You are on page 1of 8

Japanese Dental Science Review (2011) 47, 5—12

a v a i l a b l e a t w w w. s c i e n c e d i r e c t . c o m

journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jdsr

Review article

A review: Biodegradation of resin—dentin bonds


Masanori Hashimoto *, Futami Nagano, Kazuhiko Endo, Hiroki Ohno

Division of Biomaterials and Bioengineering, School of Dentistry, Health Sciences University of Hokkaido, 1757 Kanazawa,
Ishikari-Tobetsu, Hokkaido 061-0293, Japan

Received 17 August 2009; received in revised form 28 December 2009; accepted 15 February 2010

KEYWORDS Summary Resin—dentin bonding was first achieved through mechanical hybridization between
Adhesion; resin and collagen fibrils using a functional monomer containing resin system. In the last decade,
Hybrid layer; new adhesive resin systems were frequently released onto the market within a short-period of
Degradation; time. Before and after commercialization, the bond integrity has been tested by bond tests, and
Electron microscopy; leakage evaluation by researchers, but it is very difficult for clinicians to obtain a comprehensive,
Polymer; up-to-date understanding of their nature and degradation. Although newly developed adhesive
Resin adhesive resins have attempted to improve the bond strength at least in the first 24 h after bonding, the
long-term durability of the bonds has not yet been established analytically. However, numerous
recent studies have shown micromorphological evidence of biodegradation of resin—dentin
bonds, due to hydrolysis of the resin and collagen fibrils within the bonds. This review mainly
summarizes the most recent work in biodegradation of resin—dentin bonds based on micromor-
phological analyses of data obtained by scanning and transmission electron microscopy.
# 2011 Japanese Association for Dental Science. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Contents

1. Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2. Bond degradation of total-etch (etch-and-rinse) adhesives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
3. Bond degradation of self-etching adhesives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
4. Bond degradation of one-bottle self-etching adhesives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
5. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

1. Introduction
Many resin adhesive systems and types have been developed
and marketed in dentistry over the last two decades (Fig. 1).
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +81 133 23 1211; fax: +81 133 23 1960. The initial attempts at adhesion of resin concentrated on
E-mail addresses: masanori-h@mue.biglobe.ne.jp, enamel, the first successful attempts to achieve a micro-
has@hoku-iryo-u.ac.jp (M. Hashimoto). mechanical interlocking of resin tag formation with acid

1882-7616/$ — see front matter # 2011 Japanese Association for Dental Science. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jdsr.2010.02.001
6 M. Hashimoto et al.

Figure 1 Classification of adhesive resin systems. E: etchant;


P: primer; B: bonding resin (adhesive).

pretreatment being reported by Buonocore [1]. However,


resin bonding to dentin could not be achieved due to its Figure 2 Schematic illustration of bond structure of a self-
complicated structure involving surface moisture and the etching system and etch-and-rinse system (total-etching sys-
collagen network. Nakabayashi et al. reported micromecha- tem). The structure of the hybrid layer of total-etch adhesives
nical bonding of a functional monomer containing resin consists of resin and collagen fibrils. The combination of resin,
system (4-META/MMA-TBB) to collagen fibrils in deminera- collagen fibrils and inorganic matter (the smear layer) is a typical
lized dentin in 1982 [2]. Since a smear layer created during hybrid layer of self-etching adhesives. The hybrid layer of self-
tooth preparation has an adverse effect on dentin bonding etching systems is thinner than that of total-etching adhesives,
[3,4] due to weak adhesion to underling dentin [5], its due to the mild acidic effect of their acidic monomers on dentin.
removal by an acidic agent prior to application of a bonding
resin require to gain stronger bond strength. Acid-etching of steps into one component (Fig. 1). These adhesives can be
etch-and-rinse systems (total-etching system) demineralizes categorized as a self-etching system.
the dentin surface to expose a few-micron-thick collagen If the hybridized layer is impermeable to water or various
network providing space for resin infiltration. The following chemical stimuli, it could make dentin stable for long-term
application of a primer and/or adhesive penetrates into the clinical use. However, many studies have reported the long-
interfibrillar spaces of the collagen web, leading to the term water storage testing of resin—dentin bonds to measure
formation of a hybrid layer composed of collagen fibrils bond strength [11—23]. Most adhesives had decreased bond
and adhesive resin (Fig. 2). Wet bonding leaves the dentin
surface visibly moist after acid etching. This leads to
increased resin infiltration into the exposed collagen network
as a result of increasing bond strength [6,7]. However, the
degree of dentin surface wetness (i.e. moist, wet or over-
wet) greatly affects the bond strength in both the laboratory
and clinical situations. The depth of demineralization and
completeness of monomer diffusion affect the quality of the
hybrid layer. When the former exceeds the latter, a region of
naked collagen fibers is left exposed as a bond defect (Fig. 3).
For the first system of self-etching adhesives, an acidic
monomer of phenyl-P diffuses through extant smear layers to
reach the underlying calcium-rich dentin as a result of for-
mation of a hybrid layer where the smear layer remains in the
lower half of the hybrid layer [8,9]. The hybridization occurs Figure 3 Schematic illustration of demineralized dentin zone
among resin, collagen fibrils, and inorganic matter of the of total-etch adhesives. Inadequate resin infiltration into colla-
smear layer (Fig. 2). Theoretically, there are no deminera- gen fibrils leaves nano- or microspaces within the adhesive
lized dentin zones in the bond face because of the lack of acid interface. This zone is not common for self-etching adhesive
pretreatment [8—10]. This system is attractive to clinicians systems. Collagen hydrolysis of the demineralized dentin zone is
because it is thought the application step is simple and easy one of the degradation patterns for total-etch adhesives. In the
compared with total-etching systems with separate etching absence of a demineralized dentin zone within the bonds, this
and water rinsing step. collagen hydrolysis does not occur because the encapusulation of
Newly marketed one-bottle self-etching systems, have cured adhesive resins or protection of the mineral matrix of
been developed with a view to further simplifying the bond- dentin prevents chemical degradation of the collagen fibrils even
ing procedure, combining etching, priming, and bonding after long-term function.
A review: Biodegradation of resin-dentin bonds 7

