Abstract— This paper presents the losses optimization through frequency transformer (50/60Hz), is the most costeffective
an optimal modulation strategy for auxiliary railway power solution (see Fig. 1). The weight of this element is a third of
supplies. The figures of merit analyzed to compare different the whole ARPS [1], so in order to reduce weight, this
modulation techniques are the transformer losses and the transformer is commonly built using integrated magnetism,
inverter losses. For the transformer losses a model has been and so the AC filter inductor is included within the
developed for the special characteristics of this element due to its transformer leakage inductance (L cc).
integrated magnetism. In the case of the switching devices, the
losses have been obtained by means of a simulator. Both, the In this application, the maximum allowable Total
transformer and the switching device losses have been Harmonic Distortion (THD) can be established as a tradeoff
experimentally validated in a scaledown prototype, so the between the car builder and the converter manufacturer. In this
analysis can be extrapolated to other power converters. issue, the IEEE recommended practice guide [2] establishes
that it must be kept below 10% in order to avoid further
I. INTRODUCTION damage of the loads.
The railway transportation is suffering a great expansion Due to the slow dynamic imposed by the LC input filter,
against car and airplanes, because is a low cost and reliable typically 15Hz (see Fig. 1), the converter regulation can be
solution for the users. New trends regarding energy efficiency considered quasistatic and so a control strategy based on the
and safety lead to new designs in used or new vehicles. selection of the appropriate modulation index within a lookup
Therefore it is very important to optimize these systems. table with precalculated switching events, is enough to
Auxiliary railway power supplies (ARPS) are needed onboard achieve a successful performance. The modulation index
rolling stock to provide medium or low voltage to different variation can be implemented by means of a feedforward of
systems from the catenary (see Fig. 1). the input voltage together with a feedback loop which controls
the AC output voltage in order to compensate the effect of the
Due to the high input voltage range and the galvanic resistive voltage drops.
isolation, the conventional topology for ARPS that uses a low
Catenary 3Phase AC Bus
High Voltage: 1500 – 3000Vnom
Rεcc Lεcc +
+ VO
Ci A 
VDC B Lεcc
C Rεcc

N
Rεcc Lεcc
Fig. 1: Electric diagram of a typical AC voltage generation system for rolling stock onboard applications.
∑ ∑ k ·B
In this application, in the high voltage – high power range, W
the transformer temperature is very important due to the fact
pFe = ph + pe = kh · Bnα ·n· f + c
2
n n· f( )
2
(1)
kg
that it is related to the isolation lifetime [19]. Degradation in n =1 n =1
the isolation paper can cause the transformer to fail, so it is
Vn
necessary to know about the transformer operation. The Bn = (2)
temperature raise in the transformer is given by the losses; N · A·2π ·n· f
iron and copper losses. Therefore, having an estimation of the
transformer losses could serve to evaluate the isolation In (1) kh and kc are the hysteresis and eddycurrent
lifetimes. constants, respectively; and α is the Steinmetz constant, all of
them depend of the magnetic material regarding its lamination
Several researches can be found in the literature regarding (thickness, grain orientation, etc.) [11].
the losses in inverter fed transformers. The iron losses have
been studied in several works such as in [9][14] while the Due to the transformer geometry, the limbs, yokes and
copper losses are included in [15][18]. In [9] the iron losses auxiliary cores have different flux density and therefore
are studied against the inverter modulation index for a square different iron losses. The difference in the flux density is given
wave modulation, while in [10] they are analyzed against the by the different cross sectional areas and mainly by the
number of levels of the inverter. Although the state of the art voltage applied to the core. So it is necessary to determine the
presents studies in the transformer losses, they are focused on flux density for each part of the transformer, considering that
transformer without integrated magnetic. This kind of the inverter output voltage (3) can be obtained applying
transformer has a special geometry and the losses model is Fourier series to an arbitrary αi waveform with odd quarter
different from the ones in the state of the art. Therefore, in the wave symmetry as the one shown in Fig. 3.
two following epigraphs, the iron losses and copper losses
model are studied and validated.
2325
α1 αN
Vcoren
Bn _ limb = (6)
N1· Acore ·2π ·n· f
Vaux n
Bn _ aux = (7)
π/2 π 3π/2 2π ωt
N1· Aaux ·2π ·n· f
 
B where Iprim_n and Isec_n are the R.M.S current values for each
harmonic component for primary and secondary windings,
C respectively, and Rac_prim and Racsec are the AC resistances
associated to the primary and secondary windings,
Fig. 4: Single phase equivalent circuit for Δ connection. respectively. It is important to notice that these resistances are
G geometry (number of layers, parallel and stacked conductors,
G G vinvn ⋅ X F ( jnω1 ) etc) and frequency dependent and their estimation is an
vcoren = vinvn − (4) important issue in the copper losses calculation. These
Z O ( jnω1 ) resistances have been obtained using Dowell’s equations [20]
applied to PWM waveforms with nth harmonics [21].
