Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Validation
Report
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
Performance
and
Efficiency
for
VMware
Data
Protection
October
2015
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
2
Contents
Introduction
................................................................................................................................................
3
Background
..............................................................................................................................................................
3
ESG
Lab
Validation
......................................................................................................................................
6
Ease
of
Integration
...................................................................................................................................................
6
Performance
and
Efficiency
.....................................................................................................................................
9
ESG
Lab
Validation
Highlights
....................................................................................................................
17
Issues
to
Consider
.....................................................................................................................................
17
The
Bigger
Truth
........................................................................................................................................
18
Appendix
...................................................................................................................................................
19
All
trademark
names
are
property
of
their
respective
companies.
Information
contained
in
this
publication
has
been
obtained
by
sources
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group
(ESG)
considers
to
be
reliable
but
is
not
warranted
by
ESG.
This
publication
may
contain
opinions
of
ESG,
which
are
subject
to
change
from
time
to
time.
This
publication
is
copyrighted
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
Any
reproduction
or
redistribution
of
this
publication,
in
whole
or
in
part,
whether
in
hard-‐copy
format,
electronically,
or
otherwise
to
persons
not
authorized
to
receive
it,
without
the
express
consent
of
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.,
is
in
violation
of
U.S.
copyright
law
and
will
be
subject
to
an
action
for
civil
damages
and,
if
applicable,
criminal
prosecution.
Should
you
have
any
questions,
please
contact
ESG
Client
Relations
at
508.482.0188.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
3
Introduction
This
report
documents
hands-‐on
testing
and
validation
of
an
EMC
data
protection
solution
for
virtual
environments
using
Avamar
Virtual
Edition
with
a
Data
Domain
system,
with
a
focus
on
the
ease
of
integration,
efficiency,
scalability,
and
backup/restore
performance.
Background
According
to
ESG
research,
over
the
past
five
years,
IT
professionals
have
consistently
identified
improving
data
backup
and
recovery,
managing
data
growth,
and
increasing
the
use
of
server
virtualization
among
their
top
IT
priorities.
In
ESG’s
2015
IT
Spending
Intentions
Survey,
only
information
security
initiatives
were
cited
more
often
(see
Figure
1).1
One
challenge
for
organizations
is
that
data
growth
has
a
big
impact
on
data
backup
and
recovery:
Ever-‐expanding
volumes
of
data
lengthen
backup
windows
and
recovery
times,
often
to
the
point
of
interfering
with
production
activities,
while
also
demanding
increasing
amounts
of
back-‐end
storage.
Figure
1.
2015
Top-‐ten
Most-‐cited
IT
Priorities
Top
10
most
important
IT
prioriAes
over
the
next
12
months.
(Percent
of
respondents,
N=601,
ten
responses
accepted)
1
Source:
ESG
Research
Report,
2015
IT
Spending
Intentions
Survey,
February
2015.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
4
Data
Domain
Data
Domain
systems
are
highly
scalable,
purpose-‐built
protection
storage
appliances
that
provide
high-‐speed
deduplication
for
backup
and
archiving,
and
replication
for
disaster
recovery.
The
family
of
models
can
scale
up
to
86.4
PB
of
logical
capacity.
Variable-‐length
deduplication
maximizes
dedupe
rates,
reducing
backup
and
archive
storage
requirements
by
10
to
30
times
on
average,
making
Data
Domain
a
cost-‐effective
alternative
to
other
backup
appliances
or
tape.
These
systems
provide
a
target
for
a
wide
variety
of
enterprise
backup
and
archiving
workloads,
including
VMs,
databases,
mainframes,
IBM
i
systems,
NAS,
e-‐mail,
big
data,
content
management
apps,
and
remote
offices.
Data
Domain
systems
support
both
backup
and
archive
data
simultaneously,
eliminating
the
need
to
buy
and
manage
a
separate
storage
platform
for
archiving,
as
well
as
enabling
global
deduplication
across
both
backup
and
archive
data.
Secure
multi-‐tenancy
is
built
into
the
Data
Domain
Operating
System
(DD
OS),
enabling
hybrid
cloud-‐based
data
protection-‐as-‐a-‐service
for
enterprises
or
service
providers.
Simple
installation
and
easy
management
ensure
lower
OpEx.
