The Susquehanna
BecomeRiver Archaeological
a member of Center
SRACof today!
Native Indian
See Studies
back ~ www.SRACenter.org
page for more ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
information.
Page 2 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 3 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 4 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The vague and limited histories that came with the two
items in Toledo do not, in and of themselves, provide con-
clusive evidence for the modern production of these
pieces. Analysis of component elements in the designs,
form, and even of the techniques of manufacture for a se-
ries of similar artifacts of known provenance would provide Incised, Winged Bannerstone From the Ted Keir Collection On
some basic information against which these data might be Display at the SRAC Exhibit Hall
compared. What is remarkable is that during the 43 years
since these two items were first described in print few the western end of Lake Erie, probably copying the forms
studies have been undertaken to better understand or from objects in known collections.
analyze these categories of artifacts. One half of a banner-
stone was recovered ca. 20 years ago during excavations Only artifacts excavated from controlled situations can be
at Pennsbury Manor at the eastern margin of Pennsyl- sufficiently well documented to provide a wealth of ar-
vania (36 Bu 19; see Becker 1988). This is one of the few chaeological information. Reliable surface collections,
examples for which we have a mineralogical analysis, from specific and well documented locations, provide a
demonstrating that the steatite (talc) from which it was limited but significant amount of important information.
made may have derived from one of the many outcrop- Entire surface collections that may be associated with an
pings of this mineral that are exposed in southeastern excavation, as well as those from a documented and re-
Pennsylvania and northern Delaware (Becker 1988: Fig. corded site that has not been excavated, are of consider-
1). Steatite exposures are well known from Washington, able value in reconstructing the vanishing past. Many of
DC up into eastern Canada and were extensively utilized these surface collections do not represent an ancient na-
by native peoples during many periods of prehistory, as tive village, but reveal the location of a favored encamp-
well as by European immigrants. I suspect that half of a ment area that was used perhaps once or twice each year,
bannerstone of similar shape, found on Spuyten Duyvil and often for 15,000 years or more! The loss or discard of
(Continued on page 5)
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 5 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
(Continued from page 4) ticularly supportive of the efforts being made by the staff at
the SRAC to gather and preserve collections that reflect
only one or two stone tools each year can produce fantas- the diligence of individuals in a local region to gather up
tic numbers of artifacts at a site that has no associated the evidence of our rich Native American heritage. We are
sub-surface features (shelters, caches, burials). Yet these at a point in time when these collections are subject to
surface finds can be very revealing of the history of such a sale and division. Every effort made to preserve and docu-
site. Nothing can replace the information provided by the ment these collections contributes to our understanding of
recovery of even one or more artifacts from a context that our own heritage.
is carefully recorded, whether it be a knoll on which there
were encampments each year or a location where a settle- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
ment once existed. Observing artifacts from a surface col-
lection or from the contexts of burials, caches, or other This paper provides an updated version of one of my first
“social” situations such as trash pits provides impressive publications (Becker 1965), intended here for a well in-
insight into the meanings that these items may have had formed general audience. Readers interested in a full bibli-
for the people who made and used them. ography may write or e-mail me for a copy. Sincere thanks
are due to Jonathan King (Museum of Mankind, London)
How many of the “intact” artifacts that appear in private and to Prof. Richard Swain (Director, Francis Harvey
collections are forgeries is difficult to determine. Farmers Green Library) and his entire staff, and to Jeannie Carpen-
and other surface-collectors who gathered native artifacts ter for her important contributions. My sincere thanks also
on their own property, or from the lands of friends and are due to the members of the Congress of The United
neighbors, are far less likely to include deliberate fakes. States of America for their support of tax laws that stimu-
For collectors who bought and sold artifacts the numbers late and encourage research in this and other areas of
of fakes entering their collections was probably propor- enquiry. The ideas and interpretations presented here are,
tional to the amounts they were willing to spend. I am par- of course, solely my own responsibility.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 6 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
COMING EVENTS
History's Mysteries - Every First Tuesday of the Month! Presentations TBA
Mineralogy - Marty Borko - February still working in this one
SRAC Archaeology Border Meeting w/ NYS TriCities and PA Andaste Chapters of Archaeology - will occur bimonthly at
SRAC and are open to the public and FREE!!!
February 16th from 6:30 - 7:30, Deb Twigg will present a little known
yet amazing site, "The Murray Garden." The actual garden of Louise
Welles Murray, this site actually is known for being the place where a
"Great Indian Chief" was unburied and on display in the Tioga Point
Museum for many years. It is also known to be the site where the
strange shell-tempered pottery with faces were uncovered that to this
day have never been found anywhere else in the world. This along
with other strange burial practices and unique finds will keep the au-
dience amazed at this local site that has been long forgotten by
many.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 7 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 8 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Vatican 1831 Wampum Belt: A Day of Study at the Vatican Museums, 9 December 2008
BY MARSHALL JOSEPH BECKER, PH D,
lections under her care. During this me to G. Pizzorusso in Rome. By
review two wampum belts were identi- chance, Pizzorusso, who specializes in
fied. One of these bands had been native peoples who came to Rome,
seen in Rome by David Bushnell had just found the documents relating
nearly a century earlier, and published to the fabrication of this wampum band
twice in his works. Bushnell’s studies in 1831 as a gift to Pope Gregory XVI.
