You are on page 1of 6



Surajit Sen1, Adam Sokolow1, Robert Paul Simion1, Diankang Sun1, Robert L. Doney2,
Masami Nakagawa3, Juan H. Agui, Jr.4, and Krishna Shenai5
Department of Physics, State University of New York at Buffalo, Buffalo, New York 14260, USA
U.S. Army Research Laboratory, Aberdeen Proving Ground, Aberdeen, Maryland 21005, USA
Department of Mining Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, Colorado 80301, USA
NASA Glenn Research Center, Microgravity Research, 21000 Brookpark Road, Cleveland, Ohio 44135, USA
Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of Toledo, Toledo, Ohio 43606, USA.
Corresponding author: S. Sen, 239 Fronczak, Dept of Physics, SUNY-Buffalo, Buffalo, NY 14260-1500, USA
Phone: 1-716-645-2017, Fax: 1-716-645-2507, e-mail:

Estimates suggest that a meter of a wave front carries ~ 100 kW of power. A significant amount of renewable
energy is hence dissipated across the time scale of minutes as surface gravity waves dissipate on any beach.
Given that the majority of the world population lives near the ocean, it makes sense to explore new technologies
associated with the conversion of wave energy into electrical energy. Here we consider one such new concept –
that of a potentially scalable system that converts wave energy into pulse energy and then to a voltage drop. The
envisioned system would exploit the well studied physics of nonlinear repulsion between elastic grains to
continuously convert the incident wave energy into dispersionless energy bundles, which can be subsequently
converted to stress pulses in a piezo-electric slab. The key points involved in the concept are sketched here.

Keywords: renewable energy in oceans, mechanical to electrical energy, solitary waves, piezo-electric sensors

1. Introduction
Ocean waves form because of wind and gravity and provide us with a renewable energy source. In coastal
regions, the typical periods associated with waves range between 3 s and 25 s with a dominant frequency in the
range of 0.1 Hz (Dean 1991). A detailed discussion on the propagation of gravity waves from deep to shallow
water has been presented in the classic work of Eckart (Eckart 1952).

It is estimated that the world’s energy consumption is < 10 trillion W (TW) per year (Archer 2005). Ocean wave
energy conversion to useful forms of energy is a relatively new field (Muetze 2006). Nevertheless, estimates
suggest that there is 1-10 TW of energy in ocean waves (Boud 2003). A simple search reveals that there are
several existing approaches to extracting wave energy but nearly all of these are in their early stages and none
are able to continuously convert most of the incident energy into tunable and “bite-sized” energy pulses. Here
we present a concept that builds on decades of work on nonlinear dynamics in granular materials and developed
and/or commercially available technologies to convert the energy in waves as they come ashore to useful forms
of electrical energy.

We argue that by using simple alignments of elastic spheres (Sen 2003) it is possible to convert the energy in a
wave that is incident in one end of the alignment to a series of stress pulses at the other end. By placing
appropriate piezo-electric slabs at the opposite end of the alignment, the stress pulses can be converted to a
voltage drop (Elvin 2001). The system is modular and arrays of alignments may be exploited to scale up the
energy recovery process.

This paper is arranged as follows. Section 2 focuses on the details of converting the ocean wave energy into
mechanical pulses. Section 3 briefly discusses the role of the piezo-electric sensors. Section 4 summarizes this

2. Conversion of Ocean Waves to Controlled Mechanical Pulses

Let us consider an axially aligned set of elastic spheres encased in a cylinder. We assume that there is a movable
piston at one end of the cylinder and a wall at the other end. We consider the wall to be a piezo-electric slab that
International Conference on ‘Advances in Energy Research’, (ICAER) 2007
can generate an electric field in response to a stress. When an impulse is incident at one end of such an
alignment, it ends up propagating as a non-dispersive energy bundle or as a solitary wave (Nesterenko 1983,
Sinkovits 1995, Sen 2001). The solitary wave would produce a stress pulse through the piezo-electric slab when
it reaches the other end and hence would generate an electric field. This simple idea, extended to incorporate
energy transport through granular chains for long-lived pulses, is the underlying principle behind the present
concept for energy recovery from ocean waves.

