Giant Skeletons! 1
The most important fact about the Engelbert site near Nichols, NY, is that it
SRAC Needs Your Help 4 was repeatedly used as a cemetery by the ancestors of the Iroquois for 600
6
years from 950 A.D. to 1550 A.D.
SRAC at Open Forest
7
The second most important fact about this key site is that it’s gone...
SRAC at Sayre House
7 (Continued on page 4)
Coming Events
Interactive Display 9
12
Membership Form G i a n t Ske l e to n s ! Fa c t o r Fi c t i o n ? by Deb Twigg
Our Vision In the late 1800's workers digging trenches for water lines on Main Street in Ath-
The Susquehanna River Ar-
chaeological Center of Native ens PA began uncovering skeletons of an ancient American Indian culture. The
Indian Studies (S.R.A.C.) is people that were present on that
dedicated to education, re-
day referred to them as giants.
search and preservation of the
Native American archaeologi- In fact, it soon became national
cal, cultural and historical news!
assets of the Twin Tier Re-
gion of Northeastern PA and
Southern NY.
Two hundred years later, the
story is seen more as myth than
Our Mission
To proactively seek out, pro- fact. However, there are enough
cure and protect all histori- historical accounts, from unre-
cally and culturally signifi-
lated sources, of these huge
cant assets relative to Native
American History within the people that I find it hard to be-
Twin Tier Region and supply lieve that "larger than normal"
educational and research
capabilities for the public.
humans did not live in our re-
gion a very long time ago.
Our Objectives and Purpose
S.R.A.C. is dedicated to edu-
cation, research and preserva- A good place to start this con-
tion of the region's Native versation is to define the per-
American archaeological,
cultural and historical assets
ception of "normal” in terms of human size. You see, the average height of Euro-
for the communities within peans, at the time of local contact, was between 4’0” – 5’3” tall. One only needs
the Twin Tier Region. to go an antique shop and look at the antique clothing to know that average size
has been steadily increasing for generations. This then, is one factor we would
(Continued on page 2)
TheBecome a River
Susquehanna member of SRAC
Archaeological Center of today! See
Native Indian back
Studies page for more
~ www.SRACenter.org information.
~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 2 Volume 3, Issue 1
G i a n t S ke l e t o n s ! Fa c t o r Fi c t i o n ?
(Continued from page 1)
have to keep in mind when reference to size is made in any given report.
“The owner like his
Also - the reported size of remains that were found must be directly related to the
forebears, long refused perception of the person who found them. If it were a professional, having seen
to examine the grave skeletal remains before, the comparison would be to the average or normal size of
at the center of the plot previous findings. If it were someone working to dig a foundation or roadway,
but at last had they might compare the size of the remains to people they are used to seeing in
consented to celebrate their daily life.
the formal opening of
the Historical Museum, For these reasons, "normal" is constantly changing and must be understood to be
a relative term. The one thing that has not changed is the length of a foot or an
and June 27th, 1895,
inch, and this too should be considered. There are other variables, such as the
the work was begun. ”
manner in which the bones are laid out that could affect the report of height of a
full skeleton. With that in mind, let's take a look at the following historical quotes
from two different sites and time periods:
"The owner like his forebears, long refused to examine the grave at the center of
the plot but at last had consented to celebrate the formal opening of the Historical
Museum, and June 27th, 1895, the work was begun. The circle of stones proved
to be over a sepulchre about 3 to 5 feet, with an upright stone at each corner, ap-
parently as a marker, for, of course this would have been well above the surface
originally...
Andaste pot found in the
Murray Garden, Athens, PA
in 1883 The writer, hoping to save the pottery, assisted Messrs. Murray and Ercanbrack
in the excavation. Finally, two large flat stones, full of devonian fossils, proved to
(Continued on page 3)
SRAC is currently seeking a person to fill the position of Secretary for our Board of
Directors. Please contact Deb Twigg at 607-727-3111 if you are interested.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
The Region’s Archaeological, Cultural and Historical Resource Page 3
G i a n t S ke l e t o n s ! Fa c t o r Fi c t i o n ?