had led me, as early as 1975, to look
At that same time a group of Mi’kmaq
for the elaborate band that he illus-
in Canada were falsely claiming in
trated. Twenty five years later three
court that this wampum band, known
disparate sets of activities converged
only from the Bushnell illustrations,
to reveal a great deal about this puz-
was an early treaty belt between their
zling wampum band. The first set was
people and the Vatican. This false tes-
the actual re-discovery (Becker 1999)
timony was withdrawn when the real
and publication (Becker 2001) of what
history of the belt was revealed (see
we now identify as the VATICAN 1831
Becker 2006). Despite withdrawal of
wampum band. The other two activi-
his testimony, the Mi’kmaq who made
ties are as different as night and day.
the court claim continued to make pub-
When I identified the VATICAN 1831 lic claims regarding this band, which
band, I thought that this elaborate ex- was in no way related to the Mi’kmaq.
ample of an “ecclesiastical wampum In fact, the Mi’kmaq never used wam-
band” must be documented some- pum bands in any context before 1930.
where in the vast Vatican archives. All
In December the audience listened
the known ecclesiastical bands, identi-
politely to all these presentations re-
fied by the presence of a Latin cross
garding the history and origins of this
at the center, were made by mission-
In 2008, the 400th anniversary of the large wampum band. But, who were
aries at convert communities to be sent
founding of Quebec, the province they to believe – a bunch of academics
to another convert group or to religious
sponsored a wide range of activities at in their suits and ties or a genuine na-
centers in Europe. Two of the finest
home and abroad. As part of this cele- tive fabulist, with his long braid in the
examples are now at Chartres Cathe-
bration the Mi’kmac claimant was modern “Indian” fashion and his mod-
dral in France. I contacted Prof. Luca
treated to a visit to the Vatican to see ern beaded artifacts made of commer-
Codignola in Genoa, an expert on na-
the wampum band that he continues to cially tanned skins?
tive peoples in Canada, who directed
allege (but not in court) was part of his
“cultural heritage.” Dr. Console used
the visit to organize a formal “Day of
Study” at the Vatican, to which schol-
ars and museum people from all over
Italy could assemble. During the day
scholars from as far away as Poland
met to hear about the history of this
impressive wampum band, which was
the last example made by natives for
any traditional purpose. Professors
Luca Codignola, M. J. Becker, and oth-
ers presented formal papers, while a
Mi’kmaq colleague offered a story
completely unrelated to any of the evi-
dence, but claiming that he has special
knowledge of these things, possibly
through his grandmother.
This “Day of Study” began in 1999
when, as part of a program of research
focusing on Native American objects
held in the Vatican Museums, Ester Replica Wampum Belt in Reversed Colors
Console took me on a tour of the col-
(Continued on page 9)
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 9 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Vatican 1831 Wampum Belt: A Day of Study at the Vatican Museums Cont.
*Photos courtesy of Dr. Bartosz Hlebowicz of underlining was lost on the non-literate people who con-
structed the band. They faithfully reproduced the image in
*References available on request.
wampum beads, where, if the text is read upside down, the
~ SIDEBAR ~ underlining appears to represent accents. The inability of the
natives to “read” the writing or to decode the convention of
The impressive VATICAN 1831 wampum belt, commis- “underlining” points out why this word was included on the
sioned by priests of the Sulpician Order as a gift to Pope
“Christian” (European) side of the cross. Literacy, as repre-
Gregory XVI, has a Latin cross at the center that clearly sented by this “text,” was then part of the European world,
identifies it as an ecclesiastical band. One half of this long where it remained for centuries.
band bears symbols relating to the Catholic Church. These
include a figure of a church as well as the Catholic symbol
representing the keys to St. Peter’s. On the other side of the
cross, among the symbols representing native culture, are a
bow and arrow and other elements. In recent years the brief
text that appears next to the church has been interpreted by
various Native American groups as representing their own
language or a treaty made by their ancestors with the Vati-
can. Not one of these modern claimant groups was involved
with the peoples at the Lake of the Two Mountains (Oka)
where the belt was made.
Although David Bushnell had published excellent illustrations
of this band a century ago, no one could “read” the apparent
“text” on the band until recently. It reads “Whọmpọm”. The
word, like the symbol of the keys of St. Peter’s, is inverted!
The priests who commissioned the belt provided drawings of
the images they wished to include on the band. They even
underlined the word “Whompom” with a series of four short Wonderful shot by Dr. Bartosz Hlebowicz of the word
dashes to indicate which way was “up.” But the convention “WHOMPOM” on the actual belt. (Note: Text above is intended to
illustrate the word on the belt below.)
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 10 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
S R AC W E L C O M E S N E W B OA R D M E M B E R !
SRAC would like to welcome Mark Madill to
the SRAC board. Mark is President of the
Andaste Chapter of Pennsylvania
Archaeology as well as a board member for
the Wyalusing Valley Museum in
Wyalusing, PA. Mark has also been On a cell phone?
involved in many historical projects
concerning Bradford County, PA and has wwwSRACenter.org/Mobile
taken part in archaeological digs in this
region as well.
