You are on page 1of 5

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW II CASES

FUNDAMENTAL POWERS OF THE STATE


A. POLICE POWER
1. JMM Promotion & Management, Inc. v. CA, 1 1. Aguirre, Mary Grace L.
260 SCRA 319, Aug. 5, 1996
2. Lutz v. Araneta, 98 Phil. 148, 1955 2 2. Allera, Crystal D.
3. Assoc. Of Small Landowners v. Sec. Of 3 3. Alvarina, Joan Rhea D.
DAR, 175 SCRA 343, 1989
4. Lozano v. Martinez, 146 SCRA 323, 1986 4 4. Aragon, Edmond G.
5. Ynot v. IAC, 148 SCRA 148 SCRA 659, 5 5. Aranas, Phoebe Catherine G.
1987
6. City Gov’t. Of Quezon City v. Ericta, 122 6 6. Aurelia, Anita
SCRA 759, 1983
7. White Light Corp. v. City of Manila, GR # 7 7. Bacalla, Joy Sunneth R.
122846, Jan. 20, 2009
8. City of Manila v. Lagio 455 SCRA 308 8 8. Bacunawa, Dewmable D.
B. POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN
1. City of Manila v. Chinese Community 40 9 9. Borja, Frances Luz L.
PHIL 349, 1919
2. Pp v. Fajardo, 104 PHIL 443, 1958 10 10. Cabanero, Celestino A.
3. Rep. v. Castelvi, 58 SCRA 461, 1974 11 11. Cablao, Eduardo Jr.
4. Phil. Press Institute v. COMELEC, 244 SCRA 12 12. Castillo, Jonathan Vincent M.
272, 1995
5. Sumulong v. Guerrero 154 SCRA 461, 1987 13 13. Damayo, Dale N.
6. EPZA v. Dulay, 149 SCRA 305, 1987 14 14. Darasin, Ma. Dorilyn S.
7. Manila Electric Co. v. Penida 206, SCRA 15 15. Dignos, Hanna Crista S.
196, 1992
8. Mun. of Paranaque v. VM Realty Corp. 292 16 16. Garnace, Reynaldo B.
SCRA 678, Jul. 20, 1998
9. NPC v. Benjamin Ong Co, Feb. 10, 2009 17 17. Gernale, Sulpecio Lee III L.
Read Rule 67, Rules of Court
C. POWER OF TAXATION
1. Pascual v. Sec. Of Public Works, 110 PHIL 18 18. Guzman, Sarah S.
331, 1960
2. Punzalan v. Municipal Board of Manila, 95 19 19. Laniba, Louela L.
PHIL 46, 1954
3. Lladoc v. CIR, 14 SCRA 292 1965 20 20. Lugasan, Leslie Ann R.
4. Abra Valley College v. Aquino, 162 SCRA 21 21. Lukban, Sonny S.
106, 1988
5. Planters Products Inc. v. Fertiphil Corp., 22 22. Mabulay, Lai Mhin
Mar. 14, 2008
ART. III BILL OF RIGHTS
SEC. 1 – DUE PROCESS OF LAW AND EQUAL PROTECTION OF THE LAWS
DUE PROCESS OF LAW
1. Ichong v. Hernandez, 101 PHIL 1155, 1957 23 23. Makabenta, Evernick D.
2. Phil. Phost Fert. Corp. v. Torres, 231 SCRA 24 24. Margate, Don Joshua D.
335, 1994
3. Javier v. COMELEC, 144 SCRA 194, 1986 25 25. Ninofranco, Dick Jim M.
4. Ynot v. IAC, 148 SCRA 148 SCRA 659, 26 26. Olazo, Mary Angeline R.
1987
5. Alonte v. Savellano, 287 SCRA 245, 1998 27 27. Pabio, Processo Tomas R.
6. Aniag Jr. V. COMELEC, 237 SCRA 424, 28 28. Pedillaga, Zandra E.
1994
