Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By
Dana Kadir
SUPERVISED BY
Sydney/Australia
2005
1
INTRODUCTION
The major focus of this research is the investigation of the contrast between the
research, I will include the following, such as the aim, the purpose of the research,
research questions, the definition of some terms, background of the literature that I
have read, and discuss the differences. The methodology that I have used in my
research, analyse the data and use quantitive research method. Finally, the results and
AIMS:
The major focus of this research is the investigation of the use of grammatical gender
between the English and the Kurdish languages. Which one of the two languages does
The purpose of my research is to find out the use of grammatical genders in both
Here the variation between English and Kurdish grammatical gender is very
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
The variation between English and Kurdish grammatical gender is very significant in
2
What is grammar?
Grammar is a rule of a language which describes how its words are made up to form
Grammatical genders, are also called (noun classes), they are classes of nouns which
are reflected in the behaviour of related words, every noun belongs to one of the
classes. For example, Indo-European languages have 1-3 noun classes that are called
families are believed by its proponents to have human, animal and object as
grammatical genders. For example, in Spanish, the word (hijo) (son) is masculine and
What is gender?
Gender is “the grammar of some languages, certain words and forms belonging to a
specific gender. For example, masculine and feminine in French; masculine, feminine
and neuter in German; common and neuter in Dutch” (Macquarie University, 1997, p.
372).
“Gender is a grammatical term, and has no real connection with sex. It was only just
later that it became used as a synonym for sex (Arnie, 2003-4, p.4)
Biological gender refers to sex, such as male or female (Harry, 2000, p.1).
3
What does masculine mean?
Feminine is linked with femaleness. According to Gershaw men are seen as having
competence feature while women are more expressive than men (Gershaw, 1995,
p.1).
I believe that culture is the main factor that has an effect on masculine and feminine
genders in any language. For example, in German, nouns end in –ug which
corresponds to ing in English, are feminine, and car brand names are masculine.
Words end in –lein and –chen, their meanings are (smaller, younger) neuter.
Another example, the ancient Romans believed the Sun is masculine and the Moon is
feminine. French, Spanish and Italian have the same idea in regard to the Sun and the
Moon. For example, the Spanish word (luna) (moon). (Harry, 2000, p.4). But
Germans believe is vice versa about the Sun and the Moon (Encyclopaedia, 2005, p-
8).
The differences between the Kurdish and English languages in terms of using
grammatical gender and which one of the two languages uses more grammatical
4
BACKGROUND OF LITERATURE
related to the topic, that I will analyse on the light of my other literature. Boroditsky
The nouns were chosen as the following, 20 words artefacts, 22 words natural objects,
During the investigation of the research, I looked at the data that the researcher had
used, to make sure was accurate and valid, but unfortunately, the researcher of the
literature, did not speak the Kurdish language, so he used the following data and
2. Pistol is masculine.
3. Hammer is a masculine noun in Kurdish but the researcher, even did not
mention it at all.
4. Key is a masculine.
7. Lion is a masculine noun in Kurdish but the researcher did not mention it
8. Fox is a feminine.
5
Schmidt, 2000, p.2) cited in Harry, 2000, p.1). Their comparison of genders
0.05. They termed this an “appreciable agreement”. But Harry the researcher and
author of this literature criticised this correlation and says this figure, a value of r
languages are agreed more on the genders of animals (r = 039, p< 0.1), than on the
The results of their study suggested the closer languages are in the family tree, the
more they agree on gender nouns the more grammatical gender nouns are used. For
(R2): (“a measure of how well the independent variable in a simple linear regression
can explain changes in the dependent variable, its value is between zero (0) meaning
poor fit and (1) meaning perfect fit”) Clark, 1985, p.452).
English and Kurdish for example have a very low correlation because it is not from
the same sub family and in addition the English language is monolingual language.
Monolingual means “able to speak only one language and written in one language
only”. Whereas the Persian language and the Afghani (Dari/Pshtu) languages come
from the same sub family, which means the correlation is much higher, than the
correlation between the English and the Kurdish language. The more similar the
6
languages, the higher the correlation. The more distant the languages the lower the
correlation.
