You are on page 1of 14

c

Tuskegee Syphilis Study


i     

     
      
 
   
    
 
  
     
!   
    

"#  # 
$
"% "  &'()
&'*) 
  
 

   
   " 

     
   
+
 
 

   "#
 ,

 

    
   #  
   "         


   
-
 #   
     
      
 
     


 "
     

     
       
+ 
    
  

   

   
    


THE TUSKEGEE TIMELINE


The Study Begins
- &'()"
   
   " # #

    -


"   


  
 
 
          +
 
 


   -
#  
 .   
  
 
 

i $ .
 

 // 0(''#
 ")/&# 
  

      
 # 
 #


   
   
 
!   
 
1   

 
#    
 
 .".

   
        
"   "  "  
  -


"
  
    
  
 

   
  
    -
2   
 
 
 
"
         2 "  
" %
 + 


 
"



# 
 3/  

What Went Wrong?


-4&'*)"%
 


  
 


 
%

 
  

  
  % 
 
  %  %  
   #
 
            
    
 "#" "" 
" 
 

"  

   


     
  2   
 
 #  "
 #   

   
  
 


  - 
"
      
  
 
 , 

    




   #         ,

 

 
    5  #      
          
&'3*"      
   


 + 
        

  #

 + 
 #      

   ,



"  # 
 #"   
 
 

  # 
  

The Study Ends and Reparation Begins
      


    
 # .
 +
  .66

#     #   #     #

 
 
    

+ 
 -7
 &'*)"
  



 % 

"

%

  
   
   
  %   
   
   

 

-
  &'*("6
#
#     





     - &'*3"  8&/  
6 6
 

 
 #     % 
  



 
"
    
  
 
    

  
   

        
 9  
   :9; #

 
 
    -&'*"# "## #   


   - &''"
   # 2 
   
  #   
  
     
  <   
    
 #    
 

 "#  
 

i
 
 -=>%-<"= 

"<"
 9   
    
 
 

    4 )//3 ?   
 ##

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

  9  
 4)//' ?   &  
    
  


‘ 9  @ 


%



52
"
          


 
 

"41 #:  
  "1  ; 
‘   
 2  
#  
1 #A   
   " 
 "
  "
 
‘‘9  @ 
 1 
$

 # 
‘ 
      
    
  + 
 

   

        + 
  
    (  
   
  
 
‘%  
 

   

 #
    
   
   
 (/   

 

  , 

  
 
2"
  
 
‘.@

 .66      
‘‘1 #A


   
+ 
 =    
 # 

 
 

   
 #  
 

 
‘A#6 
 

 ('' #
 )/&#

  #      
  


#   
 
 $
 


 .  -




    
 
.
   :< < i 1   

; 
‘A
  
 
 
 
 
  
‘$+    

    

 #     
 
 B   


#




 
  < #  
 #
 
 

‘5 
  
     


 

   
 

 

‘  

 

      
‘  
 .1 

 
.

 
  
 

 
"
    
‘9 &'3*"&)* 
 
 


 


 
‘   

 

92

 
‘<     
 
 !
:%$%i$% 
 



 
; 
‘ A
 #
  
  
‘ 
  
‘    6
#
     



 
‘ % 8&/  
6 6
 

 
     
     
   
   
     
 
  


     
9  
 :9;# 
 
 
    
‘ @ "## #   

 
‘   # 2 
  
#    
 
‘7$&
  

    
i
 
‘  
C9
# 
  
 < &/  
  


 #
    
i
 
  9

1    
 
  
   
   

  

 4& 
    
     9
 
 
  
##  9  
 4)* 

c

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

THE EXPERIMENT

å  å

  
 


  
 

  
   
!


