You are on page 1of 24

PRRAC Poverty & Race

POVERTY & RACE RESEARCH ACTION COUNCIL


July/August 2011 Volume 20: Number 4

Why Racial Integration Remains an Imperative


by Elizabeth Anderson
I n 1988, I needed to move from they did not constitute either the domi- ness; or welfare reform; or a deter-
Ann Arbor to the Detroit area to spare nant or, in aggregate effect, the most mined effort within minority commu-
my partner, a sleep-deprived resident damaging mode of undesirable racial nities to change dysfunctional social
at Henry Ford Hospital, a significant interactions on campus. More perva- norms associated with the culture of
commute to work. As I searched for sive, insidious and cumulatively dam- poverty. As this list demonstrates,
housing, I observed stark patterns of aging were subtler patterns of racial avoidance of integration is found
racial segregation, openly enforced by discomfort, alienation, and ignorant across the whole American political
landlords who assured me, a white and cloddish interaction, such as class- spectrum. The Imperative of Integra-
woman then in her late twenties, that room dynamics in which white stu- tion argues that all of these purported
I had no reason to worry about rent- dents focused on problems and griev- remedies for racial injustice rest on
ing there since were holding the line ances peculiar to them, ignored what the illusion that racial justice can be
against blacks at 10 Mile Road. One black students were saying, or ex- achieved without racial integration.
of them showed me a home with a pressed insulting assumptions about Readers of Poverty & Race are fa-
pile of cockroaches in the kitchen. them. I wondered whether there was miliar with the deep and pervasive
Landlords in the metro area were con- a connection between the extreme resi- racial segregation in the U.S., espe-
fident that whites would rather live dential racial segregation in Michigan cially of blacks from whites, which
with cockroaches as housemates than and the toxic patterns of interracial was caused and is currently main-
with blacks as neighbors. interaction I observed at the univer- tained by public policies such as zon-
We decided to rent a house in South sity, where many students were func- ing, massive housing discrimination
Rosedale Park, a stable working-class tioning in a multiracial setting for the and white flight, and which generates
Detroit neighborhood that was about first time. profound economic inequalities. Seg-
80% black. It was a model of cordial My investigations led me to write regation isolates blacks from access
race relations. Matters were different my book, The Imperative of Integra- to job opportunities, retail outlets, and
in my place of employment, the Uni- tion, which focuses primarily (but not commercial and professional services.
versity of Michigan in Ann Arbor. At exclusively) on black-white segrega- (Please turn to page 2)
the time, a rash of racially hostile in- tion. Since the end of concerted ef-
cidents targeting black, Latino, Na- forts to enforce Brown v. Board of
tive American and Asian students was Education in the 1980s, activists, poli-
raising alarms. Although overtly rac- ticians, pundits, scholars and the CONTENTS:
ist incidents got the most publicity, American public have advocated non-
integrative paths to racial justice. Integration ................ 1
Racial justice, we are told, can be Health Impact
Elizabeth Anderson (eandersn@ achieved through multiculturalist cel- Assessment ............. 3
umich.edu) is John Rawls Collegiate ebrations of racial diversity; or equal Asian American et al.
Professor of Philosophy and Womens economic investments in de facto seg- Health Equity ........... 7
Studies at the Univ. of Michigan, Ann regated schools and neighborhoods; Model Neighborhood
Arbor. She prepared this prcis from or a focus on poverty rather than race; Health Center ......... 13
her 2010 book, The Imperative of In- or more rigorous enforcement of anti- Resources ................ 19
tegration (Princeton Univ. Press). discrimination law; or color-blind-

Poverty & Race Research Action Council 1200 18th Street NW Suite 200 Washington, DC 20036
202/906-8023 FAX: 202/842-2885 E-mail: info@prrac.org www.prrac.org
Recycled Paper
(INTEGRATION: Continued from page 1) uting material goods across space. those with whom one associates, in-
More fundamentally, segregation con- duces self-segregated groups to draw
It deprives them of access to public sists of the whole range of social prac- invidious comparisons between them-
goods, including decent public schools tices that groups with privileged ac- selves and the groups from which they
and adequate law enforcement, while cess to important goods use to close are isolated. They create worldviews
subjecting them to higher tax burdens, ranks to maintain their privileges. This that are impervious to counterevidence
concentrated poverty, urban blight, includes role segregation, where dif- held by members of out-groups with
pollution and crime. This depresses ferent groups interact, but on terms whom they have little contact. They
housing values and impedes blacks of domination and subordination. tend to view extreme and deviant be-
ability to accumulate financial and Everyone knows that who you haviors of out-group members, such
human capital. If the effects of segre- know is as important as what you as violent crimes, as representative of
gation were confined to such material know in getting access to opportuni- the out-group. Role segregation also
outcomes, we could imagine that some ties. This idea captures the social capi- creates stereotypes that reinforce out-
combination of non-integrative left- tal effects of racial segregation. In seg- group disadvantage. Peoples stereo-
liberal remediescolor-blind anti- types of who is suited to privileged
poverty programs, economic invest- Avoidance of integra- positions incorporate the social iden-
ment in disadvantaged neighborhoods, tities of those who already occupy
tion is found across the them. Occupation of dominant posi-
vigorous enforcement of anti-discrimi-
nation law, and multiculturalist rem-
whole American politi- tions also tends to make people prone
edies to remaining discrimination cal spectrum. to stereotype their subordinates, be-
could overcome racial inequality. cause dominant players can afford to
regated societies, news about and re- be ignorant of the ways their subordi-
ferrals to educational and job oppor- nates deviate from stereotype.
Non-Integrationist tunities preferentially circulate within Popular understandings of racial
Remedies Are the groups that already predominate stigma and how it works lead people
Insufficient in a given institution, keeping disad- to drastically underestimate its extent
vantaged groups off or at the back of and harmful effects. We imagine ra-
Such non-integrationist remedies the queue. Cultural capital also mat- cially stigmatizing ideas as con-
are insufficient because they fail to ters: Even when the gatekeepers to sciously located in the minds of ex-
address the full range of effects of important opportunities do not inten- treme racists. Think of the KKK mem-
segregation on group inequality. The tionally practice racial discrimination, ber who claims that blacks are bio-
Imperative of Integration documents they often select applicants by their logically inferior and threatening
three additional effects that can only fit with the informal, unspoken and to whites, proclaims his hatred of
be undone through integration: social/ untaught norms of speech, bodily them, and discriminates against them
cultural capital inequality, racial stig- comportment, dress, personal style out of sheer prejudice. Most Ameri-
matization, and anti-democratic ef- and cultural interests that already pre- cans despise such extremists, disavow
fects. These effects recognize that seg- vail in an institution. Mutually isolated explicitly racist ideas, and sincerely
regation isnt only geographic, and so communities tend to drift apart cul- think of themselves as not racist. Most
cant be undone simply by redistrib- turally, and thereby undermine dis- say that racial discrimination is wrong.
advantaged groups accumulation of It is tempting to conclude that nega-
Poverty and Race (ISSN 1075- the cultural capital needed for ad- tive images of blacks are no longer a
3591) is published six times a year by vancement. Integration is needed to potent force in American life.
the Poverty & Race Research Action remedy these inequalities. Tempting, but wrong. While the
Council, 1200 18th Street NW, Suite Segregation also stigmatizes the old racist images of black biological
200, Washington, DC 20036, 202/906- disadvantaged. When social groups inferiority may have faded, they have
8023, fax: 202/842-2885, E-mail:
info@prrac.org. Chester Hartman, diverge in material and social advan- been replaced by new ones. Now
Editor. Subscriptions are $25/year, tages, people form corresponding many whites tend to see blacks as
$45/two years. Foreign postage extra. group stereotypes and tell stories to choosing badly, as undermining them-
Articles, article suggestions, letters and explain these differences. These sto- selves with culturally dysfunctional
general comments are welcome, as are ries add insult to injury, because norms of single parenthood, welfare
notices of publications, conferences,
job openings, etc. for our Resources people tend to attribute a groups dis- dependency, criminality, and poor
Section. Articles generally may be re- advantages to supposedly intrinsic attachment to school and work. Since,
printed, providing PRRAC gives ad- deficits in its abilities, character or on this view, blacks are perfectly ca-
vance permission. culture rather than to its external cir- pable of solving their own problems
Copyright 2011 by the Poverty cumstances. Spatial segregation rein- if they would only try, neither whites
& Race Research Action Council. All
rights reserved. forces these demeaning stories. Eth- nor the government owe them any-
nocentrism, or favoritism towards (Please turn to page 17)

2 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


Understanding Health Impact Assessment: A Tool
for Addressing Health Disparities
by Saneta DeVuono-powell & Jonathan Heller
H ealth is a big topic of concern ties have the worst life expectancy and A Health Impact Assessment is de-
these days. Despite outspending all mortality rates. Studies repeatedly fined as a combination of procedures,
other developed nations on health show that even when you control for methods and tools that systematically
care, our nation ranks 26th in life ex- individual variables, external factors judges the potential, and sometimes
pectancy. In recent years, we have like where people live, the quality of unintended, effects of a proposed
witnessed growing obesity, diabetes their housing and education, income project, plan or policy on the health
and asthma rates, in addition to nu- attainment and stress levels correlate of a population and the distribution
merous other health problems. Not with depression, chronic disease, of those effects within the population.
surprisingly, these health problems mortality and health risk behaviors. HIA aims to increase the consideration
have a disparate impact on vulnerable Given this knowledge, health advo- of health in decision-making arenas
communities, with people of color and cates have begun to realize that they that typically do not consider health.
those in poverty bearing a dispropor- cannot improve health conditions HIA also identifies appropriate actions
tionate health burden. For example, to manage those effects. There are two
infant mortality rates for African desired outcomes of an HIA. One is
Americans are more than twice the
HIA addresses the to influence plans policies and projects
national average, and the life expect- determinants of health. in a way that improves health and di-
ancy gap between poor African- minishes health disparities. The other
American men and affluent white without addressing these factors, is to engage community members and
women is more than 14 years. For which are known in public health other stakeholders so they understand
advocates who work with these com- circles as the social determinants of what is impacting community health
munities, health disparities are not health. Health Impact Assessment and how to advocate for improving
new. What is new is the emerging (HIA) is a tool that can help highlight health using a transparent and evi-
consensus that health outcomes will these links and mitigate health dispari- dence-based process.
not improve unless we address social ties because HIA addresses these de- A typical HIA includes six steps:
and environmental factors tradition- terminants of health. Although HIA 1. ScreeningDetermines the need,
ally understood as unrelated to health. has been practiced outside of the value and feasibility of an HIA;
Improving access to health care and United States for many years, its use 2. ScopingDetermines which health
trying to change behaviors are not here is just beginning to gain traction. impacts to evaluate, the methods
enough; we must address the decisions In 2007, a study found just 27 HIAs for analysis, and the workplan for
and policies that are not traditionally had been conducted in the U.S. In the completing the assessment;
thought of as associated with health. subsequent four years, an additional 3. AssessmentProvides: a) a profile
For the past few decades, public 92 HIAs have begun or been com- of existing health conditions; b)
health agencies focused on trying to pleted. (Please turn to page 4)
improve health by addressing indi-
vidual behavior related to poor health
outcomes. At the same time, social
and economic inequalities continued The Relationship between HIA and Environmental
to increase and we witnessed grow- Impact Assessment (EIA)
ing and persistent health disparities.
Today, the life expectancy gap be- The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 (42
tween the most and least affluent is U.S.C.4321 et seq.) requires that proposed federal activities consider
increasing, and the areas with the the environment and establishes Environmental Impact Assessment as the
greatest social and economic inequali- mechanism for doing so. Although NEPA requires health to be consid-
ered in EIA, too often health is not evaluated meaningfully as part of the
process. HIA can complement EIA either by integrating HIA into EIA, as
Saneta DeVuono-powell (saneta@ has been done, for example, in Alaska, or as a stand-alone process and
humanimpact.org) is a Research As- report that is submitted as commentary on the EIA. Unlike EIA, barring
sociate at Human Impact Partners. a few limited State examples, no legislative requirements trigger HIA, so
Jonathan Heller (jch@human the EIA process is a good entry point, enabling HIA to elevate health
impact.org) co-founded Human Im- concerns.
pact Partners in 2006.

