You are on page 1of 7

(IWMKREXMSR %%1 

7XERHEVH 7TIGMÂGEXMSR JSV


'EWXMRKW 2MGOIP ERH 2MGOIP %PPS]
8LMW WXERHEVH MW MWWYIH YRHIV XLI Â\IH HIWMKREXMSR %%1 XLI RYQFIV MQQIHMEXIP] JSPPS[MRK XLI HIWMKREXMSR MRHMGEXIW XLI ]IEV
SJ SVMKMREP EHSTXMSR SV MR XLI GEWI SJ VIZMWMSR XLI ]IEV SJ PEWX VIZMWMSR % RYQFIV MR TEVIRXLIWIW MRHMGEXIW XLI ]IEV SJ PEWX VIETTVSZEP
% WYTIVWGVMTX ITWMPSR ˜ MRHMGEXIW ER IHMXSVMEP GLERKI WMRGI XLI PEWX VIZMWMSR SV VIETTVSZEP

8LMW WXERHEVH LEW FIIR ETTVSZIH JSV YWI F] EKIRGMIW SJ XLI 97 (ITEVXQIRX SJ (IJIRWI

 7GSTI ) 1IXLSHW JSV 'LIQMGEP %REP]WMW SJ 2MGOIP'LVSQMYQ


 8LMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR GSZIVW RMGOIP RMGOIPGSTTIV RMGOIP ERH 2MGOIP'LVSQMYQ-VSR %PPS]W ;MXLHVE[R 
GSTTIVWMPMGSR RMGOIPQSP]FHIRYQ RMGOIPGLVSQMYQ ERH ) 8IWX 1IXLSHW JSV 'LIQMGEP %REP]WMW SJ 2MGOIP'STTIV
RMGOIPQSP]FHIRYQGLVSQMYQ EPPS] GEWXMRKW JSV GSVVSWMSR %PPS]W ;MXLHVE[R 
VIWMWXERX WIVZMGI ) 8IWX 1IXLSHW JSV 'LIQMGEP %REP]WMW SJ ,MKL
8IQTIVEXYVI )PIGXVMGEP 1EKRIXMG ERH 3XLIV 7MQMPEV -VSR
 8LI ZEPYIW WXEXIH MR IMXLIV 7- YRMXW SV MRGLTSYRH YRMXW 2MGOIP ERH 'SFEPX %PPS]W
EVI XS FI VIKEVHIH WITEVEXIP] EW WXERHEVH 8LI ZEPYIW WXEXIH MR
IEGL W]WXIQ QE] RSX FI I\EGX IUYMZEPIRXW XLIVIJSVI IEGL  8IVQMRSPSK]
W]WXIQ WLEPP FI YWIH MRHITIRHIRXP] SJ XLI SXLIV 'SQFMRMRK
ZEPYIW JVSQ XLI X[S W]WXIQW QE] VIWYPX MR RSRGSRJSVQERGI  (I´RMXMSRW
[MXL XLI WXERHEVH  QEWXIV LIEX¨E WMRKPI JYVREGI GLEVKI SJ VIÂRIH EPPS]
[LMGL QE] IMXLIV FI TSYVIH HMVIGXP] MRXS GEWXMRKW SV MRXS VIQIPX
 6IJIVIRGIH (SGYQIRXW EPPS] JSV MRHMZMHYEP QIPXW
 %781 7XERHEVHW  QIPXW¨E WMRKPI JYVREGI GLEVKI TSYVIH MRXS GEWXMRKW
% 8IWX 1IXLSHW ERH (IÂRMXMSRW JSV 1IGLERMGEP 8IWXMRK ;LIR QEWXIV LIEXW EVI YWIH XS TVITEVI QIPXW E QIPX EREP]WMW
SJ 7XIIP 4VSHYGXW WLEPP FI VITSVXIH
%%1 4VEGXMGI JSV 7XIIP 'EWXMRKW ;IPHMRK 5YEPMÂ
GEXMSRW SJ 4VSGIHYVIW ERH 4IVWSRRIP  +IRIVEP 'SRHMXMSRW JSV (IPMZIV]
%%1 7TIGMÂGEXMSR JSV 'EWXMRKW -RZIWXQIRX 'EV  )\GITX JSV MRZIWXQIRX GEWXMRKW GEWXMRKW JYVRMWLIH XS
FSR ERH 0S[ %PPS] 7XIIP JSV +IRIVEP %TTPMGEXMSR ERH XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR WLEPP GSRJSVQ XS XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ 7TIGM
'SFEPX %PPS] JSV ,MKL 7XVIRKXL EX )PIZEXIH 8IQTIVEXYVIW ÂGEXMSR %%1 MRGPYHMRK ER] WYTTPIQIRXEV] VIUYMVI
%%1 7TIGMÂGEXMSR JSV 'EWXMRKW 7XIIP ERH %PPS] QIRXW XLEX EVI MRHMGEXIH SR XLI TYVGLEWI SVHIV *EMPYVI XS
'SQQSR 6IUYMVIQIRXW JSV +IRIVEP -RHYWXVMEP 9WI GSQTP] [MXL XLI KIRIVEP VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %
%%1 7TIGMÂGEXMSR JSV -RZIWXQIRX 'EWXMRKW 7XIIP %1 GSRWXMXYXIW RSRGSRJSVQERGI [MXL XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR -R
ERH %PPS] 'SQQSR 6IUYMVIQIRXW JSV +IRIVEP -RHYWXVMEP GEWI SJ GSRÃMGX FIX[IIR XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR
9WI ERH 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %%1 XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR WLEPP TVI
) 8IWX 1IXLSHW JSV 8IRWMSR 8IWXMRK SJ 1IXEPPMG 1EXIVMEPW ZEMP
) 4VEGXMGI JSV 9WMRK 7MKRMÂGERX (MKMXW MR 8IWX (EXE XS
(IXIVQMRI 'SRJSVQERGI [MXL 7TIGMÂGEXMSRW  -RZIWXQIRX GEWXMRKW JYVRMWLIH XS XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR WLEPP
) 8IWX 1IXLSHW JSV 'LIQMGEP %REP]WMW SJ 7XIIP 'EWX -VSR GSRJSVQ XS XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %%1
3TIR,IEVXL -VSR ERH ;VSYKLX -VSR ;MXLHVE[R  MRGPYHMRK ER] WYTTPIQIRXEV] VIUYMVIQIRXW XLEX EVI MRHMGEXIH MR
XLI TYVGLEWI SVHIV *EMPYVI XS GSQTP] [MXL XLI KIRIVEP VIUYMVI
QIRXW SJ 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %%1 GSRWXMXYXIW RSRGSRJSV
8LMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR MW YRHIV XLI NYVMWHMGXMSR SJ %781 'SQQMXXII % SR 7XIIP QERGI [MXL XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR -R GEWI SJ GSRÃMGX FIX[IIR XLI
7XEMRPIWW 7XIIP ERH 6IPEXIH %PPS]W ERH MW XLI HMVIGX VIWTSRWMFMPMX] SJ 7YFGSQQMXXII
VIUYMVIQIRXW SJ XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR ERH 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %
% SR 'EWXMRKW
'YVVIRX IHMXMSR ETTVSZIH 1E]   4YFPMWLIH 1E]  3VMKMREPP] %1 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %%1 WLEPP TVIZEMP
ETTVSZIH MR  0EWX TVIZMSYW IHMXMSR ETTVSZIH MR  EW %%1 ´ E
(3- %C%1  3VHIVMRK -RJSVQEXMSR
*SV VIJIVIRGIH %781 WXERHEVHW ZMWMX XLI %781 [IFWMXI [[[EWXQSVK SV
GSRXEGX %781 'YWXSQIV 7IVZMGI EX WIVZMGI$EWXQSVK *SV %RRYEP &SSO SJ %781  3VHIVW JSV GEWXMRKW XS XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR WLSYPH MRGPYHI
7XERHEVHW ZSPYQI MRJSVQEXMSR VIJIV XS XLI WXERHEVH¹W (SGYQIRX 7YQQEV] TEKI SR XLI JSPPS[MRK MRJSVQEXMSR
XLI %781 [IFWMXI
8LI PEWX ETTVSZIH ZIVWMSR SJ XLMW LMWXSVMGEP WXERHEVH MW VIJIVIRGIH SR  5YERXMX] MR TMIGIW ERH
[[[EWXQSVK  +VEHI HIWMKREXMSR 8EFPI  ERH GPEWW 8EFPI  

