You are on page 1of 8

Problems are part of life -- they go together environmental contamination, ethnic

with being alive. And every community has conflict, health disparities, HIV/ AIDS,
problems, too; they go together with being a hunger, inadequate emergency services,
community. That's just a fact of community inequality, jobs, lack of affordable housing,
life. poverty, racism, transportation, violence.
Two more basic facts:

 Communities, like people, try to Rather than aim for a complete problem list,
solve their problems. here are some criteria you may consider
 And analyzing those problems helps when identifying community problems:
in their solution.
 The problem occurs too
Example, A community problem. The frequently (frequency)
downtown area of a community is declining.  The problem has lasted for a
Stores are closing, and moving out; no new while (duration)
stores are moving in. We want to revitalize  The problem affects many
that downtown. How should we do it? people (scope, or range)
 The problem is disrupting to
Our thinking here is simple: personal or community life, and
possibly intense (severity)
 We'd be better off analyzing why  The problem deprives people of legal
that decline is taking place, why the or moral rights (equity)
problem is occurring, rather than  The issue is perceived as a
simply jumping in and trying to fix problem (perception)
it.
 A good analysis will lead to better This last criterion -- perception -- is an
long-run solutions. And therefore: important one, and can also help indicate
 A good analysis is worth taking the readiness for addressing the issue within the
time to do. community.

