You are on page 1of 5

MTE Engineering Co.,Ltd.

No.5/51, 9 Quarter, Insein Road, Haling Township, Yangon,Myanmar.

EXISTING TOWER ASSESSMENT REPORT & Colocation


Operator 1:
Antenna EPA(m2): 4.5
Mounted level(m): 28

Operator 2:
Antenna EPA(m2): 1.23
4.23 m 4.23 m
Mounted level(m): 29

4.23 m
STATICAL CALCULATION
Project: Tower sharing Assessment report (Foundation Check)
SITE CODE: YN1292
Tower : 30 meters, Lattice tower
RDU Type
Wind Speed: 165 KMPH (Basic, 3 sec Gust) Servival
117.15 kmph Operational
Address: No.31,Thukha st., Kyan Khin Su Ward,MinGalardon Township,YGN.
lat: 16.90343 °
long: 96.14705 °
Elevation: 10 m
Soil Data: As per report
(Summary) Utilization %

Current Condition: Soil Reaction 106.35%


Overturning 53.35%
Base Slab (PCC) 48.27%
RC '@ top slab 144.74%
After Strebgthening: Soil Reaction
Overturning
Base Slab (PCC)
RC '@ top slab
Conclusion: This site is generally acceptable and NEED to Reinforce at top Layer of CAP SLAB.
with Existing Loadings + Additional load
Retofit method: 100mm thk. RC slab at top layer ( 10mm'@150 c/c mesh)
date: 12/9/2018 0:00
BY,
Mr. Kyaw Thura
CME Consultant /MTE engineering
95019332
email: kyawthura.mte@gmail.com
Copyright information
This publication is copyright © MTE engineering Consultant Agency. Material in it may be reproduced for personal or in -house use without formal permission or
charge, provided suitable acknowledgement is made to this publication and the MTE as the source. Requests and enquiries about the reproduction of material in
this publication for any other purpose should be made to:
Mr. Kyaw Thura
email: kyawthura.mte@gmail.com (+95095019332)
The permission to reproduce material in this publication does not extend to any material for which the copyright is identifie d as being held by a third party.
Authorization to reproduce material belonging to a third party must be obtained from the copyright holder(s) concerned.
Disclaimer
The document does not override governing legislation. If the user of this document is unsure whether the material is correct, they should refer directly to the
relevant legislation and contact the MTE engineering Co.,ltd .
More information ... Published September 2018
If you have further queries, call our contact on +95095019332 or write to us:
STEEL FOUNDATION CHECK: Written By:
MTE ENGINEERING Kyaw thura
MTE engineering
Job Name: Foundation analysis 1/3 Subject: Stability Analysis & summary
Job Number: Update calculation based on additional Operator Originator: ND Checker: KTR
YN1292 Soil Data: As per Soil Report
Input Data: Density: 16.5 kN/m3

L (m) = 4.23 side length Leg to leg Cs db (m) = 1.64 2L-Profile Cantilever
B (m) = 4.23 side length Leg to leg dc (m) = 1.64 2L-Length @ parameter
CS (m)= 2.630 Tower to short edge (c/o)
CL h (m)= 0.100 Height of Shear F
CL (m)= 3.850 Tower to Long edge (c/o) SBC (kPa)= 26.000 Soil bearing
eLPu (m)= 0.000 CL of foundation to Pu center Ultimate Soil (kPa)= 45.500 As (1.75*SBC)
eBPu (m)= 0.000 CL of foundation to Pu center Submerged= NO
Reaction (factored loads) Footing Weight(kN)= 542 @ depth m 0.600
2
Mu= 755.447 kN-m , Moment 34 m depth>Wu= 408.000 kN , Wt. Ballast
Pu= 102.288 kN , Weight of tower+Equip Fu= 32.000 kN , Wt. Steel Foun.
Hu= 50.000 kN , Shear force Density of Ballast= 20.000 kN/m3

Short Side ( stability Check) Long Side ( stability Check)


Stability Check Stability Check
Over turning check Utilization: 53.35% Over turning check Utilization: 48.41%
MO= 760.447 kN-m,Overturning Moment MO= 760.447 kN-m,Overturning Moment
MR= 1425.46 kN-m, Resisting Moment MR= 1570.8 kN-m, Resisting Moment
MR/MO= 1.9 OK ( MR > 1.33 MO) MR/MO= 2.1 OK ( MR > 1.33 MO)

Required Wt.= 289.143 kN Use wt.: 542.000 kN ( Counter wt. of Foundation back fill)

