VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No.

:
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-1. Module-A1 / Male(Mm) & Female(Mf) Louver Unit Mullion for L6 Podium Floor (5500mm)

1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 535 mm

L1

B Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 965 mm

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

Supported length : L1 = 1000 mm
Mf Mm
Supported length : L2 = 4500 mm
L

Wind Load : ω1 = Po×W1/2×10-6 = 0.45 N/mm

ω2 Wind Load : ω2 = Po×W2/2×50%×10-6 =
L2

0.41 N/mm Louver airfiow 50%

ω1 Wind Load : ω = ω1 + ω2 = 0.85 N/mm

Mf Mm

L1
A B Mb B B

ω X
def.W

L
Mw

L2
W1 W2

Calculation model against wind load

A A A
MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION

Moment of inertia : Ixm = 3660400 mm4 Male Mullion(Mm)

Section modulus : Zxm = 36571 mm3 Male Mullion(Mm)
Moment of inertia : Ixf = 2691060 mm4 Female Mullion(Mf)
Section modulus : Zxf = 35386 mm3 Female Mullion(Mf)
Combined Moment of inertia : Ix = Ixm + Ixf = 6351460 mm4
Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2
Reaction force : RA = ｛ (ω / ( L22-L12 ) / 2 L2 ｝×γf = 2194 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RB = ｛ (ω / ( L2+L1 ) 2 / 2 L2 ｝×γf = 3447 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mb = ｛ω L1 2 / 2 ｝ ×γf = 512820 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛RA ((L2 -L12)/(2L2)) - ω((L22-L12)/(2L2))2 / 2 ｝ ×γf =
2
3284501 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending moment at male mullion : M1 = Mw x ( Ixm / Ix ) = 1892886 N.mm
Bending moment at female mullion : M2 = Mw x ( Ixf / Ix ) = 1391615 N.mm

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = M1 / Zxm ×γm = 62 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 107 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.72 > 1.0 (O.K)

Bending stress at female mullion : σ2 = M2 / Zxf ×γm　= 47 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 52 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.10 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ω L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mb L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 8.80 mm < 20mm (O.K)

( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 511 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 20 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-2. Module-A1 / Intermediate Louver Unit Mullion (Mi) for L6 Podium Floor (5500mm)

1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 535 mm

L1

B Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 965 mm

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

Mi Supported length : L1 = 975.5 mm
Supported length : L2 = 4524.5 mm
L

Wind Load : ω1 = Po×W1/2×10-6 = 0.45 N/mm

Wind Load : ω2 = Po×W2/2×50%×10-6 =
L2

0.41 N/mm Louver airfiow 50%

Wind Load : ω = ω1 + ω2 = 0.85 N/mm
ω2 ω1

Mi

L1
A B Mb B B

ω X
def.W

L
Mw

L2
W2 W1

Calculation model against wind load

A A A
MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION

Moment of inertia : Ixi = 5114550 mm4 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)

Section modulus : Zxi = 47356 mm3 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)

Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RA = ｛ (ω / ( L22-L12 ) / 2 L2 ｝×γf = 2212 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Reaction force : RB = ｛ (ω / ( L2+L1 ) 2 / 2 L2 ｝×γf = 3429 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mb = ｛ω L1 2 / 2 ｝ ×γf = 488000 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛RA ((L22-L12)/(2L2)) - ω((L22-L12)/(2L2))2 / 2 ｝ ×γf = 3340636 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = Mw / Zxi ×γm = 85 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.30 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ω L24 /( 384 E Ixi ) ｝ - ( Mb L22 / ( 16 E Ixi )) = 11.28 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 401 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 21 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-3. Module-D1 / Male(Mm) & Female(Mf) Glass Unit Mullion for L6 Podium Floor (5500mm)

1680 N/m2
C
Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 285 mm

L1
B Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 1215 mm

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
Mf Mm
Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm
L
L2

