You are on page 1of 74

Chapter 11

Diaphragms and Cross Frames

Bridge Engineering 1
Introduction –Functions of diaphragms and cross frames

„ Used to resist lateral wind loads by


transferring them from the
superstructure up into the deck
„ Large stiffness of the deck in horizontal
plane will carry the loads to the supports
„ At the supports, the diaphragms or cross
frames transfer the loads down from the
deck to bearings

Bridge Engineering 2
Introduction –Functions of diaphragms and cross frames

„ They also improve vertical loads


distribution to longitudinal members
„ If closely spaced and placed at supports,
they transfer live loads more uniformly
„ They create lateral stability during
construction.

Bridge Engineering 3
Different types of bracings and diaphragms

„ Cross frames
„ X type
„ K type
„ Non-composite diaphragms
„ Composite diaphragms
„ Top chord bracing
„ Distortional bracing Steel box girder

„ Tie, etc.

Bridge Engineering 4
Different types of bracings and diaphragms

„ Bracings to reduce distortion and


rotation
„ Ties
„ Distortional bracing
„ Torsion box
„ Top chord bracing
„ End diaphragms

Bridge Engineering 5
Different types of bracings and diaphragms

Bridge Engineering 6
Different types of bracings and diaphragms

Bridge Engineering 7
Design considerations
„ Intermediate ones
„ Carry proportional to tributary area
„ End ones
„ Carry all accumulated loads to the bearings
„ Do not use too many
„ Code practice, more or less arbitrary

Bridge Engineering 8
Beam-and-Slab Bridges
„ Improve load distribution charactersitics
„ Characterizing parameters of such bridges
are:
( Dxy + D yx + D1 + D2 )
α=
2( Dx D y ) 0.5
0.25
b ⎛⎜ Dx ⎞⎟
θ= ⎜ ⎟
L ⎝ Dy ⎠
„ Minimum 2 diaphragms or bracings per
span near to one third of the span, or
Bridge Engineering 9
Beam-and-Slab Bridges
„ Minimum 3, placed at quarter and mid span
points
„ Reduced form of α is valid for characterizing
load distributions in beam and slab bridges
( Dxy + D yx )
α=
2( Dx D y ) 0.5
„
D y =(total flexural rigidity of deck plus
diaphragm)/span
„ In calculating α ignore the torsional rigidity of
the diaphragms
Bridge Engineering 10
Beam-and-Slab Bridges
„ Recommended design procedure
„ Use (α , θ ) method for slab-on-girder bridges, if
there min. 2 diaphragms per span, or 3 spans
per span
„ Calculate α as follows:

α=
(D +D )
xy yx

2(D D )0.5
x y

„ D y =(total flexural rigidity of deck plus


diaphragm)/span

Bridge Engineering 11
Beam-and-Slab Bridges
„ If plate type diaphragms, obtain effective
flexural rigidity by considering diaphragm
bending about its neutral axis
„ If cross-bracings, calculate effective moment
of inertia as follows
Ad s 3 h 2
I effective =
6 L3d
„ Ad is the cross-sectional are of diagonal members

Bridge Engineering 12
„ is the length of diagonal
Ld = s + h members
2 2

„ s is the spacing of the longitudinal girders


„ h is the depth of the cross bracing
„ Relate diaphragm size to optimum value of θ
„ No need for heavy diaphragms to achieve
optimum transverse load distribution.

