You are on page 1of 6

Recent Landslides

Landslides (2007) 4:85–90 Sandra G. Catane . Hillel B. Cabria . Cristituto P. Tomarong Jr . Ricarido M. Saturay Jr .
DOI 10.1007/s10346-006-0050-3 Mark Albert H. Zarco . Winston C. Pioquinto
Received: 7 April 2006
Accepted: 9 June 2006
Published online: 17 October 2006 Catastrophic rockslide-debris avalanche at St. Bernard,
© Springer-Verlag 2006
Southern Leyte, Philippines

Abstract On 17 February 2006, a rockslide-debris avalanche marine environment. Hummocky topography in the basal slopes of
cascaded down the steep slope of Mt. Can-abag, burying the entire the mountain suggests high frequency of prehistoric landslides.
village of Guinsaugon in St. Bernard, Southern Leyte, Philippines. However, this feature is not evident in the alluvial plain. Recent
Casualties include 139 dead with 980 still missing and presumed sediments delivered mainly by the Himbungao River underlie the
dead, making it perhaps the most catastrophic landslide in valley adjacent to the ridge where several villages of St. Bernard are
Philippine history. The landslide started at the ridge top along a located, including Guinsaugon. Basement rock is made up of
fault plane associated with the active Philippine Fault Zone. It highly sheared and serpentinized harzburgites exposed at the
started as a block slide that transformed into an avalanche. The southern part of the ridge near Cabalian Bay.
entire event lasted for only a few minutes. Estimated maximum
landslide velocity is 120–130 m/s. The landslide left behind a deep, Rainfall
wedge-shaped scarp. The central part of the deposit exhibits a The climate of the region is characterized by pronounced rainfall
hummocky topography typical of avalanches, in contrast to the from November to January. This period of rainfall was extended by
flatter surface of the debris-flow-type marginal deposit. High the current La Niña phenomenon. A rain gauge 7 km west of
amounts of soil in the matrix were derived from the scouring of Guinsaugon measured cumulative rainfall of 751 mm from
ancient landslide deposits and rice fields in the valley. The February 01 to 16, which is 2.65 times higher than the average
landslide has a total area of 3.2 km2 and a runout distance of 4.1 km. February monthly rainfall (Fig. 2). Maximum daily rainfall values
Estimated volume of debris is approximately 20 Mm3. At least four of 131 to 171 mm were recorded from February 10 to 12, at least
streams were dammed by the landslide debris. Intense precipita- 5 days before the landslide happened. Very minimal rain was
tion and earthquakes preceding the landslide are the potential recorded on February 17 (PAGASA 2006). The rain gauge is located
triggers. Preliminary back analyses assuming a planar and wedge on the leeward side of the mountain range, which receives lower
slip surface yielded very low factors of safety even under dry amount of precipitation due to orographic effects. Thus, the
conditions. A more rigorous analysis of the failure mechanism of amount of rainfall that fell on the failed slope adjacent to
the landslide is needed. Guinsaugon must have been higher than the values shown in Fig. 2.

