You are on page 1of 35

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 1 of 35




  :,//,$0$,6$$&621 Pro hac vice  
 ZLVDDFVRQ#EVIOOSFRP 
 67$&(<.*5,*6%< Pro hac vice 

  VJULJVE\#EVIOOSFRP  
1,&+2/$6$:,'1(// Pro hac vice 
 QZLGQHOO#EVIOOSFRP 
%2,(66&+,//(5)/(;1(5//3
 1HZ<RUN$YHQXH1::DVKLQJWRQ'&
7HOHSKRQH  )D[  


 5,&+$5'-32&.(5
USRFNHU#EVIOOSFRP 
 %2,(66&+,//(5)/(;1(5//3
6RXWK)RXUWK6WUHHW6XLWH/DV9HJDV19
 7HOHSKRQH  )D[  
 

'21$/'-&$03%(// 
GMF#FDPSEHOODQGZLOOLDPVFRP 
-&2/%<:,//,$06 
MFZ#FDPSEHOODQGZLOOLDPVFRP 
&$03%(// :,//,$06 
6RXWKWK6WUHHW/DV9HJDV19
7HOHSKRQH  )D[   

 
Attorneys for Defendant =XIID//&GED
8OWLPDWH)LJKWLQJ&KDPSLRQVKLSDQG8)& 

 

81,7('67$7(6',675,&7&2857 

',675,&72)1(9$'$ 

&XQJ/H1DWKDQ4XDUU\-RQ)LWFK%UDQGRQ &DVH1RFY5)% 3$/  
9HUD/XLV-DYLHU9D]TXH]DQG.\OH  
.LQJVEXU\RQEHKDOIRIWKHPVHOYHVDQGDOO 
RWKHUVVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHG '()(1'$17=8))$//&¶6 
 5(3/<,168332572)
3ODLQWLIIV 027,21)256800$5< 
Y -8'*0(17
  
=XIID//&GED8OWLPDWH)LJKWLQJ  
&KDPSLRQVKLSDQG8)& +($5,1*5(48(67('
  
'HIHQGDQW >5('$&7('@
 
 



=8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<
 
Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 2 of 35

 7$%/(2)&217(176

 ,1752'8&7,21

 $5*80(17
 
, 3ODLQWLIIV¶&ODLPV1RZ5HVW2Q$1HZ7KHRU\2I/LDELOLW\$QG0XVW%H

'LVPLVVHG
 ,, 3ODLQWLIIV¶&ODLPV)DLO%HFDXVH7KH\'R1RW'HILQH5HOHYDQW0DUNHWV
 $ 3ODLQWLIIV¶,QSXW0DUNHWVIRUD0RQRSVRQ\&ODLP$UH/HJDOO\,QVXIILFLHQW
 % 3ODLQWLIIV¶(YLGHQFH'RHV1RW'HILQH$Q2XWSXW0DUNHW)RUD0RQRSRO\
&ODLP

,,, =XIIDLV(QWLWOHGWR6XPPDU\-XGJPHQWRQ3ODLQWLIIV¶0RQRSVRQL]DWLRQ&ODLP

$ 7KH8QGLVSXWHG(YLGHQFH6KRZV&RPSHWLWLRQ 

% 3ODLQWLIIV&DQQRW6KRZ$*HQXLQH,VVXHRI)DFW&RQFHUQLQJ0RQRSVRQ\ 
3RZHU 

 3ODLQWLIIV&LWH1R5HOHYDQW'LUHFW(YLGHQFH2I/RZHU&RPSHQVDWLRQ
 7KH8QGLVSXWHG(YLGHQFH6KRZV1R5HVWULFWLRQ,Q2XWSXW 

 3ODLQWLIIV)DLO7R6KRZ$*HQXLQH,VVXH2I)DFW&RQFHUQLQJ 
&LUFXPVWDQWLDO(YLGHQFH2I0DUNHW3RZHU 
& 3ODLQWLIIV)DLO7R5HEXW(YLGHQFH7KDW=XIID'LG1RW(QJDJH,Q([FOXVLRQDU\
$QWLFRPSHWLWLYH&RQGXFW 

 3ODLQWLIIV¶$OOHJDWLRQV)LW6TXDUHO\:LWKLQD3UHGDWRU\+LULQJ&ODLP 

 3ODLQWLIIV)DLO7R5DLVH$*HQXLQH,VVXH2I0DWHULDO)DFW7KDW=XIID¶V 
&RQWUDFWV'LG1RW6XEVWDQWLDOO\)RUHFORVH&RPSHWLWLRQ 
D 3ODLQWLIIV'R1RW3XW)RUZDUG(YLGHQFH7KDW=XIID¶V/HJLWLPDWH
%XVLQHVV-XVWLILFDWLRQV$UH3UHWH[WXDO 

 3ODLQWLIIV+DYH1R(YLGHQFH2I$QWLFRPSHWLWLYH$FTXLVLWLRQVRU 
&RHUFLRQ 
,9 =XIID,V(QWLWOHG7R6XPPDU\-XGJPHQW2Q3ODLQWLIIV¶0RQRSROL]DWLRQ&ODLP 

9 3ODLQWLIIV+DYH1R(YLGHQFHWR6XSSRUW7KHLU,GHQWLW\&ODVV&ODLP 

9, 3ODLQWLIIV'R1RW+DYH6WDQGLQJ7R%ULQJ&ODLPV)RU,QMXQFWLYH5HOLHI
9,, 3ODLQWLIIV'R1RW5DLVH*HQXLQH)DFWXDO'LVSXWHV,Q7KH&62) 

$ 7KH&62)5HOLHVRQ,PSURSHURU,QDGPLVVLEOH(YLGHQFHWR$WWHPSWWR&UHDWHD 
*HQXLQH,VVXHRI0DWHULDO)DFW  

L
=8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<
Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 3 of 35

 7$%/(2)$87+25,7,(6

 &$6(6
 A. H. Cox & Co. v. Star Mach. Co.
 )G WK&LU 

 Aerotec Int’l, Inc. v. Honeywell Int’l, Inc.
)G WK&LU 

Airweld, Inc. v. Airco, Inc.
 )G WK&LU 
 Allied Orthopedic Appliances Inc. v. Tyco Health Care Grp.
)G WK&LU 
 

Am. Prof’l Testing Serv., Inc. v. Harcourt Brace
)G WK&LU  

Arminak & Assocs., Inc. v. Saint-Gobain Calmar, Inc. 
)6XSSG &'&DO  
Barnes v. AT&T
)5' 1'&DO   

City of Vernon v. S. Cal. Edison Co.
)G WK&LU  

Doe v. Arizona Hosp. & Healthcare Ass’n 
:/ '$UL]0DU  

Fishman v. Wirtz
)G WK&LU  

FTC v. Staples, Inc. 

)6XSS ''&  

FTC v. Sysco Corp. 
)6XSSG ''&  

FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.
)G ''&  

Gen. Bus. Sys. v. N. Am. Philips Corp. 
)G WK&LU  

Golden Boy Promotions LLC v. Haymon 
:/ &'&DO-DQ  

L
=8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<
Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 4 of 35


 Haro v. Sebelius
)G WK&LU 

Harris v. City of Fresno
 )6XSSG ('&DO 
 Hecht v. Pro-Football, Inc.
 )G '&&LU 

 Heerwagen v. Clear Channel Commc’ns
)G G&LU 

Image Tech Serv. Inc. v. Eastman Kodak Co.
 )G WK&LU 
 Image Tech. Servs., Inc. v. Eastman Kodak Co.
)G WK&LU   

In re Citric Acid Litig.
)G WK&LU  

In re Ebay Seller Antitrust Litig. 
:/ 1'&DO0DU  
In re Live Concert Antitrust Litig.
)6XSSG &'&DO   

In re NCAA Athletic Grant-In-Aid Cap Antitrust Litig.
)5' 1'&DO  

In re Online DVD Rental Antitrust Litig. 
:/ 1'&DO1RY  

In re Optical Disk Drive Antitrust Litig.
:/ 1'&DO'HF  

Indep. Ink, Inc. v. Trident, Inc. 

)6XSSG &'&DO  

Int’l Boxing Club of N.Y. v. United States 
86   

It's My Party, Inc. v. Live Nation, Inc.
)G WK&LU  

Kentucky Speedway, LLC v. NASCAR 
)G WK&LU  

Lee v. NNAMHS 
:/ '1HY6HSW 

LL
 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 5 of 35


 Mazda v. Carfax, Inc.
:/ 6'1<'HF 

McNeil v. NFL
 )6XSS '0LQQ 
 Missouri Hosp. v. C.R. Bard, Inc.
 )G WK&LU 

 Nationwide Power Sols. Inc. v. Eaton Elec. Inc.
:/ &'&DO2FW 

O’Bannon v. NCAA
 )G WK&LU 
 Oahu Gas Serv., Inc. v. Pac. Res., Inc.
)G WK&LU   

Ohio v. Am. Express Co.
6&W   

Olin Corp v. FTC 
)G WK&LU  
Omega Envtl, Inc. v. Gilbarco, Inc.
)G WK&LU   

Pac. Coast Fed’n of Fishermen's Assocs. v. Murillo
:/ ('&DO$XJ  

Pickern v. Pier 1 Imports (U.S.), Inc. 
)G WK&LU  

Rebel Oil Co. v. Atlantic Richfield Co.
)G WK&LU SDVVLP 

St. Alphonsus Med. Ctr-Nampa Inc. v. St. Luke’s Health Sys., Ltd 

)G WK&LU  

Taggart v. Rutledge 
)G WK&LU  

Tampa Elec. Co. v. Nashville Coal Co.
86   

Theme Promotions Inc. v. News Am. Marketing FSI 
)G WK&LU  

Thurman Indus. v. Pak’NPay Stores, Inc. 
)G WK&LU 

LLL
 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 6 of 35


 U.S. v. Syufy Entrps.
)G WK&LU 

United States v. Oracle Corp.
 )6XSSG 1'&DO 
 Universal Analytics, Inc. v. MacNeal-Schwendler Corp.
 )G WK&LU 

 White v. NCAA
:/ &'&DO2FW 

William Inglis & Sons Baking Co. v. Cont’l Baking Co., Inc.
 )G WK&LU 
 58/(6 

)HG5&LY3 F  

)HG5&LY3 H                   

LY
 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 7 of 35


 ,1752'8&7,21
 
 8QDEOHWRGLVSXWHWKHPDUNHWUHDOLWLHVRIH[SDQGLQJFRPSHWLWRUVLQFUHDVLQJRXWSXWDQG


ULVLQJFRPSHQVDWLRQ3ODLQWLIIVSXUVXHDQHZDQWLWUXVWWKHRU\DQGVXSSRUWLWZLWKDQDUUDWLYHWKDW
  
GRHVQRWDGGUHVV=XIID¶V6WDWHPHQWRI8QGLVSXWHG)DFWV ³68)´ 7KDWQDUUDWLYHUHOLHVKHDYLO\RQ

WKHSXEOLFVWDWHPHQWVRI8)&¶V3UHVLGHQW'DQD:KLWHEXWVWURQJVWDWHPHQWVSUDLVLQJ\RXURZQ

EXVLQHVVDQGGHPHDQLQJ\RXUFRPSHWLWRUVDUHHYLGHQFHRIFRPSHWLWLRQQRWRIDQDQWLWUXVWFDVH

$QG3ODLQWLIIVFDQQRWXVHWKHLUH[SHUWWRPDQXIDFWXUHIDFWXDOGLVSXWHV3ODLQWLIIVQHYHUUHEXWZLWK

HYLGHQFHFULWLFDOIDFWVWKDWUHTXLUH=XIID¶VPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWREHJUDQWHG3ODLQWLIIV

FRQFHGHWKDWGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG=XIIDKDV  LQFUHDVHGRXWSXWRI=XIIDHYHQWV  SDLG

DWKOHWHVPRUHDQG  SDLGPRUHWKDQLWVFRPSHWLWRUV&62)ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIVFRQWHQGWKDW 

VXFKIDFWVDUH³LUUHOHYDQW´EXWUHOHYDQFHLVDOHJDOLVVXHZKLFKLVZK\WKLVFDVHVKRXOGEHGHFLGHG 

RQVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW 

%\FRQWUDVWWRWKH&RPSODLQWZKLFKVXUYLYHGGLVPLVVDOEDVHGRQDFRPELQHGPRQRSVRQ\ 

DQGPRQRSRO\FODLPRQVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW3ODLQWLIIVDQGWKHLUH[SHUWVKDYHIDLOHGWRDWWHPSWWR 

VKRZDQWLWUXVWLQMXU\RUGDPDJHVIRUDPRQRSRO\FODLPRUWRDWWHPSWWRSHUIRUPWKHWHVWIRUD 

PDUNHWIRUVXFKDFODLP3ODLQWLIIVLQRSSRVLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWFDQRQO\SXUVXHDPRQRSVRQ\ 

FODLPWKDWWKH1LQWK&LUFXLWKDVFDOOHG³FRXQWHULQWXLWLYH´DQGKDVTXHVWLRQHGZKHWKHUVXFKD 

WKHRU\FDQPDNHHFRQRPLFVHQVHU.S. v. Syufy Entrps.)G WK&LU (YHQ 

IRUWKDWFODLP3ODLQWLIIVKDYHVKLIWHGWKHLUWKHRU\WRRQHEDVHGRQ³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUVDJURXSWKDW 

LVQRWGHILQHGZDVQRWGLVFORVHGLQGLVFRYHU\DQGZKLFKLVQHLWKHUWKHEDVLVRIWKHPDUNHWVWKDW 

KDYHEHHQGHILQHGQRUWKHFODVVIRUZKLFKFHUWLILFDWLRQLVVRXJKW7KHXQGLVSXWHGIDFWVVKRZWKDW 

3ODLQWLIIV¶UHPDLQLQJFODLPPDNHVQRHFRQRPLFVHQVH=XIID¶VFRPSHWLWRUVKDGDQGKDYHDFFHVV 

WRWDOHQWHG00$DWKOHWHVHVWDEOLVKHGYHQXHVUHFRJQL]DEOHVSRQVRUVDQGDZLGHYDULHW\RI 

SODWIRUPVDQGWHOHYLVLRQVWDWLRQVWRGLVWULEXWHWKHLUHYHQWV(VWDEOLVKHGFRPSHWLWRUVKDYHJURZQ 

DQGQHZFRPSHWLWRUVKDYHHQWHUHGWKHPDUNHWDQGH[SDQGHG1RWKLQJPRUHLVUHTXLUHGLQWKLV 

&LUFXLWWRJUDQWVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRebel Oil Co. v. Atlantic Richfield Co.)G 

WK&LU  VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWJUDQWHGZKHUH³FRPSHWLWRUVKDYHH[SDQGHGRXWSXWLQWKH 

UHFHQWSDVWRUKDYHWKHDELOLW\WRH[SDQGRXWSXWLQWKHIXWXUH´  


=8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<
 
Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 8 of 35


$5*80(17

3ODLQWLIIV¶2SSRVLWLRQSUHVHQWVDSDJH³&RXQWHUVWDWHPHQWRI)DFWV´ ³&62)´ WKDWGRHV

QRWGLUHFWO\UHVSRQGWR=XIID¶V68)3ODLQWLIIV¶&62)SURIIHUV³IDFWV´XVLQJWKH³VSDJKHWWL

DSSURDFK´WRVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWZKHUHDSDUW\³KDVKHDYHGWKHHQWLUHFRQWHQWVRIDSRWDJDLQVW

WKHZDOOLQKRSHVWKDWVRPHWKLQJZRXOGVWLFN´Indep. Towers of Wash. v. Washington)G

 WK&LU 7KLV&RXUWVKRXOG³GHFOLQH>@WRVRUWWKURXJKWKHQRRGOHVLQVHDUFKRI´

VXSSRUWIRUPDWHULDOGLVSXWHVRU3ODLQWLIIV¶FODLPVId.Assurance Co. of Am. v. Ironshore

Specialty Ins. Co.:/DW  '1HY0DU  GHQ\LQJVXPPDU\

MXGJPHQWUHFRQVLGHUDWLRQPRWLRQZKHUHPDQ\H[KLELWVERUH³OLWWOHWRQRUHODWLRQWRWKH

SURSRVLWLRQV´WKH\FODLPWRVXSSRUW 2WKHUWKDQVSRUDGLFUHIHUHQFHVWRIDFWXDOGLVSXWHV3ODLQWLIIV 

GRQRWLQGLFDWHZKLFKSDUDJUDSKVRIWKH68)DUHGLVSXWHG:KHUH3ODLQWLIIVIDLOWRDGGUHVV 

=XIID¶V68)WKH&RXUWPD\³FRQVLGHUWKHIDFWXQGLVSXWHGIRUSXUSRVHVRIWKHPRWLRQ´)HG5 

&LY3 F  H  See infra†9,, 

, 3ODLQWLIIV¶&ODLPV1RZ5HVW2Q$1HZ7KHRU\2I/LDELOLW\$QG0XVW%H'LVPLVVHG 

3ODLQWLIIVLQWKHLU2SSRVLWLRQIRUWKHILUVWWLPHLQWURGXFHWKHWHUP³PDUTXHH´DOOHJLQJ 

WKDW³0DUTXHH)LJKWHUVDUHE\IDUWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWLQSXWIRU00$SURPRWHUV´ &62)ˆ DQG 

WKDW=XIIDYLRODWHGWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVE\SUHYHQWLQJFRPSHWLWRUVIURPKDYLQJD³FULWLFDOPDVV´RI 

WKHVHILJKWHUV2SS7KHWKHRU\WKDWD³FULWLFDOPDVV´RI³PDUTXHH´)LJKWHUVLVD 

³FULWLFDOLQSXW´GRHVQRWDSSHDULQWKH&RQVROLGDWHG$PHQGHG&RPSODLQW ³&$&´ (&)1R 

$QGLQ3ODLQWLIIV¶LQWHUURJDWRU\UHVSRQVHV3ODLQWLIIVGLVFXVV³(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHUV´ 

DQGPDNHQRPHQWLRQRI³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUVWKHZRUG³PDUTXHH´GRHVQRWDSSHDULQany 

UHVSRQVHVHYHUDORIZKLFKVSHFLILFDOO\DVNHGDERXW³(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHU´VHUYLFHV 

([3OV¶)LUVW$P,QWHUURJ5HVSV([3OV¶6HFRQG,QWHUURJ5HVS 

$VGLVFXVVHGLQWKH&RXUW¶VRSLQLRQRQWKHPRWLRQWRGLVPLVV3ODLQWLIIV¶&$&DOOHJHGD 

PDUNHWIRU³(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHUVHUYLFHV´&$&ˆˆ(&)1RDWEXW 

3ODLQWLIIVDQGWKHLUH[SHUWWKHQGHQLHGWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDZHOOXQGHUVWRRGGHILQLWLRQRIZKRZRXOG 

FRQVWLWXWHDJURXSRIHOLWH00$DWKOHWHVE.g.([.LQJVEXU\7U ³,GRQ¶WUHFDOO 

VHHLQJDVWDQGDUGGHILQLWLRQRIDQHOLWHOHYHOILJKWHU´ ([6LQJHU5HSˆˆ UHOHYDQW 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 9 of 35


 LQSXWPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQVGRQRWLQFOXGHWKHZRUG³HOLWH´ 0RW 68)ˆ3ODLQWLIIVQRZ
 SLYRWWRDQHZWHUP³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUVWRDYRLGWKHODFNRIHYLGHQFHRIDGHILQHGJURXSRIHOLWH

 ILJKWHUV %XWQHZDOOHJDWLRQVUDLVHGIRUWKHILUVWWLPHLQRSSRVLWLRQWRVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWFDQQRW

 SUHFOXGHWKHJUDQWRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW 
 ,, 3ODLQWLIIV¶&ODLPV)DLO%HFDXVH7KH\'R1RW'HILQH5HOHYDQW0DUNHWV
 $ 3ODLQWLIIV¶,QSXW0DUNHWVIRUD0RQRSVRQ\&ODLP$UH/HJDOO\,QVXIILFLHQW

 $V=XIIDH[SODLQHGLQLWV0RWLRQ3ODLQWLIIVSURSRVHIRXUIODZHGPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQVLQ

 SODFHRIDSURSHUO\VXSSRUWHGPDUNHW0RW(DFKRI'U6LQJHU¶VSURSRVHGPDUNHWV QRQH

 RIZKLFKLVGHILQHGDV³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUV LVIODZHGEHFDXVHDOWKRXJKKHFODLPVWRXVHWKH6PDOO 

EXW6LJQLILFDQW1RQWUDQVLWRU\'HFUHDVHLQ3ULFH ³661'3´ WHVWGHULYHGIURPWKH0HUJHU 

*XLGHOLQHVKHQHYHUSHUIRUPVVXFKDQDQDO\VLVE.gSe. Missouri Hosp. v. C.R. Bard, Inc. 

