You are on page 1of 10

cc

 c c c


c c c c c

cc


c

c cccc

c c
c
c ccc !cc"c#c!$cc%!c&cc&c#c

c#'cTroy, &cc&c#cc()c''!c*cc+c,c,c'- .cc

,''!c%!c)c#c&c+c'' c+c "!c+c#&$cc+cc

+c#,!c+c"$c&ccc&'c +c+cc"cc#+&c

cc,c#cc/c0ccc''c#cc&c,-c.cc#'cc

!1cc##cc"c+!c#'cc'c&&c'!ccc'ccc

2,c"cc3 4-cc
c#'c !c0#&&c5c+c+c,,'c#c

&cc,c##ccc,c'cc,,c'&cc#-cc

6+"c.ccc,&cc,,ccTroy !c+&cc +cc2c#cThe

Iliad cc#'-cc!c#,cccc#c,c#'c )cc ,) cc

cc#cc"cmoira 3#4ckleos 3&!4ccaristeiac32,,7c,c"4-c

"c+ccc'!c ccc'c,c3c,,4cc#'ccc

*cdikec3,, c&4c#c,cccc#!c#c+-c

,+c8"c ##c"&c!c c'#ccc+c#c cc

"cc,cccc&ccc,cc,&c#c&c!cc,c

#'c'c,cc-cc ##c'cc,)c$c#'cc"c9

&c#cc/c0-c6c!cccc+c c,&cc,,cc6'c+c

""c6!+$ cccc&c6'c+c""-c0cc'c+c,&cc

#'ccc$
c !c6'cccc#cc/c0cccc!ccc

'c'cc#,c cc!cc"c-cc')cc,"c+cc

#cc'!c::c,ccc&c)c cTroy c&cc ccc+)-cc

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

c8"c ##c;8"c ##c0 c,,;c c9c<'-c
=77+++- ,-,-)7#'7+ ,,7"> ##> -'c

c,'c,:c;<'c6'?c!cc5?c!-;c.cTroy: From Homer's Iliad to Hollywood Epic-c


c=c0!9 ,)+c
@-c
-c3ccc,cTroy4c

c
c
c'cc,c'c,,c',c'#,cc+c)+c,,-ccc

c,,ccc,!ccc,&c,''cc'c#cc'Acc!c

c+cc()cc&cc ':=c*c#c"c+c#ccc&,c

,c#c'ccc,!-c

ccc2,cc +c"cc+cccThe Iliadcc

Troy-cc&"c2c#cc+c361c&c#c,cc&cccc'"4cc

cc)-c<'cc/c,"c#"c+c3ccc/c,4cc

 c ,c#cc"c#c1c,!-c.cTroy 6,c,c5c#c"&cc

c"c#c6c"cc,c"cc!cccoikos 3#'!4cc,!-c cc

6,c2c5ccB"cccc#c c"cc+-cc+cc#c

,ccc)c#c2c,)cc6,ccc,c#'!c'-$ c#c,cc

cccc"c,*cc&c'!ccc"c#c5,cc"cc

cccc'cc#c"&,cckleos-c

8"cCc#cSlate c8"c8 !c#cThe New Yorkerc c&"c!c"c

"+-cCccTroy ccc'/c'cof The Iliadcc'cc

,ccc/c0c+cc;&*c+;c#c"ccc&c,-cc

8 !c,cc'cc,cc#'c; c2&cc&,-;c8c

c#ccNY Times Book Reviewc#c'c c&&cc+cc2,!c

c; #;cc; ;ccc,,c()-c6c,'c!cc&c#c",cc

cc&ckleoscc c,'''cc&Acc')ccc#c+c  c3c

++4cc+-Dcccc'c'c ccc'!cc&ccc,*c

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

cTroy: Director's Cut-c8E8-c8,c !c0#&&c5-c  )=c0c6'cEc
-c