Data
Domain
systems
are
built
with
the
Data
Domain
Data
Invulnerability
Architecture
for
maximum
reliability
and
data
integrity,
performing
inline
verification
of
writes
and
reads
and
automatically
recovering
from
I/O
errors
during
ingest
and
retrieval.
This
ensures
that
backups
and
recoveries
are
successfully
completed.
Data
Domain
provides
a
wide
range
of
backup
options
through
support
for
NFS,
CIFS,
VTL,
NDMP,
and
Data
Domain
Boost;
the
latter
integrates
with
backup
and
enterprise
applications
to
dramatically
speed
backups
and
reduce
network
utilization.
Avamar
Avamar
backup
software
delivers
daily
full
backups
with
variable
length
deduplication
for
VMware
environments
as
well
as
for
business-‐critical
applications,
NAS,
desktops/laptops,
and
remote
offices.
Avamar
can
be
deployed
with
a
physical
appliance
for
metadata
or
using
the
Avamar
Virtual
Edition
appliance,
as
was
used
in
this
testing.
When
Avamar
is
combined
with
Data
Domain,
DD
Boost
code
included
in
the
Avamar
client
is
used
to
distribute
parts
of
the
deduplication
processing
to
the
client
side,
reducing
backup
data
and
requiring
less
bandwidth.
Avamar’s
web-‐
based
management
provides
central
control
across
a
global
deployment;
it
can
also
be
managed
through
vSphere.
For
VMware
environments,
both
guest-‐
and
image-‐level
backups
are
supported.
Avamar
is
integrated
with
VMware’s
vStorage
APIs
for
Data
Protection
(VADP),
enabling
agentless
guest
backups.
For
image-‐level
backups,
Avamar
offloads
the
backup
process
from
the
application
VMs
to
multiple
proxy
VMs
as
needed,
and
intelligently
load
balances
among
them.
Avamar
also
leverages
VMware
Changed
Block
Tracking
(CBT)
to
speed
backup
and
restore.
After
the
initial
full
backup
Avamar
transfers
only
changed
data,
but
creates
a
complete
recovery
point
for
restore.
This
“forever
full”
method
delivers
fast
performance
for
both
backup
and
restore;
in
comparison,
traditional
methods
require
rolling
back
to
the
most
recent
full
and
then
staging
the
subsequent
incremental
backups,
taking
more
time
and
sometimes
impacting
recovery
reliability.
Avamar
provides
fast,
single-‐step
recovery
of
entire
VMs
or
individual
files.
In
addition,
Avamar
VM
images
stored
on
the
Data
Domain
target
can
be
instantly
accessed,
a
technique
often
used
for
test/dev
and
recovery
validation;
VMs
can
be
run
directly
on
the
Data
Domain
for
immediate
use,
while
the
running
VM
is
transferred
back
to
the
original
location
in
the
background
using
vMotion.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
5
identify
changed
data.
Then
leveraging
DD
Boost,
parts
of
the
Data
Domain
deduplication
process
are
distributed
to
Avamar,
where
client-‐side
deduplication
ensures
only
unique
data
is
sent
from
the
Avamar
client
to
Data
Domain.
The
highly
scalable
Data
Domain
system
can
serve
simultaneously
as
a
target
for
other
backup
and
archiving
workloads,
as
shown
on
the
right.
For
this
testing,
XtremIO
was
used
as
the
client-‐side
storage
platform
to
eliminate
the
possibility
of
any
storage
bottleneck.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
6
Figure 3. Add Data Domain System via Avamar Administrator Console
The
next
step
was
click
the
Server
tab,
select
Server
Management,
and
select
Add
Data
Domain
System
(Figure
3,
right).
On
the
System
tab,
the
qualified
system
name
(dd4500a)
was
added,
and
the
DD
Boost
account
name
and
credentials
(which
had
been
created
during
the
dd4500a
set
up)
were
added.
This
authenticated
the
target
system,
enabling
write
permissions
for
Avamar
clients.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
7
A
key
setting
is
the
total
number
of
Avamar
client
backup
streams
that
can
be
launched
at
the
same
time;
in
this
case,
270
streams
were
enabled.
Since
Data
Domain
can
serve
as
a
target
for
multiple
backup
and
archiving
tasks
simultaneously,
it
is
important
to
ensure
the
optimal
balance
to
avoid
having
one
application
unintentionally
oversubscribe
the
Data
Domain
target.
