0 views

Original Title: Loss Assessment in a Low-Voltage Distribution System_Thai.pdf

Uploaded by Robert Andrew

- InterPSS Application and Development tutorial_V0.42
- Electric Systems Dynamics and Stability With Artificial Intelligence Applications
- Garis_Panduan_Electrical_System_Design_&_Installation_for_Architects_&_Engineers.pdf
- Consulting Engineering Solutions
- The Effects of Mutual Coupling and Transformer Connection Type on Frequency Response of Unbalanced Three Phases Electrical Distribution System
- Untitled
- Fort-Collins-City-of-Electric-Service-Rules-and-Regulations
- CIRED2007_0879_paper
- LECTURE 5
- Transformer Winding
- Three Phase Circuit
- Lab 2 Three-Phase Transformer (1)
- Stillwater-Utilities-Authority-Large-Power-and-Light
- 114740048 Newton Raphson Method
- hpwr
- c4-306
- AN EFFICIENT COUPLED GENETIC ALGORITHM AND LOAD FLOW ALGORITHM FOR OPTIMAL PLACEMENT OF DISTRIBUTED GENERATORS
- Reliability Analysis of Distribution Automation on Different Feeders
- Modul 10 Mesin Listrik 1.pdf
- Project 6 Final

You are on page 1of 4

Department of Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Chulalongkorn University,

Phayathai Rd., Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand, Email: raksanai.n@gmail.com

Accurate assessment of power loss in a low- in practice but depend on experience of utility experts,

voltage distribution system is still an important issue which may lead to high error calculation. Other

under present competitive environment. Even though, distribution utilities rather evaluate their power loss from

power flow analysis is still efficient to calculate power flow calculation to obtain a more accurate and

technical power loss, it requires numerous data which detailed results, even though such method requires many

may not be available for some utilities. For this reason, more parameters, some of which may not be properly

the loss assessment for a low-voltage distribution system collected. This paper proposes an alternative approach

is not easy when the demand of any customer load points for technical power loss assessment in a low-voltage

is still unclear. Therefore, distribution utilities obviously radial distribution system based on an insufficient data

require a more suitable algorithm with their available environment. The proposed approach is developed to

information to calculate their system power loss. This maintain accurate results with available data. A low-

paper proposes an alternative algorithm to crop with this voltage radial distribution system, in this work, starts

problem. The proposed approach has been tested with an from the low-voltage/ secondary side of a distribution

actual system, a low-voltage distribution system with 16 transformer and delivers electrical energy to the load

customer load points. It is found that the proposed points/customers via either single or three phase system.

method can provide satisfactory results. The technical power loss to be evaluated in this paper

includes low-voltage line power loss, which is directly

Keywords: loss assessment, power flow, node computed from an expression of I 2 R , once the power

analysis, low-voltage distribution system flow is solved.

Accurate assessment of power loss in terms of Technical power loss assessment in a low-

technical and economic aspects is still an important issue voltage radial distribution system is summarized in this

under competitive environment nowadays. It is one of section. The proposed method employs (1) node analysis

the key factors that can be used to measure system [2] to compute technical power loss, and (2) the

performance, especially for distribution systems, as they proposed algorithm to achieve loss assessment.

contribute more loss than others. Moreover, power loss

is usually one of the controlling factors when evaluating 2.1 Node analysis

alternative plans and operative strategies. It is generally accepted that power flow analysis

In general, power loss can be categorized into is a fundamental tool for power system engineers. The

two types, technical and non-technical power losses. results typically consist of voltage magnitudes and

Technical power loss results from the transportation of phases, and injected power at all buses. These

electrical energy to customers through system parameters are often further used to calculate other

components. Therefore, technical power loss is strongly related parameters, e.g. line flow and total power loss of

related to the system configuration and demand. Non- the system. Power flow analysis [3] when implemented

technical power loss, on the other hand, is due to the with a radial system is relatively simple. Even though a

problems with inadequate and also inaccurate metering considered system is not complex, there is still a

or problems with billing and collecting processes. difficulty due to the high number of load points and very