strength to various extents after long-term water storage


such as for 6 months or 1 year. All such degradation is
accelerated in the presence of water [24,25]. The hydrolytic
effect of water on the adhesives itself is of great importance
when considering the bond degradation. Although the extent
of the bond strength reduction is similar for all types of
adhesives after aging, micromorphological examination is
able to demonstrate the various degradation phases for each
adhesive system in in vivo and in vitro. Since the bond
structure of the resin—dentin bond depends on the type of
adhesive, micromorphological analysis reveals various degra-
dation patterns of bonds after aging.
The objective of this article is to provide a critical review
of the degradation of resin—dentin bonds for all types of
adhesive systems.

2. Bond degradation of total-etch


(etch-and-rinse) adhesives
Acidic solutions (i.e. 35% phosphoric acid) are used to demi-
neralize the smear layer and the underlying intact dentin to
expose the collagen network. The incomplete impregnation
of the exposed collagen space by subsequent application of
bonding resin is due to imperfect resin monomer infiltration
(Fig. 3). The discrepancy between the depth of the collagen
layer and resin infiltration creates an exposed demineralized
dentin zone under the hybrid layer (Fig. 3) [26—35]. These
zones correspond with the sites of different modes of silver
nitrate staining within the hybrid layer. Spencer and Wang
reported resin monomer distribution in the demineralized
dentin zone, especially evaluating the heterogeneity of the
Figure 4 Scanning electron micrographs of fractured surface
monomer—collagen interaction, using micro-Raman spectro-
of resin—dentin bonded beams. A three-step total-etch adhesive
scopy [34,35]. In their publications, the differentiation of
were used for both specimens. Fractured surface were obtained
resin monomer diffusion was reveal to depend on the mole-
in the dentin side of specimen after microtensile bond test. A
cular weight of the monomer at the collagen network of the
fractured surface of control specimens (after 24 h of bonding) (a)
hybrid layer [34,35]. Using atomic force microscopy (AFM),
and that had been functioning in human oral cavity for 10 months
Marshall et al. observed in situ collagen morphology before
(b). The presence of lateral branches of dentinal tubules is
and after dentin surface treatment [36—38]. The zone of
morphological symptom of collagen depletion.
demineralized dentin and the degradation phase were found
morphologically using AFM analysis [29]. The exposed col-
lagen fibrils here underwent structural deterioration due to tion has also been morphologically found using SEM and TEM
hydrolytic degradation, resulting in decreasing bond strength in in vitro testing of a total-etching system with resin—dentin
[12,14—16]. In vivo morphological evidence of collagen bonded beams after 1 year of water storage [12,14—16].
hydrolysis was first obtained using extracted human primary Several in vitro studies using morphological analysis have
teeth with resin restorations [12,39]. Fig. 4 shows collagen shown hydrolytic degradation of the collagen mesh in the
degradation within the demineralized dentin in the fractured resin—dentin interface in specimens stored in water for over
surface of a resin—dentin bonded specimen (Scotchbond 1 year [29,39,40]. Transmission electron microscopic exam-
Multi-Purpose) that functioned in the human oral environ- inations have shown the deformation of less stainable col-
ment for 10 months (Fig. 4b). Although an intact hybrid layer lagen fibrils as an indicator of collagen chemical degradation
is visible in the control specimen at 24 h after bonding [16,41]. This hydrolysis of collagen greatly affects the long-
(Fig. 4a), hydrolytic degradation of collagen fibrils term bond stability of total-etch adhesive systems. One
(Fig. 4b) is clearly observed after aging. There are many reason for this collagen hydrolysis may be the effects of
lateral branches of dentinal tubules at the fractured surfaces saliva or oral bacteria [42,43] in the human oral environment.
of the dentin side of a specimen in the aged specimen However, little information is available on the mechanism of
(Fig. 4b), whereas there are none in the control (Fig. 4a). collagen degradation in vitro.
The peritubular matrix of the dentinal tubules is richer in Recently, Pashley et al. established a different concept,
inorganic compounds than the lateral branches and the degradation of naked collagen fibrils by host-derived matrix
lateral branches are readily widened by collagen hydrolysis metalloproteinases (MMPs) in the dentin matrix [44—50].
[12,39]. The degradation of the collagen suggests that the Matrix metalloproteinases are a family of zinc-dependent
resin—dentin bonds made with this adhesive system proteolytic enzymes that are capable of degrading the
remained a demineralized dentin zone due to the incomplete organic dentin matrix after demineralization [51]. Although
encapsulation of the dentin by the resin. The same degrada- collagenolytic or gelatinolytic activity identified from oral
8 M. Hashimoto et al.