Wind Load : ω = 1.26 N/mm

ω
C C C
Mf Mm

L1
A
B Mw B B

ω X

L
def.W
W1 W2

L2
Calculation model against wind load
A A A
MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION

Moment of inertia : Ixm = 3660400 mm4 Male Mullion(Mm)

Section modulus : Zxm = 36571 mm3 Male Mullion(Mm)
Moment of inertia : Ixf = 2691060 mm4 Female Mullion(Mf)
Section modulus : Zxf = 35386 mm3 Female Mullion(Mf)
Combined Moment of inertia : Ix = Ixm + Ixf = 6351460 mm4
Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2
Reaction force : RA = ｛ (ωL1/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -2720 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RC = ｛ (ωL2/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 2722 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RB = ｛ (ωL - RA - RB ｝×γf = 8314 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛ω( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 3266393 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending moment at male mullion : M1 = Mw x ( Ixm / Ix ) = 1882450 N.mm
Bending moment at female mullion : M2 = Mw x ( Ixf / Ix ) = 1383943 N.mm

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = M1 / Zxm ×γm = 62 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 107 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.73 > 1.0 (O.K)

Bending stress at female mullion : σ2 = M2 / Zxf ×γm　= 47 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 52 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.11 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ω L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mw L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 6.31 mm < 20mm (O.K)

( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 721 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 22 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-4. Module-D1 / Intermediate Glass Unit Mullion (Mi) for L6 Podium Floor (5500mm)

1680 N/m2

C
Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 285 mm

L1
B Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 1215 mm

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
Mi Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm
L
L2

Wind Load : ω = 1.26 N/mm

ω
C C C

L1
Mi
A
B Mw B B

ω X

L
def.W
W2 W1

L2
Calculation model against wind load
A A A
MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION

Moment of inertia : Ixi = 5114550 mm4 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)

Section modulus : Zxi = 47356 mm3 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)

Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RA = ｛ (ωL1/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -2720 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RC = ｛ (ωL2/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 2722 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RB = ｛ (ωL - RA - RB ｝×γf = 8314 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛ω( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 3266393 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = Mw / Zxi ×γm = 83 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.33 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ω L24 /( 384 E Ixi ) ｝ - ( Mw L22 / ( 16 E Ixi )) = 7.84 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 581 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 23 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-5. A1-Cor 1L / 110.76°(Mc) Outer Stone L6 Corner Mu llion ( 5500mm )

°Outer Corner
110.76°
1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 999.3 mm

C Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 518.7 mm
L1

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

B
Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm

Mc2 Spacing : W1x =W1/2×COS34.62°= 411.2 mm

ω1
L

Spacing : W2x =W2/2×COS34.62°= 213.4 mm

Spacing : W1y =W1/2×SIN34.62°= 283.9 mm
L2

ω2 Spacing : W2y =W2/2×SIN34.62°= 147.3 mm

Wind Load : ωx =(W1x+W2x)xPox10-6= 1.05 N/mm
Wind Load : ωy =(W1y-W2y)xPox10-6= 0.23 N/mm
Mc2
C C C
A
Y

L1
B Mw B B
W2 W1
ω X
def.W

L
L2
Calculation model against wind load

ωx
W2 W1

A A A
ωy MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION
W2x W1x

Moment of inertia : Ix = 9387520 mm4 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc2)

Section modulus : Zx = 91811 mm3 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc2)
Moment of inertia : Iy = 3087410 mm4 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc2)
Section modulus : Zy = 48370 mm3 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc2)

Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RAx = ｛ (ωx L1/2) - (ωx (L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -2265 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RCx = ｛ (ωx L2/2) - (ωx (L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 2267 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RBx = ｛ (ωx L - RA - RB ｝×γf = 6924 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Reaction force : RAy = ｛ (ωy L1/2) - (ωy (L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -495 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RCy = ｛ (ωy L2/2) - (ωy (L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 495 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RBy = ｛ (ωy L - RA - RB ｝×γf = 1513 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mwx = ｛ωx ( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 2720295 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending stress at male mullion : σx = Mwx / Zx ×γm = 36 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Bending moment : Mwy = ｛ωy ( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 594579 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending stress at male mullion : σy = Mwy / Zy ×γm = 15 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

