You are on page 1of 5

Postpartum Preeclampsia Management With

Furosemide: A Randomized Clinical Trial


Marian H. Ascarelli, MD, Venessia Johnson, RN, Holly McCreary, RN, Julie Cushman, RN,
Warren L. May, PhD, and James N. Martin Jr, MD

OBJECTIVE: This investigation was undertaken to estimate Acute or chronic hypertensive disorders of pregnancy
whether a brief postpartum course of furosemide for pa- affect a substantial population of pregnant patients in the
tients with preeclampsia benefits recovery and shortens United States each year, all of whom must evidence
hospitalization by enhancing diuresis, lessening severe hy- suitable and sufficient recovery postpartum to meet cri-
pertension, and reducing the need for antihypertensive teria for safe hospital discharge. Although considerable
therapy.
attention has been directed to antepartum and intrapar-
METHODS: Two hundred sixty-four patients with pre- tum management issues regarding patients with pre-
eclampsia were enrolled. After spontaneous onset of post- eclampsia and related hypertensive disorders of preg-
partum diuresis and discontinuation of intravenous mag- nancy, such as minimizing the development of eclampsia
nesium sulfate, patients were randomly assigned to receive
using magnesium sulfate, much less research on the
either no therapy or 20 mg oral furosemide daily for 5 days
puerperium has been undertaken to illuminate the phys-
with oral potassium supplementation. Patient outcomes
iology and relevant interventions for appropriate post-
were compared between treatment groups with regard to
classification of hypertensive disease.
partum management of this heterogeneous group of
patients.
RESULTS: Only postpartum patients with severe pre-
Puerperal normalization of patients with the spectrum
eclampsia (n ⴝ 70) who received furosemide compared
of preeclampsia proceeds variably over time, possibly
with controls had significantly lower systolic blood pres-
sure by postpartum day 2 (142 ⴞ 13 mm Hg compared
exaggerating or impeding the normal extent of blood
with 153 ⴞ 19 mm Hg, P < .004) and required less antihy- volume shifts that follow the cessation of gestation in a
pertensive therapy during hospitalization (14% compared vascular system that is injured, vasospastic, or inflexible.
with 26%, P ⴝ .371) and at discharge (6% compared with Although complete recovery from severe preeclampsia
26%, P ⴝ .045). No benefit was shown for patients with can require an extended period of time,1– 4 most patients
mild preeclampsia (n ⴝ 169) or superimposed preeclamp- who develop complications do this within the first 2
sia (n ⴝ 25). Neither length of hospitalization nor fre- weeks after delivery.5 These include severe hyperten-
quency of delayed postpartum complications was posi- sion requiring medication or major fluid shifts that cause
tively affected by the intervention. cerebral or pulmonary edema. It would be desirable to
CONCLUSION: Brief postpartum furosemide therapy for pa- minimize or eliminate these altogether with use of a
tients with severe preeclampsia seems to enhance recovery low-cost medical intervention such as furosemide to
by normalizing blood pressure more rapidly and reducing accelerate recovery and shorten hospitalization without
the need for antihypertensive therapy. Shortening of hos- adverse maternal or perinatal consequences.
pitalization and reduction of delayed postpartum compli- This investigation was undertaken in patients with
cations were not benefitted. (Obstet Gynecol 2005;105: preeclampsia to assess the efficacy of a short 5-day post-
29 –33. © 2005 by The American College of Obstetricians partum course of orally administered furosemide to en-
and Gynecologists.) hance diuresis and lower blood pressure, thereby reduc-
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: I ing the need to initiate antihypertensive agents with their
attendant cost, potential side effects, and the need to hold
the patient longer in the hospital to assure the attainment
From the Departments of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Preventive Medicine of blood pressure control. A secondary goal was to
(Biostatistics), University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, Mississippi. shorten hospitalization and thereby reduce health care
Supported in part by the Vicksburg Hospital Medical Foundation, Vicksburg, cost. Although the size of the study is not adequate to
Mississippi. properly assess whether this intervention lessens periph-

