PRIVATE SCHOOLS FEE DETERMINATION COMMITTEE Dated: 23.09.2013 Coram: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE S.R. SINGHARAVELU, CHAIRMAN MR.S.VEDARATHINAM, MEMBER SECRETARY and DR.V.C. RAMESWARA MURUGAN, MEMBER DR.R.ELANGOVAN, MEMBER Hr, Sec. School, (30175 ) 90, Kannaigaipair Usha Garden, Thiruvallur - 601 102. won School Represented by : Mrs, Hemelatha Authorised Representative Enquiry was taker on service of notice to the authorities concernec, who on appearance before m2 were heard and the records produced were perused and upon consideration of bath ora! representation and documentary Jevidence and on hearing them in parson upon giving wider opportunity this committee makes the following COPY OF THE ORDER 1 The Committee, based cn the additional particulars furnished by the School in the new Questionnaire, is to determine the fee to be collected by the School, by taking into consideration of the factors provided under section 6(1) of the Temll Nadu Schools (Regulation of Collection of Fee) Aci, 2009, wnich herein after ferred as Act 22/2009.2 a Mrs. Hématath; Authorised Representative of the school | appeared in person 3, By information provided by the school end as mentioned ses LG to XE std above the total strength of the schoo! is 453 from ch The details are as follows: ey Student's strength TKG & UKG 60 TV 199 Vi = Vii 115 X= | 60 XI- xT 19 Total | 453. 4, The recognition of the school had expired on 31.05.19. Tis | submitted, they have prayed for renewal of recognition, and that the same is | pending In the office of the DMS/DEE/DSE. It is in anticipation of renewal of recognition, the prospective chance of which is more, we are proceeding further in this matter, we are only indic ing the fees or chance of approval of the to be made herein will be existing fee as the case may be, and the ord n, cence. subject to t! It of renewal of recoani 5, This revised fee shall be collected only if recognition gets continued from the Competent Authority within the above mentioned period of three academic years; otherwise they may have to collect the earlier fee fixed and upon renewal of recognition, they can adjust with the revised fee structure and make godc the same.6. AS pointed out in para 71 of juégment dated 3.5.2012, or showing the relevant documents for pencency of process of Renewsi of Recognition, we may indicate the fee structure, for which such school may not be entitled to get communicated until recognition is pending; but the same shall be communicated to the Directorate for keeping a vigil over collection of excess fee, even while process of Recognition is pending. The concept is that had there been a renewal of recognition which may perhaps be from the date of expiry of earlier recognition this revised fee indicated would date back to the expiry of original recognition which, to repeat may necessarily fall on the date of renewal of recognition. 7(i) Strenath of i ith regulation): ed by the Government in respect of teacher students ratio As per the norms which is found in the Tamilnadu Code of regulation, it is 1:30 for Elementary chool, 1:35 for Middle school, 1:40 for remaining classes of higher standards between IX and XII. This system of ratio was approved in para 90 of the judgement dated 3.5.2012 of the Honourable Divison Bench of High Court, Madras.(which hereinafter will be referred as jdgt, dt.3.5.2012) Besides that ltnere are some more benefits in favour of added strength of teaching staff found in G.O.Ms.No.525 dated 29.12.97 by applying where the following norms are considered. (i!) For classes LKG to V Standard, the ratio of 1:30 alone will be applied for calculating the strength of teaching staff along with one Headmaster.4 (iii) For Classes VI to VIIT standard, teacher pupil ratio of 1:35 would be followed with one Tamil Pandit each for 5 Sections. In fact no single stancarc of class can have more than 5 sections.(The inspector or authority may have (iv) For Classes IX to XII as per G.0,Ms.No.525 dated 29.12.97, teacher pupil power to allow the Sth section and not above that) ratio of 1:40 (or) Student strength divided by 28(hours) whichever is: highkr would indicate the Teacher strength and with one Tamil or language Pandit each for 5 sections. | This may as well apply to the minority schools because of the following observation in the last two lines of para 139 of jdgt.dt.3.5.2012. “Any such restriction regarding strength of teaching and non-teaching staff in minority schools is subject only to Government Orders.” 