- 24 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

Conbined bending stress : σ = σx + σy = 50 N/mm2

Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 2.19 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.wx = ｛ 5 ωx L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mwx L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 3.56 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 1280 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

Deflection : def.wy = ｛ 5 ωy L24 /( 384 E Iy ) ｝ - ( Mwy L22 / ( 16 E Iy )) = 2.36 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 1926 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 25 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-6. A1-Cor 2 / 115.87°Outer Corner (Mi) L6 Intermed iate Mullion ( 5500mm )

°Outer Corner
115.87°
1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 567.48 mm

C
C Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 965 mm
L1
L1

B
B
Supported length : L = 5500 mm
Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm
Mc2
Mc2 ω1
ω1
LL

Wind Load : ω = 1.76 N/mm

Mi
L2

C
L2

C C
ω2

L1
B Mw B B X

A ω

L
def.W

L2
W2 W1

95
Xs
A A A
Calculation model against wind load MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION
50 50

Moment of inertia(2.0mm S/S Frame) : Ixs = 558112 mm4

Section modulus(2.0mm S/S Frame) : Zxs = 11750 mm3
Moment of inertia : Ixi = 5114550 mm4 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)
Section modulus : Zxi = 47356 mm3 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)
Combined Moment of inertia : Ix = Ixi + 3Ixs = 6788886 mm4
Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2
Modulus of elasticity : E (ST/STL 197000) = 197000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RA = ｛ (ωL1/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -3808 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RC = ｛ (ωL2/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 3811 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RB = ｛ (ωL - RA - RB ｝×γf = 11639 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛ω( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 4572862 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending moment at intermediate mullion : M1 = Mw x ( Ixi / Ix ) = 3445062 N.mm
Bending moment at S/S female : M2 = Mw x ( 3Ixs / Ix ) = 1127800 N.mm

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = M1 / Zxi ×γm = 87 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.26 > 1.0 (O.K)
Bending stress at S/S frame : σ2 = M2 / Zxs ×γm = 115 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (Grade304) = 210 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.82 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ω L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mw L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 8.26 mm < 20mm (O.K)

( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 551 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 26 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-7. A1-Cor 3 / 115.94°Outer Corner (Mi) L6 Intermed iate Mullion ( 5500mm )

°Outer Corner
115.94°
1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 518.45 mm

C Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 965 mm
L1

B
Supported length : L = 5500 mm
Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm
Mc2
ω1
L

Wind Load : ω = 1.68 N/mm

C Mi
L2

C C
ω2

L1
B Mw B B X

A ω

L
def.W

L2
W2 W1

95
Xs
A A A
Calculation model against wind load MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION
50 50

Moment of inertia(2.0mm S/S Frame) : Ixs = 558112 mm4

Section modulus(2.0mm S/S Frame) : Zxs = 11750 mm3
Moment of inertia : Ixi = 5114550 mm4 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)
Section modulus : Zxi = 47356 mm3 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)
Combined Moment of inertia : Ix = Ixi + 3Ixs = 6788886 mm4
Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2
Modulus of elasticity : E (ST/STL 197000) = 197000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RA = ｛ (ωL1/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -3630 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RC = ｛ (ωL2/2) - (ω(L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 3633 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RB = ｛ (ωL - RA - RB ｝×γf = 11096 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛ω( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 4359327 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending moment at intermediate mullion : M1 = Mw x ( Ixi / Ix ) = 3284191 N.mm
Bending moment at S/S female : M2 = Mw x ( 3Ixs / Ix ) = 1075136 N.mm

