Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
The Johns Hopkins University Press and Society for the History of Technology are collaborating with JSTOR
to digitize, preserve and extend access to Technology and Culture.
http://www.jstor.org
Ms. LECHTMANis professor of archaeology and ancient technology at MIT where she
holds a joint appointment in the Anthropology-Archaeology Section and the Depart-
ment of Materials Science and Engineering. She is also director of the interinstitutional
Center for Materials Research in Archaeology and Ethnology. Portions of this article
were read at the 1978 meeting of the Society for the History of Technology, in the
session on "Metals in History," organized as a symposium honoring Cyril Stanley Smith.
The present article is dedicated to Prof. Smith.
? 1984 by the Society for the History of Technology. All rights reserved.
0040-165X/84/2501-0002$01.00
1
'Jane C. Waldbaum, "The First Archaeological Appearance of Iron and the Transi-
tion to the Iron Age," in The Coming of the Age of Iron, ed. Theodore A. Wertime and
James D. Muhly (New Haven, Conn., 1980), pp. 69-98; Radomir Pleiner, "Early Iron
Metallurgy in Europe," ibid., pp. 375-415; Anthony M. Snodgrass, "Iron and Early
Metallurgy in the Mediterranean," ibid., pp. 335-374.
2David G. Mitten, personal communication; Ivan Venedikov, TrakiiskataKolesnitsa,
Bulgarian Academy of Sciences (Sofia, 1960).
depicts the first and greatest of all the Inca emperors, Pachakuti
Yupanqui (whose name meant "cataclysm"), in his role as soldier and
as conqueror (fig. 1). The weapon that Poma chose above all to denote
Pachakuti as warrior-emperor is the sling. Slings made by weaving,
braiding, and plaiting animal and vegetable fibers were among the
most important weapons used throughout Andean prehistory (fig. 2).
They are, essentially, tools of cloth. Clearly, whether an adversary
were hit by shot of stone or metal could not have made any great
difference.
For body armor, soldiers wore quilted cotton tunics or else wound
layers of cloth around their bodies. Most of the Spanish soldiers
adopted quilted armor from the Inca, regarding it as superior to
European steel breastplates, at least in the humid sierra.6 Inca soldiers
hung round shields of hard chonta palm slats and cotton on their
backs. Their heads were protected by quilted or wooden helmets.
Instead of a shield made of wood and deerskin-such as the one
Pachakuti holds in Poma's drawing-soldiers sometimes wrapped
cloth around one arm to pad it against blows.
In his other hand, Pachakuti holds the second most widely used
Andean weapon, the club. Inca clubs such as his usually had pointed,
star-shaped heads made of stone or bronze. Copper mace-heads of
similar shape had been used much earlier, however-for example,
those produced by the Mochica, a people who flourished along the
north coast of Peru from about A.D. 0 to 600 (see table 1). Again, the
effectiveness of metals as contrasted with stone in delivering a crush-
ing blow was not of great significance.
Pottery was often a medium of sculpture through which ceramic
craftsmen portrayed a wide range of activities of Mochica life. Often
soldiers are shown, with their typical heavy clubs and padded or slat-
and-cotton helmets (fig. 3). One of the most important and quite rare
scenes of Mochica battle is painted along the flaring inner lip of a
pottery vase currently in the collection of the Museum fur Volker-
kunde, Berlin (fig. 4). A group of Mochica warriors leads its captives,
who are bound with ropes tied round their necks. The soldiers carry
the typical Mochica club, but the important feature of this victory
scene lies in the nakedness of the vanquished. Among Andean
peoples, cloth was undoubtedly the item of greatest value, imbued
with ritual significance, a symbol of rank, wealth, and power. It was
not only used as a tool of war, both offensively and defensively, it also
had a magico-military significance of its own, embodying the idea of
strength and force.7 An enemy stripped of his garments was an
6Gosta Montell, Dress and Ornamentsin Ancient Peru (Goteborg, 1929).
7John V. Murra, "Cloth and Its Functions in the Inca State," AmericanAnthropologist
64 (August 1962): 710-28.
.5u( rJ
.......