So this section explains what analyzing Keep in mind that what is seen as a problem
community problems is about, and why it can vary from place to place, and from
can be helpful -- and then how to do it. group to group in the same place. Although
there's no official definition of a community
This covers a lot of ground. There's a long problem, the above examples and criteria
list of nominees. And you probably know above should help you begin to name and
some of the main contenders. Can you name analyze community problems.
the leading problems in your own
community? Chances are you can at least Analyzing community problems is a way
start the list. of thinking carefully about a problem or
issue before acting on a solution. It first
Below are examples of community involves identifying reasons a problem
problems: exists, and then (and only then) identifying
possible solutions and a plan for
Example Community
improvement. The techniques for analyzing
Problems: Adolescent pregnancy, access to
community problems require simple logic,
clean drinking water, child abuse and
and sometimes the collection of evidence.
neglect, crime, domestic violence, drug use,
starting to work on a problem, and running
up against lots of obstacles -- especially
To better identify what the problem or when they are avoidable.
issue is.
When you take a little time to examine a
Kids gather on a street. Sometimes they problem first, you can anticipate some of
drink; sometimes they get rowdy. What is these obstacles before they come up, and
the problem here? The drinking? The give yourself and your members better odds
rowdiness? The gathering itself? Or, the of coming up with a successful solution.
possible fact that kids have nowhere else to
go and few positive alternatives for
engagement? Before looking for solutions,
Every community problem should benefit
you would want to clarify just what is the
from analysis. The only possible exception
problem (or problems) here. Unless you are
is when the problem is an immediate crisis
clear, it's hard to move forward.
that requires action this very moment. And
To understand what is at the heart of a even then, analysis should help later.
problem.
However, there are conditions when
A problem is usually caused by something; analysis is especially important. And
what is that something? We should find out. these are:
And often the problem we see is a symptom
of something else.  When the community problem is not
defined very clearly
To determine the barriers and resources
 When little is known about the
associated with addressing the problem.
community problem, or its possible
It's good practice and planning to anticipate consequences
barriers and obstacles before they might rise  When you want to find causes that
up. By doing so, you can get around them. may improve the chance of
Analyzing community problems can also successfully addressing the problem
help you understand the resources you need.  When people are jumping to
And the better equipped you are with the solutions much too soon
right resources, the greater your chances of  When you need to identify actions to
success. address the problem, and find
collaborative partners for taking
To develop the best action steps for action.
addressing the problem.
Having a plan of action is always better than
taking a few random shots at the problem. If
you know where you are going, you are The ultimate goal is - to understand the
more likely to get there. problem better and to deal with it more
effectively, so the method you choose should
In general, when you tackle a problem, it's accomplish that goal. We'll offer some step-
almost always smarter to analyze it before by-step guidelines here and go over a couple
you begin. That way, you've got a deeper of specific ways to determine the causes of
understanding of the problem; and you've the problem.
covered your bases. There's nothing worse
for member involvement and morale than 1. Justify the choice of the problem.
Apply the criteria we’ve listed above – public) in order to benefit yet another group
frequency, duration, range, severity, equity, by changing the environment (children are
perception – as well as asking yourself protected from secondhand smoke in
whether your organization or another can public.)
address it effectively, in order to decide
All, and particularly low-income, children
whether the problem is one that you should
should have the opportunity and the
focus on.
motivation to eat more healthily and
Let’s take the problem we used as an exercise more. Parents may need to change
example earlier: The percentage of their children’s – and perhaps their own –
overweight and obese children in the diets, and schools may need to adjust their
community has been steadily increasing, and lunch programs and exercise schedules. In
now approaches 25%. Since we know that low-income neighborhoods, there needs to
childhood obesity tends to lead to adult be greater access to healthy food and more
obesity, and that obesity and being safe places for children to play or participate
overweight are linked to chronic conditions in sports, both outdoors and indoors.
– diabetes, heart disease, stroke – this is a
problem that needs to be addressed now. 4. Analyze the root causes of the problem.
Our organization has the will and the ability The real cause of a problem may not be
to do it. immediately apparent. It may be a function
of a social or political system, or may be
2. Frame the problem.
rooted in a behavior or situation that may at
State the problem without implying a first glance seem unrelated to it. In order to
solution or blaming anyone, so that you can find the underlying cause, you may have to
analyze it without any assumptions and use one or more analytical methods,
build consensus around whatever solution including critical thinkingand the “But
you arrive at. One way is to state it in terms Why?” technique.
of a lack of a positive behavior, condition, or
Very briefly, the latter consists of stating the
other factor, or the presence or size of a
problem as you perceive it and asking “But
negative behavior, condition, or other factor.
why?” The next step is to answer that
There are too many children in the question as well as you can and then asking
community who are overweight or obese. again, “But why?” By continuing this
The problem is particularly serious among process until you get an answer that can’t be
low-income families. reduced further, you can often get to the
underlying cause of the problem, which will
3. Identify whose behavior and/or what tell you where to direct your efforts to solve
and how environmental factors need to it.
change for the problem to begin to be
solved. The difference between recognizing a
problem and finding its root cause is similar
This can be as straightforward as individuals to the difference between a doctor’s treating
changing their behavior from smoking to not the symptoms of a disease and actually
smoking, or as complex as persuading curing the disease. Once a disease is
legislators to change laws and policies (e.g., understood well enough to cure, it is often
non-smoking ordinances) in order to change also understood well enough to prevent or
others’ behavior (smokers don’t smoke in eliminate. Similarly, once you understand
buildings or enclosed spaces used by the the root causes of a community problem,
you may be able not only to solve it, but to 5. Identify the restraining and driving
establish systems or policies that prevent its forces that affect the problem.
return.
This is called a force field analysis. It means
There are too many children in the looking at the restraining forces that act to
community who are overweight or obese. keep the problem from changing (social
The problem is particularly serious among structures, cultural traditions, ideology,
low-income families. (But why?) politics, lack of knowledge, lack of access to
healthy conditions, etc.) and the driving
Because many low-income children don’t
forces that push it toward change
eat a healthy diet and don’t exercise enough.
(dissatisfaction with the way things are,
(But why?)
public opinion, policy change, ongoing
Because their parents, in many cases, don’t public education efforts, existing
have the knowledge of what a healthy diet alternatives to unhealthy or unacceptable