G
G vinvn C. Losses validation
vaux n = jnω1 ⋅ Lεcc · (5)
Z O ( jnω1 ) In order to validate the above mentioned analysis, a scale
down prototype based on Fig. 1 has been developed and its
Considering the applied voltages to each part, the number characteristics are shown in Table I. The transformer electrical
of turns and the cross sectional area, the flux densities in the steel is the grain oriented UNISIL 23P060 and the building
limbs, auxiliary core and yokes are given in (6), (7) and (8), characteristics of the transformer are shown in Table II.
respectively. It is important to notice that the limbs are mostly It is important to notice that the transformer has been built
affected by the first harmonic and no other harmonics are according to the picture shown in Fig. 2, where the auxiliary
relevant on the flux density calculation while the auxiliary core is distributed along the available window.
core is affected by all the high frequency harmonics. Due to
the fact that the flux needs a closed loop in the main core, the
yokes are supporting the induction provided by the flux
density in the limbs and in the auxiliary cores (see Fig. 2).
2326
TABLE I. SCALEDOWN PROTOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS results have the same trend and they are close to the
experimental ones, so the copper losses estimation has been
Parameter Value validated.
Input voltage range, VDC 280V600V
Line to line RMS output Voltage, VO 400V
2 VO _ 1 N 2 1
Output power 1400W M =2 (11)
3 VDC N1 3
Nominal frequency 50Hz
50
Load resistance, Rload 115Ω
48
Pcopper_exp
Load inductance, Lload 0H 46
Pcopper_theor
Copper losses, W
AC capacitor, CAC 4.5µH 44
42
TABLE II. . SCALEDOWN TRANSFORMER CHARACTERISTICS 40
38
Parameter Value 36
Limb weight 5.5kg 34
SHE needed.

B Commonly, the electrical steel manufacturer does not
I NOM provide these terms, so the evaluation of this expression is
C complicated. With the opencircuit test, these constants can be
obtained by means of curve fitting. In Fig. 8, once the
Fig. 5: Equivalent circuit in shortcircuit test. constants have been fixed, both the theoretical and
experimental results for the iron losses against the modulation
Evaluating (10), the theoretical results are shown in Fig. 6 index are shown.
together with the experimental ones against the inverter
modulation index, which is defined in (11) considering VO_1 as
the fundamental RMS line to line output voltage and VDC the
inverter input voltage. As it can be observed, the theoretical
2327
100
90
80
70
Iron losses, W
60
50
Piron_exp
40
Piron_theor
30
20 Fig. 10: PSIM® Thermal Module IGBT bridge and database editor.
10
0 This software provides with one simulation the device
0,55 0,65 0,75 0,85 0,95 1,05 1,15 losses considering all the parameters of the system, making
Modulation index, M this task easy and fast. In order to use this tool for any
Fig. 8: Iron losses against the modulation index in opencircuit test. converter, a validation test is needed. This has been carried out
Continuous line: experimental results. Dashed line: Theoretical results.
through the converter shown in Fig. 1 with the characteristics
LOAD TEST mentioned before. The IGBT device for this application is the
In the final test, the transformer is connected to the load as SKM50GB123D. The modulation techniques in this case are
depicted in Fig. 4. In this case the modulation techniques the SHE with 6 and 7 chops per quarter period. In Fig. 11,
applied to the inverter have been SHE with 6 and 7 chops. both the simulation and the experimental results for the device
Both the theoretical and experimental results are shown in Fig. losses are shown against the modulation index, which was
9. Under load condition, the total transformer losses have also defined in (11), where VO_1 is the fundamental RMS line to
the same trends as the theoretical results for both modulation line output voltage and VDC is the inverter input voltage.
techniques. The important achievement of the transformer
losses estimation lies in the fact that it can be extrapolated to a) 35
other designs with different characteristics in the transformer, SHE 6
30
the converter and the modulation technique.
25
Device losses, W
160
Device losses, W
20
140 Simulation
15
Experimental
120
10
100
εMAX=10%
5
80
0,55 0,65 0,75 0,85 0,95 1,05 1,15
Modulation index, M 0
0,55 0,65 0,75 0,85 0,95 1,05 1,15
Fig. 9: Transformer losses against the modulation index in load operation. Modulation index, M
Continuous line: SHE with 6 chops. Dashed line: SHE with 7 chops.
Fig. 11: Device losses against the modulation index. a) SHE with 6 chops. b)
III. SWITCHING DEVICE LOSSES SHE with 7 chops. Continuous lines: experimental results. Dashed lines:
simulation results.
The switching devices losses calculation can be carried out
through simulation using commercial tools based on The obtained results by means of the simulation software
manufacturer’s database such as the Thermal Module of are close to the experimental ones, with the same trends and
PSIM® [22] (see Fig. 10). low error (below 10%). This means that the software can be
used in systems with different characteristics.