.ttiy
fa
L/04 f
FIG. 1.-Pachakuti Yupanqui, ninth Inca ruler and first emperor of Tawantinsuyu, the
Inca empire, is shown as a great warrior, wearing the earspools reserved for Inca
-oyalty and wielding his sling and star-headed mace. This is one of 397 line drawings
Guaman Poma de Ayala rendered to illustrate his 1,200-page letter to Philip III of
Spain in 1613. The original manuscript is in the Royal Library of Copenhagen, Den-
mark.
enemy without retaliatory capacity. His force and his energy lay in his
clothing.
Through ethnohistoric and archaeological study we have been able
to reconstruct the panoply of weapons as they existed in the Andean
highlands during Inca domination: the sling; the star-headed mace;
the spear with tip of fire-hardened wood or of bronze; the long,
sword-shaped double-edged club made of hard chonta palm wood;
and the halberd with bronze head.8 Given the style of warfare in the
Andes among both coastal and highland peoples, with weapons that
depended on strength at impact rather than on a cutting edge, metal
weapons did not confer great advantage either to the aggressor or to
the defender.
FIG. 2.-This pre-Columbian sling of wool, from a burial located on the south Peru-
vian coast, is typical of Late Nasca culture there (ca. A.D. 400-500). Less ornamented,
utilitarian slings of identical form were used by herders to control flocks of llama and
alpaca, and as offensive weapons in times of war. A slit in the cradle helped secure the
shot-a rock or occasionally a lead ball-in place. It was the custom to carry utilitarian
slings by wrapping them around one's head. Gradually they became more elaborately
designed, and some were for purely ceremonial use; the sling illustrated here was
probably never a functional tool. (Collection of the Peabody Museum, Harvard Univer-
sity; photograph by Hillel Burger.)
8John H. Rowe, "Inca Culture at the Time of the Spanish Conquest," in Handbookof
South AmericanIndians, ed. Julian H. Steward, Bureau of American Ethnology Bulletin
143 (Washington, D.C., 1946), pp. 183-330.
E
Middle
Horizon Huar-i EmpireI
.
- 500 - T
a
cu
a
A.D. Early ud
0
- Intermediate C5
-0 Period
B.C.
1
- 500 -
Paracas-Nasca
Tradition
u
- 1000 -
Early
Horizon
Q
3r-
a
1
c
-=
-a
ued
rt
JZ
- 1500 -
Initial
Period
- 2000 -
Preceramic
Period
FIG. 3.-A Mochica ceramic vessel in the form of a soldier, with his cone-shaped
heavy club, round slatted shield, and caplike helmet. An excellent example of such a
helmet, in the Museum fur Volkerkunde in Berlin, is constructed of a spiral wooden
slatted frame, tightly wound with cotton wool. This pottery rendition of a Mochica
warrior suggests a padded chest, but we do not know how early in Andean prehistory
padded armor was used. (Collection of the British Museum, London.)
FIG. 4.-A painted scene of victors and vanquished on the flaring, inner lip of a
Mochica ceramic vessel. The Mochica soldiers, in full battle dress, lead their naked
prisoners, bound with ropes. The clubs shown here are identical with that held by the
kneeling soldier of the sculpted vessel in fig. 3. (Collection of the Museum fur Volker-
kunde, Berlin.)
FIG. 5.-A splendid earspool from the site of Loma Negra, on the far north coast of
Peru. This example dates to the period when the Mochica held sway on the north coast
(ca. A.D. 300-400). The raptorial bird, probably a harpy eagle, is fashioned from sheet
silver and mechanically attached to a round, flat plaque of hammered sheet gold. (The
bird has often been identified as a condor-I labeled it as such in Heather Lechtman,
Antonieta Erlij, and Edward J. Barry, Jr., "New Perspectives on Moche Metallurgy:
Techniques of Gilding Copper at Loma Negra, Northern Peru," AmericanAntiquity47
[January 1982]: 3-30-but this is probably an error. Donald Lathrap argues con-
vincingly that raptors such as this one, when depicted on Andean artifacts with mas-
sive tarsi, markedly recurved bills, and crests, probably represent the harpy eagle. See
Lathrap, "The Tropical Forest and the Cultural Context of Chavin," in DumbartonOaks
Conferenceon Chavin, ed. Elizabeth P. Benson [Washington, D.C., 1971], pp. 73-100.)