bacteria [52] may contribute to the hydrolysis of organic function in monkeys [11]. This small adhesive area of the
matter of the dentinal matrices in the caries process, recent microtensile bond test allowed them to make specimen
studies have reported host-derived proteinases in the form of beams from resin—dentin bonded teeth that had functioned
different types of MMPs present and released from the dentin orally. The study revealed evidence of hydrolysis of bonding
matrix [51,53,54]. When a region of naked collagen remains resin within the hybrid layer of a self-etching adhesive after 1
in the demineralized dentin zone, the gradual and slow year of functioning. Later, similar morphological evidence of
release of active MMPs dissolves the collagen during the degradation was confirmed by in vitro tests [13,14]. How-
long-term, even in in vitro conditions. In addition, by SEM ever, hydrolysis of collagen fibrils is not common as a degra-
and TEM micromorphological evidence of self-destruction of dation phase with self-etching adhesive systems. Regions of
collagen has been found in the human dentin matrix in vivo incomplete resin infiltration or incomplete resin polymeriza-
and in vitro [44—50]. tion within the hybrid layer or bonding resin termed nano-
Elution of resin from hybrid layers due to hydrolysis of the leakage have been shown by silver tracer deposition.
resin is a further possible explanation for the bond degrada- Although nanoleakage can theoretically be eliminated by
tion of total-etching adhesives [17,55—58]. This degradation using self-etching adhesives, many studies have shown that
phase has been found in all type of adhesive systems. all self-etching adhesives had a spot- or reticular-mode of
nanoleakage within the hybrid layer [63—67]. Although a
naked collagen zone was absent within the interface of
3. Bond degradation of self-etching the self-etching adhesives, it is possible that a loss of resin
adhesives may initiate and promote proteolytic hydrolysis of collagen.
However, this aging pattern is uncommon and which of the
The combination of an etchant and primer into a self-etching structures (collagen or resin) contributes to the bond degra-
primer is advantageous in that it eliminates one application dation is unclear. According to the results of these previous
step. For etch-and-rinse systems, factors affecting sensitivity studies, resin hydrolysis may be more damaging to long-term
include the surface wetness of the acid etched dentin, acid- bonding effectiveness than collagen hydrolysis in the case of
etching time, light irradiation time, thickness of the bonding the hybrid layer of self-etching adhesives.
resin layer, consecutive coating methods, and the method of
air blowing for the adhesive-coated dentin surface, etc. 4. Bond degradation of one-bottle self-
[6,7,59—61]. For self-etching adhesives, the surface wetness etching adhesives
of acid-etched dentin can be theoretically eliminated
because there is no water rinsing or dentin moisture reten- Recently, one-bottle self-etching adhesive systems are
tion. The fewer application steps of self-etching adhesives widely used in clinics because of their simple and easy
are thought to require less skill by the operator and be easier application. Self-etching adhesive systems are currently
to implement. available as two-step and single-step types. The single-step
Self-etching primer adhesives differ from the etch-and- self-etching systems can be further divided into two types,
rinse systems in that the self-etching adhesives partially the all-in-one and one-bottle types, depending on whether
involve original smear layers in the hybrid layer [8,9]. The they require mixing or not. The recently introduced all-in-
acidic monomer penetrates into the smear layer, smear plug one adhesives are supplied as two-bottles that are mixed
or underlying intact dentin but can be neutralized to stop the together immediately before use. One-bottle self-etching
demineralized reaction due to pH change [62]. Therefore, adhesives that combine the etchant, primer, and bonding
the hybrid layer of self-etching systems is a combined struc- resin into one bottle with single-step application have been
ture of resin, collagen fibrils, and minerals. The strong acid of developed, allowing simultaneous etching and priming with
etch-and-rinse systems (i.e. 35—40% phosphoric acid) com- one adhesive component. One drop of the adhesive is applied
pletely dissolves the matrix of the dentin surface, including to the dentin/enamel surface with the smear layer covered,
the smear layer, exposing the collagen network approxi- resulting in the combination of resin, collagen, and hard tissue
mately 3—7 mm in depth. For self-etching adhesives, the as a bonding substrate. This system is generally thought to be
smear layer is completely or partially enveloped into the less technique-sensitive and time-consuming than traditional
bond structure, providing simultaneous demineralization and adhesive resins (two-step self-etching and etch-and-rinse
infiltration during the application of the acidic monomer, adhesives). This system is thus attractive for clinicians because
resulting in formation of a hybrid layer. The market-driven of its easy handling and short application time.
simplification of adhesive systems of self-etching primers Nanoleakage was first visualized in SEM interfacial obser-
that combine the conditioning and priming is thought to have vations in 1995 [68] and a water tree was first found as an
overcome the shortcomings of the formation of an exposed indicator of a leakage pathway by TEM analysis in 2003 [63].
collagen network within the bonds of the total-etching Several studies have shown unfavorable bond defects such as
adhesives. However, incomplete infiltration was also found nanoleakage, water trees, bubbles, and phase separation in
as nanoleakage within the hybrid layer [63,64]. Therefore, the bond faces of all-in-one and one-bottle adhesives due to
there is a route for water impregnation into bond faces of their characteristically high amounts of water [69,70], which
self-etching systems after bonding. is needed for demineralization of dentinal hard tissue by the
One of the beneficial characteristics of a microtensile acid-effect of the monomers of self-etching systems. The
bond test is that the bond strength measurement can be hydrophilic nature of bonding resins easily induces water
done for specimens with small adhesive areas (i.e. 1 mm2). absorption as a result of replacement of the hydrophilic resin
Using a microtensile bond test, Sano et al. measured resin— monomers even after curing, leading to hydrolytic degrada-
dentin bond strengths in in vivo specimens after long-term tion in the long term [71—77]. Several studies have shown an
A review: Biodegradation of resin-dentin bonds 9