"#
     
"#
  $
%&c
c
THE DISEASE

        2


 -
     

   -

  #6  
  
"         
 

   :   ;
 
 
 "" 
"

 
 "

 "" 
< 2

  
     

 

  

 !  " 
" 
 

7 

#  
 "
 
 
 
 
: 
  
 (/

 D #

  # 
 
  &)   
  
 




; 

 

  
"#   

   

 #   


 
 

  

  
  :   ;
 ##      
  

 
 

 "# 

  
    <
 
 "

#

  
  


    
            
 
#


 



    


#
2# 

     6  
  #
  "  "  
  
"  "+
"#
  
 
     
   




  
  
 

# 
  
"#  
#  




:  "
@  

;   

 . 
6 
.

    
 
 ## 
   

 
         
 


 
 
  #  "
)E 
 
 
" 
 #  



   

% 
 

 " 



"  
   666 
 



 
" 


 
F  
   #

  
 
    
    


  

   
   


   
# - 
 
 
"
  
6

 "     "" 
" "
 

THE HEALTH PROGRAM

    "



  
  !   
"
 


 
  
 
 #  
#
   
 &'// -&'/"F   

  


 


   -&'/*"
@  

#   "  
 
     
"
F   

5   
   

 
  
#
 "
# 

+ 
 


   
 

 
  

# 
 ,   
 
 


-&'/G"  
 
< =   <  
 


 
  @
 "33


  
       
   

"  
 

 
  
  <
 
  &') ) 
 
 






   
  
 
  
#.3 /  &"///
"

 # 
 3 &"///"

 
i  * ) &"/// .

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

-&')'"<    "


 F   
 


 
  :;" 
41 #
A  




      

 1 #A# 




    

#    % 6%   A 
 
  

  
% 6%  

7  
A! +#
  


   #     
 

 

  "
  
A 
 
# #

 
 $
"% "#
  
     6
 

 A &'(/    -


  

  -



4 % % #$ 
#  
  
  
 % 6% 
  H.  

# 
 
 "# 
 "
  
 
     
 


   2
 

 
 

 
 #   




 
  .

-&'(/"$
 )*"///  
"G)  
 #  #  % 6% " 
 
 
#

 " "

  #



"  # .   
  
 


 . 
 
   
  


   . . 
 
  
   
  


 #   



 #
  

  

$

 
  #

(  
 
% 6% 
 
     
 
1 #A#  



 
 ".  

  


  #  

 

i  

  
  .
    
A
  -




 

#
  



   
%    


   
#  
 
.  
 

.
  2 
.   
  
   

 .#  "
  
  
A

  #
 
   
  $
 # 
   
   2
 
#"

1 #A




 #+ 


9# 
    
1 #A 


 

"
  


#

@  

 9
# 
#    #
 2
 

"    
 


#   

THE EXPERIMENT

%
   

 
 1 #A 
 
  &'()" 

  

+ 
# 
 "
   #
  

  
  
 
 
i $ 
  #
 


 

 

 
   2  
 
 


  
  
 
% 6%    

  #      


 7   
7"i#"


 
 

 
# 
     %    
   
  
   
 
 
 
 
 
  #  ", 
   

    %   
 
 

  -
 
 

% 
   
,   :  2  "  66   
  ;"
 
 %        
  
  :B
"

 





 

         
 &'/# 
# 




 % #

  

#    
 

    ;

- 
"< 4  5 $  
=   <   
4   
  $  

# 

". 
i    
 
  
     
# 
. 
 





#     

     $  "#  
7
#
 
 :

 ;"
$
# 

 
 
" #
  
  
 
 

-
# 
 


 
&"3//
 
$
 



 

 
1 #A"
  
   
    
  

       


   
  
 
  
 
     
 


 
-


 ## 6 , 

  
:
4 % % #$ 


  -


;

    
   

7 
 2
 
&'()" 
#   
% 

9  
"
$
 

< 

"
  -


#  "< 4 i 9 "


 
  "     

 
2     5   
   #  
 
 
 %
 
#
 
66
 6


#
 
66
# 
6 
 < 9  

    

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

< 1 =  #   


  #

 7
 &'() < =    #% 
 
#

 # 
 

# 

  

#    


 9   
       2 
66 
      
     
 ) #   
  @  6
 #  
 
 
 ..   
 