English native speakers thought the gender of nouns shows a correspondence with the
task of gender in other Indo-European languages. In order to test the prediction the
researches asked 20 native Americans of English speakers, (10 males and 10 females),
among them. Especially for words that have a natural relation with maleness and
power, for example, hammer, boulder, attack and war, or with femaleness and beauty,
for example, flower, happiness, love and butterfly. The average assignments of
genders by English speakers form a 15th population. It was compared to the 14 studied
languages to determine the degree of correlation. Look at appendix (2). The table
The investigation suggested that the opinion of the native English speakers on gender
was very weak correlation with each of the 14 languages, except Kurdish, which can
Error: “a random term included in regression and analysis of variance that represents
the effects of all factors other than those that have been specifically included in the
According to the research that suggested the Kurdish language uses more grammatical
nouns than the English language. I would like to compare the use of masculine and
feminine between the Kurdish and the English languages by finding the average use
7
for both languages in the light of the data appendix 1. in regard to the animal nouns.
Mean: “mean is the value that is equal to the sum of a list of numbers divided by the
number of numbers (same as average” (Clark, 1985, p.9, 449). The formula is used to
n
where M = Mean
E = sum of
1+4+5+6+7+8+9+10 = 50
The mean is 50 divided by 8; which is equal to 6.25 (Clark, 1985, p.9, 449).
In order to find out the average of the masculine is used in Kurdish and English, I will
use the previous formula. First I will find the average of the masculine nouns is used
in Kurdish.
M=E N=
22 22
8
Second, I will find the average of the masculine nouns is used in English.
Mean is M = E N
Mean = 0.80 + 0.10 + 0.90 + 0.60 + 0.90 + 0.50 + 0.90 +0.20 + 0.30 + 0.80 +0.60
22
22
According to the above findings, the result suggested that the average masculine
grammatical noun words are used for animals in Kurdish language are higher than
English. The difference = Kurdish average words are used – English average words
I will provide another example in order to prove the hypothesis. Here I will find the
average use of feminine noun words in both languages and I will compare the
Mean is M = E N
84
84
9
According to the above findings, the result suggested that the average feminine
grammatical noun words are used in artefacts, natural objects , abstract, ideas and
Jheem suggests and supports my argument in this regard by saying that English has no
grammatical genders. A handful of the nouns have genders such as, buck, doe.etc…..
The gender relates to the noun’s meaning, not to its usage in a sentence. For example,
in French, every noun is either masculine or feminine for grammatical purpose. Old
English had three genders such as, masculine, feminine and neuter like most Indo-
for personal pronoun in third person singular pronouns, for example, he, she and it,
with masculine and feminine genders used for persons or higher animals in colloquial
speech as in “Is n’t she a beauty? There are two reasons for departure of grammatical
gender nouns first, due to phonological change and second, other ways of marking
2005, p.6).
In the Northern group of Kurdish dialects and Mukri (e, i), the Izafe (suffix or prefix)
appears in a number of forms, for example a, a, e, i and the nominal oblique case
endings as e and i. An analysis of these forms into a clear system, with two
adjectives usually follow singular nouns and they are connected to them by
components (e) or a, e that are usually used when a noun is masculine and (a) when
10
(i) Nouns ending in consonants.
(ii) Nouns ending in vowels for example, a,a,i,e, usually insert an euphonic (y)
In the north of the east of the Kurdish area, the Izafe (suffix or prefix) after plural
and neuter. But English shows gender in third person singular only, but this is not the
case in Kurdish language. For example, pronoun of he, she, and it with the masculine
and feminine genders is used for people or higher animals (Encyclopaedia, 2005, p.6).
Nouns have the same gender in all the Kurdish dialects. There are some examples to
2. ar(d)-flour ard m
3. as-mill ji es te
4. is-work ise ta
6. bira-brother bire te
Feminine:
11
The following feminine nouns are appear occasionally with masculine forms:
The research has done by Harry did not mention any thing about compound words in
any other 14 languages and English, except the use of grammatical genders. Here I
would like to conduct a research about the compound noun words in the Kurdish and
English languages, because the previous research question has not been dealt within
the previous studies, I have reviewed. I will compare the use of compound nouns in
the similar written texts. In the light of the above findings, I would like to ask the
What is noun?
