You are on page 1of 4

IJSTE - International Journal of Science Technology & Engineering | Volume 3 | Issue 11 | May 2017

ISSN (online): 2349-784X

Soil Structure Interaction Analysis of Multi


Storey Building
Nimisha Ann Sunny Dr. Alice Mathai
PG Student Associate Professor
Department of Civil Engineering Department of Civil Engineering
Mar Athanasius College of Engineering, Kothamangalam, Mar Athanasius College of Engineering, Kothamangalam,
Kerala, India Kerala, India

Abstract
The analysis of building structure in contact with soil involves an interactive process of stresses and strains developed within the
structure and the soil field. The response of Piled-Raft Foundation system to the structure is very challenging because there is an
important interplay between the component of building structure and the soil field. Herein, soil - structure interaction of buildings
founded on Piled-Raft Foundation is evaluated through Finite Element Analyses using ANSYS v17.0. The building settlement
and equivalent stress is computed. The study has been conducted by modeling building with soil and without soil. It is concluded
that the interaction of building foundation-soil field and super-structure has remarkable effect on the structure.
Keywords: Soil – Structure Interaction, Static Analysis, Geometric Non Linearity, Piled – Raft Foundation, ANSYS
Workbench 17.0
________________________________________________________________________________________________________

I. INTRODUCTION

The process in which the response of the soil influences the motion of the structure and the motion of the structure influences the
response of the soil is termed as soil-structure interaction (SSI) The analysis of Piled-Raft Foundation is very challenging because
the load in the piled-raft structures is transferred to the soil not only by the interaction between the soil and the piles but also by
the interaction between foundation structure and superstructure. In this interaction, deformations in the soils are the key factor
which will affect forces and deformation in foundation and superstructure. The combined piled-raft foundation penetrates deep
into the foundation soil increasing its significant depth below the ground and affects the response of structure and soil. The method
of analysis of foundation and structure also affects the response of structure and soil. A simplified procedure has been followed
for estimation of building settlement and equivalent stress. In this method, piled-raft foundation under vertical load considering
interaction effects has been modeled and analyzed with soil ( flexible base) and without soil (fixed base ) in the finite element
package of ANSYS Workbench 17.0 incorporating geometric non-linearity. The study in this paper is extended by a comparison
between fixed base model and flexible base model.

II. STATIC ANALYSIS OF BUILDING IN ANSYS 17.0

Geometry of the building


In the selection of the frames' span width and height of storey, it has been tried to make the width and height to be conforming to
architectural principles and member section properties conforming to IS codes and structural principles. For this study, 10 storey
building with piled raft foundation has been considered. To reduce the complexity in analysis, a simple structure with base
dimension 12m x 12m was modeled. Cross-section properties of superstructure elements have been kept same for all floors, column
– 300 x600mm, beam – 300x50mm & floor slab – 150mm and cross-section properties of foundation elements raft – 850mm, pile
diameter – 750 mm & pile depth – 15m, all dimensions are as per design requirements. The soil plan area, was fixed such that,
horizontal dimension should be at least five times the horizontal dimension of building and depth of soil should be at least three
times depth of foundation, Therefore, soil volume modeled is 60x60x45m. The overall geometry of the two building
configurations, fixed base and flexile base are shown in Fig.1.

All rights reserved by www.ijste.org 67


Soil Structure Interaction Analysis of Multi Storey Building
(IJSTE/ Volume 3 / Issue 11 / 013)

Fig. 1: Fixed base and flexible base building models

Finite Element Modelling


The building models are modelled as three dimensional structural solids with element types assigned automatically by FEA
software, ANSYS 17.0. Mesh convergence study was done for building and used 300mm element size and for soil a coarser mesh
was used. No separation type contact was used between structure and soil elements and bonded contact type between structural
elements. The soil surface is taken as the contact surface; that of the structure (foundation) is taken as the target one, since its
rigidity is larger than that of the soil [2].

Material models used


For assessing the complete behaviour of structure and soil, proper material properties and element selection is required. Structure
and soil were modelled as linear and isotropic. Properties considered for analysis are Young’s Modulus (E), Poisson’s ratio (ν) and
Density (ρ). Properties of Concrete and soil are given in Table 1.

Boundary conditions and loading


Soil is modelled as rectangular solid around the foundation due to scope limit. Since soil is extended in infinity in actual case, we
modelled it as finite sized solid and applied boundary conditions. Bottom layer is considered as hard strata so it restrains the
movement in any direction, hence a fixed boundary condition is provided at the bottom soil solid element. That is, if soil lateral
side is perpendicular to x axis, displacement in x direction is restrained and displacement in y axis & z axis is free to move. Thus,
soil is restrained in the corresponding direction and allows free movement in other directions.
Table – 1
Material Properties of Concrete and Soil
Properties Structure Soil
Material Concrete Soft Soil
Young’s Modulus, E (Pa) 2.9 x 1010 2.5 x 107
Poisson’s ratio, ν 0.15 0.25
Density, ρ (kg/m3) 2500 1900

Fig. 2: Meshed models

Dead load and Live load are given as per IS 875 (Part I) and (Part II) 1987, respectively. Dead load includes, self-weight of all
elements and wall load, considering wall thickness of 200mm thick. All loads are applied as pressure.