VOL. 105, NO. 1, JANUARY 2005


© 2005 by The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. 0029-7844/05/$30.00 29
Published by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. doi:10.1097/01.AOG.0000148270.53433.66
eral edema and prevents subsequent hypertensive and Table 1. Composition of Treatment and Control Patient
fluid-related complications, we nevertheless assessed our Groups
patients for delayed pregnancy-related complications. Furosemide
To prevent excessive contraction of the intravascular Classification of Disease Yes No Totals P
space immediately postpartum, diuretic administration MPRE [n (%)] 81 (47.9) 88 (52.1) 169
was initiated after spontaneous postpartum diuresis was SPRE [n (%)] 35 (50) 35 (50) 70
established and patient-individualized magnesium sul- CPRE [n (%)] 16 (64) 9 (36) 25
fate prophylaxis6 was discontinued. Totals (n) 132 132 264 .325
Demographics
Maternal age 22.8 ⫾ 6.1 22.9 ⫾ 6.0 .847
(y; mean ⫾ SD)
MATERIALS AND METHODS Maternal weight 199 ⫾ 54 206 ⫾ 53 .321
The study was approved by the Institutional Review (lb; mean ⫾ SD)
African-American race (%) 74.4 74.2 .974
Board of the University of Mississippi Medical Center. Parous (%) 39.4 47.0 .214
All patients delivered of a pregnancy at or greater than Cesarean delivery (%) 35.6 37.4 .762
20 weeks of gestation and diagnosed with mild (MPRE), MPRE, mild preeclampsia; SPRE, severe preeclampsia (includes 3
severe preeclampsia or hemolysis, elevated liver en- patients with HELLP syndrome); CPRE, chronic hypertension with
zymes, low platelets syndrome (SPRE), or chronic hy- superimposed preeclampsia; SD, standard deviation.

pertension with superimposed preeclampsia (CPRE) be-


tween July 1, 1997, and March 31, 1998, were eligible for
inclusion in this investigation. Patients were not consid- Statistical analysis was performed using analysis of vari-
ered for study enrollment if they were at less than 20 ance and, if significant, the Student-Newman-Keuls multi-
weeks of gestation, had hypokalemia (K ⬍ 3.0 mEq/L) ple comparison procedure was used to detect pair-wise
on admission, were already taking diuretics or potassium difference. If the assumptions for analysis of variance were
not tenable, nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis tests based on
supplements for any reason, demonstrated any hemo-
rank transformations were used. Categorical variables were
dynamic instability surrounding the events of delivery,
analyzed using ␹2 tests and pair-wise comparisons were
or were unable to understand and sign the informed
adjusted using a Bonferroni correction. A P value of less
consent.
than .05 was considered significant.
After informed consent was obtained, patients were
We estimated that 125 patients in each of the 2 treat-
randomly assigned to groups by opening the next previ-
ment arms would be adequate to detect a 5 mm Hg shift
ously prepared sequential and numbered opaque study
in systolic blood pressure (1 standard deviation equals 13
envelope. Treatment was begun at the time that intrave- mm Hg) with approximately 80% power at the nominal
nous magnesium sulfate was discontinued and spontane- 5% level of significance. We allowed for a 10% rate of
ous diuresis initiated (⬎ 100 mL/h for 2 hours consecu- failure to meet the inclusion criteria. Thus 275 sealed
tively without stimulus) as soon as 2 hours to as long as envelopes were prepared for random assignment of pa-
24 hours after delivery. A shortened postpartum course tients to either treatment or control group. In the initial
of magnesium sulfate was used as previously described.6 randomization, no stratification into groups based on
Patients in the treatment group were assigned to receive diagnostic category was considered. A post hoc analysis
furosemide (Lasix, Hoechst-Marion Roussel, Inc, Kan- based on stratifying by diagnostic group showed that our
sas City, MO) 20 mg/d together with an oral potassium weakest test, comparing chronic hypertensives with su-
supplement (K-Dur, Schering-Plough Co, Kenilworth, perimposed preeclampsia, would allow us to detect shifts
NJ) 20 mEq/d for a total of 5 consecutive days during of approximately 15 mm Hg in systolic blood pressure.
hospitalization and after hospital discharge. Patients in The sample sizes for severe preeclampsia provide ade-
the control group received neither medication. quate power (80%) for detecting 10 mm Hg shifts in
Patients in both groups received similar postpartum systolic blood pressure. For mild preeclampsia, they are
surveillance, including blood pressure and pulse assess- adequate to detect approximately 7-mm Hg shifts.
ment every 4 hours, daily weight measurement, and
daily urinary output measurements, while hospitalized.
Antihypertensive therapy was administered to patients RESULTS
with intermittent or persistent (ⱖ 2) elevations of systolic A total of 264 patients were eligible for the study and
(ⱖ 150 mm Hg) or diastolic (ⱖ 100 mm Hg) blood consented to participate. The composition of each group
pressure(s) after assignment to receive either furosemide and demographic characteristics are shown in Table 1,
or no medication. with patients evenly balanced between treatment and