Are Kurdish and English compound noun words are used equally in the written texts,
METHODOLOGY –DATA
What is noun?Nouns are names that are given to things such as, people, animals and
things. Nouns can be individual for example, a specific thing like my toy, Adelaide.
12
What are the different types of nouns?
Class, it refers to different groups of things like, snails, snakes. Abstract, it refers to
feelings, views, beliefs, ideas such as, beauty, ugly, loyalty. Feminine or masculine
for example (daughter, man, boy). Nouns, can be singular or plural (man-men,
noun such as, (sisters-in-law, grandfather, dinning-room). Mass nouns are always
represented as singular such as, bread, sheep, fish, ice, water. Nominalisations, it
refers to noun forms of verbs such as teacher, discussion. Noun groups are groups of
words which build on a noun. They are significant language resources for forming up
descriptions. For example, Lisa’s toy is a bear. Lisa’s toy is a black fluffy bear. Here,
both sentences are classification statements but the second sentence uses a noun group
Compound nouns, can consist more than one noun such as, sisters-in-law,
The gender of nouns have a significant role in the grammar of some languages, for
example in French a masculine noun can just take the masculine form of an adjective,
but if the noun is feminine, it will take a distinct form of the same adjective, which is
feminine form. But the English language does not have grammatical gender, the
13
nouns are actually not masculine or feminine but they refer to male, or female or
animals. For example; the waiter is very prompt. The waitress is very prompt. The
1996-1998, p.1).
Are Kurdish and English compound words are used equally in written texts,
In order to find out the use of compound words between Kurdish and English
languages, I have read two stories one of them is Kurdish and the other one is English.
The Kurdish story consists of 66 pages. The name of the book is Gelawej was written
by Teiyfoor and the book was published in 1992. Gelawej is the name of the main
character in the story. I have summarised and translated the story into English. (See
appendix-3).
But I have not used the whole text; I have used 38 pages that consist of nearly128
paragraphs. I have used 30 pages from the English story which is equivalent to the
Kurdish story in terms of the data. There are approximately about 4800 words. This
story is equivalent to the English story that I have read, in regard to the length of the
text and the level of the language is involved. Both the texts are designed for
advanced language ability of the readers of the Kurdish and English languages.
The English story is consists of 85 pages. The name of the book is a journey to the
centre of the earth. The author of the novel is Jules Verne; the story was published in
1969. I have summarised the whole story (see appendix 4). I have also translated the
Kurdish compound noun words into English, (see appendix 5). But I have not used the
whole text; I have used 30 pages that consist of nearly 125 paragraphs.
14
The story is equivalent to the Kurdish story in terms of data. There are approximately
4800 words which are equivalent to the Kurdish story that I have read in regard to the
length of the text and the level of the language is involved. Both the texts are designed
I have found 57 compound nouns from the Kurdish story and the same amount in the
English written text. I have found about 22 compound noun words in the English text,
which are less than the Kurdish compound nouns, (see appendix 6). I would like to
use the previous formula in order to find out the average words that have been used
where M = Mean
E = sum of
In order to find out the average of the compound nouns used in Kurdish and English.
I will use the previous formula first, to find the average of the Kurdish nouns.
Mean = Sum of the nouns are used in the Kurdish written text (57)
4800
15
To find out the average compound noun words are used in English, I use the
following formula.
mean is M = E N
M=E N=
Mean = Sum of the nouns used in the English written text (22)
4800
I will also find the compound noun words are used per page in the Kurdish language.
Per page = 57 compound nouns = 1.5 compound noun words used per
38 pages
I will also find the compound noun words are used per page in English.
30 pages
16
According to the above findings, the result suggested that the average compound noun
The difference = Kurdish average words are used – English average words are used;
According to the above findings, the result suggested that the average
Compound noun words are used in Kurdish are higher than in English.