Figure 1: Normalized total kinetic (black) and potential (red) energies for 12 different tapered chain systems are shown.
Total system energy is constant to approximately 1 part in 1012. Each subplot element is characterized by a specific tapering
q and number of particles in the chain, N. Panels (a,d,g,j) represent a monodisperse chain of increasing length such that
panel (j) is the longest tapered chain and panel (c) is the shortest. For clarity, each subplot only shows the first 20% of the
total simulation time.

We now ask two fundamental questions – first, how do we know that the concept is workable and second, if
there is room for a concept such as this one when it comes to ocean energy recovery. There are presently several
technologies that are potentially available to recover energy carried by ocean waves – these include floating
buoys that sway as waves pass by and the energy associated with the swaying motion is converted to electricity,
turbine wheels turned by wave power and more. Here we envision systems that are made out of a large number
of cylinders comprised of spherical grains in contact and between walls, placed in close-packing and encased in
chambers. At one end of each cylinder there would be some piston-like structure that can respond to the force
exerted by the waves. At the other end there would be appropriately designed piezo-electric slabs or tiles with
International Conference on ‘Advances in Energy Research’, (ICAER) 2007
associated circuitry that would convert the mechanical pulses into electrical voltage. The chambers themselves
are envisioned to be fastened to some stable rock structure such that they would not be easily affected by the
constant onslaught of the waves. The present concept may be most useful in places where there is an abundance
of rocky beaches and strong waves. An operating version of the system is expected to be inexpensive to
manufacture and install, require low maintenance, not in need of a significant input power supply, and not likely
to pollute the environment. We now discuss the underlying physics of the work.

We first consider the dynamical behavior of the individual alignments of equal sized spherical elastic grains
placed within the confining walls of a cylinder. The centers of the grains should lie along the axis of the cylinder
to minimize frictional losses. The grains can be metallic, glassy or even polymeric. Most of the studies,

Figure 2: (Top panel) The monodisperse granular chain is shown with a piston on the left side of the system
and with a wall on the right end of the syste, the piezo-electric sensor may be placed in lieu of the wall;
(bottom panel) The total energy (Etot), Kinetic Energy (KE) and Potential Energy (PE) of a granular chain
with N=20, q=14% is shown as a function of time.
theoretical and simulational as well as experimental, have been carried out for metallic grains which tend to offer
low dissipation and are hence best suited for our purpose. We first summarize what happens when a delta
function impulse is incident at one end of the alignment. Initially, of course, all energy received by the edge
grain would be kinetic. This edge grain will press against the next grain, which would then press against the one
adjacent to it and push back the edge grain, etc. In the process, the initial kinetic energy will end up being
converted to part kinetic energy and part potential energy. When the pulse reaches the piezo-electric slab at the
other end, both potential and kinetic energies are transferred to the piezo-electric slab and hence the pulse can be
converted to an electrical voltage. The chain is a way to convert a sharp impulse into a specific form of energy
pulse or bundle. It has been discussed elsewhere that the properties of the energy bundle can be tuned by
manipulating the chain geometry (Sen 2001).

Elastic grains repel upon intimate contact via the Hertz law (Hertz 1881). Suppose there are two grains with radii
Ri and Ri+1. Let these grains be a distance xi,i+1 apart upon intimate contact. The overlap between the grains is
defined as δi,i+1 = Ri + Ri+1 – xi,i+1 ≥ 0. According to Hertz law, the repulsive potential is V(δi,i+1) = ai,i+1δi,i+1n,
where ai,i+1=(2/5D)(RiRi+1/[Ri+Ri+1])1/2, D=(3/2)(1-σ2)/Y, where σ is the Poisson ratio for the material and Y is
the bulk Young’s modulus and for spheres, n=5/2. The Hertz potential is softer than the harmonic potential (n=2
case) at small enough compressions but quickly exceeds the magnitude of the harmonic potential upon increased
compression. Energy transport between the grains interacting only via the Hertz potential is known to be
approximately “ballistic” (Nesterenko 1983, Sen 2001). Careful analysis shows that energy transport between
spherical grains is mediated via traveling energy bundles or solitary waves that are about 5 grain diameters wide
(Sen 2001). When n=2, the average kinetic and average potential energies of the system are equal to half the total
International Conference on ‘Advances in Energy Research’, (ICAER) 2007
energy. When n>2, the average kinetic energy exceeds the average potential energy and this sets the time scale
for pulse propagation through the chain and also the width of the pulse. Thus an ability to control the potential
energy can potentially allow us to control pulse propagation. In addition to examining pulse propagation in
systems where all grains have the same radii, we have also studied cases where the grains progressively shrink
along the chain such that Ri+1=(1-q)Ri, where q is the tapering percentage. When q>0, the energy pulse
accelerates as it propagates down the chain and the solitary wave breaks down. Figure 1 presents the details of
energy propagation through various chains consisting of N=20 grains placed between rigid end walls and
subjected to a delta function perturbation from one end. It can be seen that for typical metallic systems (e.g.,
titanium-aluminum alloys which have been used in the simulations reported in Figure 1) a pulse takes ~ 1
millisecond to travel along an N=20 chain. We consider chains with and without restitutional losses. The
restitutional loss w is defined in our system as follows: Funload/Fload = 1 – w, where w is the restitution constant,
typically between 0.01 and 0.1. A typical restitution coefficient may lie between 0.04 and 0.08 or so. We have
talked only about delta function impulses. Below we consider what happens when one edge is subjected to
longer-lived perturbations, i.e., we address whether one can one convert a long lived wave pulse into a finite set
of energy bundles that can easily generate a significant voltage drop. Such a step would mean that the power of
the wave can be efficiently packaged and harvested.