% 7YQQEV] SJ 'LERKIW WIGXMSR ETTIEVW EX XLI IRH SJ XLMW WXERHEVH


'ST]VMKLX  %781 -RXIVREXMSREP  &EVV ,EVFSV (VMZI 43 &S\ ' ;IWX 'SRWLSLSGOIR 4%  9RMXIH 7XEXIW

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8
%%1 c 

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8
%%1 c 
8%&0)  ,IEX8VIEX 6IUYMVIQIRXW
+VEHI ,IEX 8VIEXQIRX
'> 1 1 '= 'PEWW  1, 1' %W GEWX
17 'PEWW  '=7R&M1
17 'PEWW  0SEH MRXS JYVREGI EX ”* ?”'A QE\MQYQ ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A ERH LSPH
JSV  L TPYW ER EHHMXMSREP  QMR JSV IEGL MR ? QQA SJ GVSWW WIGXMSR SZIV 
MR 'SSP XS ”* ?”'A ERH LSPH EX XIQTIVEXYVI JSV  QMR XLIR UYIRGL MR
SMP XS VSSQ XIQTIVEXYVI
17 'PEWW  0SEH MRXS JYVREGI EX ”* ?”'A QE\MQYQ ,IEX WPS[P] XS ”* ?”'A ERH
LSPH XS HIZIPST QE\MQYQ LEVHRIWW *YVREGI SV EMV GSSP XS VSSQ XIQTIVEXYVI
21: 21 21 ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A QMRMQYQ LSPH JSV WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS
XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV SV VETMH GSSP F] SXLIV QIERW
';1; ';1 ';1' ';1 ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A QMRMQYQ LSPH JSV WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS
XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV SV VETMH GSSP F] SXLIV QIERW
'= 'PEWW  ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A QMRMQYQ LSPH JSV WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS
XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV SV VETMH GSSP F] SXLIV QIERW
'<1; ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A QMRMQYQ LSPH JSV WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS
XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV SV VETMH EMV GSSP F] SXLIV QIERW
'91'Y' ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A QMRMQYQ LSPH JSV WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS
XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV 7XEFMPM^I EX ”* ?”'A LSPH JSV
WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV SV VETMH GSSP F]
SXLIV QIERW
'<1 ,IEX XS ”* ?”'A QMRMQYQ LSPH JSV WYJJMGMIRX XMQI XS LIEX GEWXMRKW XS
XIQTIVEXYVI UYIRGL MR [EXIV SV VETMH EMV GSSP F] SXLIV QIERW
17 [LMPI QEGLMREFPI MR XLI wEWGEWXx GSRHMXMSR MW GETEFPI SJ FIMRK WSPYXMSR LIEXXVIEXIH JSV MQTVSZIH QEGLMREFMPMX] -X QE] FI WYFWIUYIRXP] EKI LEVHIRIH XS XLI
8EFPI 
*SV GVSWW WIGXMSRW SZIV  MR ? QQA MX QE] FI RIGIWWEV] XS MRGVIEWI XLI LSPH XMQI MJ QE\MQYQ WSJXRIWW MW HIWMVIH
*SV QE\MQYQ WSJXRIWW ERH XLI PIEWX ZEVMEXMSR MR LEVHRIWW PIZIPW GEWXMRKW WLSYPH FI XVERWJIVVIH JVSQ ER SZIR EX ”* ?”'A XS E WIGSRH SZIR EX ”* ?”'A

