O O o O O. O. O.
O o o O O. O. O.
O O o O O. O. O.
oo o O O. O. O. O. O. O. O. oo
oo o O O o o o oooo
o oo o of a lo ooo 11
o oO O  3 25 O o O O
o'é o o o OO
o O O O O o O O o OO
o O O o o o o oooo
9 O o O O o o
O O O O O O O
to O o O O O o
U.S. Patent Sep. 10, 1991 Sheet 1 of 6 5,047,785
an n
Y Y
N/ Ne
n Oy
X X
OO) on !
SO
*

U.S. Patent Sep. 10, 1991 Sheet 2 of 6 5,047,785
e4 e5 e6 11
o O O. O. O. O. O. O. o o o
O OO o e7 68 e9 o o OO
o O O. O. O. O. O. O. o o o
o o o O O O O.
O O o O O O O.
O O O O O O O
FG.2
1 j 1. 1. J 1.
J J J j 1 j
1 j 1. 1 J 1.
U.S. Patent Sep. 10, 1991 Sheet 3 of 6 5,047,785
SCANNED 3 C3
CONTOUR
NVISIBLE
SPACE
UNSCANNED 33
CONTOUR
HIDDEN SPACE
U.S. Patent Sep. 10, 1991 Sheet 4 of 6 5,047,785
U.S. Patent Sep. 10, 1991 Sheet 5 of 6 5,047,785
M(3BACWIOd)
FIG.8
M(3BACWIOd)
º
30 
·
FG.9
U.S. Patent Sep. 10, 1991 Sheet 6 of 6 5,047,785
:
 1 OO
 12O
 14.O
 1 SO
 18O
200
O n U ( A UN U n O
O O. O. o O O O O O O
ANGLE OFF BORESIGHT (DEG)
FIG 1 O
 1 OO
 14.O
 1 SO
 18O
2OO
O n U ( a UN U n O
O. O. O. O. O. O. O. O. O. O
ANGLE OFF BORESIGHT (DEG)
FG 11
5,047,785
1 2
and the five remaining elements comprise the other. A
SPLITPHASE TECHNIQUE FOR ELIMINATING 90degree phase shift is placed between the center pha
PATTERN NULLS FROM A DISCRETE GUARD ses of the two guard Subarrays by putting unit real
ANTENNA ARRAY weights (w = 1) on one subarray and unit imaginary
weights (w =j) on the other. The entire nine element
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION guard array is then scanned with the main beam. Guard
1. Field of the Invention nulls can only occur when both guard subarrays have a
The subject invention relates to antennas and, more null in the same direction and at the same scan. This
particularly, to a technique for producing a guard pat situation occurs at only a small number of points.
tern for an active antenna array. O
2. Description of Related Art BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
A guard pattern is useful in eliminating target returns FIG. 1 is a schematic block diagram illustrative of
outside of the main beam of an antenna. According to typical active antenna array elements;
conventional design, the guard pattern is designed to 15
FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram of an active antenna
exceed the main gain of the antenna in the sidelobe array incorporating the preferred embodiment of the
region. Simple decision logic then rejects returns whose invention;
main is not much larger than its guard. With a mechani FIG. 3 is a graph illustrating cosine space;
cally scanned antenna, one creates a guard pattern by FIG. 4 is a graph illustrating mapping between points
selecting an appropriate guard horn with a fixed orien in cosine space and a direction vector in threedimen
tation to boresight. Such a configuration is effective in sional space;
all scan directions. FIGS. 5 and 6 illustrate first and second weighting
Establishing a guard function is more difficult with an configurations;
electronically scanned antenna. Since the main beam FIG. 7 is a graph illustrating null patterns associated
scans independently of the plate of the antenna, a single, with selected guard arrays; and
fixed guard horn may not perform well at scans off the 25
mechanical boresight. Two ways around this problem FIGS. 811 illustrate cuts of guard patterns generated
according to the preferred embodiment.