SRAC is honored to have Mark accept the
position with SRAC, and look forward to his
help in fulfilling our mission in the future.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 11 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
Teachers - Would you like to schedule a class trip to our Center? We are happy to facilitate your class trip to our
Center for free throughout the school year! All we ask is that you work with us to schedule this in advance.
Please contact us to learn more! Call Deb Twigg at 607-727-3111 or email us at info@sracenter.org.
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 12 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
To date we have a huge gift shop, lecture hall, and during our DrumBeats event this year, we unveiled our Exhibit Hall
filled with thousands of artifacts that will rotate constantly as well as a huge mural funded by the DEC Art of the South-
ern Finger Lakes grant.
The event began with our membership meeting/luncheon, followed by a presentation by Dr. Dee Wymer of Bloomsburg
University called "Flowers for the Dead.” Then we had authentic Native American dance and songs presented by the
"Buffalo Creek Dancers" who were from the Seneca Nation of New York. Lastly, we unveiled our wonderful mural after a
dedication was made by Dick Cowles. Several hundred attended the event.
We hope you enjoy a gallery of images from the event. If you had the chance to
attend, I hope that it brings you the fond memories that it brings to those of us at
SRAC. Thank you to all the folks that sent photos to make this possible!
Expert Presenter, Dr. Dee Anne The Mirans Helping Out with Marcia Cowles
Wymer, Bloomsburg University
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 13 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
Daryl Stratton
Dick Jackson
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 14 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 15 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 16 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
PLEASE CONSIDER SPONSORING THE SRAC JOURNAL WITH YOUR CONTRIBUTUION AT ONE OF
THE LEVELS LISTED BELOW.
Many of you are familiar with our quarterly journal, and the quality and volume of educational information we try to bring to the commu-
nity throughout the year. In fact our range of readership includes high school students to retired persons as well as professional scien-
tists and local universities. The journal has grown into a well read and respected publication; and we hope that it will continue to grow
and be a resource of educational and entertaining material for years to come. Obviously, with this continued growth not only in content
and pages but distribution, there are added costs associated. For this reason, we have decided to offer sponsorship by local individu-
als, families, and businesses who want to help us in our efforts. We currently publish and distribute 1,000 copies each quarter ~ that's
currently 4,000 copies each year, with our coverage mainly in Bradford County PA and Tioga and Chemung Counties in NY, but we
have readership that reaches far beyond these boundaries as well.
THE FOLLOWING IS A LIST OF SPONSORSHIP LEVELS WITH FORMATS AND APPROXIMATE SIZES.
• Platinum $500.00 Our top level of sponsorship! With your donation of $500 you will be facilitating 1,000
copies of one quarterly journal. Your donation will be recognized with a full half-page gray-scale or black and
white ad that can measure up to 7 1/2” wide by 5” tall. (Sorry, but we can accept only one Platinum sponsor
per issue; however, you can reserve for future issues.) Please email artwork and text you wish included to
sfogel@hughes.net.
LINE 3
• Silver The Hollowell Family
$50.00 Jan, Christy
Ryan, Allison, and Tommy LINE 4
(Limit lines to 35 characters. Gold level can include logo if space
allows. Please email logos to sfogel@hughes.net.)
• Sup-
The Johnson Family
porter
In loving memory of our dad John
$25.00
Send check along with this form to: SRAC
For additional information call Deb PO Box 12
Twigg at 607-727-3111 or email Sayre, PA 18840
• Friend Info@SRACenter.org
$10.00 The Lucky Penny Club
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 17 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
Huge variety of rocks, minerals, geodes, etc. from all over the
world!
T H E S R AC B OA R D O F D I R E C T O R S
• Deb Twigg • Tom Vallilee
• Dick Cowles • Janet Andrus
• Ted Keir • Mary Ann Taylor
• Susan Fogel • Mark Madill
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org
Page 18 THE SRAC JOURNAL Volume 4, Issue 3
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies
PO Box 12
Sayre, PA 18840
- cut here - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Type Annual Fee Benefits
Student $15.00 Quarterly newsletter, special events, exclusive offers, and special discounts.
Family $25.00 Quarterly newsletter, special events, exclusive offers, and special discounts.
Individual $20.00 Quarterly newsletter, special events, exclusive offers, and special discounts.
Research Partner Quarterly newsletter, special events, exclusive offers, special discounts, and online data-
$100.00
(Ind.) base collection access.
Corporate or
$250.00 Quarterly newsletter, special events, exclusive offers, and special discounts.
Group
$500.00 Lifetime membership and quarterly newsletters, special events, exclusive offers, and spe-
Benefactor
One Time cial discounts.
Address:
Name:
Email:
Phone:
Become a member of SRAC!
• Please check the type of membership you wish to apply for.
• Fill out the information above.
• Submit this form with a check for the appropriate amount to: SRAC, PO Box 12, Sayre 18840
The Susquehanna River Archaeological Center of Native Indian Studies ~ www.SRACenter.org ~ email Info@SRACenter.org