Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Frequency Perennial Streams Discharge Intermittent Streams or Lake Discharge Lagoons Discharge
Monthly Average 30 mg/L BOD5 2 or 25 mg/L CBOD5 3 20 mg/L BOD5 or 18 mg/L CBOD5 30 mg/L BOD5 or 25 mg/L CBOD5
Weekly Average 45 mg/L BOD5 or 40 mg/L CBOD5 30 mg/L BOD5 or 25 mg/L CBOD5 45 mg/L BOD5 or 40 mg/L CBOD5
% removal BOD5 or CBOD5 cannot be % removal BOD5 or CBOD5 cannot be % removal BOD5 or CBOD5
Monthly Average
less than 85% less than 85% cannot be less than 65%
Monthly Average 30 mg/L TSS 4 30 mg/L TSS 90 mg/L TSS
Weekly Average 45 mg/L TSS 45 mg/L TSS
Monthly Average % removal TSS cannot be less than 85% % removal TSS cannot be less than 85%
pH 6.5 – 9.0 s.u. 5 6.5 – 9.0 s.u. 6.5 – 9.0 s.u.
1
This table summarizes current treatment standards as of 9/12/2014; check with ODEQ for updates or more information.
2
BOD5 = 5-day Biochemical Oxygen Demand
3
CBOD5 = 5-day Carbonaceous Biochemical Oxygen Demand
4
TSS = Total Suspended Solids
5
s.u. = standard units
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 2-2 Permitted Uses of Reclaimed Water
Permitted Uses
Category 1
unrestricted
access golf courses
● Toilet and urinal flushing
● Fire protection systems
● Commercial closed-loop air conditioning systems
● Vehicle and equipment washing (excluding self-service car washes)
● Range cattle watering
1 1
2 2
3 3
4 4
5 5
6 6
7 7
8 8
9 9
10 10
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-1 Wastewater System Data Gathering To-Do List (Example)
N. Drew
Complete Wastewater System History (from Table B3.2) 10/1/2014
B. Lee
Locate Facilities Map (from Table B3.3) 10/1/2014
B. Lee
Gather Permits (from Table B3.4) 10/1/2014
N. Drew
Resolve Population Projections (from Table B3.5) 10/1/2014
N. Drew
Consider completing Historicalal Water Use (Table B3.6) 11/1/2015
H. Sparks
Compete Wastewater Flow Data (from Table B3.7) 11/1/2015
N. Drew
Gather influent information (Table B3.8) 11/1/2015
N. Drew
Gather WWTP Discharge Data (from Table B3.9) 11/1/2015
H. Sparks
Consider completing future flow projections (Table B3.10) 11/1/2015
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Okl
Table 3-2: Facility Map Actions Required
Attach documentation and/or identify below physical and/or electronic location of service area map(s) and facility diagram. Attach docume
Note: Check each box where statement is true. Note: Check each box w
Below
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-2: Facility Map Actions Required (Example)
Below is an example of a simplified system diagram and sample map of a service area.
MY SYSTEM DIAGRAM
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide O
Table 3-3 Wastewater System History
Year Built
Describe secondary or
advanced treatment.
1
Mechanical, lagoon, septic, land application 1
Mechanical, lagoon,
Note: Check each box where statement is true. Note: Check each box
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-3 Wastewater System History (Example)
Describe secondary or
advanced treatment.
Aeration basin followed by secondary clarification and UV disinfection
Locatio
System has discharge ✘
n
Discharges to Sugar Creek
Historical Upgrades Date Completed
Identify all upgrades to Mechanical bar screen added in between trash rack and aeration
treatment system and date 2005
basin
completed.
Switched from chlorine disinfection to UV disinfection 2004
1
Mechanical, lagoon, septic, land application
Note: Check each box where statement is true.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Planning Guide
Table 3-4: Permits
Permit Number: Please use a separate form for each permit. Permit Number:
Attach documentation and/or identify physical and/or electronic location of permit document(s) below. Attach documen
Documentation attached
Physical Location Electronic Location
City Hall, mayor
If the permit includes a schedule of use, enter information below. If the permit incl
2012
Describe below any changes in the treatment process that have influenced effluent water quality if applicable. Describe below
2005
2006
Describe below any changes in the influent strength or flows that have influenced the treatment process. Describe below
2010
Service area map(s) and facility diagram are attached.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Planning Guide
Table 3-4: Permits (Example)
Permit Number: 123456xx Please use a separate form for each permit.
Attach documentation and/or identify physical and/or electronic location of permit document(s) below.
✘ Documentation attached
Physical Location Electronic Location
City Hall, mayor's office – on the wall On City Manager's C-drive in the folder "WWTP" in the sub-
folder "Permits"
Describe below any changes in the treatment process that have influenced effluent water quality if applicable.
2005 Added new secondary clarifier and bar screen to improve solids removal.
Describe below any changes in the influent strength or flows that have influenced the treatment process.
2010 Influent BOD and TSS has increased, which has affected the influent quality.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-5: Historical Population
System Name
Population
Year Comments Data Source(s) 2
Served 1
Identify and describe below any significant events that have affected changes in area population.
Year Event
1
If population numbers are unavailable, estimate using number of connections times 2.5 persons.
2
Data sources may include the American Community Survey or other agency databases, published documents, etc
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-5: Historical Population (Example)
Population
Year Comments Data Source(s) 2
Served 1
Year Event
1
If population numbers are unavailable, estimate using number of connections times 2.5 persons.
2
Data sources may include the American Community Survey or other agency databases, published documents, etc
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklah
Table 3-6: Historical Wastewater Flow
Demand (mgd)
Period of Data
(beginning date Data Source(s)
30-day Moving
to end date) ADF 1 ADMM 3 MinD 4 MD 5
Average Flow 2
Identify and describe below any significant events that may have affected flow. Examples may include a new company, loss of a Identify and de
company or an existing company that begins to produce more (or less) wastewater, etc. a company or a
Year Event
1
Calculate the current average daily flow (ADF) using a minimum of 1 year (3 years of data is preferred). 1
Calculate the current av
2
Calculate a 30-day moving average flow (see Appendix A). 2
Calculate a 30-day movi
3
Calculate the average day maximum month (ADMM) flow by determining the 95th percentile of the 30-day moving average values (see Appendix A). 3
Calculate the average d
4
Calculate the minimum day (MinD) flow by determining the 5th percentile of the 30-day moving average values (see Appendix A). 4
Calculate the minimum d
5
Calculate the MD flow by multiplying a factor of 1.2 to 2.0 to the ADF (see Appendix A). 5
Calculate the MD flow b
State below any Information or assistance needed to finalize incomplete task(s).
Below is an example of a simplified system diagram and sample map of a service area.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-6: Historical Wastewater Flow (Example)
Demand (mgd)
Period of Data
(beginning date Data Source(s)
30-day Moving
to end date) ADF 1 ADMM 3 MinD 4 MD 5
Average Flow 2
Influent flow meter linked to
3/1998 to 3/2001 0.35mgd See Appendix A See Appendix ASee Appendix A
recorder
Identify and describe below any significant events that may have affected flow. Examples may include a new company, loss of
a company or an existing company that begins to produce more (or less) wastewater, etc.
Year Event
1
Calculate the current average daily flow (ADF) using a minimum of 1 year (3 years of data is preferred).
2
Calculate a 30-day moving average flow (see Appendix A).
3
Calculate the average day maximum month (ADMM) flow by determining the 95th percentile of the 30-day moving average values (see Appendix A).
4
Calculate the minimum day (MinD) flow by determining the 5th percentile of the 30-day moving average values (see Appendix A).
5
Calculate the MD flow by multiplying a factor of 1.2 to 2.0 to the ADF (see Appendix A).