Because the Kurdish language is not a sub family of the English language and, the
compound noun words are used in the both languages are not equivalent and there is a
The difference between the two languages = Kurdish average words used – English
I will also found the compound noun words are used per page in the Kurdish language
Per page = 57 compound nouns = 1.5 compound noun words used per
38 pages
I have also found the compound noun words are used per page in English are less than
Per page = 22 compound nouns = 0.73 the compound noun words are
30 pages
17
Conclusion
Are Kurdish and English compound noun words are used equally in written texts,
such as, stories? No, the compound words are used in the similar texts and the length
of the stories in Kurdish and English languages are different. Because the average of
compound noun words are used per page in the Kurdish language is 1.5 but the
average of compound noun words are used per page in English is 0.73, which is less
than the compound noun words are used per page in Kurdish language, so the
hypothesis is true.
English and Kurdish for example have a very low correlation because they are not
from the same sub family; in addition the English language is monolingual language.
Where the Persian language and the Afghan (Dari/Pshtu) languages come from the
same sub family, which means the correlation is much higher, than the correlation
between the English and the Kurdish languages. The more similar the languages
towards one another, the higher the correlation. The more distant the languages the
18
Reference
Arnie, Jheem and Shufitz, 2003, Gender of Nouns, cited on
http://wordcraft.infopop.cc/eve/ubb/.x/a/tpc/f/932607094/m/3981012071 dated on
1/5/2005.
Beal, C, 1994, Keeping the peace: Across cultural comparison of questions and
requests in Australian English and French. Multilingua, 13, ½, pg. 35- 58.
Boroditsky, L., and Lauren A. Schmidt 2000, “sex syntax, and semantics”. In the
proceeding of the 22nd Annual meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, Published
by Philadelphia, PA.
http://www.englit.ed.ac.uk/studying/undergrd/american_lit_2/Handouts/cmc_sex&
http://www.englit.ed.ac.uk/studying/undergrd/american_lit_2/Handouts/cmc_sex&
http://www3.azwestern.edu/psy/dgershaw/101/androggny.htm
19
Harry F., 2000, Evolution of Gender in Indo-European languages, Published by
USA.8.
centre for English Language Teaching and Research, Macquarie University Sydney.
MacKenzie, D., 1954, Gender in Kurdish (1), BSOAS Vol XVI (pp.528-541), 1954.,
By D.N. MacKenzie.
ling/archive/most-recent/msg06769.html
http://encyclopedia.lockergnome.com/s/b/Grammactical_gender
Sweeden.
20
The Internet Grammar of English, 1996-1998, The Gender of Nouns, Published by
Verne, J. A Journey to the Centre of the Earth, 1969, Published by Thomas Nelson
21
A journey to the Centre of the Earth, By Jules Verne.
Professor Lidenbrock was a rock, stone and metal collector. He had many rock, stone
and metal collections from all over the world, some where as old 200 years old. He
had a passion for adventures and discovering new things. His nephew Axel was in his
early stages of manhood. He had great respect for his uncle who had taught him a
great deal. Professor Lidenbrock had set out one day to go on a journey to the centre
which also was a volcano. They carried their journey to Snaefells very soon. The
Professors idea to take on this journey was from a man named Arne Saknussemm, but
was unsuccessful. So, professor Lidenbrock wanted to be the next person to try.
Professor Lidenbrock, Axel and their guider named Hans, set of on their journey to
the centre of the earth. It took them about three months to return back to Hamburg
their hometown (besides Hans who was from Iceland). On their way they climbed up
and down dangerous obstacles. When they made it in the volcano called Snaefells,
after several weeks on foot, they came across many situations of life and death mattes.