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 3


(HIA: Continued from page 3) local residents led local organizations were spending more than the recom-
to decide to conduct a rapid Health mended 30% of their income on rent
evaluation of potential health im- Impact Assessment. The HIA, con- and 25% were spending more than
pacts; ducted by East Yard Communities for 50% of their incomes on rent, and that
4. RecommendationsProvides strat- Environmental Justice, Californians overcrowding was already a problem
egies to manage identified adverse for Justice and Human Impact Part- in Long Beach. Not surprisingly, the
health impacts or enhance positive ners (HIPan Oakland-based non- rates of asthma, heart disease and
health impacts; profit) in early 2011, focused on mea- other health issues (which can be re-
5. ReportingIncludes development suring what impacts the proposed plan lated back to housing cost and quality
of the HIA report and communica- would have on housing and employ- and to jobs) in Long Beach are sig-
tion of findings and recommenda- ment and how these changes would nificantly higher than the county av-
tions; and affect the health of residents. Because erage.
6. MonitoringTracks impacts on the advocates wanted to be able to use The HIA findings indicated that, as
decision-making processes and the the HIA to respond the Draft Envi- proposed, the Downtown Plan was
decision, as well as impacts of the ronmental Impact Report (EIR), there likely to have negative impacts on a
decision on health determinants. variety of health-related indicators,
including: overcrowding, population
Within this general framework, ap- A typical HIA includes displacement and unemployment. The
proaches to HIA vary as HIAs are tai- six steps. HIA also found that the adoption of
lored to work with the specific needs, the proposed Community Benefits
timeline and resources of each par- was a short timeline. This necessarily Agreement would mitigate some of the
ticular project. This article briefly limited the scope of the HIA, but it negative impacts resulting from the
describes two HIAs as examples of was still a useful tool for concerned proposed Downtown Plan by provid-
how and when an HIA can be con- community advocates and local orga- ing additional very-low-income and
ducted and then discusses strategies nizations. Fortunately, there was a moderate-income housing units and
for using HIA to address health dis- proposed Community Benefits Agree- increasing employment opportunities.
parities. ment, which allowed the HIA to fo- The HIA recommended that the plan
cus its recommendations as well as adopt these benefits. The HIA in Long
point to a specific and feasible alter- Beach was in response to a city de-
Case 1: Long Beach native course of action. Over a three- velopment plan, was submitted as a
Downtown Develop- month period, staff worked together comment on a Draft Environmental
ment Plan to gather data on: (1) existing health, Impact Report, and was limited in
housing and employment conditions scope to impacts on housing and jobs.
In 2010, the City of Long Beach in in Downtown Long Beach; (2) the Findings from the rapid HIA were
Southern California proposed plans potential impacts of the proposed plan; highlighted in local media campaigns
for extensive new development in their and (3) the potential impacts of pro- focused on the proposed Downtown
downtown area. The Long Beach posed community benefits. Plan. The City of Long Beach is ex-
Downtown Plan proposed including The availability of affordable, qual- pected to respond to comments on the
5,000 new residential units, 1.5 mil- ity housing and adequate employment EIR in the coming months.
lion square feet of office, civic and opportunities have direct health im-
cultural spaces, 384,000 square feet pacts. The Long Beach HIA cited
of new retail space, and 5,200 new studies showing that the nature and Case 2: Paid Sick
jobs. The plan, however, did not men- stability of housing and employment Days Policies
tion affordable housing or job creation impact a variety of health indicators,
for the current residents of the area. including mortality rates, infectious In most developed countries, paid
This oversight was particularly disease, depression and substance sick days are a given. In the U.S.,
troublesome given the demographics abuse. Based on the analysis of the however, there is no federal law man-
of Downtown Long Beach, an area existing demographics and conditions dating paid sick days and about 4 out
that is currently populated by an eth- in Downtown Long Beach, the HIA of every 10 workers do not have paid
nically diverse and predominantly found that the diverse residents (Long sick days. Not surprisingly, low-wage
low-income population whose current Beach is the most ethnically diverse workers, mothers and those who work
employment and housing needs are not city in California) were already fac- in the food service industry are much
being met (the list for Section 8 hous- ing a shortage of quality affordable less likely to have paid sick days than
ing is currently closed and has a ten- housing and adequate employment op- most white-collar workers. In 2007,
year wait). portunities and suffering from asso- San Francisco became the first juris-
Concern about the potentially ad- ciated health problems. For example, diction in the U.S. to mandate paid
verse impacts this plan would have for the HIA found that 46% of renters sick days for employees. Subse-

4 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


quently, various jurisdictions have in-
troduced legislation that would do the By coupling the HIA with extensive legal comments on the
same, including California in 2008 environmental impact report and an economic analysis, we have
and Congress in 2009neither of proven that affordable housing and local hiring community
which passed. Surprisingly, although benefits are legally appropriate, economically feasible and
access to paid sick days has clear would improve the health of Long Beach residents.
health implications, initially health Susanne Brown, Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles
was not part of the discussion sur-
rounding efforts to mandate paid sick
days. The main frame through which
decision-makers viewed this legisla- changing the public discourse about that are informed by scientific review
tion was that of economic impact of the issue from a question of labor as well as by lived experience of com-
requiring employers to provide paid rights or employer costs to the issue munities and stakeholders, and then
sick days. of improving the health of all people. research informs whether the hypoth-
From 2008-2010, a series of Health At the same time, the HIA offered a eses are true. This process allows
Impact Assessments that looked at rationale for public health officials to those involved to think about the
paid sick day requirements were con- health of a particular community and
ducted. In 2008, an HIA of the Cali- Two complementary understand the variety of ways that
fornia Healthy Families, Healthy strategies: focus on social factors are implicated in heath.
Workplaces Act (AB 2716, entitling The HIA on the Downtown Plan
employees to accrue one hour of paid process, focus on out- in Long Beach and the HIA on paid
sick time for every 30 hours worked) comes. sick days highlight how advocates can
was completed by Human Impact Part- use a health lens. Framing the issue
ners and the San Francisco Depart- support paid sick days, a policy they of equity around health can be a very
ment of Public Health (SFDPH) at the may not have previously engaged. powerful tool. Because HIA addresses
request of the Labor Project for Work- This health framing was picked up in social determinants of health, advo-
ing Families. The following year, HIP other jurisdictions, and Milwaukee cates and communities may find that
and SFDPH conducted an HIA of the advocates used the California HIA the use of an HIA can create head-
federal Healthy Families Act of 2009. along with Milwaukee-specific data to way around a social issue. Often a
The California and Federal Paid Sick inform public opinion on a local 2008 health lens makes it more difficult for
Days HIAs looked at the potential paid sick day ballot measure. Legis- opponents to argue against address-
health outcomes for workers, families lative advocates publicized health facts ing the real needs of a community.
and communities, including impacts through the local media, and the ini- Using an HIA as a strategy for devel-
on recovery from illness, use of pre- tiative passed with the support of two- oping a health lens can be particularly
ventative health care services versus thirds of the votes of Milwaukee resi- effective because HIA is a research-
emergency rooms, as well the trans- dents. More recently, Connecticut based tool that provides scientific data
mission of infectious disease in res- became the first state to pass paid sick in addition to assessing mitigation
taurants, schools and workplaces. The days legislation. In making their ar- strategies.
HIAs found that paid sick days has gument, advocates in Connecticut fo- The differences between the two
many positive health outcomes, in- cused on the health benefits the bill above case studies highlights two
cluding: improved food safety in res- would provide. complementary strategies for using
taurants; reduced transmission of the HIA to address health disparities: fo-
flu in childcare settings and nursing cus on process, and focus on out-
homes; and reduced emergency room Strategies for Using HIA comes. Ideally, an HIA utilizes a ro-
usage. The HIAs showed that legisla- to Address Health bust process of multi-stakeholder par-
tion that would entitle more workers ticipation, and also uses robust data
to paid sick days would be good for There are a wide variety of analysis to influence the outcome of
everyones healthworkers them- projects, policies and plans where an the project it is assessing in a manner
selves, as well as people whose lives HIA can be useful, and the first step that produces good health outcomes.
are touched by the same workers. of any HIA helps determine whether However, HIA can have powerful
Paid Sick Day HIAs were used by it is an appropriate tool. Conducting impact even if it ends up being more
coalitions of proponents of the vari- an HIA requires six steps (as outlined outcome- than process-driven, or vice
ous paid sick days legislation. Al- above). During the first two steps versa.
though neither the California nor Fed- (screening and scoping), those in- In Long Beach, advocates were
eral legislation passed, the HIA helped volved assess the need for an HIA as concerned about a land use plan and
advocates articulate a public health well as which health measures to wanted a tool they could use to weigh
rationale for the policy, thereby evaluate. HIAs start with hypotheses (Please turn to page 6)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 5


(HIA: Continued from page 5) In addition to quantitative data, HIAs stakeholders to engage meaningfully.
often include community surveys or The process of the HIA can be so im-
in on an existing, fast-moving process. focus groups, which help lend a voice portant that the skills and opportuni-
Although the HIA process was impor- and credibility to concerns about the ties for advocacy it provides become
tant, given the short timelines, what issue. In the Paid Sick Days HIAs, primary goals and are as important as
mattered most was to have an impact the material gathered from focus outcome-related goals. When a group
on the proposed plan. HIA was ap- groups was useful for highlighting the of community organizations in West
pealing because it could produce an health concerns of workers, giving a Oakland decided to learn about HIA,
evidence-based report, highlighting personal voice to the issue, and for they decided to conduct a rapid HIA
potential health consequences, to sub- engaging more people in the policy- on a proposed neighborhood develop-
mit as a comment on the Draft Envi- making process. The process of gath- ment. Although they were initially
ronmental Impact Report that was ering these narratives and combining more interested in the HIA process
being prepared. In this case, this cre- them with more quantitative (e.g., sta- than in any specific outcome, during
ated a time constraint, which limited tistical) data creates a story about the the HIA they began to work with the
and therefore deemphasized the HIA people impacted by the proposed plan, developer and as a result the project
process. HIAs provide stakeholders project or policy. As this story ended up adopting many of the HIA
with multiple ways to weigh in at vari- emerges, powerful messages that can recommendations to protect future
ous stages in a decision-making pro- be used for advocacy also emerge, as residents from air pollution and pe-
cess, almost always with the goal of destrian injury from traffic.
influencing the final decision. The HIA can build capacity In another HIA conducted in Los
HIA can be used to legitimize or as- Angeles, a community organizing
suage concerns, and can offer a
and relationships. group successfully engaged commu-
mechanism to introduce recommen- nity members in data collection as well
dations or alternatives. do powerful spokespeople. Although as advocacy. The HIA, conducted on
Although HIAs are typically set up the HIAs on paid sick days did not a development project in South Cen-
in a way that allows them to have some lead to the immediate passage of new tral Los Angeles, involved multiple
impact on outcomes, there are also legislation mandating paid sick days, stakeholders, including the developer,
reasons for conducting an HIA that their impact was felt through the nar- the public health agency and the re-
focuses more on process. Through ratives that emerged during the pro- development agency from the begin-
conducting an HIA, structured oppor- cess. The health frame that was es- ning, which led the stakeholders to
tunities for capacity-building, relation- tablished through the data and per- agree to changes based on the com-
ship-building, transparent and demo- sonal stories has been picked up by munity findings. Here, the process and
cratic process (e.g., stakeholder par- other paid sick days advocates and was outcome were both considered impor-
ticipation), community organizing, used in recent legislative victories. tant, and the success of the outcome
and developing messages are avail- Because HIA is a collaborative pro- depended on the success of the pro-
able. Regardless of outcome, an HIA cess, when effectively executed it can cess.
can be useful and impactful because build capacity and relationships. HIA Another potential use of HIA is as
of these opportunities. is a tool in which multiple stakehold- a litigation tool or as a tool to prevent
Often, the process of engaging ers have an opportunity to engage, litigation. For a plaintiff, an HIA can
multiple stakeholders in HIA actually allowing for deepening relationships serve to: (1) provide notice of poten-
brings about change in the decision. but also building the capacity of these tial harm, and (2) show the feasibility
of alternatives. Alternatively, where
steps have been taken to address con-
Partial List of HIA Topics cerns raised in an HIA and recom-
Advanced Metering Initiatives Living Wage Legislation
mendations are adopted, the HIA
(Smart Metering) Metropolitan Transportation Plans could insulate projects from subse-
Agricultural Policy Natural gas pipelines quent litigation by showing that health
Area-Specific Land Use Plans Pay Equity Legislation was seriously considered and that nec-
Carbon Cap and Trade Permits for a waste facility essary steps were taken to address le-
Regulation Public Housing Redevelopment gitimate concerns. After adopting
City Growth Policies School Discipline Policies mitigations to address environmental
City Redevelopment School Funding health concerns for low-income hous-
County General Plan Updates State Budget ing raised in an HIA in Pittsburg, Cali-
Farm-to-School Legislation Transit Plans fornia, City agencies then used the
Freeway Expansion Water Conservation Laws
Housing Development
HIA to defeat NIMBY efforts to elimi-
Zoning and Land Uses for Light Rail
Housing Vouchers nate that housing.
(Please turn to page 16)

