0 views

Uploaded by Marketing Research

logic

- Lecture 3
- Vizzini Tic-tac-Toe Source Code
- Race–a Social Destruction of a Biological Concept
- Problems 3
- DLL IN MATH ( March 6-10, 2017 ) (1)
- AfrikaKorps 3d Ed Rules
- Galileo
- The Football Formula
- Probability vs Odds
- MIT6_0001F16_ps1
- math artifiact lesson plan
- 1
- Percentage.docx
- DI
- adibah
- lesson 6
- 110211Andrikogiannopoulou_JMP
- HwkPM17-1
- Topic - 7 (Uncertainty).ppt
- ProbabilityLectures-3.pptx

You are on page 1of 23

Critical Thinking

Working with Probabilities is Hard

• What makes it hard?

– The underlying mathematics: probability theory

• We don’t do well with probability theory, especially conditional

probabilities are confusing to us

– Confusion as to what probability even is and thus means

• Is it metaphysical or epistemological?

– The connection between mathematics and the world

• What are the assumptions that go into the mathematical model,

and are they satisfied in the real life situation we’re dealing with

and want to think/reason about?

– The way we talk about probability and statistics

• Lots of ambiguity, vagueness, omissions, and just plain incorrect

ways to express chances

The Birthday Problem

• What is the chance of 2 people in this room

having the same birthday?

have ~50% chance of 2 people having the

same birthday! With 30 people, this chance is

about 70%, with 35, 80%, and with 40 people,

you’re at 90%!)

Julius Ceasar Problem

• If you take a single breath, what are the

chances that you are inhaling one or more of

the molecules that was exhaled by Julias

Ceasar when he spoke his last words: “Et Tu

Brutus”?

(this is assuming that in the thousands of years since, the

molecules have dispersed randomly in the Earth’s

atmosphere).

Coin Sequences

• Which of the two outcomes was more likely to

be the result of flipping a fair coin 20 times?

• A. TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

• B. TTHTTHTTHTTTTHHTHHHH

Answer: It Depends!

• The question is ambiguous!

– “Which of the two outcomes was more likely to be the result of

flipping a fair coin 20 times?”

• A. TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

• B. TTHTTHTTHTTTTHHTHHHH

• Interpretation 1:

– I have a fair coin, and I flip it 20 times. Am I more likely to get

sequence A or am I more likely to get sequence B, or are they

equally likely?

• Interpretation 2:

– I obtained one of the two sequences A and B by flipping a fair

coin, while the other one I just made up. Which is more likely to

be the one that was the result of actual coin flips?

• What is the answer under each interpretation?

Answers to Each

• Interpretation 1:

– Either will happen with a probability of (1/2)20

• Interpretation 2:

– Basic human psychology suggests that the 20 T’s in a row is

more likely to be the made up sequence, so the other one

is more likely the result of 20 real coin flips

– A. THHHTTHHHHHTHTTHTTTH

– B. TTHTHTTHTHHHTHTHTTHT

Tossing a Coin

• Imagine you toss a coin and write down the

sequence of heads and tails you get: HTTHH…

• If you do have a coin, actually flip it and

record the sequence

• Do this now for 20 coin tosses!

Counting Sequences

• Now count the number of times that you had

2 of the same in a row.

• Same for 3 in a row, 4, 5, etc.

• E.g. HTTHHHHTTHTHHTTTTHTT

– 2: 10

– 3: 4

– 4: 1

– 5: 0

Coin Tosses

• Suppose we do a bunch of coin flips and write

down the sequence of heads and tails.

• Each of us picks a sequence of 3, e.g. I pick

HTH and you pick HTT.

• Whoever’s sequence appears first wins.

• Who is more likely to win?

Answer: It depends!

• Do we use 1 coin or are we both flipping our

own coin (at the same rate of course)?

• If we are using 1 coin, then it’s 50/50

• If we are using 2 separate coins, then HTH is

more likely to win.

pick HHT?

Just Two Coin Tosses

• I flip a fair coin two times. You know that at

least one of the two tosses is heads. What is

the chance the other toss is heads?

Answer: It depends!

• What does “you know that at least one of the

two tosses is heads” mean? How did you come to

know this?

• Maybe you saw the outcome of both of the flips,

and you saw either HH, HT, or TH. These are

equally probable, so the chance of both being

heads is 1/3.