They had witnessed giant sea monsters, faced their some of their journey without any
food or water for a week, the rough path towards the centre of the earth was life
taking, yet the professor, Hans and Axel kept on going bravely. They came across a
sea which no man has ever seen before and they named the sea Lidenbrock Sea. They
also came across an island that they were the first to discover which they named after
After this long journey they were on a path that would lead them out of the mountain
and back onto land. Without their knowledge they ended up climbing out of a
mountain in Italy! They were pushed up by the lava of the volcano. They were lucky
22
to be alive! They were tired, weak and hungry. They soon made it back to Hamburg
and farewelled Hans who looked after them a great deal. They soon were known for
their heroic events, and for their accomplishment of coming out alive after being to
By Verne. J, 1969.
23
Gelawej
Gelwej is the name of the story was written by Teiyfoor. I would like to summarise
the story that I have read and looked at the Kurdish compound noun words. The story
was set in Sweden in 1992; the story is talking about the tragedy that Kurdish people
struggle and resistance against oppression that the Kurdish nation faces.
Gelawej is a woman, was married to Shemal and they were living in East of Kurdistan
(Iran). Gelawej was living with her mother in law and she had only one child, her
name was Triyfe, it means (Sun shine) in English. One day Gelawej’s (Shemal)
husband disappeared and nobody knew where he was? After a couple of years, she
did find out that her husband was a freedom fighter (Peshmerge) and he had joined
the Kurdish revolution. But the Iranian government knew where her husband was.
At the same time her brother in law (Heme) was a freedom fighter too.
Suddenly one day at about 2: am, some Iranian intelligent service and some solders
were raided their house and took the complete family, including, Gelawej, her
daughter (Tiriyfe) and her mother in law to jail. In the prison, they were separated
from each other and they were tortured very badly by secret police. While they were
in prison her brother in law Heme was killed in a fight with the government. The
Iranian secret police asked her for cooperation with the police; it was a condition for
their release. They were agreed to participate in order to be freed from prison.
After that, Gelawej sent a letter to her husband and asked him to come to the city with
his group of freedom fighters to rescue and them to the mountains or liberated areas.
But her husband Shemal could not come and asked his political organisation to
24
organise this operation. After some time they carried out the operation and took the
While they were crossing the mountains at night in order to reach the liberated area
which was belong to the Kurdish freedom fighters. They were raided by Iranian
When she arrived at the village. Her husband was still at about 5 hours far from the
village and it was a big war between the Kurdish freedom fighters and the
government, so again her husband could not come to see them. In the village at the
same house a girl was there and her father was a freedom fighter and he was killed
After a month of a fight between Kurdish freedom fighters and the government, she
was told by someone that her husband was wounded and got captured a life by Army.
But in reality he was injured but he was not became a prisoner of war. He was injured
Later on, she was told by the freedom fighters, that she had to leave the area due to
spread the war everywhere in Kurdish areas. So, while Gelawej was ready to leave the
house and the village towards crossing a border to another country, she was
approached by the six year old girl (Awat), and asked her to take her too. She was
agreed to take Awat and they went to Sweden as a refugee to the city of Stockholm.
Awat grew up and went to school and one day she brought back a letter from her
Kurdish friend at school about a Kurdish celebration for (Newroz). Newroz is the
beginning of the Kurdish New Year on 21st March in the year. She saw her husband’s
picture in the letter and she was so excited, she could not believe it. Her husband
25
(Shemal) was invited as a singer to participate in the celebration of Newroz (New
day).
Next, her husband was arrived in Stockholm, and Gelawej did not go to the party and
she said if he was a life, how come he did let me know what happened to him. But she
sent (Awat) with some Kurdish friends. At that night after the celebration, her
husband came to her place with some friends and found her and they met for the last
time.
Finally, after 2 months passed, someone was checking on their house, because her
husband was active politically. One day Gelawej was opening her letter box and
something got exploded and immediately killed her and Awat left alone again for the
second time without the love of her mum (Teifoor, 1992, 1-66).
26
A list of compound noun words in the Kurdish language
Noun+ Noun
27
derman draw patient medicine given
Noun+ Noun
28
gool u giya grass and flower flower and grass
29
A list of English Compound Words:
Noun + Noun
goodbye luggage
30
31
REFERENCES
APPENDIX
1. Words Examined
row).
Verne.
Words.
Words.
32