)G WK&LU  DQH[SHUW¶VDVVHUWLRQWKDWD661,3GRHVQRWFDXVHFXVWRPHUVWR 

VZLWFKLVLQVXIILFLHQWWRVXSSRUWDPDUNHWZKHUHWKHUHLVQHLWKHUDQDO\WLFQRUDQHFGRWDOHYLGHQFHWR 

VXSSRUWWKHFODLP 7KHDFFHSWHGPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQPHWKRGUHTXLUHG'U6LQJHUWRGHWHUPLQH 

ZKHUHDSULFHGHFUHDVHZRXOGFDXVH00$DWKOHWHVWRVZLWFKSURPRWHUVVRDVWRGHWHUPLQHWKH 

UHOHYDQWPDUNHWRISURPRWHUVSt. Alphonsus Med. Ctr-Nampa Inc. v. St. Luke’s Health Sys., Ltd 

)G WK&LU  ³,IHQRXJKFRQVXPHUVZRXOGUHVSRQGWRD661,3E\ 

SXUFKDVLQJWKHSURGXFWIURPRXWVLGHWKHSURSRVHGJHRJUDSKLFPDUNHWPDNLQJWKH661,3 

XQSURILWDEOHWKHSURSRVHGPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQLVWRRQDUURZ´ 'U6LQJHUGLGQRWDWWHPSWWKLVDQG 

DGPLWWHGKHGLGQRWHYDOXDWHDGHFUHDVHLQFRPSHQVDWLRQDWDOO([6LQJHU'HS 

7KHUHLVQRUHFRUGHYLGHQFHUHJDUGLQJKRZDQDWKOHWH ZKHWKHUODEHOHG³PDUTXHH´RURWKHUZLVH  

 

3ODLQWLIIVDQGWKHLUH[SHUWVZHUHQRWDVNHGDWGHSRVLWLRQIRUWKHGHILQLWLRQRI³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUV 
EHFDXVH3ODLQWLIIVKDGQRWDOOHJHGWKHH[LVWHQFHRIVXFKDJURXS

Pickern v. Pier 1 Imports (U.S.), Inc.)G± WK&LU  DIILUPLQJVXPPDU\ 
MXGJPHQWZKHUHSODLQWLIIJDYH³QRQRWLFHRIWKHVSHFLILFIDFWXDODOOHJDWLRQVSUHVHQWHGIRUWKHILUVW
WLPHLQ>3ODLQWLII¶V@RSSRVLWLRQWRVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW´ Lee v. NNAMHS:/DW 
Q '1HY6HSW  LQDSSURSULDWH³IRU3ODLQWLIIWRDVVHUWQHZDOOHJDWLRQVRXWVLGHWKH 
VFRSHRIWKHFRPSODLQW´LQVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRSSRVLWLRQ Pac. Coast Fed’n of Fishermen’s
Assocs. v. Murillo:/DW ± ('&DO$XJ  VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWQRW 
D³SURFHGXUDOVHFRQGFKDQFHWRIOHVKRXWLQDGHTXDWHSOHDGLQJV´  FLWLQJFDVHV 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 10 of 35

 ZRXOGUHVSRQGWRD661'37KLVWHVWZDVHVVHQWLDOWKHXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHLVWKDWKXQGUHGVRI
 DWKOHWHVKDYHOHIW=XIIDWRFRPSHWHIRURWKHUSURPRWHUV68)ˆ FLWLQJ%ODLU5HSˆ)LJ 
 5DWKHUWKDQWKHDFFHSWHGPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQPHWKRG'U6LQJHUUHOLHVRQLQGXVWU\OLVWVRI
 DWKOHWHVDQGGHILQHVWKHPDUNHWEDVHGRQWKHLUSURPRWHUV+HFODLPVWKDWWKHVHOLVWVDUH³LQGXVWU\
 UHFRJQL]HG´EXWDQH[SHUWRSLQLRQUHJDUGLQJLQGXVWU\UHFRJQLWLRQLVLQVXIILFLHQWDVDPDWWHURI
 ODZWRVXSSRUWPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQIn re Live Concert Antitrust Litig.,)6XSSG
 &'&DO 7KHUHLVDOVRQRHYLGHQFHWKDW'U6LQJHU¶VOLVWVDUH³LQGXVWU\UHFRJQL]HG´WR
 HVWDEOLVKmarkets or market sharesDVRSSRVHGWRWKHUDQNLQJRIDWKOHWHV
 $QGHYHQDVDUDQNLQJRIDWKOHWHVIRUWKH³7UDFNHG´PDUNHW)LJKW0HWULF¶V&(2H[SODLQHG 
WKDWWKH)LJKW0HWULFGDWDGRHVQRWFDSWXUHDFRPSOHWHOLVWRIFRPSHWLWLYH00$ILJKWHUV([ 
*HQDXHU'HFOˆˆ'U6LQJHUDOVRLQH[SOLFDEO\H[FOXGHVKXQGUHGVRISURPRWHUVIRUDWKOHWHV 
LQKLV³5DQNHG´PDUNHWGHVSLWHWKRXVDQGVRIUDQNHGDWKOHWHVFRPSHWLQJIRUWKHP68)ˆ 
([V 'U6LQJHUFRPSRXQGVWKLVSUREOHPE\H[FOXGLQJSURPRWHUVZKRVRPHWLPHVSXW 
RQERXWVZLWKUDQNHGDWKOHWHV0RW 
)LQDOO\IRUWKH³+HDGOLQHU´PDUNHW'U6LQJHULGHQWLILHVWKHWRSUDQNHGDWKOHWHVDVD 
VHSDUDWHJURXS DJURXSPXFKVPDOOHUWKDQWKHFODVV EXWGRHVQRWDGHTXDWHO\H[SODLQZKDW 
GLVWLQJXLVKHVWKHWRSUDQNHGDWKOHWHVDVDUHOHYDQWVXEPDUNHWThurman Indus. v. Pak’NPay 
Stores, Inc.)G WK&LU  ³:LWKRXWDVKRZLQJRIWKHUROHWKDWLQGXVWU\ 
DQGSXEOLFSHUFHSWLRQGLVWLQFWFXVWRPHUVRUVSHFLDOL]HGYHQGRUVSOD\LQPRWLYDWLQJDQGVKDSLQJ 
FRQVXPHUGHFLVLRQVWKHGHPDUFDWLRQRIDVXEPDUNHWIURPZLWKLQWKHSRRORISURGXFHUVDQGVHOOHUV 
ZKRVXSSO\HFRQRPLFVXEVWLWXWHVFDQQRWEHMXVWLILHG´ 3ODLQWLIIVRIIHUQRHYLGHQFHVXFKDV 
FRQVXPHUVXUYH\VRUDSULFLQJDQDO\VLVVXIILFLHQWWRVXSSRUWWKHPRUHQDUURZPDUNHWVXSKHOGLQ
 
WKHFDVHVWKH\FLWH 2WKHURI3ODLQWLIIV¶FDVHVGHILQHPDUNHWVE\TXDOLW\GLVWLQFWLRQV2SS 

FTC v. Staples, Inc.)6XSS ''&  GHILQLQJPDUNHWRIRIILFH 
VXSHUVWRUHVZKHUHHYLGHQFHVKRZHGWKDWSULFHVZHUHKLJKHU³LQPDUNHWVZKHUH6WDSOHVIDFHV
QRRIILFHVXSHUVWRUHFRPSHWLWLRQDWDOO´ FTC v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.)G 
''&  ³WKH)7&SURYLGHGGLUHFWHYLGHQFHWKDWWKHRSHQLQJRIDQHZ:KROH)RRGVLQ 
WKHYLFLQLW\RID:LOG2DWVFDXVHG:LOG2DWV¶VSULFHVWRGURSZKLOHHQWU\E\QRQ3126VWRUHV
KDGQRVXFKHIIHFW´ see alsoTheme Promotions Inc. v. News Am. Marketing FSI)G 


=8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<
Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 11 of 35


 Q%XWLQDOORIWKRVHFDVHVFOHDUDQGREMHFWLYHPDUNHWHYLGHQFHVXSSRUWHGWKHGLVWLQFWLRQV±QRW

 PHUHO\WKHVD\VRRIWKHH[SHUW±DQGLWZDVFOHDUZKRZDVLQDQGRXWRIWKHPDUNHW $GGLWLRQDOO\
 WKHFRQFHSWWKDWDSDUWLFXODUVXEVHWRIVXSSOLHUVLVVXVFHSWLEOHWRD661'3LVZKDWLVUHIHUUHGWRDV

 DSULFHGLVFULPLQDWLRQPDUNHW DQG'U6LQJHUKDVH[SUHVVO\UHMHFWHGWKDWKHLVWU\LQJWRGHILQHD
 SULFHGLVFULPLQDWLRQPDUNHW2SS([6LQJHU'HS,,
 3ODLQWLIIVFODLPWKDW'U6LQJHU³GRHVSHUIRUPD661'3WHVWDQDO\]LQJWKHSULQFLSDO
 FULWHULRQ)LJKWHUVXVHLQHYDOXDWLQJSURPRWHUVWKHDELOLW\WRRIIHUVXLWDEOHRSSRQHQWV´VSHFLILFDOO\
 ³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUV2SS%XW3ODLQWLIIVQHYHUGHILQH³PDUTXHH´DQGRIIHUQRVXSSRUWIRU
 WKHLU³VXIILFLHQWPDUTXHHILJKWHU´FULWHULRQIRUGHILQLQJDPDUNHW6XEVWLWXWLQJWKHYDJXHWHUP 
³PDUTXHH´ RUVLPLODUWHUPVVXFKDV³WRS´RU³KLJKUDQNLQJ´ IRU³HOLWH´GRHVQRWSHUPLWDPDUNHW 
WREHGHILQHGDQG'U6LQJHUGLGQRWGHILQHDPDUNHWRIVXFK³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUVRUHYHQGHILQH 
WKHWHUPLQKLVUHSRUW$QGUHDOZRUOGH[DPSOHVUHIXWHWKHFRQWHQWLRQWKDWDWKOHWHVRQO\VLJQZLWK 
SURPRWHUVZKRKDYHVRPHXQLGHQWLILHGQXPEHURIZHOONQRZQDWKOHWHVE.g.([ $EVROXWH 
&KDPSLRQVKLS%HUNXW ³$&%´ DWWUDFWHGWRSUDQNHGDWKOHWHVLQWZRWRWKUHH\HDUVGHVSLWH 
VWDUWLQJZLWKRQO\IRXUUDQNHGDWKOHWHVHDFKUDQNHGRUORZHU 'XULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRGPRUH 
WKDQDKXQGUHGSURPRWHUVH[FOXGHGIURPWKH5DQNHGPDUNHWHDFK\HDUKDGDVPDQ\UDQNHG 
DWKOHWHVDVSURPRWHUV'U6LQJHULQFOXGHG([V  
(YHQLIWKHFULWHULRQRIVXIILFLHQW³PDUTXHHILJKWHUV´ZDVDFFHSWHGWKDWFULWHULRQZRXOG 
LQYDOLGDWHDOORI'U6LQJHU¶VPDUNHWVEHFDXVHLWGHILQHVD=XIIDRQO\PDUNHW2SS ³7RS 
ILJKWHUVZRXOGOHDYH=XIIDRQO\IRUDSURPRWLRQWKDWKDGDPDVVHGDµGHHSOLQHXSRIPDUTXHH 

 
 WK&LU  HYLGHQFHWKDWWKHSULFHRIFRXSRQLQVHUWVURVHIURPSHUWKRXVDQGWR
SHUWKRXVDQGZLWKRXWVLJQLILFDQWGHIHFWLRQZDVVXIILFLHQWWRXSKROGMXU\YHUGLFW  

&RPSDUHInt’l Boxing Club of N.Y. v. United States86   LQDFRQVSLUDF\ 
EHWZHHQSURPRWHUVYHQXHVDQGEURDGFDVWHUVXSKROGLQJPDUNHWRI³FKDPSLRQVKLS´ER[LQJ
PDWFKHVZKHUH³GHWDLOHGILQGLQJV´RIUHYHQXHSULFHVDQGGHPDQGVKRZHGDGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ 
EHWZHHQ³FKDPSLRQVKLS´DQGQRQFKDPSLRQVKLSPDWFKHV ZLWKGolden Boy Promotions LLC v.
Haymon:/DW  &'&DO-DQ  GLVPLVVLQJPDUNHWRIPDQDJHUVRI 
³&KDPSLRQVKLS&DOLEHUER[HUV´³LQOLJKWRIWKHIDFWWKDWDQRQ&KDPSLRQVKLS&DOLEHU%R[HUFDQ
EHFRPHD&KDPSLRQVKLS&DOLEHU%R[HUDVWKHUHVXOWRIDVLQJOHILJKW´  

FTC v. Sysco Corp.)6XSSG ''&  GHVFULELQJSULFHGLVFULPLQDWLRQ 
PDUNHWVXQGHU0HUJHU*XLGHOLQHVDVWDUJHWLQJD³VXEVHWRIFXVWRPHUVIRUSULFHLQFUHDVHV´ 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 12 of 35

 ILJKWHUV¶7KH6FKHPHOHIWQRVXFKSURPRWHURWKHUWKDQ=XIID´ ([6LQJHU5HSˆ ³HYHQ
 WKHPRVWSURPLQHQWQRQ=XIIDSURPRWHUVGRQRWKDYHDFFHVVWRDVXIILFLHQWO\GHHSSRRORIWDOHQWHG
 )LJKWHUVWRSURYLGHFRPSHWLWLYHPDWFKXSV´ %XW3ODLQWLIIV¶H[SHUWQHYHUGHILQHGRUDQDO\]HGD
 =XIIDRQO\PDUNHWDQGVXFKDPDUNHWZRXOGFOHDUO\QRWEHSHUPLWWHGE.g.United States v.
 Oracle Corp.)6XSSG 1'&DO  ³MXGLFLDOUHMHFWLRQRIPDUNHWV
 QDUURZO\GHILQHGWRDVLQJOHPDQXIDFWXUHU¶VSURGXFWKDVEHHQHYHQPRUHSURQRXQFHGWKDQMXGLFLDO
 VNHSWLFLVPDERXWQDUURZO\GHILQHGVXEPDUNHWV´  FLWLQJFDVHV :LWKD=XIIDRQO\PDUNHWDOORI

 'U6LQJHU¶VRWKHUPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQVDUHLQYDOLG DQGKLVFDOFXODWLRQVRILPSDFWDQGGDPDJHV

 SUHGLFDWHGRQWKRVHPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQVDUHHTXDOO\LQYDOLG  
% 3ODLQWLIIV¶(YLGHQFH'RHV1RW'HILQH$Q2XWSXW0DUNHW)RUD0RQRSRO\&ODLP 

'U6LQJHUKDVDGPLWWHGWKDWKLVGHILQHGRXWSXWPDUNHWLQFOXGHV³YLHZHUVFDEOHQHWZRUNV 

EURDGFDVWQHWZRUNVDQGVSRQVRUV´ ([6LQJHU5HSˆ EXWWKDWKHGLGQRWWHVWZKHWKHU 

FDEOHQHWZRUNVEURDGFDVWQHWZRUNVDQGVSRQVRUVZRXOGVZLWFKWRRWKHUVSRUWVDQGHQWHUWDLQPHQW 

HYHQWVLQWKHIDFHRID661,30RW3ODLQWLIIVWKHUHIRUHQRZWDNHDQHZDSSURDFKFODLPLQJ 

ZLWKRXWHYLGHQFHRUDQDO\VLV WKDWWKHVHFXVWRPHUV¶GHPDQGLVXOWLPDWHO\GULYHQE\YLHZHUV 

2SS7KLVDVVHUWLRQIDLOVDVDPDWWHURIODZDVDPHWKRGWRGHILQHDPDUNHW Kentucky 

Speedway, LLC v. NASCAR)G WK&LU  DIILUPLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW 