       
  



 "   

i  

   

  9
 
 
#
  


%< =   


    # 
 
"  

  "< "


#
 
  
&/   . 
 
 
    
  
 
 
  .
< 
  # 

4 &'((< =  # 

 
 
< =   <  
 
 

  
  


 
 2
   

#

  

 #  
# 
  
 < =   
   
  &'((#


!
"#  #
 

 #
 ! 

 

       
 
   

   



  
 
"

 
  
#

   
 

   

i 

 


:
      # #   

+ 
;#     

!
 
+ 
     #


#    
 

 ..    9
  
&'(  
$$ A 

  
% 6%  "5 1 "
 
 
 
 : 
 
# 

 ;"#    

+ 
  

+ 


 




 
!   
:


 

  ;# 




  
% 6% $
  

 
 2 
 

   
 

# 

   
 &'3/ 

 

  
 

 
#
 
 
  

  
   < =  &'((

    
2 

         
  
 $
  #

 

  % 
 
%
   
 
 
 
"
 , 
 2   


  



   < =     



## 

  

% 6%   


  5   
% 
 
=   <  <" 
 

  



"   

I 

 
 
 
  
#
% 6%   
 

 
, 


  
#

     
  
 

 #

   





 
 

" 
    

        

 


      
:

 

  ;

&'(/ &'3/    


 

    #
 
 

   
 % "   
 
 #
!
  9

      

 

  "

 

     
 
  "#   
, 
  
 



  #  

    

   2 
"


 

    "     

 
 
 
 ##  
7
H. 
#-#
H


#  

i "+
 
#  


# 
 " "   . 
   
 &'"


 


2  
   

9&'3("# 
< =   <   
 
 

 

# #
 "
 

  
#  
  
 
  #   #  2  
+ 
#    


 


  




       




  .

#  

+ 


 

 #

   
  


  
 
 


 
 .     



     

 

i   "
 
     2  

   

 i 


 
 @@-- %"

   
 

-&'&"<  F+


"

 
 
 
7
"+ 
  
  #
 2  
 
   

   #
 i , 
 
  
 
: #



 

;
 -&')"

 
 

 "#  
  "   
6
 



   

  -
   

    
 
  

 




    #  
 #  
 
  
  : 
 % 2%; 

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

-4 &'"< -#4  


  
 
  
+ 



   
  

 

 + 
  
 
 

 -i  &'
92
"     

 #  

" 2     


  
 
, 


#



# 

-A  &''"


 

  

  
  

#  
 "  #   
 
 -
"  
#   %   
%



  
  !#     2  

: 
 A &'; 
%
 "

     3&) #
 )/3
 -&''" 

+ 
(
#  #
  %

 (*( 
#  #
     
#  

     
   '
G"  
 &/)  
  

#




#
  
 
  


 
   #
 
  
 

 
 


  

     
   
 5 
$
$ 

"#    
% 6%  " 


 5 # 
 + 
"

-

&'/" "< 4 B"

  


  
#.  .  

 
 

 


 


 
 2  





  
 
  #
    
 #

   


92
"#  

 # "
 


6  


  
"



%
  4   "
 
 


" 2
    

   2  
@ 

 #  "
   #
      
  #   #  

   

 4)"&'*)  
 

  

APPENDIX A

  # 
 

    

 
  
 

Table ‘ ‘ viability data of Tuskegee group

____ DEAD____ ____ALIVE____ ____UNKNOWN____


  E   E   E
 
 )3) ' G )& G )&

 *G 3  (3 (' )/

 H1# "
 :&'3;