8. Strength of Teaching staff for Co-curricular activities(with regulation) The strength of teaching staff for co-curricular activities also will be cecided as per norms provided in para 5 (supra) and subject to those found in the syllabi | mentioned in the code of regulation and matters found in such other guidelines Issued by the Government, This is ofcourse, relaxable when the interest of the parents/wards is found so high as to necessitate such of the subjects, where | there Is admission of considerable strength of students. However expense on this subject will be allowed commensurate with the facilities offered. Sundry expenses could be enhanced if there are exemplary subject ot co-cunficular activities as mentioned in para 112 of the jdat. dt.3.5.20129. Non-Teaching Staff and Its strength: At the end of para 97 of the jugt. dt.3.5.2012 it Is observed as follows:~ ‘The number of non-teaching staff to be employed is fixed in accordance with the Government Order. The Writ Petitioners cannot have any valid objection regarding strength of non-teaching staff, which is to be correlated with that of the total students’ In Para 95 of the jdat, dt.3.5.2012, it wes mentioned that the committee had chosen to fix the ratio of non teaching staff as well as ayahs and acceptance for the same was given by the Hon‘ble High Court. So we may heve to follow our tabular column which fixes the ratio of non teaching staff in relation to number of students. The security and sanitary staff will be included in non-teaching staff 20, (a) Payment of salary for Teaching Staff (except co- curricular)(vide para 99: also vide the last three lines in para 133 and the last two lines in para 139 (for minority schools) of the Jdgt. dt.3.5.2012): ( Salary and allowances (BasictGrade Pay+DA+HRA+CCA + Med.allow) Eamed Leave, yearly increment, arrears based on shifts in slabs (ii)EPF Contribution& EDLI (i) ESE (iv)Pension (v)Gratuity (subject to a maximum pay as recommended in VI Pay Commission. Payment shall be by ECS method) 10.(b).Salary for Teaching staff of Co-curricular activities, for a realistic Salary, commensurate with the periods of time devoted, strength of students, actuality of the Salary paid in ECS, the nature of Full time (or) Part time, and the qualification and experience may all be considered.10(c). Salary for Non-teaching Staff: At the end of Para 97 of jdgt. dt.3,5,.2012, it was observed that the salary payable to non-teaching staff can be considered, subject to proof as per the statutory norms of appointment and that It was further observed thal in such restriction regarding strength of teaching and non-teaching staff (also in minority schools) is subject only to Government orders.(vide para 139 of the jdgt dt.3.5.2012) A balancing approach both in favour of parents (vide para 114) and also in favour o schools ( vide para 115) was observed(the expense on selary for Security and Sanitary staff were included in non-teaching staff salary) 11. Expense on Administration / Miscellaneous: At the end of para 101 of idat, dated 3.5.2012 reasonable level of expense on this head so as not to burden the fee structure was directed to be civen. So wt may consider the following:~ a) Taxes : Taxes for water, Buiding, Property,Professional etc... claimed legally with proof b) Water : for School only. | ©) Electricity charges : | (Payment for electricity bil! and fuel for generator will be considered excepting conereestofenetettcolneratt sacar Electricity Charges: No.of rooms X Rs.6.50/- per unit X 3 units on ordinary rooms per day X 220 working days Electricity Charges: No. of A.C. machines X No.of tons X on A/C rooms Rs.6.50 per unit X 4 units per day X 220 working days (Rs.6.50/- per unit was fixed on verification with TNEB) Fuel for generator: 25% on total electricity charges till such ’ time supply of energy is improved.@)_Printing and Stationery: Printing of Cash book, ledgers, fee receipts, school magazines, prospectus, application form, report cards, circulars and purchase of office stationery items etc. will be considered. @) Postage and Telephone, Internet and SMS services: -will be considered (excluding for hostel) f) Examination Expenses: Printing of question papers, answer scripts, handwork material for students, projects will be considered. g) Books & Periodicals: Value of new arrival found in catalogue in the concerned yeer with the bill of purchase. Vide value of original stock available In the proceedings fer recognition. h) Laboratory Expenses/Administrative chargas/Au legal fees /Hospitality: rand ‘will be considered to a reasonable level in the interest of the school and also no: to burden the fee structure.The principle is thet necessity will contro! and all oxpenses which are patently needed the above necessity will be discouraged. i Teaching Aid: (Software) i) 4/Sth of value of investment on installation cf software and the utility