But the rear disk of that same plaque as well as the cylindrical spool that passes through
the ear lobe (not visible here) are made of tumbaga, a copper-gold alloy containing only
10 percent gold. The golden surfaces of the rear disk and the cylinder were achieved
through depletion gilding. (Collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Michael C.
Rockefeller Memorial Collection, Bequest of Nelson A. Rockefeller, 1979; photograph
by Thomas A. Brown.)
FiG;.6.-Elaborate Mochica nose ring of gold and plated silver from the site of Loma
Negra, on the far north coast of Peru. Originally, round gold sequins dangled from the
earspools and from the broad horizontal headband, as they still do in a few areas at the
upper extremities of the headdress. The crescent ornament that dangles from the
nose of this impressive figure is made of sheet silver, now heavily tarnished. But the
other silvered areas-at the collar, on the earspools, in the headdress-are thin films of
silver which have been deposited onto the gold through a mechanism we have not yet
determined. (Collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Michael C.
Rockefeller Memorial Collection, Bequest of Nelson A. Rockefeller, 1979.)
FIG. 7.-This is the largest golden mummy mask of Chim6 origin extant, measuring
29 inches wide by 16 inches high. Originally some of its surfaces were painted with red
cinnabar, traces of which remain, and the holes in the eyes, the ears and earspools, and
along the bottom edge of the mask indicate that other decorations-such as plaques of
copper, precious stones, or fibers-were attached when the mummy bundle was in-
terred. In spite of its lushly golden color, the mask is not made of gold but of a ternary
copper-silver-gold alloy (12 percent Cu, 49 percent Ag, 39 percent Au). Once ham-
mered to shape, the surfaces of the mask were treated chemically to enrich them in gold
through processes known as depletion gilding. (Collection of the Metropolitan Museum
of Art, New York, Michael C. Rockefeller Memorial Collection, Bequest of Nelson A.
Rockefeller, 1979.)
extremely rich graves have been excavated at the south coast site of
Paracas. The mummy bundles, not all of which have been un-
wrapped, have yielded some of the finest cloth preserved from the
prehistoric New World. Characteristic of these textiles are large,
magnificent embroidered mantles that formed part of the mummy
wrappings of high-status individuals of Paracas. A particularly fine
mantle in the collection of the Museum of Fine Arts of Boston dis-
plays, in many-colored embroidery, masked and costumed cult
figures in the form of birds, each holding a trophy head in one hand,
two heads displayed on its chest, and two on its wings (fig. 8). The Ica
River valley on the south Peruvian coast, not far from Paracas and
Nasca, has yielded pairs of miniature gold trophy heads-each only 1
or 2 centimeters in height-that probably belong to a somewhat later
Nasca version of related cult practice. They are compelling "charms";
their monumentality, despite their small size, is extraordinary (fig. 9).
*e *e *
I M: ^^^'sgip^ o y :I
FI(;. 9.-A pair of hollow gold trophy heads of Nasca style, slightly less than 2
centimeters high, from a grave in the Ica Valley on the Peruvian south coast. Each head
is composed of nineteen individual pieces of sheet gold, hammered to shape and
soldered together to produce the final form. These are metallurgical as well as aesthetic
tours de force, despite their small size. They are currently in a private collection in the
United States.
10A more detailed discussion of Mochica metallurgy as practiced at Loma Negra can
be found in Heather Lechtman, "A Pre-Columbian Technique for Electrochemical
Replacement Plating of Gold and Silver on Objects of Copper," Journal of Metals 31
(December 1979): 154-60, and in Lechtman et al.
a_ a
FIG. 10.-Seated figure from the site of Loma Negra, on the Peruvian north coast.
The three-dimensional form is constructed from many pieces of sheet copper, ham-
mered to shape and joined mechanically by a tab-and-slot system. Each preshaped piece
of copper was gilt by electrochemical replacement plating of gold onto the copper
before the figure was assembled. Although the object is almost entirely covered with
green corrosion products that formed during burial, here and there the gold surface
coating can be seen where the corrosion has worn thin. The earspools are decorated
with pieces of shell. (Collection of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Michael
C. Rockefeller Memorial Collection, Bequest of Nelson A. Rockefeller, 1979.)
plating type of process, and after mercury gilding was definitely ruled
out, we attempted to reproduce the gross characteristics and the
microstructures of these coatings using systems of electrochemical
deposition that might have been available to ancient Andean metal-
workers-that is, to deposit gold or silver onto copper without the use
of modern chemicals, such as cyanide or aqua regia for dissolving the
gold, and without the use of an external source of current.