Table  Abnormal findings in  syphilitics and  controls

Abnormality ___Syphylitics____ ____Controls____


  E   E

5 
  3& 3 )& ()
 J6 (* 3) )) (3
   
 &) &(  G
 
   K'/ (G 3( )' 3
   )3 )* )/ (&
  )G ( )& ((

 H1# "
 :&'3;

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

Table  Aortic arch and myocardial abnormalities at autopsy

____Aortic arch____ ____Myocardial____


  E   E
 
:&3/; ) 33 3G (3

:3; G & )/ (*
J)L/ // J)K/ )
  



 H# 
 :&'*(;


H>>   > >+ 


> >


Blowing the Whistle




 
  
@ 

4)"&'*)"
 
The PHS did not accept the media's
4    
%
    #
92
"  
comparison of Tuskegee with the
     
 #   
 ## 
 #  

experiments performed by Nazi doctors
   " #  "    

" 
   
 on Jewish victims during World War II
M
NM#  # 
 

"N% 
Yet the PHS offered the same defense


 
  #     M 


offered at the Nuremberg trials Ƌ they
  

    N
were just carrying out orders 

 
  
"
  
  
 2  
" 
 

  
 #
 
  

 

   A F"# #     1$
B
I"  




 8&/ 
6 6


 
 
 
    F" #  " # 
# 


 


"
  # 
 # 
# 
    2



O



      
  

 
 

 !    #

 2  
   i


4 # 
 @@-- D



 
 "
  
  

    

i  
H
 
#  +

 "  
#  

 " 2 
    
 

 
!
+
 
O 
 
   O ,  
 
     



 
   
     
  
  

" #   ,
"

 



  
 M
 
  N

The Legacy of Tuskegee

-&''/"  

&/  
 % %    


    
 
%-<


2
 
"
)/  

 





 
 
 % 


 "
 
 
   2  
 
    , 
  

@   
  
"
#

 F   
 


"  
# 


 
   
    
  6   2  
P-
 
 
    
 
"% % !#   

 
  
# 

   
  

 

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

PRESIDENTIAL APOLOGY
THE WHITE HOUSE 
7   
  

A- 
1   $&"&''*

15$%1I9D515-<5i-i%7B7FDA71 <D<7i5-i I5F55

 5
1 )H) $ 5<

515-<5iHB  
 ""$  ##  
 '


 :% ;-# 
  

#    


   H$     :% ;$ 
# 
:% ;$ A   :% ;$  +

  
 
 "   !
&&/ "-

!
    

 
  
# :B
 ;-!   %$ A  $"
" 
:% ;

-# 

      

 #    66 < 
   
 
"F# 2  "F#  :% ;
5 
 "# #
   "   
 
"i

   ""    :% ;%F  I    

" 
 $  "  :% ;

-#  
   " 
  "
 
 
#
 


     @ 

 
  !  #  
     
 -
< <
    
 -

 # @
  "  
 "
 
  9 < 
 "
  

#    " 
  " 

"   

#    " 

  " 

 % 
      "A F"
  



 
   

  
 #   
 

   

 
 

 
% # 

  "
#  
 
-
#
 # 
  
 

 "
# 
 


#
  


  
   -

  


  


#     
"

  




# 


  


 
 %#

  
"# 
   # 
 # 


%    
        #


#   
@   


     $ # #  % % "#

  #
 #

 "
   

    # 
#        
 


 
   #  
  

$     


 # #   "
    #  "
#     "

#   

  
7  
 




 

 

#  
   
A
 "    
 "#

#   "#

 
$
"% "


   "
   

 "
 % %  
 

  


  



##66 " " # -
#
 

 




 ,
 
  


"

#     "
  
  "-# 
#Hi# 5

 
 
"
  "
  

 
 @ 
# 
  
9
#  
  @ 

 # @ 

      

%   "# 

 


  
#  "-  :% ;

 %    66 


" 
   
D
#"
#   #  -
 - 


    :% ;

$
"
  "