(Continued from page 2)
(Continued on page 8)
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 4 Volume 3, Issue 1
When construction started on Route 17 through the Southern Tier of New York in the late 1960’s, exca-
vation equipment started removing fill from a 20-acre gravel knoll east of the village of Nichols. As
heavy equipment took out fill, prehistoric human burials emerged on the knoll. By
the time a desperate salvage excavation began to recover as much of the prehistoric
site as possible, nearly two-thirds of the site was gone. SUNY-Binghamton, mem- “As heavy
bers of the Triple Cities Chapter of the NYS Archaeological Association, members equipment took out
of the Tioga Historical Society, high school students, and local residents worked fill, prehistoric
feverishly to excavate features and recover the prehistoric evidence over the sum- human burials
mers of 1967 and 1968. Often they worked only feet away from the contractor’s emerged on the
heavy equipment, and many features could only be marked on site maps. knoll.”
When the crews finally wrapped up, they had mapped or excavated over 1200 fea-
tures—firepits, storage pits, postmolds, and burials. Excavators recovered or
mapped over 140 burials of the Late Woodland residents of the Susquehanna Valley. Based on the arti-
facts interred in the graves, most of the burials dated to the Late Owasco, Protohistoric and Early Con-
tact periods. These estimates are based on pottery styles, pottery technology, and copper artifacts in a
few burials which suggest the presence of European trade goods. Other features—hearths or storage
pits—contained artifacts from the Late Archaic period around 4000 years ago.
Meanwhile, the gravel knoll was nearly completely destroyed, save for an area which contained 19th cen-
tury Euro-American graves. But the amount of data recovered in those two hasty field seasons has con-
tinued to provide study material for researchers for 40 years.
(Continued on page 5)
S R A C N e e d s Yo u r H e l p !
SRAC needs to find a location for our Learning Center. With a Learning Center, we can provide work/
study space, as well as museum space for the public. Please help us to preserve our artifacts and other
evidences that represent thousands of years of our local Native Indian history. When you donate to
SRAC, you can consider your contribution as a gift to generations to come. Donations come in many
forms.
Cash Donations - SRAC is a non-profit organization, and this means that appropriate donations to
SRAC are tax deductible! Monetary donations can be sent to:
Donate a Local Collection - Dick Cowles was the first collector to donate his entire collection (rare
books and artifacts) to SRAC! Since that time, the Safford family has donated a sizeable collection of
Native Indian artifacts as well. When you donate a collection, you will have it saved as “your collec-
tion” for generations to come, as well as have a tax deduction opportunity.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 5 Volume 3, Issue 1
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 6 Volume 3, Issue 1
S R AC at 8 t h A n nu a l O p e n Fo re s t E ve n t
On March 3rd, SRAC members participated in the 8th annual
Saterlee Creek Environmental Center Open Forest. SRAC dis-
played many Native American artifacts. Although muddy, atten-
dance was good with people taking advantage of the many out-
door activities. Some of the activities included guided trail tours
by local Boy Scouts, Atlatl demonstrations, and maple syrup
processing.
Bernice donated his collection to the Cady Library in Nichols shortly before her death.
When the Triple Cities Chapter was asked to catalogue the collection in 2003, we were intrigued by its
association with the well-known cemetery site, where some of our members had assisted in the salvage
excavations 40 years ago. Before seeing the collection, we expected it to include more of the shell-
tempered and grit-tempered pottery found on the knoll, as well as the triangular Levanna and Madison
points typical of the Owasco and Iroquois periods. We thought that it might provide clues to an occupa-
tion site associated with the ceremonial center on the knoll.
To our surprise, that’s not what we found. Instead, the bulk of the collection consisted of Late Archaic
points—Lamoka, Snook Kill, and Vestal types—dating to 1500-2000 B.C. and Terminal Archaic
points—Susquehanna Broadspear and Orient Fishtail types—dating to 500-1500 B.C. There were very
few pottery fragments in the collection, which is not so surprising. Pottery is often ignored by casual ar-
tifact collectors, and the point types listed above predate the appearance of pottery in our area.