Any Town Oklahoma (ATO)
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklahoma C
Table 3-7 (page 1 of 3): Historical Influent Wastewater Characterization Table 3-7 (pa
TP Historical Loading
Identify any significant changes that may have affected flow. (Examples may include a company that has begun to use more water,
addition of a new company, or loss of a company, etc.)
Year Event
1
Sources for concentrations may be obtained from monthly DMRs. 1
Sources for concentra
2
Calculate the Loading by Flow Type by multiplying the concentration by the corresponding flow type in Table 3-6. 2
Calculate the Loadin
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-7 (page 1 of 3): Historical Influent Wastewater Characterization (Example)
TP Historical Loading
Identify any significant changes that may have affected flow. (Examples may include a company that has begun to use more water,
addition of a new company, or loss of a company, etc.)
Year Event
1
Sources for concentrations may be obtained from monthly DMRs.
2
Calculate the Loading by Flow Type by multiplying the concentration by the corresponding flow type in Table 3-6.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide O
Table 3-8: Pretreatment
List significant industrial sources and attach wastewater service plan for each.
Service Plan
Industrial Sources
is attached
If the utility has a pretreatment program that is different than ODEQ's program, attach program documents and/or describe
below.
Documentation is attached.
Note: Check each box where statement is true. Note: Check each
State below any Information or assistance needed to finalize incom
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-8: Pretreatment (Example)
List significant industrial sources and attach wastewater service plan for each.
Service Plan is
Industrial Sources
attached
If the utility has a pretreatment program that is different than ODEQ's program, attach program documents and/or describe
below.
Documentation is attached.
System Name
Schematic is attached.
Level of Treatment:
If a storm management plan is required attach the plan documents or describe below.
Documentation is attached.
Level of Treatment:
If a storm management plan is required attach the plan documents or describe below.
✘ Documentation is attached.
List below the total linear footage of each wastewater collection pipeline by size. List below the total linear footag
4 or 6 inches 4 or 6 inches
8 inches 8 inches
10 inches 10 inches
12 inches 12 inches
18 inches 18 inches
24 inches 24 inches
30 inches 30 inches
36 inches 36 inches
42 inches 42 inches
48 inches 48 inches
60 inches 60 inches
other other
other other
List below the total linear footage of each wastewater collection pipeline by size.
Common normalized Total Linear Footage in Other pipe sizes not listed at
Total Linear Footage in System
pipe sizes System left (inches)
8 inches 10,000
10 inches 5,000
12 inches
18 inches
24 inches
30 inches
36 inches
42 inches
48 inches
60 inches
other
other
System Name
Period of Data
Permit
(beginning date Parameter Average Maximum Data Source(s)
Limit 1
to end date)
BOD5 (mg/L)
pH (s.u.)
TSS (mg/L)
Toal Coliform
(mg/L)
Chlorine (mg/L)
TKN (mg/L)
TP (mg/L)
Include any relevant notes, such as number of times discharge permit limit exceeded, anticipated permit limit changes, etc.
2
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-11: Historical Wastewater Effluent Characterization (Example)
Period of Data
Permit
(beginning date Parameter Average Maximum Data Source(s)
Limit 1
to end date)
Total Coliform
2005-2010 (mg/L)
Include any relevant notes, such as number of times discharge permit limit exceeded, anticipated permit limit changes, etc.
2
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 3-12: TMDL and/or Wasteload Allocations Future Limits
System Name
TSS 20
BOD 20
Phosphorus 5
Service area map(s) and facility diagram are attached.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-1: Asset Management: Inventory, Operation and Maintenance To-Do List
System Name
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-1: Asset Management: Inventory, Operation and Maintenance To-Do List (Example)
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 4-2: Flow Measurement / Metering
Primary Secondary
Type
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms i
2
Short-lived assets are those that need to be replaced in 5 years.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-2: Flow Measurement / Metering (Example)
Primary Secondary
1
Use additional forms if necessary.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 4-3: Influent Pumps
Facility type
Number of pumps
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
Instrumentation type
Number of pumps 1
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Horsepower 160
No
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide O
Table 4-4: Screenings Removal System
System System
Name Name
Date of assessment (mm/dd/yyyy)
SYSTE
M
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Mechanical / Manual?
Manufacturer
Model Number
Drive Mechanism
Number of screens
Screenings conveyor
Screenings storage
SYSTEM
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of screens 2
No
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide O
Table 4-5: Grit Removal System
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Manufacturer
Capacity
Number of Units
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Specifications Volts
Speed (rpm)
Number of Units
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-5: Grit Removal System (Example)
SYSTEM
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Capacity 0.5
PUMP
Number of Units 1
Horsepower 5
MOTOR
Number of Units 1
Horsepower 5
1
Use additional forms if necessary.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Okla
Table 4-6 (page 1 of 2): Wastewater Tanks
Purpose
Identification
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of Tanks
Type of tank2
f RECTANGULAR, Length,
Width,
If ROUND, Diameter
& Height.
Number of inlets
Type of inlet
(90° upturned flare, submerged side inlet, etc.)
Number of outlets
Additional manway(s)
Type of discharge
Identification
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 U
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms if n
2
Including clear wells and storage tanks in distribution. (Coated concrete, steel, etc.) 2
Including clear wells and
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-6 (page 1 of 2): Wastewater Tanks
STRUCTURE
Identification Aeration
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of Tanks 2
f RECTANGULAR, Length, 40
Width, 20
If ROUND, Diameter 65
& Height. 24
Number of inlets 1
Type of inlet
(90° upturned flare, submerged side inlet, etc.) submerged submerged
Number of outlets 1
Additional manway(s) 1 1
CONTROL
Identification SCADA
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Instrumentation Type (level sensor, altitude valve, etc.) Level sensor Level sensor
controlled by controlled by
Tank level control strategy
SCADA SCADA
Use numbered columns for each separate unit2 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of Tanks
If RECTANGULAR, Length,
Width,
If ROUND, Diameter
& Height
Additional manway(s)
Number of Units
Horsepower
Specifications Volts
Speed (rpm)
Instrumentation Type
1
Use additional forms if necessary.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-7 (page 1 of 2): Primary Clarification
System
Name Any Oklahoma Wastewater Treatment Facility
STRUCTURE
If RECTANGULAR, Length,
Width,
& Height 15
Additional manway(s) no
Number of Units 1
Horsepower 1
Speed (rpm) 1
CONTROL
Use numbered columns for each separate unit2 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Valves open
close using
programmed
Tank level control strategy
sequencing
controlled by
SCADA
1
Use additional forms if necessary.