#    #
#

  

 "  "
#  % % 
 "- 

    
 


 
 

   # 
   -

  


 # 
#  


# 

# 


  
     
 
  
 
$
"% "

# 
#  #
#   # 

 
    
" 
  %
  
 #
   #

 

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

   


       "#

 
  
 @ 
 
 % # #    
 
 

%  %
 

"# 
 
#

 


 

 

@    
   
   
 @  

  
  

    
  
"

   #   #

 
  

-# 
   

    
  A
"# # 



 

  :% ;    9  @ 
"
 
 #  

F  @ 

  
#  
 
# 6  % % % " 


 
< 

  
   ##

   
  
 

    
   
#      


 

 
 

 


 

 "#  

   
 


#    



 

  
  
#

  


"  #        

# 
"   
       
  # 
  6   
   


") 
"  
   

 % % 

% %   # 
     


    
 
 
 
 
  "% 
%  
"-!  

 
  
   "< "
  
&G/

##  
  
 "   
 
 "    
 D 
66  % 
 
      #

 
 @   

  ##  


  

%  :% ;

 "#  


 
   !

 @  

#  
 



 
   ,    9
   
  




#
   
 #"
 


  

  -  
 
 
#

  #
   

  
 
       #     #
    
    
 "+
    
" 
 #

 
   
   
 

A
"
    
 
    "#  




# 



   % % 
 
 # 
  # 
  
  &''G
 
 
  

  

%" " 2 
  - 
 2

 
 
i
9
% 
7
  
&'''    
   @  
  



" 
 #   2 

 
   

 
 #
 

 


 + 
     

@      


   
    #

      

 "    
     9
#

   #  
#  
 

#  
# !
     i " "  
 #    
  
  

   # 


    


   
 

  
  


  
     
# 
 




"# 
 9
  
# " 66$  #"

#    "
    #  #

  66  
# 
  D      #

    




  
 D  
#

# 
  -  

 #  % #
    


 "F  :% ;


c

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

RESEARCH IMPLICATIONS
How Tuskegee Changed Research Practices
%

  
"
  
  
   
 
  
  
 
 
     

-&'*3"
i
1   %
# 
#" 

i
  


  + 
 
9 9 1     
       
 
#
  
 
 #   #  
- 


  !  
" 
#   &'*3

 ,    

 
  
 
   


    
< 

  
"5
"@   :<5@;  
 , 

<5@6

   + 
   # -


1  #9"#   


  #




 

          + 


           #      
   
 #   
   
A  &'G/6&'G("
  
!   
 
   5
    $    9   9 
1    
         + 

  ## 
  #    #  %5

% 9 #   
 
 &'*/
   #
           - &''&"    

 
  :&

;

A   


  + 
 
5 

 

  


    

 -7
 &''"  
9
 

i
9
%    
< 

  
      !

#
   #  
  
"  "    
            
 

    

 -
#  
  
!9
"#  # 
 )//& 
c

MORAL ISSUES ABOUT TUSKEGEE SYPHILIS STUDY


Respect for Persons
  




   + 
  
 

  
"


 #
  
 :   
  



;  

 


 
Beneficence
1     + 
 

  "#   2    
  
   "


 


 
Justice
%


 
 

 ,
 

#
  
   
     
  + 
 -
"
 

        
  ,
  

  
  
  
# 

 9  
 
  
   
  
   + 
C   

   

 
 


   

  
" 
 " 


   


"#    
  #  
# 

Issues

 
, 
 
  
 

% 2
 , 
 
  
#


+ 

    
 

  

  "
 
   
 @
  + 



  
 
   
P

„c    
 #  
  66 

#    
   66


  


#  
#  

 %     + 
   "   

i   

9  
1 

 , 
    
@ 
#  


   

  

  
P-     
  
   
+ 
"#
  , 


#


#
P
„c -# 
  #  
  

  
  