2328
IV. OPTIMAL ADAPTIVE COMBINED 9 (SHE9) and 10 (SHE10) chops per quarter period and the
MODULATION PWM with third harmonic injection with a carrier ratio of 15
(THIPWM_15) and 21 (THIPWM_21).
Since the theoretical and simulation power losses trends
have been validated, both the transformer losses estimation
and the simulation software may be used to analyze a real In order to carry out the modulation combination, some
ARPS in order to establish an optimal combination of design restrictions have to be taken into account. These are the
modulations which minimizes the total losses. maximum THD (THDmax) and the maximum power
dissipation of the switching device (PIGBTmax=11.5kW) and
The real system, which attends to Fig. 1, has the the transformer. With forced aircooling, considering a
characteristics shown in Table III and Table IV. The switching maximum power loss per dissipation area (external windings
device in this application is the FZ600R65KF2, with a area) of 2500W/m2, as a practical rule, the maximum
maximum voltage of 6500V. Due to limitations in the IGBT allowable losses in the transformer (Ptrxmax) are 3kW. All of
technology, the selected modulation techniques, implemented these maximum values are represented in Fig. 12 with dashed
within a lookup table, are the SHE with 7 (SHE7), 8 (SHE8), lines.
7
a)
6
SHE7 THIPWM_15
Output Voltage THD (%)
5 THDmax
4
SHE8
SHE9
3
THIPWM_21
2
SHE10
1
0
0,40 0,45 0,50 0,55 0,60 0,65 0,70 0,75 0,80 0,85 0,90
b) 12 SHE7
Millares
11 SHE8 SHE8
SHE9 THIPWM_21
THIPWM_15
10
Total Losses (kW)
SHE9
9 SHE10
SHE7 THIPWM_15 THIPWM_21
8
7 SHE10
5
0,40 0,45 0,50 0,55 0,60 0,65 0,70 0,75 0,80 0,85 0,90
c) 3300
3100 Ptrxmax Thermal Limit
2900 3000W
Transformer Losses (W)
SHE10, SHE8
2700
SHE9
2500
2300
THIPWM_15 SHE7
2100
1900
1700
1500 THIPWM_21
1300
0,40 0,45 0,50 0,55 0,60 0,65 0,70 0,75 0,80 0,85 0,90
d) 12
PIGBTmax Thermal Limit
Millares
11000W
10 SHE10
SHE8, SHE9
8
IGBT Losses (kW)
THIPWM_15 THIPWM_21
6
SHE7
0
0,40 0,45 0,50 0,55 0,60 0,65 0,70 0,75 0,80 0,85 0,90
VDC=3.6kV VDC=2.1kV
2329
TABLE III. REAL SYSTEM MAIN CHARACTERISTICS through simulation and also experimentally validated in the
same prototype. The presented adaptive combined modulation
Parameter Value can be extrapolated to other applications with different
Input voltage range, VDC 2.1kV3.6kV components, ranges of power and voltages, etc.
Line to line RMS output Voltage, VO 400V
Output power 290kVA ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Nominal frequency 50Hz
This work has been supported by Ministerio de Educación
Load resistance, Rload 0.605Ω y Ciencia (Spain), by means of the research projects
Load inductance, Lload 1mH MODUFLAME (DPI201021110C0202) and SAUCE (DPI:
200912501).
AC capacitor, CAC 600µH
2330
[15] W. A. Roshen, "A Practical, Accurate and Very General Core Loss IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol. 15, Issue: 2, 2000, pp.
Model for Nonsinusoidal Waveforms Harmonic winding losses". in 369376.
Proc. of IEEE App. Power Elect. Conf. (APEC’2005), 2005. [19] V. M. Montsinger, “Loading transformers by temperature”,
[16] D. MurthyBellur, M.K. Kazimierczuk, "Winding losses caused by Transactions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers, Vol. 49,
harmonics in highfrequency flyback transformers for pulsewidth Issue:2, 1930, pp.776790.
modulated dcdc converters in discontinuous conduction mode", IEEE [20] P. L. Dowell, "Effect of eddy currents in transformer windings",
Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol. 3, Issue: 5, 2010, pp. 804817. Proceedings of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, Vol. 113, Issue:
[17] D. MurthyBellur, M.K. Kazimierczuk, "Transformer winding loss 8, 1966, pp. 13871394.
caused by skin and proximity effects including harmonics in pulse [21] H. Cha, Q. Tang, F.Z. Peng, "Development of High Power DCDC
width modulated DCDC flyback converters for the continuous Converter for Metro Vehicle System", in Proc. of IEEE App. Power
conduction mode", IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol. 4, Elect. Conf. (APEC’2007), 2007.
Issue: 4, 2011, pp. 363373.
[22] PSIM Simulation Software. Powersim Inc.. [on line]. <
[18] W.G. Hurley, E. Gath, J.G. Breslin, "Optimizing the AC resistance of http://www.powersimtech.com> [Consulted: November, 17, 2012]
multilayer transformer windings with arbitrary current waveforms",
2331