Guide
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Okl
Table 4-8: Primary Sludge Pumps
Facility type
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of pumps
Type of pump
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Specifications Volts
Speed (rpm)
Number of units
Instrumentation type
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
PUMPS
Number of pumps 1
Horsepower 5
CONTROL
Number of units 1
Number of Units
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Type
Length
Height
Number of Units
Type
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-9: Secondary Treatment System - Suspended Growth (Example)
System
Name Any Town, Oklahoma (ATO)
SYSTEM
Number of Units 1
Type SBR
Length 20
Height 15
BLOWERS / AERATORS
Number of Units 2
Type PD
Horsepower 6
Number of Units
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Type
Length
Height
HRT (hours)
Number of Units
Type
Capacity (scfm)
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms i
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-10: Secondary Treatment System - Attached Growth (Example)
SYSTEM
Number of Units 2
Type RBC
Length 50
Height 10
HRT (hours) 6
BLOWERS / AERATORS
Number of Units 2
Type PD
Horsepower 5
Number of Units
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Type
Length
Depth
HRT (hours)
Number of Units
Type
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
SYSTEM
Number of Units 2
Length 100
Depth 15
HRT (hours) 6
AERATORS
Number of Units 4
Type floating
Horsepower 5
Number of Units
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Identification/Type
Length
Dimensions Width
Height
HRT (hours)
Number of Units
Type
Capacity (scfm)
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
System Name
SYSTEM
Number of Units
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Identification/Type
Length
Dimensions Width
Height
HRT (hours)
BLOWERS / AERATORS
Number of Units
Type
Capacity (scfm)
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
Number of Trains
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
DISINFECTION
Number of Trains 1
Number of Trains
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
DECHLORINATION
Number of Trains 1
Number of Reactors
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Length
Reactor Chamber
Width
Dimensions (feet)
Depth
Ballast Type2
Instrumentation Type
Reactor housing
MP lamps
Sleeve
UVT analyzer
SYSTEM
Number of Reactors 2
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1
Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Length 10
Reactor Chamber
Dimensions (feet)
Width 3
Depth 3
Number of Lamps per Reactor 100
Type of Lamp Used (magnetic, electronic) Medium pressure
Number of Ballasts per Reactor 3
Ballast Type 2
electronic
Cleaning System Type mechanical
intensity is
Description of Control Strategy measured by PLC
display
Reactor housing 10
Low-pressure lamps (LP and LPHO) 3
MP lamps 2
Sleeve 5
Duty and reference UV sensors 5
UVT analyzer 5
Perceived condition (Poor, Fair, Good, Excellent) fair
1
Use additional forms if necessary.
2
Low pressure (LP), low pressure high output (LPHO), medium pressure, etc
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide O
Table 4-16 (Page 1 of 4): Membrane Clarification (MBR)
Length
Height
Process description
Membrane identification
Number of pumps
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
Number of filters
Filter type
Type(s) of media
Number of blowers
Type of blower
Type of compressor
Cleaning substances
Cleaning solution
pH range
Temperature range
Additional notes
Heats of dilution
ACID CIP
Type
Concentrate
Delivery options
Concentrate
Delivery options
Number of tanks
Type of tank
Tank material
Diameter
Tank Dimensions (feet)
Height
Tank volume
Assumed freeboard
Other outlets
Heater capacity
Configuration
Heating time
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Type
Pump horsepower
Motor horsepower
Volts
Hertz
Assumed efficiency
Materials of construction
Suction connection
Discharge connection
System Name
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Length
Height
Process description
Membrane identification
Number of pumps
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
FILTERS
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of filters
Filter type
Type(s) of media
Number of blowers
Type of blower
Type of compressor
Cleaning substances
Cleaning solution
pH range
Temperature range
Additional notes
Heats of dilution
ACID CIP
Type
Concentrate
Delivery options
Sample
Minimum pH of cleaning solution
Concentrate Only
Delivery options
CIP TANKS
Number of tanks
Type of tank
Tank material
Diameter
Tank Dimensions (feet)
Height
Tank volume
Assumed freeboard
Other outlets
Heater capacity
Configuration
Heating time
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Type
Pump horsepower
Motor horsepower
Volts
Hertz
Assumed efficiency
Materials of construction
Suction connection
Discharge connection
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Facility name
Type of filter
Length
Height
Filter media
Underdrain
Number of blowers
Type of blower
Capacity
Discharge pressure
Motor horsepower
Volts
Hertz
System Name
Use numbered columns for each separate unit 1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Facility name
Type of filter
Height
Filter media
Underdrain
Number of blowers
Type of blower
Capacity
Discharge pressure
Motor horsepower
Volts
Hertz
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 4-18 (Page 1 of 2): Solids Thickening - Aerobic Digestion Facilities
System System
Name Name
Date of assessment (mm/dd/yyyy)
Use numbered columns for each separate unit Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Type1
Number of units
Diameter (feet)
Number of units
BOTTOM PUMP OR SLUDGE FEED PUMP Short-lived asset? Yes No BOTTOM PUM
Number of units
Type
Use numbered columns for each separate unit Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of units
Type
Sludge concentration
Number of units
1
DAF/Gravity Thickener/Gravity Belt Thickener/Rotary Drum Thickener, etc 1
DAF/Gravity Thickener
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-18 (Page 1 of 2): Solids Thickening - Aerobic Digestion Facilities
System
Name Any Town, Oklahoma (ATO)
Use numbered columns for each separate unit Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of units 2
Diameter (feet) 20
PUMP(S)
Number of units 3
Number of units 3
Type Centrifugal
Use numbered columns for each separate unit Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of units 2
Type PD
Sludge concentration 10
COMPRESSOR(S)
Number of units 2
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of units
Volume (gal.)
Number of units
Type
Number of units
Type
Number of units
Type
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
ANAEROBIC DIGESTER(S)
Number of units 1
RECIRCULATION PUMP(S)
Number of units 3
Type Centrifugal
Number of units 1
Type Flare
Number of units 3
Type Centrifugal
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-20: Dewatering / Disposal Methods
Use numbered columns for each separate unit3 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
DEWATERING PROCESS
FINAL DISPOSAL
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of Units
Type2
Manufacturer
Model No.
Size
Number of Tanks
Pump Type
Model No.
Horsepower
Capacity (gpm)
Pump Type
Model
Horsepower
Capacity (gpm)
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms
2
Scrubbers, biofilters, etc. 2
Scrubbers, biofilters,
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-21 (Page 1 of 2): Odor Control (Example)
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of Units 1
Type 2
Scrubber
Size 200
Chemical Storage/Strength
Number of Tanks 2
Recirculation
Horsepower 1
Chemical Metering
Model abc 12
Horsepower 1
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Number of pumps
Manufacturer
Horsepower
Speed (rpm)
Instrumentation type
1
Use additional forms if necessary. 1
Use additional forms
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-22: Pump(s) (Example)
System
Name Any Town, Oklahoma (ATO)
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
EQUIPMENT
Number of pumps 3
Horsepower 5
PUMP CONTROL
Use numbered columns for each separate unit1 Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3
Pipe material
PIPELINES
System Name
1
Authority's Cash, Bond Issue, Rate Increase, Bank Loan, CWSRF Low-Interest Loan, other
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-25: Items to be Replaced in 5 Years (Example)
System Name
1
Authority's Cash, Bond Issue, Rate Increase, Bank Loan, CWSRF Low-Interest Loan, other
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-26: Facility Staffing Data
System Name
Existing
Population Staffing
Facility Name Staffing Meets
Served Requirements
Requirements
System Name
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
1
Cross check the operator licensure level with the facility classification.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-27 Personnel Data (Example)
Day 555.555.5555
A. Cordes City Manager acordes@ato.com
Night
Day 555.555.5555
H. Jackson City Planner hjackson@ato.com
Night 555.555.4444
Day 555.555.5555
M. Daniels City Engineer mdaniels@ato.com
Night 555.555.4444
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
1
Cross check the operator licensure level with the facility classification.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-28: Routine Operation and Preventative Maintenance Program
System Name
Attach documentation and/or describe routine operation and preventative maintenance programs.
Documentation is attached.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-28: Routine Operation and Preventative Maintenance Program (Example)
Attach documentation and/or describe routine operation and preventative maintenance programs.
Documentation is attached.
ATO WWTP serves a population of 2,150. The system's capacity and staffing are adequate at present with system repairs
and upgrades performed as needed and personnel certfication maintained. The system is an activated sludge wastewater
treatment plant that consists of screening, grit removal, sedimentation, aeration, and disinfection. The system has five
wastewater pump stations, one of them is an influent triplex pump station and the remaining four are duplex pump stations.