7. Ang Tibay v. CIR, 69 PHIL 635, 1940 29 29. Pernis, Eutiquio A.
8. Ateneo de Manila University v. Capulong, 30 30. Salado, Ma. Sony V.
222 SCRA 644, 1993
EQUAL PROTECTION OF THE LAWS
1. Quinto v. Tolentino v. COMELEC, GR# 31 31. Salvatierra, Daisy M.
189698, Dec. 1,2009
2. Biraogo v. Phil. Truth Commission GR# 32 32. Sevilla, Faith R.
192935 & 193036, Dec. 7, 2010
3. Villegas v. Hiu Chiong Tsai Pao Ho, 86 33 33. Tamayo, King C.
SCRA 270, 1978
4. Dumlao v. COMELEC, 96 SCRA 392, 1980 34 34. Tualla, Gennie Ann R.
5. Phil. Assoc. Of Service Exporters v. Drilon, 35 35. Aguirre, Mary Grace L.
163 SCRA 386, 1968
6. Himagan v. Pp., 237 SCRA 538, 1994 36 36. Allera, Crystal D.
7. Ormoc Sugar Co., Inc. v. Treas. Of Ormoc 37 37. Alvarina, Joan Rhea D.
City, 22 SCRA 603, 1968
8. League of Cities of the Phil. V. COMELEC, 38 38. Aragon, Edmond G.
Mun. Of Baybay, etc., Nov. 18, 2008
SEC. 2 – SEARCH AND SEIZURES
1. Pp v. Marti, 193 SCRA 57, 1991 39 39. Aranas, Phoebe Catherine G.
2. Stonehill v. Diokno, 20 SCRA 383, 1967 40 40. Aurelia, Anita
3. Soliven v. Makasiar, 167 SCRA 393, 1988 41 41. Bacalla, Joy Sunneth R.
4. Silva v. Presiding Judge, 203 SCRA 140, 42 42. Bacunawa, Dewmable D.
1991
5. Morano v. Vivo, 20 SCRA 562, 1967 43 43. Borja, Frances Luz L.
6. Harvey v. Santiago, 162 SCRA 840, 1988 44 44. Cabanero, Celestino A.
7. Alvarez v. CFI, 64 PHIL 33, 1937 45 45. Cablao, Eduardo Jr.
8. Mata v. Bayona, 128 SCRA 388, 1984 46 46. Castillo, Jonathan Vincent M.
9. Pp v. Del Rosario, 234 SCRA 246, 1994 47 47. Damayo, Dale N.
10. Umil v. Ramos, 187 SCRA 311, 1990 48 48. Darasin, Ma. Dorilyn S.
11. Pp v. Sucro, 195 SCRA 388, 1991 49 49. Dignos, Hanna Crista S.
12. Pp v. Rodriguez, 205 SCRA 791, 1992 50 50. Garnace, Reynaldo B.
13. Go. v. CA, 206 SCRA 138, 1992 51 51. Gernale, Sulpecio Lee III L.
14. Posadas v. CA, 188 SCRA 288, 1990 52 52. Guzman, Sarah S.
15. Pp. v. Mengote, 210 SCRA 174, 1992 53 53. Laniba, Louela L.
16. Pp. v. Aruta, 288 SCRA 626, 1998 54 54. Lugasan, Leslie Ann R.
17. Pp. v. Aminnudin, 163 SCRA 402, 1988 55 55. Lukban, Sonny S.
18. Pp. v. Malmstedt, 198 SCRA 401, 1991 56 56. Mabulay, Lai Mhin
19. Pp. v. Musa, 217 SCRA 597, 1993 57 57. Makabenta, Evernick D.
20. Valmonte v. De villa, 185 SCRA 665, 1989 58 58. Margate, Don Joshua D.
21. Microsoft v.Corp. v. Maxicorp, Inc., Sep. 59 59. Ninofranco, Dick Jim M.
13, 2004
22. Pp. v. Maribel Lagman & Zeng Wa Shui, 60 60. Olazo, Mary Angeline R.
Dec. 8, 2008
23. Sec. Of Nat’l. Defense v. Manalo, Oct. 7, 61 61. Pabio, Processo Tomas R.
2008
Read Rules 113 & 126, Rules of Court
