Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3
SPRING 2015 | VOL. 16 NO. 1
Dear Friends,
This is my first letter to you, the readers of Alert, since becoming
president of MSF-USA’s Board of Directors following Dr. Deane
Marchbein’s tenure. It is a tremendous privilege to serve in this
position and to function as, among other duties, an interface
between MSF’s supporters and those we seek to assist.
My interactions with MSF began in a formal sense in 2008, respite in another region of their country, or beyond its
when my application to work in the field as a surgeon borders?
was accepted. During the subsequent “Information Days” Our teams work with people living with the consequences
orientation in New York, I received both a broader sense of these impossible decisions every day. And this fall, in an
of what field work would be like and a T-shirt linked to an attempt to convey what we see to our supporters and the
MSF-USA campaign called “A Refugee Camp in the Heart public at large, MSF-USA will launch a multi-year, multi-
of the City.” The shirt—which I still have—had printed on city exhibit called Forced From Home. This exhibit, which
the back in large characters: “33 million people uprooted kicks off in New York City on September 16, personalizes
by war.” I thought then that it was unfathomable that so the experiences of individuals fleeing conflict and other
many people could be displaced by conflict and so little crises, illustrating in fine relief (and even in virtual reality)
attention paid to their plight. both the challenges they face and the nature of MSF’s
Now, just eight years later, the number of people displaced emergency response.
globally has almost doubled, to an astonishing 65.3 We also hope that Forced From Home and its attendant
million. There seems to be a greater awareness of this events and discussions might counter prejudices, fear,
unwillingly itinerant population, but the tenor of discussion and xenophobia to inspire dialogue about the commonal-
around them is often degrading, demeaning, and alarmist. ity of humanity and the rights we all seek and deserve as
Worse still, some governments and others are working to human beings. This issue of Alert will tell you much more
turn away the displaced rather than uphold their obliga- about Forced From Home and its various elements, as will
tions to accept them under international law. forcedfromhome.com. We hope you will find it compelling,
For my part, I have performed eight surgical missions and we hope you will join us if and when you can.
with MSF since 2008. Most were in or adjacent to conflict
settings, so I’ve seen firsthand both the toll war takes on
With regards,
individuals—especially civilians—and the ways in which it
decimates health systems, families, and the broader fabric
of societies. In far too many places, people must make
the most painful of choices: Do they try to endure life in a
land where education, employment, food insecurity, and JOHN LAWRENCE, MD, MPH
the safety of one’s family are in constant jeopardy, or seek President, MSF-USA Board of Directors
NOT SINCE THE UPHEAVAL OF WORLD WAR II HAVE THERE BEEN SO MANY
DISPLACED PEOPLE ON THIS PLANET AT ONE TIME.
It’s shocking, given all the talk of progress in our modern age, but there In theory, their status as refugees, when confirmed, should afford
are now some 65.3 million people who have been forced from home them a raft of legal rights and protections in the countries in which they
globally. That’s nearly as many people as live in all of France. It’s more arrive. In practice, it doesn’t always work that way. They have more op-
than live in South Africa or South Korea. It’s roughly equal to the com- tions than IDPs, however, who technically remain under the jurisdiction of
bined populations of Texas and California. And yet the number, while their home governments, even if they are fleeing those same authorities.
shocking, amounts to less than 1 percent of the world’s population, Wherever they are from, whatever their reason for fleeing, every
underscoring the degree to which the international community could, displaced person has a story—of fear, of a family torn apart, of a home
but is failing to, meet their needs and its own obligations. destroyed, of mourning, of loss, of death, of dislocation. Perhaps a
Nearly a third of these people are refugees who were driven out of barrel bomb falling on their house finally pushed them out the door. Or
their countries by war, privation, persecution, or some other factor, and a sectarian or ethnically motivated massacre. Or lack of food. Or simple
who cannot yet return. Almost all of the rest are “internally displaced desperation. However the decision was reached, it insured that life
people,” or IDPs, which is to say that they are seeking sanctuary some- would never be the same.
where within their own borders. In 2015, some 12.4 million people were The hope, of course, is that life might get better, or safer, or that, at
newly displaced—most of them in or from Iraq, Syria, South Sudan, the very least, an individual might put some distance between them-
Democratic Republic of Congo, and Nigeria. This amounted to roughly selves and whatever they are fleeing. In some cases, that happens. Far
34,000 men, women, and children leaving the homes and lives they more common, though, are uncertainty, separation, and a terrifying
knew, under profound duress, every day. gauntlet of traffickers, criminal gangs, predators, corrupt border guards,
Refugees come from a host of countries, but more than half are and others who rob, beat, or sexually abuse people during their journeys.