ZKHUHSODLQWLII¶VH[SHUW 'U=LPEDOLVW GHILQHGDPDUNHWRI6SULQW&XSUDFHVZKHUH³IDQV 

WHOHYLVLRQVWDWLRQVFRUSRUDWLRQVDQGPRWRUVSRUWVUDGLRQHWZRUNVDUHFRQVXPHUV´EXWGLGQRW 

FRQVLGHUUHDVRQDEOHDOWHUQDWLYHVIRUDOOFRQVXPHUV $QGEHFDXVH'U6LQJHUGLGQRWSHUIRUPD 

661,3WHVWKHKDVQREDVLVWRDVVHUW RUNQRZ ZKHWKHUDQ\SXUSRUWHGFXVWRPHUVLQKLVPDUNHW
 
ZRXOGWXUQWRRWKHUVSRUWVDQGHQWHUWDLQPHQWRSWLRQVLISULFHVLQFUHDVHG 0RW$661,3WHVW 


Olin Corp v. FTC)G WK&LU  UHOHYDQWSURGXFWPDUNHWLV³WKHVPDOOHVW 
JURXSRISURGXFWV´DK\SRWKHWLFDOPRQRSROLVWFRXOGSURILWDEO\LPSRVHD661,3 
 
([6LQJHU'HS ³WKHPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQ,FKRRVHDQGWKHZHLJKWVWKDW,DSSO\
JHQHUDWHDPHDVXUHRIIRUHFORVXUHVKDUH´ZKLFKLVWKHQLQFOXGHGDVDQ³LQSXW´LQWKHUHJUHVVLRQ  

2SSQ'RFXPHQWVZKLFKOLVWWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIFHUWDLQYLHZHUVRIDKDQGIXORI8)& 
HYHQWVYLVjYLVRWKHUVSRUWVVD\QRWKLQJDERXWZKHWKHUHQRXJK00$YLHZHUVZRXOGFURVVRYHU
WRRWKHUVSRUWVHQWHUWDLQPHQWHYHQWVLQUHVSRQVHWRD661,3Indep. Ink)6XSSGDW 
 LQWHUQDOEXVLQHVVGRFXPHQWVFDQQRWGHILQHPDUNHWV 


=8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<
Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 13 of 35


 ZDVFUXFLDOWRMXVWLI\3ODLQWLIIV¶QDUURZPDUNHWEHFDXVHPXOWLSOHDSSHOODWHFRXUWVKDYHKHOGWKDW
 SURIHVVLRQDOVSRUWVFRPSHWHZLWKRWKHUVSRUWVDQGHQWHUWDLQPHQWE.g.Kentucky Speedway
 )G ³µDIDPLO\RIIRXUPLJKWSDWURQL]HD%HQJDOVRU5HGVJDPHRUVRPHRWKHUVSRUWVHYHQW
 LQVWHDGRID6SULQW&XSUDFH¶LIWKHSULFHRI6SULQW&XSUDFHWLFNHWVZHUHUDLVHG´  FROOHFWLQJ
 FDVHV 7KHUHZDVQRMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUVNLSSLQJWKLVWHVWWKHSHRSOHZKRNQRZWKHLUEXVLQHVVHV
 EHVW00$DQGER[LQJSURPRWHUVDQGQHWZRUNH[HFXWLYHVDOOWHVWLILHGXQGHURDWKWKDWWKH\
 FRPSHWHGLQWKHRXWSXWPDUNHWZLWKRWKHUVSRUWVDQGHQWHUWDLQPHQW68)ˆ
 3ODLQWLIIVDOVRLPSURSHUO\FRPELQHYLHZHUVRIOLYH00$HYHQWVZLWK339YLHZHUVLQWR
 RQHPDUNHWDUJXLQJWKDWEHFDXVH³DKDQGIXORIIDQV´FRXOGFKRRVHWRZDWFKHLWKHULQSHUVRQRURQ 
WHOHYLVLRQWZRPDUNHWVDUHQRWUHTXLUHG2SS3ODLQWLIIVDUHZURQJDVFRXUWVKDYHUHSHDWHGO\ 
KHOGWKDWWKHUHFDQQRWEHDQDWLRQDOPDUNHWIRUOLYHDWWHQGDQFHDWDQHYHQWHeerwagen v. Clear 
Channel Commc’ns)G G&LU Hecht v. Pro-Football, Inc.)G 
 '&&LU Fishman v. Wirtz)GQ WK&LU  
,,, =XIIDLV(QWLWOHGWR6XPPDU\-XGJPHQWRQ3ODLQWLIIV¶0RQRSVRQL]DWLRQ&ODLP 

$ 7KH8QGLVSXWHG(YLGHQFH6KRZV&RPSHWLWLRQ
3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWGLVSXWHWKDW=XIID¶VFRPSHWLWRUVGXULQJWKHUHOHYDQWWLPHSHULRGKDYH 

WHVWLILHGWKDWWKH\FRPSHWHZLWK=XIIDIRUDWKOHWHVDQGWKDW=XIIDKDVQRWEORFNHGWKHP³IURPDQ\ 

LQSXWVQHFHVVDU\WRSXWRQVXFFHVVIXO00$HYHQWV´RU³GRQHDQ\WKLQJWRLPSHGH>WKHLU@DELOLW\WR 

FRPSHWH´([&6LOYD'HS68)ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIVFODLPWKDWWKHVHSURPRWHUV¶ 

VZRUQWHVWLPRQ\DUH³ERDVWV´&62)ˆEXWQHYHUVXEPLWWHGHYLGHQFHWKDWWKLVWHVWLPRQ\LVQRW 

WUXH3ODLQWLIIVFDQQRWHVFDSHWKDW=XIID¶VFRPSHWLWRUV²WKHVXSSRVHGWDUJHWVRI=XIID¶VDOOHJHG 

FRQGXFW²VWDWHWKDW3ODLQWLIIV¶WKHRU\LVLQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKPDUNHWIDFWV,QWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHV 

VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWPXVWEHJUDQWHGA. H. Cox & Co. v. Star Mach. Co.)G 

WK&LU  DIILUPLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWJLYHQFRPSHWLWRUV¶WHVWLPRQ\³WKDWFRPSHWLWLRQLQ 

WKHPDUNHWUHPDLQHGYLJRURXV´  

3ODLQWLIIV¶UHOLDQFHRQWHVWLPRQ\IURP.XUW2WWRDQG-HUHP\/DSSHQ&62)ˆQ 

FDQQRWFUHDWHDGLVSXWHGIDFW%RWKSURPRWHG00$HYHQWVEHIRUHWKH&ODVV3HULRGDQGEHIRUH 

3ODLQWLIIVFODLP=XIIDKDGPRQRSVRQ\SRZHUPDNLQJWKHLUWHVWLPRQ\LUUHOHYDQWRebel Oil 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 14 of 35


 )GDW$QGERWKWHVWLILHGRQO\WKDWWKH\FRXOGQRWVLJQDWKOHWHVXQGHUFRQWUDFWwith Zuffa
 QRWWKDWWKH\JHQHUDOO\ODFNHGDFFHVVWRDWKOHWHV/DSSHQWHVWLILHGWKDWKH³VLJQHGPDQ\KLJKOHYHO
 ILJKWHUV´3O([DW2WWRWHVWLILHGKHFKRVHWRVLJQIRUPHU8)&FKDPSLRQVDV
 FRDFKHVEHFDXVHWKH\³ZHUHWKHOLIHEORRGRIQHZWDOHQWFRPLQJXSVR,JRWWKHFRDFKHVILUVWDQG
 WKHQ,JRWWKHJUHDWILJKWHU´3O([DWDQGWKDWHYHQLI=XIIDKDGDWKOHWHVXQGHU
 FRQWUDFWKHFRXOG³ILQGDQHZJ\PUDWWKDWKDVWDOHQWDQGEXLOGWKHPXS´Id.DW
  7KHIDFWV3ODLQWLIIVFODLPSURYHDODFNRIFRPSHWLWLRQVKRZWKHRSSRVLWH²DFRQWLQXRXVO\
 FKDQJLQJPDUNHWZLWKUDSLGHQWU\DQGH[SDQVLRQ3ODLQWLIIVFLWH%HOODWRU¶VFXUUHQW3UHVLGHQW6FRWW
 &RNHU¶VWHVWLPRQ\WKDWEHIRUHKHWRRNRYHU%HOODWRUZDVD³G\LQJEUDQG´&62)ˆ D EXWE\ 
%HOODWRURZQHGE\9LDFRPKDGJURZQVXEVWDQWLDOO\ LQFOXGLQJDWHOHYLVLRQGHDOZLWK 
=XIID¶VIRUPHUEURDGFDVWSDUWQHU6SLNH79 QRZ3DUDPRXQW1HWZRUN DQGVLJQHGDGLVWULEXWLRQ 
GHDOZLWK'$=1IRURYHUDKXQGUHGPLOOLRQGROODUV68)ˆ3ODLQWLIIVFLWHDVLQJOH 
GRFXPHQWIURPDQLQGLYLGXDODVVRFLDWHGZLWK21(&KDPSLRQVKLSRIIHULQJWREHDIHHGHU 
RUJDQL]DWLRQWR8)&&62)ˆ E EXW21(KDVEHFRPHWKHVHOISURFODLPHGODUJHVW00$
 
RUJDQL]DWLRQLQWKHZRUOG 68)ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIVFLWHHYLGHQFHDERXW:62)LQDQG 
EXW:62)3)/KDVVLQFHH[SDQGHGLWVQXPEHURIHYHQWVEURDGFDVWVHYHQWVRQ1%& 
6SRUWVDQGLVFXUUHQWO\SURPRWLQJDPXOWLPLOOLRQGROODU00$WRXUQDPHQW68)ˆˆ([ 
&6LOYD'HS3ODLQWLIIVODUJHO\LJQRUH=XIID¶VHYLGHQFHDERXWRWKHUQHZDQG 
JURZLQJFRPSHWLWRUVOLNH$&%EXWGRDFNQRZOHGJHWKDWLWKDVH[SDQGHGRSHUDWLRQVLQWR1RUWK
 
$PHULFD&62)ˆQ $QG3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWUHVSRQGWRRWKHUHYLGHQFHRIKLJKSURILOH 
ER[LQJSURPRWHU2VFDU'H/D+R\DZKRKDVWUDQVLWLRQHGLQWR00$DQGZLOOKROGD339HYHQW 
EHWZHHQWZRIRUPHU8)&FKDPSLRQVODWHUWKLV\HDU68)ˆ3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWGLVSXWHWKDW 
=XIID¶VFRPSHWLWRUVKDYHH[SDQGHGRYHUWLPH&62)ˆ  


 
3ODLQWLIIVFLWHRQHDWKOHWHZKROHIW21(IRU=XIID&62)ˆ E EXWLJQRUHWKH21(DWKOHWHV
=XIIDZDQWHGEXWFRXOGQRWVLJQ3O([6KHOE\'HS68)ˆ([ 
9HUD'HS
 
$&%KDVDOVRKDGUDSLGJURZWKLQUDQNHGDWKOHWHVFRPLQJWRWKHSURPRWLRQ([


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 15 of 35


 3ODLQWLIIVWU\WRGLVFRXQWWKHHYLGHQFHRIDKHDOWK\PDUNHWIRU00$DWKOHWHVE\FODLPLQJ
 WKDWDQ\DWKOHWHZKROHDYHVWKH8)&LVD³PLQRUOHDJXH)LJKWHU´XQZDQWHGE\=XIIDDQG
 LUUHOHYDQW2SS7KLVVWDWHPHQWLVGHPRQVWUDEO\IDOVH68)ˆˆ1RUGR3ODLQWLIIV
 H[SODLQZK\LWPDWWHUVLI=XIID³QRORQJHUZDQWV´DQDWKOHWH2SSRUZK\KLJKO\UDQNHG
 DWKOHWHVZKROHDYHWKH8)& LQFOXGLQJDVIUHHDJHQWV DUH³PLQRUOHDJXH´7KHUHOHYDQWOHJDO

 TXHVWLRQLVZKHWKHUFRPSHWLQJSURPRWHUVKDYHDFFHVVWR00$DWKOHWHV DQG3ODLQWLIIVGRQRW
 DQGFDQQRWUHEXW=XIID¶VXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHWKDWWKH\GRERWKUDQNHGDQGQRW68)ˆˆ
 0RUHRYHU3ODLQWLIIVIRFXVH[FOXVLYHO\RQDWKOHWHVZKRKDYHSUHYLRXVO\FRPSHWHGLQWKH
 8)&DQGGRQRWUHEXW=XIID¶VXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHWKDWFRPSHWLQJSURPRWHUVKDYHDODUJHWDOHQW 
SRRORXWVLGHWKH8)&IURPZKLFKWRVLJQDWKOHWHV68)ˆ,GHQWLI\LQJXSDQGFRPLQJWDOHQWLV 
LPSRUWDQWIRUDVXFFHVVIXO00$SURPRWLRQ0RW2IWKHWHQ8)&FKDPSLRQVRIWKH³PDMRU´ 
00$ZHLJKWFODVVHVRQO\WZRZHUH³+HDGOLQHUV´ZKHQ=XIIDVLJQHGWKHP)RXURIWKHWHQ 
FKDPSLRQVZHUHUDQNHGORZHUWKDQDWWKHWLPHRIVLJQLQJ([2WKHUKRXVHKROGQDPHV 
VXFKDV&RQRU0F*UHJRUZHUHQRZKHUHQHDUWKHWRSZKHQWKH\LQLWLDOO\VLJQHGZLWKWKH8)& 
([V  0F*UHJRUZDVWKHWKUDQNHGOLJKWZHLJKWDWKLVILUVW8)&ERXWRQ$SULO 
 7KHHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKHVHXSDQGFRPLQJVXSHUVWDUVZHUHDYDLODEOHWRDQ\00$ 
SURPRWLRQ([:KLWH'HS 
 /DVWO\3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDWEHFDXVHWKHLUH[SHUW¶VUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVVKRZVDUHODWLRQVKLS 
EHWZHHQZDJHVKDUHDQGIRUHFORVXUHVKDUH=XIID¶VXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHVKRZLQJDFWXDO 
FRPSHWLWLRQLQWKHPDUNHWPXVWEHZURQJ2SS7KLVDUJXPHQWLOOXVWUDWHVWKHDEXVHRI 
HFRQRPHWULFDQDO\VLVLQWKLVFDVH3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDWLIWKH\KDYHDUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOWKDWVKRZV 
GDPDJHVWKHQWKHUHPXVWEHOLDELOLW\DVZHOO7KLVWDXWRORJLFDOUHDVRQLQJKDVEHHQUHMHFWHGLQ 
RWKHUFDVHVE.g., In re Optical Disk Drive Antitrust Litig.:/DW  1'&DO 
'HF  JUDQWLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWZKHUHWKHSODLQWLIIV³MXPEOHHYLGHQFHRIGDPDJHV 
ZLWKHYLGHQFHRIFDXVDWLRQ´EHFDXVH³WKHLUEXUGHQUHPDLQVWRSURIIHUHYLGHQFHDVWRERWKRIWKRVH 
HOHPHQWVVHSDUDWHO\´ Live Concert)6XSSGDW=XIID6LQJHUDaubert5HSO\ 

 
Omega Envtl, Inc. v. Gilbarco, Inc.)G WK&LU 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 16 of 35


 (&)1RDW H[SODLQLQJWKHIDWDOHUURUVLQ'U6LQJHU¶VFLUFXODUUHDVRQLQJ ,QDQ\
 HYHQW³DVWKH1LQWK&LUFXLWKDVUHFRJQL]HGH[SHUWWHVWLPRQ\FDQQRWVXEVWLWXWHIRUPDUNHWIDFWV²
 DQGFDQQRWGHIHDWWKHPZKHQWKHIDFWVWKHPVHOYHVUHQGHUSODLQWLIIV¶WKHRU\RILQMXU\
 XQUHDVRQDEOH´In re Online DVD Rental Antitrust Litig.:/DW  1'&DO
 1RY aff’d)G WK&LU  FLWLQJRebel Oil)GDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶
 H[SHUWFDQQRWXVHPDWKHPDWLFDOHTXDWLRQVWRSUHWHQGWKDWFRPSHWLWLRQGLGQRWRFFXU
 % 3ODLQWLIIV&DQQRW6KRZ$*HQXLQH,VVXHRI)DFW&RQFHUQLQJ0RQRSVRQ\3RZHU

  3ODLQWLIIV&LWH1R5HOHYDQW'LUHFW(YLGHQFH2I/RZHU&RPSHQVDWLRQ
3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWFLWHDVLQJOHFDVHDFFHSWLQJWKDWDQLPSDFWWRZDJHVKDUHFDQVKRZ

DQWLFRPSHWLWLYHHIIHFWRUDQWLWUXVWLQMXU\$QGFHUWDLQO\QRWZKHUHDVKHUHLWLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDW 

DFWXDOFRPSHQVDWLRQLQFUHDVHG68)ˆ&62)ˆ,QVWHDG3ODLQWLIIVFLWHRQO\WRWKHLURZQ 

H[SHUWUHSRUWV3ODLQWLIIVKDYHIDLOHGWRUHEXW=XIID¶VH[SODQDWLRQVDERXWZK\DQLPSDFWRQ 

ZDJHVKDUHLVQRWHTXLYDOHQWWRDQLPSDFWRQFRPSHQVDWLRQ0RW8QGHU3ODLQWLIIV¶ZDJH 

VKDUHWKHRU\ZKHQ=XIID¶VVXFFHVVIXOSURPRWLRQVDQGSURGXFWLRQVLQFUHDVHUHYHQXHDFRXUWPD\ 

DSSO\WKHDQWLWUXVWODZVWRDGMXVWWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIFRPSHQVDWLRQVKDUHGZLWKODERU$QGZKLOH 

3ODLQWLIIVGHQ\WKDWWKH\DUHDVNLQJWKLV&RXUWWRDFWDVDFHQWUDOSODQQHU 2SS WKH\FDQQRW 

GLVSXWHWKDWWKHLUDSSURDFKZRXOGLQVHUWWKLV&RXUWLQWRMXVWWKDWUROHE\XVLQJDQWLWUXVWODZVWR  



White v. NCAA:/DW  &'&DO2FW FLWHGDW2SSQGLG 
QRWXVHZDJHVKDUHWRDVVHVVDQWLWUXVWLPSDFWRUKDUP,QDVVHVVLQJFODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQWKHWhite
FRXUWVWDWHGRQO\WKDW³>L@IVXEVWDQWLDWHG´DFRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQWKH³ODERU´FRVWVRISURIHVVLRQDO 
OHDJXHV³PD\KHOSVKRZ´WKHGHPDQGIRUFROOHJHDWKOHWHVId. DW 7KHFDVHXOWLPDWHO\VHWWOHG 
EHIRUHWKHFRXUWFRXOGUXOHRQWKHPHULWV3ODLQWLIIVDOVRFLWHDoe v. Arizona Hosp. & Healthcare
Ass’n 2SS LQZKLFKDFRXUWGHQLHGDPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVEXWGLGQRWFRQVLGHUWKHPHULWVRI 
3ODLQWLIIV¶DOOHJDWLRQV:/DW  '$UL]0DU 