Keywords Landslide . Debris avalanche . Slope stability . Landslide history and possible precursors
Guinsaugon . Philippines According to residents, earthquake swarms from 1986 to 1988 have
triggered small soil falls from the source area. They also described
Introduction that the bedrock at the failure site of the recent landslide was
A huge rockslide-debris avalanche occurred on the northeast- already exposed due to small but frequent landslides. A few days
facing steep slope of Mt. Can-abag in St. Bernard, Southern Leyte, before the huge landslide, small intermittent rock falls were
burying the village of Guinsaugon (Fig. 1). This landslide event observed. A stream that leads to the village of Guinsaugon became
killed more than a thousand individuals, making it perhaps the muddy the day before the landslide.
most catastrophic single landslide event recorded in the Philip-
pines. The chronology, effects, and possible mechanism based on Chronology of events
field reconnaissance and eyewitness interviews after the landslide On 17 February 2006, residents of Guinsaugon village and
are presented in this article. surrounding areas felt a mild earthquake at around 6:00 A.M.
local time. A stronger earthquake (surface wave magnitude=2.6,
Geologic setting depth=6 km) followed later at 10:36 A.M., the epicenter of which was
The landslide occurred at the top of a ridge of Mt. Can-abag in St. located southwest of Sogod (10.30N, 124.90E), approximately 25 km
Bernard, Southern Leyte, Philippines. The 30-km long ridge is a away from Mt. Can-abag (http://www.phivolcs.dost.gov.ph/EQlatest.
geomorphic expression of the active Leyte Segment of the 1,200- html). A swaying motion, corresponding to intensity III–IV in
km-long sinistral Philippine Fault Zone (PFZ), which has average the Rossi–Forel scale, was experienced for about 5 s. Immediately
slip rates of 0.55 cm/year (Cole et al. 1989) to 3.5 cm/year after the earthquake, a loud, rumbling sound was heard for less
(Duquesnoy 1997). It is underlain by Late Pliocene to Pleistocene than a minute, followed by an explosion that coincided with the
andesitic volcaniclastic rocks of the Dolores Formation (JICA- appearance of a white line of cloud rising from the slope face where
MMAJ 1990). The recent landslide exposed the southwest-dipping the blocks of the mountain subsequently detached. Eyewitness
volcaniclastic rocks consisting of breccias, sandstones, siltstones, accounts describe three blocks successively cascading downslope in
and mudstones at the crown area. Based on sedimentary a wave-like manner. The first block followed the existing gully,
structures, these rocks were formed in a transitional to shallow while the second and third blocks were hurled into the air as they

Landslides 4 • (2007) 85
Recent Landslides
Fig. 1 Distribution of the Guinsaugon
landslide on a UNOSAT SPOT image
taken on June 2003 (http://unosat.
web.cern.ch/unosat/asp/prod).
Yellowish brown area represents the
landslide-affected area mapped by
RADARSAT and ASAR and the brown
area by ALOS, which are interpreted in
this study as areas of detachment and
erosion and areas of deposition,
respectively. Blue outline is the upper
limit of the landslide scarp based on
aerial photos and ground survey
conducted in this study. Red lines
indicate major lineaments along the
PFZ. (Modified from Catane et al. 2006)

collided with a lower, transverse ridge that served as a ramp. The from the shattered debris and hovered over the area for 1 min before
blocks shattered when they hit the footslopes. As the debris moved dissipating. The entire event lasted less than 5 min.
through the rice fields and buried the Guinsaugon village, black mud
was sprayed into the air. A 20-meter thick cloud of dust emanated Effects of the landslide
The landslide, with an estimated volume of ∼20 Mm3, reached a
distance of 4.1 km and affected an area of about 3.2 km2. It buried
the entire Guinsaugon village with a population of 1,857 comprising
321 households. Structures in the village, including a three-storey
concrete building, were laterally translated by 550–600 m (Lagmay
et al. 2006). The total number of fatalities is 139 with 980 still
missing (http://ndcc.gov.ph/ndcc). The missing people include 248
pupils and teachers buried alive inside a school (Fig. 3) and
members of a women’s group attending a celebration in the village
hall. Of the 20 people rescued, two eventually died. The landslide
debris dammed at least four streams. Small lakes started to form
behind the landslide debris dam. Flash floods due to possible
breaching of these landslide dams constitute a secondary hazard.

Landslide mechanism and trigger

Rockslide
The landslide originated at the 700-m ridgeline of Mt. Can-abag
defined by the Leyte Segment of the PFZ in Southern Leyte
(Fig. 4a). Fresh volcaniclastic rocks comprise the failed portion of
the mountain, which had a prelandslide gradient of about 50–60°.
The failure surface is defined by the intersection of a 50–60° fault
Fig. 2 Daily and cumulative rainfall in relation to the Guinsaugon landslide event plane with subhorizontal slickensides and gouge, and a less-
(data from PAGASA 2006). Note that the landslide occurred 5 days after the peak defined, steeply dipping plane (70–90°) with irregular and highly
rainfall on February 12. (Modified from Catane et al. 2006) jointed surface (Fig. 4b). As observed from oblique aerial

