Journal Reading

Penelitian Klinikoepidemiologik pada Tuberkulosis Kutis di

Rumah Sakit Pendidikan Tersier, Andhra Pradesh, India

Oleh :
Muhammad Tohib Habib 1840312271
Putri Fernizi Harfah 1840312293
Viftrya Rosady 1740312098

Preseptor:
Dr. dr. Satya Wydya Yenny, Sp.KK(K), FINSDV, FAADV
dr. Tutty Ariani, Sp.DV

BAGIAN ILMU KESEHATAN KULIT DAN KELAMIN

FAKULTAS KEDOKTERAN UNIVERSITAS ANDALAS
RSUP DR M. DJAMIL PADANG
2018
 Penelitian Klinikoepidemiologik pada Tuberkulosis Kutis di Rumah Sakit Pendidikan
Tersier, Andhra Pradesh, India

Abstrak

Latar Belakang: Tuberkulosis kutis merupakan 1,5% dari tuberkulosis ekstra paru dan
penyakit ini terus menjadi salah satu tantangan karena memiliki tampilan klinis yang berbeda.
Penelitian ini dilakukan untuk mendokumentasikan tipe tuberkulosis kutis yang paling
umum, tampilan klinis yang atipikal (bila ada) dan responnya terhadap terapi singkat
(DOTS).

Metode: Semua pasien dengan TB kutis yang diduga secara klinis dan datang ke bagian
rawat jalan RSUP Dr. Dermatologi di rumah sakit kami dari Oktober 2012 hingga April 2016
dilibatkan dalam penelitian ini. Riwayat lengkap penyakit dan pemeriksaan menyeluruh
secara umum, sistemik dan kulit dilakukan bersamaan dengan dokumentasi rincian
demografi. Pemeriksaan darah rutin, tes biopsi dan mantoux juga dilakukan. Kasus yang
didiagnosis dan diobati dengan DOTS.

Hasil: Sebanyak 25 kasus tuberkulosis kutis dimasukkan dalam penelitian. Jenis tuberkulosis
kutis yang paling umum adalah lupus vulgaris. Gambaran klinis atipikal yang dicatat selama
penelitian adalah multifokal lupus vulgaris (LV), ko-eksistensi tubekulosis kutis verukosa
dan LV, Tuberkulosis kutis verukosa pada bibir bawah, erythema induratum of bazin
dengan tampilan plak anular dalam satu kasus dan eritema nodosum pada kasus lain. DOTS
efektif pada sebagian besar pasien.

Kesimpulan: Tuberkulosis kutis memiliki banyak tampilan klinis. Kecurigaan klinis yang
tinggi diperlukan dalam tampilan klinis yang jarang. Ko-eksistensi dari dua atau lebih pola
morfologi dapat terjadi. Kasus yang meragukan, 5-6 minggu diberikan terapi. Dosis yang
adekuat sangat penting untuk respon yang baik. Obat lini kedua harus dipertimbangkan dalam
kasus kegagalan / resistensi klinis.

Kata Kunci: Tuberkulosis kutis, Tuberkulosis Multifokal, Tampilan klini Atipikal, Erythema
induratum of bazin, DOTS
PENDAHULUAN

Tuberkulosis sudah setua usia manusia yang ada, dengan bukti dari penyakit tersebut
yang telah ditemukan pada mumi Peruvian dan pada kerangka manusia yang berusia 300 SM.
Secara global, 9,6 juta kasus-kasus tuberkulosis baru ditemukan pada tahun 2014 dan 1,3 juta
meninggal.1 Tuberkulosis biasanya dipertimbangkan sebagai penyakit yang mengenai rakyat
dengan kemiskinan dimana 94% kasus kasus yang muncul terjadi di negara-negara dengan
status sosial ekonomi rendah. Meskipun insidennya telah turun hingga 0,1% bahkan di negara
berkembang, penyakit ini tetap terjadi. Salah satu yang luar biasa karena ko-infeksi dari
human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), resistensi obat dan presentasi atipikal.2,3. Penelitian
ini dilakukan untuk mendokumentasikan tipe tuberkulosis kutis yang paling umum, tampilan
klinis yang atipikal jika ada dan respon terhadap terapi singkat (DOTS).