6 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


Health Equity for Asian American, Native Hawaiian,
and Pacific Islander Children and Youth: What's
Racism Got to Do With It?
by Laurin Mayeno, Joseph Keawe'aimoku Kaholokula, David MKI Liu,
Lloyd Y. Asato & Winston Tseng
Since entering high school, of children and youth of AA and NHPI cades, AA and NHPI advocates and
Kekoa, a 16-year-old obese Native communities is shaped by pervasive researchers have increased visibility
Hawaiian male with type 2 diabetes, racism in our society. While focusing for health inequities that impact their
has become depressed and taken up on the fundamental problems that con- communities. NHPI communities
cigarette smoking and drinking on a tribute to health inequities among AA have worked to have their health is-
daily basis. and NHPI children and youth, we also sues become visible and recognized
In 2007, Seung-Hui Cho, a 23- discuss the supportive role that fam- as distinct from those impacting AAs.
year-old Korean American college AA communities have worked to dis-
student with mental illness, killed 32 Hawaiis ethnic/racial pel the myth of the model minority
people and wounded many more, be- and, with the use of disaggregated
fore committing suicide.
hierarchy continues data, have demonstrated that not all
today. AAs are healthy, particularly recent
T hese are two individual examples immigrant and low-income AAs. (Na-
of health inequities that threaten the ily, community and culture can play tive Hawaiians and other Pacific Is-
well-being of Asian American (AA) in fostering their health and well-be- landers are people whose origins are
and Native Hawaiian and Pacific Is- ing. from three main groups of Islands in
lander (NHPI) children and youth. In the Pacific: Polynesia, Micronesia and
this commentary, we highlight these Melanesia. Native Hawaiians are the
health inequities and pose the ques- Disaggregating AA largest group of Pacific Islanders in
tion: "What's racism got to do with and NHPI the U.S. Other major Pacific Islander
it?" We begin by presenting data on groups in the U.S. include Samoans,
health inequities and briefly discuss NHPI and AA communities have Guamanians (Chamorro) and other
existing investigation and theory. We distinct histories, cultures, experi- Micronesian Groups (Federated State
then explore, through the stories of ences and health challenges. The ar- of Micronesia, Republic of the
Kekoa and Seung-Hui, how the health bitrary grouping together of NHPI and Marshall Islands and Republic of
AA for data collection and funding Palau). Asian Americans are persons
Laurin Mayeno (laurin@mayeno purposes creates barriers to under- with ancestry from Asian countries
consulting.com) is an independent standing and addressing their health and islands in the Pacific Rim who
consultant dedicated to building issues. Within both the NHPI and AA live in the United States. The largest
healthy multicultural organizations categories, there are numerous com- Asian-American populations are Chi-
and communities. munities whose acculturation experi- nese, Filipino, Asian Indian, Vietnam-
Joseph Keaweaimoku Kaholokula ences, socioeconomic status and ese, Korean and Japanese, each of
(kaholoku@hawaii.edu) is Assoc. health issues are very different. There- which number over 1 million. Cam-
Prof. & Chair, Dept. of Native Ha- fore, when possible, we will make bodian, Laotian, Pakistani and Hmong
waiian Health, John A. Burns School distinctions between different ethnic number over 200,000 each.) Although
of Medicine, Univ. Hawaii at Manoa. groups that fall under these broader much of the data is focused on adults,
David MKI Liu (kliumd@gmail. classifications and respect each there is recently a growing body of
com) is Medical Director of the groups cultural and classification evidence that health inequities do in-
Molokai Community Health Center. preferences. deed exist for AA and NHPI children
Lloyd Y. Asato (lasato@apiahf.org) and youth. Here are some examples:
is Director of the Community Capac-
ity Program at the Asian & Pacific Recognizing Health Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander
Islander American Health Forum. Inequities Children and Youth
Winston Tseng (wtseng@apiahf.
org) is Senior Research Associate at Before we can address AA and From 2003-2005, NHPI mothers in
the Asian & Pacific Islander Ameri- NHPI health inequities, they must be California and Hawaii had higher
can Health Forum. acknowledged. Over the past few de- (Please turn to page 8)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 7


(HEALTH EQUITY: Cont. from page 7) 28% of South Asian adolescents ism on children's health. There have
(ages 12-17) in California were di- been few studies investigating the role
rates of low birth weight and pre- agnosed with asthma in 2003-2005. of racism in children's health, includ-
term birth than Whites (4.1% LBW compared with the state average ing a few focused on racism and men-
and 7.5% pre-term birth), with (20%). tal health among AA adolescents.
rates for Marshallese mothers 30% of Filipino and 29% of Lao- Huge gaps exist in research on rac-
among the highest: low birth weight tian children (5th graders) in Cali- ism and children's health for both AA
8.4% and pre-term birth 18.8%. fornia are not within the Healthy and NHPI communities. There is a
54% of Samoan children (5th grad- Fitness Zone according to their dire need for more work on this topic
ers) in California followed by body mass index, compared to in order to document community as-
"Other" Pacific Islander (42%), Whites (23%). sets and needs, and develop effective
Guamanian (35%), Native Hawai- 36% of sexually active Chinese intervention strategies and policies.
ian (35%) and Tahitian (34%) chil- adolescents or their partner in Cali-
dren are not within the Healthy fornia, followed by Filipino (49%),
Fitness Zone according to their Korean (50%) and South Asian Theoretical Framework
body mass index, compared to the (51%) adolescents or their partner,
state average (32%) and Whites used any type of birth control the To conceptualize the role of rac-
(23%). last time they had sex, compared ism in child health, K. Sanders-
Native Hawaiian youth are also to the state average (72%) and Phillips and colleagues propose a gen-
more likely to be obese and smoke eral framework that draws from dif-
cigarettes. compared to youth of ferent theoretical models. From eco-
other ethnic groups. Cultural competency logical theory, they discuss the role
30% of NHPI adolescents (ages 12- training is critical for all of a child's immediate environment
17) in California were diagnosed service providers. (microsystem) and larger social envi-
with asthma in 2003-2005, com- ronment (macrosystem). They suggest
pared with the state average (20%). Whites (79%). that institutional racism at the macro-
In order to address these health in- system level, such as educational and
Asian-American Children and equities, there is a need to understand housing policies that put a particular
Youth the broader social framework that racial/ethnic group at a disadvantage,
shapes children's lives and health. can impact variables at the micro-
From 2003-2005, Cambodian and Some researchers have articulated that system, such as family functioning and
Laotian mothers in California and racial constructions, exposures to rac- neighborhood health conditions that
Hawaii had higher rates of both low ism, and other environmental and psy- increase behavioral and biological
birth weight (8.8% and 9.2%, re- chosocial stressors interact with bio- health risks for children of color.
spectively) and pre-term birth logical systems to increase health risks From social stratification theory, they
(14.0% and 13.7%, respectively), and problems among adults. suggest that a group's historical and
compared to Whites (4.1% LBW We next discuss existing frame- current place in the social hierarchy
and 7.5% pre-term birth). works that explore the impact of rac- can impact experiences and exposure

Table 1. Model of Racial Discrimination and Child Health


Exposure to racial Psychological and Child health outcomes and
discrimination biological responses disparities

Microsystem (individual and Psychological distress Increased risk of:


immediate environment) Low birth weight, premature
Examples: experiences of Changes in allostatic birth
racial discrimination, load Alcohol and other substance use
bullying and abuse
Violent behaviors
Chronic stress-related illnesses
Macrosystem (structural
(diabetes, cardiovascular disease,
level)
hypertension and others)
Examples: educational Susceptibility to infectious
practices, negative images disease
in media

8 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


to risk factors. From theories of ra- ents and three siblings and attends a
cial inequality and social integration, nearby public high school in urban New on PRRACs
they posit that racial discrimination Honolulu. Website
has an impact on individuals' judg- Exposure to Racial Discrimination.
ments, decisions and behaviors. There Racism and colonialism are difficult Affirmatively Furthering Fair
are multiple resulting consequences to disentangle in the Pacific, as rac- Housing and Secondary Mortgage
for children and their parents, which ism can be considered the ideology Market Reform: Making the Con-
ultimately lead to inequities in biologi- that has informed and justified the nection (June 2011)
cal, behavioral and social functioning. contagion of colonialism across the The CERD Treaty and U.S. Civil
Protective factors mentioned in the Pacific. Kekoa's story illustrates how Rights Law (June 2011)
model include racial awareness, ra- present-day colonialism continues to
cial socialization and certain parenting structure the distribution of power, Link to the Spivack Archive, a
styles that protect against the nega- resources and money largely along searchable database of research on
tive impact of discrimination. racial and ethnic lines. His ancestors the effects of school and classroom
In the Sanders-Phillips model were dispossessed of their land and ethnic, racial and socioeconomic
(Table 1), exposure to racial discrimi- resources and became second-class composition on student outcomes,
nation at both the microsystem and citizens in Hawaiis ethnic/racial hi- developed by Professor Roslyn
macrosystem levels creates psycho- erarchya social ranking that contin- Mickelson of UNC-Charlotte
logical responses, such as decreased (supported in part by PRRAC), a
self-efficacy and depression, and bio- member of PRRACs Social Sci-
Kekoa does not feel ence Advisory Board.
logical responses through changes in
valued as a Native
chronic stress and allostatic load, If you are not receiving PRRACs
which in turn may produce decreased Hawaiian.
biweekly email updates, please
immune function and higher, or para- sign up on our website todayjust
doxically blunted, cortisol levels. ues today. The Hawaiian homestead click on email list.
This, in turn, results in disparities or he and his family reside in is the re-
inequities in child health outcomes. sult of a settlement to return Native
A simplified version of Sanders- Hawaiians back to their lands after the
Phillips model is shown on the previ- occupation of Hawaii by the U.S. ing stressors, his father often turns to
ous page. However, many Hawaiian homesteads alcohol to deal with the stress and frus-
In the section that follows, we ex- are among the most impoverished and tration. After drinking, his father
plore two case examples of health in- obesiogenic neighborhoods in sometimes physically abuses his
equities among NHPI and AA youth Hawai'i. mother.
using Sanders-Phillips' framework as Kekoa often hears his parents wish Kekoa's social environment at
a point of reference. for Native Hawaiians to regain politi- home and in his homestead commu-
cal autonomy from the U.S. so they nity, where a majority is Native Ha-
can improve their quality of life. He waiian, is in sharp contrast to his
Case Studies also learns from his parents of how school environment. Although a large
the U.S. illegally took over Hawai'i number of students are Native Hawai-
The stories of Kekoa and Seung- and made Native Hawaiians second- ian and other Pacific Islanders (35%),
Hui give us a window into how rac- class citizens in their own homeland. the faculty of the school is predomi-
ism interacts with other social and Most neighbors in his homestead com- nantly of Asian descent (50%), with
cultural factors to impact the health munity share similar thoughts and only a small minority (8%) being
of some AA and NHPI children and frustrations and struggle to make ends Native Hawaiian and other Pacific
youth. These two examples do not meet. Ironically, most or all of this Islander. At school, Kekoa does not
represent the full spectrum of the AA communication occurs not in the Ha- feel comfortable or accepted by his
or NHPI experience. However, they waiian language, but in English, a teachers and peers, who are of other
do bear witness to health issues and further result of colonization. ethnic groups. He prefers hanging out
social dynamics that we cannot afford Kekoa's family has an annual with other Native Hawaiian students
to ignore. household income of $35,000, which whom he can better relate to. As a
is barely enough to pay the bills and result of these and other factors, the
provide for the four children, in a state public school system in Hawai'i has
Kekoa's Story with one of the highest costs of liv- been accused of inadvertently main-
ing. He experiences the frustration and taining the poor social and economic
Kekoa, a 16-year-old Native Ha- sense of helplessness of his parents in condition of Native Hawaiians and
waiian male, lives in a Hawaiian trying to make ends meet. Because of other Pacific Islanders.
homestead community with his par- their economic hardship and result- (Please turn to page 10)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 9


