You are on page 1of 76

Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 1 of 76 PageID #: 3285

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

CRYSTALLEX INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION;

Plaintiff,

v. C.A. No. 17-mc-151-LPS

BO LIV ARIAN REPUBLIC OF VENEZUELA,


PUBLIC VERSION
RELEASED AUGUST 10, 2018
Defendant.

Raymond J. DiCamillo, Jeffrey L. Moyer, Travis S. Hunter, RICHARDS, LAYTON & FINGER,
P.A., Wilmington, DE

Robert L. Weigel, Jason W. Myatt, Rahim Moloo, GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP, New
York, NY

Miguel A. Estrada, GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP, Washington, DC

Attorneys for Plaintiff.

Samuel T. Hirzel, IT, HEYMAN ENERIO GATTUSO & HIRZEL LLP, Wilmington, DE

Joseph D. Pizzuro, Kevin A. Meehan, Julia B. Mosse, Juan 0 . Perla, CURTIS, MALLET-
PREVOST, COLT & MOSLE LLP, New York, NY

Attorneys for Intervenor Petr6leos de Venezuela, S.A.

OPINION

August 9, 2018
Wilmington, Delaware
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 2 of 76 PageID #: 3286
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 3 of 76 PageID #: 3287
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 4 of 76 PageID #: 3288
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 5 of 76 PageID #: 3289
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 6 of 76 PageID #: 3290
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 7 of 76 PageID #: 3291
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 8 of 76 PageID #: 3292
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 9 of 76 PageID #: 3293
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 10 of 76 PageID #: 3294
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 11 of 76 PageID #: 3295
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 12 of 76 PageID #: 3296
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 13 of 76 PageID #: 3297
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 14 of 76 PageID #: 3298
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 15 of 76 PageID #: 3299
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 16 of 76 PageID #: 3300
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 17 of 76 PageID #: 3301
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 18 of 76 PageID #: 3302
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 19 of 76 PageID #: 3303
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 20 of 76 PageID #: 3304
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 21 of 76 PageID #: 3305
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 22 of 76 PageID #: 3306
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 23 of 76 PageID #: 3307
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 24 of 76 PageID #: 3308
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 25 of 76 PageID #: 3309
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 26 of 76 PageID #: 3310
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 27 of 76 PageID #: 3311
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 28 of 76 PageID #: 3312
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 29 of 76 PageID #: 3313
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 30 of 76 PageID #: 3314
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 31 of 76 PageID #: 3315
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 32 of 76 PageID #: 3316
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 33 of 76 PageID #: 3317
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 34 of 76 PageID #: 3318
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 35 of 76 PageID #: 3319
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 36 of 76 PageID #: 3320
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 37 of 76 PageID #: 3321
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 38 of 76 PageID #: 3322
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 39 of 76 PageID #: 3323
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 40 of 76 PageID #: 3324
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 41 of 76 PageID #: 3325
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 42 of 76 PageID #: 3326
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 43 of 76 PageID #: 3327
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 44 of 76 PageID #: 3328
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 45 of 76 PageID #: 3329
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 46 of 76 PageID #: 3330
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 47 of 76 PageID #: 3331
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 48 of 76 PageID #: 3332
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 49 of 76 PageID #: 3333
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 50 of 76 PageID #: 3334
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 51 of 76 PageID #: 3335
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 52 of 76 PageID #: 3336
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 53 of 76 PageID #: 3337
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 54 of 76 PageID #: 3338
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 55 of 76 PageID #: 3339
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 56 of 76 PageID #: 3340
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 57 of 76 PageID #: 3341
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 58 of 76 PageID #: 3342
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 59 of 76 PageID #: 3343
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 60 of 76 PageID #: 3344
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 61 of 76 PageID #: 3345
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 62 of 76 PageID #: 3346
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 63 of 76 PageID #: 3347
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 64 of 76 PageID #: 3348
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 65 of 76 PageID #: 3349
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 66 of 76 PageID #: 3350
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 67 of 76 PageID #: 3351
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 68 of 76 PageID #: 3352
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 69 of 76 PageID #: 3353
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 70 of 76 PageID #: 3354
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 71 of 76 PageID #: 3355
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 72 of 76 PageID #: 3356
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 73 of 76 PageID #: 3357
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 74 of 76 PageID #: 3358
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 75 of 76 PageID #: 3359
Case 1:17-mc-00151-LPS Document 83 Filed 08/10/18 Page 76 of 76 PageID #: 3360