METODE

Semua pasien dengan TB kutis yang diduga secara klinis dan datang ke bagian rawat
jalan RSUP Dr. Dermatologi di rumah sakit kami dari Oktober 2012 hingga April 2016
dilibatkan dalam penelitian ini. Riwayat lengkap penyakit dan pemeriksaan menyeluruh
secara umum, sistemik dan kulit dilakukan bersamaan dengan dokumentasi rincian
demografi.pemeriksaan darah rutin, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) untuk HIV,
Rontgen Toraks, Tes Mantoux dan biopsi dilakukan pada semua kasus. Pemeriksaan sputum
untuk Basil Tahan Asam (BTA), sitologi aspirasi jarum halus kelenjar getah bening dan tes
radiologi lainnya dilakukan dalam kasus yang relevan. Kasus yang terdiagnosis diberi DOTS
untuk jangka waktu 6 bulan dan respon dinilai pada 6 minggu dan pada akhir terapi,jika
terdapat efek samping juga dicatat selama masa pengobatan.

HASIL

Sebanyak 25 kasus tuberkulosis kutis dimasukkan dalam penelitian. Rasio laki-laki

dan perempuan dalam penelitian adalah 1,5: 1. Kelompok usia populasi penelitian berkisar 5-
40 tahun dengan usia rata-rata adalah 25 tahun 6 bulan. Lokasi yang paling sering terlibat
adalah ekstremitas bawah yang terlihat pada 13 kasus [52%]. Jenis klinis yang paling umum
dari tuberkulosis kutis adalah lupus vulgaris yang terlihat pada 11 kasus (44%) dan yang
paling umum adalah erythema induratum of bazin yang terlihat pada 2 kasus (8%), rincian
diberikan dalam Tabel 1.
 Table 1: Tipe-tipe TB Kutis pada Penelitian.

Clinical type Number of patients (%)

Lupus vulgaris 11 (44)

Tuberculosis Verrucosa Cutis 4 (16)
Scrofuloderma 2 (8)
Papulonecrotic Tuberculid 6 (24)
Erythemainduratum of Bazins 2 (8)

Gambar 1: Multifokal lupus vulgaris. (a) tungkai kanan bawah sisi depan (b) Telapak
kaki kanan yang meluas ke sisi medial

Dari pasien tb kutis, yang juga terkena HIV ditemukan pada 3 kasus (12%). Presentasi
atipikal yang dicatat selama penelitian adalah multifokal lupus vulgaris (LV), ko-eksistensi
tuberkulosis kutis verukosa dan LV, tuberkulosis kutis verukosa pada bibir bawah, TVC pada
bibir bawah, erythema induratum of bazin (EIB) yang muncul dengan tampilan plak anular
dalam satu kasus dan erythema nodosum dalam kasus lain seperti yang ditunjukkan pada
Gambar 1-5. Mantoux positif dalam 84,2% kasus dan histopatologi khas terlihat pada 90%
kasus. Tabel 2 menunjukkan rincian penyelidikan laboratorium dari populasi penelitian.
DOTS efektif dalam semua kasus kecuali pada 2 (8%) pasien dan truncal acne diamati pada
2 (8%) pasien seperti yang ditunjukkan pada Gambar 6 dan 7.

Gambar 2: (a) penampakan skrofuloderma di bagian lipat paha kiri dan (b)
tuberculosis verrukosa kutis pada telapak kaki kiri

Figure 3: Tuberkulosis verrukosa kutis pada bibir bawah.

 Figure 4: (a) Erythema induratum of bazin presentingas annular plaque over thigh (b)
histopatologi memperlihatkan granuloma pada lemak subkutan [H & E, 100X].

Figure 5: (a) Erythema nodosum seperti lesi pada tungkai bawah (b) tes mantoux positif
kuat
 Figure 6: Scrofuloderma (a) sebelum terapi (b) setelah 3 bulan terapi DOTS.

Figure 7: Erythema induratum of bazin (a) sebelum terapi (c) 4 bulan setelah terapi
DOTS
 Tabel 2:.Pemeriksaan Laboratorium pada populasi penelitian

Laboratory Percentage of patients showing

Investigations positive results

Mantoux test 84.2%

Sputum for AFB 0
Chest X –ray 4%
FNAC of nodes 5%
Bone radiography 0
Typical Histopathological changes 90%
HIV 12%