An incident ocean wave would be expected to generate ~ several seconds of acceleration on the edge grain of an
appropriately placed granular alignment (see Section 1). This would be the equivalent of several hundred round
trips of a single pulse. We therefore assume that an incident ocean wave would generate an approximately
constant acceleration on the edge grain for a “large enough” length of time so that for practical purposes we do

700 1
650 5

600 10
550 15
0 10 20 30 40 60
q (in %)

1/ 6
Figure 3: Here we show the dependence of the scaled quantity TF versus tapering q for a variety of
values of the applied force F (in kN) at the left edge. The time period T is measured in microseconds.

not have to worry about when the acceleration might end. We now ask how the confined granular alignment
would behave. To this end we numerically solve the coupled Newton’s equation of motion for every grain in the
chain using a velocity Verlet algorithm (Allen 1987) by assuming that one wall is a piston and the other is a
piezo-electric slab. We calculate the dynamical variables such as position, velocity, and acceleration of every
grain in the system as functions of time. The kinetic, potential, and total energies of the system are hence
obtained. Figure 2 presents our calculations for the case in which one end of the chain is driven by a constant
force. The results are robust enough such that small scale force fluctuations do not significantly affect our

The underlying physics associated with the time dependent behavior of the total energy and the kinetic and
potential energies can be described as follows. A constant acceleration is felt by an edge grain at all times. This
acceleration leads to over-compression of the system resulting in the peaks in system potential energy and the
associated dips in the system kinetic energy in Figure 2 (lower panel). The over-compression eventually leads to
strong enough outward acceleration of the grains, including the edge grain, such that the system subsequently
undergoes a dilation phase until the applied constant acceleration of the edge grain begins to dominate and the
above process repeats itself. If F is the average magnitude of the applied constant force and T is the breathing
period we find that TF1/6=constant for fixed q (see Figure 3). By tuning q, one can hence control T.

The breathing process of a system under driving could eventually cease because the energy pumped into the
system due to the driving is less than the energy lost due to restitutional losses. Under such circumstances, our
exploratory studies suggest that the number of breaths of the system is inversely proportional to the restitution

International Conference on ‘Advances in Energy Research’, (ICAER) 2007

coefficient w. We find that the product of the number of breaths and the restitution coefficient w appears to be a
constant independent of the tapering in the chain, i.e., independent of the details of energy transport within the
chain. The behavior of these systems when the energy input exceeds energy lost is not well understood at this
time. The breathing would generate periodic stresses on the piezo-electric slab. In Section 3 below we briefly
outline how such stresses can be converted to voltage drops.