30 Ascarelli et al Postpartum Severe Preeclampsia OBSTETRICS & GYNECOLOGY


Table 2. Postpartum Blood Pressure and Pulse Rate Imme- Table 3. Postpartum Antihypertensive Medication Usage
diately Postpartum and at Transfer From Labor/ for the 3 Patient Groups is Shown Both During
Delivery/Recovery Unit to Postpartum Ward for the Hospitalization and at the Time of Hospital
3 Patient Groups Discharge
Factor MPRE SPRE CPRE P Furosemide
Immediately postpartum Yes No P
Systolic BP 136 ⫾ 18 139 ⫾ 18 141 ⫾ 22 .391
During hospitalization
Diastolic BP 71 ⫾ 16 75 ⫾ 18 73 ⫾ 19 .225
MPRE 5 (4) 6 (5) 1.000
Pulse rate 98 ⫾ 17 94 ⫾ 18 92 ⫾ 16 .068
SPRE 14 (5) 26 (9) .371
Hypertensive (%)* 44 51 60 .249
CPRE 27 (4) 30 (3) 1.000
Transfer to ward
At hospital discharge
Systolic BP 131 ⫾ 13 138 ⫾ 13 146 ⫾ 15 ⬍ .001
MPRE 5 (4) 3 (3) .642
Diastolic BP 69 ⫾ 13 75 ⫾ 10 77 ⫾ 10 ⬍ .001
SPRE 6 (2) 26 (9) .045
Pulse rate 93 ⫾ 14 91 ⫾ 14 93 ⫾ 11 .500
CPRE 27 (4) 20 (2) 1.000
Hypertensive (%)* 23 43 68 ⬍ .001
MPRE, mild preeclampsia; SPRE, severe preeclampsia (includes three
MPRE, mild preeclampsia; SPRE, severe preeclampsia; CPRE, patients with HELLP syndrome); CPRE, chronic hypertension with
chronic hypertension with superimposed preeclampsia; BP, blood superimposed preeclampsia.
pressure. Data are shown as % (n).
Blood pressure values are in millimeters of mercury, and pulse rate
values are in beats per minute.
* Hypertensive: systolic BP ⱖ 140 mm Hg or diastolic BP ⱖ 90
mm Hg. time of transfer to the postpartum ward and initiation of
therapy, with a downward trend for patients with MPRE
or SPRE and an upward trend for patients with under-
control for each disease category. Altogether, 64.0% had lying chronic hypertension (CPRE).
MPRE, 26.5% had SPRE, and 9.5% were CPRE. Pa- An analysis of blood pressure values revealed that
tients with chronic hypertension and superimposed pre- systolic blood pressure was significantly lower on the
eclampsia (CPRE) were significantly older (25.6 ⫾ 7.6 second postpartum day in furosemide-treated patients
years compared with 22.8 ⫾ 5.9 and 22.2 ⫾ 5.6, P ⬍ .05) with SPRE (142 ⫾ 13 mm Hg) compared with higher
and heavier (107.1 ⫾ 32.5 kg 关238 ⫾ 70 lb兴 compared values of control patients with SPRE (153 ⫾ 19 mm Hg,
with 89.1 ⫾ 21.2 kg 关198 ⫾ 47 lb兴 and 89.6 ⫾ 24.8 kg P ⬍ .004). There were, however, no significant differ-
关199 ⫾ 55 lb兴, P ⫽ .002) than patients with mild (MPRE) ences in the diastolic blood pressure values or pulse rates