 8LI TYVGLEWIV WLEPP WTIGMJ] ER] SJ XLI JSPPS[MRK MRJSV  2MGOIP ´ '>
QEXMSR VIUYMVIH XS HIWGVMFI EHIUYEXIP] XLI HIWMVIH QEXIVMEP  2MGOIPGSTTIV ´ 1 1 1' 1, 17
 ,IEXXVIEX GSRHMXMSR WII  ERH    2MGOIPQSP]FHIRYQ ´ 21: 21 21
 6ITEMV [IPHMRK WII 7IGXMSR   2MGOIPGLVSQMYQ ´ '= ';1 ';1 ';1'
 7SYVGI MRWTIGXMSR VIUYMVIQIRXW MJ ER] WII 7TIGMÂGE '<1; '91'Y' '<1
XMSR %%1   3XLIV ´ '=7R&M1
 1EVOMRKJSVMHIRXMÂGEXMSR VIUYMVIQIRXW MJ ER] WII  %R EREP]WMW SJ IEGL QEWXIV LIEX WLEPP FI QEHI F] XLI
  ERH QERYJEGXYVIV XS HIXIVQMRI XLI TIVGIRXEKIW SJ XLI IPIQIRXW
 7YTTPIQIRXEV] VIUYMVIQIRXW HIWMVIH MRGPYHMRK XLI WTIGMÂIH MR 8EFPI  8LI EREP]WMW WLEPP FI QEHI JVSQ E
WXERHEVHW SJ EGGITXERGI VITVIWIRXEXMZI WEQTPI XEOIR HYVMRK XLI TSYVMRK SJ XLI QEWXIV
LIEX 'LIQMGEP GSQTSWMXMSR WLEPP FI VITSVXIH XS XLI TYVGLEWIV
 ,IEX 8VIEXQIRX
SV LMW VITVIWIRXEXMZI
 'EWXMRKW WLEPP FI LIEXXVIEXIH MR EGGSVHERGI [MXL XLI
 8IWX 1IXLSHW ) SV 8IWX 1IXLSHW ) WLEPP FI YWIH
VIUYMVIQIRXW MR 8EFPI 
JSV VIJIVII TYVTSWIW 8IWX 1IXLSHW ) SV 1IXLSHW ) WLEPP
238) µ4VSTIV LIEX XVIEXQIRX SJ XLIWI EPPS]W MW YWYEPP] RIGIWWEV] XS FI YWIH MJ 8IWX 1IXLSHW ) SV 8IWX 1IXLSHW ) HS RSX
IRLERGI GSVVSWMSR VIWMWXERGI ERH MR WSQI GEWIW XS QIIX QIGLERMGEP MRGPYHI E QIXLSH JSV WSQI IPIQIRX TVIWIRX MR XLI QEXIVMEP
TVSTIVXMIW 1MRMQYQ LIEXXVIEX XIQTIVEXYVIW EVI WTIGMÂIH LS[IZIV MX MW
WSQIXMQIW RIGIWWEV] XS LIEXXVIEX EX LMKLIV XIQTIVEXYVIW LSPH JSV WSQI  8IRWMPI 4VSTIVXMIW
QMRMQYQ XMQI EX XIQTIVEXYVI ERH XLIR VETMHP] GSSP XLI GEWXMRKW MR SVHIV
XS IRLERGI XLI GSVVSWMSR VIWMWXERGI ERH QIIX QIGLERMGEP TVSTIVXMIW  3RI XIRWMSR XIWX WLEPP FI QEHI JVSQ IEGL QEWXIV LIEX
I\GITX JSV KVEHIW 17 ERH '=7R&M1 [LIR XLI QEWXIV LIEX
 ;LIR 'PEWW  MW WTIGMÂIH KVEHIW '= ERH 17 WLEPP
MW YWIH XS TSYV XLI GEWXMRKW 3RI XIRWMSR XIWX WLEPP FI QEHI
FI WYTTPMIH MR XLI EWGEWX GSRHMXMSR ;LIR 'PEWW  MW WTIGMÂIH
JVSQ IEGL QIPX I\GITX JSV KVEHIW 17 ERH '=7R&M1 8IWX
KVEHIW '= ERH 17 WLEPP FI WYTTPMIH MR XLI WSPYXMSR
VIWYPXW WLEPP GSRJSVQ XS XLI XIRWMPI VIUYMVIQIRXW WTIGMÂIH MR
LIEXXVIEXIH GSRHMXMSR ;LIR 'PEWW  MW WTIGMÂIH KVEHI 17
8EFPI  8IWX FEVW WLEPP FI TSYVIH MR WTIGMEP FPSGOW JVSQ XLI
WLEPP FI WYTTPMIH MR XLI EKILEVHIRIH GSRHMXMSR
WEQI LIEX EW XLI GEWXMRKW VITVIWIRXIH
 'LIQMGEP 'SQTSWMXMSR  8LI FEV JVSQ [LMGL XLI XIWX WTIGMQIR MW XEOIR WLEPP FI
 8LIWI EPPS]W WLEPP GSRJSVQ XS XLI GLIQMGEP GSQTSWMXMSR LIEXXVIEXIH MR TVSHYGXMSR JYVREGIW XS XLI WEQI TVSGIHYVI EW
VIUYMVIQIRXW TVIWGVMFIH MR 8EFPI  XLI GEWXMRKW MX VITVIWIRXW -J XLI GEWXMRKW EVI RSX LIEXXVIEXIH
XLI FEV YWIH JSV XLI XIWX WTIGMQIR QYWX RSX FI LIEXXVIEXIH
 8LI KVEHIW XLEX TIVXEMR XS XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR EVI TPEGIH
MRXS XLI ÂZI KIRIVEP GEXIKSVMIW KMZIR FIPS[ 8LI TVSHYGIV WLEPP  8IWX WTIGMQIRW QE] FI GYX JVSQ GEWXMRKW EX XLI TVSHYG
VITSVX JSV MRJSVQEXMSR EPP IPIQIRXW MR 8EFPI  JSV [LMGL E PMQMX IV¹W STXMSR MRWXIEH SJ JVSQ XIWX FEVW
MW KMZIR JSV ER] EPPS] MR XLI WEQI EPPS] JEQMP] 8LI EPPS]  ;LIR GEWXMRKW EVI TVSHYGIH F] QIXLSHW SXLIV XLER
JEQMPMIW EVI MRZIWXQIRX TVSGIWW XIRWMSR XIWX GSYTSRW WLEPP FI QEGLMRIH XS