P% 

, 

 2 # 
2 
   

  + #


   

  

 


 " 
"#

  
+ 



 



 :  
 
 
   

  
   
$
  # 
  2  
 
i<

 
  
 
  


   

i   F  
 1  ;
„c 5 1 "
% 6%  #  
   
  




 
 +
   
 
+ 

  
 








 

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c


 
  

 #  
6  ""$
  
# 
   - 
    "
#   

 #
 


  
 
 
„c 7" #

 
 
 
 
    
   

 
 "
 
  P
„c  
 


    
#     
 
 



#


9  
 
"#  
    2  

  + 
        
 
 
"     + 
    "
 







 
   -
 
 

 
      + 
# 
  

 

 P
„c  9  
1 
 
 
 
 
   + 
   "  
  "
    +
 "   


 
 -# 
# 
  
 

  
   
 
 
„c - 2  
 
"
  


   
 
+ 
 
 
2  
   < 
 


 
   + 

2  
P


UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS


Ô c

 
c   c cc cc
c cc
c
c

c  c c
c c cc
c
c cc
 
 c c  c  c
c
ccc c

 
c 
c
c c c
c  c
c  cc

 c
 c c
c 
cc   c c
c

cc
c c
c cc c
c c 
c c  c c  c
cc
c  c c
c
c
c
c
c 
c
cc c

 c cc  c c

 
cc c 
cc
c c c cc c c
c   c
c
c
c  c c  c

 c
c
c    c

c
c  c  cc  ccc c c
c

 
cc c 
c c  cc c c c 
  cc
  c

 
cc  c cc c!
  c
ccc"
 c 
 c c
cc

c
c  cccc
c
 c cc
c c
ccc
c  c cc
c c
c
c c c  c 
c   c
c c


 c ccc
 c  c

 
c c#
 c
cc  c c
cc $ 
 ccc c!
  cc   c c
c
  c c
c   
 c c
c  c
c

c   c

 
c
c  c 
c c c  c
c   c c cc 
 c 
 c ccc 
%
 c c cc

i  

i
 
  i
 
 i   i  c
c
c  c


c c
c c
c  c
c
c
  c ccc
c c
c
c c 
c c cc c
& 

 c  
ccc 
c  cc
c
c
 c c  c   c c c  c
c   c
cc
   c
  c
 
c
c 
 
c c   c c
c
c c   c
c   
 c c
 c
c  c c c#
 c  c
c
 cc  c c   c c c    'c

! "# c 


c  c
c  c  c
c 
c c c c c   c  $ $  c c  c
c
c
c  '(c
c  c c 
c
c  c
 c c  '
  c
c  c
c 
 c c
  cc
c  c c
   ' !%# r  
 

  
 

 
!$#   c cc c
cc  c
c   c
c  c c  c & 

 c  c    c c
c c ! &# ! c c 
c c c c 
 c c  +c
 c
c
c   c )c 

c  c  
c c 
 c
c c 
c 
c 
c c  c c
c  c
 c  c 
 
c c 
c c   c  c c   '
 c 
 'c *   c  c    c 
c c 
c c
c
 c cc  
c    
c c  
 
c 
 c
cc  c c  c c c
c c  c c ! '# ! c c 
c c  c  c   c c  c c

c c
c 
c c 'cc
ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

!(#   c


cc c c   c  c ! "*#   c 
c c c  c   c c  c

c
c c cc
'   c
c  +c  c c   c   c  c

c c  c cc
c  c c
 c cc
! )# u     
    

 c c  c
c c  c c  
c  c 
 c


   

  


 u   c  c c c c 
c 
 c  c
c
 


  

   
     
    
 '
 
 
   
    
  



   
 !"+#  c
cc c c  c c  c
c
)   +c  c c   c   c  c  c   c
!*# r   
 


  c    c
c  c c  c
c 
c

 

 
 
    
  
 
  
 c
c 
c  c
c 
c
c 
 c c

  
 