• But maybe you saw the outcome of one of the

flips (and which was heads), but had your eyes

closed for the other flip. Well, then the chance is

1/2.

Disease Problem

• I have a test for a certain disease that is

90% accurate. I test positive. What is the

chance of me having the disease?

Answer: It Depends!

• First, what does it mean for the test to be 90% accurate? This

means that if you test all people, it classifies correctly 90% of

all people

• Second, it all depends on the base rate of the disease.

• Suppose 1% of all people have this disease, say 10 out of

1000.

• So, if I would test all 1000 people, 90% out of the 10 (i.e. 9)

who have the disease test positive. Also, 10% of the other 990

people (i.e. 99) who don’t have the disease test positive.

• So, 108 people test positive, but only 9 of those have the

disease. My chance of having the disease when testing

positive is therefore 9/108 or less than 9%!

Monty Hall problem

1 2 3

You are a contestant in the Monty Hall game show and have

to pick one of 3 doors, behind one of which is the big prize.

You pick door 1.

Monty Hall, the game show host, then opens door 2, and

reveals that the price is not behind door 2.

He then offers you to switch to door 3.

Should you switch?

Common Person’s Answer:

It doesn’t matter

• Most people (at least those who haven’t seen

the problem before) have the strong intuition

that it doesn’t matter: both doors 1 and 3 now

have a 50% chance of containing the price.

Mathematician’s Answer

• Wrong! You should switch!

• Suppose there would be 1000 doors. Again, you pick one, but

now Monty Hall opens up 998 other doors (he skips door

number 317) and reveals all those to be empty. Most people

understand that most likely, the price is behind door 317.

Indeed, while there is a slim (1/1000) chance you immediately

picked the right door, there is a 999/1000 chance you picked

the wrong one.

• Monty Hall opening a bunch of doors is not going to change

the chance with which you initially picked the right door. In

the original scenario, you therefore still have a 1/3 chance of

door 1 having the price, but door 3 now has a 2/3 chance of

containing the price.

Real Answer: It depends!

• If Monty Hall knew where the prize was, and made sure to show one of

the doors that he knew was empty, then: yes, you should switch!

– If you know that it is certain that Monty is going to open an empty door, then you don’t

gain any knowledge from Monty opening an empty door. Hence, the chance remains 1/3

• But if Monty Hall didn’t know where the prize was and just happened to

pick an empty door, then: it doesn’t matter!

– Now you *do* gain information by Monty opening an empty door, so the chances are

going to change. In particular, the chance of having the right door and Monty opening a

different door that’s empty is 1/3 * 1 = 1/3. The chance of picking the wrong door and

Monty opening a different door that’s empty is 2/3 * ½ = 1/3. And finally, there was also

a 1/3 chance that Monty would have opened the door with a prize. However, the last

scenario is ruled out, so one of other two scenarios applies, which are equally likely.

• If Monty Hall does know where the prize is, but shows another door if and

only if the contestant has initially picked the door with the prize, then: no,

don’t switch!

– So Monty doesn’t always open a door

• Do you know what Monty Hall is like?

Derek Jeter vs David Justice

• Batting averages:

– 1995:

• Jeter: 0.250

• Justice: 0.253

– 1996:

• Jeter: 0.314

• Justice: 0.321

– 1997:

• Jeter: 0.291

• Justice: 0.329

• Who has the better batting average for the 3-year

period 1995-1997?

Jeter vs Justice II

• Let’s look at the raw numbers:

– 1995:

• Jeter: 12 for 48 (0.250)

• Justice: 104 for 411 (0.253)

– 1996:

• Jeter: 183 for 582 (0.314)

• Justice: 45 for 140 (0.321)

– 1997:

• Jeter: 190 for 654 (0.291)

• Justice: 163 for 495 (0.329)

• Now let’s add them up!

– Jeter: 385 for 1284 (0.300)

– Justice: 312 for 1046 (0.298)

What To Think of This?

• “The gap between advancing book prices and author’s

earnings, it appears, is due to substantially higher

production and material cost. Item: plant and

manufacturing expenses alone have risen as much as

10 to 12 per cent over the past decade, materials are

up 6 to 9 per cent, selling and advertising expenses

have climbed upwards of 10 per cent. Combined

boosts add up to a minimum of 33 per cent (for one

company) and up to 40 per cent for some of the

smaller houses”.

- The New York Times Book Review

The Moral

• You can’t do normal arithmetic over

percentages and averages

– You can’t add up percentages

– You can’t take averages of averages

– Etc.