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8
%%1 c 
8%&0)  1IGLERMGEP 4VSTIVXMIW
%PPS] 2M 2M'Y 2M1S 2M'V 3XLIV
*EQMP]
'> 17 1' 1, 1 1 21 21 21: '9 ';1 ';1 ';1' '; '<1 '<1; '= '=7
  1'Y' 1; R&M1
8IRWMPI                  
WXVIRKXL ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A
QMR OWM ?14EA
=MIPH WXVIRKXL                  
QMR OWM ?14EA ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A
)PSRKEXMSR                  
MR  MR ?
QQA QMR
,EVHRIWW                 
,&;
%%1 XLI KEKI PIRKXL XS VIHYGIH WIGXMSR HMEQIXIV VEXMS WLEPP FI  XS 
 ,&; QMRMQYQ JSV XLI EKI LEVHIRIH GSRHMXMSR

XLI JSVQ ERH HMQIRWMSR WLS[R MR *MK  SJ ERH XIWXIH MR ? GQ A %PP SXLIV [IPH VITEMVW WLEPP FI GSRWMHIVIH QMRSV
EGGSVHERGI [MXL 8IWX 1IXLSHW ) 1ENSV ERH QMRSV [IPH VITEMVW WLEPP FI WYFNIGX XS XLI WEQI
 ;LIR GEWXMRKW EVI TVSHYGIH F] XLI MRZIWXQIRX UYEPMX] WXERHEVHW EW EVI YWIH XS MRWTIGX XLI GEWXMRKW
TVSGIWW XIWX WTIGMQIRW MR EGGSVHERGI [MXL 7TIGMÂGEXMSR %  'EWXMRKW SJ 1, 17 ERH '=7R&M1 QE] RSX FI
%1 WLEPP FI YWIH JSV QIEWYVIQIRX SJ XIRWMPI TVSTIVXMIW [IPH VITEMVIH
 -J ER] WTIGMQIR WLS[W HIJIGXMZI QEGLMRMRK SV HIZIPSTW  +VEHIW 21: 21 21 ';1; ';1
ÃE[W MX QE] FI HMWGEVHIH ERH ERSXLIV WYFWXMXYXIH JVSQ XLI ';1 '<1; '<1 ';1' ERH '91'Y' QE]
WEQI LIEXW VIUYMVI TSWX[IPH LIEX XVIEXQIRX EJXIV QENSV [IPH VITEMVW -J
 8S HIXIVQMRI GSRJSVQERGI [MXL XLI XIRWMSR XIWX TSWX[IPH LIEX XVIEXQIRX MW VIUYMVIH MX QYWX FI WTIGMÂIH EPSRK
VIUYMVIQIRXW ER SFWIVZIH ZEPYI SV GEPGYPEXIH ZEPYI WLEPP FI [MXL XLI KVEHI -J VIUYMVIH MX WLEPP FI TIVJSVQIH MR EGGSVHERGI
VSYRHIH MR EGGSVHERGI [MXL XLI ¶6SYRHMRK 1IXLSH· SJ 4VEG [MXL 7IGXMSR 
XMGI ) XS XLI RIEVIWX  OWM ? 14EA JSV ]MIPH ERH XIRWMPI  *SV KVEHI '91'Y' XLI GSQTSWMXMSR SJ XLI HITSW
WXVIRKXL ERH XS XLI RIEVIWX  JSV IPSRKEXMSR ERH VIHYGXMSR SJ MXIH [IPH QIXEP WLEPP FI WMQMPEV XS XLEX SJ %;7 % )6
EVIE -R XLI WTIGMEP GEWI SJ VSYRHMRK XLI RYQFIV ¶· [LIR RS 2M'V1S SV %;7 % ) 2M'V1S
EHHMXMSREP RYQFIVW SXLIV XLER ¶· JSPPS[ XLI ¶· VSYRHMRK
WLEPP FI HSRI MR XLI HMVIGXMSR SJ XLI WTIGMÂGEXMSR PMQMXW MJ  6INIGXMSR ERH 6ILIEVMRK
JSPPS[MRK 4VEGXMGI ) [SYPH GEYWI VINIGXMSR SJ QEXIVMEP  7EQTPIW XLEX VITVIWIRX VINIGXIH QEXIVMEP WLEPP FI TVI