consists of, and because, even if they did, activity or conditions, etc.) Consider how
they lack access in their neighborhoods to you can use your understanding of these
healthy foods – no supermarkets, produce forces in devising solutions to the problem.
markets, farmers’ markets, or restaurants
Forces restraining change here include:
serving healthy food – and therefore shop at
convenience stores and eat out at fast food
 The desirability and availability of
places. Kids don’t play outside because it’s
junk food – kids like it because it
too dangerous – gang activity and drug
tastes good (we’re programmed as a
dealing make the street no place for
species to like fat, salt, and sugar),
children. (But why?)
and you can get it on every corner in
Parents may never have been exposed to practically any neighborhood.
information about healthy food – they  The reluctance of supermarket chains
simply don’t have the knowledge. Market to open stores in low-income
owners view low-income neighborhoods as neighborhoods.
unprofitable and dangerous places to do  The domination of the streets by
business. The streets are dangerous because gangs and drug dealers.
there are few job opportunities in the
community, and young men turn to making Some forces driving change might be:
money in any way possible.
 Parents’ concern about their
By this point, you should have a fair children’s weight.
understanding of why kids don’t eat  Children’s desire to participate in
healthily or get enough exercise. As you sports or simply to be outdoors.
continue to question, you may begin to think  Media stories about the problem of
about advocacy with local officials for childhood obesity and its
incentives to bring supermarkets to low- consequences for children, both now
income neighborhoods, or for after-school and in their later lives.
programs that involve physical exercise, or
for parent nutrition education or for anti- A full force field analysis probably would
gang programs…or for all of these and other include many more forces in each category.
efforts besides. Or continued questioning
may reveal deeper causes that you feel your
organization can tackle.
6. Find any relationships that exist among solve the problem you’re concerned with,
the problem you’re concerned with and there are also factors within the community
others in the community. environment that may do the same. These
might include the availability or lack of
In analyzing root causes, you may have
services, information, and other support; the
already completed this step. It may be that
degree of accessibility and barriers to, and
other problems stem from the same root
opportunities for services, information, and
cause, and that there are other organizations
other support; the social, financial, and other
with whom you could
costs and benefits of change; and such
partner. Understanding the relationships
overarching factors as poverty, living
among community issues can be an
conditions, official policy, and economic
important step toward resolving them.
conditions.
We’ve already seen connections to lack of
Sample environmental factors:
education, unemployment, lack of after-
school programs, and gang violence and
 Poverty
crime, among other issues. Other
 Lack of employment and hope for
organizations may be working on one or
young men in low-income
more of these, and a collaboration might
neighborhoods
help both of you to reach your goals.
 Lack of availability of healthy food
7. Identify personal factors that may in low-income neighborhoods
contribute to the problem.  General availability – at school as
well as elsewhere – of snack foods
Whether the problem involves individual high in salt, sugar, and fat
behavior or community conditions, each  Constant media bombardment of
individual affected by it brings a whole advertising of unhealthy snacks,
collection of knowledge (some perhaps drinks, and fast food
accurate, some perhaps not), beliefs, skills,
education, background, experience, culture, 9. Identify targets and agents of change
and assumptions about the world and others, for addressing the problem.
as well as biological and genetic traits. Any
or all of these might contribute to the Whom should you focus your efforts on, and
problem or to its solution…or both. who has the power to improve the situation?
Often, these may be the same people. The
A few examples: best solution to a particular problem may be
policy change of some sort, for instance, and
 Genetic predisposition for diabetes the best route to that may be to mount an
and other conditions. advocacy effort aimed at officials who can
 Lack of knowledge about healthy make it happen. People who are suffering
nutrition. from lack of skills or services may be the
 Lack of knowledge/ skills for ones who can do the most to change their
preparing healthy foods. situation. In other cases, your targets may be
people whose behavior or circumstances
8. Identify environmental factors that need to change, and you may want to recruit
may contribute to the problem. agents of change to work with you in your
Just as there are factors relating to effort. The point of this step is to understand
individuals that may contribute to or help to
where and how to direct your work most What do you conclude? We hope you'll find
effectively. some value in analysis. We do know that
when we have tried this method with real
Targets of change might include:
problems in our own communities, we have
Parents of children in low-income drawn some additional conclusions of our
neighborhoods (or all parents in the own, going beyond the basics:
community) for education purposes
The children themselves  Analyzing community problems can
Elementary and middle school teachers be hard work. It takes real mental
School officials responsible for school food effort. We're not used to sitting down
programs and thinking deeply about a problem.
Executives and Public Relations officers of (We're too busy!)
supermarket chains  Real community problems are likely
Gang members and youth at risk of to be complex. Economic
becoming gang members development may depend on the
global economy, a force you can't
A short list of potential agents of change: have much effect on. You may have
Parents of children in low-income opposition, either from within the
neighborhoods (or all parents in the community itself, or from powerful
community) as controllers of their children’s forces trying to protect their own
diets interests.
The Superintendent of Schools, School  When you go looking for reasons and
Committee, and school administrators, as underlying causes for significant
well as those directly responsible for school problems, you are likely to find more
food programs than one. Several different reasons
Local public officials who could create may be influencing the problem, in
incentives for markets to move into different amounts, all at the same
underserved neighborhoods time. It may not be an easy task to
Community Recreation Commissions, untangle all the reasons and their
school officials, YMCAs, and other entities relative strengths, but it may be
that might create safe outdoor and indoor necessary in order to reach a
physical activity programs for children solution.
Community hospitals, clinics, and private  The problem may not only have more
medical practices than one reason; it may have more
Public relations offices of national or than one solution too. Problems
regional fast food restaurant chains often call for multi-pronged
solutions. That is, difficult problems
With your analysis complete, you can often must be approached from more
develop a strategic plan that speaks to the than one direction. So in revitalizing
real causes of the problem and focuses on the downtown, you might want to (a)
those targets and/or agents of change that beautify the streets; (b) expand the
are most likely to contribute to improving staff of the chamber of commerce;
the situation. (c) run sidewalk sales; (d) look for
Try this analysis out with a current problem outside loans; and (e) recruit new
in your own community setting. businesses. These are all parts of the
solution. Many different types of
actions might be necessary for data. It includes a detailed step-by-step
revitalization. presentation.

