759 views

Uploaded by puru55980

- Production Control & Planning
- Sales Forecasting Examples
- World: Hand Tools - Market Report. Analysis and Forecast to 2020
- PAPER Obermeyer
- Marwala's MSc Dissertation
- The Performance of Rice Markets in Bangladesh During the 1974 Famine (2)
- Forecasting
- US Federal Reserve: 199640pap
- Forecasting
- SCM APO DP Overview
- R with Azure Machine Learning Tutorial Document.docx
- Time Series Group Assignment
- summary core
- hChap13.doc
- Graphing - Line Graphs and Scatter Plots
- Demandforecsting Methods
- Working Capital China
- Forecast
- Time Series
- Analisis 1( Moving Average)

You are on page 1of 5

Introduction

In extrapolative forecasting we predict the future by extrapolating a historical trend. What has

happened in the past determines what is forecast for the future [with other forecasting methods,

such as exploratory forecasting, this need not be so. For example, with exploratory forecasting we

can explore revolutionary, as well as evolutionary, scenarios]. In some circumstances it is right to

use extrapolative forecasting. In other cases different approaches might be more suitable. It is not

an appropriate approach to use in a new product/ new business situation, or in situations where

circumstances have radically changed, and the past is no guide to the future.

Any time series [a series of numbers recording past events] will have been produced by the

interaction of a number of variables. For example, a time series of a company's past profits will

have been produced by a complex process, which involves an interaction between multiple revenue

streams and numerous costs. Extrapolative forecasting would not require the forecaster to identify

these individual variables, or the ways in which they interacted. The underlying process [variables

and their interaction], which generated profits, would be treated as a black box [not analysed in

detail].

To produce a profit forecast scenario using exploratory [what if] methods it would be necessary to

analyse and model the total sales and costs process; including cost and revenue behaviour and the

relationship between all the cost and revenue variables involved in the process. To produce a

forecast profit scenario by extrapolative forecasting it is only necessary to obtain a series of past

profit figures and extend them to produce a forecast figure.

This usually makes the extrapolative forecasting approach quicker and cheaper; it also makes it

more risky. Since the underlying processes producing the forecast are not being modeled there is a

danger of overlooking some fundamental change in the process, which makes it unwise to assume

any continuity of events.

There are a number of different extrapolative forecasting methods, ranging form the simple to the

very complex. One of the simplest methods is eyeball extrapolation. This involves producing a

chart of past values and then forecasting by line of sight. Other simple methods include weighted

average and exponential smoothing. Research has shown that the more complex methods are not

necessarily superior to the simpler methods in terms of forecasting accuracy. Often, the simpler

methods are just as reliable as the more complex. There is no single best method. Because different

time series will contain different kinds of trends [linear, exponential, logarithmic etc], and different

forms of noise [see below] forecasters need to carry out statistical tests [see below] to identify the

method that will work best with their data and suit their particular requirements [e.g. how far in to

the future do they need to forecast - some methods only work for one period ahead].

When To Use

The extrapolative forecasting approach can be employed when there is a set of historical data,

which is believed to contain a trend, and it is believed that this trend can be isolated and used to

forecast future events. For example, if a company has accurate records of its sales for the past six

periods, and believes that there has been a trend in its past sales, and, also believes that this trend

will continue into the future. In these circumstances it may be able to use extrapolative forecasting

methods to help it to forecast its sales for future periods. Before extrapolative forecasting methods

can be used a number of conditions have to be satisfied.

Consistency In The Environment

There needs to be a reasonable expectation that the conditions that have prevailed in the past will

continue to hold true for the period being forecast. This is not an absolute requirement. If there has

been some minor change in the environment a judgmental adjustment can be made to the values

produced by forecast calculations. However, whenever there have been major changes in the

environment, such as a competitor introducing a radical new product, extrapolative forecasting

methods become less appropriate. If a manager is intending to make a decision with radical

consequences extrapolative forecasting methods are of little value since the effect of the decision

would be to change the environment.

Data Availability

Reliable quantitative historical data has to be available. Extrapolative forecasting methods would

not be appropriate for start up, or new product launches where relevant historical data is not

available. Nor would they be appropriate where the historical data is unreliable, perhaps because it

has not been recorded in a consistent manner over the relevant time period. Most accounting and

business systems contain copious amounts of data organised on a time basis, but one has to be

certain that information is both reliable and in a usable form.