WIVZIH JSV X[S [IIOW JVSQ XLI HEXI SJ XVERWQMWWMSR SJ XLI
 ;SVOQERWLMT *MRMWL ERH %TTIEVERGI
VINIGXMSR VITSVX -R GEWI SJ HMWWEXMWJEGXMSR [MXL XLI VIWYPXW SJ XLI
 'VMXMGEP WYVJEGIW SJ EPP GEWXMRKW MRXIRHIH JSV GSVVSWMSR XIWXW XLI QERYJEGXYVIV QE] QEOI GPEMQ JSV E VILIEVMRK [MXLMR
VIWMWXERX WIVZMGI WLEPP FI GPIERIH 'PIERMRK QE] FI EGGSQ XLEX XMQI
TPMWLIH F] FPEWXMRK [MXL GPIER WERH SV QIXEPPMG GSVVSWMSR
VIWMWXERX WLSX SV F] SXLIV ETTVSZIH QIXLSHW  4VSHYGX 1EVOMRK
 'EWXMRKW WLEPP FI QEVOIH JSV XLI QEXIVMEP MHIRXMÂGEXMSR
 5YEPMX] [MXL XLI %781 WTIGMÂGEXMSR HIWMKREXMSR %%1 ERH
 8LI GEWXMRKW WLEPP RSX FI TIIRIH TPYKKIH SV MQTVIK KVEHI W]QFSP XLEX MW '= 8LI QERYJEGXYVIV¹W REQI SV
REXIH XS WXST PIEOW MHIRXMÂGEXMSR QEVO ERH XLI TEXXIVR RYQFIV WLEPP FI GEWX SV
 -RXIVREP GLMPPW ERH GLETPIXW QE] FI YWIH MR XLI QERY WXEQTIH SR EPP GEWXMRKW I\GITX XLSWI SJ WYGL WQEPP WM^I EW XS
JEGXYVI SJ GEWXMRKW ,S[IZIV XLI GLMPPW GLETPIXW ERH EJJIGXIH QEOI WYGL QEVOMRK MQTVEGXMGEP 8S QMRMQM^I WQEPP HIJIGXW
GEWX QEXIVMEP QYWX FI GSQTPIXIP] VIQSZIH GEYWIH F] HMWPSHKIH TEVXMGPIW SJ QSPHMRK WERH XLI RYQFIV SJ
GEWX MHIRXMÂGEXMSR QEVOW WLEPP FI QMRMQM^IH 8LI QEVOMRK SJ
 6ITEMV F] ;IPHMRK LIEX RYQFIVW SR MRHMZMHYEP GEWXMRKW WLEPP FI EKVIIH YTSR F]
XLI QERYJEGXYVIV ERH XLI TYVGLEWIV 1EVOMRKW WLEPP FI MR WYGL
 6ITEMVW WLEPP FI QEHI F] YWMRK E [IPHMRK TVSGIHYVI
TSWMXMSR EW RSX XS MRNYVI XLI YWIJYPRIWW SJ XLI GEWXMRK
ERH STIVEXSVW GETEFPI SJ TVSHYGMRK WSYRH [IPHW 8LI GSQTS
 ;LIR XLI GEWXMRKW EVI XSS WQEPP XS QEVO MRHMZMHYEPP]
WMXMSR SJ HITSWMXIH [IPH QIXEP WLEPP FI WMQMPEV XS XLEX SJ XLI
E W]QFSP XVEGIEFPI XS XLI LIEX WLEPP FI TPEGIH SR XLI GEWXMRKW
GEWXMRKW
ERH XLI VIUYMVIH MHIRXMÂGEXMSR XLIR TPEGIH SR E XEK EJJM\IH XS
 ;IPH VITEMVW WLEPP FI GSRWMHIVIH QENSV MR XLI GEWI SJ E XLI GSRXEMRIV MR [LMGL XLIWI GEWXMRKW EVI WLMTTIH
GEWXMRK XLEX LEW PIEOIH SR L]HVSWXEXMG XIWX SV [LIR XLI HITXL SJ
XLI GEZMX] EJXIV TVITEVEXMSR JSV VITEMV I\GIIHW  SJ XLI  /I][SVHW
EGXYEP [EPP XLMGORIWW SV  MR ? QQA [LMGLIZIV MW WQEPPIV  GSVVSWMSRVIWMWXERX ETTPMGEXMSRW RMGOIP RMGOIP EPPS]
SV [LIR XLI I\XIRX SJ XLI GEZMX] I\GIIHW ETTVS\MQEXIP]  MR GEWXMRKW RMGOIP EPPS]W RMGOIP GEWXMRKW