c8cc;cc.;ccF+cG)cH"+c#c )-c
=77+++-! )-,'7,7,"7
7/7
7997c
D
c. -c


c
c
#cccc &cc#'c#cc&",-c!cc,c cc'c&=c

c6'cc!cc&#!c+c c!ccc9+-cc

.c'cccc!cc+c !c,,c +cc.*c0ccTroyccc

&c!cc#ccc,,cc'c2,!c !c5c'#=ccc

I&c&''c34---c5c(&c0-c c,,ccc'"c#cc"c

#c.*-$@ccccAcTroyc,,#!c+cccc!,c#c+c,!c

.*-cc c!c9+c#'cc-c !c51c'ccc#'c#c cc

'!ccc,cc#c+cccc,,cc.*-c"cccc

,c#c&cc)c,ccc'c&c,9#9,''-ccTroycc cc

c#'cc9+c#'c !c'!&cc,)ccc,cc,cc',c

c'!,c-cccc&!Acccisc&!cc+ cccc#-c<c2'c

&c6,1c2,cc&,cc,cc c #cc&':cc",c

ccc&!cc2,,-ccc"c+cc'c#cc# c+c

'!c c,!c3c" 4cc'-cH&cccc"c#'cc*cc

c#'c)cc'c+c3ccc4c cc##!c !c##c,-c

<cc#'cc,c,cc+&c"ccccc#'')cc

!c2,ccc,&c#c&cc,,cc#cc/c0ccc,'!c

9+c,c c!c !c"cc,c'c,cc"&cc,,c#c

cc,c2&cc"cc&''c c+cc5,-c

+c)!c,ccThe Iliadc,cc5'c)&ccc#c,cc,c

 *!c,!&c'c') !c,ccccc,ccc#'-c

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc
@
c!c8c;&cc#'cc/c0=c ccc'c#c<,-;cCollege Literaturec c-c
c
3
4=c
Jc

cH,'c'cThe Iliad of Homer (translated and introduction by Richmond Lattimore-c3,&=c
K"!c%#c,&c5c @ 4c
-D @c

c
c
F"c"c#cTroy1c,,cc,,cc,1c ,cc+c

'!c#$c#'cc*"c,ccSaving Private Ryan.Jcc,cc cc'c

#,c-c<c.c)c+c'!c##c+!c,cc ,cc)Lc"cc

,c,'cc,cc') !c'cc,&c&!c+!c,c

!c,2c,---c%c"+c"cc&,c#cc /,c'c+cccc

#'1c&cc,c,ccc&''=cGc,)c#c+-$cc2,c

c,c c#ccThe Iliad=cGc+c,)---$ cc c&cc#'ccccc

'cc2'c+c+cc"+c c c#,cc1c/ ccc

 cc6,1ccc5'=cc+c'!c cccc(c,''L$ c

c+c*c"c,c,cc,2-c%c,c&c#'cThe Iliadc

c'cc+!ccc,c!c#,c6,1c'-c&cc#'c*cc

cc'c&ccc c&McGc+cccc&!c cc c&L$


cc

c&c#'cThe Iliad 'ccc#,cc'cc c#ccNc=c c

!=c!cc'ccc'!ccc c+cc+cc+&-c.c,c&c#cc.c

)c&c#c'---Fcccccccc,c#c&cN---$ c

##c#!c2cc'ccc&,c'c,,cc

'cc cc,,c,'!c ccc,c'-c%cc()cc,c

'c6,1c,c)c c)ccccc2c"-c.c'!c"+&c#cc

#'c,1c,c#c+ciscc,c'cc'-c.c+c'cc,c

c,cc!,&,c cc,,', cc+c#cc3ccc


cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc
J
cc5,c;8,&cc(Lc&,!cc5+ccc#c,c6!cc!-;cJournal of
Adaptation in Film & Performancec c-c
c3
J4=c
c