We have been successful in dissolving gold and silver in mixtures of
corrosive minerals which were available to Andean metalworkers and
which our earlier studies had shown were frequently used by them.
The simplest and most effective method we have used for putting
gold into solution consists of heating it gently for two to five days in an
aqueous solution of equal parts of common salt (NaCI), potassium
nitrate (KN03), and potassium aluminum sulfate (KAl[S04]2-
12H20). This solution contains inter alia the same ions as are present
in aqua regia to dissolve the gold in the form of trivalent ions.
Chloroauric acid, H(AuC14) ? 3H20, would crystallize from the solu-
tion.
The resulting gold solution is highly acidic and immediately attacks
copper dipped into it, causing a layer of copper corrosion products to
form on the surface of the metal. It was thus necessary to neutralize
the gold solution before introducing the copper. Among various salts
that can be used for this purpose, we found sodium bicarbonate most
effective. The optimum conditions for the gold in solution to plate
onto the copper surface occur at a pH of 9. Copper sheet dipped into
such a solution will be uniformly coated on all its surfaces (including
the edges) with a film of gold approximately 1 micron thick after five
minutes of gentle boiling.
We found that depositing a thin film of gold onto a copper sub-
strate by simple electrochemical plating was only occasionally suf-
ficient to bond the gold permanently to the copper. A more durable
bond could be effected, however, by heating the gilt copper at a
temperature high enough to produce solid-state diffusion of the gold
and copper across their common interface. We proceeded to heat our
gilt metal at temperatures ranging from about 500? C to 800? C for
various periods of time. In the higher temperature ranges, excellent
bonding occurred after only seconds of heating.
Most of the gold that has been analyzed from objects made on the
north coast of what is today Peru, as well as native gold panned re-
cently from rivers in that area, contains silver in amounts that range
from a few percent to as much as about 15 percent by weight. We
decided, therefore, to see if we could plate copper with alloys of gold
and silver stemming from an aqueous salt solution containing various
'3Clair C. Patterson, "Native Copper, Silver, and Gold Accessible to Early Metal-
lurgists," AmericanAntiquity36 (July 1971): 286-321; A. L. Kroeber, Peruvian Archeology
in 1942 (New York, 1944).
MIT 356.
MIT 352
FS.
Au 100%
Ag 100%
FS Cu 80%
"
. ?. *j Au 100%
JC;-X ; . 'Ag 100%
:- ':I Cu 20% - 6
. u /
_:j~A Cu,
'
Au,
I
Ii
: 1
a b
Fi(;. 15.-Two sets of concentration profiles of the alloying elements within samples
removed from depletion gilt Chimu mummy masks. a, MIT 352 is the large mask
illustrated in fig. 7 from the Metropolitan Museum of Art. b, MIT 356 is a similar but
smaller mask. The curves represent relative concentrations, not absolute concentra-
tions, of copper, silver, and gold within each sample obtained by electron microanalysis
as the sample was moved under the electron beam. The beam made a continuous
traverse across the cross section, from a point near its center out through one gilt
surface. The depletion first of copper, then of silver as one approaches the surface is
evident as is the enrichment of gold at the visible surface. The relative drop in copper
and silver concentration and attendant rise in gold is particularly dramatic in the
sample from the smaller mask (fig. 15b).
// // rl
Cl&0
Co01<1 -
// / // //
i+A:Aw
Cw a *.^ cg + A'
/ / / // ., /// / / /
Cu.4A^JJA?.
'?---- / /) /
// /
Aai?i~iii;?;liAi +A%.
containing Cu, Ag, and Au, is cold woked (hammeed at oom tempeatue)
ingot, to
-ERV, YiN PE..E'~
o IL~IN G
AA
>Q(;.RUIrN "?