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8
%%1 c 

79440)1)28%6= 6)59-6)1)287

8LI JSPPS[MRK WYTTPIQIRXEV] VIUYMVIQIRXW WLEPP RSX ETTP] YRPIWW WTIGMÂIH MR XLI TYVGLEWI SVHIV %
PMWX SJ WXERHEVH WYTTPIQIRXEV] VIUYMVIQIRXW JSV YWI EX XLI STXMSR SJ XLI TYVGLEWIV MW MRGPYHIH MR
7TIGMÂGEXMSRW %%1 ERH %%1 8LSWI [LMGL EVI SVHMREVMP] GSRWMHIVIH JSV YWI [MXL
XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR EVI KMZIR FIPS[ SXLIVW IRYQIVEXIH MR 7TIGMÂGEXMSRW %%1 ERH %
%1 QE] FI YWIH [MXL XLMW WTIGMÂGEXMSR YTSR EKVIIQIRX FIX[IIR XLI QERYJEGXYVIV ERH XLI
TYVGLEWIV

7 6EHMSKVETLMG )\EQMREXMSR

7 0MUYMH 4IRIXVERX )\EQMREXMSR

7 ,EVHRIWW 8IWXW


7 ;LIR GSQTSWMXMSR 17 QEXIVMEP MW SVHIVIH [MXL E
LEVHRIWW QE\MQYQ SV VERKI MR XLI EWGEWX SV WSPYXMSR LIEX
XVIEXIH GSRHMXMSR LEVHRIWW XIWXW WLEPP FI QEHI MR EGGSVHERGI
[MXL 8IWX 1IXLSHW ERH (IÂRMXMSRW % 8LI XIWX PSGEXMSR
RYQFIV SJ XIWXW ERH LEVHRIWW ZEPYIW WLEPP FI EKVIIH YTSR
FIX[IIR XLI QERYJEGXYVIV ERH TYVGLEWIV
7 -J GEWXMRKW EVI SVHIVIH MR XLI EWGEWX GSRHMXMSR
LEVHRIWW HIXIVQMREXMSRW WLEPP FI QEHI SR X[S HMJJIVIRX VITVI
WIRXEXMZI EVIEW SJ IEGL GEWXMRK SV GSYTSR WIPIGXIH JSV XIWX
7 &] EKVIIQIRX FIX[IIR TYVGLEWIV ERH TVSHYGIV
XLSWI EWGEWX GEWXMRKW XLEX JEMP XS QIIX XLI VIUYMVIH LEVHRIWW 1IXVMG )UYMZEPIRXW
QE] FI EGGITXIH MR XLI WSPYXMSR LIEXXVIEXIH ERH LEVHIRIH MR    
GSRHMXMSR MJ XLI LEVHRIWW XLYW HIZIPSTIH QIIXW XLI LEVHRIWW ?QQA ?A ?A ?A ?A

VIUYMVIQIRX SJ XLI WTIGMÂGEXMSR


238) µ6MWIV WLEPP FI QEGLMRIH SJJ ERH  MR ? QQA WUYEVI F] 
7 -J GEWXMRKW SVHIVIH EVI MR XLI WSPYXMSR LIEXXVIEXIH MR ? QQA GSYTSR WLEPP FI YWIH JSV \[IPH XIWX 7II *MK 7
GSRHMXMSR X[S WEQTPI GEWXMRKW SV X[S GSYTSRW VITVIWIRXMRK XLI *-+ 7 ;IPH 8IWX &EV %W 'EWX
PSX WLEPP FI LIEXXVIEXIH JSV XIWXW WII 7  ,EVHRIWW
HIXIVQMREXMSRW WLEPP FI QEHI SR X[S HMJJIVIRX VITVIWIRXEXMZI
EVIEW SJ IEGL GEWXMRK SV GSYTSR
7 ;LIR LEVHRIWW XIWXW EVI QEHI XLI WTIGMQIRW WLEPP 7 %PPS[ XLI WTIGMQIR XS GSSP XS VSSQ XIQTIVEXYVI
FI EX PIEWX ¾ MR ? QQA MR XLMGORIWW ERH XLI EVIE XS FI XIWXIH FIX[IIR TEWWIW VIQSZI EPP ÃY\ ERH I\EQMRI ZMWYEPP] JSV
WLEPP FI KVSYRH GPIER FIJSVI XLI LEVHRIWW XIWXW EVI QEHI GVEGOW
7 8LI GPEQTW QE] FI VIQSZIH JVSQ XLI WTIGMQIR
7 ;IPHEFMPMX] 8IWX EJXIV XLI ÂVWX X[S [IPH TEWWIW LEZI FIIR GSQTPIXIH
7 -J [IPHEFMPMX] XIWXW EVI WTIGMÂIH JSV 1' SV 1 7 (ITSWMX EPXIVREXI WIVMIW SJ TEWWIW YRXMP XLI HSYFPI
TVITEVI E GSYTSR SFXEMRIH JVSQ E XIWX FEV WLS[R MR *MK 7 :KVSSZI LEW FIIR GSQTPIXIP] ÂPPIH %JXIV XLI WIGSRH WIVMIW
SV *MK 7 JSV IEGL PSX SJ GSQTSWMXMSR 1' SV 1 RYQFIV  TEWW E ¾ MR ?QQA HMEQIXIV IPIGXVSHI QE] FI
GEWXMRKW 8LI [IPH XIWX XS FI YWIH WLEPP FI EKVIIH YTSR FIX[IIR YWIH MJ HIWMVIH
XLI TYVGLEWIV ERH QERYJEGXYVIV 7 (YVMRK [IPHMRK EPPS[ IEGL TEWW XS GSSP GPIER
7 4VITEVI ERH [IPH XLI XIWX FEV GEWX MR EGGSVHERGI ERH I\EQMRI ZMWYEPP] JSV GVEGOW 8LI TVIWIRGI SJ GVEGOW WLEPP
[MXL *MK 7 ERH MR EGGSVHERGI [MXL *MK 7 FI GEYWI JSV VINIGXMSR
7 1EGLMRI XLI GEWX WOMR ERH YRWSYRH QIXEP JVSQ 7 9TSR GSQTPIXMSR SJ XLI [IPHMRK GYX SRI WIGXMSR
X[S EHNEGIRX JEGIW SJ XLI EWGEWX WTIGMQIR I\GPYHI XLI VMWIV ETTVS\MQEXIP] ¾ MR ? QQA PSRK XVERWZIVWI XS XLI [IPH JVSQ
JEGI ERH GYX XLI WTIGMQIR MRXS ETTVS\MQEXIP] MR ?QQA IEGL IRH ERH HMWGEVH
PIRKXLW 7 4SPMWL IEGL IRH SJ XLI VIQEMRMRK GIRXIV WIGXMSR SR
7 'PEQT XLI X[S MR ? QQA PIRKXLW XSKIXLIV XS E KVMX [LIIP ERH IXGL [MXL GSRGIRXVEXIH ,23 SV [MXL
JSVQ E HSYFPI :NSMRX ERH [IPH X[S TEWWIW EX E XMQI SR 0ITMXS¹W IXGLERX 4VITEVI 0ITMXS¹W IXGLERX EW JSPPS[W   K
EPXIVREXI WMHIW SJ XLI WTIGMQIR YWMRK ¾ MR ?QQA HMEQIXIV SJ 2, 73 HMWWSPZIH MR  GQ SJ [EXIV   K SJ *I'P
IPIGXVSHIW XLEX [MPP HITSWMX QIXEP SJ WMQMPEV GSQTSWMXMSR SJ XLI TS[HIVIH HMWWSPZIH MR  GQ SJ ,'P  QM\ WSPYXMSRW 
XIWX TMIGIW ERH  ERH EHH  GQ SJ ,23 
DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8
%%1 c 