increased amount of silver staining in the hybrid layer or


bonding resin layer as a function of time using total-etch and
self-etching adhesives [78,79]. Recent studies have shown
water sorption of adhesive resin to be proportional to the
hydrophilic characteristics of the resin [71—77]. The self-
etching ability is commonly achieved by incorporation of
water in resin monomers that enables ionization of acidic
monomers. In addition to the water in the compounds, the
ionizable moieties of acidic monomers are also hydrophilic
[80]. The presence of such a hydrophilic layer may thus
induce water sorption and uptake, in turn, plasticizing the
polymer network [17,55—58]. Phase separation of the adhe-
sive or micro-size bubble formation in the bonding resin layer
is a typical morphology in one-bottle self-etching adhesive
systems [69,70]. A recent study has shown the effect of
dentinal surface wetness before bonding on the bond
strengths of one-bottle adhesives [81]. In that study, the
bonding strengths of resins to dentin were measured using
two different surface wetnesses for the dentin substrate
before bonding, wet-dentin with short air blowing and dentin
dried in a desiccator for 24 h. The hydrophilic one-bottle
adhesives with high contents of solvents and water exhibit
high water sorption. This water sorption further contributes
to a large decrease in the bond strength in wet-dentin
compared to dry bonding. An interesting finding was that
this result indicated the adverse effect of etch-and-rinse
systems on surface wetness. Fig. 5 shows nanoleakage
expression (silver staining) in a two-step self-etching speci-
men (Fig. 5a) and one-bottle self-etching adhesives (Fig. 5b
and c) using the back-scatter electron mode of SEM. Although
silver staining was observed in the bonding resin layer of one-
bottle self-etching adhesives, there is no silver tracer present
in the bonding resin when using two-step self-etching adhe-
sives, as shown in Fig. 5a. Based on this, it may be concluded
that the nanoleakage expression in bonding resin layers is a
special characteristic of one-bottle self-etching adhesives
(Fig. 5b and c).
Recently, a typical type of degradation of one-bottle self-
etching adhesives was found at the border between adhe-
sives and the resin composite border [82,83]. Although,
there was little or no silver staining after 24 h (not shown)
of bonding in one-bottle self-etching adhesive specimens,
silver particles were present around filler particles of the
resin composite between the bonding resin and resin com- Figure 5 Longitudinal cross-section of the resin—dentin inter-
posite border after more than 300 days (Fig. 6) in water. face of control specimens that stained silver tracer (a: back-
Fractured surface observations also showed a similar degra- scatter electron mode of two-step self-etching adhesive; b and
dation pattern (detached filler particles and gap formation) c: back-scatter electron mode one-bottle self-etching systems).
at the same region (adhesive/composite border) in in vitro There is an electron lucent layer bonding resin with no silver
tests using one-bottle adhesives, despite the fact that simi- staining in the specimens of two-step self-etching systems. Spot-
lar morphology cannot be found in other adhesive systems mode of silver impregnation (b) and balloon-shaped staining (c)
[82,83]. A schematic illustration of the region of typical are visible within the hybrid layer or adhesive layers for one-
degradation at the adhesive/composite border is shown in bottle self-etching adhesives. White arrows in (c) indicate a
Fig. 7. Oxygen inhibits free radical polymerization and yields balloon-shaped nanoleakage at the hybrid layer/bonding resin
a thin unpolymerized and/or hydrogel layer on cured sur- junction. These regions are enough large for water infiltration.
faces [84—86]. Large amounts of water and/or solvent are The degree of silver staining of bonding resin layer of one-bottle
responsible for a decrease in viscosity, and lead to oxygen self-etching system is greater than the other type of adhesive
transport to the top surface of the cured adhesive layer, and systems. B: bonding resin; C: composite resin; D: dentin.
the depth of the uncured layer with one-bottle adhesives
may be more severe than for hydrophobic adhesives. the bulk polymer, leading to hydrolysis of the filler-adhesive
Furthermore, the remaining monomer around the filler junction after aging. This poorly polymerized hydrophilic
around inadequately polymerized monomers will become polymer domain is deteriorated rapidly by environmental
a pathway for environmental water invasion and entry into water and thus is sensitive to interfacial attack by water.
10 M. Hashimoto et al.

aspect [89—91] and morphological nature in the future.


