pk

© All Rights Reserved

14 views

On the Law of Capacitance and Planck's Constant

pk

© All Rights Reserved

- AP Chemistry, Chapter Seven Vocabulary
- Anatomy of an Electromagnetic Wave
- (IIT JEE Advanced IITJEE) Arvind Tiwari Sachin Singh - Pathfinder Physics for Olympiad and IIT JEE Advanced Arvind Tiwari Sachin Singh Pearson-Pearson (2019)
- Physical Science Gr 12 Nsc Examination Guidelines (Eng)1
- Chemistry: Quantum Theory and Electronic Structure of Electrons.
- Symbol
- STWAVE
- Sounds, Physics, And Music
- Lamb Hydrodynamics
- Body & Society 2010 Henriques 57 89
- Alternating Current Circuit by Corcoran
- IFEM.Ch32
- S. Sridhar- Nonlinear Dynamics of Wave Propagation in Heterogeneous Excitable Media
- Fiitjee phase test paper
- rainbow xylophone v2
- inf3
- Physical Science Chapter 10 (New Book) .ppt
- Big Idea Mini
- Overview of Sound Waves
- Pre-Polytechnic Test PPT_2013

You are on page 1of 6

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/315673346

DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.32461.84963

CITATIONS READS

0 165

1 author:

Lori Gardi

Western University

51 PUBLICATIONS 638 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

3D Ultrasound Guided Mechatronic Aided Surgical and Biopsy Procedures View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Lori Gardi on 28 March 2017.

Plancks Constant and the Law of Capacitance

Lori-Anne Gardi

Senior Software Developer, Robarts Research Institute, Western University

lori.anne.gardi@gmail.com

Abstract

Using the law of capacitance, the exact value of Plancks constant is derived from scratch. The assumption here is

that the energy of light is directly related to the phenomenon of capacitance.

1 Introduction

Although Plancks constant, h, is a common character in the equations of theoretical physics, the reason for

its exact value is not well understood. This value was derived empirically by Max Planck in the early 1900s

and has been used, as is, ever since. A literature search shows that this value has never been derived from

first principles. In this article, the exact value of Plancks constant is derived using the law of capacitance.

Since light waves are often thought of as plane waves, the parallel plate capacitor seems well suited for this

derivation. Some assumptions are made about the geometry of the photon in this article. The validity of

these assumptions is discussed in Section 3.

The equation used to calculate the capacitance of a parallel plate capacitor is as follows:

A LW

C = 0 = 0 (1)

d d

Here, 0 is the permittivity of free space, A is the surface area of each plate (A = L x W ), and d is the distance

between the plates. Notice that as you decrease the distance between the plates, capacitance increases and

as you decrease the surface area, capacitance decreases. Although this may seem trivial to mention, it is an

important point for the purpose of this discussion. Next, we substitute L, W and d with the wavelength of

light, as follows:

C = 0 = 0 (2)

Here, the assumption is made that L = W = d = . This seems reasonable since the wavelength, , is the

only quantifiable feature of a single oscillation of light. Frequency of light is related to wavelength by the

following formula:

c

= (3)

f

This will be used later to derive equaiton (9). The potential energy of a capacitor takes the following form:

1 Q2

E= (4)

2 C

Replacing C with equation (2) gives the following:

1 Q2

E= (5)

2 0

It was noticed in the literature that the permittivity constant, 0 , is almost always accompanied by the con-

stant, 4. Here, the atomic unit of permittivity, defined by NIST, [1] is as follows:

1 = 40 (6)

In order put 1 into the equation, we multiply equation (5) by 4/4 and simplify:

1 Q2 4 2 Q2

E= = (7)

2 0 4 1

Now, we are going to substitute Q2 with the elementary charge of a particle, e:

2 e2

E= (8)

1

Substituting (3 into 8) gives the following:

2 e2

E=[ ]f (9)

1 c

This equation is starting to look like Plancks energy equation, E = hf ; however, the quantity in brackets

does not evaluate to Plancks constant, h, until we apply the fine structure constant as follows:

2 e2

E=[ ]f (10)

1 c

Here, the quantity in square brackets evaluates to exactly Plancks constant. But where does come from?