All periodic observations, adjustments, and repairs are documented and available for reference and/or review to ensure
system operational dependability and personnel accountability.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-29: Routine and Preventative Maintenance Data
System Name
Function Frequency
1
Such as adjusting flow control valves, reading flow meters, checking water or chemical levels, exercising critical valves, lubricating equipment, etc.
2
Daily, weekly, monthly, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-29: Routine and Preventative Maintenance Data (Example)
Function Frequency
Check All process units and read flow meters Three times daily
1
Such as adjusting flow control valves, reading flow meters, checking water or chemical levels, exercising critical valves, lubricating equipment, etc.
2
Daily, weekly, monthly, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-30: Normal Operational Data Tips and Tricks
System Name
Element Setting
List below items which require specific settings1 Enter setting values or specific instructions including units below2
1
Such as valve, switch, control, etc.
2
Such as valve position, readings for pump controls, gauges, electrical switches, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-30: Normal Operational Data Tips and Tricks (Example)
Element Setting
List below items which require specific settings1 Enter setting values or specific instructions including units below2
Valve 1 going to Clarifier 1 Valve is set at 75% open to achieve even flow split between Clarifier 1 & 2
MLSS (Mixed Liquor suspended solids) MLSS at aeration basin of 3500 mg/L
1
Such as valve, switch, control, etc.
2
Such as valve position, readings for pump controls, gauges, electrical switches, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-31: Suppliers
System Name
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 4-31: Suppliers (Example)
jbrown@abcchemical.com Day
Polymer (Sludge) ABC Chemical Company
abcchemical .com Night
ron.white@xyzpumps.com Day
Pumps, Parts/Repair XYZ Pumps
xyzpumps.com Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Day
Night
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-1: Wastewater System Management To-Do List
System Name
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-1: Wastewater System Management To-Do List (Example)
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 5-2: (page 1 of 4) Wastewater System Administration
Water/Wastewater Association
Local government
Corporation
Partnership
If there are written system rules, attach document or identify physical and/or electronic location of information below.
3
Documentation is attached.
Physical Location Electronic Location
Identify and check below who makes major decisions for the system (such as when to make capital improvements, how to
4
finance improvements, when to expand/consolidate, etc.).
BOARD Length of
Selected by:
Number of members: service (years):
COMMISSION Length of
Selected by:
Number of members: service (years):
State below any other decision-making individuals or parties not listed above and describe association with organization.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 5-2: (page 2 of 4) Wastewater System Administration
5 How often do those responsible for decision making meet?
Monthly
Annually
6 If all system users are notified about these meetings, identify the notification process (check all that apply).
Notice on water bill.
8 If water/wastewater bills are not mailed, describe below the notification process and frequency.
9 What is the plan for financing future system improvements (check all that apply)?
Reserve account(s)
Loans
Grants
Plan in Case of Operator Loss: If the system has an operator, and there is a plan in place in the event of operator loss,
11
describe the process and attach or identify physical and/or electronic location of information below.
Documentation is attached.
Customer Complaints Process: If there is a process to record and respond to customer complaints, describe the process
12
and attach or identify physical and/or electronic location of information below.
Documentation is attached.
13 Insurance Policies: If the system has insurance policies, check all that apply and list coverage amounts:
Automobile Liability
Garage Liability
Excess/Umbrella Liability
Flood Liability
Attach documentation or identify physical and/or electronic location of policy information below.
Documentation is attached.
Safety Procedures: If the system has written safety procedures, describe the process and attach or identify physical and/or
14
electronic location of information below.
Documentation is attached.
Financial Transaction Personnel: Identify and list below the person/party responsible for conducting financial transactions
15
(maintaining records, customer billings, making debt payments, etc.)
Water/Wastewater Association
Corporation
Partnership
If there are written system rules, attach document or identify physical and/or electronic location of information below.
3
✘ Documentation is attached.
Physical Location Electronic Location
File cabinet in City Manager's office. City Manager's computer hard drive, C:\ATO Rules
Identify and check below who makes major decisions for the system (such as when to make capital improvements, how to
4
finance improvements, when to expand/consolidate, etc.).
✘ BOARD Length of
Number of members: 5 service (years): 2 Selected by: City Manager and Mayor
COMMISSION Length of
Selected by:
Number of members: service (years):
✘ State below any other decision-making individuals or parties not listed above and describe association with organization.
WWTP Manager - technical input.
✘ Monthly
Annually
6 If all system users are notified about these meetings, identify the notification process (check all that apply).
✘ Notice on water bill.
8 If water/wastewater bills are not mailed, describe below the notification process and frequency.
N/A
9 What is the plan for financing future system improvements (check all that apply)?
✘ Reserve account(s)
Loans
✘ Grants
Plan in Case of Operator Loss: If the system has an operator, and there is a plan in place in the event of operator loss,
11
describe the process and attach or identify physical and/or electronic location of information below.
Documentation is attached.
Policy Manual for City employees.
Customer Complaints Process: If there is a process to record and respond to customer complaints, describe the process
12
and attach or identify physical and/or electronic location of information below.
✘ Documentation is attached.
13 Insurance Policies: If the system has insurance policies, check all that apply and list coverage amounts:
Garage Liability
Excess/Umbrella Liability
Flood Liability
Attach documentation or identify physical and/or electronic location of policy information below.
Documentation is attached.
Safety Procedures: If the system has written safety procedures, describe the process and attach or identify physical and/or
14
electronic location of information below.
✘ Documentation is attached.
Basic safety, no confined space entry, accident prevention, lock-out/tag out.
Financial Transaction Personnel: Identify and list below the person/party responsible for conducting financial transactions
15
(maintaining records, customer billings, making debt payments, etc.)
Attached documentation used to develop tables or identify physical and/or electronic location of information here.
Note: Check each box where statement is true. Note: Check each box w
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-3: System Management Checklist (Example)
✘ Attached documentation used to develop tables or identify physical and/or electronic location of information here.
Continue to identify and consider any potential changes that may benefit system management.
All customers are charged the same amount regardless of their water usage or wastewater generated. The
Flat Rate flat (or fixed) rate may be used in systems that do not meter water usage and may also be used in conjunction
with other rate structures to cover administrtive costs and customer expenses.
All customers are charged the same amount per water usage (typically 1,000 gallons). The uniform rate
Uniform Rate
requires metering, allowing customers to pay for their individual usage .
A surcharge is assessed on the quantity of extra strength waste being treated that exceeds residential
Surcharge
strength waste. The surcharge is usually assessed by the pound.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Okl
Table 5-5: Rate Schedule Information
Attach the system's rate schedule document or identify physical and/or electronic location below.
Documentation is attached.
List below the distribution of monthly billable gallons by customer type. List below the
Customer Type No. of Customers Billable Gallons Customer Type No. of Customers Billable Gallons
Describe the System's policy for changing wastewater rates. Select one of the options below. Describe the S
A vote is not required to change rates. Describe below the process for changing rates
If there a maximum monthly quantity billed to residential wastewater customers, show the quantity? gals. If there a maxim
If a percent of water used by residential customers determines wastewater volume charges, show the percentage? % If a percent of
Metered - Describe the metering process. Non-Metered - Describe water usage determination (billing) process.
Note: Check each box where statement is true. Note: Check each box w
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-5: Rate Schedule Information (Example)
Attach the system's rate schedule document or identify physical and/or electronic location below.
Documentation is attached.
Customer Type No. of Customers Billable Gallons Customer Type No. of Customers Billable Gallons
Residential 800 565,000
Commercial 20 150,000
industrial 1 25,000
Describe the System's policy for changing wastewater rates. Select one of the options below.
A vote is not required to change rates. Describe below the process for changing rates
If there a maximum monthly quantity billed to residential wastewater customers, show the quantity? 3,000 gals.