from Syria, Afghanistan, or Somalia. Similarly, their destinations are There are medical consequences to all this. Our teams see them
numerous, but the largest congregations can be found in countries every day in countries like South Sudan, Syria, Colombia, Mexico,
neighboring those listed above—Turkey, Pakistan, Lebanon, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Central African Republic, Lebanon, Jordan,
Ethiopia, and Jordan. Half of all refugees are younger than 18. Iraq, France, Greece, and elsewhere. Broken limbs to respiratory tract
infections, fuel burns to skin diseases, sexual abuse to post-traumatic
stress disorder—many afflictions are directly related to their flight
ABOVE: Refugees crossing from Greece into Macedonia. © Borja Ruiz Rodriguez
3
A GLOBAL DISPLACEMENT EMERGENCY
About
50%
12.4 1.8 million of the refugee
were newly displaced refugees
million population
consisted of
people were
newly displaced children
in 2015. under 18 years
of age in 2015.
8.6 million
were displaced within
their own country
SMTWTFS
34,000
60% people were displaced
from their homes per day
are from Iraq, Syria, Nigeria,
South Sudan, and DRC. in 2015
N
A
TA USA ANCE
LI
IS FR
N
N RIA
A
SY
PA
M
A
JA
GH
O
S
AF
CH MANY
2.7
INA
1.1 4.9 ER
G
UK
million million million
Source: Oxfam
COUNTRIES OF ORIGIN
MYANMAR
451,800
SUDAN
CHAD 628,800 ERITREA
369,500 411,300
SOMALIA
SOUTH SUDAN ETHIOPIA 1.1M
778,700 736,100
CAR TOP 10 TOP 10
471,100 COUNTRIES COUNTRIES
OF ORIGIN OF ARRIVAL
DEFINITIONS
UNHCR: The United Nations High Refugee: A person who has crossed a Economic Migrant: A person who
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) is national border to another country to voluntarily leaves their home country
a UN agency mandated to protect and escape conflict or persecution due to to live in another country with
support refugees at the request of a their race, religion, nationality or mem- ostensibly better working or living
government or the UN itself. It assists bership of a particular social group and conditions.
in their voluntary repatriation, local “is unable or unwilling to return to their Legal Status/Rights: Economic migrants
integration, or resettlement to a third country of origin owing to a well-found- are not eligible for protection under
country. ed fear” of further persecution or harm. international refugee law or eligible to
1951 Refugee Convention: The 1951 Legal Status/Rights: Signatories to the receive many types of aid since their
Geneva Convention, the main Geneva Conventions are obligated to take journeys are considered voluntary.
international instrument of refugee in refugees who arrive at their borders.
Asylum seeker: A refugee who seeks
law, spells out who is a refugee and the They should not be expelled or sent back
longer-term legal harbor in another
legal protections, assistance, and rights to their country of origin.
country, applying for sanctuary
he or she should be afforded from the IDP (Internally Displaced Person): (asylum) in hopes that that country will
countries that signed the document. A person who has been forced to flee grant it.
The Convention also defines a refugee’s home for the same reason as a refugee Legal rights: It depends to a degree on the
obligations to host governments. but remains in their own country. country in which one applies, but countries
The Convention initially focused on are obligated to review asylum applications
Legal Status/Rights: IDPs are not eligible
European refugees in the aftermath in due time—although “due time” is a
for protection under international refugee
of World War II, but later addendums very subjective measurement, and asylum
law or eligible to receive many types of
expanded its scope globally. seekers are often held in detention until
aid since they still remain within jurisdic-
tion of their own national government. their applications are reviewed.
5
and the conditions they endure. They must also cope with the loss of less than 9 percent of the world’s refugees (and Germany has taken in
whatever medical care they had before—the maternity services, par- a third of those).
ticularly when it comes to complicated pregnancies; the pharmacy that The outcome is a massive, moving population with little access to
provided heart medications; the hospital that provided dialysis; the crucial, even lifesaving services. In addition to its medical work, there-
emergency rooms that tended to acute crises. All that they were forced fore, MSF launched its “Safe Passage” campaign, calling on European
to leave behind. governments to assist people fleeing war and oppression, as they are
MSF provides emergency medical and psychological services people obligated to do. We have protested the EU-Turkey deal vociferously, de-
cannot otherwise access. We also care for malnourished children and, if crying a cynical, dehumanizing compact that threatens to send people
need be, distribute shelter materials and provide clean drinking water. As back into the very war zones from which they escaped.