SEC. 3 – PRIVACY OF COMMUNICATION & CORRESPONDENCE
1. Remirez v. CA & Garcia, 207 SCRA 1, 1992 62 62. Pedillaga, Zandra E.
2. Zulueta v. CA, 235 SCRA 699, 1996 63 63. Pernis, Eutiquio A.
3. Navarro v. CA, 313 SCRA 153, Aug. 26, 64 64. Salado, Ma. Sony V.
1999
SEC. 4 FREEDOM EXPRESSION, ASSEMBLY, AND PETITION
Freedom of Expression
1. Nat’l. Press Club v. COMELEC, 207 SCRA 1, 65 65. Salvatierra, Daisy M.
1992
2. Adiong v. COMELEC, 207 SCRA 712, 1992 66 66. Sevilla, Faith R.
3. INC v. CA, 259 SCRA 529, 1996 67 67. Tamayo, King C.
4. Miriam College Foundation, Inc. v. CA, 348 68 68. Tualla, Gennie Ann R.
SCRA 256, Dec. 15, 2000
5. US v. Bustos, 37 PHIL 731, 1909 69 69. Aguirre, Mary Grace L.
6. Ayer Prodcutions PTY Ltd v. Capulong, 160 70 70. Allera, Crystal D.
SCRA 861, 1988
7. Reyes v. Bagatsing, 125 SCRA 553, 1983 71 71. Alvarina, Joan Rhea D.
8. Gonzales v. Kalaw Katigbak, 137 SCRA 72 72. Aragon, Edmond G.
717, Jul. 22, 1985
9. Chavez v. Gonzales & NTC, Feb. 15, 2008 73 73. Aranas, Phoebe Catherine G.
Assembly & Petition
1. Primicias v. Fuguso, 80 PHIL 71, 1948 74 74. Aurelia, Anita
2. Reyes v. Bagatsing, 125 SCRA 553, 1983 75 75. Bacalla, Joy Sunneth R.
3. Malabanan v. Ramento 129 SCRA 359, 76 76. Bacunawa, Dewmable D.
1984
4. Luzviminda de la Cruz v. CA et al., 305 77 77. Borja, Frances Luz L.
SCRA 303, Mar. 25, 1999
5. PBM Employees Assoc. V. PBM, 51 SCRA 78 78. Cabanero, Celestino A.
189, 1973
6. BAYAN, KARAPATAN, KMP v. Ermita, 488 79 79. Cablao, Eduardo Jr.
SCRA 226, Apr. 25, 2007
SEC. 5 FREEDOM OF RELIGION
1. Aglipay v. Ruiz, 64 PHIL 201, 1937 80 80. Castillo, Jonathan Vincent M.
2. American Bible Soc. v. City of Manila, 101 81 81. Damayo, Dale N.
PHIL 386, 1957
3. Ebralinag v. Division Superintendent of 82 82. Darasin, Ma. Dorilyn S.
Cebu 219 SCRA 256, 1993
4. INC v. CA 259 SCRA, 1996 83 83. Dignos, Hanna Crista S.
5. Soriano v. Laguardia, Apr. 29, 2009 84 84. Garnace, Reynaldo B.
SEC. 6 LIBERTY OF ABODE & TRAVEL
1. Marcos v. Manglapus, 177 SCRA 668, 1989 85 85. Gernale, Sulpecio Lee III L.
2. Silverio v. CA, 195 SCRA 760, 1991 86 86. Guzman, Sarah S.
SEC. 7 RIGHT OF INFORMATION
1. Legaspi v. CSC, 150 SCRA 530, 1987 87 87. Laniba, Louela L.
2. Valmonte v. Belmonte, Jr. 170 SCRA 256, 88 88. Lugasan, Leslie Ann R.
1989
3. Echegaray v. Sec. DOJ, 297 SCRA 754, 89 89. Lukban, Sonny S.
Oct. 12, 1998
4. Chavez v. PCGG, 299 SCRA 744, Dec. 9, 90 90. Mabulay, Lai Mhin
1998
5. Neri v. Senate Committe on Accountability 91 91. Makabenta, Evernick D.
of Public Officers & Investigations, Mar.
