Batch Distillation

© All Rights Reserved

0 views

Batch Distillation

© All Rights Reserved

- Chapter 07- Trace Elements
- chemical_engineering_170715.pdf
- HiDC PhD Thesis
- Phase Equilibrium Worksheet
- Design Guidelines for Proplyene Splitters - Rev In
- Topic 8 Property CET
- Distillation
- water-content-assessment-in-acid-gas.pdf
- Tech Production BubbleDewCalc
- Aman_Resume_Project Report
- Visualizing the MacCabe Thiele diagram.pdf
- Determination of liquid-liquid equilibria of a water-acetic acid-ethyl acetate ternary system
- Cooling Systems 2012
- Engineering Design Guideline- Propylene Splitter Rev01web
- 168114_Chapter_10_Solutions__Introduction_To_Chemical_Engineering_Thermodynamics_7th_Edition__Chegg.com.pdf
- AZEOTROPIC DATA (Advances in Chemistry Volume 6).pdf
- modular-waste-lube-oil.pdf
- Improved Reliability in Operation and Mantenance
- 2 BASIC MODELING.pptx
- Flash

You are on page 1of 7

In the simple binary batch distillation system shown in Figure 9-1 the vapor product is in equilibrium with liquid

in the still pot at any given time. Since we use a total condenser, y = xD. Substituting equilibrium into Eq. (9-7),

we have

where y and x are in equilibrium with equilibrium expression y = f(x,p). For any given equilibrium expression,

Eq. (9-10) can be integrated analytically, graphically, or numerically.

The general graphical or numerical integration procedure for Eq. (9-10) is:

FIGURE 9-4 Graphical integration for simple batch distillation, Example 9-1

5. From Eq. (9-10), find the final charge of material W final in the still pot:

Click to view larger image

6. The amount of distillate, D, and the average distillate concentration, x D,avg, can be found from the mass

balances Eqs. (9-8a) and (9-8b).

The Rayleigh equation can also be integrated numerically. One convenient method for doing this is to use

Simpson’s rule (e.g., see Mickley et al., 1957, pp. 35–42; or Larsson et al., 2014, pp. 42–52). If the ordinate

in Figure 9-4 is called g(x), then the simplest form of Simpson’s rule divides the interval into two equal parts

with δx = (xF – xfin)/2.

Terms are shown in Figure 9-4. Simpson’s rule is exact if g(x) is cubic or lower order. More accuracy can be

obtained by dividing the interval into a larger, even number of parts of equal size. For example, if we use n

equal subintervals, then δx = (xF – xfin)/n, and Simpson’s rule becomes

Note that n has to be an even integer. For smooth curves, such as in Figure 9-4, Simpson’s rule is quite

accurate (see Example 9-1). For more complex shapes, Simpson’s rule may be more accurate if the integration

is done in two or more separate pieces (see Example 9-2). Alternatively, half intervals can be used in regions

where more accuracy is needed (Larsson et al., 2014). Simpson’s rule is also the MATLAB command quad

(for quadrature) (Pratap, 2006). Other integration formulas that are more accurate can be used.

If the average distillate concentration is specified, a trial-and-error procedure is required. This involves

guessing the final still pot concentration, xW,final, and calculating the area in Figure 9-4 either graphically or using

Simpson’s rule. Then Eq. (9-11) gives W final, and Eq. (9-8b) is used to check the value of xD,avg. For a graphical

solution, the trial-and-error procedure can be conveniently carried out by starting with a guess for xfin that is too

high. Then every time xfin is decreased, the additional area is added to the area already calculated.

If the relative volatility α is constant, the Rayleigh equation can be integrated analytically. In this case the

equilibrium expression is Eq. (2-22b), which is repeated here:

When it is applicable, Eq. (9-13) is obviously easier to apply than graphical or numerical integration. Analytical

solutions for limiting cases (constant α in this case) are also useful for checking numerical solutions.

Warning: If α is not constant, W final calculated from Eq. (9-13) can be very inaccurate.

A simple batch still (one equilibrium stage) is separating a 50 mole feed charge to the still pot that is 80.0 mol%

methanol and 20.0 mol% water. An average distillate concentration of 89.2 mol% methanol is required. Find the

amount of distillate collected, the amount of material left in the still pot, and the concentration of the material in

the still pot. Pressure is 1 atm.

Solution

A. Define. The apparatus is shown in Figure 9-1. The conditions are: p = 1 atm, F = 50, x F = 0.80, and

xD,avg = 0.892. Find xfin, Dtot, and W final.

B. Explore. Since the still pot acts as one equilibrium contact, the Rayleigh equation takes the form of Eqs.

(9-10) and (9-11). To use these equations, either a plot of 1/(y – x)equil vs. x is required for graphical

integration or Simpson’s rule can be used. Both are illustrated. Since x fin is unknown, a trial-and-error

procedure is required for either integration routine.

C. Plan. First plot 1/(y – x) vs. x from the equilibrium data. The trial-and-error procedure is as follows:

Guess xfin.

Integrate to find

Calculate W final from the Rayleigh equation and xD,avg,calc from mass balance.