are known. One may either switch strategically be
tween several differently oriented guard horns, or one DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE
may use a single guard array which scans with the main PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
beam. The latter single guard array approach is the 30
The following description is provided to enable any,
subject of the invention described hereafter. person skilled in the art to make and use the invention
A simple single guard subarray can be formed on an and sets forth the best modes contemplated by the in
active array antenna by devoting one or more elements ventor for carrying out his invention. Various modifica
to this function. However, one element alone cannot be
scanned because scanning requires a phase slope across 35 tions, however, will remain readily apparent to those
the antenna. Two elements together can only scan in skilled in the art, since the generic principles of the
one angular dimension. Since the single guard subarray present invention have been defined herein specifically
needs to scan omnidirectionally, it would appear to to provide a particularly useful and readily implementa
require fourfold symmetry. Thus, the smallest practical ble guard array scheme for an active antenna array.
single guard array consists of four elements in a square. 40 FIG. 1 illustrates a typical element MODn of an
The next largest square guard array has nine elements active antenna array. In this element MODn, an antenna
arranged threebythree. element 21 is connected to both a receive path 23 and a
The problem with such small guard arrays is the transmit path 25. Respective switches 27, 29 are placed
presence of excessive nulls in the guard array pattern. In in the receive path 23 and transmit path 25 to alternately
the vicinity of nulls, the guard is generally useless. The connect the antenna 21 to either a low noise input am
square arrays described above have entire null planes plifier (LNA) 31 or a power output amplifier 34. As
which move as the guard array is scanned. Such null indicated, closing of the switches 27, 29 is under control
planes lead to unacceptable performance. of a beam steering computer BSC, as is the gain of each
of the amplifiers 31, 34.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 50 The LNA, 31 outputs to a receive phase shifter 33,
Accordingly, it is an object of the invention to im which supplies a phase shifted output signal or pulse IQ
prove active antenna arrays; to an analog combining network 35. The amount of
It is another object of the invention to provide an phase shift is selected by the BSC 13 and is typically
improved guard technique for an active antenna array; applied through a series of phase increments, number
and 55 ing, for example, 32. The combining network 35 re
It is another object of the invention to eliminate ex ceives the outputs of each phase shifter 33 of all the
cessive nulls in guard arrays associated with an active other elements of the array and adds the RF signals
antenna array. together. The output voltage of the combining network
According to the invention, a guard pattern is formed 35 is mixed by respective mixers 37, 39 with a reference
using a small subarray of an active array. Nulls are oscillator signal at a reference frequency coef and the
eliminated by forming the small subarray into two quad same signal coefshifted in phase by 90 degrees, thereby
rant symmetric subarrays and placing a 90degree phase forming inphase and quadrature outputs I, Q. These
shift between the center phases of the two quadrant outputs I, Q are filtered by respective low pass filters 38,
symmetric subarrays. 40 and supplied to a main receiver and filter 41 which
As an example, one may take the guard array as a 65 outputs analog signals to first and second A/D convert
3x3 matrix of elements. Two quadrant symmetric ers 43, 44. Each A/D converter 43, 44 samples its input
guard subarrays are then formed: the four elements in to produce a succession of IQ samples xO(k) = x
the corners of the matrix comprise one guard subarray, r(k)jxo(k). Those skilled in the art will appreciate that
5,047,785
3 4
the digitized signal x0(k) represents a signal where a With the appropriate quadrant symmetry and center
relatively nonmoving target in the environment (zero phase difference having been set up, the entire nine
doppler) produces a DC signal. element guard array 11 is then scanned with the main
On the transmit side of the element MODn, the beam. Under the circumstances, guard nulls can only
power amplifier 34 is supplied with an input signal gen occur when both guard Subarrays have a null in the
erated as follows. A waveform generator 45 generates a same direction and at the same scan. This situation oc
waveform which is supplied to an exciter 47. The ex curs at only a small number of points, thus substantially
citer 47 supplies an RF signal synched to the reference eliminating problems caused by nulls discussed above.