the numbers have risen and the movement patterns have changed, MSF In the US, we are taking a much closer look at the political and hu-
has tried to adapt projects accordingly. This has meant launching search manitarian dynamics around migrants and refugees—and people who
and rescue boats in the Mediterranean, pushing pharmaceutical com- should be designated refugees but are not—in Central America, where
panies to make crucial vaccinations more affordable for people in crisis the US and Mexico have worked together to prevent Hondurans and
zones, and designing projects to be responsive to the needs teams see Salvadorans from fleeing forced gang recruitment and violence that
on the ground, from emergency obstetrics to mental health counseling has resulted in death tolls on par with full-fledged civil wars in other
to vaccinations to chronic disease care, and everything in between. countries. And to bring all of this together, we are launching a three-year,
But MSF must also serve as witness and advocate, not least nationwide exhibition called Forced From Home this fall in New York City,
because the response of many governments to the uptick in displace- an exhibition conceived of and designed to convey as immediately as
possible the experiences of displaced people the world over, along with
the experience of our staff members who have worked with them.
Wherever they are from, whatever their reason for The time and place of the launch—September 16, in Queens, New
York—will coincide with a United Nations summit on refugees. It will
fleeing, every displaced person has a story—of
then move to Manhattan the following week, before traveling onwards
fear, of a family torn apart, of a home destroyed, to Washington, DC, Boston, Pittsburgh, and Philadelphia this fall. Panel
of mourning, of loss, of death, of dislocation. discussions and other events will be staged in each city to further ex-
amine the issues. And Forced From Home will visit other regions of the
US in the spring and fall of the following two years. (See page 13 and
ment has been disappointing, to say the least. International order and forcedfromhome.com for more information.)
solidarity mechanisms born of the post-World War II era, while still Visitors will be led through the exhibition by experienced MSF staffers.
in place on paper, are fraying badly. The European Union, for example, They will see 360-degree and virtual reality video filmed in displace-
contracted with Turkey to prevent refugees from reaching its shores. ment settings over the past two years. They will learn about the “push
Numerous countries have shut their borders for fear (justified, in some factors” that drive people from their homes, the choices people have
cases) of being overwhelmed by more people than their resources to make—what to take, who to take, where to go—when they leave, and
can accommodate. Others have ignored their responsibilities under the logistics of providing medical care to populations on the move.
longstanding conventions on refugees, failing to provide safe harbor for You can read much more about the exhibition in the pages that fol-
people who are, by international law, entitled to it. Some lecture others low. We hope you will join us in whatever capacity you can.
on what they should do, without following through themselves.
Oftentimes, it seems a question of will and intent, not resources.
TOP, LEFT TO RIGHT: Middle Eastern refugees in Croatia in 2015. © Juan Carlos
Poorer countries, in fact, shoulder most of the burden, as a recent Tomasi; People being rescued by MSF teams in the Mediterranean. © Alessandro
Oxfam report pointed out, and the six richest countries in the world— Penso; Refugees from Central African Republic in Chad in 2014. © MSF
the US, China, Japan, France, the UK, and Germany, which collectively BOTTOM, LEFT TO RIGHT: Displaced people in South Sudan in 2014. © Jean-
comprise nearly three-fifths of the world’s economy—have welcomed Pierre Amigo/MSF; A refugee rescued in the Mediterranean disembarks in Italy in
2015. © Francesco Zizola; Burundian refugees in Tanzania in 2015. © Luca Sola
WHY ARE YOU FOCUSING ON DISPLACEMENT? suffering that drive people to risk their lives for the chance of a better
Some 65 million people are currently fleeing conflict or persecution and safer future.
worldwide. Due to their race, religion, or nationality, these people’s Forced From Home provides MSF an opportunity to speak out on
homes are no longer safe places to live and their governments cannot behalf of our many beneficiaries around the world who may not have a
or will not provide protection or assistance. way to speak for themselves.
MSF works around the world to provide refugees and IDPs with
urgently needed assistance, from psychological care to lifesaving nutri- WHERE IS FORCED FROM HOME GOING FIRST?
tion. Among other services, MSF sets up hospitals in refugee camps, Forced From Home is visiting New York, Washington, DC, Boston,
helps women give birth safely, vaccinates children to prevent epidemics, Pittsburgh, and Philadelphia in 2016, with more cities and events to be
and provides access to safe drinking water. announced in 2017. Visit www.forcedfromhome.com to plan your visit
and sign up for updates.
WHY AN EVENT LIKE THIS?
While delivering emergency medical care across a wide range of coun-
BELOW: An Afghan family prepares to cross from Macedonia into Greece in
tries and continents, MSF sees firsthand the horrific conditions and 2015. © Alessandro Penso
AFGHANISTAN
“My dream is peace in Afghanistan,
but I know that is not possible
now. So we left to live somewhere
without fighting.”