3ODLQWLIIV¶UHOLDQFHRQWKH³VSRQVRUVKLSWD[´WRVKRZLPSDFWRQFRPSHQVDWLRQLVLUUHOHYDQW 
EHFDXVH3ODLQWLIIVFLWHQRHYLGHQFHHVWDEOLVKLQJWKDWDWKOHWHV¶FRPSHQVDWLRQGHFUHDVHGDVDUHVXOW
 
3ODLQWLIIVPLVFKDUDFWHUL]H3URI7RSHODV³DGPLWWLQJ´WKDWH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVSUHYHQWD³WUDQVIHU
RIZHDOWK´WRDWKOHWHV2SS7KLVLVXQWUXH3URI7RSHOVWDWHGWKDWZKLOHWKHHOLPLQDWLRQRI 
H[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVZRXOGFUHDWHDVKRUWWHUP³WUDQVIHURIZHDOWK´LWLVXOWLPDWHO\KDUPIXOWR
DWKOHWHVEHFDXVHHOLPLQDWLQJH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVZRXOGGLVLQFHQWLYL]HDSURPRWHUIURPLQYHVWLQJ 
LQDWKOHWHVXQGHUFRQWUDFWDQGXOWLPDWHO\UHVXOWLQORZHUSD\IRUDWKOHWHV3O([7RSHO'HS 
+HOLNHQHGLWWR³GHFODULQJDSDWHQWVXGGHQO\LQYDOLGDQGWKHQ
DQ\ERG\FDQPDNHWKDWIRUPXODZKHUHDVWKH\FRXOGQ¶WEHIRUH7KDWKHOSVIRUDOLWWOHZKLOHEXW 
QRERG\¶VJRLQJWRLQYHVWLQWKHUHVHDUFKDQGGHYHORSPHQWDJDLQ´Id. DW


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 17 of 35


 HVWDEOLVKWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIUHYHQXHDILUPVKRXOGVKDUHDVFRPSHQVDWLRQRUZDJHV1RDQWLWUXVWRU
 RWKHUFDVHKDVHYHUKHOGRUSHUPLWWHGDYHUGLFWWKDWHYLGHQFHRIDQWLFRPSHWLWLYHDFWVPD\EH
 HVWDEOLVKHGE\VKDUHVRIUHYHQXHVZKHWKHUWLHGWRZDJHVRUSULFHV
  7KH8QGLVSXWHG(YLGHQFH6KRZV1R5HVWULFWLRQ,Q2XWSXW

 3ODLQWLIIVUHO\HQWLUHO\RQWKHLUH[SHUWVWRDVVHUWWKDW=XIIDUHVWULFWHGRXWSXWE\VLJQLQJEXW

 QRWXVLQJDWKOHWHVZKDWWKH\WHUP³VKHOYLQJ´2SS$VGLVFXVVHGEHORZWKLVLVD

 SUHGDWRU\KLULQJFODLPDQGLWIDLOVXQGHUWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVIRUVXFKDFODLP1RWDEO\3ODLQWLIIVGR

 QRWFLWHDVLQJOHSLHFHRIDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFHVKRZLQJ=XIID¶VSUDFWLFHVFDXVHGDTXDQWLILHG

 UHGXFWLRQLQRXWSXW2SS3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDW=XIIDVKRXOGKDYHH[SDQGHGHYHQPRUH 2SS 

 EXWWKHLUH[SHUWDGPLWWHGKHKDGQRUHOLDEOHPHWKRGWRPHDVXUHRUSUHGLFWWKLVK\SRWKHWLFDO 

H[SDQVLRQ([6LQJHU,,'HS0RW7KHXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFH 

VKRZVWKDW=XIIDLQFUHDVHGWKHQXPEHURILWVHYHQWVERXWVLWSURPRWHGQXPEHURIDWKOHWHVLW 

VLJQHGDQGFRPSHQVDWLRQLWSDLGWKRVHDWKOHWHV68)ˆˆ([6LQJHU5HSˆˆ([ 

ZKLOHQHZSURPRWHUVHPHUJHGDFFHVVHGQHHGHGLQSXWVDQGH[SDQGHG68)ˆˆ7KH 

PDUNHWUHDOLW\LVLQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKDILUPH[HUFLVLQJPRQRSVRQ\SRZHU2SS 

3ODLQWLIIV¶DUJXPHQWWKDWPDUNHWZLGHRXWSXWGLGQRWLQFUHDVHLVLUUHOHYDQWLI=XIID 

LQFUHDVHGRXWSXWRebel Oil)GDW UHOHYDQWTXHVWLRQLVZKHWKHU³E\UHVWULFWLQJLWVRZQ
 
RXWSXW>GHIHQGDQW@FDQUHVWULFWPDUNHWZLGHRXWSXWDQGKHQFHLQFUHDVHPDUNHWZLGHSULFHV´   

 3ODLQWLIIV)DLO7R6KRZ$*HQXLQH,VVXH2I)DFW&RQFHUQLQJ
&LUFXPVWDQWLDO(YLGHQFH2I0DUNHW3RZHU 

3ODLQWLIIVKDYHQRWVKRZQWKDW=XIIDKDVUHVWULFWHGHQWU\LQWRDQ\SXUSRUWHGPDUNHW7KLV 

LVIDWDOWR3ODLQWLIIV¶FODLP=XIIDKDVRIIHUHGDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFHUHJDUGLQJQHZPDUNHWHQWUDQWV 

3)/21($&% H[SDQGHGRXWSXWRIH[LVWLQJFRPSHWLWRUV %HOODWRU DQGIXWXUHHQWU\E\ZHOO 

HVWDEOLVKHGVSRUWVHQWHUWDLQPHQWRUJDQL]DWLRQV *ROGHQ%R\ 0RW FLWLQJ68)ˆˆ  

 
3ODLQWLIIVIDOVHO\FODLPWKDW3URI7RSHODJUHHGZLWKWKHLUFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIDPRQRSVRQLVW¶V
UHGXFWLRQLQSXUFKDVHVVXSSO\DQGRXWSXWLQVWHDGWKH\FLWHWRDGLVFXVVLRQRIVXEVWLWXWDELOLW\RI 
00$DWKOHWHVWRRWKHUSURIHVVLRQDOVSRUWV2SS FLWLQJ3O([7RSHO'HS 
 
See also Nationwide Power Sols. Inc. v. Eaton Elec. Inc.:/DW  &'&DO
2FW  UHMHFWLQJSODLQWLII¶VFRQWHQWLRQWKDWWRWDOPDUNHWZLGHRXWSXWPDWWHUVRYHU 
GHIHQGDQW¶VRXWSXWDVFRQWUDU\WR1LQWK&LUFXLWSUHFHGHQW 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 18 of 35


 :KHUHWKHUHLV³XQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHLQGLFDWLQJWKDWFRPSHWLWRUVKDYHH[SDQGHGRXWSXWLQWKH
 UHFHQWSDVWRUKDYHWKHDELOLW\WRH[SDQGRXWSXWLQWKHIXWXUH´VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLVDSSURSULDWH
 Rebel Oil)GDWOmega)GDW VXFFHVVIXOHQWU\RUH[SDQVLRQE\D
 FRPSHWLWRU³SUHFOXGHVDILQGLQJWKDWH[FOXVLYHGHDOLQJLVDQHQWU\EDUULHURIDQ\VLJQLILFDQFH´ 
 ,QUHVSRQVH3ODLQWLIIVFLWHVWDWHPHQWVIURPEDQNHUVDQGH[HFXWLYHVDERXW=XIID¶V
 ³GRPLQDQFH´DQGHQWU\EDUULHUVEXWDVH[SODLQHGEHORZVXEMHFWLYHRSLQLRQVFDQQRWGHIHDWPDUNHW
 IDFWVIndep. Ink, Inc. v. Trident, Inc.)6XSSG &'&DO aff’d
 in relevant part)G )HG&LU  GHIHQGDQW¶VVWDWHPHQWVWKDWLW³KDVDGRPLQDQW
 µPDUNHWSRVLWLRQ¶´DQGRWKHU³QRQHFRQRPLFTXDOLWDWLYHGHVFULSWLRQVRIPDUNHWVXFFHVVDUH 
LQVXIILFLHQWWRHVWDEOLVKWKDWDQDQWLWUXVWGHIHQGDQWH[HUFLVHVPDUNHWSRZHU´ 0HGLDVWDWHPHQWV 
DQGEDQNHUGHFNVFDQQRWUHEXWWKHXQGLVSXWHGIDFWVVKRZLQJFRPSHWLWLRQEHWZHHQ=XIIDDQGQHZ 
DQGH[SDQGLQJFRPSHWLWRUVWRVLJQDWKOHWHV²REMHFWLYHHYLGHQFHWKDWEHOLHVXEMHFWLYHFODLPVIURP 
\HDUVDJR68)ˆˆOmega)GDW UHMHFWLQJQHZHQWUDQW¶VODEHODV³MRNHRIWKH 
LQGXVWU\´ZKHUHHYLGHQFHVKRZHGHQWU\DQGH[SDQVLRQIURP  
& 3ODLQWLIIV)DLO7R5HEXW(YLGHQFH7KDW=XIID'LG1RW(QJDJH,Q([FOXVLRQDU\
$QWLFRPSHWLWLYH&RQGXFW 

 3ODLQWLIIV¶$OOHJDWLRQV)LW6TXDUHO\:LWKLQD3UHGDWRU\+LULQJ&ODLP 

3ODLQWLIIV¶PRQRSVRQ\FODLPPXVWEHHYDOXDWHGXQGHUWKH1LQWK&LUFXLW¶VVWDQGDUGIRU 

SUHGDWRU\KLULQJGHILQHGDVZKHUH³WDOHQWLVDFTXLUHGQRWIRUSXUSRVHVRIXVLQJWKDWWDOHQWEXWIRU 

SXUSRVHVRIGHQ\LQJLWWRDFRPSHWLWRU´Universal Analytics, Inc. v. MacNeal-Schwendler Corp. 

)G WK&LU see0RW†,,&3ODLQWLIIVGHQ\WKDWWKH\DUHPDNLQJD 

SUHGDWRU\KLULQJFODLP2SSE\SXWWLQJIRUPRYHUVXEVWDQFH3ODLQWLIIVKDYHDUJXHGWKDW 

=XIIDDFTXLUHGWDOHQWWRGHQ\LWWRFRPSHWLWRUVILUVWLQWKHLU&$&DQGODWHULQWKHLUH[SHUW 

 
E.g.&$&ˆ ³LPSRVLQJH[WUHPHUHVWULFWLRQVRQ8)&)LJKWHUV¶DELOLW\WRILJKWIRUZRXOGEH
ULYDOV´ ˆ ³WKURXJKLWVWLJKWILVWHGFRQWURORYHUWKHVXSSO\RI(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$ 
)LJKWHUV´=XIIDFRXOG³EORFNDFWXDORUSRWHQWLDOULYDOVIURPDFFHVVLQJLQSXWVQHFHVVDU\WR
FRPSHWH´ ˆ ³7KURXJKe.g.H[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVZLWK00$)LJKWHUVWKH8)&KDVGHSULYHG 
SRWHQWLDODQGDFWXDOFRPSHWLWRUVRI(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHUVHUYLFHV´ ˆ 
DFTXLVLWLRQVPHDQW³WKH8)&FRQWUROOHGYLUWXDOO\DOO(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHUV´ ˆ
³$VSDUWRILWVHIIRUWWRIRUHFORVHSRWHQWLDOULYDO00$SURPRWHUVIURPDFFHVVLQJ(OLWH 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 19 of 35


 UHSRUWVDQGQRZLQRSSRVLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW²DOOHJLQJ³=XIID¶VH[HFXWLYHVDFNQRZOHGJH
 WKHLPSRUWDQFHRIEORFNLQJRWKHUSURPRWHUV¶DFFHVVWRWRS)LJKWHUV´2SS5HJDUGOHVVRI
 3ODLQWLIIV¶ODEHOVLWLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDW=XIIDFRPSHWHGIRUDWKOHWHVE\RIIHULQJPRUHPRQH\68)
 ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIVFDQQRWKDYHLWERWKZD\VDOOHJLQJWKHHOHPHQWVRISUHGDWRU\KLULQJZKLOH
 FODLPLQJWKRVHDOOHJDWLRQVDUHLPPXQHIURPXQIDYRUDEOH1LQWK&LUFXLWSUHFHGHQWRQSUHGDWRU\
 KLULQJ:KHQHYDOXDWHGXQGHUWKHFRUUHFWVWDQGDUG3ODLQWLIIV¶FODLPVPXVWEHGLVPLVVHG
 3ODLQWLIIVKDYHQRWVKRZQWKDW=XIID¶VVROHLQWHQWLQVLJQLQJDWKOHWHVZDVWRKDUPFRPSHWLWLRQQRU
 WKDW=XIIDIDLOHGWRXVHWKHDWKOHWHVLWVLJQHG RUWKDW=XIIDGLGQRWXVH³PDUTXHH´DWKOHWHV 0RW
  
 3ODLQWLIIV)DLO7R5DLVH$*HQXLQH,VVXH2I0DWHULDO)DFW7KDW=XIID¶V
&RQWUDFWV'LG1RW6XEVWDQWLDOO\)RUHFORVH&RPSHWLWLRQ 

3ODLQWLIIVPXVWSURYHWKDWWKHH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVWKH\FKDOOHQJHFDXVHGVXEVWDQWLDOPDUNHW 

IRUHFORVXUHOmega)GDW QROLDELOLW\GHVSLWHPDUNHWIRUHFORVXUH 3ODLQWLIIV 

KHUHFDOFXODWH=XIID¶V³IRUHFORVXUHVKDUH´DV³DWOHDVWGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG´2SS 

3ODLQWLIIVDQGWKHLUH[SHUWXVHWKHWHUP³IRUHFORVXUHVKDUH´EXWGRQRWDFWXDOO\H[DPLQHWKH 

LPSDFWRIDQH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWon the marketCf. Tampa Elec. Co. v. Nashville Coal Co. 

86   ³DPHUHVKRZLQJWKDWWKHFRQWUDFWLWVHOILQYROYHVDVXEVWDQWLDOQXPEHURI 

GROODUVLVRUGLQDULO\RIOLWWOHFRQVHTXHQFH´ 3ODLQWLIIV¶GHILQLWLRQRI³IRUHFORVXUHVKDUH´DVVXPHV 

LWVRZQFRQFOXVLRQEHFDXVHLWLVDVLPSOHFRXQWRIWKHQXPEHURIPRQWKRUPRUHFRQWUDFWV 

UDWKHUWKDQIRUHFORVXUHRIDPDUNHW([6LQJHU5HSˆ6LQJHUDaubert(&)1RDW  


3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHUVWKH8)&KDVFRQWUDFWHGZLWKPRUH)LJKWHUVWKDQLWQHHGVIRUERXWV´ 
 
E.g.([6LQJHU5HSˆ LGHQWLI\LQJ³$FFHVVWRDEURDGVWDEOHRI00$)LJKWHUV´DVD
³FULWLFDOLQSXW´DQGWKDW³7KH&KDOOHQJHG&RQGXFWHQVXUHGWKDW=XIID¶VZRXOGEHULYDOVODFNHG 
DFFHVVWRWKLVFULWLFDOLQSXW´ ˆˆ ³=XIIDUHVWULFWHGWKHVXSSO\RI)LJKWHUVHUYLFHVE\ 
FRQVLVWHQWO\PDLQWDLQLQJVLJQLILFDQWO\PRUH)LJKWHUVXQGHUFRQWUDFWWKDQLWFRXOGXVH´ 

Id. 8)&DFTXLUHG:(&³EHFDXVHLWZDQWHGWKHOLJKWHUZHLJKWFODVVHVWKDWWKH:(&KDG´ id. 
 =XIIDWDUJHWHG6WULNHIRUFH³WRREWDLQ6WULNHIRUFH¶V)LJKWHUV´ id. ³ORFNLQJXSWKHµYDVW
PDMRULW\RIWRSILJKWHUV¶WKH6FKHPHEORFNHGSRWHQWLDOFRPSHWLWRUV´ id. ³=XIIDGLGQRWSD\ 
µVKHOYHG¶)LJKWHUVDQGSUHYHQWHGRWKHUSURPRWHUVIURPGRLQJVR´ id. ³8VLQJWKH6FKHPHWR 
VWDUYHULYDOVRIµR[\JHQ¶LQWKHIRUPRIWRS)LJKWHUV=XIIDZDVDEOHWRIRUFHH[LVWLQJULYDOVRXWRI
EXVLQHVV´ id. ³=XIIDFRQWUDFW>HG@ZLWKPRUH)LJKWHUVWKDQLWFRXOGXVHµVKHOYLQJ¶WKHPDQG 
OHDGLQJDULYDOSURPRWHUWRWHVWLI\WKDW=XIID¶VILJKWHUVZHUHµFROOHFWLQJGXVW¶´ 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 20 of 35