Degradation of the resin composite at the filler—matrix
junction (hydrolysis of the silane coupling agent) was easily
observed in teeth that functioned in vivo in monkeys and in
humans over 1 year [11,12], though the same morphological
results are not available for in vitro aging tests such as long-
term water storage or thermal cycling. Many studies have
reported the enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis of ester linkage in
metharylate-based monomers of resin composite [43,92—
94]. It is well known that esterases (i.e. cholesterol esterase,
salivary esterases, or porcine liver esterases) induce ester
hydrolysis. In contrast to resin or collage hydrolysis, careful
comparison between in vivo and in vitro resin composite
degradation is needed. In addition, analysis of the degrada-
Figure 6 The resin—dentin interfacial aspects of specimens (a tion of bonding resin by esterases in vitro will be an important
one-bottle self-etching adhesive) after 300 days of water storage research topic in the future.
(back-scatter electron mode of silver staining specimen). There A variety of chemical and physiological factors affect the
were filler particles of resin composite stained at the border of durability of resin—dentin bonds. This review article concen-
bonding resin and composite resin. A continuous crack formation trates on the morphological evidence of bond degradation.
was visible within the interface due to the high vacuum chamber The long-term durability and degradation patterns of resin
of electron microscope. The region of crack formation is in adhesives have changed with the types of adhesives during
accordance with weakest portion of adhesive interface. White the last two decades. There are clear differences among
arrows indicate silver staining around filler particles of resin total-etching systems (etch-and-rinse system), self-etching
composite. This silver staining pattern is typical for aged speci- system, and one-bottle self-etching systems. Typical mor-
mens, but uncommon in control group or other type of adhesive phological evidence of degradations is provided by collagen
systems. B: bonding resin; C: composite resin; D: dentin hydrolysis of total-etch adhesive systems, resin elution from
the hybrid layers of all systems, and hydrolytic degradation at
the border between the adhesive/composite junction of one-
bottle self-etching adhesives. In addition, the results in many
previous studies give promise for the translation of in vitro
into in vivo results for bond testing and morphological ana-
lysis of resin and collagen hydrolysis. This biodegradation
research will provide an avenue of progress for newly devel-
oped resin adhesives.

Acknowledgements
This work was supported, in part, by Grants-in-Aid for Scien-
Figure 7 Schematic representation of typical bond degrada-
tific Research No. 20592384, and for High-Performance Bio-
tion of one-bottle self-etching adhesive. Some filler particles of
medical Materials Research from the Ministry of Education,
resin composite are occasionally floated in the upper part of
Science, Sports and Culture, Japan.
bonding resin layer. This morphological phase suggested that the
imperfect polymerization layer was presented onto the top
surface of bonding resin, the filler particles can penetrate. References
The degradation at the adhesive/composite border is common
for most one-bottle self-etching adhesives, but none or very rare [1] Buonocore MG. A simple method of increasing the adhesion of
for other type of adhesives. The staining pattern could not be acrylic filling materials to enamel surfaces. J Dent Res
clearly observed in control specimens such as 24 h bonding. 1955;34:849—53.
[2] Nakabayashi N, Kojima K, Masuhara E. The promotion of adhe-
sion by the infiltration of monomers into tooth substrates. J
However, in vivo test results are required in further Biomed Mater Res 1982;16:265—73.
research. [3] Prati C, Biagini G, Rizzoli C, Nucci C, Zucchini C, Montanari G.
Shear bond strength and SEM evaluation of dentinal bonding
5. Summary systems. Am J Dent 1990;3:283—8.
[4] Yu XY, Davis EL, Joynt RB, Wieczkowski G. Bond strength evalu-
ation of a class V composite resin restoration. Quintessence Int
Although clinical performance depends on the respective
1991;22:391—6.
adhesive systems, recent long-term clinical trials of resin [5] Pashley DH. Dentin bonding: overview of the substrate with
composites in non-carious cervical lesions demonstrated respect to adhesive material. J Esthet Dent 1991;3:46—50.
good clinical performance [87,88]. However, laboratory stu- [6] Kanca 3rd J. Resin bonding to wet substrate. 1. Bonding to
dies of bond degradation will open the way for the develop- dentin. Quintessence Int 1992;23:39—41.
ment of new adhesive resin systems that are more stable and [7] Swift Jr EJ, Triolo Jr PT. Bond strengths of Scotchbond Multi-
have compatible components from the chemical polymer Purpose to moist dentin and enamel. Am J Dent 1992;5:318—20.
A review: Biodegradation of resin-dentin bonds 11