(HEALTH EQUITY: Cont.from page 9) tices and aspirations. These cultural many others in what has been known
practices and beliefs are being revived as the Virginia Tech massacre be-
Psychological and Biological Re- to uplift Native Hawaiian youth and fore committing suicide. The national
sponse. Since entering high school, their families. For example, Hawai- coverage labeled Seung-Hui as prima-
Kekoa has become depressed. He does ian language immersion schools and rily responsible for his rampage and
not feel valued as a Native Hawaiian cultural-based public charter schools for not seeking help sooner. Blame
and believes society does not have in Hawai'i (open to students of all was placed on this mentally ill Ko-
much to offer him in the way of a races and ethnicities) are building a rean immigrant student instead of ex-
bright future. When asked what is stronger Hawaiian identity and pro- amining and addressing the root
going on with him, he just responds viding the educational milieu neces- causes and solutions to youth violence
by saying, I Hawaiian so no moa sary to improve the social and self- among our growing diverse popula-
[more] much for me. No make sense. image of Native Hawaiian youth. tions.
I not going college so no need get good Many substance abuse interventions Exposure to Racial Discrimination.
grades. Mo bettah I get one job and involve reconnecting Native Hawai- A closer examination of the Seung-
help my ohana [family]. Although ian youth to land- and sea-based ac- Hui Chos personal history and men-
Kekoa has always been overweight, tal health trajectory suggests that the
he has gained a significant amount of [Native Hawaiian] cul- chain of events leading to the shoot-
excess weight since starting high tural practices and ing rampage and suicide started in
school and is now obese, which has childhood. Racism, closely connected
markedly decreased his physical func-
beliefs are being re- with xenophobia, played a large part
tioning. vived to uplift Native in his immigrant experiences, which
Resulting Health Inequities. Kekoa Hawaiian youth and included social alienation, genera-
has taken up cigarette smoking and their families. tional and cultural gaps, bullying and
drinking on a daily basis, his grades inadequate services. Seung-Hui came
have dropped, and he is frequently tivities, such as Kalo farming, aquac- to the U.S. from Korea when he was
absent from school. He was recently ulture and canoeing, as the venue for 8 years old. His father worked as a
diagnosed with type 2 diabetes. How- building the personal, cultural and presser at a dry cleaner to help pay
ever, his retinal exam showed early social assets and supports needed to for his childrens education. Seung-
signs of eye disease, suggesting that overcome their addiction. Cultural- Hui was labeled as a shy boy with an
he has had diabetes for some time. based programs such as these offer accent who did not speak much. His
Coupled with his smoking and drink- the promise of addressing the social classmates in junior high and high
ing, he is at risk for other diabetes- determinants of Native Hawaiian school made fun of him and occasion-
related complications, such as cardio- health inequities. On a larger scale, ally called out to him go back to
vascular and kidney disease. there are a multitude of Native Ha- China. He was also bullied by afflu-
For NHPI children in the U.S., waiian efforts to increase self-gover- ent Korean youth through Korean
racism has both direct and indirect nance. church groups. At home, he was shy
effects, experienced both in immedi- Ultimately, addressing the effects and not talkative, and often misunder-
ate health outcomes and through shap- of racism and U.S. occupation on stood by his immigrant parents due to
ing the social determinants of health. Native Hawaiian children requires their traditional Korean expectations
Many believe the compulsory accul- deconstructing the genealogy of the of his American academic and social
turation process due to U.S. occupa- sick islander child, whether from life.
tion of Hawaii has had direct adverse attention deficit disorder, anxiety, de- Psychological Response. Lack of
effects on the health of Native Hawai- pression, obesity or diabetes. The adequate, culturally competent men-
ians through increased chronic stress, deconstruction of the "sick" child can tal health services also played a role
allostatic load, historical/cultural provide a historical context to shift the in the chain of events. In 8th grade,
trauma, and impoverished, damaged discourse away from one of blame he was diagnosed with selective-mut-
environments. These effects may be the victim to one of restoring the ism, a symptom of schizophrenia. He
directly implicated in the higher sui- agency of resistance, persistence and often refused or avoided taking medi-
cide attempt rates for Native Hawai- reclamation among NHPI children and cation when it was prescribed.
ian youth, compared to youth of other families. Throughout his youth, his family
ethnic groups in Hawaii (12.9% vs. sought help for him through Korean
9.6%). churches, but avoided mental health
Eliminating Health Inequities. The Seung-Huis Story services. In college, he was labeled
resilience and fortitude of Native Ha- question-mark kid" by classmates.
waiians have allowed them to with- On April 16, 2007, Seung-Hui Seung-Huis mental condition pro-
stand many adversities and remain Cho, a 23-year-old Korean college gressively worsened over the years,
steadfast in their cultural beliefs, prac- senior, killed 32 people and wounded without adequate care or support, and

10 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


led to increasing social alienation and issues, their interconnections, and to
develop strategies for prevention. Save the date:
humiliation at school and at home. He
underwent basic psychiatric assess- Data collection should be culturally Place Matters
ments in college, but continued to fall appropriate and ensure disaggregation National Conference
through the cracks of the school and of Asian ethnic subgroups. September 7, 2011
mental health systems. His mental Prevention strategies must be aimed Washington, DC
health condition was not fully diag- at addressing root causes, such as ra-
cial discrimination and the culture of For more info:
nosed before he committed suicide.
Resulting Health Inequities. Al- violence in American schools and www.jointcenter.org/hpi
though the level of violence and trag- communities, while also building on
edy in Seung-Hui's case is unprec- community and cultural strengths, youth violence and building healthy
edented, it would be a mistake to view educating Asian immigrant youth and families and safe communities for
his mental illness as an isolated case. their parents to access and navigate Asian youth.
The lack of awareness and understand- American social and mental health
ing by family members, schools and services in their neighborhoods and
health care providers about the expe- schools, and fostering youth resil- Conclusion
riences of Seung-Hui and other Ko- ience.
rean and Asian immigrant youth with AA and NHPI children and youth
mild and severe mental health chal- It is essential to place are impacted by a wide spectrum of
lenges pose major barriers to ensur- our efforts in historical interconnected social and health in-
ing the provision of needed support equities, including those that seriously
and care. context. threaten their quality of life and life
The leading causes of death among itself. Understanding and addressing
Asian-American youth are uninten- Asian-American youth programs these inequities requires that we look
tional injuries, suicide and homicide, that build a sense of belonging and beyond the surface and confront dif-
but little is known about their root self-esteem can facilitate the preven- ficult social issues that are embedded
causes in Asian communities, such as tion of violence, reduce risk factors in history and current realities. We
the potential roles of racism and youth and strengthen protective factors in the need to disaggregate our data and eth-
violence, and the impact of violent community. Such youth programs can nic community experiences to seek a
death at an early age on the neighbor- mobilize families and communities, richer understanding of the cultural
hood, behavioral and mental health of conduct research projects, implement contexts and gaps facing different eth-
Asian families, and communities prevention programs and lead advo- nic communities.
across America. cacy efforts. In addition, cultural com- There is an urgent need for further
Eliminating Health Inequities. petency training is critical for all ser- exploration of social, physical and
Seung-Hui's story points to the im- vice providers and should include re- mental health inequities. The theoreti-
portance of ensuring that Asian im- spect and understanding about Asian cal model proposed by Sanders-
migrant youth with mild and severe mental health beliefs and practices, Phillips and her colleagues shows
mental health conditions are fully sup- particularly about face; the impor- promise as a framework for under-
ported at home, school, in the com- tance of culturally appropriate men- standing and addressing the role of
munities and by service providers. In tal health services to ensure accurate racism. Further work to build an evi-
Korean communities, for example, diagnosis and treatment; the impor- dence base will be needed to confirm
school teachers and service providers tance of ensuring family member in- the relevance of this framework
need to ensure they are culturally sen- volvement in all aspects of mental among AA and NHPI communities.
sitive and engage family members, healthcare; and the provision of so- While empirical studies may help us
friends and churches who play cen- cial support and health education for understand the direct role of racism
tral roles to care for Korean youth in family caregivers. as a determinant of health, it is cru-
everyday life. Reducing racism and Finally, partnerships of broad com- cial that we also examine the indirect,
youth violence across Asian Ameri- munity collaborations across Asian invisible role racism plays in shaping
can communities also requires more youth, family members, schools, men- other social determinants. In this re-
data and research, prevention pro- tal health providers, advocates and law gard, it is essential to place our ef-
grams, community engagement and enforcement in undoing racism and forts in historical context and explore
advocacy. strengthening youth violence preven- the role that racism has played in co-
Currently, few or no data exist tion initiatives, and working together lonial devastation and displacement of
about racism, youth violence and in caring and advocating for Asian indigenous people as well as xenopho-
mental health among Asian-American youth with behavioral and mental bia and anti-immigrant discrimination,
children and youth. More data are health conditions across our nation are and their effects in shaping contem-
needed to identify the causes of these more critical than ever in preventing (Please turn to page 12)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 11


(HEALTH EQUITY: Cont. from page 11) restore agency in resisting oppression strategies at the microsystem and
and building community health. macrosystem levels. There are rich
porary institutions and policies. This In this context, it is essential to ac- opportunities to learn from existing
exploration can be effective only if we knowledge the role that family, cul- cultural and community-based pro-
deconstruct narratives of victim-blam- ture and community can play in fos- grams to discover and build upon
ing and "sick" children, and work to tering health equity in developing promising practices.

Resources
Brown, D.E., Gotshalk, L.A., Katzmarzyk, P.T. & Allen, Gatchell, M. (2009). The State of Asian American, Native
L. (2011). Measures of Adiposity in Two Cohorts of Ha- Hawaiian and Pacific Islander Health in California Report.
waiian School Children. Annals of Human Biology, Mar Sacramento, CA: UC AAPI Policy MRP and API Joint Leg-
14. [Epub ahead of print] islative Caucus.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2011). Deaths: Sanders-Phillips, K., Settles-Reaves, B., Walker, D. &
Preliminary Data for 2009. National Vital Statistics Re- Brownlow, J. (2009) Social Inequality and Racial Discrimi-
ports, 59(4). Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and nation: Risk Factors for Health Disparities in Children of
Prevention National Center for Health Statistics Division of Color. Pediatrics, 124 (Supplement).
National Vital Statistics.
Sapolsky, R. (2004). Social Status and Health in Humans
Glanz, K., Maskarinec, G. & Carlin, L. (2005). Ethnicity, and Other Animals. Annual Review of Anthropology, 33,
Sense of Coherence, and Tobacco Use among Adolescents. 393418.
Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 29(3), 192-199.
Schempf, A.H., Mendola, P., Hamilton, B.E., Hayes, D.K.
Huang, L. N. & Ida, D. J. (2004). Promoting Positive De- & Makuc, D.M. (2010). Perinatal Outcomes for Asian,
velopment and Preventing Youth Violence and High-Risk Be- Native Hawaiian, and Other Pacific Islander Mothers of
haviors in Asian American/Pacific Islander Communities: A Single and Multiple Race/Ethnicity: California and Hawaii,
Social Ecological Perspective. Washington, DC: Georgetown 2003-2005. Am J of Public Health, 100(5), 877-887.
University Center for Child and Human Development and
National Asian American/Pacific Islander Mental Health Spoehr, H. (2007). Threads in the Human Tapestry: The
Association. Disaggregation of the API Identifier and the Importance of
Having NHOPI (Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander)
Juang, L.P. & Alvarez, A.A. (2010) Discrimination and Category in Data Collection, Analysis, and Reporting. Ho-
Adjustment among Chinese American Adolescents: Family nolulu, HI: Papa Ola Lokahi.
Con?ict and Family Cohesion as Vulnerability and Protec-
tive Factors. Am J Public Health, 100(12), 24032409. Thomas, E. (2007). Making of a Massacre: Quiet and Dis-
turbed, Cho Seung Hui Seethed, Then Exploded. His Odys-
Kaholokula, J.K., Nacapoy, A.H. & Dang, K. (2009). So- sey. Newsweek. Cover Story: Special Report. April 30,
cial Justice as a Public Health Imperative for Kanaka Maoli. 2007. U.S. Edition.
AlterNative 5(2), 116-137.
Trinh-Shevrin C., Islam, N. S. & Rey, M. J., (Eds.). (2009).
Lai, M. (2008). Asian/Pacific Islander Youth Violence Pre- Asian American Communities and Health. San Francisco:
vention Center: Community Mobilization Efforts to Reduce Jossey-Bass.
and Prevent Violence. American Journal of Preventive
Medicine, 34(3S), S48-S55. UCLA Center for Health Policy Research. California Health
Interview Survey 2001-2007. Los Angeles, CA: UCLA Cen-
Lee, S., Juon, H.S., Martinez, G., Hsu, C.E., Robinson, ter for Health Policy Research.
E.S., Bawa, J. & Ma, G.X. (2009). Model Minority At
Risk: Expressed Needs of Mental Health by Asian Ameri- Yeh, M., McCabe, K., Hough, R.L., Lau, A., Fakhry, F.
can Young Adults. J Community Health, 34(2), 144-152. & Garland, A. (2005) Why Bother with Beliefs? Examin-
ing Relationships between Race/Ethnicity, Parental Beliefs
Native Hawaiian & Pacific Islander Alliance. (2008). Guid- about Causes of Child Problems, and Mental Health Service
ance on the Classification of Native Hawaiian and Pacific Use. J Consult Clin Psychol, 73(5), 800-7.
Islanders. Gardena, CA: Native Hawaiian and Pacific Is-
lander Alliance and Asian & Pacific Islander American Health Yuen, N., Nahulu, L., Hishinuma, E. & Miyamoto, R.
Forum. (2000). Cultural Identification and Attempted Suicide in
Native Hawaiian Adolescents. Journal of the American
Okamura, J. (2008). Ethnicity and Inequality in Hawaii. Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 39(3), 360
Philadelphia, PA: Temple Univ. Press. 367.
Pachter, L.M. & Coll, C.G. (2009) Racism and Child Zane, N. W. S., Takeuchi, D. T. & Young, K. N. J. (Eds.).
Health: A Review of the Literature and Future Directions. (1994). Confronting Critical Health Issues of Asian and Pa-
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 30(3), 255-263. cific Islander Americans. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publi-
cations.
Ponce, N., Tseng, W., Ong, P., Shek, Y.L., Ortiz, S. &