If a percent of water used by residential customers determines wastewater volume charges, show the percentage? 8.0 %
Describe below the customer billing process.
Metered - Describe the metering process. Non-Metered - Describe water usage determination (billing) process.
Residential meters (water) read manually monthly, large City ordinance for six customers without meters. Ordinance
commercial users have remote metering. sets monthly rate.
System Name
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-6: Existing Debt (Example)
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
$ $ % $
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-7: Funded System Improvement Projects
System Name
Potential
Asset/Project Name Expected Year Project Description or Purpose Cost Estimate
Funding Source1
System Name
Expected Potential
Asset/Project Name Project Description or Purpose Cost Estimate
Year Funding Source1
Potential
Project Name Project Description or Purpose Cost Estimate
Funding Source
System Name
Expected Potential
Asset/Project Name Project Description or Purpose Cost Estimate
Year Funding Source1
Grant/Assess
Aeration Basin 2015 Expansion of aeration basin $ 2000000
surcharge
$ $
$ $
$ $
$ $
$ $
$
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-11: Operational Budget
F Debt payments $ $ $ $ $ F
40,000
Expenses
1. Grants $ $ $ $ $
2. Reserves $ $ $ $ $
B
3. Loans/Bonds $ $ $ $ $
4. User Charges $ $ $ $ $
CIP Total [A –
C $ $ $ $ $
(B1+B2+B3+B4)]
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklaho
Table 5-12: Operational Costs and Budgets Information Checklist Tab
Used EPA's Setting Small Drinking Water System Rates for a Sustainable Future document in this process.
Attached documentation used to develop tables or have identified physical and/or electronic location of information
Note: Check each box where statement is true. Note: Check each box where
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 5-12: Operational Costs and Budgets Information Checklist (Example)
✘ Used EPA's Setting Small Drinking Water System Rates for a Sustainable Future document in this process.
✘ Attached documentation used to develop tables or have identified physical and/or electronic location of information
System Name
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-1: Projected Wastewater Needs To-Do List (Example)
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 6-2: Population Projections
System Name System Name
List selected population projections below for the system service area.
Projected Population
Planning Source for
A Comments
Year Population Projections1
Population
Not Served by System
Served by System
1
U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey, 2012 Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan Update, etc. 1
U.S. Census Bureau's
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-2: Population Projections (Example)
System Name Any Town Oklahoma
List selected population projections below for the system service area.
Projected Population
Planning Source for
A Comments
Year Population Projections1
Population
Not Served by System
Served by System
2015 2,268
2020 2,393
2025 2,525
2030 2,663
2035 2,810
2040 2,965
2045 3,128
2050 3,300
1
U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey, 2012 Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan Update, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Okla
Table 6-3a: Historical Wastewater Flow and Per Capita Flow Computation Table
Selected Historical Inf. Wastewater ADF per capita (mgd)3 > < Enter this value in Table 6-3b, Column B Selected Inf. W
1
To calculate per capita wastewater flow, divide the historical influent wastewater flow by the corresponding population. Example, using a population of 3,000 1
To calculate per capita w
and a corresponding historical wastewater ADF of 1.0 mgd, the per capita wastewater flow is 0.003 mgd per capita or 333 gpcd (or 1,000,000 gpd/3,000 3,000 and a correspondi
people = 333 gpcd). gpd/3,000 people = 333
2
Sources for average daily flows may be found in Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.) 2
Sources for average da
3
Select per capita wastewater flow data for use in calculating annual wastewater flow projections in Table 6-3b. 3
Select per capita waste
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3a: Historicalal Wastewater Flow and Per Capita Flow Computation (Example)
Selected Inf. Wastewater ADF per capita (mgd) 2 > 0.00031 < Enter this value in Table 6-3b, Column B
1To calculate per capita wastewater flow, divide the Historicalal influent wastewater flow by the corresponding population. Example, using a population of
2,150 and a corresponding Historicalal wastewater ADF of 0.669 mgd, the per capita wastewater flow is 0.00031 mgd per capita.
2 Select per capita wastewater flow data for use in calculating annual wastewater flow projections in Table 6-3b.
3 Sources for average daily flows may be found in Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.)
.242/1590
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3a: Historical Wastewater Flow and Per Capita Flow Computation (Example)
Selected Inf. Wastewater ADF per capita (mgd) 2 > 0.00031 < Enter this value in Table 6-3b, Column B
1
To calculate per capita wastewater flow, divide the historical influent wastewater flow by the corresponding population. Example, using a population of
3,000 and a corresponding historical wastewater ADF of 1.0 mgd, the per capita wastewater flow is 0.003 mgd per capita or 333 gpcd (or 1,000,000
gpd/3,000 people = 333 gpcd).
2
Sources for average daily flows may be found in Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.)
3
Select per capita wastewater flow data for use in calculating annual wastewater flow projections in Table 6-3b.
.242/1590
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3b: Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Per Capita Information
System Name
Table 6-3b Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Per Capita Information
Note: Use separate copies of this table for each year of wastewater flow projection planning using land use information. Note: Use sep
Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Land Use Information Influent Waste
Typical
Number in
Units per Wastewater Projected Influent
Category Description Service Unit Total Units Data Source(s) 2
Category Flow per Unit Wastewater ADF (gpd)4
Area
(gpd)1
Residential Housing, single
Persons 55
family
Residential Housing, apartment Persons 40
Office Employee 5
Hotel Guest 50
Hotel Employee 10
Parking
Shopping Center 2
Space
Shopping Center Employee 10
< gpd
Planning Year > Projected Total
< mgd3
1
Typical values taken from Wastewater Engineering, Treatment Disposal Reuse published by Metcalf & Eddy. Local wastewater flows should be used if available. 1
Typical values taken fro
2
Sources for per capita information (e.g., Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.): 2
Sources for per capita in
3
Record each planning year's resulting mgd value in "Table 6-3c-1: Summary of Influent Wastewater Flow Projections Using Land Use Information" 3
Record each planning y
4
Total units x Typical wastewater flow per unit 4
Total units x Typical was
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3c: Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Land Use Information (Example)
System Name Any Town Oklahoma
Note: Use separate copies of this table for each year of wastewater flow projection planning using land use information.
Typical
Number in Projected Influent
Units per Wastewater
Category Description Service Unit Total Units Wastewater ADF Data Source(s) 2
Category Flow per Unit1
Area (gpd)4
(gpd)
Residential Housing, single
family 800 Persons 2.5 2,000 55 110,000
Residential Housing, apartment 25 Persons 25 625 40 25,000
Office 20 Employee 5 100 5 500
Restaurant (including toilet) 6 Customer 300 1,800 9 16,200
Hotel 2 Guest 65 130 50 6,500
Hotel 2 Employee 12 24 10 240
Parking
Shopping Center 1 Space 200 200 2 400
Shopping Center 1 Employee 25 25 10 250
Theater, indoor 0 Seat 0 0 3 0
Hospital, medical 1 Bed 50 50 150 7,500
Hospital, medical 1 Employee 25 25 10 250
Rest Home 2 Resident 125 250 90 22,500
Rest Home 2 Employee 40 80 10 800
School, day, with cafeteria, gym
and showers
Student 400 400 25
1 10,000
School, day, with cafeteria 3 Student 150 450 15 6,750
Projected Influent
Planning
Wastewater ADF Notes
Year
(mgd) 1
1
From Table 6-3c for each planning year. 1
From Table 6-3c for each
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3c-1: Summary of Influent Wastewater Flow Projections Using Land Use Information (Example)
System Name Any Town Oklahoma
Summary of Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Land Use Information
Projected Influent
Planning
Wastewater ADF Notes
Year
(mgd) 1
2011 0.20690
1
From Table 6-3c for each planning year.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Okl
Table 6-3d: Monthly Distribution of Drinking Water Usage
Note: Use separate copies of this table for each year of monthly distribution pattern calculating . Note: Use sep
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Total Annual Usage (mgd)
< Total of Distribution Pattern should sum to 1.00
>
Year of Record > < Minimum Monthly Distributation Pattern 4
1
Information may be taken from metered results or water treatment plant production values. 1
Information may be tak
2
To calculate the monthly distribution pattern, divide the monthly usage by the total annual usage. Note: the sum of the monthly distribution pattern values 2
To calculate the month
should sum to 1 (one). should sum to 1 (one).