—Haseeb, 13, fled Afghanistan with his mother
Brutal, indiscriminate conflict across Afghanistan, along with a wholesale lack of hope in a better future, has displaced more than one million people
internally and forced millions more to flee the country. Many seek refuge in neighboring Iran and Pakistan, but tens of thousands of Afghans have
also risked their lives, paying thousands of dollars to travel in airless vehicles and dangerously unstable boats, in a desperate bid to reach Europe.
Many who survive end up stranded at closed borders, deprived of basic services, with little or no information about what comes next.
Syria’s catastrophic war has killed hundreds of thousands of people, driven nearly 5 million from the country, and displaced some 6.6 million inter-
nally (as of July 2016). Civilian areas and hospitals are bombed routinely, and the provision of even basic aid is severely restricted by administrative
obstacles, insecurity, and outright threats. Where and when possible, MSF provides care for displaced people inside Syria, supports hospitals and
other emergency medical projects run by Syrian medical professionals, and works with Syrian refugees in surrounding countries.
SYRIA
“It was hell. I didn’t think I would survive such a journey. But I had no choice. I accepted everything
[in return] for my safekeeping and that of my family.” — B ahar, Syrian refugee and former MSF aid worker,
Domiz Refugee Camp, Iraq
9
Forced From Home
FORCED FROM HOME EXHIBIT MAP
LEGAL STATUS
ON THE MOVE
BASIC NEEDS
3
PUSH FACTORS
4
360° 2
VIDEO DOME 5
1 6
MEDICAL
NEEDS
7
DESTINATIONS 9
VIRTUAL
REALITY
TAKE ACTION: EXPERIENCE
LEARN HOW YOU
CAN HELP
11
Forced From Home
MEET YOUR GUIDES
Each Forced From Home tour will be led by an experienced MSF
aid worker who knows the issues and the challenges first hand.
Here are just a few of the MSF team members working to bring
the exhibition to life:
SARAH KHENATI
Hometown: Verdun, France
Occupation: Psychologist
Age: 33
MSF Assignments: Central African Republic,
Occupied Palestinian Territories
Visit forcedfromhome.com for more infor- WASHINGTON, DC: Meeting the Unique Medical Needs of
mation, including directions, and to register, Migrants and Refugees
EXHIBITION:
or to watch live simultaneous webcasts of October 18, 2016: 7:30 p.m.
WASHINGTON MONUMENT
the events. Old South Meeting House
October 1- October 9, 2016
MSF has long treated displaced people along
Visit Forced From Home in the shadow of
every stage of their journey. What’s new is the
NEW YORK, NY: the Washington Monument, just south of the
massive numbers of displaced people and
EXHIBITION: Smithsonian’s National Museum of African
the scope of their medical conditions. Hear
NEW YORK HALL OF SCIENCE American History and Culture and directly
aid workers discuss how this has challenged
September 16 – September 20, 2016 west of the National Mall.
MSF’s time-tested methods of providing
Forced From Home opens in the most diverse EVENTS: emergency medical supplies and treatment.
borough of the most diverse city in the United Reporting from the Frontlines of the Global
States, at the New York Hall of Science in Refugee Crisis
Corona, Queens. October 3, 2016: 2:00 p.m. PITTSBURGH, PA
BATTERY PARK CITY ESPLANADE Knight Studio at Newseum EXHIBITION:
September 23 - September 27, 2016 Journalists and MSF staff examine the ethics SCHENLEY PLAZA
Take in the views of the Statue of Liberty as and challenges of reporting on the largest October 27 - October 31, 2016
Forced From Home moves into Manhattan, displacement crisis in modern history. Forced From Home comes to Pittsburgh’s
just south of North Cove Yacht Harbor, a short Migrant or Refugee? Central America’s community green space, between the Carn-
walk from Brookfield Place. Migration Reality egie and Hillman Libraries, the Cathedral of
October 6, 2016: 7:30 p.m. Learning, and the Frick Fine Arts Building.
EVENTS:
What We See: Stories from the Global National Geographic Grosvenor Auditorium EVENTS:
Refugee Crisis Parts of Central America are marred by The Global Refugee Crisis: Flight and
September 13, 2016: 7:30 p.m. extreme violence that forces residents to flee Resettlement
Tishman Auditorium at The New School and undertake a treacherous journey through October 26, 2016: 7:30 p.m.