25, 2008
SEC. 8 RIGHT TO FORM ASSOCIATIONS
1. SSS Employees Assoc. v. CA, 175 SCRA 92 92. Margate, Don Joshua D.
686, Jul. 28, 1989
2. Victoriano v. Elizalde Rope Workers Union, 93 93. Ninofranco, Dick Jim M.
59 SCRA 54, 1974
3. In Re: Edillon, 84 SCRA 554, 1978 94 94. Olazo, Mary Angeline R.
SEC. 10 NON-IMPAIRMENT CLAUSE
1. Ortigas Co. v. Feati Bank, 94 SCRA 533, 95 95. Pabio, Processo Tomas R.
1979
2. Lozano v. Martinez, 146 SCRA 323, 1986 96 96. Pedillaga, Zandra E.
SEC. 12 CUSTODIAL INVESTIGATION
1. Gamboa v. Cruz, 162 SCRA 642, 1988 97 97. Pernis, Eutiquio A.
2. Pp v. Ayason, 175 SCRA 216, 1989 98 98. Salado, Ma. Sony V.
3. Pp v. Mahinay, 302 SCRA 455, Feb. 1, 99 99. Salvatierra, Daisy M.
1999
4. Pp. v. Maqueda, 242 SCRA 565,1995 100 100. Sevilla, Faith R.
5. Pp. v. Daniega, 25 SCRA 626, 637, 1995 101 101. Tamayo, King C.
6. Pp. v. Bandula, 232 SCRA 566, 1994 102 102. Tualla, Gennie Ann R.
7. Pp. v. Lucero, 244 SCRA 425, 1995 103 103. Aguirre, Mary Grace L.
8. Pp v. Agustin, 240 SCRA 541, 1995 104 104. Allera, Crystal D.
9. Pp. v. Pinlac, 165 SCRA 675, 1988 105 105. Alvarina, Joan Rhea D.
10. Pp. v. Bolanos, 211 SCRA 262, 1992 106 106. Aragon, Edmond G.
11. Pp. v. Andan 269 SCRA 95, 1997 107 107. Aranas, Phoebe Catherine G.
12. Pp. v. Macam 238 SCRA 306, 1994 108 108. Aurelia, Anita
13. Pp v. Herson Tan y Verzo, GR# 117321, 109 109. Bacalla, Joy Sunneth R.
Feb. 11, 1988
14. Pp. v. Dy 158 SCRA 111, 1988 110 110. Bacunawa, Dewmable D.
15. Pp. v. Alicando, GR# 117487, Dec. 2, 1995 111 111. Borja, Frances Luz L.
16. Aquino v. Paste, Jun. 25, 2008 112 112. Cabanero, Celestino A.
READ RA 7438
SEC. 13 RIGHT TO BAIL
1. Basco v. Rapatalo, 269 SCRA 220, Mar. 5, 113 113. Cablao, Eduardo Jr.
1997
2. Pp. v. Donato, 198 SCRA 130, 1991 114 114. Castillo, Jonathan Vincent M.
3. Pp. v. Fortes 223 SCRA 619, 1993 115 115. Damayo, Dale N.
4. Comendador v. De Villa, 200 SCRA 80, 116 116. Darasin, Ma. Dorilyn S.
1991
5. Baylon v. Judge Sison, 243 SCRA 284, 117 117. Dignos, Hanna Crista S.
1995
6. Manotoc v. CA, 142 SCRA 149, 1986 118 118. Garnace, Reynaldo B.
READ RULE 114, RULES OF COURT
SEC. 14 CRIMINAL DUE PROCESS
Criminal Due Process
1. Tatad v. Sandiganbayan, 159 SCRA 70, 119 119. Gernale, Sulpecio Lee III L.