 6LQJHUDaubert 5HSO\(&)1RDW$QG'U6LQJHUGRHVQRWEDVHKLVGHILQLWLRQ
 RIIRUHFORVXUHVKDUHRQHFRQRPLFHYLGHQFHDQGLQVWHDGGRHVVREDVHGRQZKDWKHEHOLHYHV³ZRXOG
 EHDGXUDWLRQWKDWZRXOGEHDFFHSWDEOHWRD&RXUW´([6LQJHU'HS,,
 (YHQXQGHUDFRQWUDFWEDVHGGHILQLWLRQRIIRUHFORVXUH3ODLQWLIIVFKRVHWRQRWHYDOXDWHWKH
 QXPEHURIDFWXDO=XIIDDWKOHWHVXQGHUFRQWUDFWFRPSDUHGWRWKHUHVWRI'U6LQJHU¶VPDUNHWOLNHO\
 EHFDXVH=XIIDRQO\KDVDVPDOOSHUFHQWDJH QRKLJKHUWKDQ RIWKH5DQNHGPDUNHW68)ˆ
 3ODLQWLIIVLQVWHDGDUJXHWKDWORRNLQJDW=XIID¶VDFWXDOSHUFHQWDJHRIUDQNHGDWKOHWHVLV
 LPSURSHUEHFDXVHLWWUHDWVDOODWKOHWHVDVLIWKH\ZHUHWKHVDPH2SS3ODLQWLIIVWKHQPDNHWKH
 VDPHHUURUE\ZHLJKWLQJHDFKDWKOHWHE\SURPRWHUUHYHQXHUHJDUGOHVVRIUDQNRUDQ\RWKHU 
DWWULEXWH3ODLQWLIIVGRWKLVEHFDXVH=XIIDHDUQVPRUHUHYHQXHVWKDQRWKHUSURPRWHUVLQFUHDVLQJ 
WKHZHLJKWLQJRILWVDWKOHWHV7KLVFUHDWHVWKHQRQVHQVLFDORXWFRPHWKDWDUGUDQNHGDWKOHWHLV 
ZHLJKWHGWLPHVJUHDWHUWKDQDUGUDQNHGDWKOHWHPHUHO\EHFDXVHWKHIRUPHUFRPSHWHVIRU8)& 
DQGWKHODWWHU%HOODWRU([7RSHO5HSˆ,IWRSDWKOHWHVDUHDVLPSRUWDQWDV3ODLQWLIIV 
FRQWHQG3ODLQWLIIV¶UHYHQXHZHLJKWLQJPHFKDQLVPLVLUUHOHYDQWDQGLQFDSDEOHRISURYLQJDQ\WKLQJ 
RWKHUWKDQZKRFRPSHWHVIRU=XIIDDQGZKRGRHVQRW 
 3ODLQWLIIV¶2SSRVLWLRQFODLPVWRKDYHVKRZQVXEVWDQWLDOIRUHFORVXUHLQWKUHHZD\VEXW 
QRQHGHPRQVWUDWHWKDW³WKHRSSRUWXQLWLHVIRURWKHU>SURPRWHUV@WRHQWHURUUHPDLQLQWKHPDUNHW 
>DUH@VLJQLILFDQWO\OLPLWHG´Taggart v. Rutledge)G WK&LU First3ODLQWLIIV 
FRQWHQGWKDWUHFRUGHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDW=XIIDDQGRWKHUPDUNHWDFWRUV³UHFRJQL]HGWKDWRQHRI 
=XIID¶VJUHDWHVWDVVHWVZDVLWVDELOLW\WRXVHLWV([FOXVLYH&RQWUDFWVWRIRUHFORVHFRPSHWLWLRQ´ 
2SS%XWLQWHQWLVQRWHQRXJK³5DWKHUµZLWKRXWVRPHHYLGHQFHRIDQDGYHUVHimpactRQ 
FRPSHWLWLRQ¶WKHIDFWWKDWDVXSSOLHUVHFXUHVDQH[FOXVLYHGHDOµLQRUGHUWROLPLWFRPSHWLWLRQ¶´LV 
LUUHOHYDQWMazda v. Carfax, Inc.:/DW  6'1<'HF see 
Aerotec Int’l, Inc. v. Honeywell Int’l, Inc.)G WK&LU  

 

)RUWKH+HDGOLQHUPDUNHW3ODLQWLIIVZHLJKWXVLQJWKHLQYHUVHRIDQDWKOHWH¶VUDQN i.e.WKHWK 
UDQNHGDWKOHWHLVZRUWKWZLFHDVPXFKWRDSURPRWHUDVWKHWKUDQNHGDWKOHWH EXWQRUHDVRQDEOH
MXU\FRXOGUHO\RQWKLVDVVHVVPHQWEHFDXVH'U6LQJHUDFNQRZOHGJHVWKDWKHPHUHO\JXHVVHGDVWR 
WKHDSSURSULDWHZHLJKWLQJUHODWLRQVKLS([6LQJHU'HS,


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 21 of 35


 Second3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDW'U6LQJHU¶VUHJUHVVLRQSURYLGHVHYLGHQFHRIVXEVWDQWLDO
 IRUHFORVXUHWRFRPSHWLWLRQ%XW'U6LQJHUUHSHDWVKLVFLUFXODUDQDO\VLVLQKLVUHJUHVVLRQEHFDXVH
 KHDGPLWVWKDW³IRUHFORVXUHVKDUH´LVDQinput EDVHGRQKLVNQRZOHGJHRIZKDWDFRXUWZRXOG
 DFFHSWQRWDQRXWSXWRIKLVUHJUHVVLRQ([6LQJHU'HS,
  Third3ODLQWLIIVFRQWHQGWKDW=XIID¶VPRQWKFRQWUDFWV³ODVWORQJHUWKDQWKHDYHUDJH
 )LJKWHU¶VFDUHHUDQGDUHHIIHFWLYHO\SHUSHWXDO´2SS$VDQLQLWLDOPDWWHUQRUHDVRQDEOHMXU\
 FRXOGUHO\RQWKLVDVVHVVPHQWEHFDXVH3ODLQWLIIVGHILQHDSURIHVVLRQDO00$DWKOHWH¶V³FDUHHU´WR
 EHWKHOHQJWKRIWLPHDQDWKOHWHLVDWZuffa 2SS DQGH[FOXGHDOORWKHUSURIHVVLRQDO00$
 ERXWVLQFOXGLQJIRUSURPRWHUVLQ3ODLQWLIIV¶SURSRVHGPDUNHWV,I=XIIDDWKOHWHV¶FDUHHUVDUH 
FDOFXODWHGWRLQFOXGHDOORIWKHLUSURIHVVLRQDOERXWVWKHPHGLDQFDUHHUOHQJWKLV\HDUVRU 
WLPHVWKHOHQJWK3ODLQWLIIVDVVHUW68)ˆ0RUHRYHU3ODLQWLIIV¶MXVWLILFDWLRQLVQRQVHQVLFDO 
EHFDXVHHYHQPRQWKFRQWUDFWVZRXOGDFFRUGLQJWR3ODLQWLIIV¶FDOFXODWLRQODVWORQJHUWKDQDQ 
DWKOHWH¶VFDUHHUEXWZRXOGOHDGWR=XIIDKDYLQJDIRUHFORVXUHVKDUH([6LQJHU'HS, 
1RUGR3ODLQWLIIVH[SODLQKRZDQH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWRIDQ\GXUDWLRQFRXOGVXEVWDQWLDOO\ 
IRUHFORVHFRPSHWLWLRQLIDQDWKOHWH¶VFDUHHULVRQO\\HDUV,IDWKOHWHV¶FDUHHUVDUHUHDOO\OHVV 
WKDQD\HDUFRPSHWLQJIRUWKHFRQWUDFWRIXSDQGFRPLQJDWKOHWHVZRXOGEHRISDUDPRXQW 
LPSRUWDQFH3ODLQWLIIVDOVRFLWHQRHYLGHQFHLQVXSSRUWRIWKHLUDVVHUWLRQWKDWWKHOHQJWKRIDQ 
DWKOHWH¶V=XIIDFDUHHULVHYLGHQFHRIIRUHFORVXUHDQDVVHUWLRQXQDQLPRXVO\FRQWUDGLFWHGE\WKH 
00$SURPRWHUVZLWKZKRP=XIIDFRPSHWHV68)ˆˆ 
D 3ODLQWLIIV'R1RW3XW)RUZDUG(YLGHQFH7KDW=XIID¶V/HJLWLPDWH
%XVLQHVV-XVWLILFDWLRQV$UH3UHWH[WXDO 

2QFHDGHIHQGDQWKDVSXWIRUWKDOHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQWKHEXUGHQVKLIWVWRWKH 

SODLQWLIIWRVKRZWKDWWKHEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQLVSUHWH[WXDOImage Tech. Servs., Inc. v. Eastman 

Kodak Co.)G WK&LU 3ODLQWLIIVKDYHIDLOHGWRSXWIRUZDUGDJHQXLQH 

 
&RQWUDU\WR3ODLQWLIIV¶UHSHDWHGDVVHUWLRQWKDW3URIHVVRU7RSHO³FRQFHGHV´WKHHIIHFWRI'U
6LQJHU¶VUHJUHVVLRQ 2SS 3URIHVVRU7RSHOIRXQG'U6LQJHU¶VUHJUHVVLRQ³PLVOHDGLQJIDWDOO\ 
IODZHGDQGXQUHOLDEOH´LQFOXGLQJEHFDXVH³KLVPHDVXUHRIERWKµIRUHFORVXUH¶DQGFRPSHQVDWLRQ
DUHHFRQRPLFDOO\DQGHFRQRPHWULFDOO\LQFRUUHFW´([7RSHO5HSˆ 

City of Vernon v. S. Cal. Edison Co.)G WK&LU  3ODLQWLIIV³KDYHWKH 
EXUGHQRISURYLQJWKDWWKHGHIHQGDQWDFWHGZLWKRXWDOHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQ´ 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 22 of 35


 LVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWWRUHEXWWKDW=XIID¶VH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVVHUYHWKHOHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVV
 SXUSRVHVRI  LQFUHDVLQJRXWSXWDQG  SURGXFLQJKLJKTXDOLW\HYHQWV0RW7KH1LQWK
 &LUFXLWKDVUHSHDWHGO\DIILUPHGVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWRGHIHQGDQWVZKHUHSODLQWLIIVIDLOWRPHHWWKDW
 EXUGHQCity of Vernon)GDWUniversal Analytics)GDWAllied
 Orthopedic Appliances Inc. v. Tyco Health Care Grp.)G WK&LU 
 3ODLQWLIIVUHO\RQDQLQFRUUHFWOHJDOVWDQGDUGWKDWDSSOLHVWRD6HFWLRQFRQVSLUDF\FDVH
 ZKHUHSURFRPSHWLWLYHMXVWLILFDWLRQVDUHLUUHOHYDQW per seFDVH RUVXEMHFWWRDEDODQFLQJWHVW UXOH
 RIUHDVRQFDVH 2SS FLWLQJO’Bannon v. NCAA)G WK&LU 
 &62)ˆ³:KHQDOHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQVXSSRUWVDPRQRSROLVW¶VH[FOXVLRQDU\ 
FRQGXFWWKDWFRQGXFWGRHVQRWYLRODWH†´Image Tech.)GDW Universal Analytics 
)GDW DQWLWUXVWGHIHQGDQW¶VFRQGXFW³LVUHGHHPHGE\DOHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVSXUSRVH´  
3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDWGRFXPHQWVVKRZ=XIIDNQHZLWVFRQWUDFWVZRXOGGHQ\FRPSHWLWRUVWKH 
³R[\JHQ´QHHGHGWRFRPSHWH2SS%XWFRQGXFWVXSSRUWHGE\OHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVUHDVRQV 
HYHQZKHUHWKHUHLVDOVRHYLGHQFHRIDQLQWHQWWRKXUWFRPSHWLWRUVFDQQRWHVWDEOLVKD6HFWLRQ 
YLRODWLRQUniversal Analytics)GDW PHPRWKDWVDLGKLULQJDQHPSOR\HHZRXOG 
³ZRXQG´DFRPSHWLWRU³DJDLQ´ZDVLQVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUW6HFWLRQYLRODWLRQZKHUH³WKH 
PHPRGRHVQRWXQGHUPLQH06&¶VOHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVUHDVRQVIRUKLULQJPXFKQHHGHGDQG 
FRPSHWHQWFRPSXWHUSURJUDPPHUVRUSHUPLWDMXU\WRILQGWKDWDQ\RI06&¶VUHDVRQVIRUKLULQJ 
WKHSURJUDPPHUVZDVSUHWH[WXDO´  Oahu Gas Serv., Inc. v. Pac. Res., Inc.)G 
WK&LU  ³:KHUHDPRQRSROLVW¶VUHIXVDOWRDLGDFRPSHWLWRULVEDVHGSDUWLDOO\RQDGHVLUHWR 
UHVWULFWFRPSHWLWLRQZHPXVWGHWHUPLQHDQWLWUXVWOLDELOLW\E\DVNLQJZKHWKHUWKHUHZDVD 
OHJLWLPDWHEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQ´  
$VVXPLQJIRUSXUSRVHVRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWKDW=XIID¶VDFWLRQVZHUHEDVHGSDUWLDOO\RQ 
DGHVLUHWRUHVWULFWLWVFRPSHWLWRUV3ODLQWLIIVFLWHQRHYLGHQFHWKDW=XIID¶VFRQGXFWZDVQRWDOVR 
EDVHGRQWKHEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQVRILQFUHDVLQJRXWSXWDQGSURPRWLQJTXDOLW\HYHQWV3ODLQWLIIV 
GRQRWGLVSXWHWKDWFRQVLVWHQWZLWK=XIID¶VVWDWHGEXVLQHVVSXUSRVH=XIID¶VRYHUDOORXWSXWRI 
HYHQWVZHQWXSIURPLQWRLQ 68)ˆ&62)ˆ DQG3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWSXW 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 23 of 35


 IRUZDUGDQ\HYLGHQFHWRUHEXWWKHPXOWLSOHZLWQHVVHVZKRWHVWLILHGWKDW=XIID¶VH[FOXVLYH
 FRQWUDFWVZHUHFULWLFDOWRWKLVH[SDQVLRQ0RW 68)ˆ3ODLQWLIIV¶DVVHUWLRQWKDW=XIID
 FLWHV³noHYLGHQFH´LQVXSSRUWRILWVMXVWLILFDWLRQ 2SS LVZURQJ$QGWKHW\SHRI
 DOWHUQDWLYHVDQDO\VLVSURSRVHGE\3ODLQWLIIV¶H[SHUWV &62)ˆ LVOHJDOO\LUUHOHYDQWLQD6HFWLRQ
 FDVH Image Tech Serv. Inc. v. Eastman Kodak Co.)G WK&LU aff’d
 86   ³WKHUHLVQROHDVWUHVWULFWLYHDOWHUQDWLYHUHTXLUHPHQWLQWKHFRQWH[WRID6HFWLRQ
 FODLP´ 
 7KHUHFDQDOVREHQRGLVSXWHWKDW=XIID¶VFRQWUDFWVDVVLVWHGLWWRSXWRQKLJKTXDOLW\
 HYHQWV,WPXVWEHOHJLWLPDWHWRFRQWUDFWZLWKWRSWDOHQWLQDQ\LQGXVWU\WKURXJKPXOWL\HDU 
FRQWUDFWV²ZKHWKHUWKHWDOHQWLVDWKOHWHVFRPSXWHUSURJUDPPHUVDQDO\VWVRULQQXPHUDEOHRWKHU 
FDWHJRULHV3ODLQWLIIVWKHPVHOYHVDUJXHWKDW³DGHHSSRRORIWDOHQWHG)LJKWHUVLVDFULWLFDOLQSXWWR 
WKHRQJRLQJVXFFHVVRIDQ00$SURPRWLRQ´EHFDXVHRIWKHQHHGIRU³DVWHDG\VXSSO\RI 
DSSURSULDWHO\PDWFKHG+HDGOLQHUVWRRFFXS\WKH7RSRIWKH&DUG´DQG³WKHQHHGWRUHSODFH 
)LJKWHUVWKDWEHFRPHXQDYDLODEOHGXHWRLQMXU\´([6LQJHU5HSˆ3ODLQWLIIVWKXV 
DJUHHWKDWWKHHYLGHQFHHVWDEOLVKHVWKDW=XIID¶VUHDVRQIRUH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVKDVPHULW0RW 
68)ˆ 
 3ODLQWLIIV+DYH1R(YLGHQFH2I$QWLFRPSHWLWLYH$FTXLVLWLRQVRU
³&RHUFLRQ´ 

8QGLVSXWHGPDUNHWIDFWVVKRZWKDW=XIID¶VDFTXLVLWLRQVGLGQRWFDXVHDQ\ODVWLQJRU 

VXEVWDQWLDODQWLFRPSHWLWLYHKDUP'XULQJWKHUHOHYDQWWLPHSHULRGWKHUHLVQRPDWHULDOGLVSXWH 

WKDWDWKOHWHFRPSHQVDWLRQLQFUHDVHGDWKOHWHVUHPDLQHGDYDLODEOHLQODUJHQXPEHUVWRRWKHU  



68)ˆe.g.$FTXLVLWLRQV'HS FLWHGDW68)ˆ  ³\RXMXVWFDQ¶WUXQD 
EXVLQHVVGRLQJRUHYHQWVSHU\HDUZLWKRXWKDYLQJWKHDWKOHWHVH[FOXVLYHWR\RXEHFDXVH\RX 
MXVWFDQ¶WSURGXFHWKDWRXWSXWRIHYHQWVQRWNQRZLQJWKHDWKOHWHVDUHJRLQJWREHWKHUHIRU\RXDQG
QRWILJKWLQJIRUVRPHRWKHURUJDQL]DWLRQ,PHDQ\RXFDQKDYHQRQH[FOXVLYHDJUHHPHQWVEXW 
\RX¶UHRQO\JRLQJWREHGRLQJDKDQGIXORIHYHQWVSHU\HDU´ 

2SS ³DµGHHSURVWHURIWDOHQWHGILJKWHUV¶LVµHVVHQWLDO¶WRVWDJHOLYH00$HYHQWV 
VXFFHVVIXOO\´ id.DW ³2QO\E\KDYLQJDFFHVVWRDEURDGVWDEOHRIWRS)LJKWHUVFDQDSURPRWHU 
GHYHORSQHZWRS)LJKWHUV´ &$&ˆ ³VXFFHVVIXOSURPRWLRQRIDOLYH(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$
HYHQWUHTXLUHV(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHUV´ id.ˆ ³(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$)LJKWHU 
VHUYLFHV>DUH@QHHGHGWRVXVWDLQDVXFFHVVIXOOLYH(OLWH3URIHVVLRQDO00$SURPRWLRQ´ 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 24 of 35