lservices including contents of the CDs & DVDS and the expenses on the jdemonstrators: per annum will be considered ii) The investment being the duty of the proprietor of the schoo! to instell ynachine just like he makes construction of the building to get opening rermission, and is a capital expense, that the usage of that capital may be for a minimum of 10 years, 1/5th of its value is accredited in annual expenses. li). Excepting software, expense on other teaching aids, if any, will be considered, i). Uniform i) Anaually two sets of uniform: = for students Below Age 10- Rs.750/- | Subject to perusal of above Age 10-Rs.1000/- | register for delivery of goods with acknowicagement ofk) Sports: Far purchase of sports articles of utility subject to proof, Expenses on NCC/NSS/IRC/Scouts with proof except Grant from the Government 1) Educational Tour:~ Expenses of proof except the sum collected from the students. m) Seminar; - Necessary expenses with proof n) Functions: Reasonable expense for Independence Day, Republic Day, ‘Sports Day, Parents Day, Children’s Day, Annual Day and Religious Festival Day. ©) Advertisement Expense: Only for recruitment of teachers may be admitted 9) Recognition Charges: It is tho Privilege of the proprietor of tha school to get recognition; and as it involves the school’s obligation towards the state and not any expense of learning for the students. (vide last line of para 101 of dat. dt. 3.5.2012) Se not admitted, a) Bank/ Interest charges: Subject to proof. 1) Sanitary Articles Purchase of Acid, Phenyl, brooms, bleaching powder, mops and brushes will be considered s) Security Services; (vide Pera 8(c)) t) Vehicle Maintenance: This will be decided in assessing the expenses on transportation ‘Travelling and Conveyance: (Transportation) Expenses on Transport for students from Residence ta School & bac in Diese! or Petrol van(Unlike in other cases this quantification on transport charges is | made in order ta restrict occasions of exploitation regarding which recently son oral remarks were made by the parents side)9 Cost of one litre diesel is Rs.57 which may make the van to run 10kms students within an average radius of 6km from school may travel For morning pick up (two trips a5 To & Fro) Fer evening Return (two trigs as To & Fro) Thus for 4 trips per day, one van may travel 25 KM. For 25 km the diesel required is 2 ¥ litre. (Cost @ Rs.57 per litre is Rs.143 + bil) = Rs.150 per day As one van may contain 15 students + 1 driver ; per student Rs.10/- per day fuel charges. For salary of one driver and one attendant(Rs.12000+6000(one van) Rs.18000 per month, = Rs.600/- per day. This shall be borne by 15 students travelling in a van Therefore each student shall bear Rs.40/- per day as cost of driver salary. Therefure each student shall bear Rs.10/- per day as fuel charges. Therefore each student for one van shall bear Rs.50/- per day, Annually this may come to Rs.50 X 220 = Rs.11000/- in case af Diesel Vehicle or Rs.12320 In case of Petrol Vehicle @ Rs.91 Per litre. N.B1. The school may be permitted initially to extend this transport service to all the students and collect the Fees on this head as aforesaid: and in case if such cudents who are unwilling to avail this service and want refund of Rs.11000/- p.a the same may be odliged by the schoo! 2. In case any student wants transport facilities from a place the distance of which is from the school is more than the average distance which was taken as above (6 k.m.); after all it is only the fuel charges that will be little more, tor which suitable charges of such expenses alone may be collected after getting such approval from the Committee by filing a statement or application in this regard, thet may be treated es an objection and suitable order may be passed according to Law 4) Maintenance of La As mentioned in para 141 - expenses on maintenance of land may be allowed in Proportion to the extent of land owned/possessec by the school excluding taxes paid therefor, since that is allowed in separate category in pare 10(a) supra20 ¥). Campus Maintenance: Salary of sufficient number of gardeners (depending upon extent) |whoge | services may be useful 1g, Laboratory anc 12. Development Fund (Maintenance of Bui Equipment): In this connection the observation of the Honourable High Court in the Modern School case was thet the development charges of 10-15% on the tuition fees may be given for purchase, upgradation and replacement of furniture, fixtures and equipments and the same was observed in para 108 pt jdgt. dated 3.5.2012. 