Elementary charge is related to Planck charge, qpl , by the following:

e2

2

qpl = 20 h c = 2 = 2.2102 1035 (11)

This allows us to simplify (10) to the following:

2

qpl

E=[ ]f (12)

1 c

In other words:

2

qpl

h= (13)

1 c

Understanding the recipricol nature of permittivity and permeability (c 1 = 1/c 1 ), allows us to write

equation (13) in terms of the permeability of free space, as follows:

2

h = qpl 1 c (14)

Here, 1 = 0 /4.

Equations (13) and (14) give us a clean look at Plancks constant without any unitless constants such as 2,

4 and which unnecessarily complicate the equations. (In computer science, this is referred to as code

cleanup). Here, Plancks constant is defined in terms of the permittivity of free space, the permeability of

free space, the rate of propagation of a wave in free space and Planck charge which here, interprets as the

charge associated with free space. What does this mean for the theory of light?

3 Discussion

It is commonly understood that higher frequency light carries more energy than lower frequency light. This

is why a high frequency ultraviolet light can do more damage to our skin than infra red light. This is also why

X-rays and gamma rays are so dangerous. Here, I am going to argue that one unit of light (one wavelength

of light) carries one unit of energy, that is, the energy equal to Plancks constant, h. Historically, Plancks

constant is assigned the units of action, however, in a previous paper by the author [2], an argument is made

for Plancks constant as an energy constant. This is the energy per one cycle or oscillation of a light wave.

Figure 1 will be used to help understand this logic:

Figure 1 : This figure depicts light waves at three different frequencies. At the right is a detector

of some sort. The vertical parallel lines to the left of each wave represent the parallel plates of

a (virtual) capacitor occupying one wave length of the wave. The small dot within the capacitor

represents the energy contained within each wave. Each dot has energy, E, equal to Plancks

constant, i.e., 6.62607004 1034 [J].

Figure 1 is a depiction of three different light waves of different frequencies (i.e., different wavelengths).

The one on the top has a lower frequency (larger wavelength). The one on the bottom has a higher frequency

(smaller wavelength). In order for L = W = d in equation (2), the size of the wave must change with the

frequency of the wave. In terms of the parallel plate capacitor analogy, as the distance between the plates gets

smaller (which increases capacitance), the surface area of the plates must also get smaller (which decreases

capacitance). This ensures that each wavelength, , of light will carry the same energy (Plancks constant or

h), no matter what the frequency. This, I propose, is the true meaning behind Plancks constant. In Figure 1,

energy is quantized by h, regardless of frequency.

Although this may sound counter-intuitive in terms of standard thinking, with a small change in per-

spective, this is easily explained. Since the speed of light, c, is constant, all of these waves are propagating

(moving toward the detector) at the same rate. We can see from Figure 1 that more energy units will hit

the detector per unit time in the bottom wave than in the top wave. This explains why higher frequency

light carries more energy than lower frequency light. Higher frequency light transports more energy to

the detector per unit time. Using this logic, it is clear to see that every single oscillation of light (which is

not a photon) carries the same energy regardless of wavelength. In other words, photons, ill-defined by the

standard model as fundamental particles, in reality correspond to the transport of energy per unit time to a

detector (or from an emitter). The real fundamental particle is the particle associated with one unit of energy,

h which I affectionately refered to in a previous paper [3] as an OM particle. The photon of the standard

model, according to the logic presented herein, is merely a misunderstanding of the nature of light and, by

definition, cannot be fundamental.

This line of thinking explain why, when you bring two parallel plate capacitors together, the capacitor

can store more charge. This is easily explained using Figure 2.

Figure 2 : This figure depicts a capacitor with various distances, d, between the parallel plates.

As you can see, the capacitor with the smallest distance between the capacitor is able to store

more energy units than the capacitor with a larger distance.

