You are on page 1of 166
IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA (HELD AT BRAAMFONTEIN) Case No: CCT 248/2018 In the matter between: COMMISSIONER THOMAS SWABIHI MOYANE Applicant and PRESIDENT CYRIL RAMAPHOSA First Respondent MINISTER PRAVIN GORDHAN Second Respondent JUDGE ROBERT NUGENT NO Third Respondent ADVOCATE AZHAR BHAM SC NO Fourth Respondent PROFESSOR MICHAEL KATZ Fifth Respondent ADVOCATE MABONGI MASILO NO ‘Sixth Respondent MR VUYO KAHLA NO Seventh Respondent FILING NOTICE DOCUMENTS: FIRST RESPONDENT'S ANSWERING AFFIDAVIT FILED BY: STAyE ATTORNEY 1 and 2 Respondents’ Attorneys SALU Building 316 Thabo Sehume Street TO: AND TO: AND TO: Cor Francis Baard Street PRETORIA Private Bag X91 PRETORIA Tel: 012 309 1500 Fax: 012 309 1649 email: ichowe@justice gov.za Ref: Mr KI Chowe Ref No: 1507/2018/Z53 C/O THE STATE ATTORNEY JOHANNESBURG 13" FLOOR NORTH STATE BUILDING JOHANNESBURG REF: V. DHULAM TEL: (011) 330 7621 Fax to email: 086 612 4106 Email: VDhulam@justice.qov.za THE REGISTRAR OF THE ABOVE HONOURABLE COURT BRAAMFONTEIN MABUZA ATTORNEYS Applicants’ Attorneys 83 Central Street Houghton JOHANNESBURG Tel: 011 483-1508 / 483-2387 / 483-0476 Fax: 011 728.0145 Cell: 082 561 1067 Email: eric@mabuzas.co.za Ref: Mr ET Mabuza WERKSMANS ATTORNEYS 36th ~ 7 RESPONDENTS THE CENTRAL, 96 RIVONIA ROAD SANDOWN, SANDTON JOHANNESBURG, 2196 TEL: (011) 535 oes NCE REF: MRC MANAKA AND TO: MKHABELA HUNTLEY ATTORNEYS INC 4" Respondent Block C 7 Eton Road Sandhurst SANDTON Tel: (011) 783 8020 Fax: (011) 783 3842 Ref. Mr L Mkhabela/gn Email: mkhabela@mhalaw.co.za/ gayle@mhalaw.co.za