You are on page 1of 1

Decreasing the Opioid Epidemic: Implications for Advanced Practice Registered Nurses

Bronson Bybee, BSN Student, Jonathan Plaskett, BSN Student

School of Nursing and Health Sciences, Westminster College, Salt Lake City, UT

Abstract Conclusion Literature Review

Background: The prescribing rates of opioid analgesics have significantly increased in recent years leading The rising use of prescription opioids has lead to epidemic levels of increased opioid-related complications. Three articles were chosen which were published within the last 5 years and which supported elements of our research
to increased related adverse conditions (Kolodny et al., 2015, p. 559). This study’s intention is to determine Consequently, opioid overdose death rates have reached the CDC’s top 10 causes of death. including the background and relevance of the problem, current practices for both APRNs and physicians, and
whether advanced practice registered nurses (APRN) and physicians (MD, DO) have different prescribing methodologies of APRNs deemed peculiar to the profession. The following paragraphs will detail strengths of each
practices and if those differences would be significant in regards to decreasing the U.S. opioid crisis. States with independent APRNs have shown significantly lower opioid prescribing rates than states where article chosen as well as clarify the value of each.
Methods: A literature review of 11 articles discussing the opioid crisis and prescribing rates by provider type APRNs have prescribing restrictions. Emergency department physicians are twice as likely to prescribe
Schirle & McCabe (2015) published a journal titled State Variation in Opioid and Benzodiazepine Prescriptions
was conducted to address the following questions: Is there a difference in opioid prescription rates between opioids for musculoskeletal pain than prescribing mid-level providers (e.g. nurse practitioner, physician
Between Independent and Non-independent Advanced Practice Registered Nurses. The purpose of this study was, “to
APRNs and physicians? If so, what causes heterogeneity? What are the implications of methods utilized by assistant, etc.). It has been suggested that this phenomenon may correspond with APRN training being more investigate the relationship in opioid- and benzodiazepine-prescribing rates between independent and non-independent
APRNs? Can these methods be utilized to decrease rates of prescription opioid use and subsequently lower holistic and wellness focused, proposing that nurses are more likely to incorporate nonopioid pharmacologic APRN prescribing states” (p. 86). The authors analyzed a 2014 CDC study reporting state variations in prescribing
rates of opioid related adverse complications? and non-pharmacologic alternatives to treat pain. Additionally, many states require APRN controlled rates. This represented 259 million prescriptions distributed by pharmacies, which distribute approximately 90% of the
Results: There were significantly lower opioid prescribing rates in APRN independent practice states than in substance education before granting authority to prescribe; which is not always required of physician- Nation’s opioids. They defined independent states as those in which all APRN types were free of restrictions relating to
states where APRNs cannot prescribe or have prescribing restrictions. Mid-level providers (MLP)(e.g. nurse prescribing counterparts. An anticipated concern may regard APRNs having lower levels of patient prescribing and non-independent states were those with APRN prescribing restrictions. Their findings stated that
practitioner, physician assistant, etc.) were found to be half as likely to prescribe opioids for musculoskeletal satisfaction and their patients being undertreated. On the contrary, data supports that APRNs maintain high independent APRN states had significantly lower opioid and benzodiazepine prescribing rates than those of non-
pain in the emergency department (ED) than their physician counterparts. It has been suggested that APRN levels of patient satisfaction, even when compared with physician care. This study confirms existing independent APRN states. Furthermore, their numbers remained significant after controlling for differing state
education and training may lead nurses to use alternative modalities for pain management before prescribing differences in prescribing rates of physicians and APRNs; specifically lower opioid prescribing rates among characteristics (e.g., number of physicians/capita, Medicare rates, race, and socioeconomic status). Included are
opioids. This study found no evidence that APRN patients are undertreated or have lower patient satisfaction APRNs. suggested explanations for the differences between prescriber type practices explaining that many independent APRN
scores, even when compared with physician care. states mandate controlled substance education before an APRN could obtain independent prescribing status,
Conclusions: Prescribers are recommended to use caution when prescribing opioids and utilize alternative This research recommends prescribers use more caution when prescribing opioids for both acute and chronic but this requirement is not always required of physician-prescriber counterparts (p. 91). Additionally, they
suggest that, “APRN training is more holistic, wellness focused, and less disease oriented and cure focused, so
pain management modalities when appropriate. When prescription opioids are favorable, it is recommended pain management, limit extended-release opioids, limit emergency department prescription supplies to 3 days,