 



    '

! +# ! c c 


c c  c  c

c
 c ! $,# ,-.c   c 
c c c  c   c c
 c c)' 
c
c
c

 ' ,/.c ! c c 
c c
c c c c
c

 'c
! ",#   c  c c cc 
c c
c
 c
c
 c 
c c
c c
c 

c  
c c ! $"# ,-.c   c 
c c c  c 
c 
c c c
c  
 c c  c  c
c 
  c
c c
c   c c  c  c  c c  c c  c

c 
c

 c'   
 ' ,/.c   c 
c c c c 
c
 c
 c  c   c c  c  ' ,0.c (c c c c  c

c c c 
 c c c
 c c   +c  c c
! ""#,-.c   c 
c c
c 
c  c 
c 
c c )  c c    c
c c    c  c
c c  c c   c  c c  c c 
ccc
c
c
c 
c
c 
cccc

c c
cc
c c 
c
c  cc 
c 
c
cc  c c cc
c c c   '


 c  
c  c  c  ' ,/.c ! c c 
c c
c c c
c 
c  c c
c c
c
c c
  c  c c  c  c
c 
c  c  c !$$#   c
c
c c c c
cc c

 
c c  
 
c 
c
c c c c c 
c  c 
c   c
c  c c  c 
%
 c  c
'c! c 
c
c
 c
cc  c
cc 
 
c  c
c  
 
c $ 
 c
c c
c 
c 
c

c
c c c c 
c  c 
c

 c c c 
%
 c
c    c c 
c
' #
c c c    c 
c
c 
c  c
 
c c cc
cc c c c c
 
'
! "$# ! c c 
c c  c  c

c
   c c  c  
c 
c  c c
   c  c  c

 c  c  c    c
c !$%#,-.c  c
cc c c c c c   c

 'c   c 
c c c  c c    c c c c c c c
c
 
c   c c c
c

c

 c  c   c c

 '  c    c

 c  ' ,/.c   c  c

c 
 c
cc c c
c
c c
c '
,0.c  c c  c
cc c c c
c
 
c
! "%# ,-.c   c 
c c c  c   c c 
 c   c  c  c
c  c 
c
c
 c
c   c c c   c c 
c 
' )  c  c c 
c c
c c c
,/.c  c
cc c c
c
c  c c c  
cc  c
 c c 
c   ',1.c  c
c
c c  c c c  ' 
c c c  c  c
c  c  c 
c   c  c c
   c c c   '
!"&# ,-.c  c 
cc c c c
c  c  c
c  c   c
c  c    ' ,/.c ( c c ! $&#   c 
c c c  c  c
c   c

c  c c  c c c
c c     c c  c 

c
 c c c  c
c   c

 c c $ 


c  c c c
 c 
c cc  
 cc
'
   c
c   c cc c!
  '
!$'# ,-.cr  
 


  
!"'#,-.c  c
cc c c
c
 
',/.c! c 

 
         
c 
cc

c c c c
 
c cc         
          
c c c 
c c
 
'        
 

 
 

 
 
   
  
! "(#,-.c c
c  c c c
c  c
c    
       
    

 cc c
c
 
c c  c
cc c c 
  ,/.c   c
c  c
cc c  
c

c
c c c
c
'c(c
cc c
c  c
c
c
 
 'c c  c  c  c c c c c

c  c 

c  c 

c
c
c  c   ' ,/.c  c 
c cc
c 
c   '


c 
c c  c  c c c c  c
c c
 c c c c    ' ,0.c (c 
c  c c ! $(# ,-.c   c 
c c c  c 
 'c


c
c

c cc c c
c cc 
 c 
c c  c
c 
c c c 
c
c
 c   cc c
cc#
' 