oscillator frequency and outputs to a combiner 49. The It may be noted that all elements are effectively scanned
combiner 49 distributes low level RF energy to all the 10 simultaneously. Data is ordinarily not collected during
elements, including transmit phase shifter 51 and the element transition.
phase shifters of the other elements. The phase shifter A technical rationale for the elimination of nulls as
51 imparts a phase shift selected by the BSC 13 to its described may be set forth as follows. If the distribution
input signal and supplies the phase shifted signal to the of radiators, e.g., e1... e9 in an array such as that shown
input of the power amplifier 34. 15
in FIG. 2 has quadrant symmetry, then the phase of the
On transmission, an element MODn takes exciter resultant voltage is the same, independent of look and
power, amplifies it, shifts the phase, and then radiates. scan angles. Since each of the two guard subarrays of
On receive, the process is reversed. The received en array 11 has such quadrant symmetry, then one may be
ergy is amplified, phase shifted, then sent to the receiver taken as pure real and the other as pure imaginary (90
41. degree phase difference). Thus, the composite guard
FIG. 2 illustrates an example guard array 11, formed power, which is the sum of the real and imaginary com
as a Subarray containing elements e1, e2, e3, e4, e5, e6, e7, ponents squared, can only be zero if both guard subar
e8, eg of an active antenna array 13. In the context of rays have nulls.
guard nulls per se, the guard antenna could be located 25 Let ni and si be the respective unit vectors in the look
anywhere on the main array 13. However, to minimize and scan directions. Take a coordinate system such that
distortion of the main pattern formed from the remain the antenna lies in the xy plane with the z axis along
ing elements, the guard is typically at an edge of the mechanical boresight. Let n and s be the respective
array 13. The reason for such placement is that the main projections of ni and si onto the xy plane. The voltage
channel is typically amplitude weighted with low inten 30 V at a particular direction is given by the phase summa
sities at the edgethus, a disturbance here causes little tion over the antenna surface, incorporating the weights
problem. wk at position xk with wavelength A.
The elements e1, e2. . . eg of the guard array 11 shown
in FIG. 2 form a 3x3 square matrix. The 3x3 square
matrix is further subdivided into a first guard subarray 35
V(n  s) = wk exp2it j k . (n  s)/A (l)
containing the four corner guard array antenna ele
ments e1, e3, e7, e9 (shaded) and a second guard subarray Equation (1) can be rewritten in terms of its x and y
containing the remaining guard array antenna elements components as:
e2, e4, es, e6, e3. The Subarrays el . . . eg; e2 . . . e8 are
further given quadrant symmetry, i.e., the amplitude 40
weights wik associated with elements at Ex and tv
positions are identical, as discussed in mathematical
detail hereafter.
Further according to the preferred embodiment, a For the postulated quadrant symmetry, the weights wk
90degree phase shift or difference is placed between 45 are identical at tx and EV positions. Thus, the com
the center phases of the first and second subarrays e1, e3, plex exponentials can be turned into ordinary trig func
e7, eg; e2, e4, es, e6, es, respectively. The center phase is tions.
the effective phase at the geometrical center of the
subarray, even if no element exists there. The actual V(n  s) 4. i. wk cos(27 xk(n  Sr.)/A) (3)
element phases are set to values producing the desired SO
phase slope across the subarray.