Using the model presented in Figure 2, the capacitor with the smaller spacing is able to store more

energy units than the capacitor with a larger spacing. This is because the capacitor with the larger spacing

can only store the energy of a few wavelengths whereas the capacitor with the smaller spacing can store

the energy of many wavelengths. In the model presented herein, each wavelength contains only one unit of

energy equal to Plancks constant, h [J].

4 Conclusion

Using the law of capacitance and the analogy of a parallel plate capacitor, the exact value of Plancks constant

is derived from scratch. This leads to an alternate way of describing light that has each wavelength of light

carrying the same unit of energy. In this model, a photon corresponds to the number of energy units

transported per unit time. This line of thinking gives a logical explanation as to why parallel plate capacitors

can store more energy units when the spacing between the parallel plates is decreased.

5 Acknowledgements

Special thanks to Lane Davis for the idea of modelling the photon as a parallel plate capacitor[4]. Although

my approach was slightly different than yours, the idea of relating the photon to the law of capacitance came

directly from your paper and our discussions.

References

From: http://physics.nist.gov/constants, All values (ascii),

http://physics.nist.gov/cuu/Constants/Table/allascii.txt, (retrieved, Feb. 13, 2017).

[2] Gardi, Lori-Anne. Calibrating the universe, and why we need to do it. Physics Essays 29.3 (2016):

327-336.

[3] Gardi, L. The Mandelbrot set and the fractal nature of light, the Universe, and everything. SPIE

Optical Engineering+ Applications. International Society for Optics and Photonics, 2013.

[4] Davis, Lane M. Quantized Capacitance and Energy of the Atom and Photon. (2015).

- AP Chemistry, Chapter Seven VocabularyUploaded byHelie
- Anatomy of an Electromagnetic WaveUploaded byRavishankar Rs
- (IIT JEE Advanced IITJEE) Arvind Tiwari Sachin Singh - Pathfinder Physics for Olympiad and IIT JEE Advanced Arvind Tiwari Sachin Singh Pearson-Pearson (2019)Uploaded bynghiachi.com
- Physical Science Gr 12 Nsc Examination Guidelines (Eng)1Uploaded byrhinox7
- Chemistry: Quantum Theory and Electronic Structure of Electrons.Uploaded byjonasestrada97
- STWAVEUploaded byDudu Dudu
- Sounds, Physics, And MusicUploaded byElizabeth Grace Rambo
- Lamb HydrodynamicsUploaded byMary Gilliam
- SymbolUploaded byAnonymous JZFSB3D
- Body & Society 2010 Henriques 57 89Uploaded byLester Worthy
- Alternating Current Circuit by CorcoranUploaded byMahmudur Rahman
- IFEM.Ch32Uploaded byvsbalint
- S. Sridhar- Nonlinear Dynamics of Wave Propagation in Heterogeneous Excitable MediaUploaded byGretymj
- Fiitjee phase test paperUploaded byNaveen Nayan
- rainbow xylophone v2Uploaded byapi-285146233
- inf3Uploaded byAnabell Tiban
- Physical Science Chapter 10 (New Book) .pptUploaded byburnsjo
- Big Idea MiniUploaded bybgm7966
- Overview of Sound WavesUploaded byEthan
- Pre-Polytechnic Test PPT_2013Uploaded byDeepak Kumar Rajak
- Bhimsen K. Shivamoggi Auth. Introduction to Nonlinear Fluid-Plasma WavesUploaded by陳琮方
- summative testUploaded byapi-380820076
- Ch 10Uploaded bycuteabhi47
- WirelessUploaded byfrancis dimakiling
- mar06.pdfUploaded byAnonymous 22YdY7k
- 1-s2.0-0734743X87900650-mainUploaded bykhalid naeem
- 2004 MCUploaded byTaylor Winkler
- Set-I-AUploaded bySachin Chakradhar
- Chapter 16, Concept Question.pdfUploaded byAnderson Eiji Kanawa
- 1. Measurements and ExperimentationUploaded byNitesh Dubey