3. Pulses onto Piezo-Electric Sensors to Voltage Drops

In piezo-electric materials such as the slab mentioned above, an applied stress results in an electrical voltage
(Ikeda 1996). The process is reversible in the sense that an applied voltage also generates a mechanical stress.
Due to the space restrictions here we refrain from developing what would have to be a formidable mathematical
discussion of the process of conversion of the periodic mechanical stresses on the piezo-electric slabs into
voltage that will be generated where the crystal is placed in an appropriate circuit. We focus instead on how the
piezo-electric slab can be used to harvest power.
A well known way to convert the applied stresses on a piezo-electric slab to a voltage is as follows. The
approach involves a typical power harvesting circuit as shown in Figure 4 below (Horowitz 1989, Elvin 2001).
Here a half-diode-bridge is connected to a charging capacitor. The resistor R across the charging capacitor is
added to the circuit to take into account voltage leakage. The voltage generated on the capacitor can be modeled

Figure 4: The top panel shows a half-bridge power harvester with a leakage resistant R. The lower panel
sketches the typical form of the voltage generated in the capacitor as a function of time under sinusoidal
using electric circuit simulation software. Results of a typical simulation (Elvin 2001) are displayed in the V vs t
sketch in Figure 4. The model calculations reveal that the voltage on the capacitor increases on each positive
value of the load.

4. Summary and Conclusions

To summarize, we have argued that ocean waves release a tremendous amount of energy as they come ashore.
This energy is largely wasted. If the energy in ocean waves can be harvested, it could solve at least a significant
fraction of the world’s energy needs. To harvest ocean energy it would be important to efficiently and
inexpensively convert the energy into useful forms of energy such as into a electrical energy. Here we show that
it may be possible to design assemblies of granular chains that would be able to convert wave energy into bite-
sized chunks or bundles of mechanical energy. The mechanical energy bundles can be next converted via a half-
bridge power harvester with a piezo-electric slab into a potential drop. An assembly of granular chains with the
appropriate circuitry and casing may be firmly embedded on rock surfaces and/or beaches where the waves come
ashore. The system could potentially be a relatively inexpensive one to construct and maintain.

This work has been supported by the US Army Research Office.

Allen, M.P. and D.J. Tildesley, 1987, Computer Simulation of Liquids, Clarendon, Oxford.
Archer, C. L. and M. Z. Jacobson, 2005, Evaluation of global windpower. J. Geophys. Res.-Atm., 110, D12110
Boud, R, 2003, Status and Research and Development Priorities, Wave and Marine Accessed Energy, UK Dept.
of Trade and Industry (DTI), DTI Report # FES-R-132, AEAT Report # AEAT/ENV/1054.

International Conference on ‘Advances in Energy Research’, (ICAER) 2007

Dean, R.G. and R.A. Dalrymple, 1991, Water Wave Mechanics for Engineers and Scientists, World Scientific,
Teaneck, New Jersey.
Eckart, C., 1952, The propagation of gravity waves from deep to shallow water, Nat’l Bur of Stds., Circular 521,
Washington, DC., 165-173.
Elvin, N.G., A.A. Elvin and M. Spector, 2001, A Self-Powered Mechanical Energy Strain Sensor, Smart Mater.
Struct. 10, 293-299.
Hertz, H., 1881, Ueber die beruehrung fester elastischer koerper, J. reine u. angew. Math. 92, 156-171.
Horowitz, P., 1989, The Art of Electronics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Ikeda, T., 1996, Fundamentals of Piezoelectricity, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Muetze, A. and J.G. Vining, 2006, Ocean Wave Energy Conversion – A Survey, Proc of IEEE/Industry
Applications Society 41st Annual Meeting, Tampa, Florida.
Nesterenko, V.F., 1983, Propagation of nonlinear compression pulses in granular media, J. Appl. Mech. Tech.
Phys. 5, 733-743.
Sen, S. and M. Manciu, 2001, Solitary wave dynamics in generalized Hertz chains: An improved solution of the
equation of motion, Phys. Rev. E 64, 056605-1-056605-4.
Sen, S., S. Chakravarti, D.P. Visco, Jr., M. Nakagawa, J. Agui, Jr. and D.T. Wu, 2003, Impulse propagation in
granular systems, Proceedings of PASI on Modern Challenges in Statistical Mechanics, American Inst of Physics
Conference Proceedings, vol. 658, 357-379 Eds. V.M. Kenkre and K. Lindenberg American Institute of
Physics, New York.
Sinkovits, R.S. and S. Sen, 1995, Nonlinear dynamics in granular columns, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 2686-2689.

International Conference on ‘Advances in Energy Research’, (ICAER) 2007