12 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


Neighborhood The Smallest Unit of Health:
A Health Center Model for Pacific Islander and
Asian Health
by Jamila Jarmon
N eighbors being Neighborly to Hawaiians, Filipinos, Samoans and builds trust as an institution in the
Neighbors. This is how Kokua Kalihi Micronesians, to name a few. The tra- community. This helps KKV fulfill its
Valley Comprehensive Family Ser- ditional services associated with com- mission of serving communities,
vices (KKV) approaches neighbor- munity health centers are present at families and individuals through
hood health in Kalihi Valley, a mostly KKV, including primary care physi- strong relationships that foster health
immigrant community of 30,000 resi- cians, dental, nutrition, behavioral and harmony.
dents on the edge of urban Honolulu. health, elderly care, and maternal- KKV focuses on its internal capac-
KKV is a federally-qualified commu- child health services. These services ity to continue providing services to
nity health center, serving about help KKV to retain its identity as a the community. The bottom line for
10,000 residents, primarily Pacific traditional community health center. KKV is the neighborhoods health and
Islander and Asian-American, a year, In addition, KKV staff speak 21 dif- well-being; all programs that begin out
fostering neighborly values to ensure of this community dialogue are de-
health for all. Through the years, KKV embraces an signed for sustainability. As a com-
KKV has grown and currently oper- munity participant, KKV seeks to de-
expanded meaning of velop the internal capacity of its part-
ates at seven separate locations in the
community, including the largest pub- health care. ners and clients so that programs can
lic housing complex in the State of last beyond individual project fund-
Hawai`i. With growth, KKV retains ferent languages, supporting language ing. The neighborhood is an integral
an original grassroots vision of health access and cultural competency for part driving programming based on
and well-being developed together limited-English-proficient speakers. need. For KKV, it is important to keep
with the community. KKV staff diversity enables it to de- up the organizations side of the part-
KKV has humble roots, beginning velop innovative programs that sup- nership and retain continuity of the
in 1972 with four outreach workers port neighborhood health in culturally programs offered, regardless of fund-
operating out of a trailer, going door- competent ways. ing challenges.
to-door getting to know their neigh- Adapting a community-based KKV embraces an expanded mean-
bors: their immediate needs, their health model pioneered by Dr. Jack ing of health care by having a broad
hopes, dreams and individual talents, Geiger and others on the mainland view of neighborhood health. It has
too. The four spoke three different U.S., KKV understands that commu- developed a variety of innovative
languages and were able to assist com- nities want to be active participants in neighborhood health partnerships that
munity members with agency re- developing solutions and strategies serve its diverse ethnic community,
sources. From their trailer-offices, that benefit neighborhood health. which includes many new Pacific-Is-
workers interacted with the commu- KKV addresses ongoing human re- lander and Asian-American immigrant
nity. Soon, medical and dental physi- source needs by hiring from the com- communities. This commentary high-
cians volunteered their time, broad- munity, building lasting relationships lights four programs at KKV: Lei
ening KKVs community participa- and thinking programmatically. Hir- Hipu`u o Kalihi; Kalihi Valley In-
tion. Standing by its motto, KKV con- ing workers from the community al- structional Bike Exchange; Medical-
tinues to expand, maintaining an ac- lows KKV to have a continued con- Legal Partnership for Children in
tive and ongoing conversation with the nection with the community. The Hawai`i; and Ho`oulu `Aina. Fo-
growing community that includes employee is able to listen and work to cusing on culture and family, these
develop programs within the commu- programs are guided and led by the
Jamila Jarmon (jjarmon@hawaii. nity that are sustainable. The policy community.
edu) is a Post-Graduate Legal Fellow also provides paying jobs to the com-
with the William S. Richardson School munity, yielding not only health im-
of Laws Health Policy Center Medi- pacts, but also economic impact. By Lei Hipu`u o Kalihi
cal-Legal Partnership for Children building relationships and working on
Hawai`i and Kokua Kalihi Valley an equalized plane, KKV is able to KKVs Lei Hipu`u o Kalihi (Lei
Comprehensive Family Services Lei not only recognize strength and lead- Hipu`u) is a grantee of the Health
Hipu`u o Kalihi Program. ership within the community, it also (Please turn to page 14)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 13


(NEIGHBORHOOD: Cont.from page 13) Park Terrace Residents Association the help of KVIBE staff and other
(KPTRA). Kuhio Park Terrace (KPT) youth who have gained skills from
Through Action Grant from the Asian is the largest public housing complex their time at KVIBE. This program
& Pacific Islander American Health in the State of Hawai`i, and many exists because it recognizes that a bike
Forum sponsored by the W.K. residents receive services from KKV. shop is one method to affect or un-
Kellogg Foundation. Lei Hipu`us KPTRA, in partnership with Lei derstand community health.
purpose it to work on capacity-build- Hipu`u, created monthly talk story KKV acknowledges that through
ing in the area of early childhood meetings. Talking story is a cus- knowledge of building a bike, KVIBE
health within the Kalihi Valley com- tom of dialoguing about community is able to build the capacity of the
munity. Because KKV serves various and family issues or events. These talk Kalihi Valley youth. Not only do they
ethnic groups, Lei Hipu`u conducts stories have resulted in committees redeem a bike after building it, they
focus groups with each around early forming to address issues within the learn responsibility, hard work, and
childhood health issues, identifying community, such as tackling fire gain mentors to help guide them.
cultural similarities and differences. safety with the Honolulu Fire Depart- KVIBE staff are trained to discuss
These focus groups produce qualita- ment and discussion of traditional healthy relationships and foster a safe
tive data that help Lei Hipu`u, as a health practices amongst the different environment where no gang colors are
representative of KKV, understand cultures in housing led by residents allowed, targeting youth to build a sus-
how the community raises their chil- of KPT. Lei Hipu`u builds the capac- tained neighborhood health capacity
dren. Many of these focus groups are ity and confidence of the KPTRA to for the future of Kalihi Valley. KVIBE
assembled by the community outreach continue a dialogue in the community is a true innovation in neighborhood
specialist for Lei Hipu`u, who is a in order to recognize needs of their health, providing youth a viable al-
leader in the Chuukese (Micronesian) neighbors. Lei Hipu`u contributes ternative to learn, grow and make
community. Hiring from the commu- greatly to neighborhood health and the healthy choices from positive experi-
nity for this position provides Lei ences.
Hipu`u continuous opportunities to Health is community.
work in partnership with the commu-
nity and understand neighborhood pri-
Medical-Legal Partner-
orities. The Micronesian community equalization of resources to benefit all ship for Children in
is the newest and fastest growing im- participants in the Kalihi Valley com- Hawai`i
migrant community in Hawai`i and a munity. Lei Hipu`us goal is for com-
large consumer of KKV services. Hir- munity residents to take ownership of The Medical-Legal Partnership for
ing from the community not only cre- their neighborhoods health. Children in Hawai`i (MLPC Hawai`i)
ated the opportunity to build a rela- is a project of the Health Law Policy
tionship with a new and growing im- Center of the William S. Richardson
migrant population, it built the com- Kalihi Valley Instruc- School of Law (University of Hawai`i
munity outreach specialists capacity tional Bike Exchange at Manoa). Medical-Legal Partner-
and provided economic opportunity ships follow a model established by
for work previously done without pay. The Kalihi Valley Instructional Dr. Barry Zuckerman of the Boston
Relationships are built through Lei Bike Exchange (KVIBE) is a program Medical Clinic, who hired an attor-
Hipu`u, which serves as a connector of KKV that lives by the motto If ney to address the social determi-
in the neighborhood. Lei Hipu`u cre- you build it they will come. KVIBE nants that negatively impact the health
ated a Leadership Council that is a non-profit bicycle shop that be- of vulnerable populations. Recogniz-
comes together monthly as a cohort gan in 2005 and promotes bicycle-re- ing KKVs unique relationship with
of Kalihi-based service providers, in- lated activities for at-risk youth in the Kalihi Valley community, the co-
cluding social workers, librarians, Kalihi Valley. KVIBE stocks about director of the Health Law Policy
school staff and officials, community 100 bikes at a time and relies on steady Center partnered with a pediatrician
leaders, doctors, lawyers and more. donations. Two neighborhood resi- at KKV to construct a program that
The relationships developed have re- dents who previously volunteered with allowed legal interventions and advo-
sulted in increased trust, support and the program currently staff KVIBE. cacy to improve health care and ac-
collaboration among the community One had previous bicycle repair ex- cess. This particular doctor and law-
of service providers. The prevailing pertise and the other was a youth par- yer saw that there were instances when
culture of the Leadership Council re- ticipant who developed skills over medical conditions could be alleviated
mains focused on the ever-shifting time. Personal relationships help to through legal intervention, such as
needs and hopes of the communities foster trust in KVIBE. This trust en- when a child with chronic asthma and
served. gages Kalihi Valley youth to come and eye infections needs a landlord to fix
Lei Hipu`u fosters a notable com- either buy, build or repair bikes there. a leaky pipe that has caused mold to
munity relationship with the Kuhio Those who choose to build do so with develop in his bedroom. MLPC

14 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


Hawai`i approached its partnership ing these resources gives the commu-
with KKV by engaging with the com- nity this power and experience to ef- Federal Employee
munity first. To begin, the MLPC fectively advocate for themselves. Friends:
Hawai`i legal director and law stu- Working closely with the community,
Please consider PRRAC
dent interns accompanied KKV pub- service providers and health profes-
during this years
lic housing outreach workers on a sionals foster the goals of MLPC
door-to-door survey to introduce KKV Combined Federal
Hawai`i to value and respect collabo-
services and to hear about public hous- ration in real-life settings. Taking the Campaign.
ing residents needs, including the lack time to build and foster these valu- We appreciate your support!!
of accessible legal services. After lis- able relationships also helps legal ad- CFC#: 11710
tening to the neighborhood, MLPC
Hawai`i built on the trust families Hooulu Aina recog-
have with their childrens doctors and nizes land as a commu- Chuukese diabetes group to exercise.
began providing direct legal services In a meeting, the interpreter explained
to families at KKV to address the so- nity member. that there was no word for exercise
cial/legal problems that negatively in Chuukese. They tried Take a
impact their health. MLPC Hawai`i vocates to stay in touch with the ever- walkto which the participants said
runs its legal clinics to coincide with shifting needs and hopes of the neigh- To where? It is not in their cul-
the KKV Pediatric Clinics, allowing borhood. MLPC Hawaiis partnership ture to take a walk or exercise
legal advocates to meet with families with KKV has contributed to building without a purpose or destination.
alongside pediatricians in the exam resources and advocacy opportunities Also, highly urban areas like Kalihi
rooms during well-child medical vis- for the neighborhood. are sometimes difficult or dangerous
its. KKV generously provided office for walking. Farming was mentioned
space to MLPC Hawai`i in their of- as an option and hands shot up! This
fice located in the KPT Resource Cen- Ho`oulu `Aina led to weekly trips to Ho`oulu `Aina,
ter, giving MLPC Hawai`i a central to begin clearing land so that gardens
and constant presence in the neigh- Ho`oulu `Aina is a part of KKV could be planted, harvested, cooked
borhood to continue garnering trust. located on a 99-acre land preserve in and shared with family and neighbors,
MLPC Hawai`i also works to build Kalihi Valley to engage communities for their exercise. In addition, other
the capacity of the community to ad- in nurturing their land. Hawaiians for programs at Ho`oulu `Aina enforce
vocate for themselves. Clients are generations and until today honor this health through story-telling, native re-
taught about their legal rights, recog- area as sacred to the creation gods, forestation and learning the history of
nize the effect on health, and are em- and this land in the past was very fer- Kalihi Valley.
powered with the understanding that tile, providing sustenance for the Ho`oulu `Aina recognizes the
those rights are enforceable. For ex- people of Kalihi Valley and beyond. community as experts in their health
ample, the right to have habitable Ho`oulu `Aina recognizes land as a and values their expertise in under-
housing is reinforced with law for cli- community member. In partnership standing the social forces that affect
ents because many health ailments are with the community, Ho`oulu `Aina neighborhood health. During an open
exacerbated or persist from uninhab- uses a land-based program to improve dialogue with the community, they
itable living conditions. overall neighborhood health. When discussed how difficult it was to find
Also, MLPC Hawai`i has engaged people come to Ho`oulu `Aina to or afford healthy food in Kalihi Val-
in language access advocacy on both work, they nurture the land, which in ley. In addition, the large immigrant
individual and systemic levels. They turn nurtures them: O ka ha o ka population is unfamiliar with West-
enlist the help of interpreters from `aina ke ola o ka po`e: the breath of ern foods and their nutritional value.
KKV staff to ensure open dialogue the land is the life of the people. Ho`oulu `Aina and partners are now
with their many limited-English-pro- Most of the staff at Ho`oulu `Aina embarking on the Roots Project,
ficient clients. They even look to the live in Kalihi Valley and bring valu- with the goal of building community
community for translation services to able relationships to enrich accessi- capital by providing more education
produce legal resources and informa- bility to this unique neighborhood ex- and opportunity to enjoy and prepare
tion in native languages. In addition, perience. These opportunities are, like healthy foods as neighbors. Ho`oulu
MLPC Hawai`i advocates provide other KKV programs, fostered `Aina will increase food production
clients with language access rights through community dialogue. For with the neighborhood and utilize the
cards so they can enforce their state example, KKVs Nutrition Programs new commercial kitchen being built
and federal right to an interpreter at diabetes group has utilized this access at KKVs main clinic. Neighbors will
state agencies, federal agencies and for exercise and nutrition purposes. have the opportunity to work the land,
hospitals. Knowledge is power and For a year, the nutrition program was grow food, learn how to prepare that
can galvanize people to act; provid- unable to influence members of the (Please turn to page 16)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 15