Data Comparability

Data relating to several past periods has to be reduced to a common basis. This can be a problem

when forecasting something like future sales. Usually what one is trying to do is forecast future

sales volumes and the temptation is to do this using sales values as a surrogate for volumes since

the accounting system will have recorded values, not physical volumes. The danger in doing that is

that price inflation will have affected sales values and £1m of sales in 1999 does not represent the

same volume of physical sales as £1m in 1989. In a situation like that, if sales values are to be used

for forecasting purposes the values have to be inflation adjusted. If possible physical volumes

should be used instead of monetary units but there are unfortunately many instances where this is

not feasible. Another problem in data comparability arises when a company sells a range of

products or services and that mix has changed over time. Here again it may be necessary to forecast

each component in the mix separately.

Cost

The benefit expected from the forecast should exceed the costs of collecting and processing the

data. A supermarket might well want to forecast the short term demand for each of its many

thousands of product lines but could only do so if it could easily collect data on past sales at point

of sale via some method such a bar code reading by lasers at the checkout, and process the data

using a fairly simple and computationally undemanding extrapolative forecasting technique.

Simplicity

As a general rule management will use information it understands. Someone who is responsible for

a decision will usually not base that decision on a technique, which they cannot understand. There

is a wide range of forecasting techniques. Ranging from simple ones, which are readily intelligible

to most people, to others, which require a PhD in mathematics to understand. If it becomes obvious

that the only appropriate forecasting technique is mathematically complex you have to ask yourself

firstly whether you can competently employ it, and secondly whether the client will understand and

accept the results of the calculations.

Some Extrapolative Forecasting Methods

The simplest extrapolative forecasting method is the naïve forecast, which involves taking the

actual value for the current period as the forecast for the next period. This method assumes that

there is no pattern present in historical data. This is sometimes the case and the naïve forecast

method is then the most accurate to use. Forecasts produced by this method can also be used as

benchmarks to measure the accuracy of other forecasting methods when applying the statistical

tests mentioned above.

Eyeball Forecasting

A time series is charted and a forecast is made by line of sight. Testing has shown this to be a

surprisingly accurate method.

Moving Average

The simplest smoothing method is the moving average. The average can be taken over any number

of periods. The fewer the number of periods the faster the forecast values will be to respond to

changes in actual values. The greater the number of periods the slower the forecast will be to

respond to changes and the less it will be influenced by random variations. Which period is

appropriate will depend on the variability of the data.

It may be that in a data series there is a great deal of random variation and this needs to be

smoothed out to prevent it corrupting the forecast. In this case a long period average would be used.

In other circumstances it may be that it is felt that there is a rapidly changing pattern in the data and

the forecast needs to respond quickly to changes. In that case a three period average may well be

more appropriate. It should be noted that the moving average method is usually only used to

forecast for one period in advance. The weakness with the method is that it attaches equal weight to

all the periods taken into the averaging calculation.

One of the weaknesses of the simple moving average can be overcome by attaching weights to

different past periods when performing the averaging calculation. This allows greater weight to be

given to the most recent periods and less to earlier periods by varying the weights attached. Some

experimentation is usually needed to determine what set of weights works best with a particular set

of data.

Exponential Smoothing

Exponential smoothing employs the formula Ft = Ft-1 + [Et-1*alpha]

This means that a forecast Ft is calculated by taking the previous periods forecast value Ft-1and

adding to it some percentage [alpha] of the error Et-1 [difference between the previous periods

actual value and the previous periods forecast value] in the last periods forecast. The value of alpha

determines how much of the current error is taken into account when calculating the next periods

forecast.

If the value of alpha is, say, 0.9 then nearly all the error will be taken into account and the forecast

will be very responsive to changes in actual values. If the value of alpha is 0.1 then the forecast will

respond much more slowly to changes in actual values.

The selection of an appropriate value of alpha will be a matter of trial and error [and the results of

statistical tests of accuracy], and will depend very much upon the variability of the series being

forecast. Selection of the alpha value can be done by calculating forecasting using several different

values of alpha and then calculating several measures of error for each forecast. This method would

be used for forecasting one period into the future. It does not work well with highly seasonal data.

Both the moving average and exponential smoothing methods work best with data, which exhibits a

horizontal, though perhaps highly variable, data pattern. They work much less well with series that

include a seasonal or trend pattern. If simple exponential smoothing is used on a series that includes

a trend the forecast will always lag behind in recognising the trend. If a series is believed to contain

randomness, a trend and seasonality then Winters exponential smoothing may be used.