nurses may be more likely to incorporate nonopioid pharmacologic and non-pharmacologic treatment
that supplies are limited; specifically ED supplies should be limited to 3 days. and implement sufficient alternatives for pain management when appropriate. Further research is warranted to modalities to treat pain” (p. 91). One anticipated concern mentioned is that patients of APRNs may be undertreated
confirm these preliminary conclusions. due to lower rates of opioid prescribing. However, the authors address this concern explaining that, “data evidences
high levels of patient satisfaction with APRN care, even as compared with physician care” (p.92). The authors
Problem Statement Opioid prescriptions per 100 persons in states with independent and non-independent practice for APRNs
state a limitation of their study is that prescribing statistics were limited to pharmacy distributed prescriptions and do
It is well documented that the rising use of prescription opioids has significantly increased in the last two not account for all prescription sources.
decades (CDC, 2012). Since the late 1990’s, consumption of hydrocodone has more than doubled,
consumption of oxycodone has increased nearly 500%, and the rate of opioid-related overdose death has This article was chosen to support our study as it provided extensive evidence regarding the differences in opioid
prescription rates of physicians and APRNs in independent versus non-independent states. The data provided by this
nearly quadrupled (Kolodny et al., 2015, p. 559). Kochanek, Murphy, Xu, & Tejada-Vera (2016) reported that
article included information gathered from pharmacies across the Unites States with distinction of practice by state. As
opioid overdoses accounted for more than 20,000 deaths in 2015 according to the CDC, ranking it in the top the inclusive sample included pharmacies throughout the Nation grouped by state with factors such as Medicare rates,
10 causes of death alongside other common killers such as Parkinson’s disease and pneumonitis. While race, socioeconomic status, and number of physicians/capita being considered and controlled for (Schirle, et al., 2015),
problems can arise when comparing data from different years, the magnitude of the problem and the rate at this study had strong external validity.
which it is escalating is apparent and concerning. The increase of opioid prescription rates have lead to
increased rates of opioid-related hospitalization, readmission, addiction, overdose, and death. Methods to The article by Thomas et al. (2015), titled Variation Between Physicians and Mid-Level Providers in Opioid Treatment
decrease complications related to this problem should be searched out and addressed. For Musculoskeletal Pain in the Emergency Department, “assessed for possible association between practitioner status
(physician [MD] vs. mid-level provider [MLP]) and use of opioids for in-ED treatment of musculoskeletal pain
(MSP)” (p. 415). The design was a secondary sub-analysis of 688 prospectively studied subjects with MSP who
received pain treatment in the ED. Data was collected from September 2012 to February 2014 from 12 EDs at
academic centers throughout the U.S. Of the 688 participants physicians saw 58% of the sample while MLPs saw 42%.
Schirle, L., & Mccabe, B. E. (2016). State variation in opioid and benzodiazepine prescriptions between independent and nonindependent Findings showed that physicians prescribed over twice the amount of opioids as MLPs. While this seems
advanced practice registered nurse prescribing states. Nursing Outlook, 64(1), 86-93.
significant, the authors make note that this study was intended to serve as an analysis to determine heterogeneity of
practice and not as a conclusive basis regarding MD/MLP prescribing practices (Thomas et al., 2015); this study is
limited due to this fact. The authors emphasize that further studies are warranted to confirm their preliminary
Nursing Implications conclusions. This article supported our research questions by providing additional data suggesting that heterogeneity
exists between the prescribing practices of physicians and mid-level providers.
The nursing discipline comes from a background of patient advocates with a focus on care and cure rather
than being strictly disease oriented. Today, this background is reflected in the curriculum of the nursing The article was selected due to its sample being collected over multiple academic centers throughout the U.S.,
discipline. APRNs have a unique place in medicine as they have many roles and can be considered anything increasing the variability and scope of the sample and thus the validity.
from mid-level provider, to primary care provider, to specialist.
Kolodny et al. (2015) indicates in their literature review, The Prescription Opioid and Heroin Crisis: A Public Health
This study suggests that, due to curriculum differences between APRNs and physicians, some states mandate Approach to an Epidemic of Addiction, that their purpose is to address the rising opioid crisis and recommend
APRNs take controlled substance education courses prior to administering medications. This may be a interventions by taking an epidemiological approach through focusing on preventing opioid addiction (primary
contributing factor to their prescribing habits, which implies that APRN education can be supplemented prevention), assessing early signs and symptoms of addiction (secondary prevention), and providing access to