13. Surplus Fund: | As observed in pata 109 a reasonable surplus of 10-15% was held to be permissible (In para 110 it is fixed as follows) Village and Town Panchayats : 10% Municipalities and District Head Quarters : 12% Corporations: 15% Instead of the above unit of percantage, said to be dependent on cation for all schools, there Is an exception for minority schools run by Catholic Diocese to have a total of 25% of surplus irrespective of location and that 25% includes 10% corporate development fund(vide para 149 of jtigt DE.3.5.2012)44. Grai 9 on Infra Structure Fa Depending on location, we are alse allowing increase In fees as per infrastructiiry grading(vide para 111 of the judgementand the seme is applicable for rminor ty schools other than catholic as observed in para 154 of jegt.3.5.2012). What applies to minority schools run by Catholic Diocese was dea't in par The system for measuring the ellowance of facility for infrastructure of ih @ 155(vi) i.e. they would be entitled to the same without dependent uson lacatian schools may be graded in the following manner:- Requirement as per the norms. 'D' : 7 Available more than the requirement" Available more than adequate ‘B’: 9% Avaliable Modern Facilities ‘A’: 10% | As there is workable difficulty in having break up figure upon similar facility depending upon location, we will give for all, the prescribed 7% - 10% Irresnective of location; this system will not cause prejudice to the minority schools run by catholic or any other. There is a separate format available in the file in assessing the grading a infrastructure facilities that will tell the details of process of derivation of th amount, In that format, we have teken into consideration the following Let aspects for grading: |. Teacher Pupil Ratio, 2.Class Room pupil ratio, 3. Qualified teacher atin . 4.Teachers pay rating 5, Per capita availability of playground area 6.Co- curricular activities and Extra curricular activities, 7.Library books §,Gre environment and soshistication, 9.Inclusive education, 10. Transparency in the functioning of the school.2 15. Sundry Expenses; 45 observed in Para 112 a sum of Rs.600/- per student up to Middle School and Rs.750/- per student up to Higher Secondary School per annum Is allowed. Tt was further observed that increase in sundry expense could be given depending on the lecation and availability of extra-curricular activities in she schoo) In this connection we have to see also para 6 (supra). 16 . Depreciation: We cannot accept depreciation value of the building, because we ere of the opinion that depreciation Is a concession found in the Income Tax Act, intended for the benefit of the tex payer. Educational institutions being exempted category under the Income Tax Act, may not be entitled to that concession of depreciation because they were exempted to pay the tay. Although the building may get depreciated, the site value gets appreciated every year making the net asset to grow multifold, For these reasons, we do not allow the same, 27. Rent: The next Important claim which could not be accepted is fegarding the rental value of the bullding of the school/or the lease value of such of the bullding site. So faras the daim of lease for piace where school is Situated or rent for the building taken on rent, this committee took the view, which was also considered by the judgement dated 3.5.2012 in its para 106 and except the observation that the guidelines formulated by the earlier was reasonable, no further direction or mandate was granted, Thus there is no embargo for us to follow our con: tent view on the following grouncs;-B I. In most of the schools the land/building was given as charity to run the school as mentioned in its trust deed by and Under which the school was run for getting recognition dy relying upon the trust deed. Therefore the schools are controlled by che terms of the Trust Deed in which, the buliding or the site was given es charity only and consequently no value of lease of site or rent of building cen be claimed. Tl. Even for getting recognition, the condition precedent is that the proprietor/Trust/Society which run the school shall own the building for the school. This Is also supported in G.O.Ms.No.131 dated 10.8.2006 which itself was based upon the recommendation of the Honourable Justice Thiru K Samaath who was enquiring in to the incident of the accident that occurred on 16.7.2004 at Sri Krishna Aided Primary School, Kumbakonam, Tanjore District in which $4 children succumbed to the sustained burn injuries ILL As per G.0.2(D}/48 dated 21.7.2004 school Education (x2)Dept based upon the recommendation of Dr.S.V. Chitti Babu Committee the school building should be owned / secured/ en rent free basis or taken on long lease of 30 years. Added to that the management shoule produce licence for the use of the school