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = M1 / Zxi ×γm = 83 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.32 > 1.0 (O.K)
Bending stress at S/S frame : σ2 = M2 / Zxs ×γm = 110 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable bending stress : Ps (Grade304) = 210 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 1.91 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ω L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mw L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 7.88 mm < 20mm (O.K)

( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 578 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 27 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-8. A1-Cor 4 / 90.05°(Mc) Outer Stone L6 Corner Mull ion ( 5500mm )

°Outer Corner
90.05°
1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 575.62 mm

C Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 427.81 mm
L1

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

B Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
ｃ1
Mｃ
Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm

ω1 Spacing : W1x =W1/2×COS45.03°= 203.4 mm

L

Spacing : W2x =W2/2×COS45.03°= 151.2 mm

L2

ω2 Spacing : W1y =W1/2×SIN45.03°= 203.6 mm

Spacing : W2y =W2/2×SIN45.03°= 151.3 mm
Wind Load : ωx =(W1x+W2x)xPox10-6= 0.60 N/mm
Wind Load : ωy =(W1y-W2y)xPox10-6= 0.09 N/mm
Mc1
C C C
A Y

L1
B Mw B B
W2 W1
ω def.W

L
X

L2
Calculation model against wind load

ωx A A A
MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION
W2 W1

ωy Moment of inertia : Ix = 13254700 mm4 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)

W2x W1x Section modulus : Zx = 102804 mm3 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)
Moment of inertia : Iy = 3489490 mm4 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)
Section modulus : Zy = 27746 mm3 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)

Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RAx = ｛ (ωx L1/2) - (ωx (L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -1286 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RCx = ｛ (ωx L2/2) - (ωx (L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 1287 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RBx = ｛ (ωx L - RA - RB ｝×γf = 3931 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Reaction force : RAy = ｛ (ωy L1/2) - (ωy (L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -190 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RCy = ｛ (ωy L2/2) - (ωy (L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 190 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RBy = ｛ (ωy L - RA - RB ｝×γf = 580 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mwx = ｛ωx ( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 1544264 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending stress at male mullion : σx = Mwx / Zx ×γm = 18 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Bending moment : Mwy = ｛ωy ( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 227716 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending stress at male mullion : σy = Mwy / Zy ×γm = 10 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

- 28 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

Conbined bending stress : σ = σx + σy = 28 N/mm2

Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 3.95 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.wx = ｛ 5 ωx L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mwx L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 1.43 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 3183 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

Deflection : def.wy = ｛ 5 ωy L24 /( 384 E Iy ) ｝ - ( Mwy L22 / ( 16 E Iy )) = 0.80 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 5683 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 29 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-9. D1-Cor 1L / 90°(Mc) Outer Stone L6 Corner Mullio n ( 5500mm )

D1-Cor 1R / 90°(Mc) Outer Stone L6 Corner Mullion ( 5500mm )

°Outer Corner
90°
Max. Wind pressure : Po = 1680 N/m2

Horizontal frame spacing : W1 = 757.5 mm

C Horizontal frame spacing : W2 = 607.5 mm
L1

Supported length : L = 5500 mm

B Supported length : L1 = 950 mm
ｃ1
Mｃ
Supported length : L2 = 4550 mm

ω1 Spacing : W1x =W1/2×COS45°= 267.8 mm

L

Spacing : W2x =W2/2×COS45°= 214.8 mm

L2

ω2 Spacing : W1y =W1/2×SIN45°= 267.8 mm

Spacing : W2y =W2/2×SIN45°= 214.8 mm
Wind Load : ωx =(W1x+W2x)xPox10-6= 0.81 N/mm
Wind Load : ωy =(W1y-W2y)xPox10-6= 0.09 N/mm
Mc1
C C C
A Y

L1
B Mw B B
W2 W1
ω def.W

L
X
Calculation model against wind load L2

ωx A A A
MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION
W2 W1

ωy Moment of inertia : Ix = 13254700 mm4 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)