Technical power loss generally comes from two limited information on individual points. Generally, the

main causes i.e. the load power loss and no-load power power flow analysis tools used nowadays can be

loss. The load power loss consists of heating of classified into (1) balanced three-phase power flow, and

conductors, coils, and windings of transformers and (2) unbalanced three-phase power flow. The balanced

other devices when electrical current flows through three-phase power flow takes advantage of a balanced

them. The no-load power loss does not depend on system condition of a system to calculate only a single phase or

demand variation. The majority of no-load power loss is the positive sequence network, which is normally

typically associated with transformer core loss suitable for transmission systems. The unbalanced three-

emanating from the excitation current. phase power flow, on the other hand, is suitable for

Many distribution utilities simply determine primary distribution systems, where the effect of current

their technical power loss by means of some flowing in a neutral wire due to unbalancing can be

approximated formulae [1], or a fixed percentage e.g. 1% neglected, since most of primary feeders do not have a

neutral wire on their routes. For a low-voltage To understand the proposed concept, consider

distribution system, technical power loss assessment also the sample circuit illustrated in Fig 2.

can employ unbalance three phase power flow analysis.

Nonetheless, it seems to be inconvenient and takes lots

of effort and computation cost since a set of equations to

be solved is non-linear. This set of non-linear equations

is the power balance at each node written in terms of

non-linear relation between voltage and active and

reactive power. In this paper, instead of directly solving

a set of non-linear equations when modeling the load as

constant power, we apply Node analysis which is simply Fig. 2. Simple medium-voltage radial distribution system

a circuit calculation by modeling load as a current Fig. 2 depicts an example of a simple low-

source, making the calculation easy due to the linear voltage radial distribution system with 4 load points,

property. This methodology does not only increase each of which is a single-phase load, e.g. M1 is a single-

stability and speed of computation but also support a phase meter connected to phase A. Redraw the system in

three phase four-wire distribution configuration as well. Fig. 2 with its detail included as shown in Fig. 3.

This configuration type is not easily solved by a power

flow calculation. Since with the existence of a neutral j4 e j9 e

5 8

wire, branch voltage not node-to-datum voltage is of

consideration. Interestingly, this equivalent current j5 j10

j1 j7

source is not constant. This is because when solving the VA

problem with load modeled as a current source, the load e4 = 0 e1 e6

j6

points at the end of the feeder will receive the amount of VB j2

load less than the specified value due to the voltage drop. e2 j11

Thus, the current source will be adjusted in each iteration VC

until all load points receive the amount of load equal to

j3 e3 j8 e7

that specified as constant power. Once the circuit

problem has been solved, the power loss in all three

phase lines (ABC) of each feeder in the circuit and Fig. 3. Detailed circuit of the system in Fig. 2

power loss in the neutral line (N) can be computed. The

flowchart which summarizes the proposed node analysis The circuit in Fig. 3 consists of 8 nodes and 11

algorithm is depicted in Fig. 1. branches. The phase voltages (line-to-neutral) at the

infeed-bus are assumed to be at a nominal level, e.g.

VA = 220∠0° , VB = 220∠ − 120° , and VC = 220∠120° V.

Here, we pick the neutral-ground as the datum node

(node 4). There are two basic equations of node analysis

which are obtained from a network graph and

Kirchhoff’s laws.

To begin with, we define j1 , j2 ,...., jb and

v1 , v2 ,...., vb as branch current and voltage respectively,

and e1 , e2 ,...., en as node-to-datum voltage. To solve for

e1 , e2 ,...., en , we need to know the branch characterization

of the network through the node incidence matrix, A ,

and branch equations which relate the branch voltage

and branch current. From Kirchchoff’s laws we have (1)

and (2).

