You are on page 1of 9

c

KILOSA BAYAN VS MORATO

G. R. No. 118910)

c
c
c c c
  c  c c    c  c c  c c  c  c  c  c c    c  c   c c  c
    c c   c  c c c c c !!""#"$c %"%c c !!&c
'    c    c  c  c   c c c    c ( c c    c c ')*c   c c  c
  c c  c
  c  c c+c, c!--+$c  c c  c  c (c c
cc c    c c( c c
   c %.%/$c   c 0123c c  c !-4#c      c c    c c  c )c  c c 4+2++2c
 
  c 5    c  c
   *c  c c c c  c
c
06c
7  c c  c
   c
 c  c   c  c c  c  c   c
  c
c
60 c
 c 
  c   c  c c  c    c  c c c 
 c   c c       c  (c    c   c
  c  c  c cc
  c( c  c c
  c8 cc  c
  c c  c (c cc  c
  c  $c cc   c 9 $c :
 c c c( c   c cc  c
c   c'    c
 c cc  c (c( c
  9 c   c  c  c cc c cc  c c c  c
   c
   c   cc  cc c( c    c  c cc c c

Summary: Ocampo vs. House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal (GR 158466, 15 June 2004)

) 
c c ;  c c 
    c    c  c
<c !+4=>>$c !+c ? c %&&=@c
cA $c   2   9c.?/c!"c c

 c)c%"c, c%&&!$c  c,  c cA c c   c


   c,  cAc 
$c  c, c?  9$c
 c c   c    c c  c > c 3  c c ,  c
  c c  c !=c , c %&&!c    c ; c ( c
  c( c"%$&-#c c c c c c#>4c c  c'  cBc) 
c( c   c"!$"%-c c)c"!c
, c %&&!$c ) 
c  c ( c  c ;  c c 
    c    c  c .;/c c    c
  c
  c 
$c
c  c    cc4&#c
  cc  c> c3  c c,  c c  c  (c c
.!/c c c c   cc) 
Cc.%/c   c c    c Cc."/c    c c    c
 Cc.=/c c c  $c
 $c  c c  c  Cc c.+/c
   c c  c( cc  c
 c
c ( c
 c.;c  c&!2&%=/c) 
c
  c  c c  c c

   c c  c  cc  c4&#c
   c
  c c  Cc c  $c    $c c c
   c  cc   c   c c  c
> c 3  c c ,  c )c !4c ? c %&&!$c  
c  c c ( c ( c   2
  +c     c  c
 c  c   c c   c  c c  c  c
  c     c  ( c  c
  c c !%c ?c
%&&!$c  c;c c c    >c c  c c c $c(  c  c 2c( c  c
c 
Cc c  $c(  c) 
c c c
   c  cc   c
    c c  c> c3  c
c ,  c , ( $c c >c , c %&&"$c  c ;$c c ;c   c &!2&%&c .A   c   c Dc '  c
?   c c ,  c  
/$c c &!2&%"c .   c c ,c ) 
c c ,  c  
/$c  c     c
  c  c  
c c E  c  c  c ) c c 
    c c : c 3  c c ,  c  c  c c
   c c  c   Ec c  c Ec c   c c  Ec  
c  c c   c  c      c
  c  c ( c   c )c !%c , c %&&"$c ) 
c  c c   c c 
   c    c >c c 
c  c
>>=>c)c%>c, c%&&"$c 
c c c

  c c) 
Fc  c c
   c  c c
  c)c
%#c, c%&&"$c  c;c c c    c c  c 
c( c c c 2c c5 c
c c    c c  c > c 3  c c ,  c   c  c   c  c c (  c ) 
c  c  c

   c  cc   c   $c  c;c c  c c  c


  c  c c
   c  c c
 c  c   c 5  c   $ c c c  c  c ) 
c   c  c
   c c  c c
  c 
    c c  c : c    c 3  c c ,  c ) 
c  c c
  c   c  c
     c c( c  c) 
c c  c
  c c    c( c  c
  c  c