4AL'TIo
A QIL)IN G
''TA C 2
FIG. 16.-Stage 2, To remove silver from the surface of the metal sheet, the object is
covered completely with an aqueous paste of ferric sulfate and salt. This corrosive
material dissolves the silver from the surface binary alloy of silver and gold, leaving a
thin skin of gold in place. The object is left with a three-layered structure: an inner core
of ternary copper-silver-gold alloy, a surface zone of binary silver-gold alloy, and a
visible surface skin of gold.
swept through the Americas from Peru to Mexico and were in com-
mon use in that entire region when the Spaniards invaded Central
and South America in the 16th century. They constitute the most
significant contribution of the New World to the repertoire of alloy
systems developed among ancient societies. In the Central Andes,
copper-rich tumbagas continued to be used after the Early Inter-
mediate Period primarily to produce gold-colored objects of sheet
metal in contrast to their use in Colombia, the Isthmian area, and
Mexico, where they were employed primarily in castings.
* * *
There has been considerable discussion about why tumbaga had the
impact it had, why it spread so far and overcame the particular
metalworking traditions of the various cultures that adopted it (e.g.,
the almost diametrically opposed traditions of Peruvian and Colom-
bian artisans, the former exquisite forgers of metal, the latter superb
founders), each tailoring the concept of depletion and enrichment to
its own techniques.14 Explanations have invoked the economy of the
system-that is, one can spread one's gold much farther if objects are
made of tumbaga rather than of pure gold. But if one argues for the
economizing of gold, one has also to bear in mind that in alloys of
tumbaga all the gold inside the alloy is "wasted." Only that at the
surface is functional in the sense that it is visible. Using gold leaf or
other external plating systems would be much more economical. In
fact, metal objects were gilt with gold foil, and William Root examined
a number of objects made of copper-gold tumbaga from Cocle, in
Panama, and from Costa Rica, Guatemala, and Yucatan in which the
gilding was achieved by applying the foil to the surfaces of the tumbaga
castings!15 Clearly in these cases the gold within the alloy was present
for a purpose entirely different from any possible gilding function.
The ternary copper-silver-gold tumbagas were also used, at least in
parts of Colombia, in the manufacture of tools such as awls and axes
which were cast and selectively work hardened to rival the best Inca
products in copper-tin bronze. Thus it was a serviceable alloy for tool
14I have expressed many of the views argued here in previous publications: Heather
Lechtman, "Style in Technology-Some Early Thoughts," in Material Culture: Styles,
Organization, and Dynamics of Technology,ed. Heather Lechtman and Robert S. Merrill
(St. Paul, 1977), pp. 3-20; "Issues in Andean Metallurgy," in Pre-ColumbianMetallurgyof
South America, ed. Elizabeth P. Benson (Washington, D.C., 1979), pp. 1-40; and "The
Central Andes-Metallurgy without Iron," in Wertime and Muhly, eds. (n. 1 above),
pp. 267-334.
'5William C. Root, "Gold-Copper Alloys in Ancient America," Journal of Chemical
Education 28 (February 1951): 76-78.
production, though it was used much less frequently for making tools
than for almost every other variety of object produced by the
Colombians-nose rings, tunjos, vessels, ornaments, and so forth. Root
argued that although tumbaga might have been used because it made
casting easier, it made objects harder, and it made a small amount of
gold go farther, the most likely reason for its employ was that the
people who made and used it preferred the color of gold to that of
copper-or, to put it another way, they liked the color of tumbaga
more than that of gold or of copper.
While all these explanations certainly enter into the constellation of
tumbaga, there is another consideration that lies more in the realm of
attitudes: attitudes of artisans toward the materials they used and
attitudes of a culture area toward the nature of the technological
events themselves. We are really seeking explanations, not for the use
of the particular copper-gold alloy called tumbaga, but for the de-
velopment, geographical spread, and persistence for over two millen-
nia of systems of surface enrichment that stimulated the invention of
a variety of alloys and that were adaptive to quite disparate traditions
of handling metals.
The basis of Andean enrichment systems is the incorporation of the
essential ingredient-the gold or the silver-into the very body of the
object. The essence of the object, that which appears superficially to
be true of it, must also be inside it. In fact, the object is not that object
unless it contains within it the essential quality, even if the essence is
only minimally present. For, without the incorporation of the essence,
its visual manifestation is impossible. Although these enrichment
systems-whether of silver or gold-have been used by metalworkers
in other areas of the world, the role they played in the Andes is
unique. Almost from the earliest appearance of metallurgy there,
depletion and enrichment processes assumed a special place that per-
sisted throughout the entire course of Andean metallurgical develop-
ment and were responsible for stimulating some of its most interesting
achievements. Although ideological considerations may have had lit-
tle to do with the initial working out of these procedures, it seems
certain that the way in which Andean peoples perceived such
processes-or at least the objects that resulted from their use-had a
great deal to do with the way in which the technology emerged and
matured. Belief systems and attitudes toward materials supported the
technology and gave rise to further developments along similar lines.