The 90degree phase shift between the respective
center phases of the first and second arrays is achieved The k/4 in Equation (3) indicates a summation over
by putting unit real weights (w = 1) on one subarray and only the first quadrant (x20, y 20).
unit imaginary weights (w =j) on the other. Ordinarily, 55 If the weights in Equation (3) are real, then so is V for
there is a separate receiver for each of the main and all scan and look directions. This proves the claim that
guard arrays. Such a receiver may include a combiner quadrant symmetry implies phase invariant patterns.
such as combiner 35 for combining (adding) the re Hence, the two guard subarrays of array 11 each main
ceived guard array element voltage signals, as well as tain the phases of their respective pattern voltages,
receiver circuitry following the combiner, to IQ detect independent of scan and look angle changes. Because
the guard channel signal, as shown in FIG. 1. Before the these voltages are 90 degrees out of phase, one may be
voltages from the nine guard elements e1 . . . eg are considered pure real and the other pure imaginary.
added together by the combiner to form the guard sig Clearly, guard nulls occur only at simultaneous nulls of
nal, a 90degree phase shift is added to the voltage sig the Subarrays.
nal received by each of the elements of one subarray, 65 A great simplification occurs in the understanding
e.g., e1, e3, e7, eg, for example, by a microwave device and design of antenna patterns if one uses a cosine space
or by using element phase shifters such as the phase representation. This simply means that instead of di
shifter 33 of FIG, . rectly using look and scan angles, one uses the sine or
5
5,047,785
6
cosine of these angles. In fact, a cosine space representa That is, all the nulls and contours move in the direction
tion can be easily constructed by projecting unit vectors of the scan vector. It is assumed that the origin is kept
for the look and scan directions onto the xy plane. The fixed during the translation. Thus, since the visible part
vectors n and s of Equation (1) were devised precisely of cosine space is inside a unit circle around the origin,
for this purpose. which has not moved, then some points that were visi
The magnitudes of n and s are bounded by one. ble are now hidden, and some points which were hidden
Hence, the magnitude of their difference is bounded by are now visible. Furthermore, since the magnitude of
two. This means that cosine space only needs to be the scan vector is no greater than one, the only signifi
specified within a radius of two around the origin. cant part of hidden space is within a radius of two when
These ideas will become more apparent with some ex 10 the beam lies along mechanical boresight.
amples. As stated earlier, ordinarily, null planes are a problem
Referring to FIG. 3, consider the 3dB contour of an for a small discrete array. This is easily shown. Assume
unscanned pattern. It is a circle around the origin in for concreteness that the element spacing is W/2.
cosine space for a circularly symmetric antenna. This
circle is defined by the equation: 15
If the entire nineelement guard array were weighted
uniformly (w = 1), then from Equation (3) the un
V(n)= C3 (4) scanned voltage is:
This is understood to be the set of all points in cosine v (7)
space traced out by n such that Equation (4) is satisfied. 4.25 + .5 cos(7 n.) + .5 cos(at n) +
20
Here C3 is a constant equal to the 3dB pattern voltage. cos(at nx)cos(at n)
The V in Equation (4) is, of course, given by Equation (1 + 2 cos(Tn))(1 + 2 cos(at n)
(l). The vectors is zero in the unscanned case.
Now imagine that the beam is scanned away from the Clearly the V in Equation (7) is zero if either cosine.
origin by some scan vectors. From Equation (1), the 25 term is 0.5. Thus, the null planes within a twounit
3dB contour of the scanned pattern is given by: circle are given by:
V(ns)= Cs (5)
Since Equation (4) defined a circle around the origin in n2/3, E4/3
cosine space, then Equation (5) defines a circle centered
at the position of vector s. Thus, when a beam is 30 O
scanned, its cosine space projection is simply translated nyl2/3, E4/3 (8)
by the scan vector, as shown in FIG. 3.
Cosine space includes both visible and hidden space. The null planes depicted in Equation (8) are represented
The unit circle around the origin comprises visible by the dotted lines in FIG. 7.
space. Every point in visible space can be mapped back 35
FIG. 5 shows the weighting structure of the nineele
into a direction in normal threedimensional space by ment guard array 11. The real subarray is taken as the
simply drawing a line from the point parallel to the +z four corner elements e1, e3, e7, e9, with the rest as the
axis until it intersects a unit sphere centered at the ori imaginary array. Let the corresponding pattern volt
gin. The unit vector defined by a line drawn from the
origin to the intersection point on the sphere is the 40 ages be denoted by V and V. From Equation (3) these
corresponding direction vector in space. Conversely, voltages are given by:
each direction vector in threedimensional space maps V= 4 cos (Tn) cos (Tn)
into a point in visible cosine space, as illustrated in FIG.