c'c -

Dc

c5c(c;6,c6!cF+c!=c6!+c5c&c6'-;cArion, Third Seriesc
c-c c3
4=c
J
c

cTroy, '=c = =D9 c

cTroy, '=c = =DD9 = D= c



c'c
-
9
Jc
c

c
c
+ccc&4ccc')c'c"c !cc,-c.cTroyc,c2'cc

#,c+cc,&c cc)c'ccc&=c8cMc0ccc!cc##!c

!c#'c+c+ccc'L$ 6cc&c'cc"cccThe

Iliadcc+=c<ccc'c#cc'c+cc ,)cc'c#cc#&c-c0ccc

ccc&ccc "c+cc+)&-cc'ccc#cccc&cc

c+ccc',- Dc

c,c8c6''c+c,ccc,c cc&#c##cc'c !c

&''1c' !cc )c.Oc&&&cccccc&c'c&c

,c,-$ @c,c#cc+c-c,1cP&1c"+c#c,)c#cc

c+c'c'c#c'!ccc"cc,c +c'cc cc

#cc#'-c.cThe Iliad,c c)c!c,ccc+c'cc'c#cc

c#c5, cccc#'cc,,ccccc#'c5!2-c.cTroy,c

,ccc,$c+cccc,Acccc&c"!c$c ,c+cc

'cc+c+c"c cc&$ Jc&&"c#cc2'ccc cc

,'ccc c#cc+-ccc,c c+cc +c,cc

6,=c.cThe Iliadc6,1cc#c&c&!ccccc2'-c

³Man, supposing you and I, escaping this battle, would be able to live on forever,

ageless, immortal... (we would not fight in the front) but now, seeing that the spirits of

death stand close about us in their thousands, no man can turn aside nor escape them, let

us go on and win glory for ourselves, or yield it to others.´19

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

cTroy, '=c =D
= 9 =D= c
D
c'c - J9
c
@
c8c6''cThe Iliad As Politics: The Performance of Political Thought-c3F'=cK"!c#c%)'c
5c

4c Jc

c', -
J
9
c
J
cTroy, '=c =D = 9 =D
= c

cc'c
-
@9
Jc

Dc
c
c

'c,,c"c,##ccc&cc#cc#'c c&c.c&cccc

 !c##cc6',c,c"-c ##c ccc#,cc,$c#c

c&cc#c c##c,-
cc cc#cc+c cc#'1cc#c

c'&!cc ##1c,ccc+c&$c)ccc#c c'-cc

,,c#c"c0&&c &&ccc3!,4c ,c#cc&c&cc

c'!c ccc&"cc'"cc&ccc&!c"c#c'c, c

 /,-$
c,c,!c c2c"cc#cc6',cP&1=cC+cc

,$AcH#cc9c!$c",cAc6",)cc$c#c2, c"Ac5,,cc

"$c",Acc cc'$c#c&,!c#cc,,-

cFc#c+,c

'cc,c'cccc+!cc+Lcccc#cc&ccTroycc

& !cc,ccc#,ccc'cc2cc+,cc&c3c

,!c'c,,4c,c2,cc+c#c+Accc,1c,,c#cPc

&1cc')c'cc'&-c

cc,c+cc',c#cc2c+"+c+cc

,cc'c,!c c,c)+c -c.cc ,c+cc'$cc

"!&cc'c #cc+c'c:cc''-
c.cccc''cc

#cc',c +c'cc cc+c,cc,&ccmoira 3#4-c

6ccmoiraccc"!cF:,camor fati (love of fate)c2'#ccc#'c*c.c

,c&-c.c+c cccc+c.c'-$
c c#cc'c &c)cc c

,cc cc')cc,,cc#c3c##4cckleos #cc#c#c,cc

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc


c ##c


c"c-c0&&c;.;c,ccE,ccc,c0-c=77+&&-+-,'7&77c

c6''cDDc


cTroy, '=c =D = 9 =D
= c


cTroy, '=c =D = 9Dc

@c
c
!'!c"c+cc&!-ccc,#'cc,1cc = ³You gave me peace...