DISKUSI

Pada penelitian ini, tuberkulosis kutis menunjukkan insiden yang lebih tinggi pada
laki-laki, sama dengan mayoritas hasil studi di India. Hal ini dapat dihubungkan dengan
resiko cedera yang lebih tinggi pada laki-laki, dimana pasien yang dilibatkan dalam
penelitian kali ini berprofesi sebagai pekerja kasar. Sebagian besar pasien berada pada usia
dekade kedua, sama dengan hasil studi di India lainnya. Jenis tuberkulosis kutis yang paling
umum dalam penelitian ini adalah lupus vulgaris [44%], sama dengan beberapa studi lain.
Namun beberapa studi di India lainnya ditemukan scrofuloderma sebagai tipe yang paling
umum. Lihat Tabel 3.
` Pada penelitian ini ditemukan bahwa ekstremitas bawah merupakan lokasi tersering
kejadian TB kutis. Ditemukannya insiden tinggi TB kutis pada ekstremitas bawah di India
bisa dijelaskan dengan re-inokulasi basil tuberkulosis melalui trauma ringan, terutama saat
jongkok.

TB kutis, seperti yang dikutip oleh Pillsbury, Shelly dan Kligman sebagai “di kulit
tuberkulosis muncul dalam berbagai bentuk yang menakjubkan ”. Sejalan dengan itu kami
mengamati berbagai gambaran atipikal selama penelitian ini. Lupus vulgaris multifokal
terlihat pada laki-laki berusia 40 tahun, namun laporan mengenai penyakit multifokal pada
literatur sangat sedikit. Kejadian multifokal paling banyak terjadi pada pasien yang tidak di
vaksinasi dan malnutrisi serta umumnya mantoux test nya negatif. Ada beberapa laporan
tentang ko-eksistensi dari tuberkulosis yang berbeda pada orang yang sama dengan
kombinasi TVC dan scrofuloderma paling sering dilaporkan,termasuk pada penelitian ini.
Studi imunohistologik terhadap granuloma pada TB kutis menunujukkan perubahan spektrum
yang ditunjukkan dengan rasio CD4 +/- CD8, contohnya pada LV dengan imunitas tinggi,
TVC dengan imunitas sedang, dan SFD dengan imunitas rendah. Ada beberapa tipe TB kutis
yang muncul tergantung pada imunitas seseorang. Kemungkinan alasan lainnya adalah TVC
dapat berkembang dari auto-innoculation bacilli dari TB kutis yang berdekatan yaitu SFD.
Pada penelitian kami ditemukan kasus TVC pada lokasi yang tidak umum yaitu di bibir
bawah pada seorang wanita berusia 50 tahun. Beberapa lokasi yang tidak biasa juga
dilaporkan terjadi di jari, di atas keloid, dll.
 EIB secara klinis bisa menyerupai eritema nodusum pada suatu kasus. Observasi lain
oleh Maharaja dkk dalam studinya mengenai gambaran kliniskohistopatologis pada nodul
lunak erimatosus umumnya terjadi di ekstremitas, dimana terjadi perubahan histologis pada
eritema nodusum dalam 8/30 kasus dan 3 kasus diantaranya mengarah ke EIB. Presentasi
atipikal EIB lainnya berupa plak anular besar di bagian atas paha pada pasien berumur 25
tahun. Jadi EIB tidak selalu didefinisikan dengan gambaran klasik (nodul ulseratif di tungkai
bawah), namun tetap gambaran histopatologi yang akan membantu menegakkan diagnosis
definitif dan differensial.

` Mantoux test positif terlihat pada 84,2% kasus, hasil ini sebanding dengan studi yang
dilakukan Binod kumar dkk, hasil yang berbeda terlihat dalam penelitian lain, rincian dapat
dilihat pada Tabel 4.