Ad h

Bridge Engineering 13
Example

Bridge Engineering 14
Example

Bridge Engineering 15
Example

Bridge Engineering 16
Example

Bridge Engineering 17
Example

Bridge Engineering 18
Example

Bridge Engineering 19
Example

Bridge Engineering 20
Example

Bridge Engineering 21
Example

Bridge Engineering 22
Example

Bridge Engineering 23
Example

Bridge Engineering 24
Example

Bridge Engineering 25
Example

Bridge Engineering 26
Example

Bridge Engineering 27
Example

Bridge Engineering 28
Example

Bridge Engineering 29
Example

Bridge Engineering 30
Example

Bridge Engineering 31
Example

Bridge Engineering 32
Example

Bridge Engineering 33
Example

Bridge Engineering 34
Example

Bridge Engineering 35
Example

Bridge Engineering 36
Example

Bridge Engineering 37
Example

Bridge Engineering 38
Example

Bridge Engineering 39
Example

Bridge Engineering 40
Example

Bridge Engineering 41
Example

Bridge Engineering 42
Example

Bridge Engineering 43
Example

Bridge Engineering 44
Steel Box Girder Bridge
„ Bracings and diaphragms are to resist
wind and construction loads and
maintain stability
„ Stresses due to bending and torsion as
a result of eccentric live loads are:
„ Bending stress
„ Mixed torsion stress
„ Bending distortion stress
„ Torsional distortion stress

Bridge Engineering 45
Steel Box Girder Bridge

„ Bracing systems
„ Ties
„ Distortional bracings
„ Torsion Box
„ Top chord bracings
„ End Diaphragms

Bridge Engineering 46
Steel Box Girder Bridge
P Pc Pc Pt Pt
ex

Loading C om ponents

Pc Pc

Longitudinal bending Bending distorsion

Pt Pt
M ixed torsion Torsional distorsion

Bridge Engineering 47
Bridge Engineering 48
Bridge Engineering 49
Bridge Engineering 50
Bridge Engineering 51
Bridge Engineering 52
Bridge Engineering 53
Bridge Engineering 54
Steel Box Girder Bridge
„ Recommendations for design
1) Distortion during construction
„ Place ties at top flanges every 1/8 length
of the span (overcome distortion from
concentric construction loads)
„ Place transverse web stiffeners that
increase transverse web stiffness at least
50 times (overcome distortion due to
construction twist loads)

Bridge Engineering 55
Steel Box Girder Bridge
„ Horizontal bracing shall be placed below
the level of top flanges
„ Inter-connecting bracings shall be mounted
between boxes. These bracing systems
shall be placed at the same sections as the
interior distortional bracings

Bridge Engineering 56
Steel Box Girder Bridge
2) Overall Stability during construction
M0
„ If < 0.15 , where M 0 is the mid-span
M cr

bending moment and M cr is the cracking


moment
„ Use linear analysis with St. Venant and warping
stiffness to compute girder rotations
„ For higher loads,
„ Calculate real rotations and warping stiffness
considering non-linear effects

Bridge Engineering 57
CHBDC requirements
„ 1) General requirements
„ 5.4.6. (p 170)
„ A 5.1 d (p 202)
„ 2) Concrete
„ 8.18.5 Diaphragms (p 367)
„ 8.20.8 Concrete girder (p 371)
„ 8.22.3 Segmental construction (p 372)

Bridge Engineering 58
CHBDC requirements
„ 3) Steel
„ 10.10.9 (p 462) lateral bracing, cross –frames and
diaphragms
„ 10.10.9.1 and 10.10.9.2, 10.10.9.3
„ Load distribution & stability
„ 10.10.9 Composite beams and girders (p 462) load
distribution and stability
„ 10.12.6 Composite box girders (p 473)
„ 10.13.5 Horizontally curved girders (p 474)
„ 10.14.3 Trusses (p 480)
„ 10.16.5 Orthotropic Decks (p 482)

Bridge Engineering 59
Specific requirements

Bridge Engineering 60
CHBDC Specifications
„ End floor beams and end diaphragms under
expansion joints that are exposed to surface
runoff should be easily maintainable
„ Floor beams and diaphragms at piers and
abutments to be designed to allow jacking of
the superstructure, unless longitudinal
members can be jacked directly.

Bridge Engineering 61
CHBDC- Beams, Girders and Composite Beams

„ Spacing of intermediate diaphragms or


cross-frames:
„ Lateral torsional buckling resistance of girders
„ Need for transfer of lateral wind load
„ Need for torsional resistance due to torsion
load
„ Design for lateral load + 1% of compression
flange force, if girder not solely for lateral loads
„ If considered in analysis, design for their share
of load

Bridge Engineering 62
CHBDC- Beams, Girders and Composite Beams

„ The bracing should be stable under the


compression force that it receives from the
compression flange
„ Steel or concrete slab, if attached sufficiently to
compression flange will suffice
„ Place perpendicular to main girder, when supports
are skewed more than 20 0 and design to the force
they attract
„ Unless otherwise justified by analysis, girder spans
in excess of 50 m shall be provided with lateral
bracing at or close to bottom flanges

Bridge Engineering 63
CHBDC- Beams, Girders and Composite Beams

„ Use cross-frames and diaphragms at piers or


abutments of beam or girder bridges
„ Use cross-frames as deep as practical
„ Where practical, diaphragms shall support the
end of the deck slab.