[8] Watanabe I, Nakabayashi N, Pashley DH. Bonding to ground [30] Spencer P, Wang Y, Walker MP, Wieliczka DM, Swafford JR.
dentin by a phenyl-P self-etching primer. J Dent Res 1994;73: Interfacial chemistry of the dentin/adhesive bond. J Dent Res
1212—20. 2000;79:1458—63.
[9] Nakabayashi N, Saimi Y. Bonding to intact dentin. J Dent Res [31] Pioch T, Staehle HJ, Duschner H, Garcı́a-Godoy F. Nanoleakage
1996;75:1706—15. at the composite—dentin interface: a review. Am J Dent
[10] Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Kaga M, Endo K, Sano H, Oguchi H. 2001;14:252—8.
Fractographial analysis of resin—dentin bonds. Am J Dent [32] Pioch T, Kobaslija S, Huseinbegović A, Müller K, Dörfer CE. The
2001;14:355—60. effect of NaOCl dentin treatment on nanoleakage formation. J
[11] Sano H, Yoshikawa T, Pereira PN, Kanemura N, Morigami M, Biomed Mater Res 2001;56:578—83.
Tagami J, et al. Long-term durability of dentin bonds made with [33] Pioch T, Staehle HJ, Wurst M, Duschner H, Dörfer C. The
a self-etching primer, in vivo. J Dent Res 1999;78:906—11. nanoleakage phenomenon: influence of moist vs dry bonding.
[12] Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Kaga M, Endo K, Sano H, Oguchi H. In vivo J Adhes Dent 2002;4:23—30.
degradation of resin—dentin bonds in humans over 1 to 3 years. J [34] Wang Y, Spencer P. Quantifying adhesive penetration in adhe-
Dent Res 2000;79:1385—91. sive/dentin interface using confocal Raman microspectroscopy.
[13] Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Sano H, Tay FR, Kaga M, Kudou Y, et al. J Biomed Mater Res 2002;59:46—55.
Micromorphological changes in resin—dentin bonds after 1 year [35] Wang Y, Spencer P. Hybridization efficiency of the adhesive/
of water storage. J Biomed Mater Res 2002;63:306—11. dentin interface with wet bonding. J Dent Res 2003;82:141—5.
[14] Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Sano H, Kaga M, Oguchi H. Degradation [36] Marshall Jr GW. Dentin: microstructure and characterization.
patterns of different adhesives and bonding procedures. J Quintessence Int 1993;24:606—17.
Biomed Mater Res 2003;66:324—30. [37] Marshall Jr GW, Balooch M, Tench RJ, Kinney JH, Marshall SJ.
[15] Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Sano H, Kaga M, Oguchi H. In vitro Atomic force microscopy of acid effects on dentin. Dent Mater
degradation of resin—dentin bonds analyzed by microtensile 1993;9:265—8.
bond test, scanning and transmission electron microscopy. [38] Marshall Jr GW, Balooch M, Kinney JH, Marshall SJ. Atomic force
Biomaterials 2003;24:3795—803. microscopy of conditioning agents on dentin. J Biomed Mater
[16] De Munck J, Van Meerbeek B, Yoshida Y, Inoue S, Vargas M, Suzuki Res 1995;29:1381—7.
K, et al. Four-year water degradation of total-etch adhesives [39] Hashimoto M, Ohno H, Kaga M, Endo K, Sano H, Oguchi H. Resin—
bonded to dentin. J Dent Res 2003;82:136—40. tooth adhesive interfaces after long-term function. Am J Dent
[17] Armstrong SR, Vargas MA, Chung I, Pashley DH, Campbell JA, 2001;14:211—5.
Laffoon JE, et al. Resin—dentin interfacial ultrastructure and [40] Hashimoto M, Tay FR, Ohno H, Sano H, Kaga M, Yiu C, et al. SEM
microtensile dentin bond strength after five-year water stor- and TEM analysis of water degradation of human dentinal
age. Oper Dent 2004;29:705—12. collagen. J Biomed Mater Res 2003;66:287—98.
[18] Frankenberger R, Strobel WO, Lohbauer U, Krämer N, Petschelt [41] Yoshida E, Hashimoto M, Hori M, Kaga M, Sano H, Oguchi H.
A. The effect of six years of water storage on composite bonding Deproteinizing effects on resin—tooth bond structures. J
to human dentin. J Biomed Mater Res 2004;69:25—32. Biomed Mater Res 2004;68:29—35.
[19] Burrow MF, Harada N, Kitasako Y, Nikaido T, Tagami J. Seven- [42] Bean TA, Zhuang WC, Tong PY, Eick JD, Yourtee DM. Effect of
year dentin bond strengths of a total- and self-etch system. Eur esterase on methacrylates and methacrylate polymers in an
J Oral Sci 2005;113:265—70. enzyme simulator for biodurability and biocompatibility test-
[20] Koshiro K, Inoue S, Sano H, De Munck J, Van Meerbeek B. In vivo ing. J Biomed Mater Res 1994;28:59—63.
degradation of resin—dentin bonds produced by a self-etch and [43] Kostoryz EL, Dharmala K, Ye Q, Wang Y, Huber J, Park JG, et al.
an etch-and-rinse adhesive. Eur J Oral Sci 2005;113:341—8. Enzymatic biodegradation of HEMA/bisGMA adhesives formulat-
[21] Donmez N, Belli S, Pashley DH, Tay FR. Ultrastructural corre- ed with different water content. J Biomed Mater Res
lates of in vivo/in vitro bond degradation in self-etch adhesives. 2009;88:394—401.
J Dent Res 2005;84:355—9. [44] Pashley DH, Tay FR, Yiu C, Hashimoto M, Breschi L, Carvalho RM,
[22] Garcı́a-Godoy F, Tay FR, Pashley DH, Feilzer A, Tjäderhane L, et al. Collagen degradation by host-derived enzymes during
Pashley EL. Degradation of resin-bonded human dentin after 3 aging. J Dent Res 2004;83:216—21.
years of storage. Am J Dent 2007;20:109—13. [45] Hebling J, Pashley DH, Tjäderhane L, Tay FR. Chlorhexidine
[23] Reis A, Albuquerque M, Pegoraro M, Mattei G, Bauer JR, Grande arrests subclinical degradation of dentin hybrid layers in vivo. J
RH, et al. Can the durability of one-step self-etch adhesives be Dent Res 2005;84:741—6.
improved by double application or by an extra layer of hydro- [46] Nishitani Y, Yoshiyama M, Wadgaonkar B, Breschi L, Mannello F,
phobic resin? J Dent 2008;36:309—15. Mazzoni A, et al. Activation of gelatinolytic/collagenolytic
[24] Carrilho MR, Carvalho RM, Tay FR, Yiu C, Pashley DH. Durability activity in dentin by self-etching adhesives. Eur J Oral Sci
of resin—dentin bonds related to water and oil storage. Am J 2006;114:160—6.
Dent 2005;18:315—9. [47] Carrilho MR, Geraldeli S, Tay F, de Goes MF, Carvalho RM,
[25] Toledano M, Osorio R, Osorio E, Aguilera FS, Yamauti M, Pashley Tjäderhane L, et al. In vivo preservation of the hybrid layer
DH, et al. Durability of resin—dentin bonds: effects of direct/ by chlorhexidine. J Dent Res 2007;86:529—33.
indirect exposure and storage media. Dent Mater 2007;23:885— [48] Mazzoni A, Mannello F, Tay FR, Tonti GA, Papa S, Mazzotti G,
92. et al. Zymographic analysis and characterization of MMP-2
[26] Nakabayashi N, Watanabe A, Arao T. A tensile test to facilitate and -9 forms in human sound dentin. J Dent Res 2007;86:
identification of defects in dentine bonded specimens. J Dent 436—40.
1998;26:379—85. [49] Carrilho MR, Carvalho RM, de Goes MF, di Hipólito V, Geraldeli S,
[27] Kato G, Nakabayashi N. The durability of adhesion to phosphoric Tay FR, et al. Chlorhexidine preserves dentin bond in vitro. J
acid etched, wet dentin substrates. Dent Mater 1998;14:347—52. Dent Res 2007;86:90—4.
[28] Spencer P, Swafford JR. Unprotected protein at the dentin— [50] Mazzoni A, Pashley DH, Tay FR, Gobbi P, Orsini G, Ruggeri Jr A,
adhesive interface. Quintessence Int 1999;30:501—7. et al. Immunohistochemical identification of MMP-2 and MMP-9
[29] Yoshida Y, Van Meerbeek B, Snauwaert J, Hellemans L, Lam- in human dentin: correlative FEI-SEM/TEM analysis. J Biomed
brechts P, Vanherle G, et al. A novel approach to AFM charac- Mater Res 2009;88:697—703.
terization of adhesive tooth—biomaterial interfaces. J Biomed [51] Tjäderhane L, Larjava H, Sorsa T, Uitto VJ, Larmas M, Salo T. The
Mater Res 1999;47:85—90. activation and function of host matrix metalloproteinases in
12 M. Hashimoto et al.