86 Landslides 4 • (2007)
Fig. 3 Cadastral map of Guinsaugon
village used during the search and
rescue operation. The location of the
buried school, the transported three-
storey building, the base of the land-
slide scar, the lower transverse ridge
that served as a ramp for the
avalanche, and a stream west of the
school that became muddy a day
before the landslide are shown. Names
in the map indicate the landowners

photographs, the slopes in the crown area essentially consist of were formed perpendicular to the overall transport direction.
rocks mantled with <2-m-thick soil. The rockslide transformed Prominent flow levees mark the southwestern edge of the flow.
into an avalanche and scoured the old landslide deposits and The appearance of dust clouds after the deposition indicates
muddy rice fields as it moved further downslope. that the dominant slope material in the upper slopes is dry or at
least partially saturated when the avalanche occurred. In contrast,
Debris avalanche materials from the lower hill slopes are soil-rich old landslides and
The avalanche was formed by the collision of the sliding block with fault-scarp deposits that can be easily saturated.
the lower transverse ridge (Fig. 4a). Disaggregated blocks were
thrown into the air and shattered upon impact on the footslopes. Slope stability analyses
The resulting deposit exhibits a hummocky topography, charac- The lag time between the landslide and the maximum rain
teristic of flows with high yield strength (Figs. 5 and 6). Mud was intensity suggests a significant time for the water to infiltrate the
splattered up to 10 m high on standing coconut trees located near slope materials. Days of intense precipitation that preceded the
the margins of the avalanche deposit. This implies that the landslide event may have eventually saturated the gouge, resulting
avalanche scoured saturated soils of the old landslide deposits. to increased pore pressures and reduced shear strength. These
Maximum avalanche velocity based on potential–kinetic energy conditions destabilized the marginally stable slope. Preliminary
relationship ranges from 120 to 130 m/s. slope stability analyses assuming a planar slip surface (Hoek and
On the hill slopes along the southwest margin of the landslide, Bray 1981) were performed based on the assumption that the
coconut trees were knocked down but were not transported drained angle of friction for discontinuities ranges between 30 and
(Fig. 7). Beyond the avalanche margins, trees, which were either 33° with zero cohesion. Based on a total slope height of 700 m and a
fallen or left standing, were also abraded or shredded. Neither slope face angle of 50°, factors of safety from 0.825 to 0.927 were
rocks nor soil was deposited in this zone. These observations obtained for the case where no hydrostatic pressures are present in
suggest the generation of air blasts, which could be related to the the discontinuity. In the case of a phreatic surface occurring 350 m
downslope motion of the avalanche or the explosions described by above the toe, as determined in the field, factors of safety from
eyewitnesses. 0.676 to 0.76 were obtained. It is interesting to note that when a
wedge-type failure is assumed in lieu of the planar slip surface,
Debris flow factors of safety from 0.677 to 0.761 are obtained for the case where
A secondary debris flow from the saturated, low-relief hill slopes at no hydrostatic pressures are present in the discontinuities,
the southwest edge of the debris avalanche deposit was initiated implying that the slope was already unstable even under dry
when the avalanche scoured and removed the basal support of the conditions. This highlights the need for a more rigorous analysis of
said hills (Fig. 5). Pressure ridges on the surface of the debris flow failure mechanism behind the landslide.

Landslides 4 • (2007) 87
Recent Landslides
Fig. 4 a Source area and deposits of
the Guinsaugon landslide showing the
projection of the PFZ and other
geologic features. b Close-up of the
source area showing at least three
major failure planes. The bedrock in
the upper half of the section is
transected by fractures. The gouge
(beige) lines the slip surface (fault
plane). Mounds below the apex are
sheared rocks and older landslide
deposits. (Modified from Catane et al.
2006)

The earthquakes that preceded the landslide, in spite of their Conclusions


low magnitude, could have been the ultimate trigger. Actual The 17 February 2006 Guinsaugon rockslide-debris avalanche is
magnitudes of the earthquakes, as suggested by the strong ground perhaps the first and largest historical catastrophic single landslide
motion described by witnesses, could be higher than the values event described in the Philippines. Although ancient landslide
officially reported. A horizontal ground acceleration of 0.005 g deposits are present at the base of the mountain range where the
incorporated in the preceding slope stability analyses yielded landslide occurred, no landslide deposit of this size and extent was
factors of safety from 0.604 to 0.679. observed. The Guinsaugon landslide is essentially a dry debris