3
Sources for drinking water demand information include 2012 OCWP Update, City’s Master Plan, etc. 3
Sources for drinking wa
4
Enter each planning year's Minimum Mohthly Distribution Pattern on Form 6-3e. 4
Enter each planning ye
Note: this method of flow projection is least preferred of the three methods presented. If possible, use one of the previous methods Note: this method of flow
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3d: Monthly Distribution of Drinking Water Usage (Example)
Note: Use separate copies of this table for each year of monthly distribution pattern calculating .
Total Annual Usage > 0.699 1.000 < Total of Distribution Pattern should sum to 1.00
Year of Record > 2011 0.064 < Minimum Monthly Distributation Pattern 4
1
Information may be taken from metered results or water treatment plant production values.
2
To calculate the monthly distribution pattern, divide the monthly usage by the total annual usage. Note: the sum of the monthly distribution pattern values
should sum to 1 (one).
3
Sources for drinking water demand information include 2012 OCWP Update, City’s Master Plan, etc.
4
Enter each planning year's Minimum Mohthly Distribution Pattern on Form 6-3e.
Note: this method of flow projection is least preferred of the three methods presented. If possible, use one of the previous methods
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 6-3e: Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Drinking Water Demand Information Table 6-3e: In
Planning Drinking Water Minimum Monthly Ratio of Return Flow Projected Influent
Year Demand (mgd) 1 Distribution Pattern 2 to Demand 3 Wastewater ADF (mgd) 4
1
Use drinking water demand projections. Sources for this information include the 2012 OCWP Update. 1
Use drinking water de
2
Use the minimum monthly distribution pattern value from Table 6-3d. 2
Use the minimum mo
3 This ratio of return flow (or flow returned to the system as wastewater) to demand may be based on Historicalal information. The 2012 OCWP Update used a 3 This ratio of return flo
95 percent ratio of return flow to minimum monthly municipal and industrial water demand. used a 95 percent ratio
4
To calculate the influent wastewater, multiply the drinking water demand by the minimum monthly distribution value by the ratio of return flow to demand. 4
To calculate the influe
Example: if the drinking water demand is 1.0 mgd, the minimum monthly distribution value is 0.05, and the ratio of return flow to demand is 0.95, the
projected wastewater flow is 0.048 mgd (1.0 * 0.05 * 0.95 = 0.048).
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-3e: Influent Wastewater Flow Projections using Drinking Water Demand Information (Example)
Planning Drinking Water Minimum Monthly Ratio of Return Flow Projected Influent
Year Demand (mgd) 1 Distribution Pattern 2 to Demand 3 Wastewater ADF (mgd) 4
1
Use drinking water demand projections. Sources for this information include the 2012 OCWP Update.
2
Use the minimum monthly distribution pattern value from Table 6-3d.
3 This ratio of return flow (or flow returned to the system as wastewater) to demand may be based on Historicalal information. The 2012 OCWP Update
used a 95 percent ratio of return flow to minimum monthly municipal and industrial water demand.
4
To calculate the influent wastewater, multiply the drinking water demand by the minimum monthly distribution value by the ratio of return flow to demand.
Example: if the drinking water demand is 1.0 mgd, the minimum monthly distribution value is 0.05, and the ratio of return flow to demand is 0.95, the
projected wastewater flow is 0.048 mgd (1.0 * 0.05 * 0.95 = 0.048).
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklahom
Table 6-4a: Wastewater Load Projections - Historical Mass Loads Table
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
1
Record this information from Table 3-5 ADF: Average daily flow MinD: Minimum day flow 1
Record this information from Table 3-5
2
Record this information from Table 3-6 30-Day: 30-Day Moving Average Flow MD: Maximum day 2
Record this information from Table 3-6
3
Record this information from Table 3-7 ADMM: Average day maximum month 3
Record this information from Table 3-7
Note: Sources for per capita information include Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc. Note: Sources for per capita information in
More information on calculating the requested information can be found in Section 3 and Appendix B of this guide.
MinD – Minimum day conditions, based on 5th percentile value of 3 year Historical record
ADF – Average day conditions, based on average value of 3 year Historical record
ADMM – Average day maximum month (or maximum month) conditions, based on 95th percentile of 30-day moving
average over 3 year Historical record
MD – Maximum day conditions, based on 95th percentile value of 3 year Historical record
Inf – Influent wastewater flow conditions
BOD – Biological oxygen demand
TSS – Total suspended solids
TP – Total phosphorus
TKN – Total Kjeldahl nitrogen
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-4a: Wastewater Load Projections - Historical Mass Loads (Example)
1990 1820
2000 2030
2010 2150
1990 1820
2000 2030
2010 2150
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
1
Record this information from Table 3-5 ADF: Average daily flow MinD: Minimum day flow
2
Record this information from Table 3-6 30-Day: 30-Day Moving Average Flow MD: Maximum day
3
Record this information from Table 3-7 ADMM: Average day maximum month
Note: Sources for per capita information include Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.
gomills: Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklahoma Com
If this tableTable
appears to be
6-4b: Wastewater Load Projections - Historical Mass Loads Per Capita Table 6-4b: Waste
divided among multiple pages,
System Name simply changed the Page Layout System Name
size to Letter size and Landscape
orientation
Historical Mass Loads Per Capita Historical Mass Loads Per C
Inf BOD5 (lb/d per capita) 1 Inf TSS (lb/d per capita)
Data Wastewater
Population
Period of Record ADF (mgd)
ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
1
To calculate the per capita flow and load
1
To calculate the per capita flow and loads, divide the values in Table 6-4a by the historical population (Table 6-4a). Record these per capita values in Table 6-4b. For example, with
6-4b. For example, with an Inf BOD5 of 54
an Inf BOD5 of 540 lb/d and a population of 3,000, the Inf BOD 5 per capita would be 0.18 lb/d per capita (calculated by dividing 540 by 3,000).
by 3,000).
Note: Sources for per capita information include Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.
Note: Sources for per capita information in
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-4b: Wastewater Load Projections - Historical Mass Loads Per Capita (Example)
System Name Any Town Oklahoma
Inf BOD5 (lb/d per capita) 1 Inf TSS (lb/d per capita)
Data Wastewater
Population
Period of Record ADF (mgd)
MinD ADF ADMM MD MinD ADF ADMM MD
Jan 1990 - Dec 1990 3,000 0.50 617 1084 922 2214 200 638 584 1393
Jan 1990 - Dec 1990 3,000 0.50 16.7 33.4 41.7 54.2 100.1 166.8 191.8 216.8
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
1
To calculate the per capita flow and loads, divide the values in Table 6-4a by the Historical population (Table 6-4a). Record these per capita values in Table
6-4b. For example, with an Inf BOD5 of 540 lb/d and a population of 3,000, the Inf BOD 5 per capita would be 0.18 lb/d per capita (calculated by dividing 540
by 3,000).