building as a public building under Tamilnadu Public Building Licence Act of 1965 In this view of the matter the overwhelming effect of G.O.Ms.No. 2(D)/48 dated 21.7.2004 school Education (x2)Dept remains intact as follows: ‘oo building should be planned suitably and adequately. They should be owred or secured on a rent free basis or taken on a long lease of atleast thirty years. The management should produce a licence permitting the use of the school duilding as a public building under the Temilnadu Public Building Licence Act of 1965." We will now note that if the above conditions are fulfilled we will adhere to the same4 \ 18. The observation regarding rent fourd in para 106 of the judgement dated 3.5.2012 was made inthe context of dealing with the impugned order of the earlier committee and while dealing with it the guidclines framed by that committee was observed to be reasonable and on expiry of the period of that committee the guidelines framed by such Committee lost its force and new Such, were formulated by us and given herein; and our above view was ] ventilated in our counter filed in W.P. 8489/2012 which was also considered by the Hon'ble High Court as reproduced in para 106 of jdgt. Dt.3.5|2012. Further there is also no mandate contained in para 106 of the judgement.30 Boards working 9 hours per day making 207 working hours attending upon s average of 220 cases. Thus each school being attended for one hur and 15 minutes which goes to the chairman for overseeing taking a few days. 19. One more note before beginning the working sheet is answering che doubts of many schools as to how could the Committee take the expense of previous year (eg. 2012-13)for fixation of fees for succeeding year (for ec. 2013 14). What we do is first to take the proven fact of the expenses of the past year so as to compare the correctness of the proposed fee of the following yeal by assessing, whether the propcsed expenses of the later year is i consonance with the former one. After assessing the reasonable hike o} proposed expenses of the later year, we add that with the proven expenses 0 past year,b 20. Thus the annual expenditure is es follows: (For 453 Students) Expendite incurred per [spans |expanna| Sbenine# | HEAD oF EXPENDITURE school | (Rs) | (Rs.)_| oats yg statement] 2012-14 | 2014-15 for the | year 2012 3013 (Re) | I ‘Recount (PART- 1) A. Salary and Allowances, Teaching Staft 3641] 9408600 [ Non-teaching Staff 7_| 29400 E.P.F. Contribution 9 ° SI o ° ADL: 10% on the sum arrived at Total /\} 1s orartad as one increment @ 3% Jan Basic pay ena Grade pay ana :wo shells of BA usually alven in 1st of . ‘ Tanuary and July of a particular year. | © Bt =) SRR | SEER BSE UF those actuals of DA exceeds. 10% schools are at fiberty 20 fle applicat on for review only in that regere! Total (A) = ween |-aasozne | roe 3702600 | 4072880 | aseoias | 028161 8. Administration And M Eicctrcity Charges 72600 Generator for Tue @ water Charges 20000 { raaes Preserves Za ccephione & Mobile phone 12000 Tnternct and SMS Services 12000 4930 Siting (Printing of Cash book, ledgers Fee-Recaipts, School Magazines, 22650 cirewia stationary tame 22650 Examination Expenses 22680 Teaching Alds 15000 ta and Gavhes 22650 Jaiform [186006 Staif Welfare 30000 |Staft-Insurence ° [Bank anc interest Charces 0 Laboratory Maintenance (The expense on the apeve head is 0 jaiven in Account Part II(a) Professional Fee (Legal & Audit) 6 ry Administrative charges & Quarter (12%) / Corperation (15%) (OR) Minarity Schoal run by Catholic Diocese (25%) including Minority [Corporate Develonment Fund of 10% Hospitality ‘Aavertisement for Recruitment Only [Teachers Q TOTAL (8) aeszio | a2sai0 | azszi0 | 25219 | = ©. Other Miscalianoous Expenses | and Maintenance | [(Selery te the workers & Gardeners ane expenses on material)Garcening 0008 Building Maintenance Cine expense on the above head is | ‘given Fi Account Part 11(a) *Equipment Maintenance | (The expense on the above head is ° javen + Account Part 11(=) Security services ° Sanitation (Salary to the workers end . lexpenses on materials) aoa0n | Hrotat ( ¢) soooa | 60000 | so000 Grand Total A to © 5 | : eand ts 4cs7s10 | 4438070 | 4865356 | ACCOUNT (PART -II) Development Fund: | (10%-15%) for Purchase, upgradation: | replacement of furniture, fixture and 4os7s | 4ase07 sareiy | eau piments virtually emounting te Maintenance , Surplus Funds Location of schoo! (Total Sesensee » 10/12/15%) (Panchayat (Vilage /Town | (10%) / Moneipaiity or Ostet Hea pre A te rey ae 48781 | 445807 | 499530 | 53132Trfrastructure (7-10%) 1 special features as found In our concert, were shown 9% oF 10% on tuition fee; and if no such isshewn, a | 8% | 327025 | 35R646 min