W2x W1x Section modulus : Zx = 102804 mm3 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)
Moment of inertia : Iy = 3489490 mm4 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)
Section modulus : Zy = 27746 mm3 Stone Corner Mullion(Mc1)

Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2

Reaction force : RAx = ｛ (ωx L1/2) - (ωx (L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -1750 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RCx = ｛ (ωx L2/2) - (ωx (L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 1751 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RBx = ｛ (ωx L - RA - RB ｝×γf = 5350 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Reaction force : RAy = ｛ (ωy L1/2) - (ωy (L13+L23)) / (8L1(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = -192 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RCy = ｛ (ωy L2/2) - (ωy (L13+L23)) / (8L2(L1+L2)) ｝×γf = 192 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Reaction force : RBy = ｛ (ωy L - RA - RB ｝×γf = 588 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mwx = ｛ωx ( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 2101816 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending stress at male mullion : σx = Mwx / Zx ×γm = 25 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Bending moment : Mwy = ｛ωy ( L13+L23 ) / ( 8 ( L1+L2 ) ｝ ×γf = 230969 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
Bending stress at male mullion : σy = Mwy / Zy ×γm = 10 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

- 30 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

Conbined bending stress : σ = σx + σy = 35 N/mm2

Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 3.19 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.wx = ｛ 5 ωx L24 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ - ( Mwx L22 / ( 16 E Ix )) = 1.95 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 2339 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

Deflection : def.wy = ｛ 5 ωy L24 /( 384 E Iy ) ｝ - ( Mwy L22 / ( 16 E Iy )) = 0.81 mm < 20mm (O.K)
( L2 / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 5603 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 31 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project : Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET
Check of Curtain Wall Frames Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. (
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : )REV. Date :

6-10. Module-A1 / Alum. Louver for L6 Podium Floor (985mm)

Max. Wind pressure : Po = 1680 N/m2

Louver pitch : h1 = 202 mm

Supported length : L = 985 mm

Wind Load : ωx = Po×1/√2×10-6 = 0.24 N/mm

h1

B B B
Ag
35

X
ωx

40
A B

4.3
ω

20
Mw

L
def.W

207.5
167.5
L
2

40
A A A
145.5

Calculation model against wind load

MODEL BENDING MOMENT DEFLECTION

Moment of inertia : Ix = 36643 mm4 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)

Section modulus : Zx = 3632 mm3 Intermediate Mullion(Mi)

Modulus of elasticity : E (aluminum 70000) = 70000 N/mm2

Reaction force of supported points : RA = RB = ｛ ω L / 2 ｝×γf = 142 N γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending moment : Mw = ｛ωx L2 / 8 ｝ ×γf = 34923 N.mm γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )

Bending stress at male mullion : σ1 = Mw / Zx ×γm = 12 N/mm2 γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Allowable bending stress : Ps (BS8118) = 110 N/mm2
Safety Factor : 9.53 > 1.0 (O.K)

Deflection : def.w = ｛ 5 ωL4 /( 384 E Ix ) ｝ = 1.15 mm < 20mm (O.K)

( L / def.w : deflection ) = 1/ 859 < 1/180 (O.K)
The lesser of span/180 or 20mm

- 32 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

CHECK OF L6 MODULE-A1, Fu FASTENER Podium Office Floor L1 to L2 and L6

7-1. Curtain Wall Supported Fastener Design Requirements

7-1-1. Curtain Wall Weight : Wg ( Module-A1 W=1500xH=5500mm )

