Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a ABSTRACT
Department of Neurology,
UT-Health, Houston, Texas, We present a model hypothesis of how several types of cell therapies may target microglia as
USA; bDepartment of
one of the principal cell types contributing to the inammatory response after brain injury and
Pediatric Surgery, UT-Health,
discuss how imaging of brain inammation could potentially be applied to develop biomarkers
Houston, Texas, USA
in patients with stroke and TBI enrolled into stem cell clinical trials. STEM CELLS 2016;34:537
Correspondence: Sean I. Savitz, 542
M.D., Departments of
Neurology and Pediatric Surgery,
UT-Health, 6431 Fannin Street,
Houston, Texas 77030, USA. Cellular therapies are advancing from bench to brain parenchyma including lymphocytes, neu-
Telephone: 713-500-7083; clinical studies for acute neurological disorders trophils, and monocytes [2], all of which can
Fax: 713-500-0692; e-mail: such as ischemic stroke, brain hemorrhage, exacerbate on-going neuronal damage after an
sean.i.savitz@uth.tmc.edu
and traumatic brain injury (TBI). Over two dec- acute brain injury. In the periphery, the spleen
Received August 17, 2015; ades ago, the main intentions of using stem contracts and, as a reservoir of white blood
accepted for publication cells were to promote cell replacement and cells, releases a number of different inamma-
September 22, 2015; rst restore neural connections that were damaged tory cells and cytokines that invade and cause
published online in STEM CELLS
EXPRESS February 4, 2016;
after central nervous system injury. A surge of further injury in the brain [35]. Microglia,
available online without experimental data in the past few years now which derive from both resident cells in the
subscription through the open supports an entirely different paradigm in brain and inltrating monocytes, also become
access option. which cell therapies modulate the immune activated, migrate to injured areas, and exert
C AlphaMed Press
V
response to injury, reduce secondary neuronal dual effects depending on their phenotype.
1066-5099/2016/$30.00/0 degeneration, and enhance endogenous repair Microglia that assume a TH-1 phenotype
processes. Recent published studies are now release proinammatory cytokines and oxida-
http://dx.doi.org/ converging around microglia, which is a well- tive mediators that are detrimental to surviv-
10.1002/stem.2253
known mediator of brain inammation, as one ing neurons (M1) while microglia assuming a
of the principal cell types modulated by differ- TH-2 phenotype tend to release neurotrophic
ent types of cell therapies. As we learn more factors, prevent neuronal death, and promote
about the specic mechanisms involved, suc- brain repair (M2) [6]. Activated microglia also
cessful translation of cell therapies for acute links with the peripheral immune response as
brain disorders will require identifying bio- they can direct circulating lymphocytes to the
markers of activity in patients. We present a brain. Loane et al. demonstrated that the pro-
model hypothesis of how several types of cell gressive neurodegenerative response to trau-
therapies may target microglia as one of the matic brain injury is associated with chronic
principal cell types contributing to the inam- microglial activation [7]. The chronic microglial
matory response after brain injury and discuss activation was associated with myelin loss up
how imaging of brain inammation could to 1 year post-injury. These data are important
potentially be applied to develop biomarkers because the chronic inammatory response
in patients with stroke and TBI enrolled into has been ignored as a therapeutic target,
stem cell clinical trials. despite the fact that chronic white matter loss
has been documented in post-injury patients
and the degree of tissue loss is inversely corre-
INFLAMMATORY RESPONSE lated with neurocognitive outcomes [810].
After stroke and traumatic brain injury (TBI),
there is a brisk inammatory response orches- STEM CELLS AND THEIR EFFECTS ON
trated by immune cells originating from
INFLAMMATION AND THE SPLEEN
peripheral tissues and from within the brain
[1]. Sequential but overlapping phases of Various types of cell therapies have been
immune cells from the periphery inltrate the found to reduce neurological decits and
Figure 2. Traumatic brain injury (TBI) induces transporter protein (TSPO) staining in the ipsilateral hippocampus. (A): Photomicrograph
of a control slice at 28 days post injury (23). (B): Photomicrograph of thalamus of a control slice at 28 days post injury (203). Inset at
CA3 region of hippocampus (ipsilateral to injury) (203). (C): Photomicrograph of a TBI slice at 28 days post injury (23). (D): Photomicro-
graph of thalamus of a TBI slice at 28 days post injury (203). (E): Graph of presence of TSPO 1 staining in thalamus in control versus
TBI. Abbreviations: CA, cornu ammonis; TBI, traumatic brain injury; TSPO, transporter protein.