- Eat Fat Cut the Carbs and Avoid Snacking to Reverse Obesity and Type 2 Diabetes National Obesity Forum Public Health CollaborationUploaded byAllahdino Channa
- license.txtUploaded bydb
- en-g5v2.pdfUploaded bydb
- NMEA_Format_v0.1Uploaded byTio Top
- 287-289_mveng0200Uploaded byscribdkhatn
- Licenciamiento adafruitUploaded byNivaldo Jose Vera Gurierrez
- New York NY Dramatic Mirror 1915 Jul-Aug 1916 Grayscale - 1566Uploaded bydb
- New York NY Morning Telegraph 1923 - 0605Uploaded bydb
- New York NY Times 1914 Oct 16-31 Grayscale (422)Uploaded bydb
- Billboard 1916 - 2878Uploaded bydb
- 287_289_umeng0206Uploaded bydb
- 2015-2_ShawkiUploaded bydb
- Core Mathematical Error of Special RelativityUploaded bydb
- Nadler 2003Uploaded bydb
- 7shawUploaded bydb
- 11804-Middle Earth Basic Roleplaying - Creatures Chapter 10 - image free version.pdfUploaded bydb
- Aff LockUploaded bydb
- Ted Naiman HyperinsulinemiaUploaded bydb
- EinsteinsVariableSpeedOfLight.pdfUploaded bydb
- André Koch Torres Assis auth. Weber’s Electrodynamics.pdfUploaded bydb
- Des Vignes 1999Uploaded bydb
- 32111-117474-2-PBUploaded bydb
- 1-s2.0-002191699400075Y-mainUploaded bydb
- 04HQGR0087Uploaded bydb
- b078b5c08ae7f30a6432438fb8aa8bbcaa7a.pdfUploaded bydb
- 16_4_BOSTON_04-72_0095Uploaded bydb
- srep11799Uploaded bydb
- peerj-2810Uploaded bydb

- P-18cUploaded byrathish14u
- 3 1 1 a vex inputsoutputsUploaded byapi-264098585
- 05 Physics 11se Ub EndUploaded bypecan_lisa38
- Pore pressure and Fracture gradient from well log - RotimiUploaded bySebastianChinome
- Homework 1Uploaded byAndrés García Arce
- HW#2Uploaded bydigital1dw
- principle of virtual work.docUploaded byArjun Bishoyi
- Midpoints - Unleashing the POwer Of The PlanetsUploaded byAngela Gibson
- Physics Student Guide for Operations TrainingUploaded byDeny Handoko
- GEOMATRYUploaded byAl-amin Kishor
- Temporal Gravity VariationUploaded byRhea Celzo
- ASTM Granulometría GACUploaded byFranco Buzz
- Abstract Algebra Dummit Foote Chapter 13 Field Theory SolutionsUploaded byGuilherme Batista da Silva
- wortley2015.pdfUploaded byCarlinhos Pinheiro
- Gas text_3Uploaded byBob
- Table of ContentsUploaded byVladimir Cosme Torres
- 48561377-Modelling-a-PV-Module-Using-Matlab.pdfUploaded byluysf5480
- mtechpscUploaded byAneesh KG
- 1601Flux trapping in superconducting accelerating cavities during cooling down with a spatial temperature gradient .02118v1Uploaded byLeonardo Argento
- Linear Convolution Program in c Language Using CCStudioUploaded byHarsha
- Freezing Point DepressionUploaded bypintuchemtech
- On the Application of Graph Colouring Techniques in Round-Robin Sports SchedulingUploaded bytestuser_scribd
- Epidemiology and Medical StatisticsUploaded bysilasnunu
- Background Noise Measurement in Different VendorsUploaded byajaykkaushik
- Be BoardUploaded byYap Wen Khong Yap Wen Khong
- Point-mass delta-function sources and Black Hole EntropyUploaded byKathryn Wilson
- Driving Performance With Business RulesUploaded byPatrick Ow
- Midterm Summer 2010Uploaded byMohsen Haj Hassan
- voice-morphingUploaded byPavithra Gunasekaran
- falseUploaded byPablo Camacho