Perubahan histopatologik tipikal ditemukan pada 90% kasus yang juga ditemukan
pada penelitian India lain. Durasi pemberian obat anti tuberkulosis (OAT) untuk tuberkulosis
kutis adalah antara 6-12 bulan pada beberapa penelitian lainnya. Kami mengimplementasikan
terapi OAT yang diberikan selama 6 bulan. Pada penelitian oleh Raghu Rama dkk tentang
terapi DOTS di pasien tuberkulosis kutis, efikasinya hampir sebanding dengan kemoterapi
jangka pendek harian, dengan manfaat lainnya yaitu paparan terhadap obat yang lebih sedikit,
pemberian obat dibawah pengawasan dan pengeluaran untuk transpor menjadi lebih sedikit.
Raghu menemukan bahwa tidak ada kegagalan pengobatan atau efek samping yang
signifikan dengan penggunaan terapi DOTS pada penelitiannya. Namun, pada penelitian ini,
kami menemukan adanya kegagalan pengobatan pada 8% kasus dan ditemukannya efek
samping minor seperti jerawat dipunggung pada 8% kasus, secara detail dapat dilihat di Tabel
5.
 Lama percobaan pengobatan di pasien yang dicurigai tuberkulosis kutis adalah selama
5-6 minggu, kecuali pada pasien dengan tuberkulid dan pasien tidak yang memperlihatkan
gejala klinis yang signifikan sebelum pengobatan. Jika setelah jangka waktu tersebut pasien
tidak menunjukkan perubahan signifikan, maka diagnosisnya perlu dikaji ulang kembali.
Namun dengan adanya tuberkulosis yang multi drug resistant (MDR), pendekatan ini tidak
dibernarkan. Tuberkulosis kutis yang MDR harus selalu dipikirkan pada pengobatan pasien
yang tidak memperihatkan respon signfikan setelah pemberian OAT lini pertama atau pada
pasien yang klinisnya memburuk bahkan setelah pemberian OAT. Diagnosis definitif dari
tuberkulosis MDR sulit dilakukan akibat sukarnya isolasi dan tes diagnositik molekuler yang
sensitivitasnya masih rendah. Sehingga, selalu dibenarkan untuk dilakukannya percobaan
pemberian OAT lini kedua sebelum menganggap pasien tidak responsif terhadap terapi. Kami
memiliki satu pasien laki-laki berumur 40 tahun yang bertubuh sehat (tinggi 6 kaki, berat 120
kg) yang dikonfirmasi dengan biopsi menderita skrofuloderma, yang tidak responsif dengan
pemberian OAT rutin bahkan setelah 5 minggu terapi, sembari berpikir mengenai
kemungkinan resistensi obat sebelum memulai pengobatan OAT line kedua, kami
memberikan OAT lini pertama yang disesuaikan dengan berat badannya. Dalam 2 minggu
setelah penambahan dosis, pasien langsung memberikan respon, seperti yang dijabarkan di
gambar 8. Oleh karena ittu, pendosisan obat yang adekuat, terutama berdasarkan berat badan
pasien, juga sangat penting sebelum memikirkan kemungkinan diagnosis lain atau adanya
resistensi obat.
 Kesimpulanya, tuberkulosis kutis memiliki berbagai sisi. Kecurigaan klinis yang
tinggi dibutuhkan pada presentasi yang jarang ditemukan. Pola morfologis yang tumpang
tindih atau lebih dari 2 dapat terjadi. Pada kasus yang meragukan, percobaan terapi selama 5-
6 mingggu sangatlah mebantu. Dosis adekuat juga diperlukann untuk didapatkannya respon
yang baik. OAT lini kedua dapat dipertimbangkan pada kasus yang mengalami kegagalan
pengobatan atau resistensi obat.
International Journal of Research in Dermatology
Aruna C et al. Int J Res Dermatol. 2017 Mar;3(1):88-93
http://www.ijord.com

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18203/issn.2455-4529.IntJResDermatol20170454
Original Research Article

A clinicoepidemiological study of cutaneous tuberculosis in a tertiary

care teaching hospital in Andhra Pradesh, India
Chintaginjala Aruna*, Senthil kumar A. L., Sridevi K., Swapna K., Ramamurthy D. V. S. B.

Department of DVL, Katuri Medical College & hospital, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh, India

Received: 24 December 2016

Accepted: 24 February 2017

*Correspondence:
Dr. Chintaginjala Aruna,
E-mail: draruna88@gmail.com

Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

ABSTRACT

Background: Cutaneous tuberculosis constitutes 1.5% of extra pulmonary tuberculosis and the disease continues to
be a challenging one because of its multifaceted presentation. The present study was done to document the most
common type of cutaneous tuberculosis, atypical presentations if any and response to directly observed therapy short
course (DOTS).
Methods: All patients with clinically suspected cutaneous tuberculosis attending outpatient department of
dermatology in our hospital from October 2012 to April 2016 were included in the study. A detailed history of
presenting illness and thorough general, systemic and cutaneous examination was carried out along with
documentation of demographic details. Routine blood invetigations, biopsy and mantoux test were done. Diagnosed
cases were treated with DOTS.
Results: A total of 25 cases of cutaneous tuberculosis were included in the study. Most common type of cutaneous
tuberculosis was lupus vulgaris. Atypical presentations noted during the study were multifocal lupus vulgaris (LV),
co-existence of tuberculosis verrucosa cutis (TVC) and LV, TVC of lower lip, erythema induratum of bazin
presenting as annular plaque in one case and as erythema nodosum in another case. DOTS were effective in majority
of the patients.
Conclusions: Cutaneous tuberculosis is multifaceted. High clinical suspicion is necessary in rare presentations.
Coexistence of two or more morphological patterns can occur. Doubtful cases, 5-6weeks of therapeutic trail helps.
Adequate dose is essential for good response. Second line drugs are to be considered in case of failure /clinical
resistance.