Note: Sources for per capita information include Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklah
Table 6-4c: Wastewater Load Projections - Selected Historical Mass Loads Per Capita Table 6-4c: W
gomills:
System Name If this table appears to be System Name
divided
Selected Historical among
Mass multiple
Loads Per Capita Selected Historical Mass L
pages, simply changed the
Page Layout size to Letter Inf BOD5 (lb/d per capita) 1 Inf TSS (lb/d per capita) 1
Data Wastewater
size andPopulation
Period of Record Landscape ADF (mgd)
orientation. ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
If any of the values based on historical data need to be modified for future planning and include list values selected for future planning provide an If any of the values based on h
explanation below. explanation below.
1
To calculate the per capita flow and loads, divide the values in Table 6-4a by the historical population (Table 6-4a). Record these per capita values in Table 6-4b. For example, with 1
To calculate the per capita flow and loa
an Inf BOD5 of 540 lb/d and a population of 3,000, the Inf BOD 5 per capita would be 0.18 lb/d per capita (calculated by dividing 540 by 3,000). an Inf BOD5 of 540 lb/d and a population
Note: Sources for per capita information include Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc. Note: Sources for per capita information
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-4c: Wastewater Load Projections - Selected Historical Mass Loads Per Capita (Example)
System Name
Inf BOD5 (lb/d per capita) 1 Inf TSS (lb/d per capita) 1
Data Wastewater
Population
Period of Record ADF (mgd)
ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
If any of the values based on historical data need to be modified for future planning and include list values selected for future planning provide an
explanation below.
1
To calculate the per capita flow and loads, divide the values in Table 6-4a by the historical population (Table 6-4a). Record these per capita values in Table 6-4b. For example, with
an Inf BOD5 of 540 lb/d and a population of 3,000, the Inf BOD 5 per capita would be 0.18 lb/d per capita (calculated by dividing 540 by 3,000).
Note: Sources for per capita information include Section 3 of this guide, monthly DMRs, typical values for residential population, etc.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Oklah
Table 6-4d: Wastewater Load Projections - Projected Flow and Mass Loads Per Capita Table 6-4d: W
System Name System Name
Inf BOD5 (lb/d per capita) 3 Inf TSS (lb/d per capita) 3
Population Wastewater
Period of Data 1
ADF (mgd) 2
ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
1
Record this information from Table 6-2 1
Record this information from Table 6-2
2
Record this information from Table 6-3 2
Record this information from Table 6-3
3
To complete the Inf BOD5, Inf TSS, Inf TP and Inf TKN, take the projected population and multiply it by the per capita numbers in Table 6-4C. 3
To complete the Inf BOD5, Inf TSS, Inf
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-4d: Wastewater Load Projections - Projected Flow and Mass Loads Per Capita (Example)
System Name Anytown, Oklahoma
Inf BOD5 (lb/d per capita) 3 Inf TSS (lb/d per capita) 3
Population Wastewater
Period of Data 1
ADF (mgd) 2
ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD ADF 30-Day ADMM MinD MD
Data Source 1
Data Source 2
1
Record this information from Table 6-2
2
Record this information from Table 6-3
3
To complete the Inf BOD5, Inf TSS, Inf TP and Inf TKN, take the projected population and multiply it by the per capita numbers in Table 6-4C.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-5: Design Flow/Load as it Relates to Facility/Process
gomills:
System Name If this table appears to be divided
among multiple pages, simply changed
Design Flow Type Wastewater Component or Process Type
the Page Layout size to Letter size and
Maximum Day (MD)Landscape
and Peak Hour (PH) Sizing for secondary clarifiers, filters, disinfection processes
orientation
Sizing for all hydraulic elements (examples include pumping,
Peak Hour (PH) screening, weirs) including lift stations located within collection
system
Annual Average Day Flow (ADF) or Maximum Month (ADMM) Design capacity of wastewater treatment plant
Maximum Day (MD) Sizing for aeration system, solids processing system
Minimum Day (MinD) Check for turn down on aeration system, trickling filter recycle
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 6-6: Future Permits 1
System Name System Name
Future Discharge Permit Notes
Existing Anticipated
Constituent Notes
Permit Limit Future Limit 2
BOD5 (mg/L)
CBOD5 (mg/L)
TSS (mg/L)
pH (s.u.)
DO (mg/L)
SAR
TKN (mg/L)
TP (mg/L)
Chlorine (mg/L)
Temperature (oF)
1
Talk to DEQ about any upcoming changes that may happen
2
Refer to DEQ 525:656 for anticipated project limits
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 6-6: Future Permits (Example)
System Name Any Town Oklahoma (ATO)
Future Discharge Permit Notes
Existing Anticipated
Constituent Notes
Permit Limit Future Limit
BOD5 (mg/L) 30 20
TSS (mg/L) 30 20
DO (mg/L) 2 2
SAR
System Name
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 7-1: Capacity Analysis To-Do List (Example)
System Name
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Water Supply Planning Guide Ok
Table 7-2: Wastewater System Capacity Challenges
System Name System N
Discharge Permit
2
Limits2
Selected Wastewater
4
Flow Projection4
List treatment capacity concerns.
Selected Wastewater
5
Load Projection5
Collection System
Capacity
6
(existing and
planned projects)6 List aging infrastructure concerns.
Treatment System
Capacity
7
(existing and
planned projects)7
Discharge Permit
Limits
Selected Wastewater
Flow Projection
List treatment capacity concerns.
Selected Wastewater
Load Projection
Collection System
Capacity
(existing and
planned projects) List aging infrastructure concerns.
Pumps are getting old.
Treatment System
Capacity
(existing and
planned projects)
System Name
Describe below system capacity concerns indentified in Table 7-2. Supplemental Information Source(s)1
Describe below any regional strategies identified to address these concerns. Supplemental Information Source(s)1
If no regional strategies were identified to address these concerns, explain below. Supplemental Information Source(s)
List below the most significant concerns and rank them in order of importance.
1
OCWP Regional Reports (available at www.owrb.ok.gov/ocwp) specific to your area may be helpful.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 7-3: System Capacity Analysis (Example)
System Name
Describe below system capacity concerns indentified in Table 7-2. Supplemental Information Source(s)1
Pump run time by operator. Odor at plant in summer months None known
Describe below any regional strategies identified to address these concerns. Supplemental Information Source(s)1
If no regional strategies were identified to address these concerns, explain below. Supplemental Information Source(s)
List below the most significant concerns and rank them in order of importance.
1 1
2 2
3 3
4 4
5 5
6 6
7 7
8 8
9 9
10 10
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-1: Preliminary Alternatives To-Do List (Example)
• Are there plans to expand or modify the existing service area? Are there plans to add new customers or bulk service treatment?
• Does consolidation with other facilities (in the service area or geographic region) make sense for providing overall treatment?
• Would connecting to nearby systems for emergency or other supply be feasible?
• What is the anticipated wastewater flow based upon residential and commercial connections? How does the anticipated flow
Inflow & infiltration
• What is the overall condition of the collection and transmission system and are repairs able to be readily made?
• Is the system configured in such a way as to be able to distinguish the areas with higher peaking factors (and potentially
higher I/I)?
• Will reduction in I/I make a positive impact on overall system capacity or reduce system overflows?
• Can high efficiency pumps be installed?
Piping & transmission
• Does the influent flow following a wet-weather event result in hydraulic capacity limitations at the treatment plant? Would
on-plant storage eliminate this impact?
• Are there treatment unit processes that are capacity limited resulting in a lower overall treatment plant capacity?
• Does the condition of any unit process impact the overall capacity of treatment (i.e. bar screens in poor condition limit ability to
Treatment
• Will the current treatment processes allow compliance with the existing permit? Will the current process provide adequate
Treatment Type
• Are there other potential methods of effluent disposal? What regulatory steps will be required to implement an alternative
Effluent
disposal plan?