or severe (SPRE) preeclampsia respectively. Cesarean observed postpartum between either the MPRE or the
delivery occurred significantly more often in patients chronic hypertension groups that did or did not receive
with severe (50%) or superimposed (48%) preeclampsia furosemide. The small number of patients in both the
compared with patients with mild (29.2%) disease. No treated and control groups with CPRE, however, pre-
significant differences were observed for gravidity or cludes meaningful evaluation. Data on postpartum ma-
parity. ternal weights was inadequate to evaluate.
Blood pressures and pulse rates immediately postpar- The frequency of antihypertensive agent use was re-
tum and again at the time of discharge from the Labor/ duced to some extent in all furosemide-treated patient
Delivery/Recovery Unit to the postpartum ward when groups during hospitalization and at the time of hospital
therapy was started are depicted in Table 2 for groups of discharge (Table 3). The only statistically significant
patients with mild, severe, or superimposed preeclamp- difference observed, however, was an increase in the
sia. Patients with MPRE immediately postpartum exhib- number of SPRE patients in the control group who
ited a pulse rate that was approximately 6 beats per required additional antihypertensive medication at the
minute faster than patients in the other two groups with time of hospital discharge (26%) compared with a much
a 95% confidence interval of 1.1–10.8. There were no lower incidence of 6% in patients with SPRE who were
other significant differences at entry among groups. At receiving furosemide therapy (P ⫽ .045, Table 3).
the time of transfer to the postpartum ward, however, Length of hospitalization was related to disease cate-
both groups of patients with preeclampsia (MPRE and gory primarily, not to whether the patient received furo-
SPRE) exhibited a lower frequency of hypertension com- semide (P ⫽ .429) and was not different based on mode of
pared with an increase for patients with underlying delivery. As expected, patients with MPRE required signif-
chronic hypertension. Approximately 20% of those with icantly shorter magnesium sulfate infusion (mean 9 hours,
MPRE and hypertension immediately postpartum be- range 6.5–13) compared with SPRE (mean 15 hours, range
came normotensive before transfer to the postpartum 12–24) and chronic hypertension (mean 13 hours, range
ward. Pulse rates were equivalent among groups at the 12–22; P ⬍ .001). Patients with MPRE also had signifi-