Aj = 0 (1)

v=A e T

(2)

The branch equations are of the form shown in (3).

j = Yv + js − Yvs (3)

Where

Y is the diagonal branch admittance matrix.

J s is the branch current source vector.

Fig. 1. Flowchart of the proposed node analysis algorithm

vs is the branch voltage source vector.

Then, we have

Yn e = is (4)

where

Yn e = AYAT , and is = AYvs − Ajs

current can be determined from (5) – (7) respectively.

e = Yn−1is (5)

v=A e T

(6)

j = Yv + js − Yvs (7)

especially for the power flow calculation. However, it is

not necessary to directly solve the power flow with load

modeled as constant power in a low-voltage radial

distribution system, which is quite complicated and

inconvenient. Therefore, we model it as a temporary

current source, a more applicable form to be used for the

node analysis, and it will be adjusted in each iteration to

yield the same result as does constant power load.

Consequently, each load current source for the next

iteration will be adjusted using the most updated branch

voltage. The equation used for updating the load current

is as shown in (8).

*

( k +1)

⎛ P + jQ ⎞

j = ⎜ i (k ) i ⎟ (8)

s (i ) ⎜ v ⎟

⎝ (i ) ⎠

We then repeat the calculation of the currents source

until the norm of branch voltages converges within an Fig. 4. The flowchart of the proposed algorithm

acceptable tolerance, and the computed total load

converges to the specified value. Then, we can simply The required customer data of each customer load points

compute technical power loss in each branch, i.e. both consists of a customer phase type, a recorded energy

phase and neutral lines, based on the expression of I 2 R demand in a consideration interval, a consideration

using the computed branch current and line impedance. interval time, and the customer classifications, e.g.

residential sector, small industrial sector, and etc.

2.2 The proposed algorithm

The proposed algorithm is designed in order to Step 2 Set Initial Values

perform a loss assessment under an available data of an To solve the power flow problem, it is

actual low-voltage distribution system. The main idea is necessary to initialize a bus voltage and a demand at

to create a time-series demand at each customer load each customer load points in a consideration interval. By

point which can be obtained from combination of a using an obtained input data (2) and (3), the time-series

studied load patterns and an available data. Afterwards, a demand of each customer load points is computed by a

time-series power loss is computed from a created time- combination of the studied load patterns which are

series demand of each customer load points by the scaled by using equal energy criteria approximation.

proposed node analysis. The proposed algorithm is

categorized into 4 steps as described below. The Step 3 Perform power flow calculation via node analysis

flowchart which summarizes the proposed algorithm is To solve power flow problem, power flow

depicted in Fig. 4. calculation via node analysis in Section 2.1 is performed.

The power loss is calculated after a successful

Step 1 Get input data convergence of an iterative node analysis.

Based on available data of an actual low-

voltage distribution system, the required data are Step 4 Determine a conductor energy loss calculation

composed of; (1) system configuration which is required In order to determine a conductor energy loss

to perform power flow calculation; (2) a studied load calculation, a successive calculation is employed for a

patterns categorized by a customer type from the 1996 time-series of the estimated load. Step 3 is repeated until

Annual Load Research Report for the Thailand Electric the end of considered time-series. Then, a conductor

System [4]; and (3) an available customer data. energy loss is calculated.

3. Numerical example 4. Conclusions

3.1 The test system This paper proposes an alternative method to

In this work, a low-voltage distribution system assess the technical power loss in an actual low-voltage

starts from the low-voltage/ secondary side of a distribution system by using actual available information.

distribution transformer and delivers electrical energy to The proposed method makes the technical energy loss

the customer load point. A considered actual low- assessment in an actual low-voltage distribution system

voltage distribution system shown in Fig. 5 is used to possible under limited data. Nevertheless, this proposed

test the proposed method. The system consists of 16 method cannot provide accurate results without good

customer load points and is supplied by a 22kV/380V, quality and precise available input data. Moreover, the

250 kVA distribution transformer. accuracy of the results depends on quality of the studied

load patterns. According to our simulation it is found

that the proposed method can provide satisfactory

7 8

65 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

32

10

51 20 20 25 20 20 20

results.