Keywords: Cutaneous tuberculosis, Multifocal tuberculosis, Atypical presentations, Erythema induratum of bazin,
DOTS

INTRODUCTION formidable one because of human immunodeficiency

Tuberculosis is as old as mankind, with evidence of the
disease being found in a Peruvian mummy and in a
skeleton from 300 BC. Globally 9.6 million new
tuberculosis cases were detected in 2014 and 1.3 million
deaths were attributable to the disease.1 Tuberculosis is
usually considered as disease of poverty as 94% of cases
occur in countries with lower socioeconomic status.
Though its incidence has fallen to 0.1% even in
developing countries, the disease continues to be a
virus (HIV) co-infection, drug resistance and atypical
presentations.2,3 The Present study was done to document
the most common type of cutaneous tuberculosis, atypical
presentations if any and response to directly observed
short course (DOTS) therapy.
METHODS
All patients with clinically suspected cutaneous
tuberculosis attending outpatient department of

International Journal of Research in Dermatology | January-March 2017 | Vol 3 | Issue 1 Page 88

 Aruna C et al. Int J Res Dermatol. 2017 Mar;3(1):88-93

dermatology in our hospital from October 2012 to April
2016 were included in the study. A detailed history of
presenting illness and thorough general, systemic and
cutaneous examination was carried out along with
documentation of demographic details. Routine blood
investigations, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay
(ELISA) for HIV, X-ray chest, mantoux test and biopsy
were done in all cases. Sputum examination for acid fast
bacilli (AFB), fine needle aspiration cytology of lymph
nodes and other radiological tests were done in relevant
cases. Diagnosed cases were given DOTS for a period of
6 months and response was assessed at 6 weeks and at the
end of the therapy, side effects if any were also noted
during the treatment period.
HIV association was found in 3 cases (12%). Atypical
presentations noted during the study were multifocal
lupus vulgaris (LV), co-existence of tuberculosis
verrucosa cutis (TVC) and LV, TVC of lower lip,
erythema induratum of bazin (EIB) presenting as annular
plaque in one case and as erythema nodosum in another
case as shown from Figure 1-5. Mantoux was positive in
84.2% of the cases and typical histopathology was seen in
90% of the cases. Table 2 shows details of laboratory
investigations of the study population. DOTS was
effective in all cases except in 2 (8%) patients and truncal
acne was observed in 2 (8%) patient as shown in Figures
6 and 7.

RESULTS

A total of 25 cases of cutaneous tuberculosis were

included in the study. Male to female ratio in our study
was 1.5:1. Age group of the study population ranged
from 5-40 years with the mean age being 25 years 6
months. Most commonly involved site was the lower
limb which was seen in 13 cases [52%]. The most
common clinical type of cutaneous tuberculosis was
lupus vulgaris seen in 11 cases (44%) and the least
common was erythema induratum of bazin seen in 2
cases(8%), details are given in the Table 1. Figure 2: (a) Co-existance of scrofuloderma over left
grion and (b) tuberculosis verrucosa cutis on left the
sole.
Table 1: Types of cutaneous tuberculosis in the
present study.

Clinical type Number of patients (%)

Lupus vulgaris 11 (44)
Tuberculosis verrucosa 4 (16)
cutis
Scrofuloderma 2 (8)
Papulonecrotic 6 (24)
tuberculid
Erythemainduratum of 2 (8)
bazins

Figure 3: Tuberculosis verrucosa cutis on the lower

lip.

Figure 4: (a) Erythema induratum of bazin presenting

Figure 1: Multifocal lupus vulgaris. (a) over anterior
as annular plaque over thigh (b) histopathology
aspect of right lower limb (b) over right sole
showing granulomas in subcutaneous fat [H & E,
extending on to medial aspect of foot.
100X].