All rights reserved by www.ijste.org 68


Soil Structure Interaction Analysis of Multi Storey Building
(IJSTE/ Volume 3 / Issue 11 / 013)

III. RESULTS OF STATIC ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSIONS

Static analysis gives performance of structure under static loads, in form of total deformation, stress in members etc. Here we have
considered the total deformation (settlement) of particular column in both models and equivalent stress in the building models

Total deformation of building

Fig. 3(a): Total deformation of building with fixed base Fig. 3(b): Total deformation of building with flexible base

Fig. 3(c): Total deformation of building with flexible base (sectional view)

Total deformation occurred to the column under consideration is greater in flexible base model (0.795m) compared to fixed base
model (0.0086m). Figure above shows how soil settlement occurs in actual case.

Equivalent stress in building models

Fig. 4(a): Equivalent Stress in building with flexible base Fig. 4(b): Equivalent Stress in building with fixed base

All rights reserved by www.ijste.org 69


Soil Structure Interaction Analysis of Multi Storey Building
(IJSTE/ Volume 3 / Issue 11 / 013)

Above figure shows the equivalent stress in building considering both cases. From which we can conclude that there is a difference
in stress distribution when we consider soil along with the building while analyzing. Average stress developed in model with
flexible base is more than the other model.

IV. CONCLUSIONS

The analysis of combined piled-raft foundation of multi-storey building is very challenging because of complexities involved in
the interaction between the components of building structure and soil field. The analysis of the tall building structure with complex
foundation system in uniform soil field should include the interaction of structure-foundation-soil. In this study, the finite element
soil structure interaction analysis of building structure having piled-raft foundation with soil model and without soil model is
conducted. The complete interaction among the soil field depth, settlement of building and stress developed in building has been
evaluated. From the study, it is seen that total deformation (vertical) of building is more in flexible base model than in fixed base
model, which means that in actual case settlement occurs and it depends on type of soil beneath. In the model where soil is
considered stress distribution pattern has varied. Average stress developed in model with soil is greater than other model .This
study indicates that building should be modeled along with the soil in which it is resting considering all properties of soil for the
analysis and design purpose.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

I am extremely thankful to my beloved project guide Dr.Alice Mathai for her valuable guidance, encouragement and immense
support throughout my humble endeavour. It is beyond words to express my sincere gratitude to all my friends and teachers for
the constant inspiration in completing this work.

REFERENCES
[1] Jonathan P. Stewart, Gregory L. Fenves and Raymond B. Seed (1999), Seismic Soil-Structure Interaction in Buildings I: Analytical Methods, Journal of
Geotechnical and Geo-environmental Engineering, 125:26-37.
[2] Xilin Lu, Peizhen Li, Bo Chen, and Yueqing Chen (2005), Computer simulation of the dynamic layered soil–pile–structure interaction system1, Canana
Geotechnical Journal Vol. 42.
[3] Lewis Edgers, Masoud Sanayei & Joseph L. Alonge (2005), Modeling the Effects of Soil-Structure Interaction on a Tall Building Bearing on a Mat
Foundation, Design Considerations, and Civil Engineering Practice Fall/Winter
[4] Julio A. García (2008), Soil Structure Interaction in the Analysis and Seismic Design Of Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings, The 14th World Conference
on Earthquake Engineering, 12-17.
[5] F. Ceroni, S. Sica, M. Pecce & A. Garofano (2012), Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on the Dynamic Behavior of Masonry and RC buildings, The 15th
World Conference on Earthquake Engineering.
[6] Pallavi Ravishankar and Dr. D Neelima Satyam (2013), Finite Element Modeling to Study Soil Structure Interaction of Asymmetrical Tall Building,
Workshop of TC207 during the 18th International Conference on Soil-Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering, Report No: IIIT/TR/2013/-1.
[7] Shreya Thusoo, Karan Modi, Rajesh Kumar and Hitesh Madahar (2015), Response of Buildings with Soil-Structure Interaction with Varying Soil Types,
International Journal of Civil, Environmental, Structural, Construction and Architectural Engineering, Vol:9, No:4.
[8] Shehata E. Abdel Raheem • Mohamed M. Ahmed, Tarek M. A. Alazrak (2015),Evaluation of soil–foundation–structure interaction effects on seismic response
demands of multi-story MRF buildings on raft foundations, International Journal Advanced Structural Engneering volume7:11–30
[9] Mohd Ahmed, Mahmoud H. Mohamed, Javed Mallick, Mohd Abul Hasan (2014), 3D-Analysis of Soil-Foundation-Structure Interaction in Layered Soil,
Open Journal of Civil Engineering, 4, 373-385
[10] Rahul Sawant and Dr. M. N. Bajad (2016), Effect of Soil-Structure Interaction on High Rise RC Building, IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering,
Volume 13, Issue 1 Ver. IV,PP 85-91.
[11] Anil K Chopra, Dynamics of Structures, Pearson (3rd Edition), 2016.
[12] J A Hemsley, Design Applications of Raft Foundation, Thomas Telford, 2000.

All rights reserved by www.ijste.org 70