1IXVMG )UYMZEPIRXW
MR    
?QQA ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A ?A

*-+ 7 ;IPH 8IWX &EV %W 'EWX

7 4VITEVI ERH [IPH XLI XIWX FEV GEWX MR EGGSVHERGI


[MXL *MK 7 EW JSPPS[W
7 *MPP XLI KVSSZI MR XLI FPSGO GSQTPIXIP] [MXL [IPH
HITSWMX YWMRK QERYEP QIXEPPMG EVG TVSGIWW [MXL ¾ MR ?´QQA
SV ¾ MR ?QQA HMEQIXIV IPIGXVSHIW XLEX [MPP HITSWMX QIXEP SJ
WMQMPEV GSQTSWMXMSR SJ XLI XIWX TMIGI
7 6IQSZI SRI ¾ MR ?QQA XLMGO FIRH GSYTSR
PSRKMXYHMREPP] JVSQ XLI [IPHIH FPSGO F] QEGLMRMRK WE[MRK
EFVEWMZI GYXXMRK SV SXLIV WYMXEFPI QIERW 1EOI E XVERWZIVWI
WMHI FIRH XIWX SJ XLI [IPHIH NSMRX MR EGGSVHERGI [MXL 4VEGXMGI
1IXVMG )UYMZEPIRXW
MR 
%%1
?QQA ?A ?A 7 6IQSZI E XVERWZIVWI [IPH QEGVSWTIGMQIR JVSQ
XLI [IPHIH TPEXI ERH ZMWYEPP] I\EQMRI JSV GVEGOW 8LMW WTIGM
*-+ 7 <;IPH 8IWX
QIR QE] FI XLI WEQI SRI XS FI YWIH JSV XLI FIRH WTIGMQIR
7 %GGITXERGI
7 )\EQMRI XLI IXGLIH WIGXMSR YRHIV PS[ QEKRMÂGE
XMSR  XS »  8LI PSX VITVIWIRXIH F] XLI XIWX WTIGMQIR WLEPP 7 'VEGOW EW XIEVW MR XLI GEWXMRK MR XLI JYWMSR ^SRI SV
FI EGGITXIH MJ MX GSQTPMIW [MXL XLI JSPPS[MRK GVEGO VIUYMVI LIEXEJJIGXIH ^SRI SJ XLI QEGVSWTIGMQIR WLEPP FI GEYWI JSV
QIRXW  8LVII GVEGOW QE\MQYQ MR PMRIEV MRGL SJ FEWI QIXEP VINIGXMSR 'VEGOW SVMKMREXMRK EX XLI [IPH FIEH YRHIVGYXW EX
ERH  XLI PIRKXL SJ ER] GVEGO MR XLI FEWI QIXEP HSIW RSX [IPH WPEK MRGPYWMSRW SV EX GEWXMRK HIJIGXW WLEPP RSX FI GEYWI JSV
I\GIIH  MR ? QQA VINIGXMSR
7 'VEGOW SFWIVZIH MR XLI [IPH QIXEP HYVMRK XLI 7 'VEGOW SV SXLIV STIR HIJIGXW I\GIIHMRK ¾ MR ?
PS[QEKRMÂGEXMSR I\EQMREXMSR WLEPP RSX FI GEYWI JSV VINIGXMSR QQA QIEWYVIH MR ER] HMVIGXMSR SR XLI GSRZI\ WYVJEGI SJ XLI
7 *EMPYVI SJ [IPHIH XIWX FEVW XS GSQTP] [MXL ER] SJ FIRX WTIGMQIRW WLEPP FI GEYWI JSV VINIGXMSR I\GITX XLEX GVEGOW
XLI VIUYMVIQIRXW 7 XLVSYKL 7 WLEPP VIWYPX MR SGGYVVMRK SR XLI GSVRIVW [LMPI XIWXMRK ERH GVEGOW SVMKMREXMRK EX
VINIGXMSR SJ XLI PSX VITVIWIRXIH [IPH FIEH YRHIVGYXW WLEPP RSX FI GSRWMHIVIH