More surprising was the nearly total absence of the triangular points usually found in Owasco and Iro-
quois sites. Only two points might have been fragmentary Levanna points. We aren’t sure what that
means. Is this an example of collector bias? Has part of the collection gone elsewhere? (Family mem-
bers don’t recall the collection being broken up.) Or does it have archaeological significance? We just
don’t know at this point.
Study of the material from the Engelbert cemetery site continues. One of the most detailed studies will
soon be published as a PhD dissertation at Binghamton University. And in a fitting coda to the study of
the Engelbert family collection, John Engelbert was inducted as an Eagle Scout in 2006. His Eagle Scout
project? Setting up a permanent display of his great-grandfather’s collection in the Cady Library.
**See Coming Events on the next page for an upcoming presentation on the Englebert Site!
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 7 Volume 3, Issue 1
stand cultural identity. She has done a great deal of work on the findings from ~ Mail orders with
the Englebert Site in Nichols, NY. The Andastes Chapter will meet the third payment to SRAC,
PO Box 12, Sayre,
Monday of each month at 7 p.m. at the Bradford County library. The public is PA 18840
welcome and there is no charge. Members often bring new archaeological finds
to share with the group. For more information, call Ted Keir at 570-888-2718.
• April 22, 2007 Sayre Historical Society - “World War II History Fair ,
“Patterson Auditorium on the Guthrie Campus A highlight of the event will
be the afternoon showing of the video "When the Sky Rained Heroes" by John
'Bud' McCabe of Sayre. The Sayre Historical Society is inviting anyone who has
a collection or story about World War II to share to come to this event to help
preserve local memories of the Valley and Valley residents during the War
ur up-
years. Tables will be available for displays upon request. The event will begin at about yo
kno w e’d be
12:20 p.m. and run through 4:40 p.m. Plan on joining the Sayre Historical Soci- Let us events. W ere.
g h
comin post them
ety for a very unique look at our past. *To reserve a table for display please call y t o
happ
888-2557 or 882-8221 and leave a message.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 8 Volume 3, Issue 1
G i a n t S ke l e t o n s ! Fa c t o r Fi c t i o n ?
The Voyages of CAPTAIN JOHN SMITH (of Jamestown, Va.) during the
Years 1607-9
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
The Region’s Archaeological, Cultural and Historical Resource Page 9
The artifacts that will be used in the exhibits are from a donation from the Bernard Safford family in Wav-
erly, NY. When the family donated this collection to SRAC last year, they said that Bernie wanted his
collection to be used to educate local children. As a result, we see this as a great opportunity to use his
collection in these exhibits, making them available to our lo-
cal schools. We’re looking forward to sharing our history
with other school children in the future.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 10 Volume 3, Issue 1
G i a n t S ke l e t o n s ! Fa c t o r Fi c t i o n ?
(Continued from page 8)
cocks combe . . . The calfe of whose leg was ¾ of a yard around and all the rest of his limbes so answer-
able to that proportion that he seemed the goodliest man we ever be-
held!"
The story continues that after John Smith's experience described above
took place, he rushed back down the Susquehanna to the Chesapeake
Bay for fear of these huge warriors. As a result, when he had a map
drawn of his travels, he left only a short distance of his travels on his
map of the Susquehanna River and placed a giant Susquehannock at
the top, casting a shadow over everything else above the point that
Captain Smith had reached.
Murray's theory that the Susquehannocks were indeed the giants that
were uncovered in our region was later found to be in agreement with
other professionals such as A.B. Skinner of the American Indian Mu-
seum and W.K. Moorehead of the Andover Academy who were com-
missioned to research Native Indian sites along the Susquehanna River
in 1916.
"On reaching the vicinity of Athens, Pennsylvania, the expedition spent twenty days studying that region
lying between the mouth of the Chemung and Spanish Hill, or Carantouan, some ten miles up stream.
Spanish Hill was an Andaste fortified village, visited by Stephen Brule in 16I5, when he went on the mis-
sion for Champlain, in which he sought to obtain assistance in the war which the French were making
upon the Onondaga fort. It was the first large Andaste settlement on the river. Reinforced by local collec-
tors and Boy Scouts, the expedition searched this interesting region in the vicinity of Fort Sullivan faith-
fully, and found a cemetery (The Murray Farm) containing fifty nine skeletons, presumably Andaste."