0 c7  c) 


c c c
   c  c( c  c 
c( c5  cc  c;c

; c   c>c cc>>=>c c   c#%c c  c)c   c  c 5 c c c8  c   c  c
   c c  c  c c c 5  c   c c  c    c E  Ec ;  $c ( c c   c  c c
 c c5  cc c8  cc  c    c c c( c c $c  c c  ccc  c
  c  c    c   c  c  c  c ( c   c c   c  c    c c ( c     c
  c c  c    c c  c   ccc  cc c c c  c( c c c c
5  c c  c 8  c c  c    c  $c  c

 c  c  c c   c  $c (   c c
   c c

c  c  $c cc  c   c  c  c  c  c( c  c5  c c c  c

 c c( c  c( c   c  c :  c c  c


( c c    c;  $c 
c( c   c
5  c   c%%c  c  c  c!=c, c%&&!c    c) $c  c 5   c cE c8  c
   c    Ec c   c )c  c  c  $c  5  c 5   c c c   c ( c   c  c
  c c c c c c    c  c  c( c   c  c  c  c c c c c
 c   c  c( cc

 c c c   cc c c  c  *c  $cc c  $c?c
c),$c  cc),$cA  cc),c c3  cc),cc c c c  $c  c
c c c!-!%$c c( c c  c  c  c( c  cc c    c  c c
   c  c( cc  c
  c  c  c  c( c( cc c c c  c c  c  c c(c c( c   c0c   c
c  $cc  c(c  cc c5  c c  c5 c c  c  c c(c c( c   $c c

   c  cc c c c  c


  cc8 c  $c c  c
  cGc c  cc  c    $c
 c( c
 cc   c  c 8  c c
  c c c; c c c c
   c( c c c c
 c c   c  c c  c  c5  c  c c c  ( cc c   c  c  c c
 c    c     c
  c c  c     c c
   c  
c  c  Fc

    c  c c  $c  c
  c  c    c  c c   c  c (  c   c   c
8  c c!!c? c%&&=cc c!#c, c%&&=$c  c cA c c   c
   cA   c  c
 cc   c   c c  c: c3  c c,  c
  c c  c!&c, c%&&=c    c

ie present Senate of tie 14ti Congress conducted an inquiry in aid of legislation on tie ƏHello
GarciƐ tapes wiici allegedly contained President GMAƍs instructions to former Comelec
Commissioner Garcillano to manipulate in ier favor results of tie 2004 presidential elections.
Tie Senate Rules of Procedure Governing Inquiries in Aid of Legislation iad been publisied in
newspapers of general circulation only in 1995 and 2006. Witi respect to tie present Senate,
iowever, no effort was undertaken for tie publication of tiese rules wien tiey first opened tieir
session. Is tie Senate investigation valid?

SUGGESTED ANSWER:
c
c  c c    c  c  c  c c  
  c ( c  c
  c  5   c  c
  c   c
5cc c c   c c  cH;  c Ic
cH; (  $c  c  c c (c c c c (c5c c
 c  c  (c  c
  c c  c  c c c'   cc ( c 8 c  c  c)  c%&&4Ic
c
 c   c  c  c %!$c  c B0c c  c !-4#c      c (c   c  c
  c c  c  c c

   c c   c  c  c c  c;  c c
    $c c c c c 
  c  c   c c
 c   c5 c c c c    c  c  5 c c
  c c  c cc   c c  c  c
 c  5   c c  c
  c
c
 cc   c ccc cc  c  c c   c c'c) c c0    c
 c  c
  cHc
 c c c
   Ic 5 c  c  c c  c  c c
c c c
c
   c  c5 cc c c   c   c  c  cc  c c  c  c   c c c
 c c c   c    c  c c  c  c."/c c c  2 c c  c  Fc  
$c  c
 
  c c  c  c  c  cc  c c c c c c  c c c   c c   c c
c  c c  c  c  c  c c  c
 c  c  c c '   $c  c 8  c  c c c c
   c   c c  c != c   $c  c     $c
   c c
c
 c   c  c  c  c  
  c   c 8 c  c  2    c c  c       c   c

  c  5   c c c  c  c  c   c   c  c   c  c !--+c c  c  c  c

 c c   c  c    c c   c  c  $c c   c c  c
c c  c   Fc   c
( c
 cH c   c c c    c c  c c  c8 c  c  Fc   c c  c c c
  c   c c   c%!$c  cB0c c  c     J c      c  c c
c  c
 c  c
  c  c c  $c
   c c    c   ( c c  c   $Ic  c  c 0 c  c  c  c
 