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8
%%1 c 
7911%6= 3* ',%2+)7

'SQQMXXII % LEW MHIRXMÂIH XLI PSGEXMSR SJ WIPIGXIH GLERKIW XS XLMW WXERHEVH WMRGI XLI PEWX MWWYI
%%1 ´ E XLEX QE] MQTEGX XLI YWI SJ XLMW WXERHEVH %TTVSZIH 1E]  

 6IZMWMSR SJ LIEX XVIEXQIRX XIVQMRSPSK] XS FI GSRWMWXIRX  9THEXI ,& XS ,&; MR 8EFPI  ERH *SSXRSXI &
[MXL % WSPYXMSR XVIEXIH WSPYXMSR LIEXXVIEXIH ERH WSPYXMSR
ERRIEPIH GLERKIH XS WSPYXMSR LIEXXVIEXIH MR 8EFPI  JSSXRSXI
%  7 7 ERH 7

'SQQMXXII % LEW MHIRXMÂIH XLI PSGEXMSR SJ WIPIGXIH GLERKIW XS XLMW WXERHEVH WMRGI XLI PEWX MWWYI
%%1 ´  XLEX QE] MQTEGX XLI YWI SJ XLMW WXERHEVH %TTVSZIH 3GX  

 6IRYQFIVIH 7YTTPIQIRXEP 6IUYMVIQIRX 7 XS 7

'SQQMXXII % LEW MHIRXMÂIH XLI PSGEXMSR SJ WIPIGXIH GLERKIW XS XLMW WXERHEVH WMRGI XLI PEWX MWWYI
%%1 ´  XLEX QE] MQTEGX XLI YWI SJ XLMW WXERHEVH %TTVSZIH 1E]  

 6IZMWIH 4EVEKVETL  XS GSVVIGX ERH GPEVMJ] XLI VSYRHMRK


JEGXSVW

%781 -RXIVREXMSREP XEOIW RS TSWMXMSR VIWTIGXMRK XLI ZEPMHMX] SJ ER] TEXIRX VMKLXW EWWIVXIH MR GSRRIGXMSR [MXL ER] MXIQ QIRXMSRIH
MR XLMW WXERHEVH 9WIVW SJ XLMW WXERHEVH EVI I\TVIWWP] EHZMWIH XLEX HIXIVQMREXMSR SJ XLI ZEPMHMX] SJ ER] WYGL TEXIRX VMKLXW ERH XLI VMWO
SJ MRJVMRKIQIRX SJ WYGL VMKLXW EVI IRXMVIP] XLIMV S[R VIWTSRWMFMPMX]

8LMW WXERHEVH MW WYFNIGX XS VIZMWMSR EX ER] XMQI F] XLI VIWTSRWMFPI XIGLRMGEP GSQQMXXII ERH QYWX FI VIZMI[IH IZIV] ´ZI ]IEVW ERH
MJ RSX VIZMWIH IMXLIV VIETTVSZIH SV [MXLHVE[R =SYV GSQQIRXW EVI MRZMXIH IMXLIV JSV VIZMWMSR SJ XLMW WXERHEVH SV JSV EHHMXMSREP WXERHEVHW
ERH WLSYPH FI EHHVIWWIH XS %781 -RXIVREXMSREP ,IEHUYEVXIVW =SYV GSQQIRXW [MPP VIGIMZI GEVIJYP GSRWMHIVEXMSR EX E QIIXMRK SJ XLI
VIWTSRWMFPI XIGLRMGEP GSQQMXXII [LMGL ]SY QE] EXXIRH -J ]SY JIIP XLEX ]SYV GSQQIRXW LEZI RSX VIGIMZIH E JEMV LIEVMRK ]SY WLSYPH
QEOI ]SYV ZMI[W ORS[R XS XLI %781 'SQQMXXII SR 7XERHEVHW EX XLI EHHVIWW WLS[R FIPS[

8LMW WXERHEVH MW GST]VMKLXIH F] %781 -RXIVREXMSREP  &EVV ,EVFSV (VMZI 43 &S\ ' ;IWX 'SRWLSLSGOIR 4% 
9RMXIH 7XEXIW -RHMZMHYEP VITVMRXW WMRKPI SV QYPXMTPI GSTMIW SJ XLMW WXERHEVH QE] FI SFXEMRIH F] GSRXEGXMRK %781 EX XLI EFSZI
EHHVIWW SV EX  TLSRI   JE\  SV WIVZMGI$EWXQSVK IQEMP  SV XLVSYKL XLI %781 [IFWMXI
[[[EWXQSVK  4IVQMWWMSR VMKLXW XS TLSXSGST] XLI WXERHEVH QE] EPWS FI WIGYVIH JVSQ XLI 'ST]VMKLX 'PIEVERGI 'IRXIV 
6SWI[SSH (VMZI (ERZIVW 1%  8IP   LXXT[[[GST]VMKLXGSQ

'ST]VMKLX%781-RXIVREXMSREP
4VSZMHIHF]-,7YRHIVPMGIRWI[MXL%781
0MGIRWII!4IXVSJEG-RXIVREXMSREP0XH9WIV!6ENY1ERM
2SVITVSHYGXMSRSVRIX[SVOMRKTIVQMXXIH[MXLSYXPMGIRWIJVSQ-,7 2SXJSV6IWEPI1(8

You might also like