• Is the effluent disposal method sized consistent with the plant capacity or will changes be required.
• Will new regulations or permit changes make the current method of effluent disposal possible?
• Is wastewater reuse a possibility? Are there customers available? Are there potential industrial customers for reuse?
• Endangered species or their habitat nearby? (common for OK – Least Tern, American Burying Beetle, Whooping Crane,
Considerations
Environmental
Leopard Darter)
• Near a High Quality Water, Scenic River, Nutrient Limited Watershed, or other sensitive areas?
• TMDL for the watershed? What constituent(s)?
• Will project involve undeveloped property?
• Near natural or archeological landmarks?
• Project in the floodway or floodplain?
• Substantive increase in volume or loading of pollutants?
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-3: Evaluation and Implementation of Water and Energy Conservation Efforts
System Name
Project is a comprehensive planning effort that includes other public and/or private sector organizations
Project alternatives analysis explores the most cost-effective solution at a regional level
Rate structures will support ongoing operations and maintenance for this project
Equipment is properly maintained, operating as close to nameplate voltage as practicable, and the connection
on switches on all major power-driven equipment is checked at least annually
Facility has taken measures to implement pressure management controls throughout collection system
Facility utilizes leak detection equipment and protocols to address leaks, collapses, and I/I issues
Facility produces Class II treated effluent for agricultural/industrial/fire protection/groundwater recharge, etc.
Facility produces Class I treated effluent used for landscape irrigation, fire protection, or groundwater
recharge
System design allows for water reuse treatment and distribution
System planning involved consultation with potential water reuse and land application customers
Planning methodologies include: Comprehensive Land Use Plan, Fix-it First Methodology, Asset Management Plan, Watershed Management Plan,
1
System Name
Implementation
Influent Wastewater Challenges Preliminary Alternatives1
Time Frame
Notes
1
See Appendices C and D.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-4: Influent Wastewater Challenges and Preliminary Alternatives
System Name
Implementation
Influent Wastewater Challenges Preliminary Alternatives
Time Frame
Notes
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-3: Influent Wastewater Challenges and Preleminary Alternatives (Example)
Implementation
Influent Wastewater Challenges Preliminary Alternatives1
Time Frame
High BOD and TSS IFAS, Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor 9/30/2014
Notes
1
See Appendices C and D.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-5: Wastewater Collection Challenges and Preliminary Alternatives
System Name
Implementation
Wastewater Collection Challenges Preliminary Alternatives
Time Frame
Notes
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-6: Wastewater Treatment Challenges and Preliminary Alternatives
System Name
Implementation
Wastewater Treatment Challenges Preliminary Alternatives
Time Frame
Notes
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-7: Wastewater Effluent Disposal/Reuse Challenges and Preliminary Alternatives
System Name
Implementation
Wastewater Effluent Disposal/Reuse Challenges Preliminary Alternatives
Time Frame
Notes
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-8: Sludge Management Challenges and Preliminary Alternatives
System Name
Implementation
Sludge Management Challenges Preliminary Alternatives
Time Frame
Notes
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide Ok
Table 8-9: Conceptual Alternatives
2 2
3 3
4 4
5 5
6 6
7 7
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 8-8: Conceptual Alternatives (Example)
Conceptual
Conceptual Alternative Will this alternative be
Alternative
Description given further consideration?
Name
✘ Will be considered further
This alternative involves continued Will not be considered further (explain decision below)
operation of the existing wastewater
system without modifications to
No Action
collection, transmission, treatment,
effluent disposal, or residuals
management.
Chemicals
Pump Station
Funding Funding
Critical Non-Critical
Sources Sources
Within
1 Year
1 to 3 Years
3 to 5 Years
5 to 10
Years
10 to 25
Years
Beyond 25
Years
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 9-1: Evaluate Alternatives To-Do List
System Name
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 9-1: Evaluate Alternatives To-Do List (Example)
N. Drew 2012-2013
5 Look at impacts to residuals and disposal site
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 9-2 (page 1 of 2): Example Primary and Secondary Objectives
gomills:
IfObjective Name
this table appears to be Objective Description Secondary Objectives Performance Measure (units)
divided among multiple pages,
simply changed the Page Layout Provide system redundancy (equipment, Number of trains and N redundancy
treatment trains) to keep system For N: 0=none, 1=single equipment back-up, 2=full equipment
size to Letter size and operating during component failure back-up
Landscape
orientation
Use of proven technology in alternative
Use proven technology for treatment Qualitative 1-5 where 1 represents least proven technology
Minimize risk of overflows in and 5 represents most proven
collection system and ensure ability to
treat organic loads with variable
1 Improve Reliability wastewater flows. Each alternative Ability to change flow path through valve, gate or piping
will be evaluated based on system Maximize flexibility in operations (flow control
redundancy, ramifications of system path changes, ability to change process) Qualitative 1-5 where 1 represents least flexibility and 5
failure, and use of proven technology. represents most flexibility
As the name suggests, essentially the system is comparing two objectives at a time to determine which of the pair is more important.
For example, is objective 1 or 2 more important? Is objective 1 or 3 more important? Using the example objectives in Table 9-2, the
sample chart below was developed. Each box in the chart compares 2 objectives. There is no priority implied in the objective's
numbering assignment - the numbers simply facilitate the exercise. Each objective will be compared to each of the other objectives
selected for use in the chart. For this sample (see Example A ), we have chosen to compare four objectives, however the number of
objectives used and the issues addressed should be based on their relevance to the individual utility.
Once the objectives have been determined and selections have been made for comparison, the participant would:
1. Determine which objective (representatied by numbers) in each box is more important (excluding all other objectives) and circle
that number. For example, in the first box the objective "Improved Reliability" is compared to "Minimize Cost". The option, "Minimize
Cost" was elected as the more important objective of the two. Continue this process for all 6 boxes.
2. Tally the number of times each objective was selected (circled). Notice that objective #2, "Minimize Costs" was circled three times
in example A.
3. Divide the number of times each objective was selected by the total number of selections (6) among all the objectives to
determine the objective weighting. Multiply the results by 100 to determine the weighting in percent. The total percentage should be
near 100 (rounding considered). For example, since objective #2, "Minimize Costs" was selected a total of 3 times in the chart
among all comparisons and the total number of selections (circles) in the chart is 6, therefore the result is: 3 divided by 6 = .50 x 100
= 50%.
In the following sample, we presume 3 participants are considering 6 objectives which results in 15 squares or possible choices
each (see Example B) the number used for weighting would be 45, (3 x 15 = 45). Therefore, since objective #2 was selected a total
of 7 times, (7 divided by 45 = .1555 x 100 = 15.55) would result in a weighted value of 16% for this objective.
Sample Objective Weighting using Six Example Objectives with Three Participants
Operability and
Name of selected objective > Improve Reliability Integration with Maintainability Constructability Public Acceptance Timely Implementation
Current System
1 3 4 2 9
2 3 1 3 7
3 0 3 2 5
4 2 3 2 7
5 3 2 3 8
6 4 2 3 9
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 9-3: Weighting of System Objectives
System Name
Paired Comparison Method for Weighting Objectives (Use additional forms for more objective comparisons)
1
The cost range should reflect the relative cost differences between the alternatives. For example, if all projects have estimated costs of less than $25,000,
then $5,000 cost windows may be used to better distinguish between the projects.
2
Note that the higher ranking indicates a lower cost.
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 9-6: Sample Rating Table with Scores
10
11
12
13
14
15
Oklahoma Comprehensive Water Plan - Public Wastewater Utility Planning Guide
Table 10-1: Preparing an Engineering Report To-Do List (Example)
System Name Any Town, Oklahoma
Task Person Responsible Target Completion Date
10
11
12
13
14
15