18

17

35

16

References

[1] Nazarko, J., Styczynski, Z., Poplawski, M, “The

19

95 sq. mm.

35

53

1 fuzzy approach to energy losses calculations in low

50 sq.mm.

45

2

voltage distribution networks,” IEEE Power

30 Engineering Society Winter Meeting 2000, 23 – 27

3

Jan. 2000, vol.4, pp. 2763 – 2768.

[2] Charles A. Desoer, Ernest S. Kuh, Basic Circuit

30

30

Theory, International edition, Mc-Graw Hill, 1969.

[3] Hadi Saadat, Power System Analysis, 2nd Edition,

5

60

Fig. 5. An actual low-voltage distribution system [4] “the 1996 Annual Load Research Report for the

Thailand Electric System,” Energy Policy and

3.2 Simulation results Planning Office Ministry of Energy Royal Thai

To determine technical energy loss, we apply Government, 1997.

the proposed methodology to calculate a technical

energy loss of the considered system. By using the

simulation time interval from 4 August 2007 to 2

September 2007, the simulation result is depicted in

Table 1. As a result, percentage of energy loss portion

referred to an infeed-energy properly reflects a realistic

loss portion of an actual low-voltage distribution system.

Furthermore, it can be seen that loss in the neutral line

(N) cannot be neglected in loss assessment for a low-

voltage distribution system.

!=========================================================!

! Simulation Result !

! (Rec. = recorded, Cal. = calculated) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! In-feed Energy !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! INFEED total :: 20159.695 kWhr (Rec.) !

INFEED total :: 19689.373 kWhr (Cal.) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! Load Energy !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! LOAD in A-phase :: 8086.233 kWhr (Rec. & Cal.) !

! LOAD in B-phase :: 7486.530 kWhr (Rec. & Cal.) !

! LOAD in C-phase :: 3790.927 kWhr (Rec. & Cal.) !

! LOAD total :: 19363.690 kWhr (Rec. & Cal.) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! Recorded Total Loss Energy (Technical & Non-Technical Loss) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! LOSS total :: 796.005 kWhr (Rec.)(3.95%) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! Conductor Loss Energy (Technical Loss) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! LOSS in A-phase :: 110.781 kWhr (Cal.) !

! LOSS in B-phase :: 114.469 kWhr (Cal.) !

! LOSS in C-phase :: 20.775 kWhr (Cal.) !

! LOSS in N-phase :: 79.657 kWhr (Cal.) !

! LOSS total :: 325.682 kWhr (Cal.)(1.62%) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! Non-Technical Loss Energy (Non-Technical Loss) !

!---------------------------------------------------------!

! LOSS total :: 470.322 kWhr (Rec.)(2.33%) !

!=========================================================!