VOL. 105, NO. 1, JANUARY 2005 Ascarelli et al Postpartum Severe Preeclampsia 31


cantly shorter hospitalizations (mean 2 days, range 2–3) travascular fluid, and the difficult task of controlling
compared with SPRE (mean 3 days, range 2– 4) and blood pressure while the parturient is volume over-
chronic hypertension (mean 3 days, range 2–5; P ⬍ .001). loaded. We interpret the findings from our study to
Delayed postpartum complications requiring inter- suggest that patients with severe preeclampsia who re-
vention of some type occurred in 5.3% of the study ceived furosemide more effectively eliminated intravas-
population, 8 patients in the control arm (MPRE: wound cular fluid that was mobilized from the interstitium dur-
infection ⫽ 2, delayed postpartum hemorrhage ⫽ 1, ing the early puerperium and thereby reduced blood
endomyometritis ⫽ 1, pulmonary hypertension with volume and blood pressure, obviating the need to begin
congestive heart failure ⫽ 1; SPRE: wound infection ⫽ antihypertensive medication.
1, vulvar hematoma ⫽ 1; and CPRE: pyelonephritis ⫽ The underlying pathophysiology of preeclampsia is
1) and 6 patients in the furosemide treatment arm believed to involve diffuse vasospasm with endothelial
(MPRE: hypertension ⫽ 1, urinary tract infection and cell damage.7 Thus transudation of plasma proteins
depression ⫽ 1, endometritis ⫽ 1, nephrotic syndrome across any damaged membrane surfaces can lead to
at six weeks postpartum ⫽ 1; SPRE: hypertension ⫽ 1, hypoalbuminemia, a lowered intravascular colloid on-
wound seroma ⫽ 1; CPRE ⫽ 0). cotic pressure, fluid migration into the interstitium, intra-
vascular volume depletion, and systemic edema.8 –10 Af-
ter delivery, fluid that has been sequestered in the
DISCUSSION extravascular space is mobilized, producing a large auto-
We demonstrated that furosemide therapy initiated infusion of fluid from the extravascular to the intravas-
early in the first 24 hours postpartum to patients with cular compartment.11 Colloid osmotic pressure de-
severe preeclampsia, compared with controls, better nor- creases while increases in central venous pressure and
malized elevated blood pressure and lessened the need to pulmonary capillary wedge pressure can develop, condi-
initiate antihypertensive therapy. No immediate benefit tions that favor the development of pulmonary edema,
was gained in patients with mild preeclampsia. Length of especially in the patient with severe preeclampsia.12,13
hospitalization for the total study population, however, Protracted use of intravenous magnesium sulfate can
seemed not to be significantly shortened by this interven- exacerbate this process and itself lead to formation of
tion. Although the frequency of delayed postpartum pulmonary edema.14
complications within the first 6 weeks after delivery was Because postpartum pulmonary edema and conges-
similar between groups, the only 2 patients requiring tive heart failure can occur to some degree after delivery
readmission to the Labor/Delivery/Recovery Unit for as a result of this fluid mobilization process, logical
management of elevated blood pressure and exacerba- management would direct therapy at maintaining a low
tion of preeclampsia were 2 patients (one MPRE, one central venous pressure and pulmonary capillary wedge
SPRE) in the furosemide group. One patient in the pressure and attempting to raise the colloid osmotic
control group with mild preeclampsia did require read- pressure to preclude the development of pulmonary
mission for delayed puerperal complications related to edema and congestive heart failure.12,15 It follows that
pulmonary hypertension and congestive heart failure. fluid restriction in the postpartum period coupled with
Based on the size, number and type of hypertensive the administration of a diuretic can be considered appro-
conditions in the patients studied, we found that the priate in these circumstances. Risks of low-dose diuretic
small benefit realized in the patient with severe pre- therapy are minimal and minimized probably by the
eclampsia did not also translate into shorter hospitaliza- addition of a modest daily oral potassium supplement.
tion or fewer other complications. We emphasize that We chose to use furosemide instead of hydrochlorothi-
the treatment course for postpartum furosemide was azide for this investigation primarily because it has not
only 5 days in duration, involved a relatively low dose of been associated with neonatal thrombocytopenia in
diuretic, and was not initiated until spontaneous diuresis breastfed infants, although it does cross into breast milk
occurred. and can inhibit milk production.16
The potential benefit of diuretic use for patients with This approach to management may also apply to
severe preeclampsia or eclampsia is an important issue in minimizing the risk of central nervous system morbidity
contemporary obstetrics and maternal-fetal medicine. in puerperal patients, because cerebral edema and post-
Patients with severe and superimposed forms of pre- partum eclampsia, both hypothetically related to cere-
eclampsia can suffer sustained hypertension, presum- bral over perfusion rather than decreased cerebral blood
ably in response to the presence of excess total body flow,17 might benefit from peripheral fluid offloading
water, impaired sodium excretion due to reduced glo- and the purported benefit of some diuretics to reduce
merular filtration, mobilization of interstitial and ex- peripheral venous tone.18