Sliding check Utilization: 30.75% Any direction


SDL= 542 kN, Service Dead Load
µ= 0.3 fraction factor
Fs= 162.6 kN, Fraction force > 50.000 kN, Shear force OK

Soil Bearing check Utilization: 106.35%


eTu= 1.4030387 m > 1.36 = L/6
tu (Max.)= 48.39 kPa > 45.500 tu(min) = -16.51 kPa Soil Tension
Soil tension Area= 30.00% of Footing area < 45 % of allow
Conclusion: Rigid slab method ( conventional ) Effective Net pressure= 22.77 kPa < SBC
Foundation is Not Safe at Stability for Additional Gust Antenna loading
Strip wdith= 1.635 m
2L profile (63x63x5) LC (m)= 3.850 As max. Projection
Section Properties:
2
A= 1200 mm Section Area
C.G= 16.9 / 0 mm from bottom
Ix= 934080 mm 4
Sx= 14370 mm 3
2
Fy= 345 N/mm

Max. Shear on 2L profile per piece: 1 Pices


Shear Steel Member Utilization: 49.47%
4.23 m 1.635 m
tu (Max.)= 48.39 kN, Max. soil reaction
(L*0.5-etu)= 0.522 m
3(L*0.5-etu)= 1.566 m

tue= 32.26 kPa => 0.640361 ksf


Max. Shear/ea= 64.52 kN, Max. for each pice
Shear capacity: Web area only
Web Area= 630 mm 2

Shear capacity= 130.41 kN

Punching Shear utilization = 8.00% @ Wall strip Check Max. Moment on 2L-Profile per piece
Allowable wall load utilization = 46.79% Bending @ Mid Moment Steel member Utilization: 62.90%
Allowable wall load utilization = 48.27% Bending @ Edge Mu piece= 2.80662 kN-m
Top steel utilization = 144.74% @ Mid span Mcapacity piece= 4.461885 kN-m

Soil Reaction utilization = 106.35% @ Max.


BEAM ON ELASTIC FOUNDATION ANALYSIS
For Soil Supported Beam, Combined Footing, Slab Strip or Mat Strip
of Assumed Finite Length with Both Ends Free MTE engineering
Job Name: Foundation Analysis 2/3 Subject: Elastic foundation
Job Number: Elastic foundation check ( Soil reaction) Originator: ND Checker: KTR
L(m) = 7.50 P1 (kN)= 246.5094827 E1= 2549
Input Data: P2(kN)= -171.5094827 E2= 1710 E1
1.64 S(m)= 4.23 c E1/E2= 1.5 E2
W
Beam Data: P1 P2 e
b
Length, L = 24.6000 ft. a
E1
Width, W t = 5.0947 ft. +P
Thickness, Tt = 1.2778 ft. +wb +we +M +w
Modulus, Et = 2129.5 ksi
Subgrade, K = 11.47059 pci T
Inertia, I = 0.886 ft.^4
E,I Subgrade
transformed-section method L
Beam Loadings: x
Nomenclature
Full Uniform:
w= 1.4647 kips/ft. Results:

Start End Beam Flexiblity Criteria:


Distributed: b (ft.) wb (kips/ft.) e (ft.) we (kips/ft.) for b*L <= p/4 beam is rigid
#1: for p/4 < b*L < p beam is semi-rigid
#2: for b*L >= p beam is flexible
#3: for b*L >= 6 beam is semi-infinite long
#4:
#5: b= 0.098 b = ((K*W)/(4*E*144*I))^(1/4)
#6: b*L = 2.42 b*L = Flexibility Factor

Point Loads: a (ft.) P (kips) Beam is semi-rigid


#1: 5.3628 55.22
#2: 19.2372 -38.42
#3: Max. Shears and Locations:
#4: +V(max) = 30.47 k @x= 5.36 ft.
#5: -V(max) = -24.75 k @x= 5.36 ft.
#6:
#7: Max. Moments and Locations:
#8: +M(max) = 87.39 ft-k @x= 5.36 ft.
#9: -M(max) = -67.60 ft-k @x= 19.24 ft.
#10:
#11: Max. Deflection and Location:
#12: D(max) = -0.988 in. @x= 0.00 ft.