  Fc   c c  c
  c cc4#-%$c   c   c c c%&&&$c c

 c  c c
c  c
  c  c  c   c ( c    $c   c  c H  c  (c   c   9 c  c
 cc   c c    c c   c K c    c   Ic ccH c c  c
 c   c c  c  c
c  ($c  c c    Ic .c c !#&""4$c    c c ;  c c

    Ccc c!#-%#+$c L  cc  $c3   c%"$c%&&4/c

Avelino vs Cuenco

FACTS

 c
   $c   c ?  c   $c c c 5 c (   c
  $c  c  c   c c    c c  c
 c  c'   c c  c  c 
  $c,   c6  c

0c c   c c  c   $c    c 5  c c   c c 


c c  c c   c   c   c  c
  c '   c   c ( c

  c 7 c  c   
c c  c   c '   c   ( c c c


 $c  c    c  c c   c c


   c    c  c   c c 
c  c 'c ( c c


 c 
  c  c  $c  c  c c 8 c  c  c  c(  c  c)c!%c  c(  c
  cc  c c

 c   c c  c   c   c    c  c   c c   c   c ( c

 c c  c  c
'   c c  c  c c( c  9 c  c : c cc  c'   c c  c'

 c

06c

!c7  c c c  c  c c8  c c  c  c

%c7  c c c    c>#cDc>4c( c c

  c

;3c
!c c  c c c8  c c  c  c   c  c8  c cc
  cc  c cc c $c  c
  c(c c   c  c   c c
  c c
( c

 c  c c 5   $c  c ( c cc  c    $c c  (c c  c 


  c c
( $c  c
  c
  c c  c     c . 8  c c M 9 $c =>c '$c 4"Cc B  c c   $c ##c '$c !-%Cc
,   cc
9cB $c#4c'$c!/c c  c      c  c c  c  c c  c
( c c   c c
(c
   $c(c
( c c c c   c( $c c  c  $cc  c8 c7 c  c
c  c 9  c c  cB  c  c  cc  c c c  c   c c  c
 c  c(  c
  c   c(   c c  c  cc   c( c c  cc c  c   c  c
    c c  c
 c  c   c c  c  c    c( c  c c  c c c  c c
  c  c  $c  c c  c  c( $c$c c  c
  c c
c c c 
 $c
 c  8  c c  c  c (  c
   c c
  $c c   c  c c  c   c  c; c Nc
 cc  c
  c  c

%c0 c( c c  c   cc c5 c  c!%c c  c 8  c c%"c

0c $c c  c c8  c  c  c  c  c c   c( c  c


   c   c  c c  c (  c
 c   c ( c  c
 
c c  c   c     c c  c  c   c  c c   $c
(  c  c(c

 c  c  c $c c  $c   c(c c( c  c  $c c( c c


  c8 c c   c  c c c  c c'   c c  c  $c  c  c c    c  c
 c
c : c
c  c(c c  c 8  c c  c  $c  c c c  c  c   c  c c
 c'   c c  c c c    c c c  cc  c 8  cc c c  c   c c( c
 c c  c  $cc  c c  c c    c c c  c   c c
 c  c   c
5 c c  c  c    c c c    $  c  c (  c   c ( c

  c  c     c   c
  c c c c  c  c c   c
  c  c  c  c  (c c c  c

'  c c

People vs. Verac


<c=+>4+$c!>c   c!-"#@c
 c3 $c  c.?/c=c $c%c cc  c

 c  c '
 c c  c '

 c c  c ;  c c   c A c  


  c .;A/$c  c
 
  c  c
  c c  c   c
 $c c ,   c c 68 c c  c c  c     $c c  c
 c   c    c E c '
 c c  c '

 c 0 c c ,   c c 68 $c c Ec . c   c


=%>=-/c c  c  c c  c0  c. 0/c c,  c cc=!%&&c c  c
 c  c; c?  c)cB  $cc
 c? c c c c  c   c c c  c  c c  c0  c c,  $c( c c  c