c 
 'c 
c 
 c 
c c
 'c ( 
c
c    
c 
 c 
c c
!")# ,-.c  c
cc c c c  c
 c 
c 
c


c
c  c 
 c 
c c

c c
c c

 c c  ' ,/.c ! c c 
c c 
c
 c  c
c cc 
 c c ' ,/.c
 c


c c c c  ' 
c c   c  c c c  c c c 
c

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

 
c
c  c c  c c   c  c 
c ! $+# ,-.c   c 
c  c  c c c c
 c
c 

c    'c 2c 
c   c  c
 cc c
cc  c c  c 
c
 
c  
 c
c   c
 c
c 
  c  c  ' ,/.c 2c c )  c c  c  c
c    c


c c   c   c
c 
c   c c
 c c   c 
c c  c c  c  c 
  c
c
c
c c!
  c cc

 c c
',0.cÔ
 c  c c 
c c  c c   c c   c c

c
c   c c  c  c c c c 
 c 
c 
c   c
c   c cc  c
c   c c  c
cc c c  '
c ccc c   c c
c c  c

c c 
c 
c c
c 
 c ' ,0.c ( c
!$)# ,-.c  c
cc c c c
 
cc  c
c   c
cc c
cc)  c 
c c
c 
c c c c c  c  c c
 c
c  c c   c
c   c cc c!
  '

c c  c

 c
c  c  ' ,/.c
  c 
c c c  c c    c c c 
c
c !%,#! cc c& 

 c
cc  c
c

 
c    c  c  c
c  c 
c c c c
c#
c  c c c
c c  c 
c

  c   c c cc cc


 ' c
c
c c c  c
c
c
c
cc    c
c
c cc  c
c   c c c '
!$*#   c cc c
c 
c
c 
 
c
 c c  c c  c
c    c c  c c  c cc
& 

 c
ccc 
%'

 

Analysis

%
 ("*" G Q)#   


 %
 (



5   


 " 
 
 
 #  


 

  # 
   
  



 
-


 C 

  
       %
 *



%  ,  
#  

 
#

 

 ,

 
# %  

 
 ,


 


 
< 




  
   
   #   
 # 

 #  


    
 
+ 

 
 
 ,
 




  

"%
 G



    


 
  
 



 



  
 
 
   
 


   #    
  
  


  

  
  #  

   

  

 
#

+ 
 #   #  


 
  %
  )  

  

 5   
 

  
     ,
 
 
  # 6   
       " "
"       "


 


  
     
"  " 
" ## "     
         
    

  9 

 
    "
 
     ,
  
 #   

     





 

LEGAL ISSUES
& c      






 


R
) c    
 #


    

 


( c   
    
  






  "


#  




"


 

#    
3 c   
   



   


#    
 
 # 
   

"#  
"
#  
   
 
 
 c   
    




C#

 

 
 

 
 c  
# 

 

% % 

# 
#    






R
* c   #    
 

 

%#
#  
  
   


 %class actionrepresentative action  
 #
#       
  

>#    
  
 



 
#
 
 
     
 
 # 




#   
  2 
 

   #
#    "
#    
 +
 

 # 



 

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c
c

URISPRUDENTIAL DOCTRINES
‘  O  Pater familia
: 
   ;
M#  
  
 
    #   N 
 
  


    

     

  
    :
  ;
     :; 

u u
      
 
 
  

   "
 

 #
 
 

"

 

#    

  





# 
 
 
   
#
       


   

  

+ 
 #  "
  
   #    
 
  
 


+ 
"
 
   

  
 + 
#   
  
 


#


"
 
 



 


  
  
 +
 


   + 
 

  Doctrine of negligent conduct
 

 "
     + 


 
 
   
    6
     
 !

 
 
9   



u u
 
     
 
  
+ 


  
    

 

    "
   





     
 




    
    + 


   + 
  
  -
 
 

# 
 #



#   

"# 
   
 #  
c
c

ccT u s k e g e e S y p h i l i s S t u d y : c  c       
c
 c
c c c c  c
c