(NEIGHBORHOOD: Cont. from page 15)
Resources
food in new ways, and then share the Asian & Pacific Islander American Health Forum. Available from: http://
fruits of their labor, coming together www.apiahf.org/index.php/programs/health-through-action.html/
as neighbors. Ho`oulu `Aina, in part- Cargo M., Mercer S. The Value and Challenges of Participatory Research:
nership with the community, is di- Strengthening Its Practice. Annu. Rev. Public Health. 2008 Jan. 3; 29:325-350.
rectly impacting neighborhood health Hancock T. People, Partnerships and Human Progress: Building Community
through food production and con- Capital. Health Promot. Int. 2001 Sept; 16(3): 275-80.
sumption. Hawai`i Public Housing Authority. Annual Report Fiscal Year 2010. Available
from: http://www.hcdch.hawaii.gov/documents/
2011%20Annual%20Report_draft4.pdf.
Neighbors being Ho`oulu `Aina. Available from: http://www.hoouluaina.org/index.html/.
Neighborly to Kalihi Valley Integrated Bike Exchange. Available from: http://k-vibe.blogspot.
Neighbors com/.
Kokua Kalihi Valley Comprehensive Family Services. Available from http://
KKV is an innovative community www.kkv.net/.
health center because it understands William S. Richardson School of Law: Medical-Legal Partnership for Children in
that the community is a neighbor and Hawai`i. Available from: http://www.law.hawaii.edu/mlpc/.
collaborator. Direct services are National Center for Medical Legal Partnership. Available from: http://
grounded in the various cultural tra- www.medical-legalpartnership.org/.
ditions of patients and residents work-
ing together to provide resources nec-
essary for health access. KKV under-
(HIA: Cont. from page 6) rate and provide input on decisions
stands that language access goes hand-
in-hand with cultural competency, being made. HIAs may be appropri-
creating a trusting environment. Lan- Conclusion ate on a wide variety of subjects (see
guage access and cultural competency box on p. 6 for a partial list of topics
does not stop there however; hiring Regardless of what type of project, HIAs have covered). The value of an
from the community creates more plan or policy decision is being con- HIA can be determined by the magni-
cultural context and gives economic sidered, a Health Impact Assessment tude and likelihood of potential health
incentive to retain language and cul- may be a strategic tool for a variety impacts, the distribution of those im-
ture. KKV recognizes that when work- of reasons. In addition to providing a pacts, an accurate assessment of the
ing with a diverse community of new health lens and health analysis, an HIA likelihood of achieving the process
immigrants, Pacific Islanders and can contribute a robust participatory and/or outcome objectives of the HIA,
Asian Americans, community dia- process and a structure for communi- and a realistic evaluation of resources,
logue and support create sustainable ties and other stakeholders to collabo- capacity and stakeholder interest.
programs to serve the neighborhood.
KKV is a community health center Completed Health Impact Assessments:
with place-based focus and a health Paid Sick Days HIA http://www.humanimpact.org/component/jdownloads/
justice mission. This neighborhood finish/5/68
health models use has broad applica- Long Beach HIA: http://www.humanimpact.org/component/jdownloads/
tion for any institution or individual finish/8/102/0
working to affect neighborhood More on these and other HIAs:
health. Health is not only medical http://www.humanimpact.org/past-projects
http://www.hiaguide.org/hias
health; it is holistic. Health is com-
munity. Health is legal advocacy. Information on Income Disparities and Health:
Health is self-advocacy. Health is a
bike shop. Health is reconnecting with http://www.humanimpact.org/evidencebase/category/
income_inequality_affects_peoples_mortality_and_health
culture and land. By being a neigh- http://www.cdc.gov/omhd/default.htm
bor, KKV creates programs that fos- Laura D. Kubzansky et al., United States: Social Inequality and the
ter a healthy community. Institutions Burden of Poor Health, in Tackling Health Inequities through Public
and individuals have the ability to be Health Practice: Theory to Action 86 (Richard Hofrichter & Rajiv Bhatia,
neighborly. As a neighbor, KKV is a eds., 2010)
vital part of revitalizing and sustain- http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/countries/united-states/
ing the Kalihi Valley community now More information on the relationship between HIA and EIA can be found at http:/
and for future generations. /www.humanimpact.org/hia#EIA

16 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


(INTEGRATION: Continued from page 2) extent of black-on-white crimes. Such ways: It blocks blacks access to eco-
taken-for-granted stigmatizing public nomic opportunities, it causes racial
thing. images of blacks amount to a massive stigmatization and discrimination, and
These ideas dont have to be be- assault on the reputation of blacks, a it undermines democracy. It stands to
lieved, or even conscious, for them harm in itself. They also generate reason that racial integration would
to influence behavior. Mere familiar- public support for policies that have a help dismantle these injustices. We can
ity with derogatory stereotypes, even disproportionately negative impact on think of integration as taking place by
without belief, can cause unwitting blacks. White support for the death stages. We start with formal desegre-
discrimination. No wonder that even penalty jumps when whites are told gation: ending laws and policies that
people who consciously reject anti- that more blacks than whites are ex- turned blacks into an untouchable caste
black stereotypes have been found to ecuted. White hostility to welfare is by forcing them into separate and in-
discriminate against blacks. This is tied to the public image of the wel- ferior public spaces. This is an essen-
because stereotypes typically operate fare recipient as a single black mother, tial step toward destigmatization.
automatically, behind our backs. In even though most recipients are white. While stigma still exists, blacks pub-
addition, we need to multiply our Such impacts of racial stigmatiza- lic standing is better now that they can
models of how racially stigmatizing tion on democratic policy formation no longer be forced to the back of the
ideas cause discrimination. Pure preju- bus. Next comes spatial integration,
dicial discrimination, as in the KKK Segregation also stig- in which racial groups actually share
case, offers just one model. Econo- matizes the disadvan- common public spaces and facilities.
mists stress statistical discrimination, taged. This enables blacks to get access to
in which decision-makers use race as many of the public goodsnotably,
a proxy for undesirable traits such as safe, unblighted, relatively unpolluted
laziness or criminal tendencies. But reinforce the anti-democratic effects neighborhoods with decent schools and
often stereotypes work by altering of spatial and role segregation. De- public servicesthat most whites en-
perceptions. For some white observ- mocracy isnt only about the univer- joy. Studies of integration experiments
ers, that rambunctious black youth sal franchise. It requires a trained involving low-income families, from
shooting hoops in the park looks ag- elite, institutional structure, and cul- Gautreaux to Moving to Opportunity,
gressive and hostile, although if he ture that is systematically responsive show that spatial integration yields
were white, he would be perceived as to the interests and voices of people important material and psychic ben-
harmlessly horsing around. Other from all walks of life. This requires efits to formerly segregated blacks,
times they work by making well- that people from all walks of life have notably better housing, lower stress
meaning people anxious. Nervous effective access to channels of com- and greater freedom for children to
about appearing racist, whites may munication to elites, and that they be play outdoors.
avoid blacks, or act stiffly and for- able to hold them accountable for their The next step is formal social inte-
mally toward them. The very desire decisions. Segregation blocks both gration: cooperation on terms of equal-
to avoid discrimination can cause it. communication and accountability. ity in institutions such as schools,
Racial stigmatization also harms There is nothing like face-to-face con- workplaces, juries and the military.
blacks through paths other than dis- frontation to force people to listen and This is where some of the biggest pay-
crimination. This is why The Impera- respond to ones complaints. Out of offs of integration occur. Extensive
tive of Integration argues that the stan- sight, out of mind: Segregated elites interracial cooperation on equal terms
dard discrimination account of racial are clubby, insular, ignorant, unac- expands blacks social and cultural
inequality needs to be replaced by a countable and irresponsible. The his- capital, leading to better education and
broader account, based on the joint tory of the Civil Rights Movement job opportunities. Sustained formal
effects of segregation and stigmatiza- demonstrates how mass disruptive social integration under moderately
tion. Negative effects of stigmatiza- protests were needed to teach segre- favorable conditions, including insti-
tion not mediated by discrimination gated elites, and whites at large, fun- tutional support and cooperative inter-
include stereotype threatanxiety damental lessons about democracy and action, also reduces prejudice, stigma
caused by the fear that ones behav- justice that they were incapable of and discrimination, often to the point
ior will confirm negative stereotypes learning on their own. of promoting informal social integra-
about oneselfwhich depresses tioninterracial friendship and inti-
blacks performance on standardized mate relations.
tests. In addition, stigmatizing images Racial Segregation: A Formal social integration also im-
of blacks are not just in peoples Fundamental Cause of proves the responsiveness of demo-
heads; they are in our culture and Racial Injustice cratic institutions to all social groups.
public discourse. TV news and police Racially integrated police forces are
dramas disproportionately depict So racial segregation is a funda- less violent toward blacks and more
criminals as black and exaggerate the mental cause of racial injustice in three (Please turn to page 18)

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 17


(INTEGRATION: Continued from page 17) people to be responsive to the inter- dards of illegal discrimination to state
ests of a wider diversity of people. In action, and deliberate selection for
responsive to community concerns public opinion polling, too, whites racially integrated juries. I also argue
than racially homogeneous ones. In- express more racially conciliatory po- that voting districts should be inte-
tegrated teaching staffs are less puni- sitions when they think they are talk- grated in such a way that politicians
tive toward black students and less ing to a black pollster. cannot be elected without running on
likely to consign them to lower edu- The Imperative of Integration ar- platforms with multiracial appeal. This
cational tracks. Integrated juries de- gues that the evidence on the positive will correct a serious downside of ma-
liberate longer, take into account more effects of racial integration, combined jority-minority districting, which is
evidence, make fewer factual mis- with theory and evidence that these that remaining districts tend to favor
takes, and are more alert to racial dis- effects cannot be achieved in other race-baiting politicians running on a
crimination in the criminal justice pro- ways, provide a powerful case for re- politics of white racial resentment. In
cess than all-white juries. Part of the instituting racial integration as a policy many parts of the U.S., race relations
greater intelligence of integrated ju- goal. Integration needs to be pursued have relaxed enough to enable blacks,
ries is due to the diverse information on multiple fronts, including housing even when a minority in their district,
provided by blacks, who are more to elect their preferred candidate in
likely to raise critical questions, such Stereotypes typically coalition with a critical mass of racially
as the reliability of whites eyewitness operate automatically, tolerant whites, Latinos, Asian Ameri-
identification of blacks. Deliberation cans and Native Americans.
in an integrated setting also makes
behind our backs. The Imperative of Integration also
whites deliberate more intelligently argues for alternative models of affir-
and responsibly: They are less likely vouchers to promote low-income black mative action. Right now, discussion
to rush to a guilty judgment, and more mobility into integrated middle-class of affirmative action is dominated by
likely to raise and take seriously con- neighborhoods, abolition of class-seg- two models: diversity and compensa-
cerns about discrimination in the crimi- regative zoning regulations, adoption tion. The diversity model stresses the
nal justice process, than in all-white of integrative programs by school dis- supposed connections between racial
juries. The need to justify oneself face- tricts, extension and aggressive en- diversity and diversity of cultures and
to-face before diverse others motivates forcement of differential impact stan- ideas. It doesnt do much to support
affirmative action in industries such
as construction and manufacturing,
Further Readings where the culture and ideas of most
employees make little difference. Nor
Estlund, Cynthia. Working Together: How Workplace Bonds Strengthen a Di- does it explain why selective schools
verse Democracy. New York: Oxford UP, 2005. should preferentially admit African
Frankenberg, Erica & Gary Orfield, eds. Lessons in Integration: Realizing the Americans and Latinos, as opposed
Promise of Racial Diversity in American Schools. Charlottesville: Univ. of Vir- to foreign students. The compensatory
ginia Press, 2007. model portrays affirmative action as
Gaertner, Samuel & John Dovidio. Reducing Intergroup Bias: The Common making up for past discrimination.
Ingroup Identity Model. Philadelphia: Psychology Press, 2000. This encourages people to believe that
Kinder, Donald & Tali Mendelberg. Cracks in American Apartheid: The Politi- racial inequalities are due to long-past
cal Impact of Prejudice Among Desegregated Whites. Journal of Politics 57:2 deeds, overlooking the powerful con-
(1995): 402-24. tinuing causes of racial injustice rooted
Pettigrew, Thomas & Linda Tropp. A Meta-Analytic Test of Intergroup Contact in current segregation and stigmati-
Theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90:5 (2006): 75183. zation. It also supports public impa-
Sanders, Lynn. Democratic Politics and Survey Research. Philosophy of the
tience with affirmative action. No
Social Sciences 29.2 (1999): 248-80. wonder the Supreme Court, even
while upholding affirmative action in
Sklansky, David Alan. Not Your Fathers Police Department: Making Sense of
Grutter v. Bollinger, expressed the
the New Demographics of Law Enforcement. Journal of Criminal Law and
Criminology 96:3 (2006): 1209-43. view that affirmative action will no
longer be needed in 25 years.
Sommers, Samuel. On Racial Diversity and Group Decision Making: Identify- Once we understand that current ra-
ing Multiple Effects of Racial Composition on Jury Deliberations. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology 90:4 (2006): 597-612. cial inequality is rooted in current ra-
cial stigmatization and segregation,
Tilly, Charles. Durable Inequality. Berkeley and Los Angeles: Univ. of Califor- affirmative action can be understood
nia Press, 1999.
differently. De facto segregation cre-
Wells, Amy & Robert Crain. Perpetuation Theory and the Long-Term Effects of ates referral networks that exclude
School Desegregation. Review of Educational Research 64:4 (1994): 53155. blacks from information and recom-