1 ). Alum. Frames Wg1 = 1320 N Wg1=160N/m2×5.5×1.5 = 1320N
2 ). Alum. Louver Wg2 = 504 N Wg2=95N/m2×5.5×0.965 = 504N
3 ). 30mmthk. Granite ST/STL Frame Wg3 = 4061 N Wg3=1380N/m2×5.5×0.535 = 4061N
4 ). Back-pan(1) Wg4 = 113 N Wg4=53N/m2×5.5×0.535 = 156N
5 ). Insulation(1) Wg5 = 103 N Wg5=35N/m2×5.5×0.535 = 103N
Total : Wg = ΣWgi = 6101 N Wg = 6101×1.2 = 7300 N
γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor ) Wg = 7300 N ( 7.2 kN )

7-1-2. Wind Load : Rn ( Module-A1 W=1500xH=5500mm )

1 ). Max. negative wind load Pn = 1680 N/m2 γf = 1.2 ( Load Factor )
2 ). Alum. Mullion Reaction Rn1 = RB = 3447 N Refer to 6-1. RB

Curtain wall unit

714.5

L7

Uf
1000
1150

Ti1

Gn Ti1
Fu
5500

Ag
4500

Mf Mf Mm
3600

CHILLER ROOM
MECH. ROOM
Gn

Ti1
Ti1
Vs
750

s Ft
Lm Gn L6
162.5

Mi MfMm Mi MfMm Gn : 30mm thk. granite

Ag 794 N/m2 ( 81 kgf/m2 )

965 535
Vs
s
1500

CW UNIT WIDTH

- 33 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

7-2. Module-A1, L6 / Fu Fastener Model

STL Enbedded Channel

Anchor ( M16 Bolts )
Tolerance ±25mm
Horizontal tolerance ±25mm
Concrete Design
Strength/27N/mm2

Tolerance
±15mm

Wa b
Filet Weld

M12 ST/STL Bolt ( A4-50 )

Rn1

50
120

a Steel Plate Anchor Grade43

Alum. Fastener 6061-T6

M16 ST/STL Bolt ( A4-50 )

Rn2 Rn1

Mi Mf Mm

Rn1 = 3447 N / ( 6-1. RB ) Max.

Rn2 = 3429 N / ( 6-2. RB )

Wg= 7300 N

- 34 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

7-3. Check of Fastener Materials

7-3-1. M12 ST/STL Bolt ( A4-50 )

Design force : Wg = 7300 N

: Rn1 = 3447 N M12 Bolt

M12 Section area : Ae = 84.3mm2

Wg
T2 T1
Shear force : Q1 = Wg / 2 = 7300 / 2 = 3650 N Q1

L2
Rn1
Shear stress : τs1 = Q1 / Ae×γm = 3650 / 84.3×1.2 = 51.8 N/mm2 Q1
T2 T1
γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
Allowable shear stress : Pv ( BS3506 ) = 145N/mm2
L1

Tensile force : T1 = Wg×L1 / L2 = 7300×44 / 120 = 2677 N L1 = 44mm

L2 = 120mm
Tensile stress : σt1 = T1 / Ae ×γm = 2677 / 84.3×1.2 = 38.1 N/mm2
Allowable axial stress : Pt ( BS 3506 ) = 174N/mm2
γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Combined stress for D.L : τs1 / Pv + σt1 / Pt = 51.8 / 145 + 38.1 / 174 = 0.58 < 1.0 ( O,K )

Tensile force : T2 = Rn1 / 2 = 3447 / 2 = 1723 N

Tensile stress : σt2 = T2 / Ae ×γm = 1723 / 84.3×1.2 = 20.4 N/mm2

Allowable axial stress : Pt ( BS 3506 ) = 174N/mm2
γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Combined stress for D.L + W.L : τs1 / Pv + σt1 / Pt + σt2 / Pt

51.8 / 145 + 38.1 / 174 + 20.4 / 174 = 0.69 < 1.0 ( O,K )

7-3-2. Alum. Fastener ( 6061-T6 )