D. Do it. From the equilibrium data in Table 2-7 the following table is generated:

These data are plotted in Figure 9-4. For the numerical solution a large graph on millimeter graph paper

was constructed.

= 24.72

The alternative integration procedure using Simpson’s rule gives

Where is the value of 1/(y – x) calculated at xfin, and xAvg = (xF + xfin)/2.

For Simpson’s rule, W final = 24.79, Dcalc = 25.21, and xD,calc = 0.898. Simpson’s rule appears to be quite

accurate in this case. W final is off by 0.3%, and xD,calc is the same as the more exact calculation. These

values appear to be close to the desired value, but we do not yet know the sensitivity of the calculation.

Second guess: xfin = 0.60. Calculations similar to the first trial give:

Area = 1.2084, W final = 14.93, Dcalc = 35.07, xD,calc = 0.885 from Figure 9-4, and xD,calc = 0.884 from the

Simpson’s rule calculation. These are also close, but they are low. For this problem the value of x D is

insensitive to xfin.

Area = 0.971, W final = 18.94, Dcalc = 31.06, and xD,calc = 0.891 from Figure 9-4 and xD,calc = 0.890 from the

Simpson’s rule calculation of the area, which are both close to the specified value of 0.892.

E. Check. The overall mass balance is W final xfin + Dcalc xD,calc = 39.985 as compared to FxF = 40. Error is (40

– 39.985)/40 × 100, or 0.038%, which is acceptable.

F. Generalize. The integration can also be done numerically on a computer using Simpson’s rule or an

alternative integration method. This is an advantage, since then the entire trial-and-error procedure can

be programmed. Note that large differences in xW,final and hence in W final cause rather small differences in

xD,avg. Thus, for this problem, exact control of the batch system may not be critical. This problem illustrates

a common difficulty of simple batch distillation—a pure distillate and a pure bottoms product cannot be

obtained unless the relative volatility is very large. Note that although Eq. (9-13) is strictly not applicable

since methanol-water equilibrium does not have a constant relative volatility, it could be used over the

limited range of this batch distillation.

If xfin is very low, then becomes very large, and Simpson’s rule is not very accurate. If

the area is divided into two parts from xF to x ∼ 0.05 and from this point to xfin, Simpson’s rule will be

accurate for the first part. Calculate W fin,1 from Simpson’s rule. A reasonably accurate value of relative

volatility can be estimated from αAB = (yA/xA)/(yB/xB) calculated from this point. Then Eq. (9-13) will give an

accurate estimate of W fin with F = W fin,1 and xF set equal to the point used to divide the integral.

It is interesting to compare the simple binary batch distillation result to binary flash distillation of the same feed

producing y = 0.892 mole fraction methanol. This flash distillation problem was solved previously as Problem

2.D1g. The results were x = 0.756 (compare to xfin = 0.65), V = 16.18 (compare to Dtotal = 31.06), and L = 33.82

(compare to W final = 18.94). The simple batch distillation gives a greater separation with more distillate product

because the bottoms product is an average of liquids in equilibrium with vapor in the entire range from y =

0.915 (in equilibrium with x = z = 0.8) to y = 0.845 (in equilibrium with x = xfin = 0.65), while for the flash

distillation, the liquid is always in equilibrium with the final vapor y = 0.892. In general, a simple batch distillation

will give more separation than flash distillation with the same operating conditions. However, because flash

distillation is continuous, it is much easier to integrate into a continuous plant.

Extension of the solution method for simple binary batch distillation to collection of fractions is straightforward if

the values of xW1, xW2, ... are specified. Equations (9-9) are converted to simple batch by replacing xD with y,

which is in equilibrium with xW. In essence, a number of simple batch problems are solved sequentially (see

Problem 9.D23).

Extension of the simple batch equations to multicomponent systems is also straightforward, although solution

of the equations is significantly more difficult than solution of the binary equations. For simple multicomponent

batch distillation Eq. (9-5b) becomes

The Rayleigh Eq. (9-10) can be written for each component. The equilibrium expression becomes a function of

all the components, which couples all of the equations. Section 9.6 explores multicomponent simple distillation

in detail.

A process that is closely related to simple batch distillation is differential condensation (Treybal, 1980). In this

process vapor is slowly condensed, and the condensate liquid is rapidly withdrawn. A derivation similar to the

derivation of the Raleigh equation for a binary system gives

where F is the moles of feed vapor of mole fraction yF, and Dfinal is the leftover vapor distillate of mole fraction

yD,final. Differential condensation is rarely practiced.