Any trend that is present in a data set may be obscured by noise of various kinds. For example, the

data set may contain the residual influences of some expired event. Or it may contain the affects of

unusual or exceptional events. Almost certainly there will be at least some, and perhaps a great deal

of, random variation affecting the data. The problems can be illustrated by taking the example of a

company, which has sales records for eight previous periods and wishes to use this data to forecast

the next period’s sales. At the end of period four the company dropped a product line, which was

contributing 20% of sales volume. In period five part of its factory suffered a fire, which affected

its sales for two periods. It has also suffered three brief component supply interruptions during the

eight periods, all of which affected production and sales. Finally its sales are subject to quite

considerable variations about a mean due to a variety of random variations in demand from its

customers. It must decide how it should deal with each of these factors.

The dropped product line can be dealt with by removing the sales for that line from the first four

periods values. The effect of a new product line could have been dealt with by the same kind of

adjustment; by taking the sales values out of the mainstream data set and processing them

separately. The effects of the fire could be dealt with by adjusting the values for periods five and

six to what they would have otherwise have been. The component supply problems might require a

different kind of treatment. If they seem to occur fairly frequently their effect should be left in the

data set. No preliminary adjustment is required for the normal random variations.

The second problem that has to be dealt with is that there are many different kinds of patterns and

each requires a different approach. The simplest case is the horizontal pattern where the data is

subject to some random variations form period to period but overall is not increasing of decreasing

over time.

A slightly more complicated case arises when the data is subject to some random variations from

period to period and there is also and under lying increase or decrease over time. This underlying

change may follow a linear or a non-linear pattern. If the pattern in the data set is a power or

exponential trend it requires a different treatment to a linear trend.

A seasonal pattern occurs where a series varies according to the seasons of the year. A cyclical

pattern is similar to a seasonal pattern but the cycle is determined by some factor other than the

seasons. The cycle may be short or may be of several years’ duration. In a rapidly changing

environment it is sometimes difficult to detect a cyclical pattern and even more difficult to forecast

with confidence that the cycle will continue.

Statistical Testing

Statistical testing can be conducted to help identify which extrapolative forecasting method will

work best with the available data. Testing is necessary in order that inappropriate methods can be

avoided and effort concentrated on those methods, which produce the most accurate forecasts. We

can carry out testing to select the best method by producing ex post forecasts for past periods and

comparing the forecast values with the actual values for those periods. When the best method has

been found it is used to make ex ante forecasts.

Testing can also be used to refine the accuracy of the technique being employed since many

methods have internal parameters, which can be varied [e.g. weights in weighted moving average,

or the value of alpha in exponential smoothing]. Experiment and testing is used to find the most

suitable parameter values. The overall objective is to minimise the error [E] between forecast

values [F] and actual values [A]. There are a number of different tests that are used for measuring

forecasting accuracy.

• Mean Error [ME] is simply the average of the error [difference between forecast and

actual]. This measure is simple to compute but positive and negative errors tend to cancel

one another out and conceal the true magnitude of E.

• Mean Absolute Error [MAE] is the average of the absolute [ignoring sign] error. This test

overcomes the weakness of ME and provides a better measure of error.

• Mean Squared Error [MSE] is the average of the square of the absolute errors. This

measure emphasises substantial deviations from actual since an error of 2 will be squared to

4 but an error of 4 will be squared to 16. This measure would be particularly useful when

minor errors could be tolerated, but it was particularly important to avoid forecasting

methods, which produced large errors. For example, a company, which used sales

forecasting to set production levels and only maintained small finished goods stocks.

• Mean percentage error [MPE] is calculated by taking the average of absolute error as a

percentage of actual. This statistic allows easy comparisons to be made between different

forecasting methods, or different applications of the same method.

Finally, forecasts cannot be accepted unthinkingly but have to be subject to common sense

verification. Visualisation is also an important part of time series forecasting. Before using any

mathematical forecasting method it is a good idea to chart the data, and then study the chart to try

and understand the data patterns. Sometimes it will be very clear what kinds of trends are present in

the data, and what forecasting methods should be used.