- Lecture 3Uploaded byMuhammadQasim
- Vizzini Tic-tac-Toe Source CodeUploaded byapi-25977774
- Race–a Social Destruction of a Biological ConceptUploaded byAnonymous y8h5Zf
- Problems 3Uploaded byvmsgr
- DLL IN MATH ( March 6-10, 2017 ) (1)Uploaded byFlorecita Cabañog
- AfrikaKorps 3d Ed RulesUploaded byt1029
- GalileoUploaded byDerko
- The Football FormulaUploaded byCiprian Dobrescu
- Probability vs OddsUploaded byVictor Anaya
- MIT6_0001F16_ps1Uploaded byNikhil Patil
- math artifiact lesson planUploaded byapi-382675034
- 1Uploaded byPolisetty Guptha
- Percentage.docxUploaded byTanzir Hasan
- DIUploaded byMukta Mitra
- adibahUploaded bysugerglider
- lesson 6Uploaded byapi-281778031
- 110211Andrikogiannopoulou_JMPUploaded bymirymirela
- HwkPM17-1Uploaded byNitin Kumar
- Topic - 7 (Uncertainty).pptUploaded bymusabbir
- ProbabilityLectures-3.pptxUploaded byArshid Ali
- Rec 0918Uploaded byEugene Choi
- Aptitude Questions_ Percentage Set 10Uploaded byBank King
- teachingpuzzle1Uploaded byapi-272675985
- grade 8 lesson 3 percentUploaded byapi-249796897
- IBPS RRB PO Prelims 2018 - Memory Based Question Paper by AffairsCloud.pdfUploaded bySukriti Ghosh
- 2feb5Session 10 Bayes TheoremUploaded byAbhishek Jain
- Rule: Spearmint oil produced in— Far WestUploaded byJustia.com
- Project Selection Day 4Uploaded byBishwajit Chowdhury
- Decision 1Uploaded byRohan Sequiera
- 363Uploaded bySarveswara Sarma

- AuthoritarianUploaded byMarketing Research
- Critical ThinkingUploaded byMarketing Research
- Critical ThinkingUploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 6 axis robot arm.docxUploaded byMarketing Research
- Indulgent ParentingUploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- Overcoming Low Self-Esteem Extract.pdfUploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research
- 3Uploaded byMarketing Research

- STAT 230 A2 Fall 2012 SolutionsUploaded byChristina Hayes
- MQM100_MultipleChoice_Chapter4Uploaded byNakin K
- Artificial IntelligenceUploaded bySidharth Gaur
- Common Number PatternsUploaded byMazura Meor Lope
- (8)Math in Our Daily Lives 733178Uploaded byAlvaro Gonzalo Flores Guiñez
- Mathematics of Coding Information Compression Error Correction and Finite FieldsUploaded bychesstheory
- 9-Maths-Ncert-chapter-15.pdfUploaded bysridevi
- Traders SecretUploaded byTheo Iguyovwe
- 19797_PEA 303 Unit2- ProbabilityUploaded byVinay Prakash
- Homework1 SolutionUploaded byFulya Okur
- ProbabilityUploaded byHersh Oberoi
- Prog Assign 08 InstrUploaded byDalton Shultz
- ITC Lecture #01Uploaded bysohaibhaider
- ratios-msUploaded byxanjien
- A Collection of Quant Technical Interview QuestionsUploaded bytadkar
- 7 Maths NCERT Chapter 3Uploaded byRachakonda Deepika
- Chapter 1 Conceptions Of__ ProbabilityUploaded byFerb Lee
- Apttitude MathsUploaded byvinotd1
- artifact - mathematics unit plannerUploaded byapi-222191865
- TurrUploaded bychaits258
- Negotiation EngUploaded byAhmed Rahim
- Module 2Uploaded byAlexis Nicole Joy Manatad
- Ben Saunders Democracy, Political Equality, And Majority RuleUploaded byArina Iacob
- ProbabilityUploaded bySANIUL ISLAM
- Unveil by Manos.pdfUploaded byJuank Merlos
- HO27-PracticeFinal2WSUploaded byFernando Haro
- Ch04Uploaded bykir223
- Maths ProjectUploaded byUjjwal Tiwari
- Caveman Clash 2EUploaded bypoisonknees
- CK12 Prob Stat BasicUploaded byMasterofminds