Moments: c (ft.) M (ft-kips) Max. Soil Pressure and Location:


#1: Q(max) = 1.632 ksf @x= 0.00 ft.
#2: 81.60955 kPa
#3:
#4:
Bearing Pressure (ksf) Moment (ft-kips) Shear (kips)

100.0

0.0

-80.0
-40.0
80.0

-60.0
-20.0
20.0
40.0
60.0

-0.500
-1.000

2.000
1.500
1.000
0.000

0.500
-10.0
0.0

-30.0
-20.0
40.0

10.0
20.0
30.0
0.00 0.00
0.00

0.98 0.98
0.98

1.97 1.97 1.97

2.95 2.95 2.95

3.94 3.94 3.94

4.92 4.92 4.92

5.90 5.90 5.90

6.89 6.89 6.89

7.87 7.87 7.87

8.86 8.86 8.86

9.84 9.84 9.84

10.82 10.82 10.82

11.81 11.81 11.81

12.79
x (ft.)

x (ft.)
12.79

x (ft.)
12.79

13.78 13.78 13.78


Shear Diagram

Moment Diagram

14.76 14.76 14.76

Bearing Pressure Diagram


15.74 15.74 15.74

16.73 16.73 16.73

17.71 17.71 17.71

18.70 18.70 18.70

19.68 19.68 19.68

20.66 20.66 20.66

21.65 21.65 21.65

22.63 22.63 22.63

23.62 23.62 23.62

24.60 24.60 24.60


CONCRETE SLAB ON GRADE ANALYSIS
For Slab Subjected to Continuous Line Loading from Wall
Written by: Kyaw thura
Job Name: Foundation Analysis 3/3 Subject: Slab profile '@ base
Job Number: Bending,Shear and Compression check Originator: ND Checker: KTR
React soil (Ksf)= 0.9678 Top Layer
At (C15)
Avg. soil (Ksf)= 0.64 (Mesh)
t2
Input Data: Wall Wall
P Top/Slab P
Aggregaate fill (base of
Slab Thickness, t1 =3.000 in. Steel) t3
Concrete Strength, f 'c = 2500 psi
Subgrade Modulus, k = 10.833264 pci b1
PCC t1
UDL X 1.25 Load, P = 611.76 lb./ft. (C15) S1

max. clear span s1= 12.8744 ft


(Subgrade)
RC slab '@ top t2= 3 in
Sandwich Fill t3= 20 in Concrete Slab Loaded Near Center or at Joint
Bearing Width b1= 5 in

max. Edge span e1= 12 in Wall P


Bearing Width b2= 6 in Top/Slab
Bearing Width @ Soil = 8.5 in
PCC
(C15) b2 t
Moment @ Mid Mt= 121.68 k-in e1
Req'd Top Steel At= 0.11 in2/ft
2 (Subgrade)
Provided Steel At provided= 0.076 in /ft
Results: Concrete Slab Loaded Near Free Edge
Design Parameters:
Modulus of Rupture, MR = 450.00 psi MR = 9*SQRT(f 'c)
Allow. Bending Stress, Fb = 80.00 psi Fb = 1.6*SQRT(f 'c) (as recommended in reference below)
Factor of Safety, FS = 5.625 FS = MR/Fb
Section Modulus, S = 595.13 in.^3/ft. S = b*t^2/6
Modulus of Elasticity, Ec = 2850000 psi Ec = 57000*SQRT(f 'c)
Width, b = 8.50 in. b = t+ (b1+b2)/2" (assumed)
Moment of Inertia, I = 3635.84 in.^4 I = b*t^3/12
Stiffness Factor, l = 0.0069 l = (k*b/(4*Ec*I))^(0.25)
Coefficient, Blx = 0.3224 Blx = coef. for beam on elastic foundation

Wall Load Near Center of Slab or Keyed/Doweled Joints:


Allowable Wall Load, Pc = 1307.45 lb./ft. Pc = 4*Fb*S*l
= 12.8*SQRT(f 'c)*t^2*(k/(19000*SQRT(f 'c)*t^3))^(0.25)
Pc(allow) >= P, O.K.
Wall Load Near Free Edge of Slab:
Allowable Wall Load, Pe = 1267.30 lb./ft. Pe = Fb*S*l/Blx
= 9.9256*SQRT(f 'c)*t^2*(k/(19000*SQRT(f 'c)*t^3))^(0.25)
Reference: Pe(allow) >= P, O.K.
"Concrete Floor Slabs on Grade Subjected to Heavy Loads"
Army Technical Manual TM 5-809-12, Air Force Manual AFM 88-3, Chapter 15 (1987)

Punching Shear check


Punching Shear Width,Bs= 8.000 in Bs= b2 +t1 shear Length,BL= 24 in
Punching Shear ,Ps= 611.765 lb/ft < Resisting Shear ,Rs= 7200 lb