through more learning prior to prescribing sensitive medications such as opioids. Data from this study shows addiction treatment (tertiary prevention) (p. 565). Regarding primary prevention, it is recommended that health care
that APRNs generally prescribe less opioids than physicians. It can then be surmised that this difference is due professionals prescribe opioids more cautiously for both acute and chronic pain, limit extended-release opioids,
Clinical Questions to the additional education required of APRNs. utilize substituted nonopioid analgesics and nonpharmacological approaches for pain relief, and limit
emergency room prescription supplies to 3 days (p. 566). Secondary prevention methods include assessing signs and
1. Are there a differences in opioid prescribing rates between APRNs and physicians? If so, what causes symptoms of addiction in chronic pain management patients and using prescription drug monitoring programs to
heterogeneity? Thomas et al. (2015) found MLPs prescribe less than half as many opioids in the ED than physician-
prevent patients from receiving prescriptions from multiple prescribers (p. 567). Tertiary prevention involves addicts
2. What methods are utilized by APRNs when prescribing opioids? prescribing counterparts. However, this study found no correlation between the state requirements of receiving pharmacotherapy treatment and rehabilitation efforts (p. 567).
3. Can these methods be utilized to decrease rates of prescription opioid use and subsequently lower rates of substance education courses and EDs within the study done by Thomas et al. (2015). It cannot then be
opioid-related adverse complications? assumed that all ED MLPs underwent the substance education courses; the variances in prescribing practices This study was selected as an example of interventions that may be utilized by APRNs to decrease opioid prescription
among provider types must be attributed to other factors. rates. It is a strong article as it is a literature review covering the history of opioid addiction from the 19th to the 21st
Answering these questions will determine whether there are current prescribing practices easing the opioid century, as well as implications and interventions with extensive literature references. The article is peer-reviewed,
crisis and how these approaches can be more fully utilized. Research cites the background of APRNs as being instrumental in their practices and as being “more holistic, reviewed and approved by Johns Hopkins University and cleared of conflicts of interest. However, the article lacks in
wellness focused, and less disease oriented and cure focused” (Schirle, et al., 2015). This research suggests explanation with regards to methods of their data collection.
that the holistic nature of nurse education is instrumental in decreasing opioid prescribing rates and is
Methods supported by “data evidenc[ing] high levels of patient satisfaction with APRN care, even as compared with
This study, Decreasing the Opioid Epidemic: Implications for Advanced Practice Registered Nurses, was
physician care” (Schirle et al., 2015). It should be noted that this high satisfaction was expressed by patients References
of APRNs who prescribed less inpatient/outpatient opioids. This is strong evidence supporting strengths CDC (2012). CDC Grand Rounds: Prescription Drug Overdoses — a U.S. Epidemic. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 61(1), 10-13.
designed using a search in PubMed, EBSCOhost, and ScienceDirect databases conducted in November 2017.
found within nursing as a professional discipline, as well as within clinical nursing practice. Further research CDC (2011). Vital signs: overdose of prescription opioid pain relievers-United States, 1999-2008. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 60, 1487-1492.
Articles containing the terms ‘opioid prescribing rates’, ‘opioid overdose’, ‘opioid prescribing by provider Kochanek, K. D., Murphy, S. L., Xu, J. Q., & Tejada-Vera, B. (2016). Deaths: Final data for 2014. National vital statistics reports, 65(4), 1-122.
is warranted into utilizing tools found within the nursing discipline in regards to decreasing levels of opioid
type’, and ‘opioid prescribing nurse practitioners’ were searched for with a filter limiting the search to peer Kolodny, A., Courtwright, D. T., Hwang, C. S., Kreiner, P., Eadie, J. L., Clark, T. W., & Alexander, G. C. (2015). The Prescription Opioid and Heroin Crisis: A
related complications. Public Health Approach to an Epidemic of Addiction. Annual Review of Public Health, 36(1), 559-574.
reviewed articles published in the last 5 years. The abstracts of these articles were then assessed to determine Schirle, L., & Mccabe, B. E. (2016). State variation in opioid and benzodiazepine prescriptions between independent and nonindependent advanced practice
whether they contained information relating to complications of opioid use, opioid prescribing practices by registered nurse prescribing states. Nursing Outlook, 64(1), 86-93.
Thomas, S. H., Mumma, S., Satterwhite, A., Haas, T., Arthur, A. O., Todd, K. H., . . . Pollack, C. V. (2015). Variation Between Physicians and Mid-level
provider types, and/or methods to decrease opioid prescribing rates. 57 studies were reviewed to determine Providers in Opioid Treatment for Musculoskeletal Pain in the Emergency Department. The Journal of Emergency Medicine, 49(4), 415-423.
applicability, and 11 relevant papers were identified. 3 articles were selected as main support.