dentin matrix breakdown in caries lesions. J Dent Res [73] Yiu CK, King NM, Pashley DH, Suh BI, Carvalho RM, Carrilho MR,
1998;77:1622—9. et al. Effect of resin hydrophilicity and water storage on resin
[52] Jackson RJ, Lim DV, Dao ML. Identification and analysis of a strength. Biomaterials 2004;25:5789—96.
collagenolytic activity in Streptococcus mutants. Curr Microbiol [74] Tay FR, Lai CN, Chersoni S, Pashley DH, Mak YF, Suppa P, et al.
1997;34:49—54. Osmotic blistering in enamel bonded with one-step self-etch
[53] Dung S-Z, Gregory RL, Li Y, Stookey GE. Effect of lactic acid adhesives. J Dent Res 2004;83:290—5.
and proteolytic enzymes on the release of organic matrix [75] Ito S, Hashimoto M, Wadgaonkar B, Svizero N, Carvalho RM, Yiu C,
components from human root dentin. Caries Res 1995;29: et al. Effects of resin hydrophilicity on water sorption and
483—9. changes in modulus of elasticity. Biomaterials 2005;26:6449—59.
[54] van Strijp AJ, Jansen DC, DeGroot J, Ten Cate JM, Everts V. Host- [76] Hashimoto M, Tay FR, Ito S, Sano H, Kaga M, Pashley DH.
derived proteinases and degradation of dentine collagen in situ. Permeability of adhesive resin films. J Biomed Mater Res
Caries Res 2003;37:58—65. 2005;74:699—706.
[55] Shono Y, Terashita M, Shimada J, Kozono Y, Carvalho RM, Russell [77] Yiu CK, King NM, Carrilho MR, Sauro S, Rueggeberg FA, Prati C, et al.
CM, et al. Durability of resin—dentin bonds. J Adhes Dent Effect of resin hydrophilicity and temperature on water sorption
1999;1:211—8. of dental adhesive resins. Biomaterials 2006;27:1695—703.
[56] Tanaka J, Ishikawa K, Yatani H, Yamashita A, Suzuki K. Correla- [78] Reis AF, Bedran-Russo AK, Giannini M, Pereira PN. Interfacial
tion of dentin bond durability with water absorption of bonding ultramorphology of single-step adhesives: nanoleakage as a
layer. Dent Mater J 1999;18:11—8. function of time. J Oral Rehabil 2007;34:213—21.
[57] Carrilho MR, Carvalho RM, Tay FR, Pashley DH. Effects of storage [79] Okuda M, Pereira PN, Nakajima M, Tagami J, Pashley DH. Long-
media on mechanical properties of adhesive systems. Am J Dent term durability of resin dentin interface: nanoleakage vs.
2004;17:104—8. microtensile bond strength. Oper Dent 2002;27:289—96.
[58] Abdalla AI, Feilzer AJ. Four-year water degradation of a total- [80] Hiraishi N, Nishiyama N, Ikemura K, Yau JYY, King NM, Tagami J,
etch and two self-etching adhesives bonded to dentin. J Dent et al. Water concentration in self-etching primers affects their
2008;36:611—7. aggressiveness and bonding efficacy to dentin. J Dent Res
[59] Zheng L, Pereira PN, Nakajima M, Sano H, Tagami J. Relationship 2005;84:653—8.
between adhesive thickness and microtensile bond strength. [81] Hashimoto M, Fujita S, Kaga M, Yawaka Y. Effect of dentinal
Oper Dent 2001;26:97—104. water on bonding of one-bottle self-etching adhesives. Dent
[60] Wang Y, Spencer P. Effect of acid etching time and technique on Mater J 2008;27:172—8.
interfacial characteristics of the adhesive—dentin bond using [82] Hashimoto M, Fujita S, Kaga M, Yawaka Y. In vitro durability of
differential staining. Eur J Oral Sci 2004;112:293—9. one-bottle resin adhesives bonded to dentin. Dent Mater J
[61] Hashimoto M, Sano H, Yoshida E, Hori M, Kaga M, Oguchi H, et al. 2007;26:677—86.
Effects of multiple adhesive coatings on dentin bonding. Oper [83] Hashimoto M, Fujita S, Endo K, Ohno H. In vitro degradation of
Dent 2004;29:416—23. resin—dentin bonds with one-bottle self-etching adhesives. Eur
[62] Maeda T, Yamaguchi K, Takamizawa T, Rikuta A, Tsubota K, Ando J Oral Sci 2009;117:611—7.