- Chapter 07- Trace ElementsUploaded byJean Marin Padilla
- chemical_engineering_170715.pdfUploaded byArun
- HiDC PhD ThesisUploaded byMuhammad Haris Hamayun
- Phase Equilibrium WorksheetUploaded byJue Maya
- Design Guidelines for Proplyene Splitters - Rev InUploaded byOgenioja
- Topic 8 Property CETUploaded byNsv Dinesh
- DistillationUploaded bybutyok007
- water-content-assessment-in-acid-gas.pdfUploaded bype
- Tech Production BubbleDewCalcUploaded bySunil Kumar
- Aman_Resume_Project ReportUploaded byAnkur Agarwal
- Visualizing the MacCabe Thiele diagram.pdfUploaded byMayank Sinha
- Determination of liquid-liquid equilibria of a water-acetic acid-ethyl acetate ternary systemUploaded byGab Lerona
- Cooling Systems 2012Uploaded byAnonymous 73gEYyEtL
- Engineering Design Guideline- Propylene Splitter Rev01webUploaded bymuhammad_asim_10
- 168114_Chapter_10_Solutions__Introduction_To_Chemical_Engineering_Thermodynamics_7th_Edition__Chegg.com.pdfUploaded byadoxa
- AZEOTROPIC DATA (Advances in Chemistry Volume 6).pdfUploaded bySachikanta Pradhan
- modular-waste-lube-oil.pdfUploaded byAdeel Ahmed
- Improved Reliability in Operation and MantenanceUploaded byjuliancardona
- 2 BASIC MODELING.pptxUploaded byraja.mt
- FlashUploaded byJocelyn Corpuz
- Problems in Mass TransferUploaded byAngelica Joyce Benito
- Pro ValveUploaded bydonya
- Separation TechniquesUploaded byFrancis Ho Ho
- D86.pdfUploaded byLuis Deras
- MTO Lecture 4Uploaded byMubashar Rehmat Ansari
- serbezov2003Uploaded byNguyễn Thị Kim Phượng
- f02midterm1Uploaded byاحمد الدلال
- Paper D.ExtractivaUploaded bynatalia
- Thermodynamics basics 2Uploaded byKushal Kayal
- 1993 - Barreiros et al. - Modeling and simulation of structured packing column distillation (OCR, outro)Uploaded byManuel Menezes de Sequeira

- 7.docUploaded bytarhuni
- Judy Experiment Chelab1Uploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Life Cycle Analysis of Cement Industry.pptUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Distillation concepts.docxUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Nonisothermal CSTR Tutorial (1)Uploaded byStefanie Guzman Aznaran
- Characteristics of Fuels.docxUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- AntibodiesUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- flowsheet symbols and PenI diagrams.docxUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Lapse Rate and StabilityUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- NARRATIVE REPORT 2018.docxUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Batch Distillation Unfin 1Uploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- BATCH-DISTILLATION-UNFIN-1.docxUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Air PollutionUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Day-1-Exam-1.docxUploaded byCheng Pasion
- ps pdUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- EnzymesUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- BP Texas ReportUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Addin Discussion DryingUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Result and Discussion1Uploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- 12345Uploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Conclusion and RecommendationUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Conclusion and RecommendationUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- MethodologyUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- APPENDICES.docxUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- ps pdUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- MethodologyUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Bose Leneses Ramos SuorUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Approval SheetUploaded byJudy Ann Bose
- Approval-sheet.docx Cath JudyUploaded byJudy Ann Bose

- Advanced Workflow ArticleUploaded bysksow
- [電動機械L1b補充教材]NCT-tech_Power Factor Improvement.Uploaded byZerihun Demere
- Computer Security MeasuresUploaded byannie_khor_2
- painless-conjugate-gradientUploaded byMaruthi Nh
- Courses CSE University of DhakaUploaded byWalid- Bin-Habib
- Oracle GoldenGate DirectorUploaded byZzSavioRzZ
- Essbase 11.1.1 Installation TutorialUploaded byaloo_a3
- Bm2012manual EnUploaded byRomildo Silva
- Google Play Supported DevicesUploaded bySoufiane Belarbi
- tcpipstackUploaded bysnail2hemant
- Ethernet V2.0 Configuration Testing Protocol (ECTP)Uploaded bywonderful_void
- AlgorithmsUploaded byAminosuma
- CATIA Course DescriptionsUploaded bygebrefikru
- Data Uploading in SAPUploaded bynalini saxena
- SAES-Z-000Uploaded byethicalhacker2006
- Gps Module (Skutel0051)Uploaded byNhư Tổng
- Sequence CPU Functions) (for F3SP28, 38, 53, 58 and 59) IM34M6P13-01EUploaded by賴文喜
- Open Source_Stefano Maffulli_FunambolUploaded bySEE2009
- Quranic Arabic Corpus - Data DownloadUploaded bydadangkoe
- Data base Complete HandoutsUploaded byMuhammad Ahmed
- KELLY, Kevin. Out of Control.pdfUploaded bylalapoe
- ece503_ps03Uploaded byRushabh Mehta
- Iso 9001：2015实施指南 (中英文对照)Uploaded byzzuthomas
- C3 Yard Data SheetUploaded byMaria Miranda
- Ultrasonido Bkm Pro Focus 2202Uploaded byMariö Olvera
- SIAE MicroelectronicUploaded byYanSenjani
- What is CouchDBUploaded byjaysmith024
- Win SockUploaded byom18sahu
- TechFest '14Uploaded byAnukul Sangwan
- PointerUploaded byJaved Iqbal