- Production Control & PlanningUploaded byFaröuq d'Cröw
- Sales Forecasting ExamplesUploaded byMeet Bakotia
- World: Hand Tools - Market Report. Analysis and Forecast to 2020Uploaded byIndexBox Marketing
- PAPER ObermeyerUploaded byLeloulan
- Marwala's MSc DissertationUploaded byBall Sutta
- The Performance of Rice Markets in Bangladesh During the 1974 Famine (2)Uploaded byAzad Master
- ForecastingUploaded bynesjyn
- US Federal Reserve: 199640papUploaded byThe Fed
- ForecastingUploaded bygbulani11
- SCM APO DP OverviewUploaded byberater8
- R with Azure Machine Learning Tutorial Document.docxUploaded byEnzo Contreras Contreras
- Time Series Group AssignmentUploaded byLit Jhun Yeang Benjamin
- summary coreUploaded byapi-254501788
- hChap13.docUploaded bysansagith
- Graphing - Line Graphs and Scatter PlotsUploaded bySanjay Kumar
- Demandforecsting MethodsUploaded byRuchi Nanda
- Working Capital ChinaUploaded byDiego Rivera
- ForecastUploaded byพิสิทธิ์ วัฒนกุล
- Time SeriesUploaded bys.vijayarani
- Analisis 1( Moving Average)Uploaded byTommy Halim Mardhika
- A Fuzzy Inference Model for Short-term Load ForecastingUploaded byCristian Klen
- spsstrends160Uploaded byLalita Thakali
- Forecasting MethodsUploaded bydwoodmann
- Capacity PlanningUploaded bySyam Sundar
- TestUploaded byTarannum Yogesh Dobriyal
- Individual Biology investigationUploaded byMaurya Ghelani
- 13chapUploaded byMyo Myint
- Lesson 10Uploaded bySakshi Agarwal
- Managerial Usefulness of Variance Ppt Final DraftUploaded byUzma Salman
- Goals of ManagrsUploaded byRatul Khan

- Risk Management in Construction.pptUploaded bypuru55980
- Risk Management in Construction.pptUploaded bypuru55980
- The Real Reasons Why Indian Startups Struggle to Hire - Swaroop C HUploaded bypuru55980
- Resources in Project ManagementUploaded bypuru55980
- Best Practices in Project ManagementUploaded bypuru55980
- Plant MaintenanceUploaded bypuru55980
- Project Cost EstimationUploaded bypuru55980
- SCADA Point List 6 7 11Uploaded bypuru55980
- Forecasting-J E BeasleyUploaded bypuru55980
- StaticUploaded bypuru55980
- Singapore Case Formato FinalUploaded byKevin Chan
- Aol Tech Data 1Uploaded bypuru55980
- Annexure 1 -Final BMS Equipment Schedule 6 7 11Uploaded bypuru55980

- Ahbg-f-sec - Dc Power Loads ConnectorsUploaded bypatopick
- Questionnaire Impact Study Dryer CookerUploaded bykiranrauniyar
- Caro Audit ReportUploaded byAfroz Ahmed
- rylee kashmiry resumeUploaded byapi-425909723
- Virus PapayaUploaded byHenry González
- CISDL P5 GovernanceUploaded byjabarti
- Trusted Computing and Secure Virtualization in Cloud ComputingUploaded byTarik Jazic Jazha
- MSDS_EVOX DOT 4+_GBUploaded bysaab9355
- Roads in India - Designed to Fail ?Uploaded byProf. Prithvi Singh Kandhal
- Intercontinental to Open Crowne Plaza Convention Centre in OmanUploaded byBRGR
- Kory Judd IntroductionUploaded byHoang Nam
- Q MiniprepsUploaded byTham Su Ming
- Manual Corinex Low Voltage Access Gateway ENGUploaded byasesoralbert242
- 510 Monetary EconomicsUploaded byshahin317
- EDGAR-Analyzer Automating the Analysis of Corporate Data ContainedUploaded bychuff6675
- Trademark NotesUploaded byLuizaBalan
- Teranap 431 Tp 4m (en)Uploaded byFranco Saenz Solis
- ASTM D 529 – 00 Enclosed Carbon-Arc Exposures of Bituminous MaterialsUploaded byalin2005
- SAES-J-100Uploaded byethicalhacker2006
- Deployment Server 71 DeployUploaded bymlmcbride33
- STFC Prospectus FinalUploaded bymeenakshi_kumari36
- Mca IV Sem and ElectiveUploaded bysamarulraj
- LabelUploaded byrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
- @_mooring and Berthing Analysis and DesignUploaded byapi-3709579
- Control, Dynamics and OperationUploaded byGreen Heart
- Allen Holub's UML Reference CardUploaded byM.j. Méijome
- 10-auditing-rules.pdfUploaded byPurnama Pupung Hadi
- feasability proposalUploaded byapi-340734102
- App Marketing Networks 2014Uploaded bymobyaffiliates
- Cascade Tek Product Reliability Testing BrochureUploaded byCascade TEK