  c
cc68 c c
   cc  c    c c  c c   cc  c c c  c( c c
( c  c 0c c!+c)  c!-"!$c;Ac  cc  c  c c
 c
   c c c
   c  c

   cc  c  c c'

 c8
  c cc  c  c c  c
 cc  c  c c( c cc
 c  cc  c   c c  cc c  c : c
   $c  c 0$c c4c?  c!-"=$c   c c
8  c c   c  cc68 c c  c
  c c c=c c c%c  c c

 c     c c 4c  c c
 c   $c c
c  c   c c ( c     c c c   c c  c
  c
 $c;Ac6
c

$c  c  $c c%>c, c!-"+$c  c  c   c c c  c



  c c  c +c  c c >c   c c
 c     c c #c  $c >c   c c %#c  c c
 c
  $c c  c  c8  cc c  c 
 cc68 c c c  c c     c c c
  c  c c (c  c(c(  c  c c!#c3   c!-"+$c c c8  c( c  c
  c c !4c 3   c !-"+c c 68 c   
c   c c   c  c   c   c c     c c  c

  c   c c  c 6 c  c  c  c  c   c  c
  c  c     cc   $c !-">c  c

  c  $c c%=c   c!-">$c  c  c
  c 5  c ccc68 c c  c c c c
  c    c   c  c      c c (c  c c    c    c  c   c c  c   c c
c c :   c c  c8  c
c68 c c c

  c c
   c c%#c   c!-">$c   c  c  c  $c c  c
  c
c  c =%%!c c  c   c '

 c    c c 68 c  c c c


  $c  c  $c  c  c c
   c c  c  c c (c c ( c   $c  c  c c  c  c   c c  c c ( c   c
 c   c c  c   c  c  0c c ,  $c ? c '  c   c
 $c    c  c

  c  c

   c c  c 0 c '   c ) c (c     c   c c  c  c !4c ? c !-"#c   $c


 c 0c c,  $c   c $c? c?  c)cB  c
 $c c  c
  c c c c+c
c!-"#c
)c%c
c!-"#$c  c  c c  c c c,  c c c

  c c  c  c c
   c cc68 c
 c
 c
    c  c c c

  c c+c
c!-"#$c  $c  c  c $c  c c=%%!$c
c  c c c c c
 cc   c%c c  c1Bc c  c     $cc     c   c
c    c !$c   c .!/$c   c 000c c  c      c    c 5 c
   c c  c  (c  c  c
  c  c  c

  c c  c  c    c  c 0 c c    c    c !!c c  c  c  c
 (c  c
  c  c ( c  c
( c c   c  c  (c    c c  ( c c  c  
  c c
 ( cc  c 
  c
  c c
 c
    c  c c c

   c

  c c
c
!-$c !-"#$c    c c  c   c        c c  c =%%!$c c c  c     c c    c

( c c  c
  c c c   c
  c. c!$c cB0$c     /c c c  c  cc
 c

  c c  c
 c
    c :
c ( c  
 c c  c 5   c   c   c  c
       c c c=%%!c)c%4c? c!-"#$c? c?  c)cB  c
  c c    $c c  c
c68 cE c   c
c c   Ec c  c c c(c c c  cc  c
  c  cc
c =!%&&$c  c  c  c  *c
  c  c
   c )c "c ?c !-"#$c   c  c c 68 c  c c
:
 c c  c    c c
   c c c  c c   c c c c  c c     cc
   c   c  c      c c  (c  c ( c  c c   c c !"c ?c !-"#c c ( c


   cc c    c  c c     c c c!=c?c!-"#c c    c  c
(  c c c c c"!c?c!-"#$c c c c( c

 c c  c
  c c  c cc68 c
   c c  c c  c c   cc  c  c c c c cc""c."=/c  c c8 c c
 c( c  c  c  c)c>c c!-"#$c  c  c c  c c c,  c c c  c( c  c  c  c
 c  c  c c c  c c :   c c  c8  c c c  cc c  c c  ( c c  cc
68 c c 8 c c    c c  c 8  c )c !&c  c !-"#$c ? c B  c  c c  c 5c c

