. Therefore I concentrate more and more
on the precise details of suicide. I have no other practical possibility than suicide, and that after having
first killed Wassik. Forgive me ...
May you and those dear to you stay well.

This letter, and a similar letter which he wrote to his students, was never sent. Ehrenfest shot Wassik in
the waiting room of the Professor Watering Institute in Amsterdam where Wassik was being treated.
Then he shot himself. The Dutch papers only reported his sudden death and gave lengthy accounts of his
achievements.

Einstein said of Ehrenfest [2] that he was:-

He was not merely the best teacher in our profession whom I have ever known; he was
also passionately preoccupied with the development and destiny of men, especially his
students. To understand others, to gain their friendship and trust, to aid anyone embroiled

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (6 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]


Ehrenfest

in outer or inner struggles, to encourage youthful talent - all this was his real element,
almost more than his emersion in scientific problems.

Article by: J J O'Connor and E F Robertson

Click on this link to see a list of the Glossary entries for this page

List of References (10 books/articles)

Mathematicians born in the same


country

Cross-references to History Topics General relativity

Previous (Chronologically) Next Biographies Index


Previous (Alphabetically) Next Main index
History Topics Societies, honours, etc. Famous curves
Time lines Birthplace maps Chronology Search Form
Glossary index Quotations index Poster index
Mathematicians of the day Anniversaries for the year

JOC/EFR May 2001 School_of_Mathematics_and_Statistics


University_of_St_Andrews,_Scotland
The URL of this page is:
http://www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html

http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/history/Mathematicians/Ehrenfest.html (7 of 7) [23/08/2002 11:06:23]