88 Landslides 4 • (2007)
Fig. 5 Block diagram showing fea-
tures of the source area and landslide
deposits as seen from the northeast
direction. Fault trace and the location
of the buried Guinsaugon village are
indicated. The figure is not drawn to
scale. (Modified from Catane et al.
2006)

Fig. 6 Landslide deposit viewed from the base of the landslide scar. Avalanche area is dominated by hummocky topography. Small ponds are formed in interhummock
areas. Larger ponds in the photograph resulted to damming of at least four rivers by the landslide. (Modified from Catane et al. 2006)

Landslides 4 • (2007) 89
Recent Landslides
Fig. 7 Knocked down coconut trees
(height 10–12 m) on the hill slopes at
the southwest margin of the landslide

avalanche, which partially traveled through air and generated air Cole J, McCabe R, Moriarty T, Malicse JA, Delfin FG, Tebar H, Ferrer HP (1989) A
blasts. Potential triggers are the prolonged and excessive precip- preliminary Neogene paleomagnetic data set from Leyte and its relation to motion
on the Philippine fault. Tectonophysics 168:205–221
itation associated with the La Niña phenomenon and the low- Duquesnoy Th (1997) Contributions de la géodésie à l’étude de grands décrochements
magnitude earthquakes. The preparatory causes are the steep actifs associés à des zones de subduction à convergence oblique. Thése de docteur
slopes, presence of highly fractured and sheared materials en sciences. University of Paris–XI, Orsay
associated with active faulting, and adversely oriented gouge-filled Hoek E, Bray J (1981) Rock slope engineering, 3rd edn. E & FN Spon, London, pp 150–
fault plane. Preliminary slope stability analyses assuming a planar 198
JICA-MMAJ (1990) The mineral exploration—mineral deposits and tectonics of two
and wedge slip surface yielded very low factors of safety. This contrasting geologic environments in the Republic of the Philippines. Consolidated
implies that the slope was already unstable even under dry report on Leyte, Dinagat and Surigao areas. Japan International Cooperation Agency–
conditions and thus highlights the need for a more rigorous Metal Mining Agency of Japan, Japan
analysis of the failure mechanism of the landslide. The likelihood Lagmay AM, Ong JB, Fernandez F, Lapus M, Rodolfo R, Tengonciang AM, Soria JL,
of generating landslides of similar magnitude within the area is Baliatan E, Quimba Z, Uichanco E, Paguican A, Remedio G, Lorenzo G, Valdivia W,
Avila F (2006) Scientists investigate recent Philippine landslide. EOS 87(12):121–124
high because the contributory factors and triggers are prevalent in PAGASA (2006) Rainfall data from Otikon, Libagon, Southern Leyte. Philippine
the area. Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Agency, Philippines

Acknowledgements S. G. Catane ()) . H. B. Cabria . C. P. Tomarong Jr . R. M. Saturay Jr


We thank UP-NIGS, NIGS’s Commission on Higher Education National Institute of Geological Sciences,
(CHED) Grant, and PNOC-EDC for supporting this initial study. University of the Philippines,
Diliman 1101, Quezon City, Philippines
Technical and logistic support extended by Joseph Foronda, Peter
e-mail: scatane@nigs.upd.edu.ph
Zamora, Allan Mandanas, Leo Campo, and Ms. Sampaguita Capili
is highly appreciated. We also thank Hiroshi Suwa for the critical H. Zarco
M. A. Zarco
review and editorial handling. Department of Engineering Sciences, College of Engineering,
University of the Philippines,
Diliman 1101, Quezon City, Philippines
References
W. C. Pioquinto
Catane SG, Cabria HB, Tomarong CP Jr, Saturay RM Jr, Zarco MAH, Pioquinto WC (2006) Philippine National Oil Company–Energy Development Corporation (PNOC-EDC),
Extremely rapid rockslide-debris avalanche at St. Bernard, Southern Leyte, Philippines Fort Bonifacio, Makati City, Philippines
(in Japanese). Tsuki to Kiso 54-5(580):33–34

90 Landslides 4 • (2007)

You might also like