On another occasion, I suggested that one of the ways to test the
hypothesis concerning incorporation of essences as an ideological
motif underlying the elaboration of Andean metal gilding tech-
nologies and its possible, more widespread occurrence behind a style
20In thinking about the underlying similarities behind aspects of Andean prehistoric
metallurgical and cloth technologies, I have benefited greatly from discussions with two
scholars of Andean cloth production, William Conklin and Edward Franquemont.
21Regina Harrison, "Modes of Discourse: The Relacion de antigiiedadesdeste reynodel
Piru by Joan de Santacruz Pachacuti Yamqui Salcamaygua," in From Oral to Written
Expression:Native Andean Chroniclesof the Early Colonial Period, ed. Rolena Adorno (Syra-
cuse, N.Y., 1982), pp. 65-99; Gerald Taylor, "Camay,camac, et camasca dans le manu-
scrit quechua de Huarochiri,"Journal de la SocietedesAmericanistes63 (1974-76): 231-44.
221 am most grateful to the Andean ethnologist Tristan Platt for
calling my attention
to the Harrison article (n. 21 above) and to the possible relevance of the concept camay
to the technology of essences. In a personal communication of June 1982, while discuss-
ing Andean metallurgy, Platt speculated that "the notion of a divine force 'animating' a
particula- object could be equivalent to a divine metal 'giving life' to an alloy."
2:IMaryW. Helms, "Precious Metals and Politics: Style and Ideology in the Inter-
mediate Area and Peru,"Journal oJ Latin AmericanLore 7 (1981): 215-37.
2-I echtman, "The Central Andes-Metallurgy without Iron" (n. 14 above).
power-that influenced those alloys. They were alloys that altered the
properties of copper not so much to make it harder or stronger but to
confer on its surfaces a different color-indeed, to transform it so that
it actually seemed to be another metal altogether, sometimes metallic
silver but primarily metallic gold.
The copper-silver and copper-gold alloy systems developed during
the Early Intermediate Period, particularly on the north Peruvian
coast, had to be malleable, hard, and capable of retaining the shape
they assumed on plastic deformation through hammering. North
coast metallurgy was sheet metal oriented, and the alloys it developed
had to fulfill the requirements of a sheet metal tradition. Both
copper-silver and copper-gold did so admirably. In addition, the
Mochica used these alloys to produce metal qualities that were obvi-
ously paramount for them, goldenness and silveriness. In this sense,
copper, through its alloys, was a vehicle for achieving those desired
qualities. It remained a handmaiden to gold and to silver, both of
which continued to be used in the manufacture of the finest objects.
The interest in surfaces and in the display of gold as the significant
visual aspect conveyed by a metal object led to the development not
only of tumbagaalloys but also of gilding copper by means of external
systems as complex as electrochemical deposition. The sophistication
of Mochica metallurgy-one is tempted to say of Mochica
chemistry-is extraordinary. It gives us insight into what "metalness,"
at least in part, may have meant to the Mochica, and certainly what
resourceful means they used for achieving such qualities.
Ultimately, these attitudes became Andean values indoctrinated by
the Inca dynasty. The gold-silver focus within Andean society was, by
Inca times, transformed into a state-monopolized industry and one to
which the state committed substantial resources of labor and energy,
especially in the extraction and processing of the metals. They re-
mained metals of "charisma," concentrated in the hands of the few
and redistributed as tokens of royal esteem.
Copper and bronze were also highly valued, but the content of that
value is more difficult to assess. The balance between gold and silver,
on the one hand, and copper and its alloys, on the other, was never an
equal balance, probably because the former always had behind them
the weight of religious and political institutions. Copper was
nevertheless the vehicle through which the real achievements in An-
dean metallurgy took place, and it was on the threshold of assuming a
much more important role in Andean life when Andean civilization
was cut down by Spanish invaders in search of the rich gold and silver
deposits of the land.