18 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


mendations to job openings in firms Any argument for restoring racial similation and object to the psychic
that employ few blacks. Role segre- integration to a central place in the costs of integration on blacks. I argue
gation within firms creates stereotypes public policy agenda must address that integration is distinct from assimi-
of qualified workers that mirror the three objections. Conservatives op- lation, since its aim is not to erect
identities of those who already occupy pose integrative policies on grounds white practices as the norm, but rather
those roles. Non-stereotypical work- of color-blindness. In The Imperative to abolish white exclusionary practices
ers are therefore perceived to be un- of Integration, I argue that the color- and replace them with practices in-
qualified for such roles even when blind principle is conceptually con- clusive of all. And, while integration
they could fill them successfully, and fused, because it conflates different is stressful, as people learn to coop-
so are excluded even when managers meanings of race and different kinds erate across racial lines the psychic
believe they are hiring on merit. Af- of racial discrimination. It is one thing costs of integration decline. Finally,
firmative action within firms serves to discriminate out of pure prejudice readers of Poverty & Race will be fa-
to block these and other racially ex- against a group with a different ap- miliar with the argument that integra-
clusionary practices. This is discrimi- pearance or ancestry, or to treat race tion is an unrealistic fantasy. We
nation-blocking affirmative action. as a proxy for intelligence or other know, however, that the experience
Integrative affirmative action explic- merits; quite another to take race-con- of integration is self-reinforcing:
itly adopts racial integration as an in- scious steps to counteract racial dis- people of all races who grew up in
stitutional goal, in the name of pro- crimination and undo the continuing more integrated settings tend to choose
moting democratic responsiveness to causes of racial-based injustice. Af- more integrated settings later in life.
the full diversity of people whom the firmative action, properly adminis- So we should not foreclose all hope.
institution is supposed to serve, over- tered, does not compromise but rather After all, only a few years ago the
coming racial inequalities in social and promotes meritocratic selection. Some idea of a black president was regarded
cultural capital, and breaking down on the left oppose integrative policies by many Americans to be an unreal-
racial anxieties, prejudices and stereo- because they fear the destruction of izable dream.
types through integrated, cooperative autonomous black institutions and
work teams. cultural practices in the name of as-

Resources
Most Resources are Race/Racism Johnson on the Greensboro listed) from The Rights
available directly from the Massacre is available at Working Group (a project
issuing organization, either The Imperative of http://www.cnn.com/2011/ of the Tides Center), 1120
on their website (if given) or Integration, by Elizabeth US/06/07/greensboro.race/ Conn. Ave. NW, #1100,
via other contact informa- Anderson (246 pp., 2010), [12788] Wash., DC 20036, 202/
tion listed. has been published by 591-3300, www.rights
Princeton Univ. Press. Finding Our Way is a workinggroup.org [12804]
Materials published by [12763] 90-min., 3-part 2011
PRRAC are available documentary by Giovanni "The Persistence of
through our website: Angels of Mercy: White Attili and Leonie Racial and Ethnic Profil-
www.prrac.org. Prices Women and the History of Sandercock on the still ing in the United States,"
include the shipping/ New York's Colored unresolved conflict between a 98-page, Aug. 2009
handling (s/h) charge when Orphan Asylum, by indigenous people in north follow-up report to the UN
this information is provided William Seraile (287 pp., central British Columbia Committee on the Elimina-
to PRRAC. No price 2011, $27.95), has been and the government of tion of Racial Discrimina-
listed items often are free. published by Fordham Canada. Inf. at tion, published by ACLU
Univ. Press, 212/743-8337, mailbox@movingimages.ca, and The Rights Working
When ordering items from justyna.zajac.oup.com www.movingimages.ca, Group, is available (no
PRRAC: SASE = self- [12779] http://www.facebook.com/ price listed) from the latter
addressed stamped envelope FINDING. OUR.WAY. org., 1120 Conn. Ave.
(44 unless otherwise Greenboro, NC thefilm [12795] NW, #1100, Wash., DC
indicated). Orders may not Massacre: A CNN story 20036, 202/591-3300,
be placed by telephone or about Greensboro's civil "Faces of Racial www.rightsworking
fax. Please indicate from rights history and demogra- Profiling: A Report from group.org [12806]
which issue of P&R you are phy that also includes Communities Across
ordering. within a link to a video America" (81 pp., Sept. The Dream Is Free-
interview with Nelson 2010) is available (no price dom: Pauli Murray and

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 19


American Democratic "Profile of the Puerto "The Impact of Light www.loyno/edu/jsri/
Faith, by Sarah Azaransky Rican Population in Skin on Prison Time for [12821]
(176 pp., 2011, $55), has United States and Puerto Black Female Offenders,"
been published by Oxford Rico: 2008" was a Re- by Jill Viglione & Robert "Healthy Communi-
Univ. Press, 800/451-7556. search Seminar, held May DeFina, appeared in vol. ties, Strong Regions, A
[12808] 11, 2011 at the Center for 48 (2011) of The Social Prosperous America" is
Puerto Rican Studies at Science Journal, pp. 250- Equity Summit 2011,
I AM A MAN: From Hunter College, NYC. Inf. 58. [12810] organized by PolicyLink
Memphis, a Lesson in Life from 212/772-5714. (headed by former PRRAC
is a new (2011) 47-minute [12814] "Experiencing Court, Bd. member Angela Glover
documentary on the 1968 Experiencing Race: Blackwell), Nov. 8-11,
Sanitation Workers' strike Perceived Procedural 2011 in Detroit. Inf. at
that brought Martin Luther Criminal Injustice Among Court www.PolicyLink.org/
King to Memphis, resulting Users," by Jamie G. Summit [12786]
in his assassination. It's
Justice Longazel, Laurin S. Parker
available ($20 on the web, & Ivan Y. Sun, appared in
but the producer at the Race, Crime, and Vol. 1, No. 2 (2011) of Education
Memphis Convention & Punishment: Breaking the Race and Justice, pp. 202-
Visitors Bureau might Connection in America, 27. [12812] Rethinking Popular
generously send it without ed. Keith Lawrence (220 Culture and Media, eds.
charge); there's also a pp., 2011), has been Disproportionate Elizabeth Marshall &
separate 2nd "Behind the published by The Aspen Minority Contact, ed. Ozlem Sensoy (340 pp.,
Scenes" element on how the Institute. Includes essays by Nicole Parsons-Pollard 2011, $18.95), has been
movie was made. Contact Michelle Alexander, Marc (300 pp., 2011, $35), published by Rethinking
Calvin Taylor, 901/543- Mauer, Alice O'Connor, dealing with the juvenile Schools, 1001 E. Keefe
5306, calvin@mcvb.org Phil Thompson et al. justice system, has been Ave., Milwaukee, WI
[12822] Copies available (no price published by Carolina 53212, 800/669-4192,
given) from the Institute's Academy Press, 70 Kent RSBusiness@aol.com.
Breach of Peace: Fulfillment Office, PO Box St., Durham, NC 27701, Some four dozen essays, by
Portraits of the 1961 222, 109 Houghton Ln., 919/489-7486. [12813] Bob Peterson, Barbara
Freedom Riders was a Queenstown, MD 21658, Ehrenreich, Linda
marvelous exhibit [I caught 410/820-5338, "Five Myths about Christensen, Ellen
it at the SF Jewish Comm. publications@aspen Americans in Prison," by Goodman, Wayne Au et al.
Ctr.-CH] that toured institute.org [12777] Marc Mauer & David Cole, www.rethinkingschools.org
several cities, with photos appeared in the June 19, [12778]
of over 4 dozen Freedom "Mass Imprisonment: 2011 Washington Post
Riders (mug shot when Long-Term Harm versus Outlook Section. If you "The Long-Term
arrested, accompanied by Short-Term Good," by can't find it on the Internet, Effects of Early Child-
current photo), along with Robert DeFina & Lance we'll be happy to mail you hood Education," by Raj
personal statements by each Hannon, is a 3-page article a copy if you furnish a Chetty & John N. Fried-
on why they participated, in the Summer 2011 issue SASE. [12824] man, is a 2-page article in
what the journey meant for of Communities & Banking, the Summer 2011 issue of
them, what they now are the magazine of the Federal Communities & Banking,
doing. If you act quickly, it Reserve Bank-Boston, the magazine of the Federal
available (likely free) from Economic/
may be possible to arrange Reserve Bank-Boston,
for at least a partial local them at 600 Atlantic Ave., Community available (likely free) from
stop. The photographer, Boston, MA 02210, 617/ Development them at 600 Atlantic Ave.,
Eric Etheridge, published 973-3187, caroline.ellis Boston, MA 02210, 617/
the photos in a book of the @bos.frb.org [12785] 973-3187, caroline.ellis@
"Post-Katrina New
above title (214 pp., 2008, Orleans: A Welcoming bos.frb.org [12783]
Atlas & Co.-212/234- "Balancing Drug
Community?" is a special
3100). He can be reached at Policy" was a forum in the "School Testing,
4-page section, with lots of
eetheridge@gmail.com. Dec. 21, 2010 issue of The 1,2,3: Getting It Right,"
relevant data, in the Spring
Addl. inf. from the exhibit Nation. Among the by Karen Kurzman, is a 2-
2011 issue of Just South
organizers, The Skirball contributors: Ethan page article in the Summer
Quarterly, available
Cultural Center (2701 N. Nadelman, Marc Mauer, 2011 issue of Communities
(possibly free) from The
Sepulveda Blvd., LA, CA Bruce Western, David & Banking, the magazine of
Jesuit Social Research
90049), 310/440-4615, Cole. If you can't find it on the Federal Reserve Bank-
Institute of Loyola Univ.,
Erin Clancey, eclancey@ the Internet, we'll be happy Boston, available (likely
6363 St. Charles Ave., Box
skirball.org [12826] to mail you a copy if you free) from them at 600
94, New Orleans, LA
furnish a SASE. [12794] Atlantic Ave., Boston, MA
70118-6143, 504/864-7746,
jsri@loyno.edu, 02210, 617/973-3187,