 SURPRWHUVDQGH[LVWLQJDQGQHZULYDO00$SURPRWHUVFRPSHWHGGLUHFWO\ZLWK=XIIDIRUKLJKO\
 UDQNHGDQGZHOONQRZQDWKOHWHV68)ˆˆ2QWKHVHPDUNHWIDFWV=XIID¶VDFTXLVLWLRQV
 GLGQRWDQGFRXOGQRWFDXVHDQWLFRPSHWLWLYHKDUPSyufy)GDW ILQGLQJQRFRPSHWLWLYH
 LPSDFWZKHUHUHFRUG³GHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWQHLWKHUDFTXLULQJWKHVFUHHQVRIKLVFRPSHWLWRUVQRU
 ZRUNLQJKDUGDWEHWWHUVHUYLQJWKHSXEOLFJDYH6\XI\GHOLYHUDQFHIURPFRPSHWLWLRQ´ $IWHUHDFK
 DFTXLVLWLRQ=XIIDLQWHQGHGWRDQGGLGXVHWKHFRQWUDFWVIURPWKHDFTXLUHGSURPRWHUWRFRPSHWH
 PRUHHIIHFWLYHO\†,,&supra7KLVLV³YLJRURXVFRPSHWLWLRQRQWKHPHULWVRIWKHW\SHWKDWWKH
 DQWLWUXVWODZVVHHNWRSURPRWH´Arminak & Assocs., Inc. v. Saint-Gobain Calmar, Inc.)
 6XSSG &'&DO  FLWLQJAllied Orthopedic)GDW  DFTXLVLWLRQ 
ODZIXODQGSURFRPSHWLWLYHZKHUHGHIHQGDQW³LQWHQGHGWRXVHWKHDVVHWVDQGKDVGRQHVRWRPRUH 
HIIHFWLYHO\FRPSHWHIRUFXVWRPHUVDQGWRPHHWFXVWRPHUQHHGV´  
:LWKUHVSHFWWRFRHUFLRQWRFRQVWLWXWHH[FOXVLRQDU\FRQGXFW³FRHUFLRQ´PXVWKDYHD 
³VLJQLILFDQWDQGPRUHWKDQWHPSRUDU\KDUPIXOHIIHFWRQFRPSHWLWLRQ´Am. Prof’l Testing Serv., 
Inc. v. Harcourt Brace)G WK&LU 3ODLQWLIIVRIIHUWKHEURDGDQGVHOI 
VHUYLQJVSHFXODWLYHWHVWLPRQ\RIWKHQDPHG3ODLQWLIIVRIVRFDOOHG³FRPPRQNQRZOHGJH´RI 
=XIID¶VFRHUFLRQDQGFLWHGRFXPHQWVZLWKVKDUSQHJRWLDWLQJODQJXDJHRIWHQLQWHUQDOO\DPRQJ 
=XIIDHPSOR\HHV&62)ˆˆ%XW3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWSURYLGHDVLQJOHH[DPSOHRIDQ\DWKOHWH 
PXFKOHVVDEURDGJURXSRIDWKOHWHVDFWXDOO\EHLQJVXEMHFWWRWKHFRHUFLYHFRQGXFWWKH\FODLP 
RFFXUV,QVWHDGRIFRHUFLRQ=XIIDDWKOHWHVZKRUHVLJQZLWK=XIIDJHWSDLGmorecompensation 
XQGHUWKHLUQHZDJUHHPHQWV0RW([7RSHO5HSˆ ([ =XIIDDWKOHWHVSDLG 
LQVKRZPRQH\IRUWKHILUVWERXWXQGHUDQHZDJUHHPHQW 3ODLQWLIIV¶QDUUDWLYH 
LJQRUHVWKDWathletesQRW=XIIDRIWHQUHTXHVWWRUHQHJRWLDWHWKHLUFRQWUDFWVIRUKLJKHUSD\([ 
)HUWLWWD'HS3OV([6LOYD'HS(&)1RDW Q 
&RPSHWLQJYLJRURXVO\WRUHWDLQDFRQWUDFWLQFOXGLQJWKHXVHRI³VWURQJFRPSHWLWLRQ´DQG³WRXJK 
QHJRWLDWLRQ´LVFRPSHWLWLYHFRQGXFWDQG³EHQHILFLDOWRFRPSHWLWLRQ´Arminak)6XSSG 
DWsee alsoIt’s My Party, Inc. v. Live Nation, Inc.)G WK&LU  
DIILUPLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWZKHUHVSHFXODWLRQRISRVVLEOHFRHUFLRQQRWVXEVWDQWLDWHG  


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 25 of 35


,9 =XIID,V(QWLWOHG7R6XPPDU\-XGJPHQW2Q3ODLQWLIIV¶0RQRSROL]DWLRQ&ODLP

3ODLQWLIIVFRQFHGHWKDWWKH\DUHQRWVHHNLQJGDPDJHVIRU=XIID¶VDOOHJHGPRQRSROL]DWLRQ

2SS:LWKRXWSURRIRIWKHHOHPHQWVRIVXFKDFODLPRIDQWLWUXVWLQMXU\RUGDPDJHVVXPPDU\

MXGJPHQWPXVWEHJUDQWHGArminak )6XSSGDW JUDQWLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQ

DEDQGRQHGPRQRSRO\DOOHJDWLRQV 7RWKHH[WHQW3ODLQWLIIV¶PRQRSRO\DOOHJDWLRQVDUHRIIHUHGWR


³EROVWHU´WKHLUPRQRSVRQ\FODLP 2SSLQWKHDEVHQFHRISURRIRIDOOWKHHOHPHQWVRI

PRQRSROL]DWLRQ  WKHFODLPIRUPRQRSROL]DWLRQ DQGWKHFRPELQHGPRQRSRO\DQGPRQRSVRQ\

FODLP PXVWEHGLVPLVVHGDQG  DOOHJDWLRQVRIVRPHHOHPHQWVRIPRQRSROL]DWLRQDUHOHJDOO\


GHILFLHQWWRVXSSRUWDPRQRSVRQ\FODLP :LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHDFTXLVLWLRQRIPRQRSRO\SRZHU


3ODLQWLIIVKDYHDEDQGRQHGWKHLUFODLPVUHJDUGLQJYHQXHVVSRQVRUVDQGEURDGFDVWHUV DQGQRZ 

UHO\H[FOXVLYHO\RQWKHVDPHDOOHJDWLRQVDVWKHPRQRSVRQ\FODLP²=XIID¶VDFTXLVLWLRQRI 

³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUV2SS$QG3ODLQWLIIV²ZKRDUHVHHNLQJGDPDJHVIRUDOOHJHGO\ORZ 

ZDJHV²KDYHQRZKHUHDVVHUWHGRUH[SODLQHGKRZWKH\KDYHEHHQLQMXUHGE\=XIID¶VPRQRSRO\ 


 7KHVROHDVSHFWRIDPRQRSRO\FODLP3ODLQWLIIVGRDGGUHVVLVPRQRSRO\SRZHU  

3ODLQWLIIV¶WKHRU\RIVXSUDFRPSHWLWLYHSULFLQJLVSUHPLVHGRQDQLQFUHDVHLQ=XIID¶VUHYHQXHVSOLW 

ZLWK339GLVWULEXWHUVZKLFKDOOHJHGO\UHVXOWHGLQDLQFUHDVHLQ339UHYHQXH2SS 

Q%XWDQ³LQFUHDVHLQUHYHQXHFRXOGRFFXULQDYDULHW\RIZD\VQRWLQYROYLQJLQFUHDVHG 

SULFHV´St. Alphonsus)GDW7KHUHOHYDQWSULFHLVWKDWSDLGE\FRQVXPHUVDQG 

3ODLQWLIIVQHLWKHUGLVSXWHWKDW=XIIDPDGHRQO\RQHSULFHLQFUHDVHDIWHUVHYHQ\HDUVRIVWDJQDQW 


SULFHVQRUSUHVHQWHYLGHQFHWKDW=XIID¶VSULFHZDVDERYHFRPSHWLWLYHOHYHOV 0RW 


 
3ODLQWLIIVDUJXHWKDW³ORQJVWDQGLQJSUHFHGHQWLQSURIHVVLRQDOVSRUWVDQWLWUXVWFDVHV´VKRZVWKDW
PRQRSRO\SRZHUFDQ³EROVWHU´FODLPVRIPRQRSVRQ\SRZHUEXWFLWHRQO\DVLQJOHFDVHGLVFXVVLQJ 

LVVXHVUHODWHGWRFROODWHUDOHVWRSSHODQGDIILUPDWLYHGHIHQVHV2SSQ FLWLQJMcNeil v. 
NFL)6XSS '0LQQ 

Harris v. City of Fresno)6XSSG ('&DO  FRXUWPD\JUDQW 
VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQ³DGGLWLRQDOFRQGXFW´WKDW³EROVWHUV´WKHXQGHUO\LQJFODLP 
 
'U6LQJHUDGPLWWHGLQKLVGHSRVLWLRQWKDWKHGLGQRWFRQGXFWWKHQHFHVVDU\DQDO\VLVWR
VXEVWDQWLDWHWKHVHDOOHJDWLRQV([6LQJHU'HS
 
3ODLQWLIIV¶UHOLDQFHRQO’Bannon)GDW2SSQWRDUJXHWKH\FDQVKRZHLWKHU
VXSUDFRPSHWLWLYHSULFHVRUUHVWULFWHGRXWSXWLVPLVSODFHGDVWKDWFDVHDGGUHVVHGWKHVWDQGDUGLQ 
WKH6HFWLRQSULFHIL[LQJFRQWH[WQRWIRUVKRZLQJ6HFWLRQPRQRSRO\SRZHU
 
3ODLQWLIIVDOVRGLVFXVVHYHQWWLFNHWSULFHVEXWGRQRWDOOHJHWKRVHSULFHVZHUHVXSUDFRPSHWLWLYH


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 26 of 35


  3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWFRQWHVWWKDW=XIIDH[SDQGHGRXWSXW2SSLQVWHDGDUJXLQJWKDW=XIID
 UHVWULFWHGDFHUWDLQW\SHRIRXWSXW 339HYHQWV ZLWKRXWH[SODLQLQJZK\WKLVLVUHOHYDQWRU
 DQDO\]LQJZKHWKHUFRQVXPHUVYLHZ339DQGQRQ339HYHQWVDVLQWHUFKDQJHDEOHU.S. v. Syufy
 Entrps.)6XSS± 1'&DO aff’d)G WK&LU  ³WKH
 &RXUWPXVWGHFLGHLIFRQVXPHUVZRXOGFKRRVHWRYLHZPRWLRQSLFWXUHVRQKRPHYLGHRFDEOH
 WHOHYLVLRQSD\SHUYLHZWHOHYLVLRQRUDVVXEUXQPRWLRQSLFWXUHV´ 3ODLQWLIIV¶FODLPWKDWPDUNHW
 ZLGHRXWSXWGHFUHDVHGLVLUUHOHYDQW0RWJLYHQWKDW=XIID¶VRXWSXWH[SDQGHG
 9 3ODLQWLIIV+DYH1R(YLGHQFHWR6XSSRUW7KHLU,GHQWLW\&ODVV&ODLP

  3ODLQWLIIV¶VROHVXSSRUWIRUWKHLULGHQWLW\FODVVFODLPLV'U6LQJHU¶VLQIHUHQFHWKDWEHFDXVH 

=XIIDDOOHJHGO\VXSSUHVVHGERXWSD\LWPXVWKDYHVXSSUHVVHGLGHQWLW\SD\EXWDVSUHYLRXVO\ 

VWDWHGLQ=XIID¶V&ODVV&HUWLILFDWLRQ2SSRVLWLRQ (&)1R WKHLGHQWLW\ULJKWVDUHD 

FRPSOHWHO\GLIIHUHQWVHWRIULJKWVJUDQWHGXQGHUGLIIHUHQWFRQWUDFWXDOFLUFXPVWDQFHV 

9, 3ODLQWLIIV'R1RW+DYH6WDQGLQJ7R%ULQJ&ODLPV)RU,QMXQFWLYH5HOLHI
$V=XIIDKDVH[SODLQHGLQLWVFODVVFHUWLILFDWLRQRSSRVLWLRQ3ODLQWLIIVDVIRUPHU8)& 

DWKOHWHVKDYHQROHJDOEDVLVWRVHHNLQMXQFWLYHUHOLHI7RDYRLGWKLVUXOH3ODLQWLIIVFLWHLUUHOHYDQW 

FDVHVHaro v. Sebelius)G WK&LU  FRQVWLWXWLRQDOVWDQGLQJWRFKDOOHQJH 

JRYHUQPHQWDFWLRQ Barnes v. AT&T, )5' 1'&DO  VWDQGLQJIRUIRUPHU 

HPSOR\HHVEHFDXVH(5,6$H[SUHVVO\SHUPLWVLW DQGIn re NCAA Athletic Grant-In-Aid Cap 

Antitrust Litig. )5' Q 1'&DO  QRGLVFXVVLRQRIVWDQGLQJ  ,WLV 

HQWLUHO\VSHFXODWLYHZKHWKHUWKLUGSDUW\00$SURPRWHUVIRUZKRP3ODLQWLIIV9HUDDQG)LWFK 

FRPSHWHZRXOGFKDQJHWKHLUFRQWUDFWVRUSD\3ODLQWLIIVPRUHLIWKLV&RXUWZHUHWRHQMRLQ=XIID 

9,, 3ODLQWLIIV'R1RW5DLVH*HQXLQH)DFWXDO'LVSXWHV,Q7KH&62) 

%DVHGRQWKH&62)¶VODFNRIUHVSRQVHWKH&RXUWVKRXOGGHHP68)ˆˆ 
 
DQGXQGLVSXWHG 3RUWLRQVRIRWKHUSDUWVRI=XIID¶V68)DUHDOVRXQGLVSXWHG   



,QUHVSRQVHWR=XIID¶VSUHYLRXVPRWLRQIRUSDUWLDOVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW3ODLQWLIIVSURYLGHGGLUHFW 
UHVSRQVHVWRWKH68)(&)1R
 
)RUHDVHRIUHIHUHQFHWKHEHORZFKDUWLGHQWLILHVSDUDJUDSKVIURPWKH&62)WKDWLQGLFDWHWKH\
DUHUHVSRQVLYHWRWKH68),WLVLPSRVVLEOHWRGHWHUPLQHZKDWRWKHUSRUWLRQVRIWKH&62) 
3ODLQWLIIVEHOLHYHDUHUHVSRQVLYHWRWKH68)


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 27 of 35


5HOHYDQW
 8QDGGUHVVHGDQG8QGLVSXWHG)DFWV
&62)
 6LQFHWKHQXPEHURIWRWDO8)&HYHQWVVWHDGLO\LQFUHDVHG68)ˆ ˆ
$WKOHWHFRPSHQVDWLRQKDVLQFUHDVHGVLQFH=XIIDDFTXLUHGWKH8)&LQFOXGLQJ ˆ
 WKURXJKWKH&ODVV3HULRG68)ˆ
=XIIDRIWHQSD\VDWKOHWHVPRUHWKDQRWKHU00$SURPRWHUV68)ˆ ˆ

%HWZHHQDQG=XIID¶VUHVLGHQWLDO339SULFHZDVRU VWDQGDUGRU ˆ
 KLJKGHILQLWLRQ ,Q=XIIDLPSOHPHQWHGRQHLQFUHDVH=XIIDH[HFXWLYHV
H[SODLQHGWKDWWKLVLQFUHDVHZDVPHDQWWRPRYHSULFHVFORVHUWRER[LQJ339 SULFHG
 DURXQG DQGWRNHHSSDFHZLWKLQIODWLRQ68)ˆ
7KHWHUPRIWKHDJUHHPHQWLVW\SLFDOO\PRQWKVZLWKWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIWROOLQJIRU ˆ
 HYHQWVVXFKDVLQMXU\UHWLUHPHQWDQGUHIXVDOWRFRPSHWH)DFWRULQJLQWROOLQJDQG
YROXQWDU\UHQHJRWLDWLRQRIFRQWUDFWVDFFRUGLQJWR3ODLQWLIIV¶H[SHUWDQDWKOHWH¶V

DYHUDJHFDUHHUDW=XIIDODVWV\HDUVDQGWKHPHGLDQLV\HDUV)RUDWKOHWHVZKR
 FRPSHWHGLQDWOHDVWRQH=XIIDERXWWKHWRWDODYHUDJHFDUHHUOHQJWKLQ00$RYHUDOO
LV\HDUV68)ˆ 
$WYDULRXVSRLQWVLQWLPH=XIID¶V3URPRWLRQDO$JUHHPHQWVKDYHLQFOXGHGDQ ˆ F 
6XFKDJUHHPHQWVDOVRQRUPDOO\KDYH  


 
68)ˆ

2WKHU00$SURPRWHUVKDYH  ˆ  
68)ˆ

2WKHU00$SURPRWLRQVFRPSHWHZLWK=XIIDWRSXWRQ00$HYHQWV68)ˆ ˆ  

'XULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRGHQWUDQWVWRWKH00$SURPRWLRQEXVLQHVV3)/21(DQG ˆ 
$&%H[SDQGHGRXWSXW21(LQFUHDVHGLWVRXWSXWIURPHYHQWLQWRLQ
3)/LQFUHDVHGLWVRXWSXWIURPHYHQWLQWRLQDQG$&% 
LQFUHDVHGLWVRXWSXWIURPHYHQWLQWRLQ68)ˆ 
1HZ00$SURPRWHUVDUHFRQWLQXLQJWRHPHUJH68)ˆ ˆˆ
Q 
3URPRWHUVKDGDFFHVVWRWDOHQWHGDWKOHWHVGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG68)ˆ ˆˆ

  
00$SURPRWHUVKDYHVXFFHVVIXOO\RXWELG=XIIDDQGFRQWUDFWHGZLWKDWKOHWHVGXULQJ ˆ 
WKHSHULRGZKHUH=XIIDKDGDULJKWWRPDWFKDFRPSHWLWRU¶VFRPSHQVDWLRQ68)ˆ 
,QWKH5DQNHGPDUNHWIURPWR=XIIDKDGRQO\RIWRWDODYDLODEOH ˆ 
DWKOHWHVXQGHUFRQWUDFWDQG=XIIDQHYHUKDGRYHURIWKHWRWDODWKOHWHVLQ'U 
6LQJHU¶V5DQNHGPDUNHWLQDQ\\HDU68)ˆ  


 
3ODLQWLIIVFDQQRWGLVSXWHWKLVIDFWE\FLWLQJRQO\WRWKHLUH[SHUWUHSRUW$VGLVFXVVHGsupraDQ
H[SHUWRSLQLRQZLWKRXWVXSSRUWIURPUHFRUGHYLGHQFHFDQQRWSXWDIDFWLQWRGLVSXWHIn re Citric 
Acid Litig.)G WK&LU $QG'U6LQJHUSURYLGHVnoHYLGHQFHRI³8)&
2XW´FODXVHVRUVLPLODUH[FOXVLYLW\H[FHSWLRQVLQ%HOODWRU¶V21(¶VRU6WULNHIRUFH¶VFRQWUDFWV 

3ODLQWLIIVKDYHQRDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFHWRGLVSXWHWKLVIDFW††,,,$ ,,,%supra
 
3ODLQWLIIVKDYHQRDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFHWRGLVSXWHWKLVIDFW††,,,$,,,&,,, &  D supra