  cc  c   c c    c c c c c

c   c  c  c c!=c c!-"#c


)c  c  2    c $c  c  c c  c c c,  c  c c  c c cc  c c :   c
c8  cc
    c c  c  c c  c c   c c c c $c
c 8   c c  c
 cc68 $c c  c c  c

   c c  c c c c  c c8 c   
c c  c
 c c  c   c  c :   c c %!c  c !-"#$c  c
   c c   c  c   c  c   c c
   c c c c cc  c  c c c  c  c c(c c  c c  c c
   c c c c( c c c c c  c( c c  c c c c!-c c!-"#cA c
c c8  $c;Ac c  c'
 c  c c  c
  c  c c :   c  c
  c c
 c c c
c( c  c   c( c c   c
  cc  c 0c c,  c(c   cE  c 
c c  c
    c,   cc68 c c  cc  c :   c c  c   c
 cc c;    c  c c
$c :
c  c  c c c c c   c c  c

  c  c c  c8 c  c c


  c    c c c8  c c c  c
 c c  c    c,   cc68 Ec c  c
 c   c  c  c  c( c  c
 c
c  c  c c c 
 c   c  c
c  c
  c  c c%!c c!-"#c

0 c7  c  c'


 c c  c'

 $c  c  c  c   c c  c c  c c c,  $cc c


c
 cc
   c  c

; c Oc  c '


 c c  c '

 $c 
   c c  c   2   c c  c  c c  c  c c
,  $c c c

c
 c c  c
   c
  c  c   c  cc  c  c
 c ( c 
c
 c  c c c  c c  c c
  c c   c   cc  c  cc  c c c  $c
c (c   $c   c 8c c c   c c  c     c 0 c  c (   c  c  c c  c =%%!c  c
  c  c      $c  c '
 c c  c '

 $c c (  c   c  c
   c   c c   $c  c c
   c   cc c c c  c)c c
 c  c  c   c  cc  c  c :
  c
c
c c c  c   c ( c  c 
c  c    c  (c c  c     c c c  c
  c;  $c  c( 2  c c  c  c c c   c  c  c c c (c (c

ccc'c cc
 ccc
c  c cc( c c c
 c#$c!-#%cc    c c c c   cc c
c
c cc  c  c c 
  c? c c  c    c c c  c c c c c   c c c
    $c  c
  c c
 c 
  cO  (cA c   c $c0c c  c  $c  c c  c c
, c '

 c :
   $c 0c c  c    c   $c (  c ?  c A 9 c    c  c  c c
?  c c c   c c
c c  c   c c c  c   c c  c c   c  c c
 c c  c
,  c c  c    c     c  c    c  c  ($c  c  c

 c c +"c  c   c


 
  c ? c   c 'c ' c c  c  c c  c 0  c c ,  c   c  c   c c c
 c)  c=$c!-#%c;  $c  c
  c c    c c
   c
c
0c cc
c
7) c  c 
  Fc  cc cc
c
cc cc
cc
 c
  c c  c 
c  c  c    c ( c  c :
 c   c  c c c
  c c  c

   c      c E c  c  c  c  c  c (   c  c    Ec E c    c c  2  c


  9 cc c8  c  c
 c c  c    c c  c<!-"+@c     cc c  c   c c  c

  c 
c c (c($c c
 2
  c;  $c  c  c    c c c  c c c   c  c
 $cc  c  c  c c  c (c c(cc c c c c
  c cc c $c  ccc c


 c c c c c
  $c  c  c  c :
 c  c c    c  c c c   c
c  c
 c c
  c  c    c (   $c  c c  c    c c  c    c  c c   c
  c  c  c  c  c    c

  c c c 8  c   c   c


 c
  c  c  c  c

  c c  c     c c  c   c  c c


c  c   c   c c  c  c  c
   c
c
c  c8  c c

c c8 c  c c c 8  c7 c c c   c


  c c( ccc  c c'   c7  c0  c  cEc  c   c c 2  c
c  c    c(   c c   $c c c c
 cc
   $c c c  c c  c  c  c c
 c  c  c  c
  c c 8  $c   c  c   c c  2c ( c 
c c  c    c c

   c  c    c 7  c   c  c


 c    c  c  c : $c $c  c c 8   c

  c c c   $c  c 0c  c   c c    $c  c     c c  c    c c ( c


 c c
  cc    cc c c  c
c( $c  c  c c $c c c c c   c c
 c  $c  c  c   c     c c c    c
  c c       c  (Ec <( 9  c
   c0  c $c
c
 cc
c c  c'

