You are on page 1of 27

Fundamentals of high voltage

cable accessories

Diego Cisilino
PM High voltage cable Accessories
Brugg Cables

High Voltage Accessories
Electrical field in cables

The week inhomogeneous electrical field
within a cable insulation can be calculated R1
as:
U r1
E(x) 
R
x ln  
r E
E(r2)
 Highest at the inner conductor E(r1)
 The higher the higher the voltage level (at
x
same insulation thickness)
 The higher the smaller the insulation R2
thickness
 => Relevant for accessories: value of r2
electric field at the cable insulation
outer diameter

High Voltage Accessories
2
Electrical field in cable end

1 – Glow at the cut edge
(Corona)

2 – Sliding discharge brunch
(Streamer)

2 – Sliding leader + brunch

High Voltage Accessories
3
Electrical field in cable end

Local very high electrical field at cut edge
Equipotential lines
of cable outer semi conductive layer

Electrical
field lines

Semiconductive Layer XLPE Insulation Cable Conductor

High Voltage Accessories
4
Geometrical field control in HV cable
accessories
 Deflector Optimal Geometry:
 The rule is to maintain the same amplitude of the electrical field stress value at the cable
outer diameter along the contour of the deflector (Edef/Eo = 1)

1 – Deflector too small – High stress onto
cable insulation – Small volume low
cost.

2 – Deflector too big – Very low stress onto
cable insulation. – Big volume
necessary - Uneconomical

3 – Optimal shape – Balance between
safe operation and production cost

High Voltage Accessories
5
material
The resistivity of the deflector is given by the following formula:
: volume resistivity of material
l: length
A: cross section area
Cross section of a deflector with Cross section of a deflector made
painted surface of semiconductive material

Small area A, High resistivity R large area A, small resistivity R

With high resistivity R there exists under BIL (lightning impulse) conditions the danger,
that the electrical field control is not sufficient. This can result in a breakdown!

High Voltage Accessories
6
Distribution of electrical field at a cable with
geometrical field control
Deflector Stress cone

Cable insulation Cable conductor

red: high electrical field blue: low electrical field

High Voltage Accessories
7
Distribution of electrical field at cable joint
with geometrical field control
Deflectors

Cable insulation Mid-electrode Cable conductor

red: high electrical field blue: low electrical field

High Voltage Accessories
8
Electrical strength of interfaces in cable
accessories – Inner interfaces
 Electrical strength of the contact surface between insulations
under electrical stress
Insulating Insulating
Plate 2 Plate 1
SIR without interface Interface
SIR – PE d
60
breakdown voltage Ûb [kV]

p
aluminium foil
40 The picture can't be display ed.

Rubber-Bubble Valve Frame
30
The picture The picture
can't be can't be
display ed. display ed.

20
p
10 The picture can't be display ed.

0 Sample
0 1 2 3 bar 4 for testing
Variable air pressure
Pressure in the interface p

High Voltage Accessories
9
Electrical strength of interfaces in cable
accessories – Inner interfaces
 Electrical strength of interface vs. material hardness
Breakdown Voltage Ub [kV]

Hardness 80

Hardness 40
Hardness 20

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Contact pressure p [bar]

High Voltage Accessories
10
Electrical strength of interfaces in cable
accessories – Inner interfaces
 Electrical strength of interface vs. surface roughness
Breakdown Voltage Ub [kV]

P=1 bar with no migrating
filling compound

P= 3 bar

P=1 bar

Surface roughness rz [μm]

High Voltage Accessories
11
XLPE insulation surface roughness vs
cloth grain size
Roughness rz (μm)

High Voltage Accessories
12
Inner interfaces in cable accessories -
Conclusions
 Electrical strength dependant on the contact pressure between
insulation materials (Size & application range of insulating
body)

 The material roughness in the interface is decisive for a reliable
electrical strength – The the smoother insulation surface the
the less contact pressure is necessary – (Special cable
preparation allow higher application range)

 The softer an insulating material, the less contact pressure is
required to achieve same electrical strength. (Highly flexible
insulating material is therefore required)

High Voltage Accessories
13
Comparison of EPR and silicone rubber
(SiR)