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 28 of 35


5HOHYDQW
 8QDGGUHVVHGDQG8QGLVSXWHG)DFWV
&62)
 'U6LQJHU¶VUHJUHVVLRQVILQGDQHJDWLYHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQKLVLQSXWRI  WKH ˆ
QXPEHURIPRQWKPXOWLERXWH[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWV 'U6LQJHU¶V³IRUHFORVXUH 
 VKDUH´ DQGKLVRXWSXWRI  WKHSHUFHQWDJHRIDWKOHWHFRPSHQVDWLRQRIWRWDOHYHQW
UHYHQXHV WKHDWKOHWHV¶³ZDJHVKDUH´ :DJHVKDUHLVWKHGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOHLQWKH
 UHJUHVVLRQV'U6LQJHUGLGQRWORRNDWZKHWKHU=XIIDVXSSUHVVHGDFWXDOZDJHV
 ZLWKRXWFRQWUROOLQJIRUUHYHQXHV+HKDVQRWUXQDQ\PRGHOVWRHVWDEOLVKLQMXU\RU
GDPDJHVEDVHGRQDFWXDOFRPSHQVDWLRQDVRSSRVHGWRZDJHVKDUH+LVPRGHOVZKHQ
 UXQZLWKDFWXDOZDJHVGRQRWVKRZDQLQMXU\68)ˆ

 $ 7KH&62)5HOLHVRQ,PSURSHURU,QDGPLVVLEOH(YLGHQFHWR$WWHPSWWR&UHDWHD
*HQXLQH,VVXHRI0DWHULDO)DFW

3ODLQWLIIV¶VSDJKHWWLSRWRIIDFWVLQFOXGHVWKHIROORZLQJW\SHVRIHYLGHQFHWKDWDUH

LQDGPLVVLEOHRULQVXIILFLHQWWRVKRZDQLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFW 
x ([SHUWUHSRUWV3ODLQWLIIVLPSURSHUO\UHO\RQWKHLUH[SHUWVWRVXSSRUWDOOHJHGIDFWVZLWKRXW 
UHFRUGHYLGHQFH³$QH[SHUWUHSRUWFDQQRWEHXVHGWRSURYHWKHH[LVWHQFHRIIDFWVVHWIRUWK
WKHUHLQ´Citric Acid)GDW In re Optical Disk Drive, :/DW  
H[SHUWRSLQLRQDQGWHVWLPRQ\FDQQRWVWDQGLQWKHSODFHRIUHFRUGHYLGHQFH 'RFXPHQWVQRW
VXEPLWWHGDVSDUWRIWKHUHFRUGXQGHU)HG5&LY3 H FDQQRWEHFRQVLGHUHGCitric Acid 
)G DW 
x 3UH&ODVV3HULRGHYLGHQFH(YLGHQFHIURPbefore the Class PeriodFDQQRWFUHDWHDJHQXLQH 
LVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWDVWRZKHWKHU=XIIDKDGPDUNHWSRZHUduring the Class PeriodRebel
Oil)GDW ³7RGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHU5HEHO¶VFODLPRIHQWU\EDUULHUVLVUHDVRQDEOHZH 
PXVWFRQVLGHUWKRVHHQWULHVRFFXUULQJafterZKHQWKHDOOHJHGEDUULHUVZHUHLQSODFHDQG
ZKHQ$5&2DOOHJHGO\REWDLQHGWKHSRZHUWRFKDUJHVXSUDFRPSHWLWLYHSULFHV´ Airweld, Inc. 
v. Airco, Inc.)G WK&LU  UHMHFWLQJHYLGHQFHWKDWSUHFHGHGWKH
WLPHIUDPHWKHDWWHPSWHGPRQRSROL]DWLRQRFFXUUHG   

x 3XIIHU\VWDWHPHQWVDERXWFRPSHWLWRUV3ODLQWLIIVUHO\RQVWDWHPHQWVWKDW'DQD:KLWHDQG
/RUHQ]R)HUWLWWDPDGHWRSURPRWHWKH8)&7KHVHVWDWHPHQWVDUHFRPSHWLWLYHSXIIHU\DQG 
KDYHEHHQGHHPHGLPPDWHULDOIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWEHFDXVHVXFKSXIIHU\³IDLOVWRH[KLELW
PRUHWKDQDJJUHVVLYHEHKDYLRUDPRQJLQWHQVHFRPSHWLWRUV´Thurman)GDW 

x 2SLQLRQVWDWHPHQWV3ODLQWLIIVLPSURSHUO\UHO\RQKHDUVD\VWDWHPHQWVPDGHLQQHZVDUWLFOHV 
PDWHULDOGUDIWHGE\WKLUGSDUWLHVDQG=XIIDLQWHUQDOGLVFXVVLRQVWRSURYHHOHPHQWVRIWKHLU 
DQWLWUXVWFODLPVIndep. Ink)6XSSGDW VWDWHPHQWVE\GHIHQGDQW¶V
H[HFXWLYHVDQG³PDUNHWLQJPDWHULDOVDQGLQYHVWPHQWUHSRUWV´DERXWWKHGHIHQGDQW¶VDOOHJHG 
GRPLQDQFHLQWKHPDUNHWGRQRWHVWDEOLVKPDUNHWGHILQLWLRQRUPDUNHWSRZHU  FLWLQJFDVHV In
re Ebay Seller Antitrust Litig.:/DW ± 1'&DO0DU aff’d sub 
nom.)$SS¶[ WK&LU  VWDWHPHQWVE\GHIHQGDQW¶VHPSOR\HHVDQGFRQVXOWDQW
UHWDLQHGE\GHIHQGDQWFRXOGQRWEHXVHGDVHYLGHQFHRIPDUNHWSRZHU    


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 29 of 35


3OV¶
 =XIID¶V5HVSRQVH
&62)

 ˆ  7KLVVWDWHPHQWLVLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVH³PDUTXHH´ILJKWHUV RU³WRS´RU³KLJKHVWOHYHO´ LV
QRWDWHUPGHILQHGLQWKH&RPSODLQWRUHOVHZKHUHseesupra†,DQGEHFDXVHLWLV
 XQGLVSXWHGWKDW00$SURPRWHUVKDGWKHDELOLW\WRREWDLQWDOHQWHG00$DWKOHWHV
GXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG68)ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIVKDYHDOVRQRWDWWHPSWHGWRSURYH
 DQWLWUXVWLQMXU\RUGDPDJHVIRUDFODVVRI³PDUTXHH´DWKOHWHV
 ˆˆ 7KHVHVWDWHPHQWVDUHLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVHLWLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDWSURPRWHUVKDGWKHDELOLW\
 WRREWDLQWDOHQWHG00$DWKOHWHVGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRGDQGWKDWKLJKO\UDQNHG
 DWKOHWHVYROXQWDULO\OHIW=XIIDIRURWKHUSURPRWHUV68)ˆˆDQGWKDWFRPSHWLWRUV
KDGDOORIWKHLQSXWVQHHGHGWRFRPSHWH68)ˆ3ODLQWLIIV¶UHIHUHQFHWR-RH6LOYD¶V
 WHVWLPRQ\LVPLVOHDGLQJDQGGRHVQRWVXSSRUW3ODLQWLIIV¶SURSRVLWLRQ3O([6LOYD
7U ³SRSXODULW\GRHVQ¶WKDYHDQ\WKLQJQHFHVVDULO\WRGRZLWK\RXU

DFFRPSOLVKPHQWV´DQGWKDWLWKDVPRUHWRGRZLWK³FKDULVPD´ 8QGLVSXWHGUHFRUG
 HYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDWUDQNLQJVDORQHGRQRWWUDQVODWHLQWR³WDOHQWHG´RU³KRXVHKROG
QDPH´DWKOHWHVE.g.3O([&RNHU'HS ³ORZUDQNWRPHGRHVQ¶WPHDQ 
WKDW\RXFDQ¶WEHDVWDU6R\RXFDQEHUDQNHGRULQWKHZRUOGEXWWKHIOLSVLGHRI
WKDWLV\RXFDQEHUDQNHGRULQWKHZRUOGGRHVQ¶WPHDQ\RXDUHDVWDU´  
DWKOHWHVOLNH3ODLQWLII&XQJ/HZHUHXQUDQNHGEXW³GUHZELJ79UDWLQJV´ 
ˆˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWVDUHLPPDWHULDODVXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDWQHZDQG 

 H[LVWLQJSURPRWHUVH[SDQGHGGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG68)ˆˆ†,,,%supra 
0RW3ODLQWLIIV¶FLWDWLRQWR3URIHVVRU7RSHOLVLQFRPSOHWHDQGGRHVQRWVXSSRUW
3ODLQWLIIV¶DVVHUWLRQ3O([7RSHO'HS HFRQRPLVWVXVHWKHWHUP 
³µEDUULHUVWRHQWU\¶LQLQGLIIHUHQWZD\V6RWRDQHFRQRPLVWDFRVWDGYDQWDJHEHLQJ
EHWWHUDWVRPHWKLQJFDQEHFRQVLGHUHGDEDUULHUWRHQWU\,W¶VQRWDQDQWLFRPSHWLWLYH 
EDUULHUWRHQWU\´ Syufy )GDW UHMHFWLQJWKHRU\WKDW³6\XI\¶VHIIHFWLYHQHVV 
DVDFRPSHWLWRUFUHDWHVDVWUXFWXUDOEDUULHUWRHQWU\´ 5HFRUGHYLGHQFHGRHVQRW
VXSSRUW3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWDERXWWKHQXPEHURI=XIIDDWKOHWHVXQGHUFRQWUDFW 

3ODLQWLIIV¶&62)ˆGRHVQRWFLWHWRUHFRUGHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWWKDW=XIIDORFNHGXS 
WKH³YDVWPDMRULW\RIILJKWHUV´DQGPLVTXRWHV3URI7RSHO¶VWHVWLPRQ\3ODLQWLIIVDOVR
PLVTXRWH.XUW2WWR¶VGHSRVLWLRQWHVWLPRQ\2WWRWHVWLILHGWKDW=XIID¶VDQG 
DFTXLVLWLRQVRI:(&DQG:)$²ERWKEHIRUHWKH&ODVV3HULRG²OLPLWHGKLVFKDQFHVRI 
JHWWLQJDILJKWHUwho was under contract with another promoterVRKHZRXOGKDYHWR
³ILQGDQHZJ\PUDWWKDWKDVWDOHQWDQGEXLOGWKHPXSIURPVFUDWFK´3O([2WWR 
'HS2WWRGLGQRWWHVWLI\WKDWKH RURWKHUSURPRWHUV ZDVXQDEOHWR
FRPSHWHZLWK=XIID,WLVXQGLVSXWHG00$SURPRWHUVKDGWKHDELOLW\WRREWDLQWDOHQWHG 
00$DWKOHWHVGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG68)ˆˆ
ˆ 7KLVDOOHJDWLRQLVLPPDWHULDODVLWGRHVQRWHVWDEOLVKDQDQWLWUXVWYLRODWLRQ0RW 

ˆ 7KLVVWDWHPHQWLVLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVHXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDWSURPRWHUVKDG 
WKHDELOLW\WRVLJQWDOHQWHG00$DWKOHWHVGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRGDQGWKDWKLJKO\
UDQNHGDWKOHWHVYROXQWDULO\OHIW=XIIDIRURWKHUSURPRWHUV68)ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIV 
PLVTXRWH3URI7RSHO¶VWHVWLPRQ\:KHQDVNHGZKHWKHU³WKHFKDOOHQJHGFRQWUDFWVDUH
LQHIIHFWUHVWULFWLRQVRQDWKOHWHPRELOLW\´KHWHVWLILHG³,GRQ¶WNQRZLI,DJUHHZLWK 

 

)RUHDVHRIUHIHUHQFH=XIIDDOVRLQFOXGHVDFKDUWZLWKWKHFRPSOHWHODQJXDJHRIWKH&62)DQG 
=XIID¶VUHVSRQVH([


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 30 of 35


3OV¶
 =XIID¶V5HVSRQVH
&62)
 \RXUSKUDVH7KH\DUHUHVWULFWLRQVWKDWSURWHFWWKHLQYHVWPHQWVWKDW=XIIDKDVPDGHLQ
DWKOHWHV´3O([7RSHO'HS8QGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDW
 H[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVHQDEOH=XIIDWRKDYHHQRXJKDWKOHWHVDYDLODEOHWRFRPSHWHLQWKH
GR]HQVRI8)&HYHQWV=XIIDSURPRWHVHDFK\HDUDQGWRPDLQWDLQDKLJKTXDOLW\RI
 HYHQWVLQWKHIDFHRIDWKOHWHLQMXU\RULQDELOLW\WRFRPSHWH68)ˆ
 
3ODLQWLIIVFLWHQRUHFRUGHYLGHQFHWKDW=XIID¶VH[FOXVLYLW\FODXVHVDUHORQJHUIRU³WKH
 EHWWHU´ILJKWHUV7KH³5LJKWWR0DWFK´FODXVH 

 
([†([†([0HUVFK'HS
 ([(SVWHLQ'HS  
 ˆ 7KLVDVVHUWLRQLVXQVXSSRUWHGLWLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDWD8)&DWKOHWH¶VSURIHVVLRQDOFDUHHU
i.e.DOOSDLGERXWV LV\HDUVURXJKO\WKUHHWLPHVORQJHUWKDQ3ODLQWLIIV¶FDOFXODWLRQ 
RI=XIID¶VFRQWUDFWWHUP68)ˆ([6LQJHU5HEˆ
ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶DVVHUWLRQWKDWULYDOSURPRWHUV¶FRQWUDFWVFRQWDLQHG³VLJQLILFDQWH[FHSWLRQV´LV 
VXSSRUWHGRQO\E\FLWDWLRQVWRWKHLUH[SHUWDQGLVFRQWUDGLFWHGE\XQGLVSXWHGPDUNHW
IDFWV68)ˆ XQGLVSXWHGWKDW DQGSUHDFTXLVLWLRQ6WULNHIRUFHDOOKDG 

H[FOXVLYHFRQWUDFWVZLWKQRVLJQLILFDQWH[FHSWLRQV see also([&RNHU'HS 
3ODLQWLIIV¶DVVHUWLRQWKDWRWKHUSURPRWHUVZRXOGKDYHUHPRYHG
UHVWULFWLYHSURYLVLRQVLI=XIIDGLGVRLVEDVHGRQVSHFXODWLRQDQGLQDGPLVVLEOHKHDUVD\ 
ˆˆ &62)ˆLVLQDGPLVVLEOHEHFDXVHLWLPSURSHUO\UHOLHVRQH[SHUWV¶RSLQLRQVDV
 XQGLVSXWHGIDFWV7KH&62)ˆˆDUJXPHQWV²DQG0U9HUD¶VWHVWLPRQ\DERXW 
³FRPPRQNQRZOHGJH´WKDWODFNVIRXQGDWLRQDQGLVKHDUVD\²UHJDUGLQJ³FRHUFLRQ 
WKUHDWVDQGDJJUHVVLYH´FRQWUDFWXDOHQIRUFHPHQWDQGLPSHGLPHQWVWRIUHHDJHQF\DUH
FRQWUDGLFWHGE\WKHPDUNHWIDFWVDQGDUHLPPDWHULDOIRUWKHUHDVRQVLQVHFWLRQ,,,&E 
supraDQG=XIID¶V0RWLRQ SS 7KHTXRWHLQ&62)ˆ D GRHVQRWGLVFXVV
SUHYHQWLQJDWKOHWHVIURPUHDFKLQJIUHHDJHQF\LQVWHDGLWVD\V-RH6LOYDFRXOGFXW 
DWKOHWHVZKRUHIXVHDSSURSULDWHPDWFKXSV7KHTXRWHLQ&62)ˆ E IURP-RQ)LWFK
GRHVQRWVKRZHYLGHQFHRIDQ\ZLWKKROGLQJRIPRQH\ZKHWKHUWLHGWRIUHHDJHQF\RU 
QRW&62)ˆ F FLWHVQRHYLGHQFHRIDWKOHWHVSUHYHQWHGIURPUHDFKLQJIUHHDJHQF\ 
E\FRHUFLRQDQG G FLWHVQRHYLGHQFHRIFRHUFLRQDQGLQVWHDGFLWHVRQO\QHJRWLDWLRQV
WRH[WHQGDFRQWUDFW7KHFLWDWLRQVDOVRGRQRWVKRZWKDWWKHJHQHUDOL]DWLRQVDERXW 
=XIID¶VDOOHJHGFRQGXFWDUHWUXHE.g.3O([ 
 
7KHUHLVDOVRQRDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFHWKDW=XIID¶V
FRQWUDFWVDUH³HIIHFWLYHO\SHUSHWXDO´(DFKFRQWUDFWKDVDGHILQHGWHUPDQGVSHFLILHG 

SURYLVLRQVWKDWDOORZIRUH[WHQVLRQVLQDIHZFLUFXPVWDQFHV ([† 
,WLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDW=XIIDRIIHUHGWRUHVLJQDWKOHWHVIRUmore compensation
XQGHUQHZ DJUHHPHQWV0RW([0HUVFK'HS 
ˆ 7KLVVWDWHPHQWLVQRWVXSSRUWHGE\DQ\FLWDWLRQ
ˆˆ )RUWKHUHDVRQVLQVHFWLRQ,,,&Dsupra DQG0RW3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWVDUH 
 LPPDWHULDOEHFDXVHWKHUHLVQRVKRZLQJRIDQWLFRPSHWLWLYHKDUP    

3O([$FTXLVLWLRQV'HS     



 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 31 of 35


3OV¶
 =XIID¶V5HVSRQVH
&62)
  ([DW DQG  

 0U0HUVFKWHVWLILHGWKDW³WKHJHQHUDOQDWXUHRIP\
HPDLOZDVWRSDVVDORQJWKDWWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ$IIOLFWLRQDQGWKH8)&KDG
 DSSDUHQWO\EHHQUHSDLUHG´([0HUVFK'HS7KHUHFRUGHYLGHQFH
 VKRZVWKDWWKH$IIOLFWLRQDFTXLVLWLRQZDV³ORRNLQJJRRG´EHFDXVH 

 3O([([$FTXLVLWLRQV'HS
3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWVDERXW3ULGHDUHLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVH3ULGHLVRXWVLGH3ODLQWLIIV¶
 JHRJUDSKLFPDUNHWDQG 
&62)ˆ7KHUHZDVQRGHFUHDVHLQ
 =XIID¶VRXWSXWDQGWKHUHZDVDQLQFUHDVHLQFRPSHQVDWLRQ68)ˆ(DFKRIWKHVH
 DFTXLVLWLRQVDUHDOVRLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVHWKH\RFFXUUHGEHIRUHWKH&ODVV3HULRG
 
3ODLQWLIIV¶HYLGHQFHLQ&62)ˆLVLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVH  LWSUHGDWHVWKH&ODVV3HULRG
DQG  UHIHUVWR³ ´IRUWKH8)&ZLWKQRGHFUHDVH 
LQRXWSXWDQGRQO\DSRVLWLYHHIIHFWRQFRPSHWLWLRQ$VWRWKH6WULNHIRUFHDFTXLVLWLRQ
LQWKH)7&FRQFOXGHGWKDW³QRIXUWKHUDFWLRQLVZDUUDQWHG´LQFRQQHFWLRQZLWKLWV 