rum of 8% Is oranted.4* (See the 18th Page ) | 425070 Stncry Expenses per student (Rs.750/- for High School anc Higher Secondary 750 | 339750 | 339750 | 329750 | 339750 [or Rs.G00/- for Nursery and Primary & Middle Schoo Total (Part 11) 1484337 | 1588010 | 1702050 | 1827494 ACCOUNT (PART-TT SPECIFIC PURPOSES Educational Tour 0 | Seminar S000 [Group Actwities (NCCC/NSSS/ Srouits/JPC/RS: 8 pa Nedical Expenses 5000 aching through Technology (Smart Class or any ether mudern technolagy) sso | Sunction and Celebrations 45309 Rent/Lease L - [Pxtra~ Curncuiar Activities with la he }curriculam, Segoue rat 7 Incentives for Good Result 20000 acions festival Gift 20000 remrant purse a Rooks end Penodcals (Library) 28000 frovat PART 111 aeseoo | aassa0 | aesea0 | s6s800 [Total Expenditure 7 a aspen 6037047 | sixes | 7033206 | 7608605 Stace Strength 453 453 458 453 er etirdent (afer deductin , rE ( a a. | 13329 14375 19526 grant/charity amount fram the [annual expenses if any) 30175) a Sasi) ASI9796Y/ Re18 oe 1, No inspection could so far be taken. 2. No Special features were indicated by the school. 3. In case of special features shown by the school or found under inspection like environment, teacher ratio and other eight points pointed out in ihe report of Joint Director Mr. Karmegam, 9% or 10% might have been granted; (n default of the above, now a minimum 8% is granted [Flat rate without presudice), 21. The Correspondent has submitted the following as the Proposed fee pattern Classes | Proposed fee ae Income LKG 1000 30 as0000 UKG 15000 30 450000 | I 16000 54 864000 | ul 16000 60 360000 | ul iso00 30 540000 | | Iv 18000 25 450000 v 18000 30 540000 | Vi 20000 30 —aam | | VII 20000 55 1100000 VAIL 20000 30 sov000 1% 22000 35 770000 x 22000 25 550000 x 28000 a3 532000 XII o 0 o - TOTAL s40soo0 —| (Rs.84,06 LAKH ) According to the same the total annual income proposed would be Rs, 8,406,000 This is exceeding the lotel expenditure of Rs. 6,514,880 anc therefore it indicates profiteering and so, we may fx the) reasonable fee by taking into consideration of the mean value arrived | 21, (Mean Value : 14375 ) ADLIS/ ASRS ASL97AOI/ Bx19 22. After fixing the average anrual expenditure per student (mean value)it may form @ well defined quide in indicating the annual fee, per student, However it should be distributed In an equitable. manner such that some | more amount will be added to higher standerés and in order to make good the game such edge has to be lessened In the fee for the lower classes. Sy such system of working, the annual fee fixed for inclusive of smart class forthe year2013-14 is as follows. Fae Siss* (Rs.) TE BURG 12000 vv T5000 aX | 17900 | x1 & XIT 19000 AS per the above fee structure the proposed income would be Rs.6512500 as against the tetel expenses of Rs. 6511880 | thus the fee structure gets justified, viewed in the following angle:- 23) | S.NO PARTICULARS AMOUNT Rs. 1 [Annual Income as per proposed fee aAseOD I structure of the school |) [Total Annual Expenses Accepted before ‘ssa cushion I | 3. [Total Annual Expenses after giving Cushion 511886] [4 [Mean Value of 1/ Tl committee I) Ts : ——"Taaval 5 [Mean Value arrived now ia374} ¢ _ [Annual Income on Prospective Fee j étipaed l structure based on Mean Value l Sic Tr Fee Structure for 2014-15& 2015-16 a 2014-15 - Student | Annual Fee Rae Fa Ges strenath 2. s | KG BUKG 60 42200 782050, Tv 199 14850 2assi50 || Vi- vit 115 16500 1837500 | TAB X 60 18700 4122000) XI & XI 49 20900 397100 | Total 453 ° 7163750 | Total Income 7163750 Total Expenses 7033206 (Vide Table parazi)+ Mean Value Difference 430544 453 Rs.7 5526 SOI7E ASee/ RS(OTES)) Roe20 24(b). : 2015-16 e Student | Annual Fee aoe class Suen Gs) neorne IKE & UKG a 14520 71200 =v 199) 16335 3250665 Vi = vii 115) 18150 2087250 wax 6) 20570 1734200 XI 8 XIL 19 22990 a36810 Total 453 ° 7880125 Total income 7880125 Total expenses 7608665 © (MOE TABIEPAEZI) a4 value Difference 453 Rs.16792 25. For the books and note books offered, the actual cost of the same shall be collected, after being displayed in the said text books or note books 26. The Said fee shall remain in force for the academic years as above mentioned or until the expiry of recagnition, 27. More than the above said fee no amount shall be collected under any other guise, and if so collected it will be considered as violation of the provisions of the Act. 28, Copy of this order shall be sent to the concerned Directorate for the purpose mentioned in Para 6(supra) / BY ORDER / RitianA~_ Special Officer, Private Schools Fee Determination Committee, Chennai - 600 006. { vi nee eh \pRINCIPAL JWLN, Matric, Hr. Sec. School oa Gade. 9. ana a eS i fmhs2009%s em 30275) A.Sasi/ AS(97R6)/ Re