causes ongoing and progressive degeneration over time. progressive neuronal loss. They hypothesize that increased
White matter tracts are selectively vulnerable to continued TSPO expression on microglia serves to enhance protective
structural damage after trauma (Fig. 1). Microglia may be one neurosteroidogenesis that serves to promote neuronal sur-
of the major cell types contributing to progressive injury as vival. However, they noted an association with increased neu-
they remain after TBI for up to 1 year within white matter ronal cell loss adjacent to the TSPO upregulated microglia
tract regions of the corpus callosum and other areas [31]. His- (activated). We have replicated their data using the same con-
tological analyses have shown that activated microglia in the trolled cortical impact injury model in rodents, but with an
chronic stages of injury express markers of neurotoxic M1 anti-PBR Ab (Fig. 2). Human autopsy studies have veried
phenotypes at the edges of expanding cortical lesions rather that neuroinammation persists for months to years after TBI;
than M2 phenotypes, suggesting a predominance of M1 over activated microglia can be found in white matter regions asso-
M2 cell types at chronic time points after injury. Rao et al. ciated with axonal degeneration and in the thalami coinciding
demonstrated that TSPO binding of 11C PK11195 in microglia/ with neuronal degeneration. PET imaging in patients indeed
macrophages localized to the ipsilateral hippocampus and conrms increased PK11195 labeling in various cortical and
thalamus as a function of time. These authors note the dual- subcortical regions of the brain remote from the focal injury
ity of the inammatory response that can be adaptive and 11 months to 17 years after TBI and that microglial activation
protective in controlled, limited intensity, but if prolonged or correlated inversely with level of consciousness,. These
amplied, the microglial response can be associated with studies strongly support the idea that chronic inammation
Figure 4. By convention, the probability of the direction of water molecule diffusion in the brain is shown by red, blue, and green,
representing leftright, superiorinferior, and anteriorposterior directions, respectively. The fractional anisotropy (FA) value scales from
0 to 1, where zero mean isotropic and one means anisotropic diffusion; a lower FA indicates reduced microstructural integrity. The corti-
cal spinal tract, which courses through the rostral pons is shown by the blue color. In (A), the blue color in the ipsilesional pons is con-
taminated with red and has a lower FA, indicating microstructural damage, compared with the contralesional side. Serially, (BF)
following treatment with bone marrow mononuclear cells, the FA value of the ipsilesional pons increased which is shown by an increase
in blue coloration. These results suggest return of microstructural integrity in the pons. Photo provided by Muhammad Haque PhD who
performed the imaging analysis.
IMAGING HOW CELL THERAPIES MAY PREVENT ON-GOING microglia contributing to on-going inammation in the chronic
STRUCTURAL INJURY TO GREY AND WHITE MATTER stages of stroke and TBI raises the prospects that cell thera-
pies might have a therapeutic role to play in these patients
As microglia contributes to on-going secondary degeneration, months to years after injury. Even an intravenous delivery
visualizing macrostructural changes in the brain could also could conceivably be effective to reduce activated microglia in
serve as potential biomarkers for cell therapies. In pediatric chronically disabled patients after stroke or TBI. Observational
patients with TBI, MRI studies have shown reductions in studies are therefore needed to better address the temporal
whole brain volume (intracranial volume), grey matter, white and spatial distribution of microglial inammation and their
matter, and concomitant increases in cerebrospinal uid space potential causal association with impairments in patients
when compared with age matched controls at 1 year post- chronically disabled by brain injury. The challenge for these
injury [35]. Adult patients with TBI show similar degrees of studies is related to the radioligand T1/2 which requires single
grey and white matter volume loss over a similar time frame dose manufacturing that necessarily occurs physically adjacent
[7]. Several studies indicate that volumetric loss of grey and
to an advanced imaging facility capable of caring for fragile
white matter correlates strongly with functional outcomes in
patients. Ideally, serial PET-DT MRI imaging could be per-
TBI [8, 10]. We performed a pilot study testing intravenous
formed in patients after TBI or stroke. These studies would be
autologous bone marrow mononuclear cells in 10 pediatric
descriptive/observational, then interventions targeting micro-
patients with acute TBI. MRI-based volumetric analyses sug-
glial activation would be tested.
gested that there was no volume loss in grey or white matter
and there was no increase in ventricular space at the 6-
month time point compared with the 1 month time point
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
post-injury (Fig. 3) [36]. We are conducting a randomized The work was supported by the Bentsen Stroke Center and
sham control trial to verify these ndings. Therefore, struc- the NIH Grant R01-NS071127.
tural preservation or prevention of degeneration may prove
to be a very useful imaging surrogate for certain cell therapies
applied in the acute setting of TBI. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
At the microstructural level, diffusion tensor imaging,
another imaging sequence of MRI, provides information about S.I.S.: conception and design, nancial support, manuscript
the direction dependent diffusion of water molecules along writing, nal approval of manuscript; C.S.C.: conception and
white matter tracts. Fractional anisotropy (FA) derived from design, manuscript writing, nal approval of manuscript.