17 t

Design force : Wg = 7300 N X

: Rn1 = 3447 N
200

a-section Section property a -Section

2
Section area : Ax = 3400 mm
Q2
Section modulus : Zx = 9633 mm3
a
Tensile force : T1 = Rn1 = 3447 N T1 Ma
L3

Shear force : Q2 = Wg = 7300 N

L4
Bending moments : Ma = T1×L3 + Q2×L4
: Ma = 3447×50 + 7300×( 16+25 ) L3 = 50mm
: Ma = 471650 N.mm L4 = 16mm

- 35 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

Shear stress : τs2 = Q2 / Ay×γm = 7300 / 3400×1.2 = 2.6 N/mm2

Allowable shear stress : Pv ( 6061-T6 ) = 145N/mm2

Tensile stress : σt1 = T1 / Ax × γm = 3447 / 3400×1.2 = 1.2 N/mm2

Allowable axial stress : Pt ( 6061-T6 ) = 260N/mm2

Bending stress : σb1 = Ma / Zx × γm = 471650 / 9633×1.2 = 58.8 N/mm2

Allowable bending stress : Pb ( 6061-T6 ) = 240N/mm2

Combined stress for D.L + W.L : τs2 / Pv + σt1 / Pt + σb1 / Pb

2.6 / 145 + 1.2 / 260 + 58.8 / 240 = 0.27 < 1.0 ( O,K )

7-3-3. M16 ST/STL Bolt ( A4-50 )

Design force : Wg = 7300 N

: Rn1 = 3447 N M16 Bolt

M16 Section area : Ae = 157mm2 Wg

T1
Shear force : Q1 = Rn1 / 2 = 3447 / 2 = 1724 N Rn1

L7
Shear stress : τs1 = Q1 / Ae×γm = 1724 / 157×1.2 = 13.2 N/mm2 Q1
γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)
L5 L6
Allowable shear stress : Pv ( BS3506 ) = 145N/mm2

Tensile force : T1 = Wg×L5 / L6 + Rn1×L7 / L6 L5 = 16mm

T1 = 7300×(16+25) / (100-25) + 3447×69 / (100-25) L6 = 100mm
T1 = 7162 N L7 = 69mm

Tensile stress : σt1 = T1 / 2Ae ×γm = 7162 / ( 2×157 )×1.2 = 27.3 N/mm2
Allowable axial stress : Pt ( BS 3506 ) = 174N/mm2
γm = 1.2 (Material Factor)

Combined stress for D.L + W.L : τs1 / Pv + σt1 / Pt = 13.2 / 145 + 27.3 / 174 = 0.25 < 1.0 ( O,K )

7-3-4. Steel Plate Anchor Grade43

Design force : Wg = 7300 N

180

X
: Rn1 = 3447 N
270
b-section Section property b -Section
Section area : Ax = 3700 mm2
Section modulus : Zx = 100200 mm3

Tensile force : T1 = Wg = 7300 N

Shear force : Q1 = Rn1 = 3447 N

- 36 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

Bending moments : Mb = T1×L8 + Q1×L9

: Mb = 7300×(176+25) + 3447×( 231+15 )
: Mb = 2320000 N.mm
b
Mb
T1
2
Shear stress : τs1 = Q1 / Ay×γm = 3447 / 3700×1.2 = 1.1 N/mm

L9
Allowable shear stress : Pv ( BS5950 ) = 165N/mm2
Q1
L8
Tensile stress : σt1 = T1 / Ax × γm = 7300 / 3700×1.2 = 2.0 N/mm2
Allowable axial stress : Pt ( BS5950 ) = 275N/mm2 L8 =176mm
L9 =231mm
Bending stress : σb1 = Mb / Zx × γm = 2320000 / 100200×1.2 = 23.2 N/mm2
Allowable bending stress : Pb ( BS5950 ) = 275N/mm2

Combined stress for D.L + W.L : τs1 / Pv + σt1 / Pt + σb1 / Pb

1.1 / 155 + 2.0 / 275 + 23.2 / 275 = 0.10 < 1.0 ( O,K )