Bridge Engineering 64
CHBDC- Composite Box Girders

„ Internal diaphragms, cross-frames or other


means, at supports to resist transverse rotation,
displacements and distortion and transfer
vertical, transverse and torsional loads to the
bearings
„ Consider the effect of access holes and provide
adequate reinforcement
„ Intermediate cross-frames and diaphragms to
be used during fabrication, transportation and
construction.

Bridge Engineering 65
CHBDC- Composite Box Girders

„ Vertical stiffeners used as connecting plates for


diaphragms or cross-frames shall be connected
to both flanges
„ Single box girder, place diaphragms and cross-
frames every 8 m unless shown cross-sectional
distortion is not critical
„ For multiple open box girders, the bracing of
top flanges of the boxes should be provided
adequately
„ Put lateral bracing at top flange of single,
through box section girders.

Bridge Engineering 66
CHBDC- Composite Box Girders

„ Design the bracings for shear flow before


concrete is cured. Also consider bending forces.
„ The structural section assumed to resist the
portion of factored horizontal wind or seismic
loading in the plane of bottom flange shall
consist of the bottom flange acting as the web
and 12 times the thickness of the webs acting
as the flanges.

Bridge Engineering 67
Horizontally curved girders
„ Unless otherwise approved, the girders shall be
connected at each support by diaphragms to resist
twisting of the girders
„ Place diaphragms or cross-frames on I girders between
supports to resist twisting. Extend them across the whole
width of the bridge.
„ Place diaphragms or cross-frames between box girders
to resist torsion. Place them inside box girders in line
with those in between girders.
„ Treat them as main elements. They shall be as deep as
the girders and shall carry all the load they attract.

Bridge Engineering 68
Horizontally curved girders
„ In addition, place extra diaphragms or cross-
frames to resist the distortional effects of
eccentric loads on the cross-section.
„ Lateral bracing for construction, wind and
service load shall be placed on top flange of I
girders or box girders.

Bridge Engineering 69
Trusses
„ Through-truss, deck-truss shall have top and
bottom lateral bracing systems.
„ If shallower than the chord, the bracing needs
approval
„ Connect the bracings to top and bottom chords
effectively
„ For through trusses, have portal bracing rigidly
connected to the end post and top chord
flanges.

Bridge Engineering 70
Trusses
„ For through trusses, portal bracings should
take the full reaction of the top chords, and
end posts should be designed accordingly.
„ For through trusses, sway bracings shall be
installed at necessary points.
„ For deck trusses, install sway bracing at the
plane of end posts.
„ For deck trusses, install sway bracing at
intermediate panel points, unless analysis
shows unnecessary.

Bridge Engineering 71
Trusses
„ For deck trusses, the sway bracing shall have
the full depth of the truss below the floor.
„ For deck trusses, the end sway bracing shall
carry the entire upper lateral forces to the
supports through the end posts.
„ Bracings between straight compression
members or flanges shall carry the shear force
due to lateral loads plus 1% of the compression
forces in the supported members.

Bridge Engineering 72
Trusses
„ Factored compressive resistance of the column
shall be at least equal to the maximum force in
any panel of the top chord resulting from loads
at the ULS.
„ Vertical truss members, floor beams, and
connections between them shall not carry less
than (ULS) 8 kN/m lateral force applied at the
top chord panel points.

Bridge Engineering 73
Orthotropic Decks

„ Place diaphragms or cross-frames at each


support, sufficient to transmit lateral forces
to the bearings and to resist transverse
rotation, displacement and distortion.
„ Place diaphragms or cross-frames at
intermediate locations consistent with the
analysis of the girders.

Bridge Engineering 74