You are on page 1of 8

4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The

& Top Stories - The Straits Times

THE STRAITS TIMES


Asian Writers' Circle

The 'end of history' myth and the South's


challenges
Lynn Ockersz

 PUBLISHED JAN 5, 2019, 5:00 AM SGT


Capitalism has outlived political change and is the only certainty in a world of
uncertainties

The collapse of the Soviet Union at the end of the 1980s proved a seminal event in the history of
international politics and there was this pervasive euphoric sentiment that the stage was set for the
everlasting enthronement of the capitalist system along with liberal democracy, worldwide.

The belief was initiated and sustained by sections of the Western academic world and enthusiastically
supported by the political class of the same geographical hemisphere and some of its supportive
counterparts in the global South.

This anticipated, wide-ranging transformation was summed-up in the catch phrase, "end of history".

Decades into this "brave new world", the more perceptive among us realise that the "end of history" is the
stuff of myth and make-believe.

To be sure, the capitalist growth model has been adopted by almost all countries but it is an open question
whether liberal democracy has stabilised itself all over the world.

That is, we may have capitalism but not necessarily liberal democracy. In fact, today, capitalism thrives
alongside political authoritarianism in its most repressive manifestations.

Capitalism has vastly outlived political change down the ages.

This is the only relative certainty in a world riddled with uncertainties.

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to


explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.
✓ Accept

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 1/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

A casualty of the Syrian conflict. President Donald Trump recently ordered the withdrawal of US forces from Syria, even
though there is no guarantee that the conflict there has been resolved to the satisfaction of those sections of the world
community that have the interests of civilians at heart. PHOTO: AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE

If the global South ever gets down to thinking collectively about its lot, it will realise that almost nothing
that it campaigned for in the aftermath of "political independence" in the 1950s and 1960s, for instance, has
been achieved substantially and to its entire satisfaction.

It need hardly be argued that individual and collective socio-economic goals, for example, have deftly
eluded it.

Besides, security in its individual and collective forms is at best chimerical in these times when ultra-
nationalism and individualism are tending to be glaringly conspicuous; tendencies the post-World War II
order thought it had blunted.

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to


explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.
✓ Accept

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 2/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

It is in the area of security that the world finds itself to be most wanting.

The few decades leading to World War I were characterised by a degree of international peace but this
applied largely to the West. This was probably because the Western world enjoyed a degree of consensual
thinking onsite
This forms
usesof cookies
governance, such
to help us as the constitutional
serve you better. By monarchy
continuing and
to liberal democracy, and agreed
largely on the need for the capitalist growth model, on issues relating to the economy. ✓ Accept
explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 3/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

Needless to say, insecurity marked the international system in the decades between the two world wars
and, not surprisingly, nationalism and individualism came to be hallmarks of those times. Given these
broad tendencies, it was only to be expected that international tensions would mount, leading eventually to
a world war.

Compared to the present times, Southern states and their peoples enjoyed a degree of security during the
Cold War decades.

This was mainly because the world had polarised itself into two ideological, military and economic blocs,
broadly speaking, with the United States and the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation on the one side and
the Soviet Union and Warsaw Pact on the other.

These politico-ideological and military groupings balanced each other's power and influence in the
international system from the end of World War II until the 1990s, when the decline of the Soviet Union
began to be dramatically marked.

While it could be contended that part of the "end of history" prophecy has come true in that the capitalist
system has come to be universally accepted, the rest is patently false.

Liberal democracy and accountable governance are conspicuous by their absence in most parts of the
global South, although the latter hemisphere is seeing the rapid proliferation of emerging economies firmly
on the capitalist path.

The glaring lack of accountable governance in most regions of the world is emerging as a major factor in
growing international insecurity.

A tragic fallout from this lacuna in the South is increasing human insecurity.

Today, in the world's trouble spots, the number of civilian casualties of war is rising disconcertingly. This
situation is not helped by a steep rise of the political right in the West.

This tendency is epitomised, for example, by the Trump phenomenon in the US.