- InterPSS Application and Development tutorial_V0.42Uploaded byHuang Qiuhua
- Electric Systems Dynamics and Stability With Artificial Intelligence ApplicationsUploaded bydigiloko
- Garis_Panduan_Electrical_System_Design_&_Installation_for_Architects_&_Engineers.pdfUploaded bySemifallen
- Consulting Engineering SolutionsUploaded byRamesh Ananthanarayanan
- The Effects of Mutual Coupling and Transformer Connection Type on Frequency Response of Unbalanced Three Phases Electrical Distribution SystemUploaded byInternational Journal for Scientific Research and Development - IJSRD
- Fort-Collins-City-of-Electric-Service-Rules-and-RegulationsUploaded byGenability
- CIRED2007_0879_paperUploaded byrajeshbudhiraja
- Three Phase CircuitUploaded byHIREN
- LECTURE 5Uploaded bySanaAfridi
- UntitledUploaded byGenability
- Lab 2 Three-Phase Transformer (1)Uploaded byJamr
- hpwrUploaded byhoudamahdi
- Transformer WindingUploaded byrenjithas2005
- Stillwater-Utilities-Authority-Large-Power-and-LightUploaded byGenability
- c4-306Uploaded byboopelectra
- AN EFFICIENT COUPLED GENETIC ALGORITHM AND LOAD FLOW ALGORITHM FOR OPTIMAL PLACEMENT OF DISTRIBUTED GENERATORSUploaded byIJIERT-International Journal of Innovations in Engineering Research and Technology
- 114740048 Newton Raphson MethodUploaded byJoe Rante
- Reliability Analysis of Distribution Automation on Different FeedersUploaded byBONFRING
- Modul 10 Mesin Listrik 1.pdfUploaded byaswardi
- Project 6 FinalUploaded byArunYellajosula
- Foreign voltages and frequency.pdfUploaded byFiko007
- psse_system_test_for_voltage_collapse_analysis.pdfUploaded byDaniel Callupe
- 10.1109@erect.2015.7498992.pdfUploaded bysreddy4svu
- Distribution System1Uploaded byThurya Sathsara Nishakara Owitipana
- 1030 Robert Hertling JrUploaded byMuhammad Saulat Ali
- Jobswire.com Resume of DENICIOCARTERUploaded byapi-24343452
- IFAC2002 ElectricoUploaded bypadmajasiva
- Definitions About Three Phase VoltagesUploaded byMweneSafari Kevin
- UntitledUploaded byapi-77129917
- Nhom8 01216164Uploaded byNguyen Thanh Sang

- Unit 6Uploaded bysameerpatel15770
- Uni Mig Workshop SeriesUploaded byDavid Turner
- Top Plant_ Langage Combined Cycle Power - UKUploaded byEttore Mazzei
- India Solar-Investment case.pdfUploaded bymurthyeranki
- JSA ElectricalToolsElectricityUploaded byCristina Rican
- surge currentUploaded bySrijanTripathi
- meter_mounting_equipment.pdfUploaded byramkrishna
- LM3886 ChipAmp GuideUploaded byeleceng1979
- Socomech Ups 15 to 80 KvaUploaded byZIPDASH
- Goodman Furnace Troubleshooting Codes 6 BlinksUploaded byAlan
- fm2Uploaded byAnonymous dqbb02DUh
- Frontier-Utilities-Inc-Winter-11-Special-Online---IntroUploaded byGenability
- Introduction and ConclusionUploaded byMuhammad Amir
- Ki 3418621868Uploaded byAnonymous 7VPPkWS8O
- FILTER INDUCTOR DESIGNUploaded byravindragudi
- OLYMPAIN-R450 & R448 AVR MANUALL.pdfUploaded bySayed Younis Sadaat
- HVSI804S Wdg 83Uploaded bystefan998877
- Design of Hybrid Power Generation Using Solar Tracking Pv Module and Wind Turbine-4Uploaded byIAEME Publication
- tcscUploaded byWilliam Javier
- Hv Ps Upgrade Tlxr 2Uploaded byGianny Marcos Fonseca Aires
- Main Sub -6steps 1920karUploaded byYong Ee Vonn
- 2012-10-11 Project Report VendaNova II (1)Uploaded bytanujaayer
- Amana Btm Mnt Frzr Tech Sheet 16023133Uploaded byEn Vy
- Specs 2Uploaded bycushan.sharma2557
- Telecom Shelter AC Controller A5-G312PRUploaded byAbdellah Samadi
- Ndq250f7 Sharp Solar Panel SpecUploaded byIkhsanul Hakim
- JAA-APTL-Book-04-Chapter-5-Engine-Ignition.pdfUploaded byCedrick Bryll Castulo Sison
- VFD-convertidor chino.pdfUploaded byvaroniberico
- Schneider_Select_Product_Catalog_TechnicalUploaded bydom007thy
- INSTRUCTION of electrical equipmentUploaded bySushil Kumar