When analyzing real community problems, The title is definitely the part of a paper that
the analysis may show multiple reasons is read the most, and it is usually read first.
behind the problem. The analysis may not Writing a research paper title may seem a
always be easy. The solution may be more simple task but in fact, it requires serious
difficult still. consideration.
But that's why problems are problems.
Community problems exist precisely This starting point is very important as it
because they often resist clear analysis and may influence the whole work and the
solution. They persist despite our efforts. number of readers that it will attract. If you
They can be real challenges. want your article to come up in the search
results, you should make sure that its title is
Yet this doesn't mean we are helpless. a good summary of your study and that it
Analysis, including the analytic methods we addresses the right audience.
have described, can take you a long way.
With good analysis, some resources, and Here are useful tips
enough determination, we believe even the from www.scipress.com for picking up
most troublesome problems can be
a catchy title for your research paper.
addressed, and ultimately, solved.
Contributor 1. The title should be simple and concise.
Bill Berkowitz Avoid words with little or no meaning as
Online Resources they increase the total length. Good research
titles are brief, with no more than 12 words.
Addressing Community Gang Problems:
A Practical Guide by Bureau of Justice 2. Lengthy titles will hardly be read
Assistance Is a useful resource that provides completely, they seem unfocused and take
a prototype to assist communities in away the reader’s attention, some readers
identifying, analyzing, and responding to may avoid opening the full paper because of
that.
gang-related problems as well as assessing
the effectiveness of their responses. 3. Choose a declarative title for your
is provided by the Community Anti-Drug research article. It delivers the largest
amount of information and emphasizes the
Coalitions of America and the National
technical side of the research.
Community Anti-Drug Coalition Institute.
This helpful primer is designed to provide 4. The title should give a precise summary
clear guidelines for anti-drug coalitions in of the paper’s content and distinguish the
defining their communities and assessing the paper from others on a similar topic.
real needs within them.
5. Choose a descriptive phrase, not a
Framing the Issue, by Trudy Rice, Cheryl sentence. In the majority of cases writing a
Burkhart-Kriesel and Karla Trautman, is a complete sentence simply adds unnecessary
useful resource that explains how to analyze words.
community problems and access community
6. Do not use acronyms, specific
abbreviations and jargon in the title.
Readers, who are not familiar with the
meaning of such words, may just skip your
article. According
to www.scipress.com analytics - it's
true!

7. The use of active verbs is preferable.


Avoid complex phrases and unnecessary
details.

8. A good research paper title should contain


keywords used in the manuscript and should
determine the nature of the study. Try to
figure out what terms people would use to
search for your paper and include them in
the title.

9. Place your most important terms at the


beginning and at the end of the title so that a
reader could notice them when looking
through the table of contents.

10. Start with a draft title, then focus on


writing the body of the paper and return to
the title when the text is ready to decide on
the final version.

11. Make sure you can deliver on your title.


Everything in your manuscript should relate
back to the title.

12. Ask for help among your colleagues. Try


writing several variants and ask, which one
draws their attention and interest the most.

You might also like