4. The threespace components of the direction vector V/j= 1  2cos (Tnx)+cos (Tn)) (9)
ni are easily specified analytically in terms of the cosine 45
space projection vector D: The x and y components are The only way for simultaneous nulls to occur in both
the same; the z component follows easily by noting that V and V, is for either the x or y cosine term to be zero
ni has unit length. while the other one is 0.5. There are 24 solution
50
points, (ny, n), in the twounit circle of cosine space:
mix = mx (6)
(t1/2, E2/3), (t1/2, E4/3), (3/2, 2/3), (10)
niy = ny
(2/3, 1/2), (it 4/3, it 1/2), (2/3, 3/2)
niz = \d n  ny) 55
There is an alternate configuration of real and imagi
nary weights of the nineelement guard array 11 that
The spatial angle corresponding to the direction vector maintains separate symmetry of the real and imaginary
ni can be found by expressing ni in polar coordinates. subarrays. This second configuration is shown in FIG.
It should also be noted that this transformation from
cosine space to angles in threespace causes the beam to . 6.included
In this embodiment, the center element e5 is simply
with the four corner elements e1, e3, e7, e9. The
broaden asymmetrically with scans off boresight. Co corresponding subarray voltages are given by:
sine space, however, has undistorted beam contours.
All points in cosine space outside of the unit circle V. = 1 + 4 cos (Tn) cos (Tn)
form the socalled hidden space. Points in this part of
cosine space only impact threedimensional space if the 65 V/j=2 cos (arnx)+cos (arny)) (il)
beam is scanned. One may view the scanning process as
a translation of the entire cosine space, including the The only way for V and V, to be simultaneously
hidden part, by an amount given by the scan vector. zero is for either the x or y cosine term to be and the
5,047,785
7 8
other to be its negative. There are 24 solution points, subarray patterns are shown along with the composite
(nx, n), in the twounit circle of cosine space: to provide an indication of how the nulls are mutually
filled in. The remaining patterns are all from the pre
( 1/3, 2/3), (t1/3, 4/3), (5/3, 2/3), (10) ferred configuration of FIG. 5.
(2/3, 1/3), (it 4/3, it 1/3), (t2/3, it 5/3)
FIG. 10 is the unscanned 0degree cut for the config
uration of FIG. 5. It is comparable to FIG. 9, but just
The nulls for the first and second configurations of slightly better.
FIGS. 5 and 6 are plotted in FIG. 7 and represented by FIG. 11 shows a 45degree cut and 0degree scan
black squares and X's, respectively. For the nonscanned 10 angle. The main sidelobes are mostly covered in each.
beam, there are eight nulls visible for each configura Sometimes the nulls of the subarrays are close together
tion. However, the nulls for the configuration of FIG. 5 as in FIG. 11. However, the composite effect still elimi
are slightly farther away from the origin and, hence, nates the overall null.
may be less troublesome than those of the configuration In summary, the concept of two quadrant symmetric
shown in FIG. 6. This suggests that the configuration of 15 subarrays, 90 degrees out of phase with each other,
FIG. 5 is the proper weighting scheme to use. greatly alleviates the nulling problem. The preferred
The nulls in the hidden space annulus between radii 1. element configuration for a 3x3 matrix array, for exam
and 2 may shift in as the beam is scanned. With Configu ple, is the corner elements forming one subarray, and
ration 1, it appears that small scans have fewer nulls the remaining elements forming the other.