7-3-5. Filet Weld

Design force : Wg = 7300 N

b -Section weld model
: Rn1 = 3447 N

Lw2
Weld-section Section property
Weld size : S = 6mm
Throat thickness : a = S×1/√2 = 6×1/√2 = 4.2mm Lw1

Weld length : Lw1 = 270 - 2×6 = 258mm

: Lw2 = 180 - 2×6 = 168mm
Effectiveness weld section area : Ax = 2500 mm2
Effectiveness weld section modulus : Zx = 64784 mm3

Shear force : Q1 = Wg = 7300 N

Shear force : Q2 = Rn1 = 3447 N

Bending moments : Mb = Q1×L8 + Q2×L9

: Mb = 7300×(176+25) + 3447×( 231+15 )
: Mb = 2320000 N.mm
b
Mb
Q1
2
Shear stress : τs1 = Q1 / Ay×γm = 7300 / 2500×1.2 = 3.5 N/mm
L9

Allowable fillet weld stress : Pw ( BS5950 ) = 215N/mm2

Q2
L8
Shear stress : τs2 = Q2 / Ay×γm = 3447 / 2500×1.2 = 1.7 N/mm2
Allowable fillet weld stress : Pw ( BS5950 ) = 215N/mm2 L8 =176mm
L9 =231mm
Bending stress : σb1 = Mb / Zx × γm = 2320000 / 64784×1.2 = 35.8 N/mm2
Allowable fillet weld stress : Pw ( BS5950 ) = 215N/mm2

Combined stress for D.L + W.L : τs1 / Pw + τs2 / Pw + σb1 / Pw

3.5 / 215 + 1.7 / 215 + 35.8 / 215 = 0.19 < 1.0 ( O,K )

- 37 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

7-3-6. STL Embedded Channel Anchor

L10
Embedded Chanel Anchor

Fy
L8 =176mm
Fz Mb
Q1 L9 L9 =231mm
L10 =110mm

Q3
L8

1). Share Load : Fy

Fy = Q3 = Rn1×1.2kpa/1.68kpa = 3447×1.2/1.68 = 2460 N

2). Central Tension Load : Fz

Q1= Wg = 7300 N
Fz = ( Q1×L8 + Q3×L9 ) / L10
Fz = ( 7300×(176+25) + 2460×( 231+15 )) / 110 = 18840 N

3). Combined Load : F = √( Fy2 + Fz2 )

F = √( 2460 2 + 18840 2 )
F = 19000 ( 19.0 kN )

4). Check of Cast-IN Embedded Anchor

Reference only and not for approval. The cast-in anchor supplier will be informed by separate submission
together with the revised calculation.

4)-1. Channel type Combined Point Load F = 19.0 KN

: WJC5430 -3nos (H 130 L=370) Allowable Load Fa = 48.2 KN
: Channel L=370mm Fa=48.2kN form WONJIN Technical data ( Edge distance 100mm )
: hot dip galvanized steel Safety Factor : Fa / F = 48.2 / 19.0 = 2.5

4)-2. Bolt type Combined Point Load F/2 = 19.0/2 = 9.5 KN

: WJT/5 M16x65 Allowable Load : Fa = 30.6 KN
: M16 At = 157mm2 Allowable Load Fa = At x Pt = 157 x 195 = 30.6 KN
: Allowable pt = 195 N/mm2 Safety Factor : Fa / (F/3) = 30.6 / 9.5 = 3.0

- 38 -
 VIETCOMBANK TOWER, Document No. :
Project :
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SHEET Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Structural Calculation for Issue Date :
Subject :
EuroWindow Typical fastener portion 24th/Oct./2011
Yhs International LTD. Date : REV. No. ( )
Reviewed :
Prepared by : T. Hoshino Name : REV. Date :

5). Wonjin Technical Data / for Reference Only

- 39 -