DTI provides measurements of the tissue integrity of specic
white matter tracts. Reductions in FA of individual tracts cor-
DISCLOSURE OF POTENTIAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
relate with impairments in TBI and stroke [9, 33, 37, 38]. Fig-
ure 1 shows the progressive loss of white matter tracts on As an employee of the institution (UT-HEALTH), Dr. Savitz has
diffusion tensor imaging of the corpus collosum in an served as a site investigator in clinical trials run by industry
untreated, control TBI patient enrolled in one of our stem cell companies- Aldagen, Athersys, Janssen, Genentech, Pzer for
trials. Figure 4 shows serial diffusion tensor imaging of the which UT-HEALTH receives payments on the basis of clinical
corticospinal tract in a stroke patient treated with autologous trial contracts. As an employee of UT-HEALTH, Dr. Savitz
bone marrow mononuclear cells. These types of measure- serves as an investigator on clinical trials supported by NIH
ments may prove very useful to dene biomarkers of treat- grants, Lets Cure CP, the TIRR Foundation, and the Cord
ment effects of cell therapies. Blood Registry Systems. As an employee of UT-HEALTH, Dr.
Savitz is a principal investigator on an NIH funded grant in
basic science research. As an employee of the institution
IMPLICATIONS FOR CELL THERAPIES AS TREATMENTS FOR
(UT-HEALTH), Dr. Savitz has served on the data safety monitor-
CHRONIC DISABILITY DUE TO STROKE AND TBI ing board committee for a trial sponsored by SanBio.
The foregoing discussion indicates that microglia may not only Whereas UT-HEALTH employs Dr. Savitz with expertise in
prove to be an important target for cell therapies in acute stroke, UT-HEALTH serves as a consultant to Neuralstem, San-
neurological disorders but may also be important in the Bio, Mesoblast, ReNeuron, Lumosa, Celgene, Dart Neuro-
chronic stages of these disorders. The presence of persistent science, and Aldagen. All funding goes to the institution.
lowing pediatric traumatic brain injury. Dev 20 Yang B, Hamilton J, Strong R et al. astrocytes based on immunohistochemical
Neurosci 2010;32:361373. Human multipotential bone marrow stem localization in abnormal human brain. Neuro-
10 Ding K, Marquez de la Plata C, Wang JY cells exert immunomodulatory effects, pre- pathol Appl Neurobiol 2009;35:306328.
et al. Cerebral atrophy after traumatic white vent splenic contraction, and enhance func- 30 Ramlackhansingh AF, Brooks DJ,
matter injury: Correlation with acute neuroi- tional recovery in a rodent model of Greewood RJ et al. Inammation after
maging and outcome. J Neurotrauma 2008; ischemic stroke. Stroke 2011;42:E67E67. trauma: Microglial activation and traumatic
25:14331440. 21 Lee ST, Chu K, Jung KH et al. Anti- brain injury. Ann Neurol 2011;70:374383.
11 Schwarting S, Litwak S, Hao W et al. inammatory mechanism of intravascular 31 Loane DJ, Kumar A, Stoica BA et al. Pro-
Hematopoietic stem cells reduce postisch- neural stem cell transplantation in haemor- gressive neurodegeneration after experimen-
emic inammation and ameliorate ischemic rhagic stroke. Brain 2008;131:616629. tal brain trauma: Association with chronic
brain injury. Stroke 2008;39:28672875. 22 Womble TA, Green S, Shahaduzzaman M microglial activation. J Neuropathol Exp Neu-
12 Yang B, Migliati E, Parsha K et al. Intra- et al. Monocytes are essential for the neuro- rol 2014;73:1429.
arterial delivery is not superior to intrave- protective effect of human cord blood cells 32 Walberer M, Jantzen SU, Backes H et al.