since those in visible space shift out before those in 20 Those skilled in the art will appreciate that element
hidden space come in. configurations other than a 3 X 3 matrix or square array
A comparison between the points and dotted lines in may be used to create a guard according to the princi
FIG. 7 shows the enhancement due to the technique of ples of the invention, for example, such as rectangular,
phase shifted subarrays. An infinite set of nulls has been circular, or oval, as long as such configurations provide
reduced to a few points. 25 quadrant symmetry. In general, those skilled in the art
The guard subarrays each have an infinite number of will appreciate that various adaptations and modifica
nulls. However, as demonstrated above, the composite tions of the justdescribed preferred embodiment can be
guard array 11 produces a pattern with a finite number configured without departing from the scope and spirit
of isolated nulls. This is clearly a vast improvement, but of the invention. Therefore, it is to be understood that,
it is not complete justification of the selected guard within the scope of the appended claims, the invention
array 11. may be practiced other than as specifically described
One must also compare the ability of the guard to herein.
cover the main and the sidelobes. FIGS. 8 through 11 What is claimed is:
illustrate various main and guard configurations with 1. A guard for an active antenna array, said array
electronic scanning. That is, both the main and guard 35 comprising a plurality of antenna elements, said guard
arrays are scanned in the same direction. The main comprising:
array is a 26inch square with 35dB circular Taylor a selected subarray of the elements of said antenna
(n = 4) amplitude weights. The element spacing was half array, the elements of said selected Subarray being
wavelength with A=0.1 ft. The total number of ele allocated to first and second guard Subarrays, each
ments was 1,892. In FIGS. 811, the main receive pat 40 of the first and second guard subarrays having a
tern is indicated by a solid line 201, the guard pattern by physical center, each element of each of said first
a uniform small dash pattern 203, the imaginary compo and second guard subarrays further having a phase
nent (j) by a dotdash pattern 205, and the real compo and a weight associated therewith, the weight
nent (i) by a larger dash pattern 207. being selected for application to the signal received
Two fundamental effects are investigated: possible by the respective element, the weights associated
degradation of the main pattern caused by removing the 45 with the elements of the first guard subarray being
nine elements forming the guard, and the proper side selected to exhibit quadrant symmetry with respect
lobe coverage of this new main by the coscanning to one another, the weights of the second guard
guard. Since the main array contains thousands of ele subarray being selected to exhibit quadrant symme
ments, its pattern suffers a negligible change. The pat 50 try with respect to one another; and
tern coverage issue requires more care. means for establishing a 90degree phase difference
As a check, a null was selected from FIG. 7 and a cut between the phase of the received signal at the
through the corresponding pattern was made. The point physical center of said first guard subarray and the
selected was (, ). The polar coordinates are computed phase of the received signal at the physical center
by noting that: 55 of said second guard subarray.
db=tan (ny/n) 2. The guard of claim 1 wherein said selected Subar
ray comprises a matrix of elements.
8=sin(V(n2+n)) (13) 3. The guard of claim 2 wherein said matrix is a .
square matrix.
Equation (13) implies that db = 36.87 degrees and 60 4. The guard of claim 1 wherein said selected subar
6=56.44 degrees. Thus, if a 36.87degree cut is taken, ray comprises a matrix of elements and said first guard
then the null should occur within this cut at 56.44 de Subarray comprises the corner elements of said square
grees off boresight, as shown in FIG.8. The null predic Subarray.
tion is satisfied. The 0degree reference is, of course, 5. The guard of claim 4 wherein said matrix is a
parallel to the side of the guard array 11 along the x axis. 65 square matrix.