20 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


caroline.ellis@bos.frb.org Summary, Nov. 2010), is Women from 1960 to the dictionary and forum.
[12784] available (possibly free) Present, by Gail Collins Further inf. from
from MDRC, 16 E. 34 St., (482 pp., 2009, $15.99), maria.williams@ health
CRESST (UCLA's NYC, NY 10016, 212/532- was published by Back Bay expertises.com [12791]
National Center for 3200, www.mdrc.org Books (Little, Brown).
Research on Evaluation, [12800] Copiously researched, well "Place Matters
Standards & Student written history by the NY National Conference,"
Testing) announces a new "Unless Our Children Times writer, which sponsored by the Joint
and expanded website Begin to Learn To- includes a good deal of Center for Political and
(CRESST.org). Check out gether...: The State of material on race. [12759] Economic Studies, will take
their just-published policy Education in Halifax place Sept. 7, 2011 in
brief on using student County, NC," by Mark "Getting to Scale: The Wash., DC. Guest speakers
assessments for teacher Dorosin, Elizabeth Haddix, Elusive Goal," a 28-page include (PRRAC Soc. Sci.
evaluations. [12787] Benita N. Jones & Christie updated 2011 paper, Adv. Bd. member) Dolores
L. Trice (68 pp., May highlights the Magnolia Acevedo-Garcia, Congress-
"The Other Lottery: 2011), is available (possibly Place (Seattle) Community woman Donna M.
Are Philanthropists free) from the UNC Center Initiative and how it uses Christensen, Gail Christo-
Backing the Best Charter for Civil Rights, Strengthening Families pher of the Kellogg
Schools?," by Andrew J. civilrights@unc.edu Protective Factors Frame- Foundation, Manuel Pastor
Coulson, is a 23-page, June [12815] work to galvanize commu- of USC and writer/activist
2011 CATO Institute Policy nity residents, organiza- Tim Wise. Inf. from
Analysis (#677), available "A Report Card on tional partners and existing HPI@jointcenter.org
from them ($6), 1000 District Achievement: initiatives to create a local [12776]
Mass. Ave. NW, Wash., How Low-Income, response to improve a
DC 20001, 800/767-1241. African-American, and community. Available
[12789] Latino Students Fare in (possibly free) from Casey Homelessness
California School Dis- Family Programs, 2001
"Our Climate Crisis Is tricts" (2011), from Eighth Ave., #2700, Free Laundry &
an Education Crisis" Education Trust-West, is Seattle, WA 98121, Drop-in Shower Re-
appears in the Spring 2011 downloadable at contactus@casey.org, sources: A listing of such,
issue of Rethinking Schools. www.edtrust.org/west/ www.casey.org [12796] with location and hours,
Available online at publication/a-report-card- was posted on a San
www.rethinkingschools.org on-district-achievement- "Child Care Instabil- Francisco neighborhood
and from them, 1001 E. how-low-income-african-- ity: Definitions, Context, public library bulletin
Keefe Ave., Milwaukee, american-and-latino.st. and Policy Implications," board -- a nice model for
WI 53212, 800/669-4192, [12829] by Gina Adams & Monica other cities. We can mail
bill@rethinkingschools.org Rohacek (45 pp., Oct. you a copy of the posted
[12797] "What Will It Take to 2010), is available (possibly notice if you supply a
Get Qualified, Effective free) from The Urban SASE. [12792]
"Who's Bashing Teachers in All Communi- Institute, 2100 M St. NW,
Teachers and Public ties?" was a May 29, 2011 Wash., DC 20037-1231, "'Simply Unaccept-
Schools and What We Center for American 202/833-7200, pubs@ able': Homelessness and
Can Do About It," by Stan Progress event. Among the urban.org [12817] the Human Right to
Karp, appears in the Spring panelists/presenters were Housing in the United
2011 issue of Rethinking (former PRRAC Bd. States 2011" (101 pp.,
Schools. Available online at member) Linda Darling- Health May 2011) is available (no
www.rethinkingschools.org Hammond and (PRRAC price listed) from The
and from them, 1001 E. Deputy Director) Saba "Can Neighborhoods National Law Center on
Keefe Ave., Milwaukee, Bireda. Inf. from Hurt Our Health?," by Homelessness & Poverty,
WI 53212, 800/669-4192, events@american Caitlin Eicher, appeared in 1411 K St. NW, #1400,
bill@rethinkingschools.org progress.org, 202/682- the Spring/Summer 2011 Wash., DC 20005, 202/
[12798] 1611. [12802] issue of Harvard Public 638-2535, www.nlchp.org
Health Review (Harvard [12805]
"Making Preschool School of Public Health, 90
More Productive: How Families/ Smith St., 4th flr., Boston, "A Systems Approach
Classroom Management MA 02120, 617/832-8470). to Solving Homelessness
Training Can Help Women/ [12773] and Other Problems" was
Teachers," by Pamela Children held June 16, 2011 at
Morris, C. Cybele Raver, HealthExpertises has a UMass-Boston. Inf. from
Megan Millenky, Stephanie When Everything website -- www.health 617/287-4824,
J. Jones & Chrishana M. Changed: The Amazing expertises.com -- dedicated shaleah.rather@ umb.edu
Lloyd (13-page Exec. Journey of American to advice, news, topics, [12790]

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 21


Housing "Children of Immi- Rural Taryn Scott, 1225 19th St.
grants: 2008 State Trends NW, #600, Wash., DC
"The Impact of Update," by Karina Fortuny "Collaboration: The 20036. [12761]
Housing Vouchers on (7 pp., Sept. 2010), is Key to Building Rural
Renters' Neighborhood available (possibly free) Communities" is the 23- The National Housing
Satisfaction: Understand- from The Urban Institute, page, 2010 Annual Report Trust (Wash., DC) is
ing the Perceptions and 2100 M St. NW, Wash., DC of the Housing Assistance hiring a Director, Federal
Constraints among 20037-1231, 202/833-7200, Council, available from Policy. Ltr./resume to
Assisted and Unassisted pubs@urban.org [12818] them (likely free) at 1025 cnickell@nhtinc.org
Renters," by Lauren M. Vermont Ave. NW, #606, [12762]
Ross, a 30-page paper "The Integration of Wash., DC 20005, 202/
presented at the March Immigrants and Their 842-8600, hac@ruralhome. The Washington Legal
2011 American Housing Families in Maryland," by org [12782] Clinic for the Homeless is
Survey Users Conference, Karina Fortuny, Ajay seeking a Staff Atty. for its
is available from the Chaudry, Margaret Simms Affordable Housing
author, Dept. Sociology, & Randolph Capps (68 pp., Transportation Initiative. Ltr./resume/
Temple Univ. Gladfelter June 2010), is available writing sample/3 refs. to
Hall, 7th flr., 1115 W. (possibly free) from The "Missed Opportunity: jobs@legalclinic.org
Berks St., Phila., PA Urban Institute, 2100 M St. Transit and Jobs in (Housing Attorney in
19122, Lmross@ NW, Wash., DC 20037- Metropolitan America," subject line) or mail to
temple.edu [12793] 1231, 202/833-7200, by Adie Tomer, Elizabeth WLCH, 1200 U St. NW,
pubs@urban.org [12819] Kneebone, Robert Puentes 3rd flr., Wash., DC 20009.
"Housing Rights for & Alan Berube (63 pp., [12766]
All: Promoting and Immigrants Raising May 2011), is available (no
Defending Housing Rights Citizens, by Hirokazu price listed) from The The Mississippi
in the United States" (5th Yoshikawa (208 pp., 2011, Brookings Metropolitan Center for Justice (Jack-
ed., 2011, 151 pp.) is $29.95), has been published Program, 1775 Mass. Ave. son, MS) is seeking
available (no price listed) by The Russell Sage NW, Wash., DC 20036- applicants for an
from the National Law Foundation, 112 E. 64 St., 2188, 202/797-6000, www. AmericaCorps Legal
Center on Homelessness & NYC, NY 10065. [12828] brookings.edu [12801] Fellow position. $40,400.
Poverty, 1411 K St. NW, Ltr./resume/3 profl.refs./
#1400, Wash., DC 20005, Immigrant Communi- writing sample to Beth
202/638-2535, info@nlchp. ties and Fair Housing, a Orlansky, Miss. Ctr. for
org, www.nlchp.org networking/training confer-
Job Justice, PO box 1023,
[12803] ence, co-sponsored by HUD, Opportunities/ Jackson, MS 39215-1023,
PRRAC, The National Fellowships/ 601/352-2269, borlansky@
"End Game: Under- Council of LaRaza and The mscenterforjustice.org
standing the Bitter End of Equal Rights Center, will be
Grants
Evictions," by Michael D. held July 22, 2011 in DC. The Sentencing
Gottesman, is a 68-page, Inf. from 202/402-4103, Relman, Dane & Project is hiring a Re-
2007 article that appeared gregory.h.crespo@hud.gov Colfax, a leading civil search Analyst. Ltr./
in (Yale) Student Scholar- rights law firm, is hiring a resume/writing sample to
ship Papers 48. Available Litigation Associate. Ltr./ Hiring Coordinator,
at http://digitalcommons. resume/one legal writing Sentencing Project, 1705
International sample/law school tran-
law.yale.edu/student_ DeSales St. NW, Wash.,
papers/48 [12820] Human Rights script/names-tel. #s of 3 DC 20036, employment@
and U.S. Civil refs. to careers@ sentencingproject.org
relmanlaw.com or mail to
Immigration Rights Policy Taryn Scott, 1225 19th St. The American Youth
NW, #600, Wash., DC Policy Forum is hiring a
"A Human Rights 20036. [12760]
"The Role of Immi- Program Associate.
Response to the Economic
gration in Fostering Resume/ltr. with salary
Crisis in the U.S.," by Relman, Dane &
Competitiveness in the reqs./writing sample/
Radhika Balakrishnan, James Colfax, a leading civil
United States" (25 pp., complete inf. for 3 refs.
Heintz & Stephanie Seguino, rights law firm, is hiring a
May 2011), is available (Program Associate
is an 8-page, June 2009 Fair Lending Compliance
(possibly free) from The Search in subject line) by
report from the Rutgers Associate/Counsel. Ltr./
Migration Policy Institute, July 18 to cwilson@aypf.
Center for Women's Global resume/one legal writing
1400 16th St., #300, org or fax to 202/775-9733
Leadership. Possibly free, sample/law school tran-
Wash., DC 20036, 202/ or mail to the Forum at
from www.cwgl.rutgers.edu script/names-tel. #s of 3
266-1940, www.migration 1836 Jefferson Pl. NW,
[12807] refs. to careers@
policy.org [12816] Wash., DC 20036.
relmanlaw.com or mail to

22 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 July/August 2011


PRRAC'S SOCIAL SCIENCE ADVISORY BOARD

Dolores Acevedo-Garcia Fernando Mendoza


Bouv College of Health Sciences, Northeastern Univ. Department of Pediatrics, Stanford Univ.

Camille Zubrinsky Charles Roslyn Arlin Mickelson


Department of Sociology, Univ. of Pennsylvania Univ. of No. Carolina-Charlotte

Stefanie DeLuca Pedro Noguera


Johns Hopkins Univ. New York Univ. School of Education

Ingrid Gould Ellen Paul Ong


New York Univ. UCLA School of Public Policy
Wagner School of Public Service & Social Research

Lance Freeman Gary Orfield


Columbia Univ. School of Architecture, UCLA Civil Rights Project
Planning and Preservation
Gregory D. Squires
John Goering Department of Sociology, George Washington Univ.
Baruch College, City Univ. of New York
Margery Austin Turner
Heidi Hartmann The Urban Institute (Wash., DC)
Inst. for Womens Policy Research (Wash., DC)
Margaret Weir
William Kornblum Department of Political Science
CUNY Center for Social Research Univ. of California, Berkeley

Harriette McAdoo David Williams


Michigan State Department of Sociology Harvard School of Public Health

If You Are Not Already a P&R Subscriber,


Please Use the Coupon Below.
Sign Me Up! 1 year ($25) or 2 years ($45)

Please enclose check made out to PRRAC or a purchase order from your institution.

Name _____________________________________________________________________________________
Address ___________________________________________________________________________________
Address Line 2 _____________________________________________________________________________
City, State, Zip _____________________________________________________________________________

Telephone: ____________________________ email: _________________________________________

Mail to: Poverty & Race Research Action Council


1200 18th Street NW Suite 200 Washington, DC 20036

July/August 2011 Poverty & Race Vol. 20, No. 4 23


Poverty & Race Research Action Council Nonprofit
U.S. Postage
1200 18th Street NW Suite 200 PAID
Washington, DC 20036 Jefferson City, MO
Permit No. 210
202/906-8023 FAX: 202/842-2885
E-mail: info@prrac.org
Website: www.prrac.org

Address Service Requested


7-8/11

PRRACs Combined Federal Campaign number is 11710

POVERTY & RACE RESEARCH ACTION COUNCIL


Board of Directors/Staff
CHAIR Janis Bowdler Demetria McCain Camille Wood
John Charles Boger National Council Inclusive Communities National Legal Aid &
University of North Carolina of La Raza Project Defender Assn.
School of Law Washington, DC Dallas, TX Washington, DC
Chapel Hill, NC John Brittain S.M. Miller
University of the District The Commonwealth Institute [Organizations listed for
identification purposes only]
VICE-CHAIR of Columbia School of Cambridge, MA
Jos Padilla Law Don Nakanishi Philip Tegeler
California Rural Legal Washington, DC University of California President/Executive Director
Assistance Sheryll Cashin Los Angeles, CA
San Francisco, CA Georgetown University Dennis Parker Saba Bireda
Law Center American Civil Liberties Deputy Director
SECRETARY Washington, DC Union Chester Hartman
john powell Craig Flournoy New York, NY Director of Research
Kirwan Institute for the Study Southern Methodist Anthony Sarmiento
of Race & Ethnicity University Senior Service America Kami Kruckenberg
Ohio State University Dallas, TX Silver Spring, MD Policy Associate
Columbus,OH Damon Hewitt Theodore Shaw
Lauren Hill
NAACP Legal Defense Columbia Law School
Development & Government
TREASURER and Educational New York, NY
Relations Associate
Spence Limbocker Fund, Inc. Brian Smedley
Neighborhood Funders New York, NY Health Policy Institute Cara Brumfield
Group Olati Johnson Joint Center for Political and Bill Emerson National
Columbia Law School Economic Studies Hunger Fellow
Annandale, VA
New York, NY Washington, DC Victoria Ajayi
Elizabeth Julian Catherine Tactaquin Law & Policy Intern
Inclusive Communities National Network for
Project Immigrant & Refugee Rights Alyssa Wallace
Dallas, TX Oakland, CA Law & Policy Intern
Jasmine Jeffers
Policy Intern

You might also like