Aid workers discuss the ways displacement Mexico. MSF aid workers, project coordina- Carnegie Library (Oakland), Lecture Hall
has affected MSF patients, and MSF-USA tors, and outside experts discuss this crisis, How do refugees arrive in the US, and what
executive director Jason Cone explains why along with the challenges facing those who happens when they get here? Local resettle-
it is vitally important for MSF to speak out on reach the US. ment agencies join MSF to discuss the press-
these issues. Additionally, the crisis will be ing needs and challenges in the Pittsburgh
brought back to the local level: how do we see BOSTON, MA area, issues that are mirrored in communities
the impact in New York City? Hosted by The throughout the country.
EXHIBITION:
New School.
LONG WHARF
The Global Refugee Crisis: Humanitarian October 15 – October 23, 2016 PHILADELPHIA, PA
Needs and International Policy Visit Forced From Home at Boston’s historic EXHIBITION:
September 21, 2016: 7:30 p.m. pier, steps from historic Faneuil Hall and INDEPENDENCE MALL
The Great Hall, Cooper Union Christopher Columbus Waterfront Park. November 5 – November 13, 2016
The Special Advisor for the UN Summit on
EVENTS: Forced From Home comes to America’s most
Refugees and senior leaders from other
BostonTalks Investigates: Health Care for historic square mile. Visit our exhibit in Phila-
international NGOs join MSF for a high-level
Refugee Women delphia’s famous national historical park.
discussion on the state of the global response
to the refugee crisis. Hosted by Cooper Union October 12, 2016: 7:00 p.m. EVENTS:
Office of Continuing Education & Public WGBH Studios Frontline Doctors: Winter Migrant Crisis
Programs. In partnership with WGBH BostonTalks November 10, 2016: 7:30 p.m.
Investigates, MSF midwives and a mental The Academy of Natural Sciences
health counselor will discuss the unique and MSF presents a special BBC One documentary
pressing health challenges facing the nearly that examines the migration crisis in Europe,
30 million women currently forcibly displaced sharing the stories of patients treated by MSF
from their homes. and other NGOs. The screening will be fol-
lowed by a discussion with MSF staff.
13
Events
DONOR PROFILE
15
Supporting MSF
333 Seventh Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10001-5004
Doctors Without Borders/
T 212-679-6800 F 212-679-7016 Médecins Sans Frontières
www.doctorswithoutborders.org
(MSF) works in nearly
70 countries providing
medical aid to those most
in need regardless of their
race, religion, or political
affiliation.
US Headquarters
333 Seventh Avenue, 2nd Floor • New York, NY 10001-5004 • T 212-679-6800 • F 212-679-7016
www.doctorswithoutborders.org
Alert is a quarterly newsletter sent to friends and supporters of Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières
(MSF). As a private, international, nonprofit organization, MSF delivers emergency medical relief to victims of war
and disaster, regardless of politics, race, religion, or ethnicity.
Doctors Without Borders is recognized as a nonprofit, charitable organization under Section 501(c)(3) of the
Internal Revenue Code. All contributions are tax-deductible to the fullest extent allowed by law.
Editor: Phil Zabriskie • Deputy Editor: Elias Primoff • Contributors: Kim Daley, Leila Fuleihan, Melissa Pracht
Design and Information Graphics: Melanie Doherty Design • Comments: alert_editor@msf.org
US Headquarters
333 Seventh Avenue, 2nd Floor | New York, NY 10001-5004 | T 212-679-6800 F 212-679-7016
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT: South Sudanese
www.doctorswithoutborders.org refugees in Ethiopia. © Lexi Cole; An Iraqi
Alert is a quarterly newsletter sent to friends and supporters of Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières refugee family in Greece. © Mohammad
(MSF). As a private, international, nonprofit organization, MSF delivers emergency medical relief to victims of war Ghannam; Burundian refugees in Tanzania.
and disaster, regardless of politics, race, religion, or ethnicity. © Luca Sola; A Syrian refugee family in
Doctors Without Borders is recognized as a nonprofit, charitable organization under Section 501(c)(3) of the Greece. © Alex Yallop; A Burundian refugee
Internal Revenue Code. All contributions are tax-deductible to the fullest extent allowed by law. in Tanzania. © Luca Sola; Syrian refugees in
Serbia. © Achilleas Zavallis
Editorial Director: Phil Zabriskie | Deputy Editor: Elias Primoff | Contributors: Jessica Brown, Leila Fuleihan,
Katherine Smith | Design and Information Graphics: Melanie Doherty Design | Comments: alert_editor@msf.org COVER: Afghan men, women, and
children aboard a flimsy rubber raft in
the Mediterranean, soon before they
were rescued by MSF teams working with
Greenpeace. © Will Rose