FIG. 9 depicts an unscanned 0degree cut through 6. The guard of claim 2 wherein said matrix is a 3x3
the pattern produced by the configuration of FIG. 6. It Square matrix and wherein said first guard subarray
shows both the main and guard patterns. The guard comprises the four corner elements of said Square ma
5,047,785
10
trix and the second guard Subarray comprises the re 13. The method of claim 12 wherein said step of ap
maining elements. portioning comprises the step of selecting a matrix of
7. The guard of claim 2 wherein said matrix is a 3x3 elements to comprise said subarray.
square matrix and wherein said first guard subarray 14. The method of claim 12 wherein said step of es
comprises each corner element of said matrix and the tablishing comprises the step of shifting the phase of the
center element of said matrix and wherein said second respective signals received by each element of said first
guard subarray comprises the remaining elements of guard subarray by 90 degrees. 
said matrix. 15. The method of claim 13 wherein said step of es
8. The guard of claim 1 wherein said means for estab tablishing comprises the step of shifting the phase of the
lishing comprises phase shifter means for shifting the 10 respective signals received by each element of said first
guard subarray by 90 degrees.
phase of the signal received by each respective element 16. A method of generating a guard pattern for an
of said first guard subarray. active antenna array, said array comprising a plurality
9. The guard of claim 6 wherein said means for estab of elements, each said element including a means for
lishing comprises phase shifter means for shifting the 15 applying a weight to the received signal, said method
phase of the signal received by each respective element comprising the steps of:
of said first guard subarray. selecting a subset of the elements of said array to form
10. The guard of claim 7 wherein said means for a guard Subarray; and
establishing comprises phase shifter means for shifting allocating purely real weights to a first set of the
the phase of the signal received by each respective 20 elements of said guard subarray and purely imagi
element of said first guard subarray. nary weights to the elements of said guard subarray
11. The guard of claim 1 wherein said plurality of which are not members of said first set.
antenna elements is arrayed in a rectangular matrix, and 17. A guard for an active antenna array, said array
wherein said guard is disposed at the edge of said an comprising a plurality of antenna elements, said guard
tenna array. 25 comprising:
12. A method of generating a guard pattern for an a selected subarray of the elements of said antenna
active antenna array, said array comprising a plurality array, the elements of said selected subarray being
of antenna elements, said method comprising the steps allocated to first and second guard subarrays, each
of: of the first and second guard subarrays having a
apportioning a subarray of elements of said array into 30 physical center, each element of each of said first
first and second guard subarrays, each of the first and second guard subarrays further having a phase
and second guard Subarrays having a physical cen and a weight associated therewith, the weight
ter, each element of said first and second guard being Selected for application to the signal received
subarray further having a phase and a weight asso by the respective element, the weights associated
ciated therewith, the weight being applied to the 35 with the elements of the first guard subarray being
signal received by the respective element; selected to exhibit quadrant symmetry with respect
selecting the weights associated with the elements of to one another, the weights of the second guard
the first guard subarray to exhibit quadrant symme subarray being selected to exhibit quadrant symme
try with respect to one another; try with respect to one another; and
selecting the weights of the second guard subarray to
40 means for establishing a 90degree phase difference
exhibit quadrant symmetry with respect to one between the phase of the received signal at the
physical center of said first guard subarray and the
another; and phase of the received signal at the physical center
establishing a 90degree phase differential between of said second guard subarray; and
the phase of the received signal at the physical 45 means at each element for applying the respective
center of said first guard subarray and the phase of weight associated with that element to the signal
the received signal at the physical center of said received by thats element.
second guard subarray. s s k
50
55
. 60
65
UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION
PATENT NO. : 5,047,785
DATED : September 10, 1991
INVENTOR(S) : Michael D. Julian
it is certified that eror appears in the aboveidentified patent and that said Letters Patent is hereby
corrected as shown below:
Column 1, after the title and before the heading "BACKGROUND OF THE
INVENTION," insert the paragraph:  This invention was made with Government
support under Contract No. G3590KC1D awarded by the Government. The
Government has certain rights in this invention. 
Column 3, line 41, delete "v" and insert therefor  y .
Column 4, line 44, delete "v" and insert therefor  y .
Attest: (a team
BRUCELEHMAN