Today, the idea that the larger than life Andastes/Susquehannocks lived in our area is accepted, and only
the debate concerning the time period that they left remains. To date, I can find only one scientific report
that delves into the matter of whether or not these people actually were as big as the accounts claim:
"When John Smith first contacted a group of Susquehannock in 1608 he described these people as
"gyant-like." Direct confirmation of this observation can now be provided through studies of the long
bones of a population which was part of the Susquehannock "confederacy." Recent excavations at a Sus-
(Continued on page 11)
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
The Region’s Archaeological, Cultural and Historical Resource Page 11
G i a n t S ke l e t o n s ! Fa c t o r Fi c t i o n ?
(Continued from page 10)
quehannock site on the South Branch of the Potomac River in Hampshire County, West Virginia, revealed
portions of a palisaded village and associated features dating from the middle of the 16th century. This
remnant of a flood-destroyed site yielded 13 relatively intact burials. Surface collection of skeletal mate-
rial immediately downstream of the site after the flood provided long bones from at least 18 other adults.
Calculation of the stature of the individuals represented in this sample and comparisons with the other Na-
tive American populations of this period confirm John Smith's observations…"
Dr. Becker goes on to state that although the males were consistently taller than any other native (or colo-
nial) population in the entire northeast (avg. height 5' 10") the women were not taller than regional aver-
ages.
My unprofessional opinion is that locally, however we may have been too quick to jump to the conclusion
that all of these giant skeletons, found so long ago, were from the Andaste/Susquehannock brood. While
these people were indeed said to be giants by European standards, were they the only abnormally tall people
to have lived in this region? I am not sure we know that answer for sure.
We know that our area is located along an old Indian path referred to as the "Forbidden Trail." We also
know that Tioga Point, Spanish Hill, and this region are natural strategic locations in the doorway to the
south, via the Susquehanna River. No matter the date, we know that this area was used and traversed by the
many cultures that came and went over the centuries. Since we find artifacts from many cultures in our re-
gion, would it be a stretch to ask whether or not we would have a diverse group of people buried here as
well?
I believe that significant questions still remain. When I queried a group of professional scientists as to
whether or not the sepulchral burial sites described in the beginning of this article were common burial
practices of the Andaste/Susquehannocks, the answers were negative. Instead they felt the sepulchers
seemed to be more likely the remnants of an earlier culture.
Until further research can be done, the story of the giant skeletons in our region will continue to spur debate
and imaginations. This research project, like so many others are needed if we are ever to understand the
early prehistory of our region. I hope that you can see the importance of our mission at SRAC. When you
support the Susquehanna River Archaeological Center (SRAC) you are supporting the continuation of re-
search and educational projects such as this. Please consider joining SRAC today!
*SRAC does not support unprofessional excavations of any burial site, and this article is merely a report of
historical data for the sake of research.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
SRAC
PO Box 12
Sayre, PA 18840
- cut here - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Type Annual Fee Benefits
Quarterly newsletter, discount on copies and photos (up to a set limit), and
Student $10.00
online database collection access
Senior (65 and Quarterly newsletter, discount on copies and photos (up to a set limit), and
$10.00
over) online database collection access
Quarterly newsletter, discount on copies and photos (up to a set limit), and
Family $20.00
online database collection access
Quarterly newsletter, discount on copies and photos (up to a set limit), and
Individual $20.00
online database collection access
Research Part- Quarterly newsletter, free copies (up to a set limit), discount on photos (up to a
$100.00
ner (Ind.) set limit), and online database collection access
Corporate or
$250.00 Quarterly newsletter, discount on copies and photos (up to a set limit)
Group
$500.00 Lifetime membership and quarterly newsletters, discount on copies and photos
Benefactor
One Time (up to a set limit) and online database collection access
Name: Address:
Email:
Phone:
Become a member of SRAC!
1. Please check the type of membership you wish to apply for.
2. Fill out the information above.
3. Submit this form with a check for the appropriate amount to: SRAC, PO Box 12, Sayre 18840
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org