International Journal of Research in Dermatology | January-March 2017 | Vol 3 | Issue 1 Page 89

 Aruna C et al. Int J Res Dermatol. 2017 Mar;3(1):88-93

DISCUSSION

Cutaneous tuberculosis showed a higher incidence in men

in our study similar to majority of the Indian studies.4-6
This may be attributed to higher risk of sustaining injury
in men, as many of our patients were involved in heavy
manual work. Most of the patients were in their second
decade, similar to that observed in other Indian studies.6,7
The most common clinical type of cutaneous tuberculosis
in our study was lupus vulgaris [44%], this was similar to
few studies.5,6,8 However few other Indian studies found
scrofuloderma as the most common type and Table 3
shows the details.7,9,10
Figure 5: (a) Erythema nodosum like lesions on lower
We found lower limb as the most common involved site,
limb (b) strongly positive mantoux test.
it was also noticed by few authors.6,8 High incidence of
cutaneous tuberculosis on the legs in Indians can be
explained by the re-inoculation of tuberculosis bacilli
through minor trauma, especially during squatting.

Cutaneous tuberculosis was earlier quoted by Pillsbury,

Shelly and Kligman as “in the skin tuberculosis presents
itself in an astonishing variety of forms”.11
correspondingly we observed various atypical
presentations during our study. Multifocal lupus vulgaris
was seen in a 40 year old male, there are very few reports
of multifocal disease in the literature.12,13 Multifocal
Figure 6: Scrofuloderma (a) before treatment (b) after involvement is mostly seen in unvaccinated and
3 months of DOTS therapy. malnourished patients and usually have negative mantoux
test. There are few reports of co-existence of different
tuberculosis in the same person with combination of TVC
and scrofuloderma [SFD] being most commonly reported
including ours.14,15 Immunohistological study of
granuloma in cutaneous tuberculosis have shown a
spectrum of changes as evidenced by CD4±CD8 ratio, i.e
LV with strong immunity, TVC with intermediate
immunity and SFD with low-level immunity.16
Depending up on the level of immunity in a person over a
period of time, may be different types of cutaneous
tuberculosis are expressed. Another probable reason is,
TVC may develop from auto-innoculation of bacilli from
adjacent cutaneous tuberculosis that is SFD. We found
Figure 7: Erythema induratum of bazin (a) before TVC of lower lip in a 40 year old female which is an
therapy (c) after 4 months of DOTS therapy. uncommon site, few uncommon sites already reported in
the literature are finger, over a keloid etc. 17,18 EIB
Table 2: Details of laboratory investigations of the clinically resembled erythema nodosum in one case. A
study population in the present study. similar observation was made by Maharaja et al in his
study of the clinicohistopathological features of
Laboratory Percentage of patients erythematous tender nodules predominantly involving the
investigations showing positive extremities, in which histological disacordance of
results erythema nodosum was seen in 8 cases [total 30 cases]
Mantoux test 84.2% and among them 3 cases were suggestive of EIB.19
Sputum for AFB 0 Another atypical presentation of EIB noted in our study
Chest X -ray 4% was a large annular plaque over thigh in a 25 year old
FNAC of nodes 5% male. So, EIB may not always present as classically
Bone radiography 0 described (ulcerating nodules on calves), it is the
Typical Histopathological 90% histopathology that helps in definitive diagnosis and
changes differentiation.
HIV 12%

International Journal of Research in Dermatology | January-March 2017 | Vol 3 | Issue 1 Page 90

 Aruna C et al. Int J Res Dermatol. 2017 Mar;3(1):88-93

Positive mantoux was seen in 84.2% of the cases, this
was comparable to Binod kumar et al study, different
results were seen in other studies, details given in Table
4.7,8,20
Typical histopathological changes were seen in 90% of
cases similar to other Indian studies.20 Duration of
antitubercular therapy [ATT] for cutaneous tuberculosis
ranged from 6-12 months in different studies.20-22 We
employed DOTS therapy which was given for 6 months.
Table 3: Comparison of clinical types of cutaneous tuberculosis in the present study with other studies.
In Raghu Rama Rao et al study on DOTS therapy in
cutaneous tuberculosis, efficacy was comparable with the
standard daily short course chemotherapy with added
advantage of exposure to less number of drugs, standard
drugs being given under supervision and less travel
expenses.21 He made the observation of no treatment
failure or significant side effects with DOTS therapy in
his study.21 In contrast we observed treatment failure in
8% of cases and minor side effects like truncal acne in
8%, details given in Table 5.