 @cPPP c   $c c c    $c c  c c  c c  c  c


cc   c  c c
 c  cc?  cA 9 cc, c$c(  c  c c    c c
c c   c  c c c cc  c c  c    c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
   cc3   cc c!=>#!&2!+$c, c%$c%&&!c   cc  cc c!=>#"4$c, c%$c%&&!cc
 $c?  c%+$c%&&-c'  cc   c7 cc
  c  c3  $c'   c (cc

c
 c0c  c, c!!$c!--4c    $c
   c? 
c   c( c   c'   c( c 
  c  c
, 
 2  c ( c   c B 2'   c  c  c  c c c $c  (  $c
   c ( c

  c c
  c  c  (c   c c

  c )c )  c =$c %&&&$c 0  c c    c   c
 $c c   c c c  c
   $c  c  c
   $cc c c c c  c c
c
 c c8 c c c :
 Fc  c c   c c  c)c   c!"$c%&&&$c;  c

 cB c   c  c  c c0
  c cc!!+c
    c c  c  c!K"c c c
 c   c c  c ;  c c 
    c c  c   c )c   c %&$c %&&&$c  c   c   c

 c  c
  c  c c  c
   c)c?  c!>$c%&&!$cc c c c!!2!&$c  c  28 c
 c   c  c
c c  c  c  
c(c   c   c   c (c  c
   c
 c '""c  c c c   c  c   c  c  c   c H?  c B   Ic  c c ( c  c c c

  c   c c  c  c  c  c   c c  c  
c    $c  c  c  c c  c
' 'c(  (c  c

 c c  c   c    c  c  c   $c    $c   c


   c c c c  c c  c
 c

)c?  c%&$c%&&!$c c   c!%c $c c?  c3  c   c  c c c 


  c  c c
'   c c  c '

 c )c  c   c  $c


   c  c c
 c    c  c  c ( c  c
,    c '   c  c  c   c c
 c c c  c c  c  c  c
  c c  c   c 0 c  c

 c  c c  c  c $c c c c c c  c c( c   c c    c  c c( c


  c c :  c  c
( c c  c cc  c c  cc
  c c (c c  c     $c  c
B 2'   c c c  c c'   cc
c c  c c( c  c c
 c     c c  c
'   c'  c c  c  c c

 cc c c  c
( $c  c
   Fc  c
  c

 cc c   c  c


  c c
  ccc  c) c c  c) c(  c cc  c

0 cc
.!/c 7  c c  c  c
   c   c c '   c
.%/c 7  c c  c  c
   c c c 
 c   c c  c c '   c
c
c
; c '    c   c  c   c c '   c c  c  c  c  c c
   c   cc
c
   cc c   c5   c0c  c c  c c c   $c   c c c c  c c c c
 c   c  c  c  
 c c  c c  5  c  c   c c c    c c  c    c c c
  c 5   c c c c0 c c c  c0 c c c( c0 c c c :
 c0 c c c
 cc c
c  c   cc $c c c c c  c   c0c  c  c c $c  c  c (c  c
   cc
 c ( c c   c  c c    c    c  c ,    c '   c   5  $c (  c c  c

   c  c c c c  c cc  c c  c   $cc c  c? c%&$c%&&!c c
c  c  c c
 $c   
  c c
  c   c c    c   c  c c   c
    c c  c c c  c c c     c( (c c  c c cc c  c
   c
  c
c  c c c:   c c  c  9 cc  c'c3 c05 c3c  c c  c c    c
 ( c    c c  c