S, et al. pH changes of self-etching primers mixed with pow- [84] Rueggeberg FA, Margeson DH. The effect of oxygen inhibition on
dered dentine. Dent Mater 2008;36:606—10. an unfilled/filled composite system. J Dent Res 1990;69:1652—8.
[63] Tay FR, King NM, Chan KM, Pashley DH. How can nanoleakage [85] Gauthier MA, Stangel I, Ellis TH, Zhu XX. Oxygen inhibition in
occur in self-etching adhesive systems that demineralize and dental resins. J Dent Res 2005;84:725—9.
infiltrate simultaneously? J Adhes Dent 2002;4:255—69. [86] Van Landuyt KL, Snauwaert J, de Munck J, Coutinho E, Poitevin
[64] Tay FR, Pashley DH. Water treeing–—a potential mechanism for A, Yoshida Y, et al. Origin of interfacial droplets with one-step
degradation of dentin adhesives. Am J Dent 2003;16:6—12. adhesives. J Dent Res 2007;86:739—44.
[65] Tay FR, Pashley DH, Suh BI, Carvalho RM, Itthagarun A. Single-step [87] Peumans M, De Munck J, Van Landuyt K, Lambrechts P, Van
adhesives are permeable membranes. J Dent 2002;30:371—82. Meerbeek B. Five-year clinical effectiveness of a two-step self-
[66] Agee KL, Pashley EL, Itthagarun A, Sano H, Tay FR, Pashley DH. etching adhesive. J Adhes Dent 2007;9:7—10.
Submicron hiati in acid-etched dentin are artifacts of desicca- [88] Van Landuyt K, Peumans M, Fieuws S, De Munck J, Cardoso MV,
tion. Dent Mater 2003;19:60—8. Ermis RB, et al. A randomized controlled clinical trial of a HEMA-
[67] Carvalho RM, Chersoni S, Frankenberger R, Pashley DH, Prati C, free all-in-one adhesive in non-carious cervical lesions at 1 year.
Tay FR. A challenge to the conventional wisdom that simulta- J Dent 2008;36:847—55.
neous etching and resin infiltration always occurs in self-etch [89] Nishiyama N, Suzuki K, Yoshida H, Teshima H, Nemoto K.
adhesives. Biomater 2005;26:1035—42. Hydrolytic stability of methacrylamide in acidic aqueous solu-
[68] Sano H, Takatsu T, Ciucchi B, Horner JA, Matthews WG, Pashley tion. Biomaterials 2004;25:965—9.
DH. Nanoleakage: leakage within the hybrid layer. Oper Dent [90] Salz U, Zimmermann J, Zeuner F, Moszner N. Hydrolytic stability
1995;20:18—25. of self-etching adhesive systems. J Adhes Dent 2005;7:107—16.
[69] van Landuyt KL, Snauwaert J, Peumans M, de Munck J, Lam- [91] Moszner N, Salz U, Zimmermann J. Chemical aspects of self-
brechts P, van Meerbeek B. The role of HEMA in one-step self- etching enamel—dentin adhesives: a systematic review. Dent
etch adhesives. Dent Mater 2008;24:1412—9. Mater 2005;21:895—910.
[70] Sauro S, Mannocci F, Toledano M, Osorio R, Thompson I, Watson [92] Bean TA, Zhuang WC, Tong PY, Eick JD, Yourtee DM. Effect of
TF. Influence of the hydrostatic pulpal pressure on droplets esterase on methacrylate and methacrylate polymers in an
formation in current etch-and-rinse and self-etch adhesives: enzyme simulator for biodurability and biocompatibility test-
a video rate/TSM microscopy and fluid filtration study. Dent ing. J Biomed Mater Res 1994;28:59—63.
Mater 2009;25:1392—402. [93] Armstrong SR, Jessop JL, Vargas MA, Zou Y, Qian F, Campbell JA,
[71] Malacarne J, Carvalho RM, de Goes MF, Svizero N, Pashley DH, et al. Effects of exogenous collagenase and cholesterol esterase
Tay FR, et al. Water sorption/solubility of dental adhesive on the durability of the resin—dentin bond. J Adhes Dent
resins. Dent Mater 2006;22:973—80. 2006;8:151—60.
[72] Chersoni S, Suppa P, Grandini S, Goracci C, Monticelli F, Yiu C, [94] Toledano M, Osorio R, Osorio E, Aguilera FS, Yamauti M, Pashley
et al. In vivo and in vitro permeability of one-step self-etch DH, et al. Effect of bacterial collagenase on resin—dentin bonds
adhesives. J Dent Res 2004;83:459—64. degradation. J Mater Sci Mater Med 2007;18:2355—61.