in a lifetime of war.´25

cccdikec± c&,c,#,c#c&cc'!c ccc c'c,!c"c

cTroy c,c,!c"ccc)#1c&c"c+ccmoiraccc

##cc,c-ccdike c#c,c !c,1c/,c#c6,1c,c##c

ccc'cc#'=c---c+!cc +c'cc-$
@c.cc#'cc

!cc'c2,c ,cccc,c,c2c'#ccc!'cc

&c',&---clions-$
c0c,cc6,c'!c"c,cc'c

,''c+ccc'c'cccccctimec34ccc&c

kleos.c0c6,cccc,)c&cc#cc,c,''=c³Get up Prince of

Troy. I won¶t let a stone take my glory.´28cc#&ccccatec3&Ac#9

,4cc c,c,cccc2,ccaristeia-c.cc'cc#c#c

c!cTroyc2,c+cc,c,ccaristeia-c&c#'cc&c,c+c+c

c,ccc&c,c+#!c2,ccc+cc,cc

#cc+-cc,#,c,c")ccc#'cc#,ccc&cc )cOO.c#cThe

Iliad=c c,c+&ccc+c,)c'c cc,)ccc,9 cc

c 9&c+c&c#c&c-c6cccc&c#,c++c

c!cc&ccc ,)c c#+---$


c

c'c+c,c'&!c&cc#'c+c'c-c

c"+c5c(c&cc+c6'c':ccaristeiac#cc"cc

cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

D
cTroy, '=c= = D9D
c

@
c'c

-
@
c


cTroy, '=cD
= 9 c

J
cTroy, '=c
=
D= D9 Dc


c'c
- @9 c

c
c
Troyc,cc6,c&cccc&c'-$ c0cccc2,c#c

cc +c6,cc,cc,'ccc+)cc,1c,cc"c

 -cc'/c()c c+c#&c+c,cc#'cc,cc c

"c ccc#'cc'ccccccc',:cc,:c

,-c'!ccc5c#c##&cc',ccc#'cc&Ac

#c &ctooc,-c8cc"c#c'c,,cc#'ccc'!c c

,c/ccThe Iliadccc!c#c,- cc#'cc+c,ccc,c

+c'c &ccc#c!-cc

.c,,cc!ccc#'')c#cc6'ccc#c

c/c0c'!-ccc'c#cmoirackleosccaristeiacccc

,ccc+!cc'c,c,c,c cc ccc,cc,c

&c#c6'-cc cc&!cc&!c#c,ccc,c'c#c#c

c2,!cc&!c#c+c#-ccc,&c#c'c,,c,cc2,!c

!c !cc#cc'c+#cc',!c#,c,cc6!+c ccc

ccc#caristeiacc&!-cc+cccc' c+ccc#c)c

cc'c,,ccc'c+c,c,,!c,,:ccccc,'2cc

#c+-c&cThe Iliad c+c6,ccc#c!cc#'ccccc &Ac

%!1cc )cc#'c&ccaristeia #cP 1c,=cc'c!c

.c+)c+c&---cc'c!c.c"ccc'c#c6,c )c#c-cc'c!c

.c"ccc'c#c,-$
c

c
cccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc cccccccc

c(c J c

c'c c c


cTroy, '=c= = 9= D= c

Jc
c
Ñ cc

##c8"-c;8"c ##c0 c,,c-;c c9c<'-c

=77+++- ,-,-)7#'7+ ,,7"> ##> -'c3,,cc c


4-c

8c!c-c;&cc#'cc/c0=c ccc'c#c<,-;cCollege

Literaturec c-c
c3
4=c

9
@
-c

(c5-c;6,c6!cF+c!=c6!+c5c&c6'-;cArion, Third Seriesc


c-c c3
4=c  9 J-c

6''c8-cThe Iliad as Politics: The Performance of Political Thought (Oklahoma Series

in Classical Culture)-cF'=cK"!c#c%)'c5c

-c

,:c,'-c;<'c6'?c!cc5?c!-;c.cTroy: From Homer's Iliad to

Hollywood Epic-cc=c0!9 ,)+c


@-c
9
-c

'cH,'-cThe Iliad of Homer (translated and introduction by Richmond Lattimore-c

,&=cK"!c%#c,&c5c @ -c

c8c-c;cc.cccc-;ccF+cG)cH"+c#c )cccccccc-c

=77+++-! )-,'7,7,"7
7/7
7997c3,,cc c


4-c

5,c-c;8,&cc(Lc&,!cc5+ccc#c,c6!cc

!-;cJournal of Adaptation in Film & Performancec c-c


c3
J4=c 9 
-c

Troy: Director's Cut-c8E8-c8,c !c0#&&c5-c  )=c0c6'cEc


-c

0&&c"c--c;.;c,ccE,ccc,c0-c

=77+&&-+-,'7&77c3,,cc c
4-c

0)cc--c;c.ccc'-;c.cTroy: From Homer's Iliad to Hollywood

Epic-cc=c0!9 ,)+c
@-c 9 -c

c
c