Clinical type of Present study, Puri et al study8 Patra AC et al Thakur BK et al

Cutaneous number of cases [%] number of cases [%] study,6 number of study,7 number of
tuberculosis cases [%] cases [%]
Lupus vulgaris 11 [44] 11 [55] 60 [57.69] 18 [42.86]
Tuberculosis 4 [16] 1 [5] 20 [19.23] 2 [4.76]
verrucosa cutis
Scrofuloderma 2 [8] 5 [25] 22 [21.15] 21 [50]
Orificial 0 1 [5] 0 0
tuberculosis
Papulonecrotic 6 [24] 1 [5] 0 0
tuberculid
Erythemainduratum 2 [8] 1 [5] 0 0
of bazins
Lichen 0 0 2 [1.92] 1 [2.38]
scrofulosorum
Total cases 25 20 104 42

Table 4: Comparison of laboratory investigations in our study with others.

Laboratary investigations Present study Thakur BK et al study7 Binayak Chandra et al study20

Mantoux test 84.2% 4% 96%
Sputum for AFB 0 0% 6%
Chest X -ray 3% 4.76% 4%
FNAC of nodes 5% 45.24% 8%
Bone radiography 0 7.14% 0
Typical histopathological
90% 59.5% 96%
changes
HIV 12% 0 4%
Total cases 25 42 50

Table 5: Comparison of duration of ATT and percentage of failure and side effects in our study with others.

Studies Duration of ATT Treatment failure Side effects

[First line agents]
Present study 6 months 8% 8%[truncal acne]
Binayak Chandra et al20 8 months 4% Not mentioned
Raghu Rama Rao et al21 6 months 0 Not seen
Ramesh V et al22 6-12 months 1.9% Not mentioned

The duration of therapeutic trial in case of suspected
cutaneous tuberculosis is 5-6 weeks, with the exception
of tuberculids and patients showing minimal clinical
activity before treatment. The diagnosis used to be
reviewed in patients who didn't respond by this time. But
with the advent of multi drug resistant (MDT)
tuberculosis, this approach is not justified. MDR
cutaneous tuberculosis should always be kept in mind in
the management of patients with lack of clinical response
to the first line ATT drugs or in those patients showing
clinical deterioration even while on ATT. The definitive
diagnosis of MDR tuberculosis is difficult owing to poor

International Journal of Research in Dermatology | January-March 2017 | Vol 3 | Issue 1 Page 91