LQYHVWLJDWLRQRIWKDWDFTXLVLWLRQ([8QGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHVKRZVWKDW 

3O([$FTXLVLWLRQV'HS&RNHU¶VGHSRVLWLRQWHVWLPRQ\ 
FLWHGLQ&62)ˆˆFRQWDLQVLQDGPLVVLEOHKHDUVD\DQGLVFRQWUDGLFWHGE\WKH
XQGLVSXWHGUHFRUGHYLGHQFHWKDWFRPSHQVDWLRQ²LQFOXGLQJIRUIRUPHU6WULNHIRUFH 
DWKOHWHV²LQFUHDVHGRYHUWLPH68)ˆˆ$OORIWKHDFTXLVLWLRQVDUHDOVRLPPDWHULDO
EHFDXVHXQGLVSXWHGPDUNHWIDFWVVKRZWKDWQHZFRPSHWLWRUVKDYHHQWHUHGWKHPDUNHW 

DQGH[SDQGHGDIWHUWKHVHDFTXLVLWLRQV68)ˆˆ 
ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLVLQDGPLVVLEOHEHFDXVHLWLPSURSHUO\UHOLHVRQH[SHUWUHSRUWVWR
SURYHIDFWV,WLVDOVRFRQWUDGLFWHGE\WKHXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHWKDWKLJKO\UDQNHG 
DWKOHWHVOHIWWKH8)&YROXQWDULO\IRURWKHUSURPRWHUV68)ˆˆ7KHRWKHUFLWHG
PDWHULDOSURYLGHVQRVXSSRUW7KHFLWHGH[KLELWDQGWHVWLPRQ\GLVFXVVHVDQDWKOHWHZKR 
³ ´ 
1RWKLQJLQWKDWGRFXPHQWLQGLFDWHVWKDW=XIIDSUHYHQWHGWKHDWKOHWHIURPEHFRPLQJD
IUHHDJHQWDWWKHHQGRIKLVFRQWUDFWRUHYHQH[WHQGHGKLVFRQWUDFWEHFDXVHKHUHIXVHGWR 
FRPSHWH3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLVDOVRLPPDWHULDOIRUWKHUHDVRQVGLVFXVVHGLQVHFWLRQV
,,,$DQG,,,&DQG=XIID¶V0RWLRQ SS  
ˆ See5HSO\DW=XIID68)ˆsupra3ODLQWLIIV¶UHFRUGHYLGHQFHIURP5DLQHLVDQ
LQDGPLVVLEOHVWDWHPHQWE\DWKLUGSDUW\DQGFDQQRWEHFRQVLGHUHGRQVXPPDU\ 
MXGJPHQWDVHYLGHQFHRI=XIID¶VLQWHQWSee William Inglis & Sons Baking Co. v. 
Cont’l Baking Co., Inc.)GQ WK&LU 5DLQHH[SODLQHGWKDW
3O([LQFOXGHGTXHVWLRQVIURPDSRWHQWLDOLQYHVWRU³DQGWKHDQVZHUVZRXOGKDYH 
EHHQFRPSRVHGE\5DLQH´([1HYLOOH'HS5DLQHKDGQR
UHFROOHFWLRQRIZKHWKHU=XIIDKDGLQSXWLQWRWKHGRFXPHQWid.DQGWKHUHLVQRUHFRUG 
HYLGHQFHWKDW=XIIDDGRSWHGDQ\RIWKHWKLUGSDUW\¶VVWDWHPHQWV,QDGGLWLRQWKLV
VWDWHPHQWLVLQDFFXUDWHDQGLPPDWHULDOSee††,,,$DQG,,,%supra,WFDQQRWEHDQ 

DQWLWUXVWYLRODWLRQWREUDJDERXWWKHTXDOLW\RI\RXUEXVLQHVV 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 32 of 35


3OV¶
 =XIID¶V5HVSRQVH
&62)
 ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLVLQDGPLVVLEOHEHFDXVHLWLPSURSHUO\UHOLHVRQH[SHUWUHSRUWVWR
SURYHIDFWV$VVHWIRUWKLQWKH0RWLRQ S VHFWLRQ,,,&supraDQGLQ=XIID¶V
 Daubert0RWLRQ'U6LQJHU¶VIRUHFORVXUHDQDO\VLVLVXQUHOLDEOHIODZHGDQGPXVWEH
GLVUHJDUGHG(&)1RDW(&)1RDW H[SODLQLQJ
 WKHIDWDOHUURUVLQ'U6LQJHU¶VFLUFXODUUHDVRQLQJ 
 ˆˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWVDUHEDVHGRQLQDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFHDQGH[SHUWVXSSRVLWLRQWKDW
 FRQWUDGLFWPDUNHWIDFWV=XIID¶VFRPSHWLWRUVIURPWKH&ODVV3HULRGKDYHXQLYHUVDOO\
 WHVWLILHGWKDWWKH\FRPSHWHGZLWK=XIIDDQGKDYHDOOLQSXWVQHHGHGWRFRPSHWH68)ˆ
7KHXQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHDOVRVKRZVWKHVHFRPSHWLWRUVKDYHHQWHUHGWKHPDUNHWDQG
 H[SDQGHGSee†,,,%supra68)ˆˆRebel Oil)GDW3ODLQWLIIV
LPSURSHUO\DWWHPSWWRUHEXW=XIID¶VVWDWHPHQWVZLWKSUH&ODVV3HULRGHYLGHQFHDQG

VWDWHPHQWVRISXIIHU\RURSLQLRQZKLFKDUHERWKLQFDSDEOHRIFUHDWLQJDJHQXLQHLVVXH
 RIPDWHULDOIDFW,WLVQRWLOOHJDOWREUDJDERXWWKHTXDOLW\RI\RXUEXVLQHVV3ODLQWLIIV¶
FODLPWKDWRWKHUSURPRWHUVDUH³QRWRQSDUZLWKWKH8)&´2SSˆQLVLUUHOHYDQW 
DVWKHODZGRHVQRWUHTXLUHDFFHVVWRWKHEHVWLQSXWVEXWRQO\WKHDELOLW\WRFRPSHWH
Gen. Bus. Sys. v. N. Am. Philips Corp.)G WK&LU  

3ODLQWLIIV¶FLWHGHYLGHQFHLVDOVRLQDGPLVVLEOHDQGPLVOHDGLQJ3ODLQWLIIV¶FLWDWLRQWR([ 

RPLWVSDUWVRIWKHGRFXPHQWWKDWVKRZLWUHODWHVWR=XIID¶V%UD]LOLDQRSHUDWLRQV 
RXWVLGHWKHDOOHJHGJHRJUDSKLFPDUNHW([1HYLOOH'HS([
H[FHUSWH[FOXGHGIURP3O([ 3ODLQWLIIVDOVRPLVTXRWHDSRUWLRQRI:KLWH¶V 
GHSRVLWLRQDQGOHDYHRXW0U:KLWH¶VWHVWLPRQ\WKDW2QHLV³QRWDPLQRUJUDVVURRWV
RUJDQL]DWLRQ7KH\¶UHDPRQVWHU´3O([:KLWH'HS 
ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLVQRWVXSSRUWHGE\DGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFH=XIIDFLWHVVZRUQ 
WHVWLPRQ\IURP00$FRPSHWLWRUVGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRGDERXWWKHLUDELOLW\WR
FRPSHWH68)ˆˆ3ODLQWLIIVLPSURSHUO\DWWHPSWWRUHEXWWKHVHVWDWHPHQWV 
ZLWKSUH&ODVV3HULRGHYLGHQFHDQGSXIIHU\DQGRSLQLRQZKLFKDUHLQFDSDEOHRI
FUHDWLQJDJHQXLQHLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFW3ODLQWLIIV¶FODLPWKDWVXFKWHVWLPRQ\LV³QRW 
FUHGLEOH´LVQRWDSURSHUFRXQWHUVWDWHPHQWRIPDWHULDOIDFWV. City of Vernon)G
DW 
ˆ 3ODLQWLIIVLPSURSHUO\UHO\RQWKHLUH[SHUWV¶RSLQLRQVDVIDFWVDQGWKRVHRSLQLRQVDUH 
FRQWUDGLFWHGE\XQGLVSXWHGPDUNHWIDFWV$GGLWLRQDOO\3ODLQWLIIVPLVUHSUHVHQW'DQD
:KLWH¶VVWDWHPHQWVUHJDUGLQJFRPSHWLWLRQZLWKRWKHUFRPEDWVSRUWVE\VHOHFWLYHO\ 
H[FOXGLQJVZRUQWHVWLPRQ\WKDW=XIIDGRHVFRPSHWHZLWKRWKHUVSRUWVDQG
HQWHUWDLQPHQW3O([:KLWH'HS ³ZHFRPSHWHRYHUFHUWDLQWKLQJV 
YHQXHVDQGQLJKWV´ 3O([3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWGLVSXWH
WKHHYLGHQFHRIFRPSHWLWLRQEHWZHHQ00$SURPRWHUVDQGRWKHUVSRUWV68)ˆ 

ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLPSURSHUO\UHOLHVRQWKHLUH[SHUWV¶RSLQLRQVDVIDFWV3ODLQWLIIV 
DOVRLQFRUUHFWO\VWDWHWKDW=XIIDFRQFHGHVWKDW³DEVHQWWKH6FKHPH)LJKWHU:DJH6KDUH
ZRXOGEHVXEVWDQWLDOO\KLJKHU´FLWLQJ75ˆ7KDWFLWHGSDUDJUDSKVHWVIRUWK3URI 
7RSHO¶VRSLQLRQWKDW'U6LQJHU¶VUHJUHVVLRQHYLGHQFH³LVPLVOHDGLQJIDWDOO\IODZHG
DQGXQUHOLDEOH´LQFOXGLQJEHFDXVH³KLVPHDVXUHVRIERWKµIRUHFORVXUH¶DQG 
FRPSHQVDWLRQDUHHFRQRPLFDOO\DQGHFRQRPHWULFDOO\LQFRUUHFW´3ODLQWLIIVDJUHHWKDW
=XIIDSD\VPRUHWKDQRWKHUSURPRWHUVDQGDWWULEXWHVWKDWKLJKHUSD\WR=XIID¶V 

GRPLQDQFHFRQWUDU\WRLWVFDVHIRUPRQRSVRQ\SRZHU 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 33 of 35


3OV¶
 =XIID¶V5HVSRQVH
&62)
 ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLVLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVHZRUNHUVZKRDUHSDLGDORZHUSHUFHQWDJHRI
UHYHQXHEXWKLJKHUDFWXDOFRPSHQVDWLRQKDYHQRWVXIIHUHGDQWLFRPSHWLWLYHLQMXU\0RW
 =XIIDDaubert0RWLRQ(&)1R
ˆ 3ODLQWLIIV¶VWDWHPHQWLVEDVHGRQO\RQWKHLUH[SHUWV¶VSHFXODWLRQWKDWLVQRWVXSSRUWHGE\
 DQ\H[SHUWDQDO\VLVRUUHFRUGHYLGHQFH3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWVKRZVXSSUHVVHGZDJHVWKH\
 SXUSRUWWRVKRZVXSSUHVVHGZDJHVKDUH3ODLQWLIIVPLVTXRWH3URIHVVRU%ODLU¶V
GHSRVLWLRQFRQWHQGLQJWKDW3URIHVVRU%ODLU³FRQFHGHG´FHUWDLQHIIHFWVZRXOGRFFXUE\
 ³VXSSUHVVLQJDWKOHWHFRPSHQVDWLRQ´2SSˆQ3URIHVVRU%ODLUK\SRWKHVL]HG
DERXWSRWHQWLDOHIIHFWVWKDWFRXOGRFFXULIDWKOHWHVZHUHSDLG³VXEVWDQWLDOO\EHORZWKHLU
 PDUJLQDOUHYHQXHSURGXFW´([%ODLU'HS3ODLQWLIIVKDYHQRWDWWHPSWHG
WRFDOFXODWH053LQWKLVFDVH([6LQJHU'HS,,

ˆ 3ODLQWLIIVGRQRWGLVSXWHWKDW=XIIDLQFUHDVHGWKHQXPEHURILWVHYHQWV7KHUHPDLQLQJ
 SDUWVRI3ODLQWLIIV¶DVVHUWLRQDUHLPPDWHULDOEHFDXVH  LQHYDOXDWLQJPDUNHWSRZHUWKH
UHOHYDQWLVVXHLVZKHWKHU³E\UHVWULFWLQJLWVRZQRXWSXW>DGHIHQGDQW@FDQUHVWULFW 
PDUNHWZLGHRXWSXWDQGKHQFHLQFUHDVHPDUNHWZLGHSULFHV´Rebel Oil)GDW
DQGLWLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDW=XIID¶VRXWSXWZHQWXS  XQGLVSXWHGHYLGHQFHVKRZV 
FRPSHWLWRUHQWU\DQGH[SDQVLRQGXULQJWKH&ODVV3HULRG 68)ˆˆ DQG  
3ODLQWLIIVFLWHQRHYLGHQFHWKDWRXWSXWIHOOGXHWRWKH6FKHPH3ODLQWLIIV¶H[SHUW 

DFNQRZOHGJHVKHGLGQRWUXQDUHJUHVVLRQWRFRQWUROIRUDOORWKHUIDFWRUVWKDWPLJKW 
DIIHFWPDUNHWZLGHRXWSXWDQGLV³VLPSO\WDNLQJDWUHQGRIRXWSXWDWWKHLQGXVWU\OHYHO
DQGSURMHFWLQJLWIRUZDUGIURP´([6LQJHU'HS,, 

7KHUHPDLQLQJSRUWLRQRIWKHVWDWHPHQWWKDW=XIIDLQFUHDVHGWKHSULFHDERYH 
FRPSHWLWLYHOHYHOVLVQRWVXSSRUWHGE\UHFRUGHYLGHQFHEHFDXVH3ODLQWLIIVKDYH 
SUHVHQWHGQRHYLGHQFHRIFRPSHWLWLYHSULFHVDQGFRVWVLQWKHPDUNHW0RW†,,,$
1RUGLG'U6LQJHUSHUIRUPDUHJUHVVLRQWRFRQWUROIRUWKLQJVOLNHGHPDQGDQGFRVWVWR 
HYDOXDWHWKHFKDQJHLQ339SULFHOhio v. Am. Express Co.6&W
 ³:KHUHRXWSXWLVH[SDQGLQJDWWKHVDPHWLPHSULFHVDUHLQFUHDVLQJULVLQJ 
SULFHVDUHHTXDOO\FRQVLVWHQWZLWKJURZLQJSURGXFWGHPDQG´ 
ˆ 7KLVVWDWHPHQWPLVVWDWHV1LQWK&LUFXLWODZ6HHsupra†,,,&D3ODLQWLIIVGRQRW 
UHEXWWKDW=XIID¶VFRQWUDFWVDOORZLWWRLQFUHDVHRXWSXWDQGSXWRQKLJKTXDOLW\HYHQWV 
68)ˆ3ODLQWLIIV¶H[SHUWDGPLWVWKDW³RQJRLQJDFFHVVWRDGHHSSRRORIWDOHQWHG
)LJKWHUVLVDFULWLFDOLQSXWWRWKHRQJRLQJVXFFHVVRIDQ00$SURPRWLRQ´EHFDXVHRI 
³WKHQHHGIRUDVWHDG\VXSSO\RIDSSURSULDWHO\PDWFKHG+HDGOLQHUV´DQG³WKHQHHGWR
UHSODFH)LJKWHUVWKDWEHFRPHXQDYDLODEOHGXHWRLQMXU\´([6LQJHU5HSˆ 
(YLGHQFHRIFHUWDLQW\SHVRIUHVWULFWLYHFRQWUDFWVLQRWKHUVSRUWVGRHVQRWVKRZWKDW
=XIID¶VVSHFLILFEXVLQHVVMXVWLILFDWLRQVDUHSUHWH[WXDO 

  

   


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 34 of 35


'DWHG1RYHPEHU 5HVSHFWIXOO\6XEPLWWHG


 %2,(66&+,//(5)/(;1(5//3

 

 %\V:LOOLDP$,VDDFVRQ 
:LOOLDP$,VDDFVRQ

Attorneys for Defendant =XIID//&GED
 8OWLPDWH)LJKWLQJ&KDPSLRQVKLSDQG8)&

 :LOOLDP$,VDDFVRQ Pro Hac Vice 
6WDFH\.*ULJVE\ Pro Hac Vice 
 1LFKRODV$:LGQHOO Pro Hac Vice 
 %2,(66&+,//(5)/(;1(5//3
1HZ<RUN$YH1: 
:DVKLQJWRQ'&
7HO   
)D[  
(PDLOZLVDDFVRQ#EVIOOSFRP 
 VJULJVE\#EVIOOSFRP 
 QZLGQHOO#EVIOOSFRP 

'RQDOG-&DPSEHOO
-&ROE\:LOOLDPV 
&$03%(// :,//,$06
6RXWKWK6WUHHW 
/DV9HJDV1HYDGD
7HO   

)D[   
(PDLOGMF#FDPSEHOODQGZLOOLDPVFRP
 MFZ#FDPSEHOODQGZLOOLDPVFRP 

 
5LFKDUG-3RFNHU
%2,(66&+,//(5)/(;1(5//3 
6RXWK)RXUWK6WUHHW6XLWH
/DV9HJDV19 
7HO   
)D[  
(PDLOUSRFNHU#EVIOOSFRP 

Attorneys for Defendant =XIID//&GED 8OWLPDWH 
)LJKWLQJ&KDPSLRQVKLSDQG8)& 
 

 


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<

Case 2:15-cv-01045-RFB-PAL Document 611 Filed 11/02/18 Page 35 of 35


&(57,),&$7(2)6(59,&(


 7KHXQGHUVLJQHGKHUHE\FHUWLILHVWKDWWKHIRUHJRLQJ=XIID¶V5HSO\,Q6XSSRUW2I0RWLRQ
 IRU6XPPDU\-XGJPHQWZDVVHUYHGRQ1RYHPEHUYLDWKH&RXUW¶V&0(&)HOHFWURQLF
 ILOLQJV\VWHPDGGUHVVHGWRDOOSDUWLHVRQWKHHVHUYLFHOLVW
 
       
       V5RGHULFN&UDZIRUGBBBBBBBBBBBBB
       $QHPSOR\HHRI%RLHV6FKLOOHU)OH[QHU
                    


 =8))$¶6027)256800$5<-8'*0(175(3/<