Source: Silikonelastomer für Kabelgarnituren, Isolatoren und
Überspannungsableiter-Profil einer Werkstofffamilie; J.
Kindersberger, ETG Workshop Berlin, VDE Verlag 2003)

High Voltage Accessories
14
Silicone rubber for joint body and stress
cones

● Important properties of silicone rubber for internal
interfaces application (joint bodies and stress cones)
 Excellent thermal resistance and high ignition
temperature
 Optimal shore Hardness (30-40)
 Excellent chemical resistance to oils, greases and
hydrocarbons

High Voltage Accessories
15
External interfaces in outdoor terminations

● Electrical field over the
insulator surface

 The electrical strength of
surrounding air depends
mainly on air pressure and
humidity and type of voltage
applied.

 Electrical strength of the
surface between insulator
and surrounding air is
mainly affected by pollution

High Voltage Accessories
16
External interfaces in outdoor terminations
Creepage distance – Flashover distance
 The flashover distance is defined
as the shortest distance between
the two electrodes of the insulator.
 Determinant for BIL withstand in
dry and wet condition

 The creepage distance of an
insulator is the geometrical
distance between the two
electrodes along the surface
of the insulator.
 Determinant for AC
withstand in dry and wet
condition while polluted

High Voltage Accessories
17
Quantitative determination of an insulator
creepage distance
Overview of different site pollution classes
● The unified specific according to site pollution severity [IEC
creepage distance is 60815_2008]
defined as the ratio of the Unified specific creepage
between the quantitative Site pollution class
distance (uscd)
creepage distance of the Very light a 22.0 mm/kV
Light b 27.8 mm/kV
insulator and the max. phase Medium c 34.7 mm/kV
to earth voltage. Heavy d 43.3 mm/kV
Very heavy e 53.7 mm/kV

● According to IEC 60815 the
quantitative minimum unified
specific creepage distance
depending on the pollution
class of the environment.

High Voltage Accessories
18
Determination of the minimum crepage
distance of an insulator acc. IEC 60815
Site pollution class Altitude correction factor
(SPS) IEC 60815-1 Ka  1 altitud  1500m
Insulator Diameter correction factor
Specific creepage distance
RUSCD Kad  1 Da  300mm
IEC 60815-2 / IEC 60815-3
(2  Dt  Ds1 Ds2)
Da 
4
Correction factors
Installation altitude Ka
USCD = RUSCD x Ka x Kad

U max
CDinsulator  USCD 
3
High Voltage Accessories
19
Insulator pollution test acc. IEC 60507

● Test voltage withstand
under pollution.

U max
Ut 
3
● Procedure:
- Preconditioning flashover
- 12x 1 hour withstand at Ut
● Criteria:
No flashover must occur on
each 1 hour test

High Voltage Accessories
20
Hydrophobicity of silicone elastomers

Silicone elastomers have an outstanding hydrophobicity!

Silicone elastomers have the unique property that the hydrophobicity
regenerates again after it was destroyed.

High Voltage Accessories
21
Comparison of the hydrophobicity of
porcelain and silicone

Water droplet on a Water droplet on a
porcelain surface Silicone coated surface

High Voltage Accessories
22
Silicone rubber for outdoor terminations

● Important properties of silicone rubber for outdoor
insulators
 Excellent UV resistance
 Excellent hydrophobicity and regeneration of
hydrophobicity
 Very good mechanical properties very low temperature
(e.g. -40 ⁰C)

High Voltage Accessories
23
Recommendations

● Refer to IEC 60815-1/-2/-3 for creepage distance
selection and design criteria
● Oversizing of creepage distances may cause
unexpected new problems
 Handle extreme oil volumes – Expansion tanks required
 Tracking and erosion problems on insulator surface due
to constant dry band arcing
● Hydrophobicity of composite insulators are
provides better pollution performance particularly
in coastal areas
● If necessary periodical washing of insulator
surfaces is more effective solution

High Voltage Accessories
24
Pollution Mitigation - Washing

● On-line or Off-line washing
procedures are available
● IEEE 957 – 2005 “Guide
for cleaning of insulators”

High Voltage Accessories
25
High Voltage Accessories
Break

High Voltage Accessories