  $c  c
c ( c  c   c c
 c c  c   c c
( c
 c   c c  c
   c( c
 c3c  c  c c c    $c  c   c c  c

   c( c  c  c c c c  c c c  c
 c c  c  c(  c  c  c c c
   c c  c
  c c c  c  c    c
 c  c   c  c  c  c    c c  c

   c  c c  c0 c( c  ccc c,    c0c  c


 c   c  cc
 c   $c.!/c c  (  c  c 2 c c  c 
  c c'   c c  c
$c c( c
 c    c   c c   Cc.%/c c 
 9 c c( c c  c'   $c  c c c  c
  $c c
 c  c c
 c cc  c c c  c c
  c c  c  c; cc c c c( c c  c
'   c c c cc c  c c  c c( c c c  c  c
  c c c c  c  c


Cc."/c c :
  cc   c c  c

 c c  c

  c c  c  Cc.=/c c  c  c


 c(c cc c c  c   c  c c  c  cc  c  c  c c  c  Cc c.+/c
 c  c cc

 c c8 ccc  c
   c c c    c   c
 c c    c c
   c
c
 c   c  c  c  c     c c  c
   c  c  c c   c 
 c   c c
 c  c

( c c  c c  c
  $c c  cc c'   c c  c c  c cc   cc  c
? c%&$c%&&!c c c
   c  c c  c' c'  c c
 c     c3 
 c c $c
 c ;  c c 
    c
 c c     c 

 c  c 
 c  c  c c   c c
'   c c  c  c
 c c    c c  c   c c  c cB 2'   cA c
  c c  c  c  9 c 
  c  c c  c'   c0
 c cc  c    cc
 c
  c  c  c   c c
   c    c c  c   c 
 c   c  c  c  8  c

   Fc c c  c c  c  c


c
c
   Fc c c  c c  c  c
( c
c   c c  c
  c  c 5   c c
  c c   c c   c   c c   c c
      c  c 0 c c c
  c  c (c   c  c   c c  c   c (   c   c  c


 c c
  c c
( c

c
0ccA  9c
<c#>!4&$c%=c)  c!-4>@c
    cc $c' c c#c c

 c0c c
  c c   c  c
 c c 
  $c  cBcA  9$c c c ( $c
5 c  c c
 
c c   c+c c  c1B000c c  c

 c!-4>c     $c(c
  c  c
E  c:2 c c c  c  c'   c cB 2'   c   cc  c#c  c!-4>c    c$c
 c

 c c 9  c c    $c  c :  c c c c"&c? c!--%c c c  c
   c c  c'   c cB 2'   c c c     c c c c c  c  c,  c c
, c!--%Ec c  c  c c
  cEc c Ec c c( c c  $c c  c c  c  cE c
   c c ( c  c5   c c  c    c c   c c c( $c  c  c
   c  c
'   c  9 c5 c cB c'   c   c  c c  c   c'   c  cc,  c
cB c'   c  c,c    c c   c c c  c c   c+c. c#/c c  c1B000c c  c
  c'  c c  c

 c!-4>c     c  c c

0 c7  c5 c c  c  c  c   c'   c cB c'   c c  c'

 c

; c c
  c c c  c c   cA  9*c    c c  c c   c c  c
  c
c   c  $c c c c c c
c  c c  c
c (  c  c  c
      c  c  c   c c  c'   c  9 cc5 c cB 2'   c
   c;c  $c c c c  c
 $c c
  c c  c :  c c  c c c c c"&c? c
!--%c c

 c c 9  c c    c;  $c  c  c
 
c c  c c   c
  c
 c  c c c  c  c,  c c, $c!--%c c  c c  c    c c  c'   c cB 2
'   c c c!-4>c     c, c $c   c c c c5   c  c'   c  9 cc
5 c cB 2'   c   c;c  c  c  c  c c   c'   c cB c'   c c
 c
c c  c'

 c   $c  c   c c  c5 c    cc c c8   c c0 c


  c c  c c c
 c(  c c  c

 c c  c'

 c  c  c8 cc  c

 c  c
  c  c8  Cc  c  c 
c  c    c c'   c  9 cc5 c(ccc    c
   c c  c   c  c c  c cc c  c c c  c    c cc  c c (c c c8 c
    c,   $c  c  c c  c c  9 c  c   c c  c
   c    c
c  c   c  c c c  $c c  9 $c  c( c c
 c  c   c (c c  c

c c c    Ec