The ultra-nationalist agenda of the Trump presidency is compelling the US to withdraw militarily from
conflict and war zones where civilians are most exposed and vulnerable to the horrors of armed conflict.
For instance, as this is being written President Donald Trump has ordered the withdrawal of US ground
troops from Syria.

But there is no guarantee that the Syrian conflict has been resolved to the satisfaction of those sections of
the world community that have the interests of civilians at heart.

Would the US now "cut and run" from Afghanistan as well?

This is a moot point.

Washington's reluctance to honour its commitments to war-affected civilians of the South runs parallel to
its tendency to uses
This site withdraw from
cookies tomultilateral
help us serveeconomic andBy
you better. related forums
continuing towhich are seen as affecting US
interests. It hasour
explore already done
site, you so in the
accept our case ofcookies.
use of
✓ Accept
a couple of Obama era economic treaties that were seen as

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 4/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

benefiting both South and North.

There is plenty in these unexpected developments that should set the South thinking.

It cannot expect a consensus of thinking among the big powers on questions affecting its security and
economic interests.

The South will be valued by the big powers in these "brave new" times to the extent to which it keeps its
markets open for trade and investment.

The South cannot expect to be protected by the big powers, be they from the North or South.

It could, though, expect the major powers to enter into economically exploitative relations with it and little
else.

However, the South should think of re-grouping to the extent to which it could. South-South ties should be
revived and made to prosper in the socio-economic field, in particular.

Ironically, as it goes along, the South is bound to realise that "Third World" development agendas of the
days gone by are not completely irrelevant in these times when the rest of the world could not care less for
its most vital interests.

• The writer is an associate editor of The Island newspaper in Sri Lanka.

• The Asian Writers' Circle is a series of columns on global affairs written by top editors and writers
from members of the Asia News Network and published in newspapers and websites across the region.

Unlock more articles at just $0.99/month


Subscribe and get access to all Premium stories today. Cancel anytime.

Subscribe Now

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to


explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.
✓ Accept

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 5/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

Twins in viral video Former Singapore Sri Lanka All-American burger


scuffle lose civil suits Idol winner Hady explosions: Scale of treat with classic
Mirza making a attacks suggests milkshakes
comeback sophisticated
planning, training

 Apr 21, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 21, 2019

Recommended by

MORE FROM THE STRAITS TIMES

Peeping Tom caught Andy Hui scandal: Faye Wong's PM Abe's ruling bloc
filming in NUS hall Hong Kong daughter wins Best loses two seats in
shower: Thousands broadcaster TVB in Supporting Actress Japan by-elections
sign petitions calling hurry to repair award for movie
for tougher action Jacqueline Wong debut

 Apr 22, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 23, 2019

FROM AROUND THE WEB

How I Sold More [Photos] The Most NZXT's updated Don't Miss This
Than A Million Unforgettable Oscars HUE 2 Ambient Million KrisFlyer
Dollars Of Products Outfits Of All Time lighting kit will Miles Giveaway
On Amazon! drench your
workstation in RGB
Amazon Workshop Coolimba HardwareZone The MileLion

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to Recommended by

explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.


✓ Accept

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 6/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

ST VIDEOS
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II celebrates 93rd birthday

'It was a river of blood': Dashcam footage shows explosion


outside Sri Lanka church

Sri Lanka explosions: World leaders condemn bombings,


express condolences

Sri Lanka explosions: Over 200 die in church and hotel blasts

Recommended by

BRANDED CONTENT
CUT your risk of diabetes

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to


explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.
✓ Accept

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 7/8
4/24/2019 The 'end of history' myth and the South's challenges, Opinion News & Top Stories - The Straits Times

5 Ways to Smarter Food Management at Home

It Changed My Life: She paddles to help others stay afloat

Working towards retirement by 35

Aspiring tech-entrepreneurs, you could be the future

New hope for lung cancer patients

 Terms & Conditions  Data Protection Policy


 Need help? Reach us here.  Advertise with us

SPH Digital News / Copyright © 2019 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn. No. 198402868E. All rights reserved

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to


explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.
✓ Accept

https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/the-end-of-history-myth-and-the-souths-challenges 8/8