32 Ascarelli et al Postpartum Severe Preeclampsia OBSTETRICS & GYNECOLOGY


Our study has limitations due to small sample size 5. Magann EF, Martin JN Jr. Complicated postpartum pre-
particularly in the SPRE and CPRE groups. Bias is eclampsia-eclampsia. Obstet Gynecol Clin North Am
possible, because the clinicians were not blinded to group 1995;22:337–56.
assignment. Because each patient in the investigation 6. Ascarelli MH, Johnson V, May WL, Martin RW, Martin
continued treatment a few days after discharge, we do JN Jr. Individually determined postpartum magnesium
not know how many patients actually took the medica- sulfate therapy using clinical parameters to safely and cost
effectively shorten treatment for preeclampsia. Am J
tion after leaving the hospital. Significant adverse events
Obstet Gynecol 1998;179:962– 6.
are relatively infrequent in most traditionally treated
7. Roberts JM, Lain KY. Recent insights into the pathogene-
patient populations with preeclampsia, thus requiring a
sis of pre-eclampsia. Placenta 2002;23:359 –372.
very large patient population studied in multiple sites
8. Mabie WC, Ratts TE, Sibai BM. The central hemodynam-
and circumstances to truly evaluate any impact of post-
ics of severe preeclampsia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1989;161:
partum diuretic therapy upon delayed fluid mobiliza- 1443– 8.
tion–related complications. Our study was too small to
9. Visser W, Wallenburg HC. Central hemodynamic obser-
evaluate this issue, because no patient in either group vations in untreated preeclamptic patients. Hypertension
developed such a complication. The only patient in the 1991;17:1072–7.
entire study to develop congestive heart failure did so as 10. Sibai BM, Mabie BC, Harvey CJ, Gonzalez AR. Pulmo-
a result of previously undiagnosed pulmonary hyperten- nary edema in severe preeclampsia-eclampsia: analysis of
sion in association with mild preeclampsia. thirty-seven consecutive cases. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1987;
This study does not firmly establish a short course of 156:1174 –9.
low dose furosemide begun at the time on spontaneous 11. Bolton LM, Thomas TH, Dunlop W. Erythrocyte ion and
diuresis as a clearly advantageous adjunct to the routine water balance and membrane potential in the puerperium
management of patients with severe or superimposed of normal pregnancy. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1996;103:
preeclampsia. Although the need for antihypertensive 547–51.
therapy was reduced whenever furosemide was used, it 12. Pearson JF. Fluid balance in severe preeclampsia. Br J
was only significant in patients with severe preeclampsia, Hosp Med 1992;48:47–51.
and this may not matter to clinicians, because the benefit 13. Clark SL, Cotton DB. Clinical indications for pulmonary
was not translated into shorter hospitalizations or fewer artery catheterization in the patient with severe preeclamp-
complications. A larger investigation in these 2 patient sia. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1988;158:453– 8.
populations, perhaps using a larger systemic dose of 14. Yeast JD, Halberstadt C, Meyer BA, Cohen GR, Thorp
furosemide initiated soon after delivery, is needed to JA. The risk of pulmonary edema and colloid osmotic
determine whether there is benefit and minimal risk to pressure changes during magnesium sulfate infusion. Am J
using this approach for the prevention of delayed com- Obstet Gynecol 1993;169:1566 –71.
plications, including pulmonary edema, postpartum 15. Fadnes HO, Oian P. Transcapillary fluid balance and
eclampsia, preeclampsia-related cerebrovascular acci- plasma volume regulation: a review. Obstet Gynecol Surv
dents, and myocardial infarction. 1989;44:769 –73.
16. Jerkner K, Hitti J, Victorin L. Platelet counts in mothers
and their newborn infants with respect to antepartum
REFERENCES administration of oral diuretics. Acta Med Scand 1973;
1. Ferrazzani S, De Carolis S, Pomini F, Testa AC, Mastro- 194:473–5.
marino C, Caruso A. The duration of hypertension in the 17. Belfort MA, Anthony J, Saade GR, Allen JC Jr. A compar-
puerperium of preeclamptic women: relationship with ison of magnesium sulfate and nimodipine for the preven-
renal impairment and week of delivery. Am J Obstet tion of eclampsia. N Engl J Med 2003;348:304 –11.
Gynecol 1994;171:506 –12. 18. Goodlin RC. Venous reactivity and pregnancy abnormal-
2. Jacober SJ, Morris DA, Sowers JR. Postpartum blood ities. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 1986;65:345–7.
pressure and insulin sensitivity in African-American
women with recent preeclampsia. Am J Hypertens 1994;
7:933– 6. Reprints are not available. Address correspondence to: James N.
3. Suzuki S, Gejyo R, Ogino S, Maruyama Y, Ueno M, Nishi Martin Jr, MD, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Uni-
S. Postpartum renal lesions in women with preeclampsia. versity of Mississippi Medical Center, 2500 North State Street,
Nephrol Dial Transplant 1997;12:2488 –93. Jackson, MS 39216; e-mail: jnmartin@ob-gyn.umsmed.edu.
4. Giannina G, Belfort MA, Cruz AL, Herd JA. Persistent
cerebrovascular changes in postpartum preeclamptic
women: a Doppler evaluation. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1997; Received July 6, 2004. Received in revised form September 15, 2004.
177:1213– 8. Accepted September 23, 2004.

VOL. 105, NO. 1, JANUARY 2005 Ascarelli et al Postpartum Severe Preeclampsia 33

You might also like