nous delivery of autologous bone marrow following middle cerebral artery occlusion in In-vivo detection of inammation and neuro-
mononuclear cells in acute ischemic stroke. rat. Mol Cell Neurosci 2014;59:7684. degeneration in the chronic phase after per-
Stroke 2013;44:34633472. 23 Ohtaki H, Ylostalo JH, Foraker JE et al. manent embolic stroke in rats. Brain Res
13 Lee ST, Chu K, Jung KH et al. Anti- Stem/progenitor cells from bone marrow 2014;1581:8088.
inammatory mechanism of intravascular decrease neuronal death in global ischemia 33 Yu C, Zhu C, Zhang Y et al. A longitudi-
neural stem cell transplantation in haemor- by modulation of inammatory/immune nal diffusion tensor imaging study on Waller-
rhagic stroke. Brain 2008;131:616629. responses. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2008; ian degeneration of corticospinal tract after
14 Broughton BR, Lim R, Arumugam TV 105:1463814643. motor pathway stroke. Neuroimage 2009;15;
et al. Post-stroke inammation and the 24 Liu GJ, Middleton RJ, Hatty CR et al. The 47:451458.
potential efcacy of novel stem cell thera- 18 kDa translocator protein, microglia and 34 Thiel A, Radlinska BA, Paquette C et al.
pies: Focus on amnion epithelial cells. Front neuroinammation. Brain Pathol 2014;24: The temporal dynamics of poststroke neuro-
Cell Neurosci 2013;6. Article 66. 19. 631653. inammation: A longitudinal diffusion tensor
15 Bedi S, Walker PA, Shah SK et al. Autologous 25 Yoder KK, Nho K, Risacher SL et al. Inu- imaging-guided PET study with 11C-PK11195
bone marrow mononuclear cell therapy attenu- ence of TSPO genotype on 11C-PBR28 stand- in acute subcortical stroke. J Nucl Med 2010;
ates activated microglia/macrophage response ardized uptake values. J Nuclel Med 2013;54: 51:14041412.
and improves spatial learning after traumatic 13201322. 35 Wilde EA, Hunter JV, Newsome MR
brain injury. J Trauma 2013;75:410416. 26 Owen D, Howell, OW, Tang SP et al. Two et al. Frontal and temporal morphometric
16 Bedi SS, Hetz R, Thomas C et al. Intrave- binding sites for 3HPBR28 in human brain: ndings on MRI in children after moderate
nous multipotent adult progenitor cell ther- Implications for TSPO PET imaging of neuro- to severe traumatic brain injury.
apy improves spatial learning after traumatic inammation. J Cerebral Blood Flow Met J Neurotrauma 2005;22:333344.
brain injury. Stem Cells Translational Med 2010;30:16081618. 36 Cox CS, Baumgartner JE, Harting MT
2013;2:953960. 27 Kreisl WC, Jenko KH, Hinds CS et al. A et al. Autologous bone marrow mononuclear
17 Vendrame M, Gemma C, Pennypacker genetic polymorphism for translocator pro- cell therapy for severe traumatic brain injury
KR et al. Cord blood rescues stroke-induced tein 19kDa affects both in vitro and in vivo in children. Neurosurgery 2011;68:588600.
changes in splenocyte phenotype and func- radioligand binding in human brain to this 37 Ewing-Cobbs L, Prasad MR, Swank P
tion. Exp Neurol 2006;199:191200. putative biomarker of neuroinammation. et al. Arrested development and disrupted
18 Schwarting S, Litwak S, Hao W et al. J Cerebral Blood Flow Met 2013;33:5358. callosal microstructure following pediatric
Hematopoietic stem cells reduce postisch- 28 Schroeter M, Dennin MA, Walberer M traumatic brain injury: Relation to neuro-
emic inammation and ameliorate ischemic et al. Neuroinammation extends brain tissue behavioral outcomes. Neuroimage 2008;42:
brain injury. Stroke 2008;39:28672875. at risk to vital peri-infarct tissue: A double 13051315.
19 Walker PA, Shah SK, Jimenez F et al., Intra- tracer [11C]PK11195- and [18F]FDG-PET study. 38 Bendlin BB, Ries ML, Lazar M et al. Lon-
venous multipotent adult progenitor cell therapy J Cereb Blood Flow Metab 2009;29:12161225. gitudinal changes in patients with traumatic
for traumatic brain injury: Preserving the blood:- 29 Cosensa-Nashat M, Zhao ML, Suh HS brain injury assessed with diffusion-tensor
brain barrier via an interaction with splenocytes. et al. Expression of the translocator protein and volumetric imaging. Neuroimage 2008;
Exp Neurol 2010;225:341352. of 18 kDa by microglia, macrophages and 42:503514.