 Aruna C et al. Int J Res Dermatol. 2017 Mar;3(1):88-93
isolation rates and low sensitivity of molecular diagnostic 6.
tests. So it is always justified to give a trial of second line
ATT for atleast two months before labelling a patient non
responsive to therapy.23 We had one wellbuilt (height 6 7.
feet, weight 120 kg) 40 year old male patient with biopsy
confirmed scrofuloderma who had not responded to
routine dosages of ATT [AKT-4 kit] even after 5 weeks
of therapy, thinking in terms of drug resistance before 8.
starting 2nd line agents we gave him the first line agents
adjusting to his per kg body weight. Within 2 weeks of
hiking the dose the patient responded promptly, as 9.
presented in Figure 8. Hence, adequate drug dosing
especially adjusted to the per kg body weight of a person
is also most important before considering either
alternative diagnosis or drug resistance.
10.
11.
12.
Figure 8: (a) Scrofuloderma after 5 weeks of AKT (b) 13.
2 weeks after hiking the dose (c) at the end of 6
months of therapy.
14.
To conclude, cutaneous tuberculosis is multifaceted. High
clinical suspicion is necessary in rare presentations.
Coexistence of two or more morphological patterns can 15.
occur. In doubtful cases, 5-6 weeks of therapeutic trail
helps. Adequate dose is essential for good response.
Second line drugs are to be considered in case of failure
/clinical resistance. 16.
Funding: No funding sources
Conflict of interest: None declared 17.
Ethical approval: Not required
REFERENCES 18.
1. World health organisation, global tuberculosis
report 2015. Available from http:// http://www.who.
19.
int/tb/publications/global_report/en/.
2. Kumar B, Rai R, Kaur I, Sahoo B, Muralidhar S,
Radotra BD. Childhood cutaneous tuberculosis: a
study over 25 years from northern India. Int J
Dermatol. 2001;40:26-32.
3. Kumar B, Muralidhar S. Cutaneous tuberculosis: A-
20.
Twenty-year prospective study. Int J Tuberc Lung
Dis. 1999;3:494-500.
4. Kumar B, Kaur S. Pattern of cutaneous tuberculosis
in North India. Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol.
1986;52:203-7.
21.
5. Acharya KM, Ranpara H, Dutta R, Mehta B. A
clinicopathological study of 50 cases of cutaneous
tuberculosis in Jamnagar district. Indian J Dermatol
Venereol Leprol. 1997;63:301-3.
International Journal of Research in Dermatology | January-March 2017 | Vol 3 | Issue 1
Patra AC, Gharami RC, Banerjee PK. A profile of
cutaneous tuberculosis. Indian J Dermatol.
2006;51:105-7.
Thakur BK, Verma S, Hazarika D. A
clinicopathological study of cutaneous tuberculosis
at Dibrugarh district Assam. Indian J Dermatol.
2012;57:63-5.
Puri N. A clinical and histopathological profile of
patients with cutaneous tuberculosis. Indian J
Dermatol. 2011;56:550-2.
Sehgal VN, Srivastava G, Khurana VK, Sharma
VK, Bhalla P, Beohar PC. An appraisal of
epidemiologic, clinical, bacteriologic,
histopathologic and immunologic parameters in
cutaneous tuberculosis. Int J Dermatol.
1987;26:521-6.
Gopinathan R, Pandit D, Joshi J, Jerajani H, Mathur
M. Clinical and morphological variants of cutaneous
tuberculosis and its relation to mycobacterium
species. Indian J Med Microbiol. 2001;19:193-6.
Pillsbury DM, Shelley WB, Kligman AM. Systemic
bacterial infection. In: Dermatology. Philadelphia:
WB Saunders; 1956: 499-540.
Murugan S, Vetrichevvel TP, Subramanyam S,
Subramanian A. childhood multicentric lupus
vulgaris. Indian J Dermatol. 2011;56:343-4.
Vora RV, Diwan NG, Rathod KJ. Tuberculosis
verrucosa cutis with multifocal involvement. Indian
Dermatol Online J. 2016;7:60-2.
Rao AG. Scrofuloderma associated with
tuberculosis verrucosa cutis. Indian J Dermatol
Venereol Leprol. 2014;80:76-8.
Sethuraman G, Kaur J, Nag HL, Khaitan BK,
Sharma VK, Singh MK. Symmetrical scrofuloderma
with tuberculosis verrucosa cutis. Clin Exp
Dermatol. 2006;31:452-82.
Sehgal VN, Gupta R, Bose M, Saha K. Immuno
histopathological spectrum in cutaneous
tuberculosis. Clin Exp Dermatol. 1993;18:309-13.
Narayana GP, Sandhya I. Verrucous carcinoma of
the finger: A rare site of occurrence. Indian
Dermatol Online J. 2014;5:218-9.
Kala S, Pantola C, Agarwal A. Tuberculosis
verrucosa cutis developing over a keloid: A rare
presentation. J Surg Tech Case Rep. 2010;2:75–6.
Maharaja K, Khandpur S, Ramam M, Singh MK,
Kumar U, Sharma VK. A study of the clinico-
histopathological features of erythematous tender
nodules predominantly involving the extremities.
Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol. 2014;80:235-
42.
Dwari BC, Ghosh A, Paudel R, Kishore P. A
clinicoepidemiological study of 50 cases of
cutaneous tuberculosis in a teritiary care teaching
hospital in Pokhara, Nepal. Indian J Dermatol.
2010:55:233-7.
Raghu Rama Rao G, Sridevi, Lakshmy Narayan B,
Amareswar A, Sandhya S. Directly observed
treatment short course and cutaneous tuberculosis:
Page 92
 Aruna C et al. Int J Res Dermatol. 2017 Mar;3(1):88-93

Our experience. Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol.
2011;77:330-2.
22. Ramesh V, Sen MK, Sethuraman G, D'Souza P.
Cutaneous tuberculosis due to multidrug-resistant
tubercle bacilli and difficulties in clinical diagnosis.
Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol. 2015;81:380-4.
23. Ramam M, Tejasvi T, Manchanda Y, Sharma S,
Mittal R. What is the appropriate duration of a
therapeutic trial in cutaneous tuberculosis? Further
observations. Indian J Dermatol Venereol Leprol.
2007;73:243-6.
Cite this article as: Aruna C, Senthil kumar AL,
Sridevi K, Swapna K, Ramamurthy DVSB. A
clinicoepidemiological study of cutaneous
tuberculosis in a tertiary care teaching hospital in
Andhra Pradesh, India. Int J Res Dermatol
2017;3:88-93.

International Journal of Research in Dermatology | January-March 2017 | Vol 3 | Issue 1 Page 93