1988
2. Gatman v. Sandiganbayan, 144 SCRA 43, 120 120. Guzman, Sarah S.
1986
3. Alonte v. Savellano, 287 SCRA 245, 1998 121 121. Laniba, Louela L.
Presumption of Innocence
1. Pp . v. Dramayao, 42 SCRA 60, 1971 122 122. Lugasan, Leslie Ann R.
2. Dumlao v. COMELEC, 95 SCRA 392, 1980 123 123. Lukban, Sonny S.
3. Marquez v. COMELEC, 243 SCRA 538, Apr. 124 124. Mabulay, Lai Mhin
18, 1995
4. Corpuz v. Pp., 194 SCRA 73, 1991 125 125. Makabenta, Evernick D.
5. Trillanes IV v. Pimentel, Sr. Jun. 27, 2008 126 126. Margate, Don Joshua D.
Right to be heard himself & counsel
1. Pp. v. Holgado, 85 PHIL 752, 1950 127 127. Ninofranco, Dick Jim M.
2. Pp. v. Agbayani, 248 SCRA 315 128 128. Olazo, Mary Angeline R.
3. Amion v. Chongson, 301 SCRA 614, Jan. 129 129. Pabio, Processo Tomas R.
22, 1999
4. Cruz v. Millanes, Sept. 11, 2008 130 130. Pedillaga, Zandra E.
Right to be informed of the nature & cause of accusation
1. Pecho v. Pp., 262 SCRA 518, 1996 131 131. Pernis, Eutiquio A.
2. Soriano v. Sandiganbayan, 131 SCRA 184, 132 132. Salado, Ma. Sony V.
1984
3. Borja v. Mendoza, 77 SCRA 422, 1977 133 133. Salvatierra, Daisy M.
4. Mendoza v. Pp., Jul. 13, 2009 134 134. Sevilla, Faith R.
Right to speedy, impartial and public trial
1. Pp. v. Tee, GR#s 140546 to 47, Jan. 20, 135 135. Tamayo, King C.
2003
2. Flores v. Pp. 61 SCRA 331, Dec. 10, 1974 136 136. Tualla, Gennie Ann R.
3. Conde v. Revira, 45 PHIL 650, 1924 137 137. Aguirre, Mary Grace L.
4. Mateo, Jr. V. Villaluz, 50 SCRA 18, 1972 138 138. Allera, Crystal D.
5. Garcia v. Domingo, 52 SCRA 143, 1973 139 139. Alvarina, Joan Rhea D.
Trial in absentia
1. Pp. v. Salas, 143 SCRA 163, 1986 140 140. Aragon, Edmond G.
2. Carredo v. Pp., 183 SCRA 273, 1990 141 141. Aranas, Phoebe Catherine G.
3. Pp. v. Mapalao, 197 SCRA 79, 1991 142 142. Aurelia, Anita
4. Pp. v. Valeriano, et al., 226 SCRA ___, Sep. 143 143. Bacalla, Joy Sunneth R.
23, 1993
Right of confrontation
1. US v. Javier, 37 PHIL 449 144 144. Bacunawa, Dewmable D.
2. Talino v. Sandiganbayan, 148 SCRA 598, 145 145. Borja, Frances Luz L.
Mar. 16, 1987
SEC. 15 SUSPENSION OF THE PRIVILEGE OF THE WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS
1. Lansang v. Garcia, 42 SCRA 448, Mar. 16, 146 146. Cabanero, Celestino A.
1987
SEC. 16 RIGHT TO A SPEEDY DISPOSITION OF CASES
1. Padua v. Ericta, 161 SCRA 458, May 24, 147 147. Cablao, Eduardo Jr.
1988
2. Flores v. Pp. 61 SCRA 331, Dec. 10, 1974 148 148. Castillo, Jonathan Vincent M.
SEC. 17 RIGHT AGAINST SELF-INCRIMINATION
1. US v. Tan Teng, 23 PHIL 145, 1912 149 149. Damayo, Dale N.
2. Villaflor v. Summer, 41 PHIL 62, 1920 150 150. Darasin, Ma. Dorilyn S.
3. Beltran v. Samson, 53 PHIL 570, 1929 151 151. Dignos, Hanna Crista S.
4. Chavez v. CA, 24 SCRA 663, 1968 152 152. Garnace, Reynaldo B.
SEC. 19 PROHIBITED PUNISHMENT
1. Pp. v. Estosia, 93 PHIL 674, Aug. 27, 1953 153 153. Gernale, Sulpecio Lee III L.
2. Pp. v. Esparas & Libed, GR# 120034, Aug. 154 154. Guzman, Sarah S.
20, 1996
3. Echegaray v. Sec. DOJ, 297 SCRA 754, 155 155. Laniba, Louela L.
Oct. 12, 1998
SEC. 20 NON-IMPRISONMENT OF DEBT
1. Serafin v. Lindayag, 67 SCRA 166, 175 156 156. Lugasan, Leslie Ann R.
2. Lozano v. Martinez, 146 SCRA 323, 1986 157 157. Lukban, Sonny S.
SEC. 21 DOUBLE JEOPARDY
1. Pp. v. Obsania, 23 SCRA 1249, 1968 158 158. Mabulay, Lai Mhin
2. Paulin v. Gimenez, 217 SCRA 323, 1993 159 159. Makabenta, Evernick D.
3. Icasiano v. Sandiganbayan, 209 SCRA 377, 160 160. Margate, Don Joshua D.
May 1992
4. Pp. v. Balisacan, 17 SCRA 1119, 1966 161 161. Ninofranco, Dick Jim M.
5. Pp. v. City Court of Silay, 74 SCRA 248, 162 162. Olazo, Mary Angeline R.
1976
6. Esmena v. Pogoy, 102 SCRA 861, 1981 163 163. Pabio, Processo Tomas R.
7. Pp. v. Judge Penida 219 SCRA 1, Feb. 16, 164 164. Pedillaga, Zandra E.
1993
8. Pp. v. Tampal, 244 SCRA 202, 1995 165 165. Pernis, Eutiquio A.
9. Melo v. Pp., 85 PHIL 766, 1950 166 166. Salado, Ma. Sony V.
10. Pp. v. Adil, 76 SCRA 462, 1977 167 167. Salvatierra, Daisy M.
11. Pp. v. Judge Relova, 148 SCRA 292, 1987 168 168. Sevilla, Faith R.
SEC. 22 EX POST FACTO LAW & BILL OF ATTAINDER
1. Pp. v. Ferrer, 48 SCRA 382, 1972 169 169. Tamayo, King C.
2. Bayot v. Sandiganbayan, 128 SCRA 383, 170 170. Tualla, Gennie Ann R.
1984
3. Pp. v. Sandiganbayan, 211 SCRA 241, 1992 171 171. Aguirre, Mary Grace L.
4. Lacson v. Executive Sec. et al., 301 SCRA 172 172. Allera, Crystal D.
298, Jan. 20, 1999
ART. IV CITIZENSHIP
1. Tecson, et al. v. COMELEC, GR# 161434, 173 173. Alvarina, Joan Rhea D.
Mar. 3, 2004
2. Co. v. HRET, 199 SCRA 292, 1991 174 174. Aragon, Edmond G.
3. Yu v. Defensor-Santiago, 169 SCRA 364, 175 175. Aranas, Phoebe Catherine G.
1989
4. Frivaldo v. COMELEC, 174 SCRA 245, 1989 176 176. Aurelia, Anita
5. Rep. v. Judge de la Rosa, 232 SCRA 785, 177 177. Bacalla, Joy Sunneth R.
1994
6. Labo v. COMELEC, 176 SCRA 1, 1989 178 178. Bacunawa, Dewmable D.
7. Aznar v. COMELEC, 185 SCRA 703, 1990 179 179. Borja, Frances Luz L.
8. Mercado v. Manzano & COMELEC, 307 180 180. Cabanero, Celestino A.
SCRA 630, May 26, 1999
9. In re Ching, Bar Matter #914, 316 SCRA 181 181. Cablao, Eduardo Jr.
1, Oct. 1, 1999
10. Bengzon III v. HRET & Cruz, GR# 142840, 182 182. Castillo, Jonathan Vincent M.
May 7, 2001