Next,
SNMP
details
were
added
to
enable
Avamar
to
collect
and
display
details
regarding
system
health,
alerts,
and
capacity.
Once
these
steps
were
completed,
ESG
Lab
was
able
to
view
the
Data
Domain
target
within
the
Avamar
Administrator
dashboard
(Figure
4,
top).
In
addition,
from
the
Server/Server
Management
tabs,
we
could
click
the
dd
icon
in
the
toolbar
and
view
the
system
details
of
the
newly
added
dd4500a,
including
hostname,
used
and
available
capacity,
bytes
protected,
replication
status,
stream
limit,
and
the
status
of
encryption,
authentication,
and
monitoring
(Figure
4,
bottom).
Figure
4.
Managing
Data
Domain
from
Avamar
Administrator
GUI
With
the
dd4500a
target
properly
configured,
the
final
step
was
to
create
an
Avamar
backup
policy
for
the
VMware
VMs.
For
the
backup
job
titled
VM_Test,
the
Options
tab
was
selected.
From
the
drop-‐down
box
we
selected
Linux
VMware
Image
and
checked
the
box
to
use
Change
Block
Tracking.
Next,
we
clicked
the
Store
Backup
on
Data
Domain
system
check
box,
selected
dd4500a
from
the
list
of
available
targets,
and
clicked
OK.
At
this
point,
the
next
manual
or
scheduled
backup
for
the
dataset
VM_Test
would
send
data
directly
to
the
Data
Domain
target.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
8
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
9
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
10
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
11
400
350
300
250
TiB
200
Dedupe
rate
72.3
x
150
100
50
0
Data
Protected
Data
Stored
aker
Dedupe/Compression
100.00
80.00
60.00
40.00
20.00
0.00
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
12
Next,
ESG
Lab
reviewed
data
for
a
restore
test
using
CBT.
After
a
complete
reset
of
the
environment,
another
50GB
data
set
was
generated
for
31
VMs,
creating
VMs
of
70
GB
each.
After
an
initial
full
backup
was
done,
a
single
data
modification
cycle
was
executed.
Next,
CBT
restores
were
conducted
for
a
single
VM,
for
10
VMs
simultaneously,
and
for
20
VMs
simultaneously.
This
simulates
restore
after
a
corruption
or
a
rollback
of
application
data
to
a
specific
point
in
time
for
a
VM
or
group
of
VMs.
Figure
10
displays
the
average
restore
time
for
the
three
test
iterations.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
13
Restore 1 Client
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
Minutes
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
14
90
80
70
Data
Domain
60
ESX
1
Percentage
50
ESX
2
40
ESX
3
30
ESX
4
20
10
0
Time
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
15
Figure 12. Scale Test: Backup Performance as Data Volumes Grow
10.8 180
10.6 160
10.4 140
10.2 120
Minutes
TBs
10 100
9.8 80
9.6 60
9.4 40
9.2 20
9
0
Inidal
Data
200
Incremental
50
Incremental
100
Incremental
150
Incremental
200
VMs
Vms
VMs
VMs.
VMs
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
16
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
17
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
18
2
Source:
ESG
Research
Report,
2015
IT
Spending
Intentions
Survey,
February
2015.
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
Lab
Validation:
EMC
Data
Domain
and
Avamar
19
Appendix
Table
1.
ESG
Lab
Test
Bed
Backup
Software
Disk
Target
Avamar
Virtual
Edition
7.2
Data
Domain
DD4500
2
x
vCPU
DD
OS
5.6.0.3
6
x
vRAM
4
x
ES30-‐30
Disk
Shelves
900
GB
Disk
Space
4
x
10
GbE
Interfaces
(2
used
in
testing)
Virtualization
Servers
VMware
vCenter
5.5.2
4
x
Cisco
UCS
240
OS:
SLES
12.3
Storage
Network
2
x
EMC
XtremIO,
7.56
TB
usable
each
10GbE
©
2015
by
The
Enterprise
Strategy
Group,
Inc.
All
Rights
Reserved.
20
Asylum
Street
|
Milford,
MA
01757
|
Tel:
508.482.0188
Fax:
508.482.0218
|
www.esg-‐global.com